Decoding Avar society
Using ancient DNA and archaeological evidence to unravel the kinship, social practices and transformations of early medieval steppe groups in Europe
IMAGE:
EXCAVATION WORKS CONDUCTED BY THE EÖTVÖS LORÁND UNIVERSITY AT THE AVAR-PERIOD (6TH-9TH CENTURY AD) CEMETERY OF RÁKÓCZIFALVA, HUNGARY, IN 2006.
view moreCREDIT: INSTITUTE OF ARCHAEOLOGICAL SCIENCES, EÖTVÖS LORÁND UNIVERSITY MÚZEUM, BUDAPEST, HUNGARY
The Avars, who had come from Eastern Central Asia, ruled much of Eastern Central Europe for a quarter millennium, from the 6th to the 9th century CE. They may be less known than their less successful predecessors, the Huns. Yet in their cemeteries, they left one of the richest archaeological heritages in European history, including around 100,000 graves that have so far been excavated. From Avar funeral customs, and from written reports of their neighbours, scholars have reconstructed some of their social practices and ways of life. Yet now, archaeogenetics offer a totally new viewpoint on Avar communities who lived more than 1000 years ago. We can now analyse the ways in which individuals were related to each other up to the sixth to tenth degree.
By combining newly generated ancient DNA data with complementary archaeological, anthropological and historical information, a team of the multidisciplinary Synergy Grant research project HistoGenes funded by the European Research Council (ERC) has thus opened new ways to find out more about kinship patterns, social practices and population development in the distant past. The team includes researchers from the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Leipzig, Germany, together with Hungarian, Austrian and US research groups. In their collaboration, they set new standards by using all available methods, including the most advanced genetic and bio-informatic tools.
Studying whole communities
The historical knowledge on the Avar period populations was passed on to us by their enemies, mainly the Byzantines and the Franks, so we lack information on the internal organisation of their clans. Women are particularly underrepresented in historical sources, with only three incidental mentions, so knowledge of their lives is practically non-existent. We know that some groups came to Europe from the East Asian and Pontic steppes, but to what extent, if at all, were steppe traditions maintained in Avar society if at all? How did the newcomer groups from the East interact with each other and with the population of their new homeland in Europe? In essence, how did their way of life change over time in a completely new environment after they left the steppes and abandoned their nomadic way of life?
The study was carried out as part of the ERC Synergy Grant project HistoGenes (No. 856453), by a multidisciplinary research team of geneticists, archaeologists, anthropologists and historians, including researchers from the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Leipzig, Germany, the Institute of Archaeological Sciences and Department of Biological Anthropology at Eötvös Loránd University (ELTE), Institute of Archaeogenomics, HUN-REN Research Centre for the Humanities, Budapest, Hungary, the Curt Engelhorn Center for Archaeometry in Mannheim, Germany, the Institute for Austrian Historical Research of the University of Vienna, Austria, the Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton, USA, and others. Contrary to common practice in ancient DNA research, the team aimed to study whole communities and therefore focused on sampling all available human remains from four fully excavated Avar period cemeteries. Thanks to exceptional aDNA preservation, they were able to analyse a total of 424 individuals and discovered that around 300 had a close (1st and 2nd degree) relative buried in the same cemetery. This allowed the reconstruction of several extensive pedigrees, the largest of which is nine generations deep and spans about 250 years.
Community dynamics
The researchers were able to identify communities that practised a strict patrilineal descent system, where patrilocality (male individuals staying in the community after marriage) and female exogamy (female individuals moving to their partner’s community after marriage) were the norm. Communities were locally centred around a main patriline, were related to each other through the systematic practice of female exogamy. Zuzana Hofmanová, senior author of the study says: “In a way, this pattern shows the role of females in promoting the cohesion of this society, it was the role of females that connected the individual communities”. Multiple reproductive partners were common. Several independent cases show that these communities practised so-called levirate unions. This practice involves related male individuals (siblings or father and son) having offspring with the same female individual. Guido Alberto Gnecchi-Ruscone, first author of the study, adds: ”These practices, together with the absence of genetic consanguinity, indicate that the society maintained a detailed memory of its ancestry and knew who its biological relatives were over generations”.
These social practices are consistent with evidence from historical sources and anthropological research on Eurasian Steppe societies. Thanks to the high resolution provided by the extensive pedigrees and whole-cemetery data, the researchers were also able to identify a clear temporal transition within one of the sites analysed. This was revealed by the shift from one patriline to another and by changes in patterns of distant relatedness (the network of genetic relatedness, i.e. the IBD-network). Zsófia Rácz, co-first author of the study, says: “This community replacement reflects both an archaeological and dietary shift that we discovered within the site itself, but also a large-scale archaeological transition that occurred throughout the Carpathian Basin”. This change, probably related to political changes in the region, was not accompanied by a change in ancestry and would therefore have been invisible without the study of whole communities. This finding highlights how genetic continuity at the level of ancestry can still conceal replacements of whole communities, and has important implications for future studies comparing genetic ancestry and archaeological shifts.
Burial with a horse at the Rákóczifalva site, Hungary (8th century AD). This male individual, who died at a young age, belongs to the 2nd generation of pedigree 4, and was one of the sons of the founder of this kinship unit.
CREDIT
Institute of Archaeological Sciences, Eötvös Loránd University Múzeum, Budapest, Hungary
Gold figurine from the excavation at Rákóczifalva, Hungary. Metal detector find from the territory of the Avar cemetery (7th century AD).
CREDIT
Institute of Archaeological Sciences, Eötvös Loránd University Múzeum, Budapest, Hungary
This research project has been funded by the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union's Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme (Grant Agreement No. 856453 ERC-2019-SyG HistoGenes). HistoGenes is a research framework investigating the period of 400 to 900 CE in the Carpathian Basin from an interdisciplinary perspective.
JOURNAL
Nature
ARTICLE TITLE
Network of large pedigrees reveals social practices of Avar communities
ARTICLE PUBLICATION DATE
24-Apr-2024
Study reveals social organization of Avar realm
INSTITUTE FOR ADVANCED STUDY
IMAGE:
THE LARGEST SET OF INTERCONNECTED PEDIGREES RECONSTRUCTED IN RÁKÓCZIFALVA (RK) AND THE CEMETERY MAP HIGHLIGHTING THE BURIAL LOCATION OF THE RELATED INDIVIDUALS: A) A LARGE (146 INDIVIDUALS) INTERCONNECTED SET OF SUB-PEDIGREES, NUMBER 1 TO 5 AND FOUR SMALLER PEDIGREES (34 INDIVIDUALS), NUMBER 6, 7, 8 AND 12. LEVIRATE UNIONS ARE REPORTED WITH COLORED LINES CONNECTING THE PARTNERS INVOLVED. THE MALES’ Y-HAPLOGROUPS ARE VISUALIZED WITH COLORED BORDERS AROUND THE INDIVIDUALS. BLACK SYMBOLS CORRESPOND TO THE INDIVIDUALS WE HAVE ADNA FROM, WHITE ONES ARE THE MISSING INDIVIDUALS INFERRED ON THE BASIS OF AVAILABLE DATA. ON THE LEFT A COLORED BAR REPRESENTS THE TIMELINE SPANNING THE WHOLE AVAR PERIOD COVERING THE 9+ GENERATIONS OF THE PEDIGREES. B) CEMETERY MAP OF RÁKÓCZIFALVA 8 (THE SMALLER PART ON THE RIGHT SEPARATED BY 95 METERS) AND 8A (THE LEFT PART) COLOR CODED ACCORDING TO THE PEDIGREE NUMBERED AS IN A.
view moreCREDIT: HISTOGENES
A multidisciplinary research team including Patrick Geary, Professor Emeritus in the School of Historical Studies at the Institute for Advanced Study, together with Hungarian, Austrian, and German research groups, has combined ancient DNA data with a clear archaeological, anthropological, and historical context to reconstruct the social dynamics of Avar-period steppe descent populations that settled in Europe's Carpathian Basin in the 6th century.
Their research findings were published today in Nature.
The Avars, who had come from Eastern Central Asia, ruled much of Eastern Central Europe for a quarter millennium, from the 6th to the 9th century C.E. They may be less known than their less successful predecessors, the Huns. Yet in their cemeteries, they left one of the richest archaeological heritages in European history, including around 100,000 graves that have so far been excavated. From Avar funeral customs, and from written reports of their neighbors, scholars have reconstructed some of their social practices and ways of life. Yet now, archaeogenetics offers a totally new viewpoint on Avar communities who lived more than 1,000 years ago. We can now analyze the ways in which individuals were related to each other up to the sixth to tenth degree.
The historical knowledge on the Avar period populations was passed on by their enemies, mainly the Byzantines and the Franks, so information is lacking on the internal organization of their clans. Women are particularly underrepresented in historical sources, with only three incidental mentions, so knowledge of their lives is practically non-existent. It is known that some groups came to Europe from the East Asian and Pontic steppes, but to what extent were steppe traditions maintained in Avar society, if at all? How did the newcomer groups from the East interact with each other and with the population of their new homeland in Europe? In essence, how did their way of life change over time in a completely new environment after they left the steppes and abandoned their nomadic way of life?
Studying whole communities
Contrary to common practice in ancient DNA research, the team aimed to study whole communities and therefore focused on sampling all available human remains from four fully excavated Avar period cemeteries, analyzing entire communities by sampling all available human remains from four fully excavated Avar-era cemeteries, analyzing a total of 424 individuals and discovering that around 300 had a close (1st and 2nd degree) relative buried in the same cemetery. This allowed the reconstruction of several extensive pedigrees—the largest of which is nine generations deep and spans about 250 years—revealing that the communities practiced a strict patrilineal system of descent. Women played a key role in promoting social cohesion, linking individual communities by marrying outside their original community. Changes within a site indicated community replacement, probably linked to political changes, that remained genetically invisible, showing that genetic continuity at the level of ancestry can mask the replacement of whole communities, with important implications for future archaeological and genetic research.
The study was carried out by a multidisciplinary research team of geneticists, archaeologists, anthropologists, and historians, including researchers from the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Leipzig, Germany; the Institute of Archaeological Sciences, Eötvös Loránd University, Budapest, Hungary; the Curt Engelhorn Center for Archaeometry in Mannheim, Germany; and the Institute for Austrian Historical Research of the University of Vienna, Austria; as well as the Institute for Advanced Study.
Community dynamics
The researchers were able to identify communities that practiced a strict patrilineal descent system, where patrilocality (male individuals staying in the community after marriage) and female exogamy (female individuals moving to their partner’s community after marriage) were the norm. Communities were locally centered around a main patriline and were related to each other through the systematic practice of female exogamy. Zuzana Hofmanová, senior author of the study, says, "In a way, this pattern shows the role of females in promoting the cohesion of this society, it was the role of females that connected the individual communities." Multiple reproductive partners were common. Several independent cases show that these communities practiced so-called levirate unions. This practice involves related male individuals (siblings or father and son) having offspring with the same female individual. Guido Alberto Gnecchi-Ruscone, first author of the study, adds, "These practices, together with the absence of genetic consanguinity, indicate that the society maintained a detailed memory of its ancestry and knew who its biological relatives were over generations." These social practices are consistent with evidence from historical sources and anthropological research on Eurasian Steppe societies. Thanks to the high resolution provided by the extensive pedigrees and whole-cemetery data, the researchers were also able to identify a clear temporal transition within one of the sites analyzed. This was revealed by the shift from one patriline to another and by changes in patterns of distant relatedness (the network of genetic relatedness, i.e., the IBD-network). Zsófia Rácz, co-first author of the study, says, "This community replacement reflects both an archaeological and dietary shift that we discovered within the site itself, but also a large-scale archaeological transition that occurred throughout the Carpathian Basin." This change, probably related to political changes in the region, was not accompanied by a change in ancestry and would therefore have been invisible without the study of whole communities. This finding highlights how genetic continuity at the level of ancestry can still conceal replacements of whole communities, and has important implications for future studies comparing genetic ancestry and archaeological shifts. The team has thus opened new ways to find out more about kinship patterns, social practices, and population development in the distant past. In their collaboration, the team set new standards by using all available methods, including the most advanced genetic and bio-informatic tools.
"This study, which is one in the series of innovative publications from the HistoGenes project, demonstrates how new, fundamental insights into past societies can be gained when historians, archaeologists, anthropologists, and geneticists collaborate as equals," said Geary.
This research project has been funded by the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union's Horizon 2020 research and innovation program (Grant Agreement No. 856453 ERC-2019-SyG HistoGenes). HistoGenes is a research framework investigating the period of 400 to 900 C.E. in the Carpathian Basin from an interdisciplinary perspective.
About the Institute
The Institute for Advanced Study has served as one of the leading independent centers for theoretical research and intellectual inquiry since its establishment in 1930, advancing the frontiers of knowledge across the sciences and humanities. From founding IAS Faculty Albert Einstein, Erwin Panofsky, and John von Neumann to influential figures Emmy Noether, George Kennan, and J. Robert Oppenheimer to the foremost thinkers of the present, IAS is dedicated to enabling independent inquiry and fundamental discovery.
Each year, the Institute welcomes more than 250 of the world’s most promising post-doctoral researchers and scholars who are selected and mentored by a permanent Faculty, each of whom are preeminent leaders in their fields. Among present and past Faculty and Members, there have been 35 Nobel Laureates, 44 of the 62 Fields Medalists, and 23 of the 27 Abel Prize Laureates, as well as winners of the Pulitzer Prize in History; the Wolf, Holberg, and Kluge prizes; and many MacArthur and Guggenheim fellows, among other honors.
Network analysis of the haplotype-IBD sharing between the Avar period individuals analyzed in the study: a) Visualization of the network of IBD connections (edges) between the ancient individuals (nodes) colored according to their site with squares representing males and circles females. The males’ Y-haplogroups are visualized with colored borders around the individuals. The strength of the IBD connection is summarized by the maximum IBD length in centi-Morgan found for each pair of individuals. The distribution of these lengths from the lowest (>12 cM cutoff) to the highest (>280 cM for first degree relatives) is reflected in the width and the color scale of each edge. b) the only adults network considering only males (top) and only females (bottom). c) Network statistics calculated on the adults-only network. On the left the degree centrality, k (defined as the number of links held by the node) is plotted vs the cumulative density function of the degrees distribution. On the right, the total k is plotted vs the ratio of k calculated between-site edges and total k (kB/k).
CREDIT
HistoGenes
JOURNAL
Nature
ARTICLE TITLE
Network of large pedigrees reveals social practices of Avar communities
ARTICLE PUBLICATION DATE
24-Apr-2024
