Here's how NASA might break the news.
Morgan McFall-Johnsen
Feb 18, 2023
Extraterrestrial life likely wouldn't show up as flying objects, but finding it could cause similar chaos.
NASA's greatest challenge could be explaining any alien discovery to the public, the agency's planetary-science chief said.
NASA isn't announcing the existence of extraterrestrial life. But if the last two weeks show anything, it's if the agency ever breaks such news, the world may have trouble understanding.
The latest UFO mania started with the "Chinese spy balloon" flying across the US. China's government has insisted it was just a weather balloon that blew off course. The US military shot it down off the coast of South Carolina, later saying the balloon was part of a global network Beijing uses to collect surveillance on other militaries.
How NASA scientists might explain any alien findings — gradually
Morgan McFall-Johnsen
Feb 18, 2023
A time-lapse of the Milky Way Galaxy as seen from the International Space Station. NASA/Kjell Lindgren
UFOs (or UAPs) shot down over North America probably aren't aliens, but that hasn't stopped rumors.
UFOs (or UAPs) shot down over North America probably aren't aliens, but that hasn't stopped rumors.
Extraterrestrial life likely wouldn't show up as flying objects, but finding it could cause similar chaos.
NASA's greatest challenge could be explaining any alien discovery to the public, the agency's planetary-science chief said.
NASA isn't announcing the existence of extraterrestrial life. But if the last two weeks show anything, it's if the agency ever breaks such news, the world may have trouble understanding.
The latest UFO mania started with the "Chinese spy balloon" flying across the US. China's government has insisted it was just a weather balloon that blew off course. The US military shot it down off the coast of South Carolina, later saying the balloon was part of a global network Beijing uses to collect surveillance on other militaries.
The suspected Chinese spy balloon drifts to the ocean after being shot down off the coast in Surfside Beach, South Carolina. Randall Hill/Reuters
Suddenly the US seemed to be spotting UFOs (which the Department of Defense now refers to as "unidentified anomalous phenomena," or UAPs) everywhere.
By Sunday, US fighter jets had gunned down three more mysterious "objects" in the skies over Alaska, Canada, and Lake Huron.
There's no evidence that these UFOs — sorry, UAPs — are alien technology from space. Still, speculation abounds.
Google searches for "extraterrestrial life" and "are aliens real" spiked. The Associated Press reported that online posts mentioning extraterrestrials increased by nearly 300% after the first balloon. Even Elon Musk weighed in with an alien joke.
Suddenly the US seemed to be spotting UFOs (which the Department of Defense now refers to as "unidentified anomalous phenomena," or UAPs) everywhere.
By Sunday, US fighter jets had gunned down three more mysterious "objects" in the skies over Alaska, Canada, and Lake Huron.
There's no evidence that these UFOs — sorry, UAPs — are alien technology from space. Still, speculation abounds.
Google searches for "extraterrestrial life" and "are aliens real" spiked. The Associated Press reported that online posts mentioning extraterrestrials increased by nearly 300% after the first balloon. Even Elon Musk weighed in with an alien joke.
A woman looks at a UFO display outside of the Little A'Le'Inn, in Rachel, Nevada.
AP Photo/John Locher, File
"I know there have been questions and concerns about this, but there is no — again, no — indication of aliens or extraterrestrial activity with these recent takedowns," Karine Jean-Pierre, the White House press secretary, said at a briefing on Monday, adding: "It was important for us to say that from here because we've been hearing a lot about it."
The breathless rumors are just a peek at what Lori Glaze, who leads NASA's planetary science division, might face should scientists ever discover true evidence of life beyond Earth.
"I know there have been questions and concerns about this, but there is no — again, no — indication of aliens or extraterrestrial activity with these recent takedowns," Karine Jean-Pierre, the White House press secretary, said at a briefing on Monday, adding: "It was important for us to say that from here because we've been hearing a lot about it."
The breathless rumors are just a peek at what Lori Glaze, who leads NASA's planetary science division, might face should scientists ever discover true evidence of life beyond Earth.
An apparently unidentified object detected on a Navy plane’s infrared camera.
US Department of Defense/Navy Times
"You can't overstate just how important that discovery would be. How we're going to confirm that and announce it responsibly, I think is a really, really important question," Glaze told Insider at the American Geophysical Union's meeting in December.
"The biggest challenge is trying to keep that communication on an even keel, right? With an excitement, and yet also understanding that we need to set the expectations that we have to follow the scientific process."
"You can't overstate just how important that discovery would be. How we're going to confirm that and announce it responsibly, I think is a really, really important question," Glaze told Insider at the American Geophysical Union's meeting in December.
"The biggest challenge is trying to keep that communication on an even keel, right? With an excitement, and yet also understanding that we need to set the expectations that we have to follow the scientific process."
How NASA scientists might explain any alien findings — gradually
NASA’s Perseverance Mars rover took this selfie on September 10, 2021.
NASA/JPL-Caltech/MSSS
Maybe the James Webb Space Telescope detects a telltale molecule in the atmosphere of a distant Earth-like planet. Maybe Mars samples from the Perseverance rover reach Earth in a decade, and scientists find fossils of ancient microbes inside them.
Many astrobiologists (exactly what it sounds like — people who study the idea of biology beyond Earth) think that evidence of extraterrestrial life could turn up soon.
But it's unlikely that any evidence would be completely, irrefutably, obviously aliens. Scientists will probably disagree, and won't be 100% confident. That could be hard to explain to the public.
Maybe the James Webb Space Telescope detects a telltale molecule in the atmosphere of a distant Earth-like planet. Maybe Mars samples from the Perseverance rover reach Earth in a decade, and scientists find fossils of ancient microbes inside them.
Many astrobiologists (exactly what it sounds like — people who study the idea of biology beyond Earth) think that evidence of extraterrestrial life could turn up soon.
But it's unlikely that any evidence would be completely, irrefutably, obviously aliens. Scientists will probably disagree, and won't be 100% confident. That could be hard to explain to the public.
Two people dressed as extra-terrestrials with aluminum foil costumes walk in the streets near the Peak of Bugarach, in France.
Jean-Philippe Arles/Reuters
"This is going to be a very, very hard thing to actually get the scientific community, I think, to agree upon — unless we actually see something moving around and waving at us, which is unlikely," Glaze told Insider.
That's why NASA has tried to develop a procedure for assessing and sharing such a monumental, sensitive discovery. The conversation is still ongoing, Glaze said, but in 2021, the agency published a framework as a starting point. It could help scientists, journalists, and NASA itself explain the science.
It's called the "confidence of life detection" (CoLD) scale, rating scientific confidence in any potential alien-life discovery on a scale of one to seven. A possible detection can climb to higher levels of confidence as evidence builds.
"This is going to be a very, very hard thing to actually get the scientific community, I think, to agree upon — unless we actually see something moving around and waving at us, which is unlikely," Glaze told Insider.
That's why NASA has tried to develop a procedure for assessing and sharing such a monumental, sensitive discovery. The conversation is still ongoing, Glaze said, but in 2021, the agency published a framework as a starting point. It could help scientists, journalists, and NASA itself explain the science.
It's called the "confidence of life detection" (CoLD) scale, rating scientific confidence in any potential alien-life discovery on a scale of one to seven. A possible detection can climb to higher levels of confidence as evidence builds.
An illustration of the CoLD scale for determining confidence in a detection of alien life. NASA/Aaron Gronstal
For example, a level one detection might be the discovery of a molecule that could be related to life inside a Perseverance Mars sample. The evidence would graduate to level two once scientists confirm there was no contamination in the sample, or the instruments involved, that could have influenced their findings. By ruling out non-biological sources of the molecule, or by confirming that it came from an environment suitable for life, scientists could move it further up the scale.
Other scientific teams would have to measure the Mars sample themselves, with different methods, and confirm the initial finding to graduate to level six.
According to NASA, in this Mars molecule example, additional evidence from a different part of the red planet may be necessary to bring it up to level seven — where it's probably life.
Each new level of confidence could mean a new public announcement.
The discovery of extraterrestrial life is likely to be a slow build-up, rather than an explosive eureka moment.
"Until now, we have set the public up to think there are only two options: it's life or it's not life," Mary Voytek, head of NASA's Astrobiology Program, said in a press release when the new scale was published. "We need a better way to share the excitement of our discoveries, and demonstrate how each discovery builds on the next, so that we can bring the public and other scientists along on the journey."
The president or other countries could be involved in announcing extraterrestrial life exists
For example, a level one detection might be the discovery of a molecule that could be related to life inside a Perseverance Mars sample. The evidence would graduate to level two once scientists confirm there was no contamination in the sample, or the instruments involved, that could have influenced their findings. By ruling out non-biological sources of the molecule, or by confirming that it came from an environment suitable for life, scientists could move it further up the scale.
Other scientific teams would have to measure the Mars sample themselves, with different methods, and confirm the initial finding to graduate to level six.
According to NASA, in this Mars molecule example, additional evidence from a different part of the red planet may be necessary to bring it up to level seven — where it's probably life.
Each new level of confidence could mean a new public announcement.
The discovery of extraterrestrial life is likely to be a slow build-up, rather than an explosive eureka moment.
"Until now, we have set the public up to think there are only two options: it's life or it's not life," Mary Voytek, head of NASA's Astrobiology Program, said in a press release when the new scale was published. "We need a better way to share the excitement of our discoveries, and demonstrate how each discovery builds on the next, so that we can bring the public and other scientists along on the journey."
The president or other countries could be involved in announcing extraterrestrial life exists
President Joe Biden speaks at Delaware State University.
Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images
Announcing the existence of alien life would be an "administration-level" affair, Glaze said, referring to the US presidency. It wouldn't just be NASA explaining itself at press conferences.
NASA might not even be the first entity to discover evidence of life on another planet. Another nation's space agency could find it first.
Announcing the existence of alien life would be an "administration-level" affair, Glaze said, referring to the US presidency. It wouldn't just be NASA explaining itself at press conferences.
NASA might not even be the first entity to discover evidence of life on another planet. Another nation's space agency could find it first.
A Chinese Long March 5 Y-4 rocket lifts off, carrying a mission to Mars.
Carlos Garcia Rawlins/Reuters
The discovery of intelligent alien life would be even more Earth-shattering. That would come with its own conundrums: How do we communicate with them? What do we say? And how might they respond?
Even beaming little hints of ourselves into the void has been controversial. In 1974, astronomers sent out radio signals containing the numbers one through 10, information about the composition and structure of DNA, a figure of a human and our global population, and a graphic of the solar system with Earth highlighted.
Critics like Stephen Hawking have said that contacting any extraterrestrial intelligence could pose an existential risk for humanity.
Needless to say, any discovery of alien life would likely lead to chaos — at least in public discourse.
Glaze said NASA's goal is to be a trusted, transparent source of clear scientific information. It could be the agency's biggest challenge yet.
"I'm not sure we even have words to describe it," she said. "The confirmation that we're not alone in the universe is, I think, going to be akin to realizing that the universe doesn't rotate around Earth. It's a very different way of thinking about who we are, where we came from."
The discovery of intelligent alien life would be even more Earth-shattering. That would come with its own conundrums: How do we communicate with them? What do we say? And how might they respond?
Even beaming little hints of ourselves into the void has been controversial. In 1974, astronomers sent out radio signals containing the numbers one through 10, information about the composition and structure of DNA, a figure of a human and our global population, and a graphic of the solar system with Earth highlighted.
Critics like Stephen Hawking have said that contacting any extraterrestrial intelligence could pose an existential risk for humanity.
Needless to say, any discovery of alien life would likely lead to chaos — at least in public discourse.
Glaze said NASA's goal is to be a trusted, transparent source of clear scientific information. It could be the agency's biggest challenge yet.
"I'm not sure we even have words to describe it," she said. "The confirmation that we're not alone in the universe is, I think, going to be akin to realizing that the universe doesn't rotate around Earth. It's a very different way of thinking about who we are, where we came from."
No comments:
Post a Comment