Who's left of the Kadhafi clan 10 years after revolt?

Libyan strongman Moamer Kadhafi was ousted and killed in the 2011 uprising, but several of his family members survived.

© JOSEPH EID Several members of Libyan dictator Moamer Kadhafi's family survived the 2011 uprising

A decade on, what has happened to them?

Three of Kadhafi's seven sons died in the uprising, including Mutassim, who was killed by rebels in the dictator's home town of Sirte on October 20, 2011, the same day as his father.

Another son, Seif al-Arab, perished in a NATO air raid in April 2011, and his brother Khamis died in combat four months later, at the height of the revolt.

But other members of the Kadhafi clan survived, including his wife Safiya, his eldest son Mohammed -- from his first marriage -- and his daughter Aisha, who are known to be living in exile.

© - From left to right, Kadhafi's wife Safiya, his sons Hannibal and Mohammed and his daughter Aisha

Mystery, however, surrounds the whereabouts of the dictator's erstwhile heir apparent, Seif al-Islam Kadhafi, who is wanted for war crimes by the International Criminal Court (ICC).

- The family -

After the fall of Tripoli to rebels in August 2011, Safiya, Mohammed and Aisha escaped to neighbouring Algeria.

They were later granted refuge in the Gulf sultanate of Oman on condition they do not carry out political activities, the country's then foreign minister Mohammed Abdelaziz told AFP in 2013.

Aisha, a lawyer by profession and a former UN goodwill ambassador, had been part of an international defence team for Saddam Hussein after the Iraqi leader was ousted in the 2003 US-led invasion. 

© MAHMUD TURKIA Seif al-Islam (L) has not been seen or heard from since June 2014, when he appeared via video from Zintan during his trial by a Tripoli court

High-rolling son Hannibal also sought refuge in Algeria after the uprising, before trying to sneak into Lebanon to join his wife, Lebanese model Aline Skaf.

But Lebanese authorities arrested and charged him in 2015 with withholding information about prominent Muslim Shiite cleric Mussa Sadr, who went missing in 1978 during a visit to Libya.

Hannibal and his wife had sparked a diplomatic incident with Switzerland in 2008, when they were arrested in a luxury Geneva hotel for assaulting two former domestic employees.

Playboy son Saadi Kadhafi -- once a professional footballer in Italy -- fled to Niger after the uprising but was later extradited to Libya, where he was wanted for murder and repression during the revolt.

© MAHMUD TURKIA Saadi Kadhafi, once a professional footballer, is currently held in a Tripoli prison

He is currently held in a Tripoli prison, accused of crimes committed against protesters in 2011 and of the 2005 killing of Libyan football player Bashir al-Rayani.

- Heir apparent -

Seif al-Islam, whose name means "sword of Islam", was captured by a Libyan militia in November 2011, days after his father was killed.

Four years later, a Tripoli court sentenced him in absentia to death for crimes committed during the revolt.

The armed group which captured him announced in 2017 that Seif al-Islam had been released.

The claim was never confirmed independently, and in 2019, the ICC prosecutor said there was "reliable" information that he was in Zintan, western Libya.

But Seif al-Islam has not been seen or heard from since June 2014, when he appeared via video from Zintan during his trial by the Tripoli court.

- Clan and tribe -

During his glory days, Kadhafi considered himself the "Leader of the Revolution" and declared Libya a "Jamahiriya", or "state of the masses" run by local committees.

Thousands of his supporters, including from his own Kadhadfa tribe, fled Libya during and after the regime's fall, with many settling in Egypt and Tunisia.

"Contrary to what is thought, the Kadhadfa tribe suffered under the regime of Kadhafi, and several members who had opposed him landed in jail," said Libyan law professor Amani al-Hejrissi.

The clan also included members of Kadhafi's revolutionary guard -- a paramilitary force tasked with protecting the regime against its detractors -- who were not necessarily blood relatives.

Some pined for home, and a group in Cairo later revived the Al-Jamahiriya television network, Kadhafi's propaganda arm.

But could Kadhafi's exiled supporters play a political role in the now divided country?

"I don't think so," said Hejrissi.

"Most Libyans see the fallen regime as the root of the corruption and destruction of the political system."

bur-hme-rb/nd/vl/gk/hkb/lg/pjm/fz/kjm

THEY ARE CLUELESS

U.S. warns against moves that damage institutions in Haiti amid political gridlock

PORT-AU-PRINCE (Reuters) - The United States said on Tuesday it was "deeply concerned" about Haiti's fragile institutions, although it stopped short of chastising President Jovenel Moise after his government retired three Supreme Court judges who posed a threat to his leadership.

© Reuters/VALERIE BAERISWYL Motorcyclists ride near a street barricade after protests against Haiti's President Jovenel Moise, in Port-au-Prince

© Reuters/VALERIE BAERISWYL People walk near a street market in Port-au-Prince

Fresh political turmoil engulfed the volatile Caribbean nation this weekend after Moise alleged there was an attempt to overthrow the government and 23 people were arrested, including a Supreme Court judge and a senior police official.

© Reuters/VALERIE BAERISWYL Police sit on the back of a pick-up truck while patrolling the area, in Port-au-Prince

The detained judge was one of three Supreme Court justices who the opposition approached as possible candidates to be interim leaders of a transitional government to take over from Moise until elections are held.

On Monday, the government issued an executive decree ordering the three judges to be retired from the court.

The U.S. Embassy in Port-Au-Prince said in a statement that it had seen the executive order about the judges.

"We are deeply concerned about any actions that risk damaging Haiti's democratic institutions. The Executive Order is now being scrutinized to determine whether it conforms to Haiti's constitutions and laws," the embassy said.

Haiti's opposition claims Moise should step down as his five-year term in office expired on Feb. 7 following 2015 elections, which were disputed and the result cancelled by the electoral counsel.

Moise rejects those claims, pointing out he took power in February 2017 after winning fresh elections in 2016 and has pledged to step down next year.

Washington last week appeared to back Moise's timeline, with a State Department spokesperson saying a new leader should replace Moise in February 2022.

The U.S. Embassy said "all political actors should focus on restoring to the Haiti people the right to choose their lawmakers by organizing overdue legislative elections as soon as technically feasible and presidential elections soon after".

The opposition accused Moise of violating the constitution as his government failed to hold legislative elections in 2019, leaving the parliament without lawmakers and allowing the president to rule by decree since January 2020.

(Reporting by Andre Paultre; Writing by Drazen Jorgic; Editing by Raju Gopalakrishnan)

Mysterious metal monolith appears at ancient temple site in Turkey

Similar structures have appeared around the world since late 2020.

 

Turkish police guard a metal monolith found in southeastern Turkey. 

Screenshot from a video uploaded Feb. 6, 2021. Photo by YOUTUBE/TRT.
Al-Monitor Staff

Feb 8, 2021

A metal monolith has appeared in southeastern Turkey. Similar mysterious structures grabbed headlines across the world late last year.

The pillar stands at 3 meters (9.8 feet) tall and 1 meter (3.2 feet) wide. It is located at the Gobeklitepe archaeological site in the southeastern Anatolia region near the Syrian border. The authorities are currently investigating where it came from and have yet to find out its origin, the state-run Anadolu News Agency reported on Sunday.

Gobeklitepe is an an ancient temple recognized by the United Nations as a World Heritage Site.




The structure’s appearance follows similar instances around the world. In November, a large, metallic, column-like structure appeared in the desert in the southwestern American state of Utah and then disappeared. Days later, a similar structure appeared in California. A metallic monolith also showed up in Romania in eastern Europe days after the Utah one and then vanished.

Other structures reportedly popped up later in Iran, Morocco and numerous other countries.

The origin of the first Utah monolith are still unknown. A group of local men later came forward and said they removed the structure. Details surrounding the Romanian monolith are also still unclear. Other monoliths have been made by artists inspired by the original, and some have been removed by the authorities. The phenomenon has led to unfounded theories that aliens placed the monoliths on earth.

The Turkish monolith is engraved with a phrase that translates to, “Look at the sky if you want to see the moon.” It is written in Old Turkic script, according to Anadolu. This alphabet predates the Latin-based alphabet utilized by modern Turkish.

Update: Feb. 9, 2020. Anadolu reported on Tuesday that the structure has disappeared from its location in Gobeklitepe. Photos showed the monolith was under police guard before it was removed. It joins other monoliths that have appeared and then vanished.

Read more: https://www.al-monitor.com/pulse/originals/2021/02/metal-monolith-structure-gobeklitepe-turkey-utah-column.html#ixzz6m2l3DFdx

Mystery of Turkey’s monolith is solved

By Tamar Lapin

February 9, 2021 

A monolith that mysteriously appeared in Turkey before vanishing on Tuesday turned out to be a publicity stunt tied to the country’s newly-announced space program.

The 10-foot metal slab inscribed with the phrase “Look at the sky, you will see the moon” in ancient Turkish script was discovered Friday by a farmer in the Sanliurfa province.

By Tuesday morning, the shimmering structure had disappeared, puzzling locals.

“We don’t know if it was placed on my field for marketing purposes or as an advertisement,” farmer Fuat Demirdil told the state-run Anadolu Agency.

“Residents cannot solve the mystery of the metal block,” he added.





But the enigma was solved later in the day, when President Recep Tayyip Erdogan projected an image of the monolith on a screen as he announced the country’s new space program.

“I now present to you Turkey’s 10-year vision, strategy and aims and I say: ‘look at the sky, you will see the moon,’” Erdogan said during a televised event.Turkish police officers standing near the recently discovered monolith in Sanliurfa on February 7, 2021.Bekir Seyhanli/IHA via AP

Erdogan’s use of the structure and of the phrase inscribed on it during his announcement made it clear that the monolith’s appearance had been part of a gimmick.

It was just the latest in a series of recent incidents where similar structures appeared and disappeared in numerous countries.

With Post wires

Turkish student protests feed anti-Erdogan anger

Fenced in by riot police, Zeynep Kurbanzade stands with her university classmates in daily protest against the rector picked by President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, who has ruled Turkey since she was just one year old.

© Bulent Kilic Turkish police officers detain protesters during a rally against the appointment of a ruling Justice and Development Party (AKP) loyalist, as new Bogazic university rector

Small in number, loud in voice and filled with a thirst for change, the Bogazici University students are posing a worrisome challenge to the 66-year-old Turkish leader, who has responded by flooding the streets with police.

For the religiously conservative Erdogan, their social media-driven campaign -- now in its second month -- has ominous echoes of 2013 protests that began in defence of an Istanbul park before morphing into a national movement.

For the students, the appointment of Melih Bulu, a losing parliamentary candidate from Erdogan's ruling party who denies claims of plagiarising his doctorate thesis, as head of the elite Istanbul institution was the last straw in a life filled with discontent.

 President Recep Tayyip Erdogan decided to turn the protests into part of a broader culture war being waged across Turkey's deeply polarised society

"We are not happy with the economy, we are not happy with the growing pressure," Kurbanzade, 19, told AFP outside the campus, which has been besieged by police barricades since the start of the year.

"Acts of femicide go unpunished, mobsters walk free from jail and are given the red carpet treatment, but our friends are detained because of a tweet. We don't accept this," she said.

Police have fired rubber bullets and tear gas while detaining hundreds across Istanbul and in smaller solidarity rallies in big cities such as Ankara and Izmir.

Although most are quickly released, the jailings and heavy-handed police tactics remind many of the sweeping powers Erdogan has assumed since surviving a coup bid in 2016, which was followed by a punishing social and political crackdown.

"A mood of discontent -- from the presidential regime to the economic collapse -- has found a new form of expression through Bogazici," said Zeynep Gambetti, an associate professor of political theory at the university.

- Culture wars -

After initially ignoring the protests, Erdogan this month decided to turn them into part of a broader culture war being waged across Turkey's deeply polarised society.

For the first time since assuming power in 2003, he unleashed several verbal assaults on the LGBT movement, blaming it for the protests with a venom that drew immediate condemnation from the United States and the European Union.

"Don't pay attention to what those lesbians say," he told a group of female supporters last week, defending Bulu's appointment as lawful.


The students have responded to Erdogan on the streets and on Twitter, with several who run the protests' social media accounts jailed and charged with insulting the president.

"Kayyum Rektor Istemiyoruz!" (We don't want a trustee rector) has become a rallying cry, a protest against Erdogan's decision in 2016 to start picking the heads of universities.

For many students and professors, these appointments run similar to his naming of government trustees in place of dozens of mayors who have been dismissed or jailed for alleged links to outlawed Kurdish militants.

"What we need to discuss is autonomy at universities but we talk about detentions. Who benefits from the chaos? Not us," said Tinaz Ekim, a professor of industrial engineering at the university.

- 'An overreaction' -

Ustun Erguder, who served two terms as Bogazici University's elected rector in the 1990s, compared this standoff to the late 1970s, when left and right-wing militants clashed across the streets of Ankara and Istanbul.

Eventually the army seized power in a 1980 putsch, but even then the 158-year-old institution remained an island of stability, Erguder recalled.

"When I was a young academic in the 1970s, all the universities were in a state of war. Even under those circumstances, education at Bogazici continued uninterrupted," Erguder told AFP.

"We could calm (the protests on campus) without the police, but today there's an overreaction."

Erguder said Bulu visited him in his home soon after being appointed.

"I told him how his predecessor won the hearts and minds, and advised him to build bridges. He carefully listened and took notes."

Bulu told a pro-government newspaper last week: "I never think about resigning."

- Strong headwinds -

The students are facing formidable headwinds, from the brute power of the police, to the absence of a natural protest leader, to their mistrust in other political parties.

For all of these reasons, Ozgur Unluhisarcikli of the US German Marshall Fund said it was unlikely that the protests would grow.

"There is an understanding among opposition parties that mass protests lead to polarisation and galvanise Erdogan's supporters," said Unluhisarcikli.

One Western diplomat told AFP that he could detect "no sign so far" that the protests could broaden.

But for now, at least, the students and their supporters vow defiance.

"These youngsters live on the internet, see blocked websites, bans, detentions over a tweet, all sorts of pressure, so they feel compelled to channel their frustration in one way or another," said political analyst Gurkan Ozturan, a Bogazici graduate.

fo/zak/txw

IT USED TO BE THE OTHER WAY AROUND

U.S. authorities seize Florida-bound convoy allegedly smuggling 270 kg of Canadian marijuana

Jorge Barrera 

© Courtesy of Aboriginal Peoples Television Network 

Seth Lazore, a member of Akwesasne, which straddles the Canada-U.S. border, was charged in connection with a U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration operation targeting a convoy of pickup trucks allegedly…

U.S. authorities recently intercepted a convoy of late-model pickup trucks pulling trailers in New York state with more than 270 kilograms of Canadian-grown marijuana headed for Florida, U.S. court documents allege.

The Feb. 5 bust was part of a multi-agency operation that included surveillance and cellphone wiretaps.

The operation, headed by the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA), tracked the movements of a motorboat across the St. Lawrence River and the departure of vehicles from the Mohawk community of Akwesasne, which straddles the Canada-U.S. border about 120 kilometres southwest of Montreal.

The convoy was eventually intercepted by New York state police on Hwy 87 heading south toward Lake Placid, N.Y., with Florida as the ultimate destination, according to an affidavit filed by the DEA.

The bust comes as the U.S. inches toward removal of marijuana from the list of controlled substances. The U.S. House of Representatives passed a bill late last year to push the effort forward. The proposed change is expected to gain traction in a Democrat-controlled Senate.

New York and Florida are also moving toward legalizing the recreational use of marijuana, which has been legal in Canada since 2018.

New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo said in January that he planned to legalize and tax marijuana in the state by the end of the year. In Florida, state legislators are also moving to legalize recreational marijuana use this year, with bills introduced in the state House and Senate.
Intercepted text messages tipped off DEA

The DEA began its operation after obtaining information that "large amounts of marijuana" were being smuggled into the U.S. through Akwesasne, according to the affidavit filed by DEA agent Niles DuPont, who also works for the U.S. Bureau of Indian Affairs.

The Akwesasne Mohawk territory is cut in half by the border, leaving some portions of the reserve within Canada, accessible domestically only by river, or through the U.S. by roads with no border checkpoints.

Given this geography, coupled with the historic nationalism of Akwesasne, the region has been used to move tobacco north and marijuana south — mainly across the river by boats and by snowmobile in winter when it freezes over.

The DEA received wiretap authorization to intercept the cellphone of John Skidders Jr., who is an Akwesasne member, according to the court document.

The DEA intercepted a text conversation between Skidders and another Akwesasne member named Seth Lazore on Feb. 3, allegedly discussing the packaging of 650 bags of marijuana.

"What time we leaving trw," said an alleged text message from Lazore.

"Soon as its all sealed," Skidders allegedly responded, according to the affidavit. © CBC News An alleged text message exchange between Akwesasne members John Skidders Jr. and Seth Lazore intercepted by the Drug Enforcement Administration.

The DEA then set up surveillance of a warehouse on Cook Road, which is on the U.S. side of Akwesasne. It skirts the Canadian side of the reserve in a section called Snye, which sits between the St. Lawrence River and the U.S. border.

"This location is believed to be utilized by Skidders to load marijuana for transport and to organize marijuana shipments," the court document alleges.
Boats used to move marijuana

The DEA surveillance team then observed a Ford F-350 with New York licence plates.

The truck was pulling a "hydro-yacht type boat" on a trailer. Surveillance also spotted another truck, a black GMC pickup, pulling a "camouflaged coloured hydro-yacht," which was later monitored by a second surveillance team heading into a nearby marina in Hogansburg, N.Y.

The camouflage boat was then observed heading across the St. Lawrence toward Canada. A little less than an hour later, the surveillance team spotted it on a trailer towed by the same black GMC truck headed back to the warehouse, the court document says.

"Drug smugglers commonly use boats to smuggle narcotics between Canada and the U.S.," the affidavit says.

The next morning, the surveillance team watched four vehicles — including the Ford F-350 and a 2021 Yukon Denali spotted at the warehouse — at a plaza on Route 37, which cuts through the U.S. side of Akwesasne.

The Denali was towing a trailer with two ATVs and the F-350 pulled a trailer with a Corvette bearing a California licence plate. A third vehicle, a 3500 Dodge pickup truck, carried a trailer with an "antique-like pickup truck." The fourth vehicle, a 1500 Chevrolet Silverado, did not have a trailer but did have a Florida licence plate, according to the court document.

The DEA then began to monitor the movement of the four-vehicle convoy as it headed for Lake Placid. Agents noticed that vehicles "made the same turns and maintained an even speed."

New York State Police troopers then swept in, pulling over the vehicles one by one, several kilometres apart.

Lazore was allegedly found sitting in the passenger seat of the Denali, along with an unnamed driver and two minors. Skidders was allegedly pulled over driving the F-350 that was pulling the Corvette. There were two minors in the truck with him, the court document says.

The DEA said it found 270 kilograms of marijuana hidden in the floorboards of the three trailers.

Skidders and Lazore are each charged with one count of conspiracy to possess and distribute marijuana.

Lawyers for the two did not respond to a request for comment.

U.S. Assistant Attorney Troy Anderson did not respond to a request for comment.

People living rough on Vancouver's streets brace for Arctic blast

© Provided by Vancouver Sun 

Taze Haasbeek outside his tent at Strathcona Park as temperatures are expected to drop to -10c overnight in Vancouver.

It’s the same advice you would give someone on the Prairies during a blast of Arctic cold front: Layer up.

It is not as cold as Winnipeg or Edmonton and their minus-30C temperatures, but for those living on the street, this week’s weather poses real and dangerous problems.

“We’re surviving,” Chrissy Brett said. “It helps that we have a warming centre and the sacred fire.”

Brett is a spokeswoman at the tent city in Vancouver’s Strathcona Park, where more than 200 people have decided to brave out the winter rains, wind, and now cold weather.

At the request of the city, B.C. Housing provided a mess tent with propane heaters inside. But because of pandemic protocols, only 18 people are allowed inside at a time.

A Nanaimo couple has come up with candles made of paint cans and cinder blocks, with wire mesh to prevent items such as blankets or sleeping bags from falling into the flames and burning down a tent.

“It’s very, very difficult having to deal with the cold,” said Fiona York, an advocate for people without shelter. “We’re trying to double up on extra tarps, sleeping bags. We’re doing our best.”

© NICK PROCAYLO The warming tent at Strathcona Park.

At Strathcona park on Tuesday, a volunteer delivered huge bags of dog and cat food, while another pulled a wagon loaded with treats for residents.

The city, in cooperation with the province, opens extreme-weather shelters as soon as temperatures drop to freezing. They have been open 75 nights so far this winter, on top of the temporary winter shelters that are open every night between November and March.

The city has also opened warming centres from Feb. 8 to 12, which are activated when the temperature reaches minus-5C or below.

“Due to the cold weather this week, additional extreme-weather response shelter spaces are open from Feb. 8 to 12 at Evelyne Saller Centre, Directions Youth Services Centre, Tenth Church, Langara YMCA, and Cascades Church,” a city spokeswoman said. “Warming centres are activated when the temperature reaches minus-5C or below, or when it feels like minus-5C or below.

“These spaces act as a life-saving measure for people sleeping outside during the colder winter months. The city encourages anyone who is sleeping outside to visit one of these centre which are open to all, including couples, and provide hot drinks and snacks.”

Most centres accept people with pets and carts.

But with pandemic protocols in place, all shelters and warming centres have reduced capacity to accommodate social distancing.

At Strathcona Park, there are two warming tents to enable people to stay warm, as well as temporary shower and washroom facilities. The first tent is for people who have symptoms of COVID-19, and the second for those who are not experiencing symptoms. Both tents operate 24 hours a day and are operated by a non-profit and staffed by peers.

“I definitely don’t want to go inside (a single-room occupancy building),” Strathcona Park resident Taze Haasbeek said outside his igloo-looking tent, citing past violent attacks. “My worry here is, I don’t want to wake up on fire.”

When the temperature drops, danger rises, said Jeremy Hunka of Union Gospel Mission, pointing to a fire death at a North Shore homeless camp in January.

And aside from things such as frostbite and hyperthermia, the cold can bring on pneumonia, Hunka said.

“The cold gets in your body, your bones, your lungs.”

Union Gospel Mission’s cold-weather spaces are open and its mobile mission is dropping off socks, toques, blankets, sleeping bags and, if need be, winter footwear.

Most widespread cold this century, Canada

(THIS CENTURY IS ONLY 21 YEARS OLD)

The Weather Network
Duration: 01:13

Look Closely, Bird's Breath Is Visible In The Frigid Calgary Air

Wood Buffalo council defies AHS, will stop sending EMS calls to provincial dispatchers

© Provided by Calgary Herald Mayor Don Scott sits with Regional Fire Chief Jody Butz 

during a press conference at the Jubilee Centre in Fort McMurray, Alta. On May 3, 2018.

Regional Municipality of Wood Buffalo council is defying Alberta Health Services and is no longer transferring local calls for EMS services to the province’s dispatch centre.

On Jan. 19, the dispatch system run by Alberta Health Services (AHS) replaced local EMS dispatchers for the Fort McMurray Wood Buffalo region, as well as Calgary, Red Deer and Lethbridge. The provincial system is based out of call centres in Calgary, Edmonton and Peace River.

Regional Municipality of Wood Buffalo Mayor Don Scott, who has opposed AHS’ centralization plan since it was announced in August, proposed the motion after fire chief Jody Butz argued the new system is flawed.

“We simply need to take a new approach and that is simply to refuse, and that’s exactly what this does,” said Scott. “This region has been getting the shaft over and over, and now they’re putting people’s health at risk.”

Butz told council that local emergency workers have seen an “obvious degredation of service” in more than 50 incidents, or one-in-four calls.

The LocalHERO medevac service, for instance, has been delayed for remote calls. In two cases, the Anzac Fire Department was not sent to local accidents. In one incident, the accident happened across the street from the homes of several firefighters. In both cases, an ambulance from Fort McMurray took between 30 and 40 minutes to arrive.

Councillor Mike Allen said he would support the motion “right to the bitter end.” Councillor Phil Meagher said it was “undoubtedly” the most important motion he’s supported and called the situation “silly.”

“Obviously they’re not using any part of their brain for this because it just makes common sense,” he said. “If the provincial government wants to write me off of city council they can, but we are certainly in defiance of this and rightfully so.”

Since the province announced that consolidation would be happening last August, Butz, Scott, all municipal councillors, the union representing local firefighters, and First Nation and Métis leaders have protested the provincial system. Council has also offered to pay for a local service.

CAO Jamie Doyle gave his support. He admitted the municipality has an obligation to transfer calls coming in, but said he also has a priority for residents’ health and safety.

“We’ve exhausted, up until now, every reasonable option we had to help show some data and further a conversation that puts the health and safety of our residents at the forefront and it’s gone unheeded,” he said.

Councillor Verna Murphy was concerned about potential lawsuits or legal consequences. Municipal lawyer Chris Davis said this is being researched. The 911 agreement with Telus does not involve AHS, he said. But the dispatch agreement that ended in January has transition requirements, including that the municipality cooperate with AHS.

“If this is the one issue where we need to stand our ground on, no matter the cost, then I’m prepared to do it,” argued Scott.

“It’s time to take a strong stand. We represent the citizens of this region, we have an obligation to protect their health, and let’s do it. Let’s support this motion and tell the province they need to do the same.”

Yao supports councils decision

Tany Yao, UCP MLA for Fort McMurray-Wood Buffalo, is supportive of council’s decision, but is worried about legal repercussions. He also fears this decision could impact funding agreements or requests.

“I admire my municipal colleagues and my former coworkers on this decision,” said Yao, who is a former firefighter and paramedic. “They didn’t receive satisfactory answers from Alberta Health Services and I need to support them.”

Yao also said he was frustrated after hearing about the incidents in Anzac.

“We expect these groups to be transparent and accountable as to what happened, and I never received any answer that gave me confidence,” he said. “It sounds like what I deemed to be a significant error and it happened twice to people outdoors in this weather.”

© Vincent McDermott/Postmedia Network Tany Yao, the MLA for Fort McMurray-Wood Buffalo.

Laila Goodridge, UCP MLA for Fort McMurray-Lac La Biche, and a spokesperson for Alberta Health Minister Tyler Shandro could not be reached for comment. In a Tuesday evening email, AHS spokesperson Kerry Williamson said AHS was aware of the motion’s outcome, but had not been given any formal notice from the municipality.

“AHS will do all it can to ensure patients are not put at risk,” he wrote in a brief email.

Darren Sandbeck, chief paramedic and senior provincial director of AHS EMS, said during a media conference last week that dispatch centralization has not caused any delays or negative outcomes. He said 911 calls are handled the same way they were before consolidation and no response plans have changed.

Sandbeck said the snowmobile accident was transferred from Wood Buffalo RCMP, who described it as an “unknown problem.” He said local firefighters would not have been called to that incident.

As for the incident with the tree, Sandbeck said it happened in a “remote, rural location.” He also insisted the cases would have been handled the same way under the old system.

-with reporting from Vincent McDermott

lbeamish@postmedia.com

WHAT, ONLY TWO
Two of Premier Kenney's caucus members join coalition fighting COVID-19 restrictions


EDMONTON — Two members of Alberta Premier Jason Kenney’s caucus are challenging the province's COVID-19 economic restrictions and have joined a national coalition pushing against lockdowns.

© Provided by The Canadian Press

Drew Barnes, the United Conservative legislature member for Cypress-Medicine Hat, and Angela Pitt, the deputy speaker of the house and chair of committees, say Albertans have not been given adequate evidence to justify the rules and real hardship and harm is resulting.

“Down here in Medicine Hat our mental health crisis is as big as our COVID crisis,” said Barnes in an interview Tuesday.

“Let’s give people more freedoms.”

He said the province should take a more regional approach to restrictions, as was done for a while last year.

There are few infections in his region, he said, and he’d like to see businesses allowed to open up more, with additional testing and with health restrictions to keep COVID-19 in check.

Barnes added he doesn't worry about challenging government policy in the UCP caucus.

“I’m not worried about disciplinary action,” he said. “As a government backbencher, I’m not a part of cabinet. I’m not part of the decision making. It’s my job to speak up with what my constituents want.”

Pitt, the member for Airdrie, said she has been trying for months to get information out of the government to determine what evidence and rationale there is for the restrictions.

She said she and her constituents don’t, for example, understand why restaurants were allowed to reopen this week to in-person dining while gym and fitness centres can't have group workouts.

“There’s a lot of confusion around some of the restrictions that have been put in place because of the lack of information sharing,” said Pitt in an interview.

“My constituents are having a hard time buying in, as are many Albertans across the province. And you see that in the ways of civil disobedience.

“Albertans aren’t buying into this because the case has not been made.”

Pitt and Barnes have signed on to the End the Lockdowns national caucus, part of a group called Liberty Coalition Canada.

The group includes past and present federal, provincial and municipal politicians, including Paul Hinman, the interim leader of the Wildrose Independence party, a right-wing rival to Kenney’s United Conservatives.

“After careful examination and scrutiny of mitigation measures undertaken by all levels of government, it is now evident that the lockdowns cause more harm than the virus and must be brought to an end,” writes the caucus on the Liberty website.

​Jerrica Goodwin, Kenney’s spokeswoman, responded in an email statement.

“MLAs are elected to represent their constituents, and are able to do so,” she said.

“Alberta's restrictions are based on expert medical advice.

“What's more, Alberta has resisted the total lockdowns of some other jurisdictions. For example, while some other provinces fully shut down non-essential retail, Alberta did not. And just yesterday, restaurants and bars were allowed to reopen, with specific requirements, as part of our phased, evidence-based plan.”

Kenney’s government has been getting squeezed from both sides of the lockdown debate as it works to keep the economy afloat and the pandemic in check.

Alberta's current economic restrictions have been in place since mid-December when surging COVID-19 case numbers put daily infections at 1,800 and those in hospital with the virus at 800.

The numbers have been dropping ever since. Daily case counts are well under 300. On Tuesday, there were 427 people in hospital with COVID-19.

The rules initially limited restaurants to take out only.

Retailers and faith-based services remain capped at 15 per cent capacity, and entertainment venues like museums and movie theatres are closed. Indoor gatherings are banned and outdoor get-togethers are capped at 10 people.

The government began reopening the economy this week after some restaurants opened illegally to in-person dining, arguing if they didn’t violate the rules they would have to close for good.

Also, GraceLife church, just west of Edmonton, had been hosting 300 congregants at Sunday services, calling the pandemic a deliberately overblown attempt to restrict personal liberties. The church's pastor was charged by RCMP on Monday with violating the Public Health Act.

KENNEY UCP WAGE THEFT

Bigger investment in wage top-up could have resulted in $400M GDP increase and 2,000 jobs, NDP says

© Alberta NDP

  NDP Leader Rachel Notley presented the findings of the analysis in Calgary on Tuesday, and said its modelling used the same fiscal multipliers as Prime Minister Stephen Harper's 2009 economic action plan.

An economic analysis released by the Alberta NDP suggests a more substantive investment in the federal wage top-up program could have led to a GDP increase worth hundreds of millions and created nearly 2,000 jobs.

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau announced last May that the provinces had agreed to collectively pitch in $1 billion to bolster $3 billion in federal funds that would boost the pay of essential workers.

While other provinces accessed all or half of the matching federal funds by September, Alberta was the sole exception, having accessed just $47 million of its $347-million allocation.

The NDP's recent analysis used a fiscal multiplier model that indicated an investment of $100.3 million in 2020 could have generated a sustained GDP increase of $401.3 million, and job growth of 1,706, by the fourth quarter of 2021.

Leader Rachel Notley presented the findings of the analysis in Calgary on Tuesday, and questioned why the UCP had not taken full advantage of the eligible funding for Alberta.

"Essential workers have been working on the front lines of this pandemic. They risk their health every single day," Notley said.

"The federal program is put in place to ensure that essential workers are properly compensated for the risk that they take to do their job … and for some reason, [Premier] Jason Kenney has been dragging his feet."
'300% return on our investment'

Alberta Finance Minister Travis Toews told a legislature committee in November that the province had received the $47 million in federal funding with no strings attached.

The remaining funds would have been cost-shared at a 3:1 ratio, and could be used to pay top-up wages to health-care workers, correctional officers, first responders and other essential workers on the front lines of the COVID-19 pandemic.

"This was good for workers, and it was a good deal for the provinces — for every one dollar they spent on topping up essential worker wages, the federal government paid another three dollars," Notley said Tuesday.

"From an economic perspective, in the most simplistic of terms, this is a 300 per cent rate of return on our investment."

In its analysis, the NDP stated that it used the same methodology as Prime Minister Stephen Harper's finance ministry when creating its 2009 economic action plan.

The $100.3-million investment in the federal top-up plan, the analysis said, would have directly increased Alberta wages and been used to stimulate the economy in the short- and medium-term.

Its stimulative effects would have included an increase in spending by households, or increased savings, that encourage a higher level of sustained economic output or investment, according to the analysis.

While Calgary economist Trevor Tombe told CBC News that he does not endorse fiscal multiplier methodology — expressing concern that it can sometimes be used to arrive at whatever effect one wants — he said the NDP used the model sensibly.

"A multiplier of 1.0 is not unreasonable to use within this class of economic impact analysis. So [the NDP's] numbers are sound," Tombe said.

"I have serious critiques with the method as a whole, but the NDP in this case appears to be using the tool the way that one should."
'Political game-playing'

The province's seeming reluctance to invest robustly in the program has also drawn the ire of unions across the province.

"Alberta is an outlier, a gross outlier, in regards to doing what's necessary to make sure that these low-paid, front-line workers get the so-called hero pay that they've been promised," Alberta Federation of Labour president Gil McGowan said in November.

Notley acknowledged Kenney has suggested the UCP would be providing an update about the wage top-up soon, but still reserved strong words for the party.

"This would have been money that we saw flowing into our economy almost immediately, and there would have been job creation," Notley said.

"I struggle to comprehend what the delay is, I'm left to wonder if maybe it really was about … political game-playing."

CBC News contacted the finance minister's office, seeking comment, but had not received a response prior to publication.