Friday, November 18, 2022

Ban on Beer Is Latest Flash Point in World Cup Culture Clash

Qatar’s about-face on alcohol signaled that FIFA, soccer’s governing body, may no longer be in full control of its showcase championship.


Qatar’s ban on beer in stadiums complicated FIFA’s relationship with Budweiser, which pays $75 million every four years to be associated with the World Cup.
Credit...Patrick T. Fallon/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images

By Tariq Panja
Nov. 18, 2022

DOHA, Qatar — The tiny but fabulously wealthy Gulf nation of Qatar has spent 12 years preparing to host soccer’s World Cup, a marathon of planning and patience during which it has redrawn an entire nation by building stadiums and hotels, roads and sidewalks, even a gleaming new subway system.

Yet it was not until Friday that it finally settled on what to do about the sale of beer during the tournament, and the decision — to the consternation of the roughly 1 million fans set to arrive in the coming days — was to ban the sale of it at the event’s eight stadiums.

The decision, announced by FIFA, soccer’s global governing body, was an abrupt about-face by Qatar, and the latest flash point in the ongoing culture clash inherent in staging the tournament in a small, conservative Middle Eastern monarchy.

Ever since Qatar was surprisingly awarded the hosting rights to the tournament more than a decade ago, local organizers and global soccer leaders had insisted that beer — a fixture at sporting events around the world, but one that is tightly controlled in Qatar — would be available for fans. Two days before the World Cup’s first game, though, that message changed.

Instead, Qatari officials have decided that the only drinks that will be on sale to fans at games during the monthlong World Cup will be nonalcoholic.

It is unclear what prompted the ban so close to the tournament, but the sudden change was in keeping with the tournament’s ever-shifting policy toward alcohol, and its availability to fans attending games. Plans have repeatedly been drawn up and then revised, and then remade again — a possible signal that domestic politics or even royal family influence were playing a role.

“Following discussions between host country authorities and FIFA, a decision has been made to focus the sale of alcoholic beverages on the FIFA Fan Festival, other fan destinations and licensed venues,” FIFA said. The decision, it said, would require “removing sales points of beer from Qatar’s FIFA World Cup 2022 stadium perimeters.”

A beer stand at a fan festival in Doha, Qatar’s capital. Sales in fan zones will be unaffected by the revised stadium plan.
Credit...Muath Freij/Reuters

The decision to ban beer comes a week after an earlier edict that dozens of red beer tents covered in the branding a Budweiser, a longstanding World Cup sponsor, would have be moved to more discreet locations at the World Cup’s eight stadiums, away from where most of the crowds attending the games would pass.



Staff members, according to three people with direct knowledge of that earlier change, were told the move followed security advice. But the belief that the change had originated with Sheikh Jassim bin Hamad bin Khalifa al-Thani — the brother of Qatar’s ruling emir and the royal most active in the day-to-day planning of the tournament — suggested it was nonnegotiable.

Now beer will not merely be hidden out of view: It will not be available to fans at all.


The ban is the latest and most dramatic point of contention between FIFA and Qatar, which had sought and won the right to host the World Cup as part of an ambitious effort to announce itself on the global stage. In recent weeks, Qatari government leaders, including the emir, have mounted an increasingly strident defense of their nation.

But it also will complicate FIFA’s $75 million sponsorship agreement with Budweiser; infuriate fans already chafing at restrictions, costs and inconveniences around the event; and once again leave organizers scrambling to adjust in the final hours before the tournament begins.

But it also suggested that FIFA, which has faced years of blistering criticism for its decision to bring its showpiece championship to Qatar, may no longer be in full control of major decisions related to its event. A decade ago, for example, the soccer body pressured Brazil for just the opposite outcome: leaning on the Brazilian government to change a law in order to allow beer to be sold in stadiums, a practice that had been banned in Brazil since 2003.

In Qatar, FIFA has instead bowed to the demands of the host country. That raised the possibility that other promises that run counter to local laws and customs — including issues like press freedom, street protests and the rights of LGBTQ+ visitors — were not as rock-solid as Qatar and FIFA have said.

The Football Supporters’ Association, a fan advocacy group based in Britain, criticized the decision.

“Some fans like a beer at a game and some don’t, but the real issue is the last minute U-turn which speaks to a wider problem — the total lack of communication and clarity from the organizing committee toward supporters,” the group said in a statement

“If they can change their minds on this at a moment’s notice, with no explanation, supporters will have understandable concerns about whether they will fulfill other promises relating to accommodation, transport or cultural issues.”

The ban on alcohol consumption seemed to apply only to fans attending games. Beer and other drinks, including an official FIFA Champagne and an array of sommelier-selected wines, will still be available in stadium luxury suites reserved for FIFA officials and other wealthy guests.


Qatar World Cup Faces New Edict: Hide the Beer
Nov. 14, 2022


Qatar has grappled with the subject of alcohol ever since the tiny Gulf nation was awarded World Cup hosting rights in 2010. Alcohol is available in the country, but sales are strictly controlled. Most visitors, even before the World Cup, were permitted to buy beer and other alcoholic beverages only in upscale hotel bars and at unusually high prices.

World Cup organizers appeared eager to mollify Budweiser and its corporate parent, the Belgium-based multinational Anheuser-Busch InBev, saying, “tournament organizers appreciate AB InBev’s understanding and continuous support to our joint commitment to cater for everyone.”

Representatives for Budweiser, who had suggested last week that they were blindsided by Qatar’s earlier changes to their sales strategy for the World Cup, did not immediately reply to requests for comment.

Initially, the company’s only public statement was a wry one from its Twitter account, which wrote, “Well, this is awkward….” The tweet was deleted about 90 minutes later, and just before FIFA’s statement was released.

Later in the day, a representative of the company said it would have to cancel some of its marketing plans for the World Cup “due to circumstances beyond our control.”

Last week, Qatari organizers tried to play down the rising tension over beer sales, a fixture of World Cups for generations, by saying that operational plans were still being finalized, and that changes were still being made in “the location of certain fan areas.” Its statement also noted that “pouring times and the number of pouring destinations” remained the same at all eight stadiums.

Budweiser, which pays FIFA the $75 million for each four-year World Cup cycle, had said it was working with organizers “to relocate the concession outlets to locations as directed.”

The newest plan means that the brewer’s red tents now may not be visible at all around stadiums; unbranded white replacements are being considered. Refrigerators in the company’s famous red colors are likely to be replaced by blue ones, the color associated with Budweiser’s nonalcoholic brand, Budweiser Zero.


Qatar Offered Fans Free World Cup Trips, but Only on Its Terms
Nov. 3, 2022


Tariq Panja covers some of the darker corners of the global sports industry. He is also a co-author of “Football’s Secret Trade,” an exposé on soccer’s multibillion-dollar player trading industry. @tariqpanja


More Coverage of the 2022 World Cup

Hundreds of thousands of Nepalis were part of an army of migrant workers who remade Qatar for its World Cup moment. But in chasing desperately needed paychecks abroad, many pay a heavy price.

Luxury hotels featured prominently in Qatar’s master plan for the tournament. But as visitors started arriving, the one set to host FIFA’s most senior executives wasn’t quite ready for them.

Qatari officials have decided that the only drinks that will be on sale at games will be nonalcoholic. The ban is the latest change to an evolving alcohol plan that has for months increased tensions between FIFA and the conservative Muslim nation.

Iran’s national team, known as Team Melli, has been a unifying force in a fractious nation. But ahead of the World Cup, the squad has become ensnared in its country’s internal politics.

World Cup organizers offered free trips to hundreds of fans, but there’s a catch: They must not criticize Qatar, and they must report people who do.

Qatar is the first Arab nation to host the World Cup, bringing all the country’s contradictions to the fore. These five books shed light on some of Qatar’s most important aspects.



A Brief Guide to the 2022 World Cup
Card 1 of 8


What is the World Cup? The quadrennial event pits the best national soccer teams against each other for the title of world champion. Here’s a primer to the 2022 men’s tournament:


Where is it being held? This year’s host is Qatar, which in 2010 beat the United States and Japan to win the right to hold the tournament. Whether that was an honest competition remains in dispute.


When is it? The tournament will open on Nov. 20, when Qatar plays Ecuador. Over the two weeks that follow, four games will be played on most days. The tournament ends with the final on Dec. 18. Here’s the full match schedule.


How many teams are competing? Thirty-two. Qatar qualified automatically as the host, and after years of matches, the other 31 teams earned the right to come and play. Meet the teams here.


How does the tournament work? The 32 teams are divided into eight groups of four. In the opening stage, each team plays all the other teams in its group once. The top two finishers in each group advance to the round of 16. After that, the World Cup is a straight knockout tournament.


How can I watch the World Cup in the U.S.? The tournament will be broadcast on Fox and FS1 in English, and on Telemundo in Spanish. You can livestream it on Peacock, or on streaming services that carry Fox and FS1.


When will the games take place? Qatar is five hours ahead of London, eight hours ahead of New York and 11 hours ahead of Los Angeles. That means there will be predawn kickoffs on the East Coast of the United States for some games, and midafternoon starts for 10 p.m. games in Qatar.


Got more questions? We’ve got more answers here.


No alcoholic beer sales in World Cup stadiums: FIFA

Announcement comes two days before tournament kicks 

off in Qatar

Cans of Budweiser beer featuring the FIFA World Cup logo are displayed in Doha on Friday ahead of the Qatar 2022 World Cup soccer tournament. FIFA said alcoholic beer won't be sold inside stadiums during the event. (Patrick T. Fallong/AFP/Getty Images)

In a reversal, alcoholic beer will not be sold at Qatar's World Cup stadiums, world soccer governing body FIFA said in a statement on Friday.

The announcement comes two days before Sunday's kickoff of the World Cup, the first to be held in a conservative Muslim country with strict controls on alcohol, the consumption of which is banned in public.

"Following discussions between host country authorities and FIFA, a decision has been made to focus the sale of alcoholic beverages on the FIFA Fan Festival, other fan destinations and licensed venues, removing sales points of beer from Qatar's FIFA World Cup 2022 stadium perimeters," a FIFA spokesperson said in the statement.

England's Football Supporters' Association said the decision raises concerns about Qatar's ability to fulfil its promises to visiting fans on "accommodation, transport or cultural issues."

For years, Qatar's tournament organizers have said that alcohol would be widely accessible to fans at the tournament.

"Some fans like a beer at the match, and some don't, but the real issue is the last-minute U-turn which speaks to a wider problem — the total lack of communication and clarity from the organizing committee towards supporters," the association said in a statement on Twitter.

Qatar, the smallest country to host a World Cup, is bracing for the expected arrival of 1.2 million fans during the month long tournament, more than a third of the Gulf Arab state's 3 million population.

Long-term sponsor

Budweiser, a major World Cup sponsor, owned by beer maker AB InBev, was to exclusively sell alcoholic beer within the ticketed perimeter surrounding each of the eight stadiums three hours before and one hour after each game.

"Some of the planned stadium activations cannot move forward due to circumstances beyond our control," AB InBev said in a statement.

Budweiser has been a World Cup sponsor since 1985, the year before the event was held in Mexico. For 2022, it has launched its biggest ever campaign, with activities for Budweiser and other brands in more than 70 markets and at 1.2 million bars, restaurants and retail outlets.

The World Cup typically boosts beer consumption, and the Belgium-based maker of brands such as Stella Artois and Corona clearly wants to profit from the millions of dollars it pays to be a sponsor.

However, it has said those profits will come less from consumption at the event's location than from fans watching on television.

Budweiser's Twitter account tweeted: "Well, this is awkward...," without elaborating Friday. The tweet was later deleted.

The reversal of that policy comes after long-term negotiations between FIFA president Gianni Infantino, Budweiser, and executives from Qatar's Supreme Committee for Delivery and Legacy (SC), which is organizing the World Cup, a source with knowledge of the negotiations told Reuters on condition of anonymity.

The SC did not respond to Reuters' request for comment and FIFA did not confirm Infantino's involvement.

"A larger number of fans are attending from across the Middle East and South Asia, where alcohol doesn't play such a large role in the culture," the source said.

"The thinking was that, for many fans, the presence of alcohol would not create an enjoyable experience."

Non-alcoholic beer will be sold

Champagne, wine, whiskey and other alcohol is still expected to be served in the luxury hospitality areas of the stadiums.

Budweiser will sell its non-alcoholic beer throughout the stadium precincts for $8.25 per half-litre, the statement said.

Questions have swirled around the role alcohol would play at this year's World Cup since Qatar won hosting rights in 2010. While not a "dry" state like neighbouring Saudi Arabia, consuming alcohol in public places is illegal in Qatar.

Stadium 974 in Doha, Qatar, is among the tournament's eight stadiums where the sale of alcoholic beer has been banned. (Carl Recine/Reuters)

Visitors cannot bring alcohol into Qatar, even from the airport's duty free section, and most cannot buy alcohol at the country's only liquor store. Alcohol is sold in bars at some hotels, where beer costs around $15 US per half-litre.

Budweiser will still sell alcoholic beer at the main FIFA Fan Fest in central Doha, the source said, where it is offered for about $14 US per half-litre. Alcohol will also be sold in some other fan zones, whereas others are alcohol-free.

"Fans can decide where they want to go without feeling uncomfortable. At stadiums, this was previously not the case," the source said.

Soccer-World Cup tickets in Qatar most expensive ever - study

Reuters - Yesterday

DOHA (Reuters) - Soccer fans attending World Cup matches in Qatar will fork out nearly 40% more for match tickets compared to those who watched the 2018 edition in Russia, with tickets for the final costing an eye-watering 684 pounds ($812) on average, a study shows.


FIFA World Cup Qatar 2022 Preview© Thomson Reuters

While fans in Russia paid an average of 214 pounds for a seat, tickets to matches in Qatar cost an average 286 pounds, according to a study by Keller Sports.

The ticket prices in Qatar are the most expensive ever for World Cup games in the last 20 years, with those for the final 59% higher than four years ago, according to the study by the Munich-based sports outfitter.

"The World Cup in Qatar is already considered the most expensive World Cup ever. The construction of six new stadiums and the complete renovation of two other arenas in the country are said to have cost around $3 billion," the study said.

"Much more money was spent on expanding the infrastructure of the capital Doha, such as transport routes and the reconstruction of the international airport.

"It is hardly surprising that the World Cup in Qatar is also the World Cup with the most expensive tickets on average."

World soccer's governing body FIFA did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

FIFA had earlier said nearly three million tickets across the eight stadiums in Qatar had been sold ahead of the Nov. 20-Dec. 18 World Cup, the first to be held in the Middle East.

Tickets for the 2006 World Cup in Germany were considered the most affordable in the last 20 years, with an average cost of 100 pounds for matches while tickets to the final at Berlin's Olympiastadion cost, on average, 221 pounds per seat.

($1 = 0.8425 pounds)

(Reporting by Rohith Nair in Doha; Editing by Ken Ferris)
Canada makes 16 new jobs eligible for permanent residence, including nurse aides

By Saba Aziz Global News
Posted November 17, 2022 
Canada is now allowing foreign workers in 16 new occupations to apply for permanent residence, as the federal government looks to boost immigration to tackle labour shortages across the country.

In a statement on Wednesday, the immigration department said the new categories will build on plans to bring in global talent in high-demand sectors like health care, construction, and transportation.

READ MORE: As Canada boosts immigration, skills mismatch ‘discouraging’ newcomers

The new occupations now eligible for permanent residence under the Express Entry program include nurse aides, dental assistants, and pharmacy technical assistants as the country’s health-care system is in crisis with staffing shortages, long emergency room wait times and surgical backlogs.

The list also includes elementary and secondary school teacher assistants, truck drivers, bus drivers, subway operators, aircraft assemblers and estheticians, among others.

“We are using all of the tools at our disposal to tackle labour shortages, particularly in key sectors like health care, construction, and transportation,” said Immigration Minister Sean Fraser in a statement.

“These changes will support Canadians in need of these services, and they will support employers by providing them with a more robust workforce who we can depend on to drive our economy forward into a prosperous future.”

1:28 International students allowed to work more hours to help with labour shortage


The announcement comes as Canada has raised its immigration targets, with the goal of welcoming 1.45 million new immigrants over the next three years.

Out of these, 848,595 people will come under different economic streams for skilled workers to help industries struggling with acute labour shortages, according to the government.

READ MORE: Canadians worried about housing as Ottawa raises immigration targets: poll

The move has been widely welcomed by human resources experts and industries who say this will benefit the economy, but a more strategic and skills-based approach is needed without delays.

“If we’re really going to bring in skilled workers, we need to let them start working immediately,” said Sherri Rabinovitch, an HR expert in Montreal, in an interview Monday.

“We need to expedite the process and we need to get them integrated into the workplace as soon as possible,” she told Global News.


2:25 Sean Fraser: Canada needs more people


In an effort to fill labour gaps, Ottawa has temporarily lifted a cap of 20 working hours per week for international students in Canada.

Immigrants make up nearly a quarter of all people in Canada, according to the latest 2021 census data.

Immigration accounts for 90 per cent of Canada’s labour force growth and approximately 75 per cent of population growth, according to Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC).
Hyundai’s hydrogen fuel cell concept hints at the performance N brand’s future

Just don't say it's inspired by the DeLorean

Abigail Bassett@abigailbassett / 2:11 PM MST•November 17, 2022


Image Credits: Kirsten Korosec

Hyundai revealed Thursday a hydrogen fuel cell hybrid concept vehicle called the N Vision 74 that the company says demonstrates the performance sub-brand’s vision for electrification.

The Hyundai N sub-brand, the performance-focused arm of the automaker, has been applied to a range of production vehicles since its founding in 2015, from the Hyundai Veloster N and Elantra N to the Kona N.

The N brand, a name inspired by Germany’s famed racetrack in Nürburgring and where Hyundai tests these models, has targeted luxury performance brands like BMW M, Mercedes AMG, Audi RS and Cadillac V-series with its N brand.

The N Vision 74 raises the stakes. Just don’t say it’s inspired by the DeLorean.

A closer look at N Vision 74




Image Credits: Abigail Bassett

Hyundai calls the N Vision 74 a “rolling lab,” — a testbed of sorts for future products. Although there is some Hyundai Pony Coupe history in there too.

The N Vision 74 pays homage to the Hyundai Pony Coupe concept from 1974, which was developed by the legendary car designer Giorgetto Giugiaro, who also designed the DeLorean. (The DeLorean made its debut in 1981 after the Pony Coupe.) It’s a detail that Sang Yup Lee, the Hyundai Global Design Center and an executive vice president at Hyundai Motor Company was quick to point out.

“Don’t say they look alike, because we did it first,” Lee said during the press conference.



N Vision 74 gets a unique hydrogen hybrid and battery-electric architecture. Underpinning the N Vision 74 concept sits both a fuel cell stack and a battery pack. The fuel cell stack at the front puts out 85 kW (max 95 kW), while the 62.4 kWh battery sits at the rear.

The hydrogen W fuel cell converts hydrogen to electricity to charge the 62 kWh battery. The car also gets independent rear-mounted motors on each wheel to generate a total power output of 500 kW and nearly 670 horsepower and 663 pound-feet of torque. Hyundai says that allows for engineers to tune power distribution between left and right wheels and optimally set the N Vision 74 up to handle different types of tracks.

The N Vision 74 concept gets dual-charging capabilities. It can be filled with hydrogen or recharged on a DC fast charger thanks to the underlying 800-volt architecture E-GMP platform. Hyundai says it can get as much as 372 miles of range and a top speed of 155 mph.

The question is, of course, will this hydrogen fuel cell hybrid technology come to a production car?


Hyundai wouldn’t say whether this kind of powertrain will go into production. However, Lee did conclude his presentation stating that “The N Vision 74 Concept has undeniable Hyundai DNA and design that serves as a compass to guide our future.”
Billionaires are far from harmless. Fuelling the climate crisis, they’re among the most dangerous people on Earth


The best hope of averting climate disaster may well be wealth taxes that significantly reduce the wealth and power of the superrich.


By Linda McQuaig
TORSTAR
Contributing Columnist
Thu., Nov. 17, 2022

Watching Elon Musk reveal himself in recent weeks to be the world’s richest buffoon has certainly been entertaining. However, it could lead to the conclusion that billionaires are silly but harmless — which is far from the truth.

Yes, they are often silly. But they are rarely harmless. Indeed, they’re among the most dangerous people to walk the earth.

And I’m not just referring to their hoarding of resources while much of the world goes hungry. The real danger they pose to humanity is their enormous and largely hidden role in the climate crisis.

The problem is twofold. First, the carbon footprint of a billionaire is gigantic.

By contrast, the poorest half of the world’s population — four billion people — hardly contribute to climate change at all. On average, each person in this deprived bottom half of humanity contributes only 1.6 tons of carbon a year.


However, the average person in the top one per cent of the global population contributes 110 tons of carbon a year, while the average person in the top .01 per cent contributes a monstrous 2,531 tons. Meanwhile, a billionaire typically contributes a jaw-dropping 8,190 tons.

So while the ranks of the superrich are small, their carbon emissions (from private jets, yachts and multiple homes) are so immense — and fast-growing — that they are a key driver of climate change.

Now we come to the second part of the problem: their role as corporate owners directing enormous pools of capital towards fossil fuel production and infrastructure.

In a new study, Oxfam notes that if the investments of billionaires are factored in, their average emissions move from thousands of times greater than an ordinary person to more than a million times greater.

Oxfam examined the investments of 125 billionaires and found that they were skewed toward fossil fuels. If these billionaires moved their investments to a fund that simply followed the S&P 500, the intensity of their emissions would be reduced by half.

Billionaires clearly have a choice where to put their money, but there are only rare exceptions to the pattern — such as Patagonia sportswear billionaire Yvon Chouinard, who put the company’s ownership into a trust, declaring “Earth is now our only shareholder.”

Most, however, use their capital — and the enormous political clout that comes with it — in ways that further our dependence on fossil fuels, both by investing in their production and infrastructure and by influencing governments to block climate action.

That influence can be observed at the COP27 climate conference in Sharm el-Sheikh, Egypt, where more than 600 lobbyists and executives from fossil fuel-related industries are working hard — often ensconced right inside national delegations — to block climate progress.

Canada’s official delegation includes eight industry supporters, including a senior vice-president of the Royal Bank of Canada, which invests heavily in fossil fuels.

With that kind of insider’s seat, no wonder there’s so little progress at these global climate gatherings.

Given the gigantic carbon footprints of the mega-rich and their oversized political influence, the best hope of averting climate disaster may well be wealth taxes that significantly reduce their wealth and power.

Oxfam argues that wealth taxes could help fund assistance for poor countries devastated by climate change, whose citizens have contributed almost nothing to the problem.

There are lots of other good reasons to introduce wealth taxes, which have been proposed by U.S. senators Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren, and in Canada by NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh.

But, despite the popularity of such taxes as well as the urgency of the climate crisis and other needs, momentum toward them has stalled.

Certainly, the Trudeau government has never been interested, instead merely imposing extra sales taxes on luxury cars and yachts — taxes which barely impact the superrich.

But if Prime Minister Justin Trudeau really were the climate warrior he poses as, he’d be listening less to the Royal Bank and more to groups desperately trying to save their countries from drowning in rising sea waters.



Linda McQuaig is a Toronto-based freelance contributing columnist for the Star. Follow her on Twitter: @LindaMcQuaig
Ontario memo directs school boards to ‘implement contingency plans’ after CUPE strike notice

By Hannah Jackson 
 Global News
Posted November 17, 2022 


Ontario’s Ministry of Education is directing school boards to “implement contingency plans” after the union representing some 55,000 education workers issued another strike notice.

In a memo, obtained by Global News, the Ministry of Education said it was making the request to school boards in an effort to “minimize disruptions to students, parents and guardians in the event that CUPE does not reach and agreement, and proceeds with its strike action.”

“School boards that would be affected by a work withdrawal by CUPE staff should carefully assess how best to ensure student safety and continuity of learning,” the memo read.

The Canadian Union of Public Employees (CUPE), which represents custodians, educational assistants, administrative staff in schools, librarians and bus drivers, said Wednesday that negotiations with the Ontario government had once again broken down.

READ MORE: What you need to know as Ontario education workers issue another strike notice

Laura Walton, president of CUPE-OSBCU, said members will walk off the job for a “full strike” on Monday.

In the memo, the ministry said “where a school board determines that it can provide in-person learning for all students, school boards should plan accordingly and continue to communicate with students and families to ensure appropriate notice is provided, including expectations about how long in-person learning may be possible during this upcoming withdrawal of services.”

The ministry said “unless other circumstances exist that require closure,” schools should remain open to staff so they are able to “deliver remote learning.”

What’s more, the ministry said if a board determines its schools can’t stay open, they must “support students in a speedy transition to remote learning.”

“It is important that students are benefitting from live, teacher-led learning during this period,” the memo said. “It is expected that school boards deliver synchronous learning to students, to ensure the continuity of learning.”


1:00 Ontario’s education minister “disappointed” in CUPE strike notice

The ministry said “special attention should be paid to our most vulnerable children and those with special education needs,” adding that boards should work “flexibly to accommodate their needs” including ensuring they have access to specialized equipment and supports.”

Where possible, boards are asked to “continue to focus planning efforts to support in person learning” for students with special education needs who “cannot be accommodated through remote learning based on individual needs.”

The ministry also said boards should have “safety plans” in place for those students who are or could be experiencing mental health challenges, and should make “every effort” to accommodate children who rely on Ontario’s Breakfast programs to ensure they have access to nutritional food.

READ MORE: Ontario education workers file strike notice again, say talks broke down

The ministry said child care programs should also be considered in contingency planning.

Several school boards in the Toronto area have already indicated they will close their schools to students if CUPE members withdraw their services on Monday, including the Toronto District School Board, Toronto Catholic District School Board, York Region District School Board and Peel District School Board.

In a statement Wednesday, Education Minister Stephen Lecce said the government is “disappointed” that the union filed another strike notice.

Lecce said that since talks resumed, the government has put forward “multiple improved offers” to CUPE members, that he said “would have added hundreds of millions of dollars across the sector, especially for lower income workers.”


“CUPE has rejected all of these offers,” he said in the statement. “We are at the table ready to land a fair deal that invests more in lower income workers and keeps kids in class.”

READ MORE: Some Toronto-area boards will close schools next week if CUPE workers strike

Speaking at a press conference on Wednesday, Walton said the two sides had reached a middle ground with the government on wages, but claims the government has refused to “invest in the services that students need and parents expect.”

“This has never been just about money,” Walton said. “This is what the premier and the minister want you to believe — that this is about money in our hands. This has always been about services.”

Both sides have indicated the talks will continue ahead of the strike deadline.

In a statement Thursday, CUPE said both parties had agreed to set a deadline of 5 p.m., on Sunday evening “so we can provide parents and caregivers as much notice as possible.”

McMaster University students brace for possible teaching assistants strike Monday

Teaching assistants and research assistants at McMaster University could potentially walk off the job Nov. 21 should a deal not be reacxhed between the school and CUPE Local 3906.
Teaching assistants and research assistants at McMaster University could potentially walk off the job Nov. 21 should a deal not be reacxhed between the school and CUPE Local 3906.
 Lisa Polewski / Global News

Teaching and research assistants at McMaster University may be on strike 

next week.

The university and CUPE Local 3906 have another mediated bargaining session on Friday and the union says if there isn’t a deal, 2,500 workers will walk off the job Monday at 12:01 a.m.


In mid-October, 90 per cent of the assistants voted yes to job action demanding a fair and reasonable offer to protect students from tuition increases, address rising cost of living concerns in Hamilton, and the lack of work opportunities for graduate students.

The union is also looking for an end to inequitable wages between undergraduate and graduate teaching assistants.

READ MORE: Western University students brace for possible faculty strike Tuesday

“Not only are the proposals we have tabled around protections against tuition increases and extended work guarantees for graduate students reasonable and well within McMaster’s means, they also exist at many other comparable universities in Ontario,” said Local 3906 president Chris Fairweather in a release.

The university said the campus will remain open during any walkout and students will hear from their instructors if there are any changes to classes.

“Recognizing that a potential TA labour disruption may pose challenges to our community, the university has started making contingency plans,” said McMaster executives in their own release Wednesday.

Lightspeed is 'spending a fortune on hiring' as tech sector cuts thousands

Marisa Coulton
Thu, November 17, 2022 

Screen Shot 2022-11-17

The world’s biggest digital technology companies are in the midst of laying off tens of thousands of people, but Montreal’s Lightspeed Commerce Inc., one of Canada’s leading tech companies, doesn’t plan to join the bloodletting.

Instead, chief executive Jean Paul Chauvet said he’ll pick up the talented employees that companies such as Amazon.com Inc., Meta Platforms Inc., Shopify Inc. and Twitter Inc. have left behind.

“We have 350 open positions, and if we could hire them today, we would hire them today,” Chauvet said during a roundtable with journalists this week at the company’s headquarters in Montreal. “It’s the number one priority right now, in operations.”

It’s been a rough year for big tech. Many of those digitally oriented companies experienced an e-commerce bump from the pandemic, but it fizzled once in-person retail opened up. Layoffs.fyi, a layoff tracker, reports that 122,000 employees across 800 tech companies have been let go this year as companies try to figure out how to be profitable again. Shopify laid off 1,000 employees in July. Twitter let go 3,700. Amazon.com Inc. and Meta plan to lay off 10,000 and 11,000 respectively.

Not Lightspeed, which provides point-of-sale and e-commerce software to hotels and retailers. The company isn’t feeling the strain as acutely as “pure digital” players such as Meta, said Chauvet, because Lightspeed serves brick-and-mortar companies.

“We’re spending a fortune on hiring,” said Chauvet. “Our recruiters spend their time saying: ‘Yeah! Facebook just downsized!’ … Let’s go and try and recruit the best people there.”

Unappreciated stock


Pouring money into hiring may seem a counterintuitive choice for Lightspeed, whose share price is down about 60 per cent this year.

But Chauvet said his company is being unfairly punished by an indiscriminate move away from tech stocks, as they look like riskier bets amid higher interest rates and worries about a recession. Meta and Shopify are both down about 70 per cent from January, and the tech-heavy Nasdaq composite index is down 30 per cent on the year.

Lightspeed’s share price is “a short-term reflection of a market where interest rates are through the roof and yields are very far from what they were,” said Chauvet, and “is no way a reflection of our performance.”

Thanos Moschopoulos, an analyst at BMO Capital Markets who follows Lightspeed, said Chauvet might have a point.

“I’d say there is a disconnect in the performance of the business and the stock,” said Moschopoulos, adding that he expects Lightspeed’s stock to outperform the market over the next year. “They’re in a competitive space. But I think the market isn’t fully appreciating the strength of their competitive position.”

Chauvet, who replaced Lightspeed founder Dax Dasilva as CEO in February, and president Jean-David Saint-Martin said they believe that if they stick to their three-part plan — consolidating their acquisitions under one cohesive brand, implementing their payments business and narrowing their focus to established small- and medium-sized businesses — profitability will naturally follow.

“Certainly I agree with that,” said Moschopoulos. “I think their path to profitability is very credible,” he added, highlighting the company’s plan to prioritize its most profitable customers. At the roundtable, Chauvet said Lightspeed will devote most of its resources to larger, more established retailers, which account for the vast majority of the US$80 billion in transactions the company’s clients process annually.

“Companies out there are taking different routes to (reach profitability), like, you know, laying off cohorts of employees,” said St-Martin. “We can get to our path to profitability and beyond by just continuing to execute on our plan.”

Good time to be a ‘Lightspeeder’

Technology companies such as Meta are choosing to prepare for a recession by conducting mass layoffs, and expressing regret for overreacting to pandemic-era signals as they do so.

“I view layoffs as a last resort,” Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg wrote in a message to employees. “At the start of COVID, the world rapidly moved online and the surge of e-commerce led to outsized revenue growth. Many people predicted this would be a permanent acceleration that would continue even after the pandemic ended.”

Zuckerberg added, “I did too, so I made the decision to significantly increase our investments. Unfortunately, this did not play out the way I expected.” He added that decreased ad revenue and the impending recession have resulted in lower revenues.

Lightspeed posts wider $79.9-million loss in second quarter

Montreal’s Lightspeed is leading the workplace renaissance

Meta wasn’t the only company to misjudge the shift to e-commerce. Shopify, one of Lightspeed’s main competitors, made the same ill-fated gamble. “We bet that the channel mix — the share of dollars that travel through e-commerce rather than physical retail — would permanently leap ahead by five or even 10 years,” Shopify chief executive Tobi Lütke wrote in a message to staff. “Ultimately, placing this bet was my call to make and I got this wrong.”

As a result, the industry has lost much of its swagger. Gone are the days where tech staff “thought they could find jobs everywhere, anywhere,” said Chauvet. Now, they’re asking themselves, “Do I have job security? Am I with an employer that’s going to keep me? And I think it’s reassuring for Lightspeeders to see that we are doing so well in a market that’s having difficulties,” he said.

The company posted a $79.9-million loss last quarter, but Chauvet said Lightspeed is “extremely well capitalized,” with $860 million left in the bank. “We burned, in cash, last quarter, $40 million. We could go on at this rate for many, many years before we are in trouble.”

Lightspeed expects a spike in retail revenue around Christmas, but leaders aren’t getting their hopes up too high. “This market is going to be struggling, especially for tech. The cost of money is going to go up, investment rounds are going to be much tougher,” said Chauvet.

Chauvet added that the complexity of the operating environment actually bodes well for Lightspeed, because its products reduce complexity, and will be increasingly in demand as the market becomes more complicated. Retailers are battling inflation, staff shortages and a possible recession, he said, and “these factors are really favourable to Lightspeed.”

• Email: mcoulton@postmedia.com | Twitter: marisacoulton

CANADA 

Federal dental benefit officially becomes law

Dental-care plan part of Liberal deal to secure NDP 

support in Parliament

The Canada Dental Benefit, which officially became law Thursday night, will provide dental care to 500,000 children between the ages of two and 12 at a cost of close to $1 billion. (Shutterstock / chanchai plongern)

The first stage of the Canada Dental Benefit officially became law Thursday night after Bill C-31 passed its final reading in the Senate and received royal assent from Governor General Mary Simon.

The benefit will provide dental care to 500,000 children between the ages of two and 12  at a cost of close to $1 billion.

Earlier this year, the Liberals and New Democrats struck a deal committing the NDP to voting with the minority Liberal government in the House of Commons on confidence votes until June of 2025. In exchange, the government agreed to meet a number of policy benchmarks along the way.

That deal committed the government to the goal of expanding the dental program to include those under 18 by next year, and all Canadians who qualify by the end of 2025.

"With this benefit, children will be able to access the basic dental care they need, while we develop a long-term Canada-wide dental care program," Health Minister Jean-Yves Duclos said in a statement.

Two men smile at each other while shaking hands.
NDP leader Jagmeet Singh meets with Prime Minister Justin Trudeau on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Nov. 14, 2019. Earlier this year, the Liberals and New Democrats struck a deal committing the NDP to voting with the minority Liberal government until June 2025. In exchange, the Liberals committed the goal of expanding the dental program. (Sean Kilpatrick/The Canadian Press)

'Just the first step'

NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh said Thursday that he plans to ensure the Liberals follow through on the rest of the deal.

"This is just the first step, we're going to keep fighting to make sure all Canadians can access comprehensive dental care as part of our health-care system," Singh said in a statement.

Beginning later this year, children under 12 with family incomes of less than $70,000 a year will be able to qualify for  $650 per year in dental coverage for the next two years. 

Children in families with incomes between $70,000 and $79,000 will be able to qualify for $390 per child per year for the next two years.

Families with incomes between $80,000 and $89,000 could get $260 per child per year for the next two years.

The government says that further details on how and when to apply for the benefit will be communicated in due course, but parents will be able to apply to the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) directly for the benefit, either through the CRA's "My Account" or through a CRA contact centre.

To get the benefit, parents and guardians have to attest that their child does not have access to private dental care coverage and that they will use the benefit to pay for dental services.

Applicants will have to prove that they have a child in the eligible age range and that the family income fits into the correct range. Parents are also required to provide CRA with their employer's information. 

People using the program also have to provide the CRA with the name of the dentist and the date of the appointment. They must retain their bills for the work done in case CRA asks them to verify that it took place. 

Families that provide false information, can't provide receipts or don't use the money for dental care could face a maximum fine of $5,000.

The benefit is to cover the cost of a dentist's services, which is defined in the legislation as: "services that a dentist, denturist or dental hygienist is lawfully entitled to provide, including oral surgery and diagnostic, preventative, restorative, endodontic, periodontal, prosthodontic and orthodontic services.‍"

The federal government says that it came up with the annual maximum claim amounts by calculating the cost of various dental services for children.

Once a person receives the benefit, they must use it to pay for dental services — but if the services in that year cost less than the total benefit amount, the recipient is not required to return what remains.