Wednesday, September 01, 2021

OUCH
Manitoba chiefs endorse Liberal candidate at press conference with NDP’s Singh
Rachel Gilmore 
NDP leader Jagmeet Singh and Grand Chief Garrison Settee, left, Manitoba Keewatinowi Okimakanak, listen to Grand Chief Arlen Dumas, right, Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs, following a meeting Manitoba Keewatinowi Okimakanak in Winnipeg, on Thursday, August 26, 2021. 
THE CANADIAN PRESS/Paul Chiasson

Two Manitoba chiefs stepped up to the microphone at NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh's press conference last week and endorsed the candidate of their choice -- but it wasn't the NDP one.

Standing side by side before the cameras with Singh, they endorsed the Liberal candidate in their riding.

The awkward moment happened on Aug. 26, when the two First Nations leaders said their appearance at Singh's press conference shouldn't be read as a show of NDP support.

Commentary: Singh’s NDP seeks new seats with a focus on Indigenous campaigns

Rather, they're throwing their weight behind the Liberal candidate in the Churchill–Keewatinook Aski riding, Shirley Robinson, because she is Indigenous, Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs Grand Chief Arlen Dumas and Manitoba Keewatinowi Okimakanak (MKO) Grand Chief Garrison Settee shared at the microphone

NDP incumbent Niki Ashton is not Indigenous, and the chiefs said they'd like to see more Indigenous people involved in the political process.


"Our executive has recognized the candidate that is running for our riding and she's Indigenous," said Settee.

"We want Indigenous people to get involved in this process because as I said earlier, we have a vested interest in what happens in Canada when it comes to Indigenous people."

Dumas stepped up to the microphone immediately afterwards to echo Settee's remarks.

"We will always advance our First Nations candidates. On that level, being an elected official for the past two decades, I think that it's time for a fresh start in the north," Dumas said.

"I absolutely support Shirley Robinson in her candidacy."

Commentary: Federal election another ‘Moon of Many Promises’ for Indigenous people in Canada

And as Singh looked on, Settee stepped in front of the cameras once again.

"I concur with that comment," he said, following Dumas's explicit endorsement of the Liberal candidate.

Robinson had asked for the chiefs’ endorsement earlier this month, citing the fact that she is an Indigenous person and the incumbent candidate, Ashton, is not.

“What we need is a strong voice from a native speaker inside the halls of influence,” Robinson told the MKO chiefs earlier this month, according to a report in the Thompson Citizen.

However, Singh and the NDP are committed to keeping Ashton in the House — even as they seek to elect Indigenous New Democrats elsewhere in the country.

“It should be really clear that I support my candidate Niki Ashton,” Singh said on Friday during a stop in Thunder Bay, Ont.

“She has been a strong voice for Indigenous people and has a proven record, and New Democrats in general have shown that we are backing up our words with action.”


--With files from Global News' David Akin


Métis candidates hope to win seats for NDP, Liberals in Saskatchewan


Two Métis candidates are hoping to become blemishes on the Conservative’s perfect record of sending a full complement of 14 Members of Parliament from Saskatchewan to Ottawa.

Robert Doucette, who is running for the New Democratic Party in the Saskatoon-West riding, aims to become the first Indigenous MP to represent an urban riding in Saskatchewan.

Buckley Belanger, running for the Liberals in Desnethé—Missinippi—Churchill River, wants to be a voice on the inside of the government for his northern riding and Indigenous people.

Both men are strong candidates with public recognition in the political field, although their choice of federal parties may come as a surprise.

Doucette, who has been involved in Métis politics for 30 years, is the former president of the Métis Nation-Saskatchewan and presently is the executive director of the Saskatoon Indian and Métis Friendship Centre. In those positions, he has worked closely with the Liberal government and says he has “felt betrayed as an Indigenous person” by Crown-Indigenous Relations Minister Carolyn Bennett.

Doucette draws attention to the exclusion of Métis from the Sixties Scoop Settlement Agreement reached in 2017 despite, he says, Bennett’s promise to include Métis. The Liberals came to power in 2015. It took until this past July for the court to issue a certification order for a similar class action undertaken by Métis and non-status Indians.

“There’s lots of examples of why I’m running for the NDP… I want a leader and Jagmeet (Singh) is that person. Where he says, he or she, is going to do something and they actually do do it if they’re given a chance,” said Doucette, who says his personal values align with the NDP and his family has always voted NDP.

For Belanger, it’s been a move in the other direction. Although first being elected as a Liberal in 1995, Belanger has served in the Saskatchewan legislature as a member of the NDP since 1998, including as a member of the Cabinet for two NDP premiers.

“You’re sitting there as an elected NDPer, a provincial MLA, and you’re frustrated. I could have stayed there for three more years and collected a pay cheque and I just didn’t think that that was something I wanted to continue doing … If (running for the Liberals) was going to move the agenda for my people in my riding and make things a lot better, then it’s important that I keep that in mind,” he said.

Belanger says it was his lobbying for his constituents in the northern provincial riding of Athabasca that brought his name and work to the attention of federal Cabinet ministers and resulted in Prime Minister Justin Trudeau asking him to join his team.

Belanger is reluctant to draw parallels between his personal invitation from Trudeau and the personal recruitment of First Nation’s candidate Jody Wilson-Raybould in 2015. Wilson-Raybould resigned from the Liberal caucus in the midst of a political scandal that implicated Trudeau and was re-elected as an independent in 2019; she is not seeking re-election this time around.

“I don't know all the particulars and all the circumstances,” he said about Wilson-Raybould. “Any candidate, including me … has to have a team discipline, and that's how you get things done. And sometimes opinions can be very strong from people and lots of times it is difficult to keep the team intact, but I know being in Cabinet in Saskatchewan … you can certainly push your ideas and get your concepts to bring forward changes and if you get the support of the caucus and the Cabinet, you see those changes occur. But ... you still have to have a structure. You’ve got to have a team. You’ve got to have discipline. Those are prerequisites to being a good MP.”

Belanger points to Ontario, Quebec, the Atlantic provinces and British Columbia as having representatives within the government. He says Indigenous peoples and the prairie provinces also need representation. There were six Indigenous Liberal MPs elected in 2019.

“Instead of sitting at home hoping things happen, I want to be in there to drive the change and speed up the process,” said Belanger.

Doucette emphasizes that neither he nor the NDP are running to come in second or third, but he does point to the pivotal role the NDP played in a minority government during the coronavirus pandemic, which included getting the Liberals to double the Canada Emergency Response Benefit (CERB) from $1,000 to $2,000 a month and ensuring that small businesses got support.

“The NDP kept the Liberals and Conservatives honest in parliament,” he said.

A Mainstreet poll of the Saskatoon-West riding from Aug. 21 to Aug. 25 shows the NDP in a tie with the Conservatives, both with 33 per cent support.

Doucette says Saskatoon-West has substantial Indigenous, ethnic and diverse populations and if those numbers come out to the polls in strength, they “can have a huge impact in this riding.”

He also points out that incumbent Brad Redekopp was one of the 13 of 14 Saskatchewan Conservatives to vote against a bill to ban conversion therapy. That bill died in the Senate because of the election call.

Doucette said he has been door-knocking and has heard concerns about housing and the need for the NDP-proposed pharmacare (government-coverage costs for medicine). He stresses he has been following a strict protocol set out by the NDP for campaigning.

“A lot of the NDP supporters have said we need to carry forth with the 94 recommendations from the (Truth and Reconciliation Commission on the legacy of Indian residential schools). And also to ensure that the living conditions, the conditions that Indigenous people find themselves in, has to be rectified. And the NDP party has made that a priority,” said Doucette.

He underscores Singh’s early stop in the campaign at the Cowessess First Nation and meeting with Chief Cadmus Delorme to bring attention to the unmarked children’s graves found at the former residential school site and the experiences of those who attended residential schools.

Doucette is trying to return the Saskatoon-West seat to the NDP who won it in 2015.

Beyond the Conservative candidate Redekopp, Doucette is facing three other candidates in his fight: Liberal (Ruben Rajakumar), Green (David Greenfield), and People’s Party (Kevin Boychuk).

Belanger says “folks delivering food hampers from the federal Liberal government” during COVID-19’s community lockdown and the availability of CERB to help feed families and pay for utilities illustrated the concern the Trudeau government has for Indigenous people.

He says the Liberals have also lifted the majority of boil water advisories on First Nations and has pledged to continue with that work.

As for the criticism the party has faced for not meeting enough TRC Calls to Action or yet to implement a national action plan to deal with the recommendations from the Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls national inquiry final report, Belanger said, “When I spoke to the Prime Minister … he is very, very committed to working with me if we are successful and, obviously, he said he will continue to work even if we are not. We made great strides on that front. Obviously, you have to be inside of government to make things happen and that’s where I want to go.”

Belanger has a “4-H” campaign for the priorities in his riding: housing, highways, hope and healing. He says adequate housing, safe highways, and services for healing all “fit together” to give people hope.

Unlike the majority of Saskatchewan ridings, which saw Conservatives win with 70 per cent or more support, Conservative Gary Vidal won in Desnethé—Missinippi—Churchill River with 42 per cent of the support in 2019, as the First Nations NDP incumbent and the First Nations Liberal candidate split approximately 56 per cent of the vote.

Beside Vidal, Belanger is facing two other candidates who are both Indigenous. Harmonie King, a Métis, is running under the NDP banner, while Nasser Dean Chalifoux, non-status First Nations, is running for the Greens. Belanger is not concerned that the Indigenous vote – the riding is 71 per cent Indigenous – will be split and incumbent Vidal will maintain the seat.

“I’m the only northerner. I understand the challenges and that gives me a distinct advantage,” said Belanger, whose home in Île-à-la-Crosse puts him further north than any of the other five candidates. There is also an independent (Stephen King) and a candidate from the People’s Party (Dezirae Reddekopp).

The NDP have 27 self-declared Indigenous candidates running in this election; only one is an incumbent. The Liberals have not responded to requests from Windspeaker.com for similar information, although their five incumbent Indigenous MPs are running again. The Assembly of First Nations reports there are 15 Indigenous Liberal candidates running in this election.

Windspeaker.com

By Shari Narine, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter, Windspeaker.com, Windspeaker.com

ECOCIDE
BC
Herbicide spraying by lumber company hurts wildcraft business


An owner of Prince George foraging and wildcraft business is crying foul after learning a pair favourite spots for collecting her product have been sprayed with a controversial herbicide.


Jennifer Cote, owner of Moose Mushrooms and Mud, had travelled to two cutblocks she had previously scouted and at both locations, she found signs indicating it had been sprayed with a herbicide containing the chemical glyphosate.

The signs say people should avoid the area for 72 hours, but, according to James Steidle of Stop the Spray, recent research shows berries can have more glyphosate than what is allowed in stores the following year.

Cote erred on the side of caution and did not harvest any of the berries, forgoing hundreds of pounds in the process.

“There’s so much up there, and it can’t be touched. It really frustrates and saddens me,” said Cote in a statement issued by Steidle, who has long campaigned to eliminate use of herbicides in B.C. forests.

Cote uses the huckleberries to teach people how to make jams and jellies.

“I put three or four different jellies on the class. As soon as you put huckleberries on the list people are like woohooo...people look forward to the huckleberry jam,” said Cote.

“It’s a gourmet jam to some people as you don’t commonly find huckleberry jam in the grocery store. The reason you don’t find huckleberry jams in the grocery stores is because huckleberries cannot be grown commercially, like cultivated blueberries.

"Having huckleberries for wild-food classes is really awesome on the repertoire as it gives people a chance to taste some of the local and wild food that people may not otherwise be familiar with.”

Steidle said Canfor is behind the spraying which is used to clear cutblocks of deciduous trees and other types of vegetation to make way for seedlings of spruce, pine and fir that form the basis of lumber production in the Central Interior.

He has said that not only does the herbicide kill valuable species but pose a health hazard to people too, noting that glyphosate, the active ingredient, has been linked to cancer.

"Prince George area forests are the most heavily sprayed in British Columbia. One hundred percent of 2021 interior aerial spraying was conducted in P.G. regional forests, to the best of our knowledge," Steidle said. "The public is not notified beforehand and there is nothing the public can do to stop it.

In a statement, Canfor spokesperson Michelle Ward said the company no longer uses herbicides on leading stands of deciduous trees and, instead, relies on manual brushing on those sites.

"Our limited herbicide application is reserved for sites where it is required in order to meet legal reforestation requirements, and is done in strict accordance with Health Canada requirements. We continue to investigate ways to further reduce the use of herbicides going forward," Ward added.

Cote said the spraying has hurt her way of making a living.

“My hope this year was if I had enough of this wildcraft product in stock, not only could I run a few jam and jelly classes with the huckleberries, but I could also host a few ‘wild dessert’ classes and have a ‘wild-food-to-table social’ to talk about ‘all things wild,’" Cote said.

"There is a growing sector in which people want to know about wild, local food. Wild food helps reconnect us with the land. It can be part of people’s food security system and it provides a source of natural food, free from chemicals and sprays. Wild berries sprayed with herbicides are no longer ‘natural’.

“It’s not just about lumber, it’s about other people’s livelihoods and food security.”

Mark Nielsen, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter, Prince George Citizen
Level 3, not Level 4: U.S. mistakenly tells Americans ‘do not travel’ to Canada
Rachel Gilmore 
 Canadian and American flags fly near the Ambassador Bridge at the Canada-USA border crossing in Windsor, Ont. on Saturday, March 21, 2020.
 THE CANADIAN PRESS/Rob Gurdebeke

The United States mistakenly told Americans not to travel to Canada at all, just one day after warning prospective U.S. tourists to "reconsider" their travel plans due to the COVID-19 pandemic.


The U.S. State Department confirmed to Global News that it had to release a "corrected" travel advisory update, after mistakenly announcing that its travel advisory alert for Canada had been raised to a "level 4," which means "do not travel." The statement was reported by several media outlets.

Read more: U.S. advises citizens to ‘reconsider travel’ to Canada amid rise in COVID-19 cases

So while Americans are still being told to "reconsider" plans to travel to Canada — a "level 3" designation — they aren't being urged to cancel them altogether.

Multiple countries, including Switzerland, Laos and Estonia, were actually slapped with the highest alert level by the U.S. this week due to the rising spread of COVID-19.

The State Department's website describes Level 4 as the "highest advisory level" due to the "greater likelihood of life-threatening risks."

"During an emergency, the U.S. government may have very limited ability to provide assistance. The Department of State advises that U.S. citizens not travel to the country or to leave as soon as it is safe to do so," the website explained.

Canada's COVID-19 cases have been trending upwards recently in what experts are warning is a fourth wave driven by the Delta variant. Canada reported just over 2,700 new cases on Monday, and it has over 31,000 active COVID-19 cases across the country.

Read more: How bad is Canada’s 4th COVID-19 wave getting? Here’s a look at the data

The United States, however, has been seeing much higher case numbers. There have been over 158,000 daily average COVID-19 cases reported daily over the past week, according to the New York Times. That's about 272 active cases per 100,000 people in the United States, according to the Centers for Disease Control's tracker.

Canada, meanwhile, has just nine cases per 100,000 people, according to the New York Times.

For the first time in 16 months, Canada reopened its land borders for fully vaccinated Americans on Aug. 9, but the U.S. has yet to reciprocate.

American travellers who are fully vaccinated don’t have to quarantine upon arrival in Canada, but they’re required to show a negative COVID-19 test upon arrival and provide proof of vaccination by way of the ArriveCAN smartphone app or web portal.

Video: Coutts border sees slow 1st day of Americans being allowed into Canada for non-essential purposes

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, who is seeking re-election, stood by the decision when pressed on it by reporters on Tuesday.

"We have brought measures in that allow fully vaccinated Americans to come to Canada because we know that getting back to normal quickly is something we want to do, and if people are fully vaccinated, they are low risk. Extremely low risk," he said.

"There is a fourth wave, primarily around the unvaccinated, people unable or unwilling to get vaccinated right now, that is cause for concern. But that is why we are continuing to encourage and to create motivation and accountability and mandates and support passports so that more and more people get vaccinated."

Read more: Travellers double up on COVID-19 vaccine as Delta variant spreads through U.S.

Conservative Leader Erin O'Toole agreed that Americans should continue to be allowed into Canada.

"We need to make sure that we keep our economy open and the border open, safely," he said.

"We can do that by leveraging the levels of vaccination, of course, in our country and in the United States, but also faster access with daily rapid testing."

Over 82 per cent of Canadians aged 12 and older have received at least one dose of a COVID-19 vaccine, and over 74 per cent are fully vaccinated, according to Health Canada.

The United States hasn't been quite as enthusiastic in its uptake of the vaccine. Just over 61 per cent of Americans have gotten at least one COVID-19 vaccine dose, according to the CDC, and a little over 52 per cent are fully vaccinated.

The U.S. has extended land border restrictions — in place since March 2020 — for Canadians and Mexicans until Sept. 21.

--With files from Global News' Saba Aziz
Vaccine hesitancy highest in Alberta, racialized groups at rollout's start: survey

TORONTO — A national survey suggests the vast majority of Canadians planned to get vaccinated against COVID-19 when the country's rollout began, but intentions were lower among certain demographics, including residents of Alberta and racialized communities
.
© Provided by The Canadian Press

The survey, led by researchers at Toronto's St. Michael's Hospital, was published online Tuesday in The Lancet Regional Health —Americas.


The survey asked more than 14,500 Canadians online between December 2020 and February 2021 if they intended to get vaccinated once they were eligible, with researchers identifying differences in participants by age, education, ethnicity, and home province.

Nine per cent of respondents overall said they did not intend to get vaccinated, with hesitancy highest in Alberta at 16 per cent, and Manitoba and Saskatchewan, both at 14 per cent.

Fifteen per cent of respondents who identified as Indigenous and 12 per cent of those identifying as racialized said they did not intend to get vaccinated.

Men were more hesitant than women overall — 11 per cent versus eight — and participants aged 40 to 59 had the lowest vaccination intention, with about 12 per cent reporting no intention to get vaccinated.

The survey suggested that education also factored into hesitancy, with 14 per cent of participants with a college education or less saying they did not intend to get vaccinated, compared to five per cent of respondents with a bachelor's degree or higher.

The study did not indicate whether intent translated into action, but researchers say they plan to answer that in the coming months.

They noted that 18 per cent of eligible Canadians had not yet received a COVID-19 vaccine dose by Aug. 27 — nearly twice the rate expected in the survey.

Researchers said the findings should encourage policymakers to target vaccine campaigns on the most reluctant groups, as well as those who said they planned to get a shot but did not.

The study was a collaboration between the Centre for Global Health Research at Unity Health Toronto, the University of Toronto and the Angus Reid Forum. Funding was provided by an unrestricted grant from Pfizer Global Medical Grants and Unity Health Toronto.

This report by The Canadian Press was first published Aug. 31, 2021.

The Canadian Press
ANTI MASK, ANTI MIGRANT, ANTI VAXXER
People's Party of Canada leader Maxime Bernier makes Alberta campaign stop

CBC/Radio-Canada 16 hrs ago
 
© CBC People's Party of Canada Leader Maxime Bernier speaks to supporters at a community hall in Cochrane, Alta., on Monday evening, joining Banff-Airdrie riding candidate Nadine Wellwood as they hosted town halls there and in Airdrie.

People's Party of Canada Leader Maxime Bernier made his federal election pitch to Albertans in person Monday night, joining Banff-Airdrie riding candidate Nadine Wellwood as they hosted two town halls in Cochrane and Airdrie.

More than 200 people showed up at a Cochrane community hall for speeches and a question period with Bernier, in his first Alberta stop during the campaign before the Sept. 20 election.

Bernier says the PPC is the only national political party speaking against COVID-19 vaccination passports and mask mandates, arguing the party is standing up for freedom of choice.

"We want to be sure that Albertans and Canadians understand that this election, it's about our way of life," he said.

"Do you want more and more of the same? Draconian restrictions on your freedoms, or you want to go back to your life before COVID-19?"

The party's platform also includes more provincial autonomy, significant changes to the federal equalization plan, a withdrawal from the Paris Climate Accords, a streamlined pipeline approval process and finding a private buyer for the Trans Mountain project.
'The Conservative Party of Canada abandoned Alberta,' says PPC candidate

PPC candidate Nadine Wellwood said she believes she is the better choice for voters in the Banff-Airdrie riding who want a truly conservative candidate than Conservative candidate, Blake Richards, the incumbent.

"The Conservative Party of Canada abandoned Alberta, in my opinion, and conservatives a long time ago," she said. "If we want change in our province, we have to change how we vote."

As of Tuesday morning, other candidates in the Banff-Airdrie riding include: Aidan Blum for the Green Party, David Gamble for the Liberals, Tariq Elnaga for the Maverick Party, Sarh Zagoda for the NDP and John Ross, Derek Sloan and Caroline O'Driscoll as Independents.

PPC trying to lure voters who feel O'Toole is 'Liberal-light': political scientist


Mount Royal University policy studies professor Duane Bratt says the PPC is trying to appeal to voters who feel like Conservative Party Leader Erin O'Toole is just "Liberal-light."

"It's going to be anti-COVID and it will be anti-climate change. And for a certain segment of society, those two almost go hand in hand — that you can't believe the science on climate and you can't believe the science on COVID because they saw a YouTube video," he said.

The People's Party of Canada didn't win a seat in 2019 and received just 1.6 per cent of the vote.

"It's possible they could be picking up more votes, maybe they'll be at four, maybe they'll be at five per cent," Bratt said.

"Clearly, there are people that do support him, largely in rural Alberta."

Other party leaders visited Alberta early


Alberta tends to receive little attention from party leaders during federal election campaigns, as it traditionally has elected Conservatives to all or the vast majority of its 34 ridings.

While the Liberals had a breakthrough in the 2015 election that brought Justin Trudeau to power, capturing four seats, they lost them all in 2019 with the Conservatives capturing every riding except a central Edmonton one retained by the NDP.

During that 2019 campaign, Albertans barely glimpsed the major party leaders. The then-leader of the Conservatives, Andrew Scheer, only made two visits to the province, as did Trudeau — including one in the final hours of the campaign. Bernier campaigned a bit in the province, the Green leader stopped once and the NDP's Jagmeet Singh didn't visit at all.

This time around, Bernier, whose next stops are in B.C. and Saskatchewan, has not been the only national party leader to swing by relatively early in the campaign.

Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau visited Calgary on Aug.19 for a rally with candidate George Chahal, who is trying to take the Calgary Skyview riding for the Liberals.

The incumbent, lawyer Jag Sahota, won back the riding back for the Conservatives in 2019. Other confirmed candidates as of Tuesday include: Nadeem Rana for the Centrist Party, Janna So for the Greens, Lee Aquart as an Independent, Daniel Blanchard for the Marxist-Leninists, Gurinder Singh Gill for the NDP and Harry Dhillon for the PPC.


Hours before Trudeau appeared in Calgary, NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh made campaign stops in Edmonton, where he promised more money for health care.

And Conservative Leader Erin O'Toole made an appearance in Edmonton on Aug. 21, where he promised to increase the disability supplement of the Canada Workers Benefit from $713 to $1,500.
In climate reversal, Biden okays new oil and gas mega auction

Issued on: 01/09/2021 - 
The court decision to ban a pause in leasing area in the Gulf of Mexico for oil exploration represents a significant step back for the White House's ambitious climate agenda and was quickly challenged by a coalition of environmental groups
 Jim WATSON AFP/File


Washington (AFP)

US President Joe Biden's administration on Tuesday announced plans to open more than 80 million acres in the Gulf of Mexico for oil and gas exploration after a court ruled against the administration's pause in leasing.

The decision represents a significant step back for the White House's ambitious climate agenda and was quickly challenged by a coalition of environmental groups.

The Interior Department's Bureau of Ocean Energy Management expects a final notice of sale in September, "with a lease sale to follow in the fall of this year," the agency said in a statement.

In January, Biden announced a moratorium on new drilling from federal land pending a review, as the Democrat sought to place the climate crisis at the heart of his presidency.

But in June, a Louisiana judge appointed by former president Donald Trump stepped in to rule that the administration required approval from Congress for its pause.

According to a Record of Decision posted online, the government projects up to 1.1 billion barrels of oil and 4.4 trillion cubic feet of gas from the auction.

It noted a new report by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change "detailing observations of a rapidly changing climate in every region globally," but said it did not present sufficient cause to change the environmental impact statement for the drilling at this time.

Environmental groups led by the Earthjustice advocacy group sued the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management and Interior Secretary Deb Haaland after the notice.

"In the aftermath of Hurricane Ida, it is clear that we need to be doing everything we can to transition away from fossil fuels to reduce the impacts of climate change such as stronger, more frequent hurricanes," said Healthy Gulf's executive director Cynthia Sarthou.

"This lease sale is deeply disappointing. The Biden administration has folded to the oil industry based on its campaign of disinformation and political pressure, ignoring the worsening climate emergency we face," added Brettny Hardy, Earthjustice attorney.

© 2021 AFP
New hate trial for French far-right veteran Jean-Marie Le Pen


Issued on: 01/09/2021 - 
Jean-Marie Le Pen has long relished in the outrage provoked by his comments regarding Jews, blacks and immigrants. 
JOEL SAGET AFP/File

Paris (AFP)

The 93-year-old founder of France's main far-right party, Jean-Marie Le Pen, goes on trial Wednesday over allegations of once again inciting racial hatred, this time with comments targeting a Jewish pop singer.

He already has a string of hate speech convictions that eventually became too much for his daughter Marine Le Pen, who expelled him from the National Front's leadership in 2015 in a bid to achieve mainstream respectability.

Le Pen senior, however, has continued to relish the outrage prompted by his statements regarding Jews, Muslims, black people and immigrants.


The latest trial stems from a 2014 video on the party's website in which Le Pen railed against artists who denounced his extremist stances, including Madonna and the French tennis star-turned-singer Yannick Noah.

Asked about the French singer and actor Patrick Bruel, Le Pen referred to his Jewish origins with a pun evoking the Holocaust -- "I'm not surprised. Listen, next time we'll do a whole oven batch!"

The taunt sparked a torrent of indignation including from leaders of his own party, with Marine Le Pen criticising what she called a "political error".

Jean-Marie claimed the comments carried no anti-Semitic connotations "except for my political enemies or imbeciles".

He does not intend to appear in person at the trial in Paris, where he is charged with inciting anti-Semitic hatred, according to associates.

"This case is based only on part of a phrase taken out of context," said his lawyer Frederic Joachim, who will seek to have the charge dismissed.

- Challenges loom -

The trial was delayed for years while Le Pen claimed immunity from prosecution as an MEP, a seat he won in 1984 and held until 2019.

But fellow lawmakers stripped his legal protections over the case in 2016.

Le Pen, his daughter and others from the party -- now rebranded the National Rally -- are also facing financial misconduct charges over subsidies earmarked for paying their EU parliamentary aides.

Investigators say they used 6.8 million euros ($8 million) in public funds to finance party work in France.

Despite the troubles, Jean-Marie Le Pen remains a regular media presence and a lodestar for many on the far right who brush off his multiple hate speech convictions -- not least his repeated insistence that the Nazi gas chambers were just a "detail" of history.

His shock success in the 2002 presidential election -- getting to the run-off stage before being defeated by Jacques Chirac -- sent the leftwing Socialists into the political wilderness and proved to his supporters that a rightward lurch in France was possible.

But a new conviction could complicate the bid by Marine Le Pen to take on Emmanuel Macron again for the presidency next year, especially after the National Rally failed to take control of any French region in elections last June.

© 2021 AFP
South America's Parana river is drying up, baffling experts

Issued on: 01/09/2021 - 
Aerial view of people walking along the Parana river bank in Rosario, Santa Fe, Argentina, in August 2021 
JUAN MABROMATA AFP


Corrientes (Argentina) (AFP)

South America's second longest river, the Parana, has dropped to its lowest level since the 1940s, leaving environmentalists and experts worried that climate change is to blame.

The decrease has become so drastic that it is affecting commercial shipping, electricity generation, fishing, tourism, as well as the provision of water for drinking and irrigation.

The effects even extend to the changing of topographies, soil and the mineral composition of the river's water

Experts are baffled as to whether this is part of a natural cycle or the result of climate change.

The Parana is linked to the Guarani aquifer -- one of the largest underwater fresh water sources in the world -- and runs for more than 4,000 kilometers (2,500 miles) through Brazil, Paraguay and Argentina.

It merges with the Paraguay and Uruguay rivers, forming the Rio de la Plata before emptying out into the Atlantic Ocean. Along the way, it splits into several arms and forms the Parana Delta wetlands in Argentina, feeding many agricultural plains.

"The Parana is the largest, most biodiverse and the most important socio-productive wetland in Argentina," geologist Carlos Ramonell, a professor at the National University of the Littoral in Santa Fe, told AFP.

While the main branch of the river continues to flow, in its network of irrigation channels "only 10 to 20 percent have water, the rest are dry," said Ramonell.

"People have mentioned Brazilian dams, deforestation and climate change as causes but from a scientific point of view we cannot say. Obviously it is due to a lack of rains, but what provoked that?"

Horses gallop along a tributary of the Parana river that has been left almost dry by falling water levels
 JUAN MABROMATA AFP

The navigable part of the Parana is vital for landlocked Paraguay and Bolivia.

"It's not been possible to sail the Parana since April. Goods have to be transported by land to the Paraguay river, which quadruples the cost," Juan Carlos Munoz, director of the Paraguayan riverboat owners association, told AFP.

Some 4,000 barges, 350 tug boats and 100 container carriers were waiting for the river level to rise.

The rainy season was still three months away.

In May, Brazil exceptionally opened its dams to allow hundreds of barges to pass downstream, but the river level has since dropped too low.

Bolivia's soy bean exports and diesel imports have been affected.

- 'Enormous impact' -


The Parana's average flow rate is 17,000 cubic meters a second, but that has dropped to just 6,200 -- barely above the record low of 5,800 recorded in 1944.

That has reduced by half the electricity generated by the Yacyreta hydroelectric plant that spans the Parana river between Argentina and Paraguay. The plant supplies 14 percent of Argentina's electricity.

Vehicle tracks can be seen close to a boat sitting at the bottom of the dried up river bed of a Parana tributary in Goya, Argentina
 JUAN MABROMATA AFP

"Last year we thought we'd hit rock bottom but this year it got worse," said Marcelo Cardinali, a manager at the plant.

The low water level has affected the ability of fish to reproduce, leaving streams cut off from the main river by sandbanks and blocking off lagoons where they would usually lay their eggs.

"Added to the stress suffered by the biotic system due to being cut off, is the water's increasing saline content," said Ramonell.

The dried up streams have exposed piles of rubbish while cattle have started grazing on the weeds that appear at the bottom of empty lagoons.

"With the dropping water level, all the chemicals -- mercury, lead -- are concentrated on the shore. When the water returns, the fish that suck mud will die. We're going to see an enormous impact," said Ana Pirkas, a resident in Goya, a city in Corrientes province that has seen its fishing tourism sector disappear.

A hydrometer in Itati, Argentina, marks the exceptionally low level of the Parana river JUAN MABROMATA AFP

A weekend fishing ban has been put in place to protect the river's 200 fish species.

"Since the dams were built, the river has changed a lot," said fisherman Ramon Acuna.

Gone are the tarpon -- at the base of the Parana fish pyramid -- that Acuna's father used to fish.

"We cannot discount the possibility that the dropping water level is just a natural variable," said Ramonell, pointing to similar cycles a century ago, when there were no dams, deforestation or global warming.

Who, or what, is to blame is a question yet to be answered.

© 2021 AFP
ALL CAPITALI$M IS STATE CAPITALI$M
North African sun offers green hope but state role key

Issued on: 01/09/2021 - 
This handout satellite imagery released by Maxar Technologies on May 20, 2021 shows a view of the Noor Ouarzazate solar complex in Morocco - 
Satellite image ©2021 Maxar Technologies/AFP


Cairo (AFP)

Blessed with year-round sunshine, North Africa has enormous potential for solar energy, but the huge investment and state subsidies required for large-scale projects are a challenge for cash-strapped regional governments.

The region boasts a few marquee projects that are among the largest in the world but renewable energy entrepreneurs say the focus should be at community level, helping whole villages to operate off the national grid and without using diesel fuel.

Egypt, the most populous Arab country, with more than 100 million people, has made solar power a priority in its quest to source 42 percent of its electricity from renewables by 2035.


In the western desert, about 40 kilometres (25 miles) north of the southern city of Aswan stands the Benban Solar Park. Visible from space, the $4 billion World Bank-funded project is the fourth largest solar park in the world, stretching over 37 square kilometres (14 square miles).

With six million solar panels, Benban was connected to Egypt's national grid in 2019 and currently produces 930 gigawatt hours a year, which is enough to light up 420,000 households, according to the UN.

Egypt's 42 percent target is an ambitious one. In 2016, just nine percent of its power needs came from renewable sources, according to official figures.

- Incentives -

But experts say the state will need to provide incentives if it expects much help from consumers, few of whom have the means or space to switch to solar energy for their household needs.

"In Cairo, it's a bit difficult to install solar panels because you need a lot of space on top of buildings plus it doesn't cover all your electricity needs like powering an air conditioner during summer," said Mohamed Abdel Raouf, an expert on green economies in the region.

]This handout satellite imagery released by Maxar Technologies on May 20, 2021 shows a view of the power substation at the Benban Solar Park in Egypt. The $4 billion World Bank-funded project is the fourth largest solar park in the world - 
Satellite image ©2021 Maxar Technologies/AFP

He said tourist resorts on the Red Sea and Mediterranean coasts as well as rural centres offered more fertile ground.

"The state needs to incentivise it for the average consumer because it would cost me around 60,000 pounds ($3,800) to switch over to solar energy for my home in urban Cairo," he said.

"Why would I invest in environmentally friendly technology that's expensive? The state really needs to take the lead in making it attractive."

The International Energy Agency said over the past decade North Africa has managed to increase its renewable energy production by 40 percent. But that does not mean that addiction to fossil fuels has waned.

In oil-rich Algeria, which receives around 3,600 hours of sun per year, renewable energy only represents a paltry 1.8 percent of the country's consumption.

- 'Monstrous projects' -

In Morocco, the gaps in its green strategy are embodied by the gigantic Noor Ouarzazate solar complex -- the world's largest multi-technology solar installation.

At the gateway to the Sahara, the enormous complex has four power plants with an installed capacity of 530 megawatts.

Blessed with year-round sunshine, North Africa has enormous potential for solar energy Ludovic MARIN AFP

"From the start, it was clear that the strategy was unbalanced. The strategic error was to want to invest in monstrous projects that are difficult to finance," Said Guemra, a specialist in energy management, told AFP.

Rabat sells its green energy at a loss with the generating costs double the price it is sold at to the national grid.

Concentrated solar power (CSP) stations produce energy costing between 1.6 and 1.4 dirhams (18 cents to 16 cents) per kilowatt hour, which is sold to the National Electricity Office (ONEE) at 0.8 dirhams.

The strategy has not paid off and the privately-owned, publicly-funded Moroccan Agency for Sustainable Energy (Masen), which runs the Noor complex, is more than $100 million in debt.

The CEO of Cairo-based start-up Karm Solar, Ahmed Zahran, says it is time to move away from the model of selling electricity to the state in a private public partnership like Benban.

"The business model... is pretty abusive and... not comprehensive. Companies are focusing on selling electricity to one offtaker (the state) and they're not interested in participating in the infrastructure of the countries they're operating in," Zahran told AFP.

"So they're always viewed as opportunistic investors, who are trying to get specific contracts in place, preferably with the government and that's it."

Zahran's company designs solar-powered buildings and water pumping systems to help whole villages operate off the national grid and without using diesel fuel.

It was the first private solar company to obtain a power distribution licence in Egypt.

"We realised that our future is not in being a solar developer but in being a utility-scale solar firm... We're working on the entire infrastructure from building the power plant, building the distribution network, we're doing the tower management, the power mix, everything," Zahran said.

His firm says it has saved 2.3 million litres (608,000 gallons) of diesel and offset 10,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide annually in the process of installing solar plant projects with over 71 MW capacity.

© 2021 AFP
Tunisia plants seeds of hope against climate change



Issued on: 01/09/2021 - 
A Tunisian farmer harvests wheat in the Jedaida region, some 30 kilometres (18 miles) northwest of the capital Tunis
 FETHI BELAID AFP

Jedaida (Tunisia) (AFP)

Tunisian farmers are turning to the past to ensure a future by planting indigenous seeds as the North African country suffers at a time of drought, disease and climate change.

Traditional seeds come from a genetic heritage best suited to the environment, said Maher Medini, from Tunisia's National Gene Bank, which promotes the development of sustainable agriculture in the country.

"They are reservoirs of genes hundreds, if not thousands of years old," Medini said, adding that the seeds are more resistant to the ever-growing dangerous impacts of global warming.

Climate change is causing challenging variations in rainfall, temperature and humidity, creating disease in the crops, he said.

"The foundation of adaptation is diversity," Medini said.

Wheat varieties developed in the 1980s are being blighted by disease in Tunisia, but farmers say that traditional varieties appear to be more resistant.

In the past, using indigenous seeds, Tunisian farmers set aside a small part of the harvest to sow in the next season.

But the development of hybrid or genetically modified seeds resulted in better harvests, and native varieties largely fell out of use.

One problem is that seeds from the new varieties cannot be replanted, and farmers have to buy in more seed every year.

Now some farmers are looking at the methods used by their forebears.

Mohamed Lassad ben Saleh farms in the agricultural region of Jedaida, some 30 kilometres (18 miles) northwest of the capital Tunis.

Wheat varieties developed in the 1980s are being blighted by disease in Tunisia, but farmers say that traditional varieties appear to be more resistant
 FETHI BELAID AFP

Eight years ago he switched to planting a traditional variety of wheat, known as Al-Msekni. On his farm, the harvest is now in full swing.

The wheat harvested from each hectare is weighed separately, so each plot's productivity can be calculated.

"The results are good," Ben Saleh said.

- Superior yield -


When he meets other farmers, he lets them know how his traditional seeds are performing.

The national average in recent years has been 1.4 to two tonnes a hectare, while Ben Saleh says his yield has been five tonnes.

Ben Saleh reports his seeds are more resistant to drought and disease, which means he does not have to use as much pesticide.

The UN's Food and Agriculture Organization estimates that over the past century, around three quarters of the diversity in world crops has disappeared 
FETHI BELAID AFP

"The new varieties are weak and quickly affected by mould," he said.

With most farmers buying new seeds every season, the country currently imports 70 percent to 80 percent of its seeds each year.

"A return to local or native seeds is one of the conditions needed to reach food sovereignty," said Aymen Amayed, a researcher in agricultural policies.

The UN's Food and Agriculture Organization has warned against the increased use of hybrid seeds, and considers it a threat to indigenous varieties and to local genetic heritage.

The FAO estimates that over the past century, around three quarters of the diversity in world crops has disappeared.

- '2050 is tomorrow' -

But Tunisia's gene bank is working to "reclaim its genetic heritage".

Since 2008, it has been collecting traditional seeds from farmers, and also working to recover indigenous Tunisian seeds stored in gene banks around the world.

In the past, using indigenous seeds, Tunisian farmers set aside a small part of the harvest to sow in the next season 
FETHI BELAID AFP

So far, it has been able to repatriate more than 7,000 samples of seeds from fruit trees, cereals and vegetables out of over 11,000 located worldwide.

These seeds are once more being planted in Tunisian soil.

M'barek Ben Naceur, head of the national gene bank, says that more than 400 farmers have been persuaded to use these seeds, and old varieties such as Al-Msekni and Al-Mahmoudi are being sown again.

"These seeds are the descendants of this land, and they know it," said Ben Naceur.

"Our varieties have been accustomed to rises in temperature and drought for thousands of years, so they will resist climate change and temperature rises," he added.

A report last month by the UN's Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change showed unequivocally that the climate is changing faster than previously feared, and because of human activity.

August saw record-breaking temperatures: in Tunis the mercury reached 48 degrees Celsius at midday (118 Fahrenheit), smashing the capital's previous record high of 46.8 degrees in 1982.

'A return to local or native seeds is one of the conditions needed to reach food sovereignty,' one researcher in agricultural policies said
 FETHI BELAID AFP

"Between now and 2050, temperatures in the world will rise between 1.8 and two degrees," Ben Naceur said.

"And 2050 is tomorrow -- it's not so far away. Varieties that are not resistant will disappear."

© 2021 AFP
Sri Lanka organic revolution threatens tea disaster

Issued on: 01/09/2021 -
Tea plantation owners warn a crop failure would cause huge unemployment
 Ishara S. KODIKARA AFP

Ahangama (Sri Lanka) (AFP)

Sri Lanka's drive to become the world's first 100 percent organic food producer threatens its prized tea industry and has triggered fears of a wider crop disaster that could deal a further blow to the beleaguered economy.

President Gotabaya Rajapaksa banned chemical fertilisers this year to set off his organic race but tea plantation owners are predicting crops could fail as soon as October, with cinnamon, pepper and staples such as rice also facing trouble.

Master tea maker Herman Gunaratne, one of 46 experts picked by Rajapaksa to guide the organic revolution, fears the worst.

"The ban has drawn the tea industry into complete disarray," Gunaratne said at his plantation in Ahangama, in rolling hills 160 kilometres (100 miles) south of Colombo.

"The consequences for the country are unimaginable."

The 76-year-old, who grows one of the world's most expensive teas, fears that Sri Lanka's average annual crop of 300 million kilogrammes (660 million pounds) will be slashed by half unless the government changes course.

Sri Lanka is in the grip of a pandemic-induced economic crisis, with gross domestic product contracting more than three percent last year, and the government's hopes of a return to growth have been hit by a new coronavirus wave.

Fertiliser and pesticides are among a host of key imports -- including vehicles and spare parts -- the government has halted as it battles foreign currency shortages.

- Food security 'compromised' -

But tea is Sri Lanka's biggest single export, bringing in more than $1.25 billion a year -- accounting for about 10 percent of the country's export income.

Rajapaksa came to power in 2019 promising subsidised foreign fertiliser but did a U-turn arguing that agro chemicals were poisoning people.

Gunaratne, whose Virgin White tea sells for $2,000 a kilo, was removed last month from Rajapaksa's Task Force for a Green Socio-Economy after disagreeing with the president.

He says the country's Ceylon tea has some of the lowest chemical content of any tea and poses no threat.

Master tea maker Herman Gunaratne warned Sri Lanka's annual tea crop could be slashed by half unless the government rethinks its approach 
Ishara S. KODIKARA AFP

The tea crop hit a record 160 million kilos in the first half of 2021 thanks to good weather and old fertiliser stocks but the harvest started falling in July.

Sanath Gurunada, who manages organic and classic tea plantations in Ratnapura, southeast of Colombo, said that if the ban continues "the crop will start to crash by October and we will see exports seriously affected by November or December".

He told AFP his plantation maintained an organic section for tourism, but it was not viable. Organic tea costs 10 times more to produce and the market is limited, Gurunada added.

W.A. Wijewardena, a former central bank deputy governor and economic analyst, called the organic project "a dream with unimaginable social, political and economic costs".

He said Sri Lanka's food security had been "compromised" and that without foreign currency it is "worsening day by day".

- Jobs at stake -

Experts say the problem for rice is also acute while vegetable growers are staging near daily protests over reduced harvests and pest-affected crops.

"If we go completely organic, we will lose 50 percent of the crop, (but) we are not going to get 50 percent higher prices," Gunaratne said.

Tea plantation owners say that on top of the loss of earnings, a crop failure would cause huge unemployment as tea leaves are still picked by hand.

"With the collapse of tea, the jobs of three million people will be in jeopardy," the Tea Factory Owners Association said in a statement.

Tea is Sri Lanka's biggest export and brings in about $1.25 billion a year
 Ishara S. KODIKARA AFP

Plantations minister Ramesh Pathirana said the government hoped to provide organic compost in place of chemical fertilisers.

"Our government is committed to providing something good for the tea industry, fertiliser-wise," he told AFP.

Farmers say Sri Lanka's exports of cinnamon and pepper will also be affected by the organic drive.

Sri Lanka supplies 85 percent of the global market for Ceylon Cinnamon, one of the two leading types of the spice, according to United Nations figures.

Still, Rajapaksa remains confident in his course, telling a recent UN summit that he was confident that his organic initiative will ensure "greater food security and nutrition" for Sri Lankans.

He has called on other countries to follow Sri Lanka's move with the "bold steps required to sustainably transform the world food system".

© 2021 AFP
New coronavirus variant ‘Mu’ under close scrutiny by WHO


Issued on: 01/09/2021 -
Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, the head of the World Health Organization (WHO), delivering a speech on May 24, 2021. 
© Christopher Black, AFP
Text by: NEWS WIRES


The World Health Organization has said it is monitoring a new coronavirus variant known as "Mu", which was first identified in Colombia in January 2021.

Mu, known scientifically as B.1.621, has been classified as a "variant of interest", the global health body said Tuesday in its weekly pandemic bulletin.


The WHO said the variant has mutations that indicate a risk of resistance to vaccines and stressed that further studies were needed to better understand it.

"The Mu variant has a constellation of mutations that indicate potential properties of immune escape," the bulletin said.

There is widespread concern over the emergence of new virus mutations as infection rates are ticking up globally again, with the highly transmissible Delta variant taking hold – especially among the unvaccinated – and in regions where anti-virus measures have been relaxed.

All viruses, including SARS-CoV-2 that causes Covid-19, mutate over time and most mutations have little or no effect on the properties of the virus.

But certain mutations can impact the properties of a virus and influence how easily it spreads, the severity of the disease it causes, and its resistance to vaccines, drugs and other countermeasures.

The WHO currently identifies four Covid-19 variants of concern, including Alpha, which is present in 193 countries, and Delta, present in 170 countries.

Five variants, including Mu, are to be monitored.

After being detected in Colombia, Mu has since been reported in other South American countries and in Europe.

The WHO said its global prevalence has declined to below 0.1 percent among sequenced cases. In Colombia, however, it is at 39 percent.

(AFP)

  • James Churchward - Wikipedia

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Churchward

    James Churchward (27 February 1851 – 4 January 1936) was a British occult writer, inventor, engineer, and fisherman. Churchward is most notable for proposing the existence of a lost continent, called "Mu," in the Pacific Ocean. His writings on Mu are considered to be pseudoscience.

    Churchward was born in Bridestow, Okehampton, Devon at Stone House to Henry and Matilda (née Gould) Churchward. James had four brothers and four sisters. In November 1854, Henry died and the family moved in with Matilda's parents in the hamlet of Kigbear, near Okehampton. Census records indicate the family next moved to London when James was 18 after his grandfather George Gould died. 

    Wikipedia · Text under CC-BY-SA license
  • THE SACRED SYMBOLS OF MU - James Churchward

    www.bahaistudies.net/.../Col-James-Churchward-The-Sacred-Symbol… · PDF file

    COLONEL JAMES CHURCHWARD AUTHOR OF "THE LOST CONTINENT OF MU" "THE CHILDREN OF MU" ILLUSTRATED IVES WASHBURN; NEW YORK Scanned at sacred-texts.com, December, 2003.

  • 3 Beards Podcast: Is the Lost Continent of Mu Real?

    Author Jack Churchward joins the show to talk about his books that cover The Lost Continent of Mu, a subject brought to life by the works of his great grandfather Col. James Churchward.

    Lifting the Veil on the Lost Continent of Mu: The Motherland of Men
    The Stone Tablets of Mu
    Crossing the Sands of Time
    are books Jack Churchward has penned to cover the works of his great grandfather and bring into focus on what is fact and what is fiction.

    The mythical idea of the “Land of Mu” first appeared in the works of the British-American antiquarian Augustus Le Plongeon (1825–1908), after his investigations of the Maya ruins in Yucatán. He claimed that he had translated the first copies of the Popol Vuh, the sacred book of the K’iche’ from the ancient Mayan using Spanish. He claimed the civilization of Yucatán was older than those of Greece and Egypt, and told the story of an even older continent.

    Col. James Churchward claimed that the landmass of Mu was located in the Pacific Ocean, and stretched east–west from the Marianas to Easter Island, and north–south from Hawaii to Mangaia. According to Churchward the continent was supposedly 5,000 miles from east to west and over 3,000 miles from north to south, which is larger than South America. The continent was believed to be flat with massive plains, vast rivers, rolling hills, large bays, and estuaries. He claimed that according to the creation myth he read in the Indian tablets, Mu had been lifted above sea level by the expansion of underground volcanic gases. Eventually Mu “was completely obliterated in almost a single night” after a series of earthquakes and volcanic eruptions, “the broken land fell into that great abyss of fire” and was covered by “fifty millions of square miles of water.” Churchward claimed the reasoning for the continent’s destruction in one night was because the main mineral on the island was granite and was honeycombed to create huge shallow chambers and cavities filled with highly explosive gases. Once the chambers were empty after the explosion, they collapsed on themselves, causing the island to crumble and sink.

    Has the wildlife 'Red List' let Africa's big cats down?


    Issued on: 01/09/2021 -
    Lions have lost more than 90 percent of their range and their numbers over the last 150 years 
    Roberto SCHMIDT AFP/File

    Paris (AFP)

    Lions and cheetahs are closer to extinction than the authoritative Red List of Threatened Species suggests, according to conservation scientists who warn that sharp drops in populations could be going undetected.

    Africa's marquee big cats are currently listed as "vulnerable", but with declines in lion numbers close to the threshold for a higher risk category and heated debate over how many cheetahs are actually left in the wild, experts are asking if this is enough.

    An "uplisting" does not guarantee protection, they say, but it would more accurately reflect their dire situation and could channel resources to help them survive in the wild, where they are most recently menaced by poaching and the pet trade.

    The stone lions guarding Beijing's Forbidden City, the bronze ones at Admiral Nelson's feet on Trafalgar Square, the constellation Leo and the emblems of a score of top European football clubs all attest to the cultural significance of these majestic creatures.

    But as apex predators, they are also lynchpins in their ecosystems -- as South African conservationist Paul Funston puts it, the "big daddy holding a lot of things in place."

    For half a century, the International Union for the Conservation of Nature (IUCN) Red List has classified species along a spectrum from "least concern" and "near threatened" to "vulnerable", "endangered", "critically endangered" and "extinct in the wild".

    Broadly, if at least half the population of a species is lost within three generations, it moves to a more threatened category.

    Last stop on the slide to oblivion is "extinct".

    Threatened status can trigger national protective measures, restrictions in international trade and funding from states or NGOs.

    Lions and cheetahs were both reconfirmed as "vulnerable" in 2014 and are unlikely to change category in a Red List update at the IUCN congress in Marseille, from Friday.

    But some experts want the IUCN to go further.

    "Cheetahs should be classified as 'endangered'," Sarah Durant, an expert on cheetahs and a member of the IUCN's cat specialist group, told AFP via Zoom.

    Following the 2014 assessment, to which she contributed, Durant and another 50 conservation experts made that case in a peer-reviewed study.

    One-size-fits-all criteria applied by the IUCN, they argued, do not do justice to all species.

    - Catastrophic declines -

    Overall, the cheetah's global numbers were estimated to have dropped about 30 percent to roughly 7,000 over the space of three generations, or 15 years.

    To put that in perspective, the ratio of people to cheetahs on Earth is roughly a million-to-one.

    While steep, the decline was still well short of the 50-percent threshold for an uplisting to "endangered".

    But that assessment is likely over-optimistic, scientists say, because the data comes overwhelmingly from protected areas, such as national parks and game reserves, even though that is not where most cheetahs are found.

    About three-quarters of the big cat's range -- and an estimated two-thirds of its population -- is in unprotected zones where the solitary feline must contend with scarce prey, fragmented habitat and deadly encounters with pastoralists defending their livestock.

    "We're measuring population decline in the area where they're actually doing best," Durant said.

    More long-term, the picture is even bleaker.

    The cheetah once roamed as a top predator across most of Africa, the Middle East, central Asia and India, but today occupies less than 10 percent of its historic range 
    JOE KLAMAR AFP/File

    The cheetah was once a top predator across most of Africa, the Middle East, central Asia and India, but today it occupies only a sliver -- less than 10 percent -- of its historic range.

    And since 1900, their numbers have dropped by more than 90 percent.

    "These are catastrophic declines," said Durant, a professor in conservation science at the Zoological Society of London.

    Lions have not fared better, even if their population in the wild exceeds 20,000, said Funston, senior director of the lion programme at conservation NGO Panthera.

    In the 2014 assessment, to which he contributed, their global population was found to have dropped by 43 percent over three generations -- 21 years -- missing a reclassification threshold by a whisker.

    - Hunted -


    Unlike cheetahs, lions live in groups, or prides, and almost exclusively within protected areas.

    But that doesn't mean they are always easy to locate.

    "Every time we go and look in any real detail, we find that there are fewer lions than we thought, typically three, four, even ten-fold fewer," Funston told AFP.

    In 2017, Funston led an intensive survey of two large national parks in southeastern Angola where conservation authorities had put the population at about 1,000.

    Industrial-scale bush-meat poaching has emptied parts of the African savannah of big cats and their prey TONY KARUMBA AFP/File

    "Actual numbers were so low we couldn't derive a proper scientific estimate," he said.

    "We concluded that there were 10 to 30 lions left."

    The top driver of lion decline is industrial-scale bush-meat poaching, either of the lions themselves or their prey.

    Trophy hunting, habitat loss and conflict with humans also menace the animals.

    - 'Influencer' effect -


    Since 2014, new threats have emerged.

    "Particularly in southern Africa, we are suddenly seeing an increase in the poaching of lions for body parts" -- especially teeth, claws and bones -- to supply a booming market in Southeast Asia and China for bogus health and virility elixirs, Funston said.

    This illegal traffic has been spurred on by South Africa's decade-old and controversial commercial captive lion-breeding industry, according to a recent report he co-authored.

    From 2011 to 2019, poaching for body parts -- evident from the dismembered carcasses left behind -- accounted for more than 60 percent of all lion mortality within Limpopo National Park in Mozambique, with a clear increase from 2014 onwards.

    For cheetahs, the new threat comes from the Gulf states, where a demand for pets has fuelled a brisk trade in cubs, especially from the horn of Africa, where a sub-species teeters on the brink of extinction.

    Demand in the Gulf States is driving a brisk illegal trade in cheetah and lion cubs 
    Delil SOULEIMAN AFP/File

    Social networks are driving a demand for live big cats as well.

    "Influencers are flying out of Dubai to get photographed with a cheetah or lion to boost Instagram traffic," Durant said, highlighting a recent expose by the website Bellingcat.

    One key to protection is investment.

    In central and western Africa, spending is only about $50-$100 annually per square kilometre, according to Funston.

    Little wonder, he said, that both regions have lost more than 90 percent of their large wildlife.

    In southern Africa however, where lion populations have gone up, $500 to $800 is invested annually per square kilometre.

    Craig Hilton-Taylor, who heads the IUCN's Red List Unit, defended its classification process as "robust" and said experts looked at a full range of issues.

    But he acknowledged that without the efforts of southern African countries, "the lion would have been uplisted from 'vulnerable' to 'endangered'."

    "If the experts do the assessment again, and project forward rather than just looking in the past, they might be able to get it over the threshold," he told AFP.

    © 2021 AFP