Friday, February 02, 2024

Nigerian royals say Cambridge bosses ‘duped’ as Benin Bronzes row reignites

Craig Simpson
Fri, 2 February 2024 

Senior prince of Benin has ordered the university to return artefacts
 - NEIL HALL/EPA-EFE/SHUTTERSTOCK

Nigerian royals have claimed Cambridge University bosses were “duped” into an agreement to repatriate the Benin Bronzes and must now return them to a local king.

In 2022, the university pledged to return 116 artefacts to Nigeria, but paused its plan when it emerged that the treasures would become the private property of the king of the Benin people, rather than a Nigerian government body.

The Benin royal household has now claimed that Cambridge bosses were “duped” into making deals with false claimants to the Bronzes amid an internal political wrangle in Nigeria.


A senior prince representing the palace has insisted that the university stop stalling and return the artefacts to their “legitimate” owner, the king or “Oba” of Benin, reigniting an international row over the metal artworks.

Hundreds of artworks were created for the monarchs of the Kingdom of Benin – which was absorbed into Nigeria – and looted by British troops after they stormed the palace of then-ruler Oba Ovonramwen in an 1897 expedition.

His modern-day descendant, Oba Ewuare II, contends that the artefacts rightfully belong to him and should be returned directly.

The position has been endorsed by the Nigerian state to the surprise of pro-repatriation European museums.

‘I feel sorry for the Europeans’

Prince Aghatise Erediauwa of Benin, the younger brother of the Oba, has insisted that Cambridge respect his wishes.

He told the Telegraph: “I feel sorry for the Europeans who have been duped and received promises about the artefacts from those who should not have been claiming the Bronzes.”

He added: “Cambridge should most definitely return the artefacts. The Oba of Benin is the legitimate owner.

“The president of Nigeria has recognised this.

“I understand they are hesitating, but they must return the artefacts. They must now do the right thing, and return the artefacts to the right people.”


Benin Bronzes were created for the monarchs and looted by British troops
 - TOBY MELVILLE/REUTERS

Cambridge holds 116 Bronzes in its Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology, which have faced demands for repatriation. Oxford’s museum collection and the more than 900 housed in the British museum have also been the subject of debate.

The Telegraph has been told that the Benin royal household became concerned when a third party, Nigeria’s National Commission for Museums and Monuments, began negotiating terms for the repatriation of Bronzes from Western museums.

The commission wanted returned artefacts to be housed in the Edo Museum of West African Art (EMOWAA) that it plans to build in Benin City. It is the capital of the former Kingdom of Benin, once looted by the British in an expedition that eventually led to the Bronzes being dispersed around the world.

Cambridge, Oxford and the Horniman Museum in London agreed to repatriate in 2022, taking their lead from institutions in Germany.

No comments:

Post a Comment