Novel machine-learning method produces detailed population trend maps for 550 bird species

Peer-Reviewed Publication

CORNELL UNIVERSITY

 

IMAGE: IN THIS EXAMPLE, THE EBIRD TRENDS MAP SHOWS WOOD THRUSH POPULATIONS INCREASING (BLUE) IN SOME AREAS BUT DECREASING (RED) IN OTHERS, ALLOWING FOR TARGETED CONSERVATION PLANNING. view more 

CREDIT: EBIRD/CORNELL LAB OF ORNITHOLOGY

Scientists at the Cornell Lab of Ornithology have developed a novel way to model whether the populations of more than 500 bird species are increasing or decreasing. The method solves a nagging statistical problem by accounting for year-to-year changes in the behavior of people collecting the data. The result is detailed trend maps for each species down to an eight-mile radius--a major boost for local conservation efforts. Scientists used an approach called Double Machine Learning. Details are published in the journal Methods in Ecology and Evolution.

“Changing human behavior presents a problem for statistical analysis of data collected by volunteers,” explained lead author Daniel Fink at the Cornell Lab. “For example, is a particular species really declining in a region—or are there simply fewer people making observations in the bird’s preferred habitat compared to past years?”

Birding behavior may change when people adopt new tools, get better at identifying birds, or go birding in new areas. Changes in human behavior become what is called a “confounding” factor. A confounding factor has an impact on the primary question being studied and can distort reality. In this case, changes in the recorded abundances of birds may be real, or they may be artifacts that appear because of changes in the observation process over time.

Double Machine Learning is applied to bird observation data collected by the Cornell Lab’s global eBird program and then visualized with detailed maps. With Double Machine Learning, two types of patterns are “learned” and then identified in the data. One pattern is the variation in the reported counts of birds. The second pattern reflects variation in birders’ behavior. The effect of the behavior pattern is then removed, leaving only variation in the actual recorded abundances of birds.

“Now, we have a way to analyze these data that produce robust estimates of population change, even for species and/or regions without rigorous monitoring programs,” said Fink. “The ability to estimate trends while accounting for confounding factors inherent in citizen science data has the potential to fill important information gaps.”

Reference

Daniel Fink, Alison Johnston, Matthew Strimas-Mackey, Tom Auer, Wesley Hochachka, Shawn Ligocki, Lauren Oldham Jaromczyk, Orin Robinson, Chris Wood, Steve Kelling, Amanda Rodewald. A Double Machine Learning Trend Model for Citizen Science Data. Methods in Ecology and Evolution. July 2023. https://doi.org/10.1111/2041-210X.14186

In this example, the eBird Trends map shows Wood Thrush populations increasing (blue) in some areas but decreasing (red) in others, allowing for targeted conservation planning.

CREDIT

eBird/Cornell Lab of Ornithology

---

JOURNAL

Methods in Ecology and Evolution

DOI

10.1111/2041-210X.14186 

METHOD OF RESEARCH

Data/statistical analysis

SUBJECT OF RESEARCH

Not applicable

ARTICLE TITLE

A Double machine learning trend model for citizen science data