Shanifa Nasser - Yesterday
A well-known Toronto television personality has filed a human rights complaint against Bell Media, alleging "a systemic pattern" of racism, sexism and discrimination, adding that during her 11 years with the company, she was "treated as a token and a commodity."
In a complaint filed with the Canadian Human Rights Commission on Wednesday, Patricia Jaggernauth, a weather specialist, remote reporter and co-host for the Bell-owned news channel CP24, describes being repeatedly passed over for promotions and earning less than a living wage.© Robert Krbavac/CBC
In a complaint filed with the Canadian Human Rights Commission on Wednesday, Patricia Jaggernauth, a weather specialist, remote reporter and co-host for the Bell-owned news channel CP24, describes being repeatedly passed over for promotions and earning less than a living wage.
Jaggernauth says she watched as white colleagues, often newer ones, made it higher up the corporate ladder, while she wasn't even offered a contract — something she attributes to the fact that she is a racialized woman.
Part Guyanese and part Jamaican, Jaggernauth claims she was denied full-time stable employment and was instead forced to work weeks straight without a day off — an experience she says landed her in hospital with pneumonia because she felt she had no choice but to put work ahead of her health.
"I almost died doing what I loved because a freelancer can't say no. Every hour is bread, every hour is rent, every hour is that tank of gas," said Jaggernauth, who resigned from Bell Media last Tuesday.
In an email to CBC News, a Bell Media spokesperson said, "We do not comment on matters involving current or former staff members, but can confirm that Bell Media takes allegations of any potential discrimination very seriously, and are committed to a safe, inclusive, and respectful work environment where employees can thrive.
"If a matter is brought to our attention where an employee did not feel adequately supported, a process is triggered to review and address when required."
'Good enough to fill in but never ... to invest in'
In an exclusive interview with CBC News, Jaggernauth broke her silence about her time at Bell.
At first, she said, landing a job there felt like "a dream."
"I'm the girl living in metro housing that got out. I'm the one that was never supposed to succeed," she said. "I knew that I loved people, I loved community, I loved conversation ... And where I was working provided that — but not ever on a contractual basis, always as a fill-in.
"How come I'm always good enough to fill in but never good enough to invest in?"
Jaggernauth says she was guaranteed just two days of work each week, and called at random to fill in for hosts who were off sick or away. With no certainty as to what her weeks would look like, she says she relied on the ability to take on other jobs to supplement her income — something she had done throughout her time there.
This past summer, management moved to limit that ability, blocking her from performing any paid activities outside of the company without management approval, according to her formal complaint. The rule was originally created in 2019 when Bell employees unionized, but was never enforced until this year, she says.
"Bell has done this while at the same time denying Ms. Jaggernauth promotions she has earned and is qualified for, and while refusing to provide her with full-time work," the complaint reads.
"At Bell, people of colour are cynically used as tokens," it adds.
Long days, short turnarounds led to breakdown: complaint
Jaggernauth's complaint comes on the heels of Bell Media's recent dismissal of celebrated chief anchor Lisa LaFlamme, who said she was "blindsided" when the company ended her contract at CTV National after more than 30 years as part of a "business decision." The move caused an uproar and in the days that followed, CTV News executive Michael Melling went on leave from the company.
In 2019, Jaggernauth says she contracted a virus and was hospitalized after "years of long days, short turnarounds, lengthy work stretches and being told to work for weeks upon weeks, non-stop."
After a three-month unpaid sick leave, she says she pleaded with Bell for more stability. What she was offered, she says, was a part-time contract formalizing her two days of work per week and giving her access to medical and dental benefits — with no additional shifts, no change to her wage and no ability to continue freelancing outside of Bell.
The complaint says the treatment Jaggernauth faced led her to suffer "a breakdown" during the most recent Bell Let's Talk Day while live on the air. In the segment, later posted to YouTube by CP24, five hosts open up about their mental health.
The last host to share is Jaggernauth, who speaks candidly about her personal and professional struggles, including the toll of working weekends for 11 years.
"I'm going to cry. Oh my God," she says in the segment, tearing up. "In this industry what I've found is you get to be in the bright lights, you know, here you have this amazing career and people think you're a multi-millionaire, you're so lucky, but do you want to put my shoes on guys?"
Jaggernauth alleges none of her supervisors reached out at the time.
'I'm walking away and I will persevere'
It wasn't until two weeks later when she reached out to her manager for help that a therapist was offered, she says. Ineligible for therapy through a benefits plan, Jaggernauth says she was finally offered a Bell-recommended therapist, but ultimately says she didn't feel safe with the arrangement and declined the help.
The complaint says Jaggernauth had repeated conversations with management about her concerns at Bell — concerns she says were not taken seriously. Among those she spoke to were Melling and the company's president, "however her complaints were sidelined," according to the complaint.
Bell Media employees are part of a union, however given settlements between employers and unions are often kept secret through non-disclosure agreements, Jaggernauth says she felt a human rights complaint was the best way forward.
A complaint at the commission can not only result in payment of denied wages but also monetary damages for alleged discrimination. It can also force policy changes such as pay equity says Jaggernauth's lawyer Kathryn Marshall of the firm Levitt Sheikh.
Jaggernauth says for her, the complaint goes beyond money — it's also about demanding change for women who look like her in the industry and for women overall.
As for her next steps, she says, "I came from hardship. I persevered. I started this career with hardship and I persevered, and I'm walking away and I will persevere."
CP24 anchor Patricia Jaggernauth launches human rights complaint against Bell Media
TORONTO — Longtime on-air television personality and CP24 weather specialist Patricia Jaggernauth has filed a complaint with the Canadian Human Rights Commission against Bell Media, alleging systemic discrimination throughout her 11-year career.
Jaggernauth's complaint, launched on Wednesday and first reported by CBC, makes allegations of discrimination based on race, gender and disability by Bell, her former employer. The Toronto-based media company owns cable news network CP24. In the complaint, Jaggernauth alleges Bell continually passed her over for promotions and attempted to restrict her ability to freelance outside the company despite never offering her a full-time job.
"She has been used as a token and commodity when it is convenient and beneficial,” the Toronto-based reporter's complaint reads. Jaggernauth identifies as being of Guyanese and Jamaican ancestry on social media.
“And Bell now wants to own her likeness and her career, despite putting her in a position where she cannot earn a living wage despite giving 11 years of her career to the company."
In a statement emailed Saturday, Bell Media said it cannot comment on matters involving current or former staff.
"Bell Media takes allegations of any potential discrimination very seriously, and are committed to a safe, inclusive, and respectful work environment where employees can thrive," the statement said. "If a matter is brought to our attention where an employee did not feel adequately supported, a process is triggered to review and address when required."
In the complaint, Jaggernauth alleges Bell Media only offers her two days of paid employment per week, and she therefore earned most of her income doing freelance work. Her complaint alleges the company enforced a term this past summer that she could not perform any paid activities outside of the company without management's approval.
"Bell has done this while at the same time denying (Jaggernauth) promotions she has earned and is qualified for, and while refusing to provide her with full-time work," the complaint reads. The complaint details a number of positions she was allegedly denied "for no justifiable basis."
The human rights complaint further alleges an "unsafe and unhealthy work environment" at Bell Media caused her "a myriad of health issues," including severe stress, anxiety and depression. “Years of long days, short turnarounds, lengthy work stretches and being told to work for weeks upon weeks, non-stop with no breaks,” contributed to Jaggernauth being hospitalized in 2019, the claim alleges.
It says she later experienced a "traumatic" on-air breakdown during Bell Let's Talk Day. A segment from this year's Bell Let's Talk Day posted to CP24's YouTube channel shows five hosts, including Jaggernauth, discussing their mental health.
Jaggernauth begins crying when she opens up about her struggles.
"In this industry, what I've found is you get to be in the bright lights, you know, here you have this amazing career, and people think you're a multimillionaire, you're so lucky. But want to put my shoes on guys?" the clip shows her saying through tears.
Jaggernauth's complaint claims she approached her manager weeks later for help, and was offered a company-recommended therapist, who she said she wasn't comfortable speaking to.
The document also alleges men and women are paid differently at the company, and that Black women are not well represented on-air at CP24. "At Bell, people of colour are cynically used as tokens," the document reads.
The Canadian Human Rights Commission application states Jaggernauth repeatedly brought up her concerns with Bell management — specifically to Bell's president and vice-president of news Michael Melling — but that she was not taken seriously. Melling took leave from his job in August, amid the fallout from the ousting of Lisa LaFlamme as anchor of CTV National News, the company's flagship newscast.
Jaggernauth's lawyer Kathryn Marshall said in a statement that her client is "relieved to finally be telling her story."
Jaggernauth did not immediately respond to a request for an interview.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Oct. 8, 2022.
———
This story was produced with the financial assistance of the Meta and Canadian Press News Fellowship.
Tyler Griffin, The Canadian Press
TORONTO — Longtime on-air television personality and CP24 weather specialist Patricia Jaggernauth has filed a complaint with the Canadian Human Rights Commission against Bell Media, alleging systemic discrimination throughout her 11-year career.
Jaggernauth's complaint, launched on Wednesday and first reported by CBC, makes allegations of discrimination based on race, gender and disability by Bell, her former employer. The Toronto-based media company owns cable news network CP24. In the complaint, Jaggernauth alleges Bell continually passed her over for promotions and attempted to restrict her ability to freelance outside the company despite never offering her a full-time job.
"She has been used as a token and commodity when it is convenient and beneficial,” the Toronto-based reporter's complaint reads. Jaggernauth identifies as being of Guyanese and Jamaican ancestry on social media.
“And Bell now wants to own her likeness and her career, despite putting her in a position where she cannot earn a living wage despite giving 11 years of her career to the company."
In a statement emailed Saturday, Bell Media said it cannot comment on matters involving current or former staff.
"Bell Media takes allegations of any potential discrimination very seriously, and are committed to a safe, inclusive, and respectful work environment where employees can thrive," the statement said. "If a matter is brought to our attention where an employee did not feel adequately supported, a process is triggered to review and address when required."
In the complaint, Jaggernauth alleges Bell Media only offers her two days of paid employment per week, and she therefore earned most of her income doing freelance work. Her complaint alleges the company enforced a term this past summer that she could not perform any paid activities outside of the company without management's approval.
"Bell has done this while at the same time denying (Jaggernauth) promotions she has earned and is qualified for, and while refusing to provide her with full-time work," the complaint reads. The complaint details a number of positions she was allegedly denied "for no justifiable basis."
The human rights complaint further alleges an "unsafe and unhealthy work environment" at Bell Media caused her "a myriad of health issues," including severe stress, anxiety and depression. “Years of long days, short turnarounds, lengthy work stretches and being told to work for weeks upon weeks, non-stop with no breaks,” contributed to Jaggernauth being hospitalized in 2019, the claim alleges.
It says she later experienced a "traumatic" on-air breakdown during Bell Let's Talk Day. A segment from this year's Bell Let's Talk Day posted to CP24's YouTube channel shows five hosts, including Jaggernauth, discussing their mental health.
Jaggernauth begins crying when she opens up about her struggles.
"In this industry, what I've found is you get to be in the bright lights, you know, here you have this amazing career, and people think you're a multimillionaire, you're so lucky. But want to put my shoes on guys?" the clip shows her saying through tears.
Jaggernauth's complaint claims she approached her manager weeks later for help, and was offered a company-recommended therapist, who she said she wasn't comfortable speaking to.
The document also alleges men and women are paid differently at the company, and that Black women are not well represented on-air at CP24. "At Bell, people of colour are cynically used as tokens," the document reads.
The Canadian Human Rights Commission application states Jaggernauth repeatedly brought up her concerns with Bell management — specifically to Bell's president and vice-president of news Michael Melling — but that she was not taken seriously. Melling took leave from his job in August, amid the fallout from the ousting of Lisa LaFlamme as anchor of CTV National News, the company's flagship newscast.
Jaggernauth's lawyer Kathryn Marshall said in a statement that her client is "relieved to finally be telling her story."
Jaggernauth did not immediately respond to a request for an interview.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Oct. 8, 2022.
———
This story was produced with the financial assistance of the Meta and Canadian Press News Fellowship.
Tyler Griffin, The Canadian Press
No comments:
Post a Comment