On the Political Right, Anger and Suspicion Over Virus Precautions

Elizabeth Williamson, The New York Times•March 17, 2020


Virus Outbreak Trump
President Donald Trump and Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin, right, listen to a question during a press briefing with the coronavirus task force, at the White House, Tuesday, March 17, 2020, in Washington. Listening from left are Health and Human Services Secretary Alex Azar, Stephen Hahn, commissioner of the Food and Drug Administration, Administrator of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services Seema Verma and Dr. Deborah Birx, White House coronavirus response coordinator, and Dr. Anthony Fauci, director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases. (AP Photo/Evan Vucc

WASHINGTON — When Deborah Frank Feinen, the mayor of Champaign, Illinois, drafted an emergency powers declaration Thursday to confront the coronavirus pandemic, she was proud of her city’s early preparation. But by the time she got to work the next morning, the National Rifle Association had blared a “national alert” saying “anti-gun extremists” were moving “to undermine our firearms freedom.”

The city government was soon under siege.

“We were talking about how to get food to kids when schools were closed, and suddenly I’m getting Facebook messages about how I’m violating the Constitution and taking away people’s rights,” Feinen said in an interview. Now, in addition to working on plans for fire and police departments, emergency supplies, and helping small businesses weather state-mandated closures, “I’m obsessively looking at my email, checking for threats.”

Keen to defend President Donald Trump from criticism and portray virus-related warnings as politically motivated fear-mongering, conservative organizations, media and Trump loyalists are undermining state and local government efforts to convey accurate information and protect their constituents.

An NBC News-Wall Street Journal poll conducted last week found that 81% of Republican voters said Trump has done well in handling the coronavirus crisis, and 84% of Democrats said the opposite. More than half of Republicans — 54% — worried that government will go too far in responding to the crisis, while just 31% of Democrats did, according to the poll.

Trump’s Republican loyalists, including Rep. Devin Nunes of California, Gov. Kevin Stitt of Oklahoma, Gov. Jim Justice of West Virginia and others, have made statements contradicting or flouting public health experts’ guidance.

“If you want to go to Bob Evans and eat, go to Bob Evans and eat,” Justice said Monday.

The former New York police chief Bernard Kerik, a felon pardoned by Trump, posted on Twitter on Sunday, “Why do I feel this hysteria is being created to destabilize the country, and destroy the unparalleled and historic economic successes of President @realDonaldTrump?”

On Monday the federal government issued new guidelines telling Americans to avoid bars, restaurants, travel and gatherings of more than 10 people. Some trusted figures on the right have joined the call for more dramatic action. Newt Gingrich, the former House speaker, said the Trump administration should be preparing military hospital ships and cruise ships to handle an overflow from the nation’s hospitals. And the latest maneuver on the right is to label the enemy “the Chinese virus,” as Trump did Tuesday morning.

Trump wrote on Twitter: “Cuomo wants “all states to be treated the same.” But all states aren’t the same. Some are being hit hard by the Chinese Virus, some are being hit practically not at all. New York is a very big “hotspot”, West Virginia has, thus far, zero cases. Andrew, keep politics out of it....”

But the president has not rebuked his allies for their denialism. During a news conference, Trump was asked about Nunes’ Fox News interview Sunday, in which he encouraged Americans “go to a local restaurant, go to your local pub.” Trump said he was not familiar with the comments.

In Florida, some megachurch pastors connected to Trump are defying public health officials’ guidance to avoid large gatherings, according to reports by The Miami Herald and the liberal People for the American Way’s Right Wing Watch project. On Sunday, designated by Trump as a national day of prayer, the Rev. Rodney Howard-Browne, an evangelical pastor and conspiracy theorist who has prayed with Trump in the White House, encouraged his tightly packed congregation to shake hands, to prove they were not “pansies.”

“Because the climate change narrative for global governance failed,” Howard-Browne said in a video of the service, “they are using the World Health Organization to then come in and take over the control of nations.” He added, “There’s going to be forced vaccines” to “kill off many people.”

In Kendall, Florida, the megachurch pastor Guillermo Maldonado, another Trump religious adviser, derided members of his flock who stayed “home in a cave afraid of the virus,” according to The Herald, saying, “If we die, we die for Christ.”

“There are a lot of people who are getting messages like this from media that they trust,” said Peter Montgomery, senior fellow at Right Wing Watch, who wrote about Maldonado’s service. “How does a public health official compete with that?”

On Monday, Sen. Marco Rubio, R-Fla., tried to combat the disinformation.

“Please stop spreading stupid rumors about marshall law. COMPLETELY FALSE,” he wrote. “We will continue to see closings & restrictions on hours of nonessential businesses in certain cities & states. But that is NOT marshall law.”

Rubio later acknowledged his misspelling of martial law but called it “marital” law.

The problems in Champaign began when Feinen included in materials for the City Council a section of municipal code that has been on the city’s website since at least 2006, granting the mayor wide latitude to respond to disasters such as tornadoes and riots. The section, used by the State of Illinois and other jurisdictions, contains 30 different provisions allowing a mayor to ration food and gasoline, enforce curfews, cut off utilities, and “order the discontinuance of selling, distributing, dispensing or giving away of explosives or explosive agents, firearms or ammunition of any character whatsoever.”

The mayor was chiefly concerned with such mundane items as closing the firehouse to public tours, giving the city manager broader authority to manage staffing and buy supplies like face masks. But the code provided for far more than that.

Feinen posted all the materials, including the code, to the city’s website Thursday night, in preparation for a required City Council approval vote Friday morning. Then she went home, thinking, “I’m pretty proud of us,” she said. “Instead of just referring to the code, we attached it, so people could see it.”

By Friday morning, the NRA had sent an alert, “Champaign, IL First Locality to Use ‘Emergency Powers’ to Ban Gun Transfers,” and urged members to “swiftly” oppose it.

Phones rang off the hook at City Hall, and “our social media just started blowing up,” Feinen said.

Stories about the gun provision were picked up by The Daily Caller, Breitbart News and several gun-rights and far-right conspiracy websites. Donald Trump Jr. tweeted about it. Rumors based on the NRA’s alert circulated on social media; one user wrote “WHEN TYRANNY BECOMES LAW, REBELLION BECOMES DUTY.” A friend of Feinen called her to report that sales of ammunition (and toilet paper) were booming at a local store.

Feinen emphasized that some comments and calls were from Champaign residents, legitimately confused and concerned by the sweeping provisions.

“I am a small government person. I understand that when you see it in a vacuum it’s very scary,” she said. “I also know that in a pandemic you need to protect health and safety and be proactive.

“I wasn’t trying to give myself a crown.”

The city of Champaign posted a clarification on its Facebook page reading, “There is currently no firearm ban and no intent to seize property or close businesses. Additionally there are no restrictions on the sale of alcohol or gas or the ability to enter or leave Champaign.”

“Some mayor and city council members are asking to get tarred and feathered,” wrote one commenter.

Feinen said: “Our staff was working around the clock to get accurate messaging out, but people weren’t paying attention to it. Whether or not someone’s angry with the mayor pales in comparison.”

City staff members worked all weekend to quell the uproar, in between preparing for statewide school, restaurant and bar closures ordered by Gov. J.B. Pritzker, a Democrat.

Champaign County on Sunday announced its first coronavirus case, a woman in her 60s who is recovering at home, Feinen said.

“So we weren’t out of line, being prepared,” she said. But it is strange, she added: “The governor has the same powers. He implemented his emergency order, and nobody blinked.”

This article originally appeared in The New York Times.
© 2020 The New York Times Company

Fox News hosts Sean Hannity and Laura Ingraham 

have changed their coronavirus tune in a big way
March 18, 2020 By Shawn Langlois

Fox News personality Sean Hannity, an ally and informal adviser to President Trump, visiting the White House briefing room. Getty

What a difference a few days, and a few thousand coronavirus cases in the U.S., make.

On Fox News in recent weeks, downplaying the outbreak was all the rage. Pete Hegseth said “the more I learn about this, the less there is to worry about.” Jeanine Pirro said the mainstream-media “doesn’t reflect reality.” Ainsley Earhardt claimed “it’s actually the safest time to fly.” Sean Hannity and Laura Ingraham talked about the press as “panic pushers” stirring up “mass hysteria.”

And perhaps the most glaring of all came from Trish Regan over on Fox Business, who accused the “liberal media” of using the coronavirus “to impeach the president. Her monologue may have cost her the job, though she chalked it up to Fox’s “prioritizing its coverage during market hours.”

The tone has clearly shifted among the notable right-wing personalities on the network, as you can see from this Washington Post video that racked up more than 5 million views overnight:

Tucker Carlson was notably absent from the compilation. The “Tucker Carlson Tonight” host strayed from his colleagues early when he described the virus as “a very serious problem.”

The rest of the network now appears to be on board, with the “Fox & Friends” bunch spreading out across the studio on Tuesday to demonstrate best practices.

“To be responsible, to show social distancing, all three of us are apart — same studio, plenty of distance,” Brian Kilmeade told viewers to start the broadcast.

Meanwhile, the number of COVID-19 cases in the U.S. continues to rise as more testing options become available. There are now 6,510 cases and have been 114 deaths across the country, according to data aggregated by Johns Hopkins University.

The fear is reflected in the stock market, with the Dow Jones Industrial Average DJIA, -6.30% down more than 2,000 points in Wednesday’s trading session.

Fox News’s parent company, Fox Corp. FOX, -10.00%, shares common ownership with News NWS, -14.55%, the parent of MarketWatch publisher Dow Jones.

About the Author

Shawn Langlois
Shawn Langlois is an editor and writer for MarketWatch in Los Angeles.