To mask or not to mask: That is still the question

‘Subtle nature of new evidence on masking means leadership decision-making will be really hard’

Northwestern University

CHICAGO --- Despite the association between mask mandates/mask wearing and reduced death rates during the pandemic, masking remains controversial and highly politicized, with many people still asking, “do masks work, and should they be recommended?”

In an editorial about the use of surgical face masks in public, published today, Aug. 23, in The BMJ, Northwestern Medicine internal medicine experts Drs. Jeffrey Linder and Rachel Amdur make the case for masking but acknowledge it’s not a cut-and-dried topic. 

The editorial is in response to recent findings from a Norwegian study published in The BMJ, which found modest benefits from masking. 

Media interested in speaking to the experts should contact Kristin Samuelson at ksamuelson@northwestern.edu.

The experts can speak about to media about:

• Why mixed evidence on masking makes it difficult for public health officials to craft masking guidelines
• The merits of masking and when mask mandates make sense
• Who should mask and when
• What could happen if future, more dangerous variants emerge or future pandemics occur
• The medical implications of mask bans, such as the recently signed law in Nassau County, New York

“The way masks work is more complicated than simply blocking the transmission of infectious droplets or virus between people,” said Linder, chief of general internal medicine at Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine. “The mixed, subtle nature of the evidence means leadership decision-making is still going to be really hard.”

“This recent study shows that masking can lead to reduction in transmission, but there are likely behaviors (i.e. avoiding crowds, isolating when ill) that also contribute to reduced transmission,” said Amdur, assistant professor of medicine (general internal medicine) at Feinberg. “Public health officials would need to consider multiple measures, including mask mandates, if more dangerous variants emerge or in the case of future pandemics.”

---

Journal

The BMJ

DOI

10.1136/bmj.q1843 

Article Title

Surgical face masks to prevent respiratory symptoms