CRIMINAL CAPITALI$T
IG faults Elaine Chao at Transportation over ethics concerns
HOPE YEN
Wed, March 3, 2021,
The Transportation Department’s watchdog asked the Justice Department to criminally investigate Elaine Chao late last year over concerns that she misused her office when she was transportation secretary under President Donald Trump but was rebuffed, according to a report released Wednesday.
The report said the department’s inspector general found that Chao used her staff and office for personal tasks and to promote a shipping business owned by Chao’s father and sisters, in an apparent violation of federal ethics rules.
But when the inspector general’s office referred its findings to the U.S. attorney’s office in Washington and prosecutors at the Justice Department who focus on public integrity cases, both declined to bring charges, the report said.
“A formal investigation into potential misuses of position was warranted,” deputy inspector general Mitch Behm wrote in a letter to lawmakers.
Chao, the wife of Senate Republican leader Mitch McConnell of Kentucky, stepped down from her job early this year in the last weeks of the Trump administration, citing her disapproval over the Jan. 6 insurrection at the Capitol by Trump’s supporters.
Chao has denied wrongdoing. In the report released Wednesday, she did not specifically respond to allegations, instead providing a September 2020 memo that argued promoting her family was an appropriate part of her official duties at the department. The shipping company owned by her family does substantial business with China.
“Asian audiences welcome and respond positively to actions by the secretary that include her father in activities when appropriate,” that memo said.
The watchdog report cited several instances that raised ethical concerns. In one, Chao instructed political appointees in the department to contact the Homeland Security Department to check personally on the status of a work permit application for a student who was a recipient of her family’s philanthropic foundation.
Chao also made extensive plans for an official trip to China in November 2017 — before she canceled it — that would have included stops at places that had received support from her family’s business, the New York-based Foremost Group. According to department emails, Chao directed her staff to include her relatives in the official events and high-level meetings during the trip.
“Above all, let’s keep (the Secretary) happy," one of the department’s employees wrote to another staffer regarding Chao’s father. “If Dr. Chao is happy, then we should be flying with a feather in our hat.”
The report found that Chao also directed the department’s public affairs staff to assist her father in the marketing of his personal biography and to edit his Wikipedia page, and used staff to check on repairs of an item at a store for her father.
The IG report said Justice Department officials ultimately declined to take up a criminal review, saying there “may be ethical and/or administrative issues” but no evidence to support possible criminal charges.
As a result, the inspector general's office said in the report it was now closing its investigation “based on the lack of prosecutorial interest” from the Justice Department.
Rep. Peter DeFazio, D-Oregon, chairman of the House transportation committee, who requested the investigation, expressed disappointment that the review was not completed and released while Chao was still in office.
“Public servants, especially those responsible for leading tens of thousands of other public servants, must know that they serve the public and not their family’s private commercial interests,” he said.
Inspector general: Ethics questions prompted criminal referral involving Elaine Chao
Shawna Chen
Wed, March 3, 2021,
The Transportation Department's deputy inspector general said a "formal investigation into potential misuses of [former Secretary Elaine Chao's] position was warranted," after finding evidence of possible ethics violations, according to a report made public on Wednesday.
Why it matters: The report reveals that the IG last December asked the Justice Department and U.S. Attorney for the District of Columbia to consider a criminal investigation into Chao's actions, citing possible ethical or administrative concerns. Both declined to investigate.
Stay on top of the latest market trends and economic insights with Axios Markets. Subscribe for free
The state of play: The IG found multiple “potential ethics concerns arising from the actions of the Secretary and Office of the Secretary (OST) staff under her direction,” the investigators wrote, adding that Chao used the department's staff time “for tasks for the Secretary that appear to be personal in nature." Such requests include:
Asking staff to contact the Department of Homeland Security about the status of a work permit for a student who benefited from her family's philanthropic foundation.
Making "extensive plans" to include family members in events during an official trip to China in November 2017 that was ultimately canceled, per a House committee press release on the IG report.
Directing staff to support her father, in marketing his biography and editing his Wikipedia page. She allegedly instructed two staffers to send a copy of his book to a "well-known CEO of a major U.S. corporation (which is not regulated by DOT)."
Zoom out: The Transportation Department's Office of Inspector General opened the investigation into Chao in 2019 upon the request of the House Committees on Transportation and Infrastructure and Oversight and Reform.
Chao, who's married to Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, announced her resignation on Jan. 7 after the Capitol riots.
Her family company, Foremost Group, is responsible for "orders at one of China's biggest state-funded shipyards," according to the New York Times.
What they're saying: Rep. Peter DeFazio (D-Ore.), chair of the House Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure, said he was "disappointed" that the DOJ declined to pursue the matter.
"Secretary Chao’s flagrant abuse of her office provides further evidence that additional ethics and transparency reforms are needed," Rep. Carolyn Maloney (D-N.Y.), chair of the Committee on Oversight and Reform, added in the statement.
The other side: Chao declined to respond to a request for comment from the New York Times, but shared a memo expressing the importance of promoting her family as part of her duties.
"Asian audiences welcome and respond positively to actions by the Secretary that include her father in activities when appropriate," the memo, dated September 2020, said.
Wed, March 3, 2021,
The Transportation Department's deputy inspector general said a "formal investigation into potential misuses of [former Secretary Elaine Chao's] position was warranted," after finding evidence of possible ethics violations, according to a report made public on Wednesday.
Why it matters: The report reveals that the IG last December asked the Justice Department and U.S. Attorney for the District of Columbia to consider a criminal investigation into Chao's actions, citing possible ethical or administrative concerns. Both declined to investigate.
Stay on top of the latest market trends and economic insights with Axios Markets. Subscribe for free
The state of play: The IG found multiple “potential ethics concerns arising from the actions of the Secretary and Office of the Secretary (OST) staff under her direction,” the investigators wrote, adding that Chao used the department's staff time “for tasks for the Secretary that appear to be personal in nature." Such requests include:
Asking staff to contact the Department of Homeland Security about the status of a work permit for a student who benefited from her family's philanthropic foundation.
Making "extensive plans" to include family members in events during an official trip to China in November 2017 that was ultimately canceled, per a House committee press release on the IG report.
Directing staff to support her father, in marketing his biography and editing his Wikipedia page. She allegedly instructed two staffers to send a copy of his book to a "well-known CEO of a major U.S. corporation (which is not regulated by DOT)."
Zoom out: The Transportation Department's Office of Inspector General opened the investigation into Chao in 2019 upon the request of the House Committees on Transportation and Infrastructure and Oversight and Reform.
Chao, who's married to Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, announced her resignation on Jan. 7 after the Capitol riots.
Her family company, Foremost Group, is responsible for "orders at one of China's biggest state-funded shipyards," according to the New York Times.
What they're saying: Rep. Peter DeFazio (D-Ore.), chair of the House Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure, said he was "disappointed" that the DOJ declined to pursue the matter.
"Secretary Chao’s flagrant abuse of her office provides further evidence that additional ethics and transparency reforms are needed," Rep. Carolyn Maloney (D-N.Y.), chair of the Committee on Oversight and Reform, added in the statement.
The other side: Chao declined to respond to a request for comment from the New York Times, but shared a memo expressing the importance of promoting her family as part of her duties.
"Asian audiences welcome and respond positively to actions by the Secretary that include her father in activities when appropriate," the memo, dated September 2020, said.
No comments:
Post a Comment