When rescue from modern slavery does not mean freedom: research flags harsh reality of post-rescue life
Humanitarian organisations urged to look beyond point of rescue
University of Bath
People freed from modern slavery are often cast into years of bureaucratic wrangling and legal limbo or forced back into exploitative work, highlighting the need for anti-trafficking organisations to give greater focus to post-rescue support, new research from the University of Bath shows.
The study of rescued bonded labourers in India showed many were marooned in the legal process for up to 37 years after their rescue as they slowly progressed through courts, district welfare offices, NGOs, and other bodies to determine their status and entitlement to state support.
“There is a stark gap between visions of freedom, and the harsh, unfulfilled realities of post-rescue life, which for many is chiefly one of waiting while the law, welfare agencies and government offices process their cases. This waiting means rescued workers are often forced to return to exploitative work,” says Dr Pankhuri Agarwal of the University’s School of Management.
The study - What happens after ‘modern slavery’ rescues? A case of rescued bonded labourers in ‘waiting’ in India - examined the experiences of 31 labourers in domestic work, and the brickmaking, construction and stone cutting industries.
It also interviewed 10 law enforcement workers, revealing a post-rescue world characterised by complex, hard-to-understand legal process, arbitrary bureaucratic rules and delay, needless duplication, and, above all, endless waits for decisions on welfare and legal status that could stretch on for years.
“Rescue should not be equated with freedom. I found that, following rescue, the hard and ironic truth is, many are forced back to the very job from which they were freed to avoid starving to death. This is something for the global anti-trafficking and rescue industry to pay attention to if it really wants to break the cycle of exploitation,” Dr Agarwal says.
“Far from being a fresh start, the post-rescue experience often feels like a painful repetition of the indignities they faced as bonded labourers—reaffirming their status as marginalized caste individuals. Their social positioning as subordinate not only affects their treatment by employers but also extends to their interactions with NGOs, state officials, and the legal system,” Dr Agarwal adds.
She said the study highlighted how well-intentioned states, organisations and NGOs, focused on the point of rescue from crime, often inadvertently inflicted new forms of violence, effectively perpetuating cycles of exploitation by not putting enough aid and resource into the post-rescue experience, and failing to understand the consequences of their actions.
“No one willingly chooses to work in conditions of exploitation, yet for many, the painful reality is that such work—however brutal—is the only option. Is it truly better to be rescued than to endure exploitation? This question is especially urgent given the widespread faith in, and the millions of dollars invested in, the global anti-trafficking industry,” Dr Agarwal says.
She urged NGOs to re-evaluate their standard operating procedures, currently focused on the point of rescue, to account better for the post-rescue journeys of the freed workers, including considering making provision for alternative work or welfare support during the rehabilitation process which may last years.
“Rescue alone cannot be the answer. The promise of liberation must be paired with sustainable support that empowers workers to thrive, not just survive. Without this, the so-called "rescue" is merely a temporary escape from an otherwise unbreakable system of exploitation,” Dr Agarwal says.
ENDS/tr
Notes to editors
- For more information contact the University of Bath Press office at press@bath.ac.uk
The University of Bath
The University of Bath is one of the UK’s leading universities, with a reputation for high-impact research, excellence in education, student experience and graduate prospects.
We are ranked in the top 10 of all of the UK’s major university guides. We are also ranked among the world’s top 10% of universities, placing 150th in the QS World University Rankings 2025. Bath was rated in the world’s top 10 universities for sport in the QS World University Rankings by Subject 2024.
Research from Bath is helping to change the world for the better. Across the University’s three Faculties and School of Management, our research is making an impact in society, leading to low-carbon living, positive digital futures, and improved health and wellbeing. Find out all about our Research with Impact: https://www.bath.ac.uk/campaigns/research-with-impact/
Journal
The Sociological Review
Method of Research
Survey
Subject of Research
People
Article Title
What happens after ‘modern slavery’ rescues? A case of rescued bonded labourers in ‘waiting’ in India
No comments:
Post a Comment