Friday, May 05, 2023

Biofortification of microgreens with zinc could mitigate global ‘hidden hunger’

Research aimed at dealing with catastrophe also shows method to reduce malnutrition

Peer-Reviewed Publication

PENN STATE

Pradip Poudel 

IMAGE: PRADIP POUDEL, THE DOCTORAL STUDENT IN THE DEPARTMENT OF PLANT SCIENCE WHO SPEARHEADED THE RESEARCH, WITH PEA AND SUNFLOWER PLANTS SHORTLY AFTER SEEDS GERMINATED, GROWING IN TRAYS FILLED WITH PEAT-PERLITE MIX. view more 

CREDIT: PENN STATE

UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — When the seeds of plants such as pea and sunflower are biofortified with zinc, the seedlings they quickly produce — harvested as microgreens — could both help to mitigate global malnutrition and boost the odds of people surviving a catastrophe.

That’s the conclusion of a Penn State research team that experimented with several biofortification methods to determine the most effective way to incorporate a mineral essential to human health into the young plants while not diminishing the amounts of other essential nutrients they produce. Microgreens biofortified with zinc offer people a lifeline in the face of starvation risk, according to team leader Francesco Di Gioia, assistant professor of vegetable crop science.

“This study has demonstrated that zinc biofortification through seed nutri-priming achieves needed levels of zinc in the young pea and sunflower plants we focused our experiments on,” he said. “These results have implications for both global ‘hidden hunger’ and emergency or catastrophe preparedness.” 

The work is another development in the ongoing project "Food Resilience in the Face of Catastrophic Global Events," funded by the nonprofit foundation Open Philanthropy. In Di Gioia’s work, an international team of researchers found that microgreens can be grown in a variety of soilless production systems in small spaces indoors, with or without artificial lighting. The zinc biofortification component is an important new innovation.

Biofortification is the process of growing crops to increase nutritional value from the seed on, Di Gioia explained. It is different from food fortification, which involves adding nutrients to foods during post-harvest processing. In poor regions of the world, or under post-catastrophic conditions, simply soaking seeds in a zinc solution is a practical and effective strategy for producing nutrient-dense microgreens, he pointed out.

“Starting decades ago as fashionable, high-value gourmet greens, microgreens today have gained popularity among consumers for their nutritional profile and high content of antioxidant compounds,” he said. “Our work shows microgreens can help people to survive a global catastrophe such as all-out nuclear war, a large asteroid strike or supervolcano eruption in the short term, but additional nutritional resources may be needed in the longer term.”

Such a cataclysmic event would endanger agricultural productivity by reducing sunlight and temperature, disrupting rainfall patterns, and contaminating water supplies, thus threatening starvation for survivors of the initial event. Early on, biofortified microgreen production could improve the probability of human survival under these conditions.

The prospect of also being able to expeditiously mitigate hidden hunger excites Pradip Poudel, the second-year doctoral degree student in the College of Agricultural Sciences who spearheaded the research. He suggested that production of nutrient-dense crops using agronomic biofortification techniques is a sustainable strategy that is badly needed to address malnutrition.

The World Health Organization defines "hidden hunger" as a lack of vitamins and minerals that occurs when the quality of food people eat does not meet the nutrient requirements they need for their growth and development, Poudel noted. Two billion people suffer from vitamin and mineral deficiencies, according to the WHO.

“We were thinking, how can we increase the content of zinc in microgreens, developing a very simple way that people could use at home in a ‘microgreens growing kit’ that could be delivered in an emergency situation,” he said. “And we know it will be important to include a fertilizer source for zinc so people will just have to soak the seeds before putting them in germination — a very simple process that anyone can do to enrich their microgreens with zinc.”

In findings recently published in Frontiers in Plant Science, the researchers reported that zinc sulfate, which is sometimes taken as a dietary supplement to treat a zinc deficiency or to promote wellness, was the most effective zinc source. Seeds soaked in a 200 parts per million solution of zinc sulphate resulted in higher zinc accumulation in both peas (126%) and sunflower microgreens (230%).

Researchers examined the effect of different zinc sources and soaking concentrations on microgreen-yield components such as mineral content; phytochemical constituents such as total chlorophyll, carotenoids, flavonoids, anthocyanin and total phenolic compounds; antioxidant activity; and antinutrient factors such as phytic acid.

Seed soaking in zinc sulfate and zinc oxide solutions at higher concentrations reduced phytic acid in both pea and sunflower microgreens — a positive development — the researchers pointed out. Because phytic acid is known to be an “anti-nutrient,” its lower level suggests the zinc might be more bioaccessible, or nutritionally available, to consumers.

While microgreens and sprouts are similar, they are not the same thing, Poudel noted. Both are baby plants; both can be grown indoors; and both can be grown from the same types of seeds. But that is where the similarities end.

A sprout is the first stage in a plant's life cycle after the seed germinates. When the baby plant grows beyond its first shoot and root, it transitions to the microgreen stage. Microgreens are essentially the mature plant in miniature, with leaves, stems and roots. They are typically harvested after the stem has grown 3 to 5 inches tall and its first set of leaves appear.

“The reason microgreens are so rich in nutrients, vitamins, minerals and antioxidants,” he added, “is that they all soon would be spread throughout the maturing plants’ leaves, flowers and fruit.”

Joshua Lambert, professor of food science, and Erin Connolly, professor and department head of plant science, contributed to the research.

This research was funded by Open Philanthropy through the "Food Resilience in the Face of Catastrophic Global Events" grant and the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s National Institute of Food and Agriculture.

In the study, seeds were kept in the dark until they germinated. A sprout is the first stage in a plant's life cycle after the seed germinates. When the baby plant grows beyond its first shoot and root, it transitions to the microgreen stage.

CREDIT

Penn State

Nutrition research continues to support the health benefits of regular watermelon consumption

Two new studies look at watermelon and higher diet quality in children and adults and the role watermelon juice plays in cardio-metabolic health

Reports and Proceedings

WILD HIVE

There’s no question that watermelon is both delicious and nutritious, but new research underscores this nutrient-rich fruit’s contributions to overall diet quality and heart health.

A recent study published in Nutrients suggests that watermelon can increase nutrient intake and overall diet quality in both children and adults.The study analyzed National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES) data and found that total diet quality was higher in watermelon consumers as compared to non-consumers. According to the study, children and adult watermelon consumers had higher intakes of dietary fiber, magnesium, potassium, vitamin C and vitamin A as well as lycopene and other carotenoids, while they had lower intakes of added sugars and total saturated fatty acids. Research analyst and author on the study, Kristen Fulgoni, will present the research findings at Nutrition 2023, the American Society for Nutrition annual meeting, held July 22-25, 2023 in Boston. 

In addition to the NHANES study, another new study also published in Nutrients builds on previous work in this area of research to show that watermelon juice supplementation protects vascular function during hyperglycemia.2 Conducted at Louisiana State University, this randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled crossover trial to test the effects of 2 weeks of daily watermelon juice supplementation, specifically looked at the potential beneficial modulating effects of L-citrulline and L-arginine – two compounds found in watermelon – on nitric oxide bioavailability and heart rate variability.  Both studies were funded by the National Watermelon Promotion Board.

“We acknowledge that while the sample size was small (18 healthy young men and women) and more research is needed, this study adds to the current body of evidence supporting regular intake of watermelon for cardio-metabolic health. In addition to L-citrulline and L-arginine, watermelon is a rich source of antioxidants, vitamin C and lycopene – all of which can help reduce oxidative stress and play a role in heart disease prevention,” said Dr. Jack Losso, Ph.D., professor at Louisiana State University’s School of Nutrition and Food Sciences.

The Dietary Guidelines for Americans (DGA) recommend 1.5 to 2.5 cups of fruit daily and currently U.S. adults and children fall short of this goal – getting only about half the recommended fruit serving each day. Watermelon is a nutrient-rich fruit and an excellent source of Vitamin C (25% DV), a source of Vitamin B6 (8% DV), and a delicious way to stay hydrated (92% water), with only 80 calories per 2-cup serving.

Thoughts of juicy watermelon at your upcoming BBQ or outdoor get together likely conjure up memories of enjoying the perfectly ripe fruit in summer’s past. The reality is that watermelon can be enjoyed any time thanks to the diversity of climates that enable watermelon production year-round. Whether you’re waiting for the first signs of summer to enjoy watermelon – or not – let this new nutrition research nudge you to include watermelon as part of your balanced diet.

A hypocaloric diet attenuates brain changes related to age-associated memory loss

Peer-Reviewed Publication

UNIVERSITAT AUTONOMA DE BARCELONA

A study coordinated by the Institute of Neurosciences of the UAB (INc-UAB) analyzes in old rats the effects of a calorie-restricted diet on the hippocampus, a brain structure that is critical in learning and memory processes. The results corroborate that there is a cognitive improvement derived from diet, linked to a reduction in the levels of inflammation and neuronal loss in the hippocampus.
Advances in the scientific, technological, and health sectors has led to an increase in life expectancy in our society and consequently, to a greater incidence of neurodegenerative diseases associated with age. This improvement in life expectancy therefore also requires research into strategies that can delay brain aging.
In this regard, it has been described that some of the brain alterations observed during aging, which may include an increase in oxidative stress and neuroinflammation, alterations in gene expression, a reduction in neurogenesis, and a dysregulation of mechanisms involved in synaptic plasticity, are related to the cognitive dysfunction that manifests naturally as we age. These processes, which depend on both genetic and environmental factors, are particularly important in the hippocampus.
Calorie-restricted diets have been shown to extend life expectancy and improve cognitive status, both in humans and in animal models, but many of the cellular processes associated with these benefits are still unknown. In this study, coordinated by Professor Gemma Guillazo from the INc-UAB and the Department of Psychobiology and Methodology, and Professor Carlos Barcia from the INc-UAB and the Department of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, researchers confirm the ability to memorize and learn in rats on calorie-restricted diets compared to rats fed a constant supply of food, and analyzed the effects on the hippocampus.
The results show that the group that followed a hypocaloric diet had better results in the spatial object recognition test, a memory test that allows you to evaluate, among others, the functioning of the hippocampus. In addition, the data obtained suggest that this improvement is linked to a reduction in both age-related neuronal loss and inflammatory activity in this structure.
"This article evidences the effects of the hypocaloric diet in the preservation of hippocampal functions and in the reduction of neuroinflammation associated with aging, and supports interventions at this level to improve the quality of life of elderly people," explains Dr. Guillazo
The study highlights the potential of changes in habits, such as dietary modifications, to promote healthy aging of the brain and prevent age-related cognitive deficits.

New East Coast-specific broccoli variety shows promise

Business Announcement

CORNELL UNIVERSITY

ITHACA, NY – The Cornell University-led Eastern Broccoli Project, which built a broccoli industry on the East Coast worth an estimated $120 million over the last 13 years, has produced a promising new broccoli variety in partnership with Bejo Seeds, a Geneva, New York-based seed company.

The new broccoli variety, now undergoing commercial trials, is believed to produce good, high-quality yields – even under the stress of hot East Coast summers.

“There are many forces at work that underscore the need for East Coast-specific broccoli varieties,” said Thomas Björkman, professor of horticulture at Cornell AgriTech and director of the Eastern Broccoli Project. “As a result of climate change, West Coast growers are faced with water shortages and rising temperatures, which can cause the head of broccoli to become distorted and unmarketable. Diversifying the production area is important for maintaining food security.”

Improving broccoli’s adaptation to warm night temperatures in East Coast summers was among Björkman’s priorities in the project. To succeed on the East Coast – where the rising consumption and value of broccoli along with overall consumer interest for locally grown food continues to spark growers’ interest – broccoli needed to be developed for East Coast conditions.

Björkman enlisted the help of Phillip Griffiths, associate professor of horticulture at Cornell AgriTech, to develop a breeding strategy. Because of the complexity of genes that would be needed to produce a successful East Coast variety, Griffiths and Björkman teamed up with Bejo Seeds. To further expand access to advanced broccoli genetic material, Griffiths also worked with Mark Farnham, research leader at the United States Department of Agriculture Vegetable Laboratory in Charleston, South Carolina.

The partnership has led to a broccoli variety that is a combination of environmental resistance traits and quality. Bejo, Griffiths and Björkman are relying on growers to help maximize commercial trial results this year. Growers are currently able to trial the variety in their own fields by calling Bejo for seeds.

The variety will receive a commercial status and a fitting name once adaptability and commercial fit are confirmed.

For additional information, see this Cornell Chronicle story.

-30-

How seaweed has been misleading scientists about reef health

Peer-Reviewed Publication

UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA

For decades, scientists have looked to seaweed as an indicator of the health of coral reefs lying underneath.

But what if the seaweed was misleading them?

New UBC research reveals it was, and scientists need new ways to determine whether human activity is harming a particular reef.

"This is especially critical today, given that reefs globally are threatened by climate-driven stressors,” said Dr. Sara Cannon, a postdoctoral fellow at the UBC Institute for the Oceans and Fisheries and the study's lead author.

Local species behave differently

Seaweed belongs to a group of organisms called macroalgae. Macroalgae at the ocean's surface has long served as a proxy for reef health, because it is relatively quick and easy to measure. Since the 1970s, scientists have assumed that local human impacts increase macroalgae while simultaneously damaging underlying reefs.

However, the study just published in Global Change Biology looked at data from over 1,200 sites in the Indian and Pacific Oceans over a 16-year period and revealed that this approach is misleading and may even have hidden signs of reef stress.

For example, macroalgae coverage depends heavily on the species growing in a particular area. Sargassum is less likely to grow in water contaminated by agricultural runoff, but Halimeda will thrive. In both cases, a reef will suffer.

The global research team concluded that using macroalgae coverage as an indicator of local human impacts can actually obscure how much our actions are harming reefs, and cause scientists to misidentify the reefs most in need of intervention.

Journalists interested in speaking with the research team can make arrangements by emailing erik.rolfsen@ubc.ca.

Vanishing glaciers threaten alpine biodiversity

Peer-Reviewed Publication

UNIVERSITY OF LEEDS

Glacial retreat in the European Alps 

IMAGE: REMNANT GLACIER ICE, SULZTAL, AUSTRIA view more 

CREDIT: UNIVERSITY OF LEEDS

Vanishing glaciers threaten alpine biodiversity 

With glaciers melting at unprecedented rates due to climate change, invertebrates that live in the cold meltwater rivers of the European Alps will face widespread habitat loss, warn researchers. 

Many of the species are likely to become restricted to cold habitats that will only persist higher in the mountains, and these areas are also likely to see pressures from the skiing and tourism industries or from the development of hydroelectric plants. 

The research study – led jointly by the University of Leeds and University of Essex - calls on conservationists to consider new measures to protect aquatic biodiversity. 

Invertebrates - key role in ecosystems 

The invertebrates, which include stoneflies, midges and flatworms, play a key role in nutrient cycling and organic matter transfer to fish, amphibians, birds and mammals in the wider Alpine ecosystem. 

Using glacier, landscape and biodiversity mapping data collected across the Alps, scientists from across Europe simulated how key invertebrate populations across the mountain range are likely to change between now and 2100 because of climate change.  

As the climate warms, the modelling predicted the invertebrate species would seek out colder conditions in the highest parts of the mountain range. In the future, these colder areas are also likely to be prioritised for skiing or tourism or the development of hydropower plants.  

Lee Brown, Professor of Aquatic Science at the University of Leeds who co-led the research, said: “Conservationists need to be thinking about how protected area designations must evolve to take into account the effects of climate change. 

“It may be that some species will have to be moved to refuge areas if we want to safeguard their survival as many of them are not strong fliers so they cannot disperse easily through the mountains.” 

The research paper - “Glacier retreat reorganises river habitats leaving refugia for Alpine invertebrate biodiversity poorly protected” - is published today (May 4) in the scientific journal Nature Ecology and Evolution. (The paper will be live on the Nature Ecology and Evolution website at this link when the embargo lifts:  https://www.nature.com/articles/s41559-023-02061-5

Alpine climate is changing rapidly 

The research, involving a collaboration between nine European research institutions, brought together data on invertebrate species distribution in the Alps, an area that covers more than 34,000 square kilometres, and mapped it alongside expected changes to glaciers and river flows. 

There was sufficient data to model what was likely to happen to 19 invertebrate species, mainly aquatic insects, that live in the cold-water regions of the Alps. 

Dr Jonathan Carrivick, from the School of Geography at Leeds who co-led the research, said: “We have quantified that as glaciers melt and retreat, the rivers running through the Alps will experience major changes in their water source contributions.  

“In the short term, some will carry more water and some new tributary rivers will form, but over several decades from now - most rivers will become drier, flow slower and become more stable, and there could even have periods in a year when there is no water flow. Additionally, most water in Alpine rivers will also be warmer in the future.” 

Losers and winners 

By the turn of the century, the modelling predicts that most of the species would have experienced "consistent losses” of habitat.  

Those hardest hit are expected to be the non-biting midges, Diamesa latitarsis grp., D. steinboecki, and D. bertrami; the stonefly, Rhabdiopteryx alpina; and mayfly, Rhithrogena nivata. 

However, several species are expected to benefit from the habitat changes, including the flatworm, Crenobia alpina and the flat headed may fly, Rhithrogena loyolaea. 

Other species would find refuge in new locations. The scientists predict the stonefly Dictyogenus alpinus and the caddisfly Drusus discolor will be able to survive in the Rhone valley in southeast France while other species will be lost from the rivers that flow into the Danube basin. 

Conservation 

Writing in the paper, the researchers describe the “substantial work” that is necessary to protect the biodiversity in rivers that are being fed by retreating glaciers. The locations where glaciers still exist late in the 21st century are likely to be prioritised for hydropower dam construction and ski resort development. 

Dr Martin Wilkes, from the University of Essex and who co-led the research, said: “The losses we predict for Alpine biodiversity by the end of this century relate to just one of several possible climate change scenarios.  

“Decisive action by world leaders to reduce greenhouse gas emissions could limit the losses. On the other hand, inaction could mean that the losses happen sooner than we predict.” 

Understanding how invertebrate populations respond to climate changes is key to understanding how biodiversity in high mountainous areas can be affected, and the techniques developed in the study could be applied to other mountain environments. 

The UK’s Natural Environment Research Council contributed to the funding of the study. 

END

  

Sulztalferner, Austria

Odenwinkelkees, Austria

Odenwinkelkees, Austria

CREDIT

University of Leeds

Wind energy from a 3D printer

Pilot project for energy self-sufficient schools

Grant and Award Announcement

JACOBS UNIVERSITY BREMEN GGMBH

Research funding for Constructor University in Bremen 

IMAGE: PROFESSOR UYGUN'S RESEARCH GROUP AT CONSTRUCTOR UNIVERSITY IS DEVELOPING VERTICAL WIND TURBINES AND WILL PRODUCE THEM IN ITS OWN 3D PRINTER ON CAMPUS IN BREMEN. view more 

CREDIT: CONSTRUCTOR UNIVERSITY

A pilot project for energy self-sufficient schools is now starting in the County of Friesland, Northern Germany, in which school buildings will be equipped with vertical-axis wind turbines. This will be facilitated by a research group led by Professor Uygun from Constructor University. This group is studying and developing vertical wind turbines, which will be produced in its own 3D printer on the campus in Bremen and will be tested in practice within this project. This creates a fully functional test field that provides important data and experience for technology transfer.

In the current energy crisis and the accompanying energy-saving measures, it is becoming increasingly difficult for schools to cover their high energy consumption with renewable energy. This is also due to the fact that they have to meet high requirements - for example, no horizontal wind turbines may be used - and solar panels are often not efficient enough for the high energy demand.

"With this project, we are breaking new ground in urban energy generation on this scale for the first time, with the aim of making public properties energy self-sufficient. After successful testing at the Hohenkirchen Secondary School, the project is to be scaled up easily and quickly so as to contribute to the energy transition," said Prof. Uygun.

The funding of the Metropolitan Region Northwest exclusively considers project ideas around the topics of resource efficiency, resource protection and energy transformation. In addition to Professor Uygun's project, two other campaigns have been awarded funding from the support fund of the states of Bremen and Lower Saxony. One identifies potential for saving drinking water, whereas the other one explores ways to recycle residual and commercial waste.

Further information:
www.metropolregion-nordwest.de



Electric car batteries are difficult to recycle – at least for now

Electric cars are a growing market, and so are the large batteries they use. Often these batteries are difficult to recycle. But help is on its way

Reports and Proceedings

NORWEGIAN UNIVERSITY OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY

Engineering their way to recycling electric car batteries 

IMAGE: BATTERIES FOR ELECTRIC CARS ARE HARD TO RECYCLE, BUT THIS GROUP FROM THE NORWEGIAN UNIVERSITY OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY (NTNU) IS ON THE CASE. ERIK PRASETYO, LEJLA BUZALJKO,ANNA MINGUET LOPEZ, VEGARD EIDEM PEDERSEN AND SULALIT BANDYOPADHYAY. view more 

CREDIT: PER HENNING, NTNU

Electric cars require batteries. This is a billion-dollar industry that Norway is investing heavily in. Five gigafactories are currently being built in Norway. All of these will manufacture batteries for electric cars, and the market could be huge.

How environmentally friendly this battery production is depends on how we manage to solve the problem of reuse.

“The problem now is that there’s a division between the companies that make the batteries and those that will recycle them. The way the batteries are produced make them unnecessarily difficult to recycle,” says Sulalit Bandyopadhyay, an associate professor and battery expert in the Department of Chemical Engineering at NTNU, the Norwegian University of Science and Technology.

What the four new factories have in common is that they will all manufacture battery cells for the batteries.

“We can help the industry by making batteries that are much easier to recycle,” says Bandyopadhyay.

This focus could quickly become even more important.

Strongly growing market

Almost four out of five new cars in Norway are now electric vehicles. Worldwide, the proportion of new EVs is around 10 per cent, but that number has increased sharply in recent years. Last year, almost eight million new EVs hit the roads.

The batteries in all these cars contain rare metals that are expensive, sometimes difficult to obtain and often very environmentally unfriendly.

The environmental effect of all these electric cars might become more questionable if we don’t manage to reuse the materials in the batteries.

“We’ll have to recycle electric car batteries in the future,” says Bandyopadhyay.

The batteries could be designed and produced in new ways that make this much, much easier.

The associate professor has worked with batteries and recycling for many years. The importance of this work is reflected in how much NTNU is investing in the field.

A few years ago, the work on battery recycling processes at NTNU involved a group of just three or four researchers. Now Bandyopadhyay heads a larger group that has this focus as its field of expertise, and he oversees the HolE-LIB project that looks at how the lithium in the batteries can be more easily recycled.

Economics play in

The main reasons battery factories are not making the batteries more recyclable are clearly economic.

“Yes, it’s more expensive to make batteries that are easier to recycle. But the day that the regulations for recycling become stricter, it will cost money to redesign and rebuild battery production,” says Bandyopadhyay.

He and his group already work closely with several industry players, including Hydro, Vianode, Hydrovolt, Glencore Nikkelverk and Morrow.

Many battery factories needed

Five giant battery factories for EVs are currently being built in Norway. They are located in:

  • Mo i Rana – Freyr Battery company.
  • Arendal – Morrow Batteries.
  • Orkanger – Elinor Batteries.
  • Stavanger – Beyonder.
  • Fredrikstad – Hreinn.

A few years ago, SINTEF, Scandinavia's largest independent research institute, estimated that Europe alone will need 55 new battery factories before 2030 to cover the need. By 2050, 600 such factories will be needed worldwide.

Use for other purposes difficult

Researchers at NTNU have also looked at whether fixing old batteries instead of just recycling them would be possible, and perhaps then using these batteries for purposes other than cars afterwards.

Bandyopadhyay points out that when an electric car battery is no longer usable for an EV, 80 per cent of its charge is still available.

Potentially the batteries could be used in other areas instead, such as for street lighting or various household purposes.

The two most common battery types are NMC batteries which contain nickel, manganese and cobalt, and LFP batteries which contain lithium, iron and phosphorus.

LFP batteries are generally unsuitable to use for other purposes. NMC batteries also run into problems, because they have to eventually be recycled anyway after being used for something other than cars. But the technical obstacles are not the whole problem.

“We can imagine replacing some of the defective cells in the batteries that have become inadequate for cars and then using these batteries for something else. But here we run into problems with legalities and who bears responsibility for the battery afterwards. Is the battery factory or the person who repaired the cells responsible?” says Bandyopadhyay.

Methods are getting better

“All Li-ion batteries have in common that they use graphite as the anode material. Currently this is not recycled, but at Vianode we’ve developed a method to also be able to recycle the graphite,” says Gunstein Skomedal, product manager for battery materials at Vianode.

NTNU is one of Vianode’s partners who are working on the recycling of graphite in the SUMBAT project. This work is supported by Innovation Norway, the Research Council of Norway and SIVA.

“This work is important so that we’ll be able to recycle all the valuable materials in the battery in the future,” says Skomedal.

Battery recycling is a complicated field. But the challenges must be solved if we are to reap the full benefit of converting to electric cars.

Altruism can make job seekers afraid to negotiate salary

With more companies today claiming they "make an impact," job candidates are guilted into accepting lower pay.

Peer-Reviewed Publication

UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS AT AUSTIN

AUSTIN, Texas — Job seekers looking to land a role with an altruistic organization may feel too guilty to ask for higher pay, according to a new study from the McCombs School of Business at The University of Texas at Austin.

Both for-profit and nonprofit organizations increasingly employ what has been termed “social impact framing” that emphasizes that their work has welfare benefits for society.

Although companies might have entirely noble intentions when using social impact framing, a recent study by Texas McCombs Assistant Professor of Management Insiya Hussain illustrates how it may work against prospective employees during salary negotiations. Specifically, job candidates exposed to such messaging feel it would be against company norms to ask for higher pay.

“This speaks to a broader social phenomenon about how we view money when it comes to doing good,” Hussain said. “There’s an implicit assumption that money and altruism don’t mix. Money taints attempts to do good. Even if job candidates might not necessarily subscribe to this view, they’re assuming that hiring managers will.”

The research is online in advance in Organization Science.

Hussain and co-authors Marko Pitesa and Michael Schaerer of Singapore Management University and Stefan Thau of INSEAD found that job candidates who were exposed to social impact framing refrained from negotiating for higher salaries because they felt uncomfortable with that “ask.”

They were concerned that asking for a greater material reward when an organization emphasized altruistic goals would be seen as inappropriate by those with hiring power, and they might thus be viewed unfavorably.

The researchers describe this attitude as a “self-censoring” effect, which Hussain said is a novel finding for research on social impact framing and wage demands. Prior work assumed that candidates sacrificed pay for meaningful work. Hussain and colleagues show this effect may be driven by job candidates feeling uncomfortable with such negotiation.

Whether companies are intentionally using social impact framing to suppress pay is unclear. But, regardless, the researchers suggest managers should be aware of what it may be costing the company in terms of human resources. They suggest that if managers are educated about their motivation purity bias, they can better temper their approach to prospective employees who ask about material rewards.

They also recommend managers create greater transparency about company norms and values regarding compensation, and that they offer job rewards based on objective criteria instead of salary negotiations.

“Job seekers could consider whether companies that stress social impact take care of their own employees — financially or otherwise,” Hussain said. “And companies shouldn’t assume that extrinsically motivated workers don’t care about the job and aren’t willing to work hard to perform well.”

Read the McCombs Big Ideas story.