Wednesday, September 01, 2021

We’re breathing PFAS: Study finds harmful forever chemicals in indoor air


Peer-Reviewed Publication

GREEN SCIENCE POLICY INSTITUTE

KINGSTON, R.I.—The air we breathe in our homes, schools, and workplaces can be polluted with harmful PFAS chemicals, according to a study published today in Environmental Science & Technology Letters. A new measurement technique developed by the research team detected PFAS chemicals in the air of kindergarten classrooms, university offices and laboratories, and a home—some with levels as high as those measured at an outdoor clothing company and carpet stores selling PFAS-treated products. The results suggest indoor air is an underestimated and potentially important source of exposure to PFAS, particularly for children.

“Food and water are known to be major sources of PFAS exposure,” said Rainer Lohmann, senior author of the study and professor of oceanography at the University of Rhode Island. “Our study shows that indoor air, including dust, is another source of exposure to potentially harmful forever chemicals. In fact, for children in homes or schools with old PFAS-treated carpets, inhalation may be even more important than dust as an exposure pathway to volatile PFAS that eventually could biotransform to more persistent and harmful PFAS.”

Well-studied PFAS have been associated with a wide range of serious health harms, from cancer to infertility to immune system problems. All PFAS are either extremely persistent in the environment or break down into extremely persistent PFAS.

By affixing polyethylene sheet samplers to ceilings, the scientists measured volatile PFAS chemicals in the air of nine carpeted kindergarten classrooms, one home, and the storage room of an outdoor clothing store in California; as well as two laboratories, five offices, one classroom, one storage room, and one elevator at the University of Rhode Island; and two carpet stores, also in Rhode Island. PFAS were detected in the air of nearly every location.

Several kindergarten classrooms and rooms at the university had higher indoor air concentrations of PFAS than the storage room of the outdoor clothing store, which was full of jackets and gear treated with PFAS. The highest concentrations were found in the two carpet stores. “PFAS were formerly used as stain and water repellents in most carpets," according to the paper’s lead author Maya Morales-McDevitt. “Fortunately, major retailers including The Home Depot and Lowe’s now only sell PFAS-free carpets. We believe that slowly smaller retailers will do so as well.”

While families, schools, and workplaces can reduce indoor air levels of PFAS by replacing carpets, there are still many other products that can emit volatile PFAS into indoor air, including clothing, shoes, building products, and furnishings.

“As long as they continue to be used in products, we’ll all be eating, drinking, and breathing PFAS,” said Tom Bruton, a co-author and senior scientist at the Green Science Policy Institute. “We need to turn off the tap and stop all unnecessary uses of PFAS as soon as possible.”

 

Watercooler parts could be a source of organophosphate ester exposure


Peer-Reviewed Publication

AMERICAN CHEMICAL SOCIETY

Watercoolers have become a staple in homes, offices and schools, but their tanks and parts are made of materials that could release unwanted or potentially harmful compounds into drinking water. In a preliminary study, researchers in ACS’ Environmental Science & Technology Letters report that organophosphate esters (OPEs) were found in water dispensed from these systems, but they estimated that daily consumption would be far below the levels associated with health problems.

As drinking water from freestanding dispensers has become wildly popular, some concern has been raised about the quality of the water coming out of these systems. For example, OPEs have been found in various types of drinking water, including tap, well and bottled water, in some locations in the U.S., South Korea and China. These compounds are used widely worldwide, replacing harmful brominated flame retardants and as additives in plastics, and now researchers are finding that OPEs are also associated with poor health outcomes. Because these substances are applied to materials or used as additives, which are not strongly bonded to plastic polymers, they can easily contaminate dust or leach into water. So, Yali Shi, Guangshui Na and colleagues wanted to see if water dispensers could contribute to OPE exposure, estimating the amount someone would consume on a daily basis if they only drank water from these types of systems.

The researchers collected water from 53 water dispensers in office buildings in China, both from the storage tanks and dispensed through room temperature and hot water taps. They analyzed the samples for 22 OPEs and detected eight of them in the majority of samples, with tris(2-chloroisopropyl) phosphate (TCIPP) being the most abundant. The water dispensed from the hot and room temperature taps had higher amounts of these compounds than water held in the tanks. Upon closer inspection, the researchers found that the plastic dispenser and the tubing contained these compounds, and the tubing could accumulate OPEs from the air. Finally, the team calculated that if people drank water dispensed solely from these systems, their total daily exposure to TCIPP — a potential carcinogen and endocrine disruptor — was far less than is considered to cause harm to humans. The researchers say that while their study was small, it identifies a need for future research to examine whether silicone is the most suitable tubing material for watercoolers.

The authors acknowledge funding from the National Key R&D Program of China and the National Natural Science Foundation of China.

The paper’s abstract will be available on Sept. 1 at 8 a.m. Eastern time here: http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/acs.estlett.1c00592.

The American Chemical Society (ACS) is a nonprofit organization chartered by the U.S. Congress. ACS’ mission is to advance the broader chemistry enterprise and its practitioners for the benefit of Earth and all its people. The Society is a global leader in promoting excellence in science education and providing access to chemistry-related information and research through its multiple research solutions, peer-reviewed journals, scientific conferences, eBooks and weekly news periodical Chemical & Engineering News. ACS journals are among the most cited, most trusted and most read within the scientific literature; however, ACS itself does not conduct chemical research. As a leader in scientific information solutions, its CAS division partners with global innovators to accelerate breakthroughs by curating, connecting and analyzing the world’s scientific knowledge. ACS’ main offices are in Washington, D.C., and Columbus, Ohio.

To automatically receive news releases from the American Chemical Society, contact newsroom@acs.org.

Follow us: Twitter | Facebook | LinkedIn | Instagram

Exposure to persistent environmental toxins in everyday products may increase diabetes risk in Latina adolescents

Study by researchers from the Keck School of Medicine of USC finds link between “forever chemicals” and changes in glucose metabolism

Peer-Reviewed Publication

KECK SCHOOL OF MEDICINE OF USC

A new USC study finds that a class of environmental pollutants known as “forever chemicals” may increase the risk of type 2 diabetes in Latino girls. The pollutants, called per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS), are a group of man-made chemicals used across the United States in a wide range of industrial and consumer products, including cookware, stain repellant and pizza boxes.

“Because PFAS are in such widespread use and they don’t break down, they have made their way into the drinking water of roughly 200 million Americans,” said researcher Leda Chatzi, a professor of population and public health sciences at the Keck School of Medicine of USC and director of the new USC Center for Translational Research on Environmental Health. “This is the first study to measure their potential impact on glucose metabolism over time among adolescents and young adults.”

The study appears in Environmental Health Perspectives.

Researchers looked more than 310 Latino children between the ages of eight and 13 from SOLAR (Study of Latino Adolescents at Risk of Type 2 Diabetes). Each participant was tested for levels of certain PFAS at the start of the study and then followed for up to 12 years, with annual check-ups on how their bodies metabolized glucose. 

PFAS and glucose metabolism

Data from the study showed that, starting in late puberty, girls who had high levels in childhood of a PFAS called perfluorohexane sulfonate (PFHxS) tended to have poorer metabolism of glucose than girls who had low levels of PFHxS as children. The association between high levels of PFHxS and dysregulated glucose metabolism increased after puberty and persisted through 18 years of age. The researchers replicated their findings in a separate group of young adults from the Southern California Children’s Health Study, showing that this link may persist into adulthood.

The study found no consistent association between high levels of PFAS and dysregulated glucose metabolism in boys. 

“We saw the biggest changes in glucose metabolism in puberty, and there are lots of differences in puberty between boys and girls,” said Jesse Goodrich, a postdoctoral scholar at the Keck School of Medicine of USC and first author of the study. “One hypothesis is that PFAS may interact with sex hormones. We plan to follow up on this study by examining the biological mechanism behind the association of PFAS with type 2 diabetes.”

Young Latinos at higher risk of type 2 diabetes

Rates of diabetes in Latino children in the U.S. are five times higher than that of non-Hispanic whites; in Latino adults, the rate is 80% higher than that in non-Hispanic whites. Yet diet and lifestyle alone don’t account for the difference.

“Type 2 diabetes is potentially preventable, and one key area of focus should be environmental influences,” said Chatzi. “PFAS exposures are modifiable through individual behaviors, like avoiding non-stick cookware and plastic containers for food storage. But we are not just exposed in one place or one source - PFAS are everywhere. Government can play a major role in regulating the use of PFAS.”

Although certain PFAS chemicals are no longer manufactured in the United States, they are still produced internationally and can be imported into the U.S. in consumer goods such as carpet, leather and apparel, textiles, paper and packaging, coatings, rubber and plastics, according to the Environmental Protection Agency. A few weeks ago, the House passed the PFAS Action Act, which would require the Environmental Protection Agency to establish national drinking water standards for these so-called “forever chemicals.”

About the Study

In addition to Chatzi and Goodrich, other authors of the study include Brittney Baumert, Zhangua Chen, Frank Gilliland, Katerina Margetaki, Sarah Rock, Nikos Stratakis and David Conti from USC; Tanya Alderete from the University of Colorado Boulder; Kiros Berhane from Columbia University; Michael Goran from Children’s Hospital, Los Angeles; Xin Hu and Dean Jones from Emory University School of Medicine; Damaskini Valvi and Douglas Walker from Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai.

The study was supported by the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences (R01-ES029944, T32-ES013678, R00-ES027853, R00-ES027870, R21-ES029328, P30-ES023515, P01-CA196569, P30-ES007048, P30-CA014089, R01-ES030691, R01-ES030364, R21-ES028903, R21-ES029681).

About Keck School of Medicine

Founded in 1885, the Keck School of Medicine of USC is one of the nation’s leading medical institutions, known for innovative patient care, scientific discovery, education and community service. Medical and graduate students work closely with world-renowned faculty and receive hands-on training in one of the nation’s most diverse communities. They participate in cutting-edge research as they develop into tomorrow’s health leaders. With more than 900 resident physicians across 50 specialty and subspecialty programs, the Keck School is the largest educator of physicians practicing in Southern California.

Salinas Valley teens find green cleaning is worth the hype

High school students worked with UC Berkeley researchers to test whether switching to green cleaning reduces users’ exposure to harmful chemicals

Peer-Reviewed Publication

UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA - BERKELEY

Green cleaning 

IMAGE: IN A NEW STUDY, TEENAGERS FROM CALIFORNIA’S SALINAS VALLEY WORKED ALONGSIDE UC BERKELEY SCIENTISTS ON RESEARCH SHOWING THAT SWITCHING TO GREEN CLEANING PRODUCTS CAN REDUCE USERS’ EXPOSURE TO A VARIETY OF TOXIC CHEMICALS. THE HIGH SCHOOL TEAM ALSO CREATED A SERIES OF ANIMATED PUBLIC SERVICE ANNOUNCEMENTS, IN BOTH ENGLISH AND SPANISH, TO SHARE THE RESULTS WITH THEIR COMMUNITY. THIS IMAGE IS A SCREENSHOT FROM THEIR PSAS. view more 

CREDIT: LUCIR STUDY IMAGE

Berkeley — Jessica Cabrera knows the recipe for homemade window cleaner by heart — and is more than happy to share it.

“All you have to do is mix vinegar, water and dish soap, and there you have it,” Cabrera said.

Cabrera, who grew up in California’s Salinas Valley, just started her first year as an undergraduate student at the University of California, Berkeley. And while it may seem unusual for a new college student to have a passion for window cleaner, Cabrera has good reason for knowing the ins and outs of DIY cleaning products.

For the past three years, Cabrera has been part of a group of Salinas Valley teens working alongside UC Berkeley researchers to investigate whether housecleaning products expose their users to potentially harmful chemicals — and whether making the switch to cleaning products marketed as lower chemical, or “green,” can help reduce these exposures.

Cabrera is now a co-author of a peer-reviewed study, published Sept. 1 in the journal Environmental Health Perspectives, showing that making the switch to green cleaning products can reduce users’ exposure to up to 17 different carcinogenic and endocrine-disrupting chemicals, including chloroform and benzene.

“What I found the most interesting was that there was an 86% decrease in chloroform exposure after switching from conventional cleaning products to green cleaning products,” Cabrera said. “And it really put into perspective how cleaning products can serve as potential carcinogens and hormone disruptors. It's something that you don't really think about when you clean because you think cleaning is a good thing. And it is, but it also can have some detrimental effects to your health in the long term.”

Cabrera and her peers carried out the research as part of the Center for the Health Assessment of Mothers and Children of Salinas (CHAMACOS) Youth Council, a group of 10 to 15 high school students who gain hands-on experience in environmental health research by helping to design and carry out their own studies under the guidance of UC Berkeley public health experts.

Study lead author Kim Harley, associate director of the UC Berkeley Center for Environmental Research and Children’s Health (CERCH), said that the youth council was originally created to give teens a voice in the CHAMACOS study, a long-term investigation into the impact of pesticides and other chemical exposure on pregnant women and their children. However, she and her colleagues quickly realized the potential of teaching and engaging the youth in conducting rigorous public health research, empowering them to become the next generation of environmental health leaders in their community.

Earlier research projects tackled by the youth council include an investigation into endocrine-disrupting chemicals in makeup, shampoos and lotions, and a study looking at the presence of pesticides in teens’ homes.

According to Harley, the council’s interest in cleaning products grew out of conversations about the importance of housecleaning in Latinx culture, as well as the fact that 81% of professional housecleaners and janitors in California are Latinx.

“For the CHAMACOS study, we asked people how often they clean their homes, and 40% of our population said that they do substantial housecleaning every day — and by substantial, they mean things like mopping their floors or vacuuming every day,” Harley said. “So, the youth council really felt like this was an environmental justice issue that was affecting their Latino community and particularly Latina women in California.”

One of the youth council’s main missions is to share the results of their research with their community. Since the COVID-19 pandemic forced the cancellation of most in-person events, the council decided to work with the group Artists Ink to create a series of animated public service announcements in both English and Spanish to help spread awareness about how people can protect themselves from potentially harmful chemicals in cleaning products. The students have also presented their results to regulators at the California Safer Consumer Products program.

“I’ve always been passionate about making an impact on my community, and I think the youth council is great because it targets the future of the community — the youth,” said study co-author Stephanie Mayo-Burgos, a recent member of the council who is now starting her first year as an undergraduate at UC Santa Cruz. “It starts off by educating us and then helps us educate our community.”

Finding safer ways to shine

Cabrera remembers being a sophomore in high school, hungry and ready for lunch, when she first learned about the CHAMACOS Youth Council.

“My math teacher announced that there was a new research opportunity through CHAMACOS, and told us how the original mission of CHAMACOS was investigating the health impacts of pesticides among farmworkers and their children,” Cabrera said. “This hit home to me, because I come from a family of farmworkers. Both my grandfathers, my dad and even my mother all worked in the fields.”

Cabrera joined the youth council, and one of her first tasks, along with Mayo-Burgos, was to help choose the name and logo for the new project. They ended up deciding on LUCIR, which stands for Lifting Up Communities by Intervening with Research.

“LUCIR means ‘to shine,’ in Spanish, and we thought that name worked well because when you clean, you can make things look shiny and nice,” Cabrera said.

To conduct the study, the council worked closely with Harley and CERCH community science manager James Nolan to recruit 50 Latinas from their Salinas Valley community. Each woman was asked to spend 30 minutes cleaning her kitchen and bathroom using her normal cleaning products, and then repeat the process a week later using her choice of a selection of green cleaning products that the students had found at local stores.

While they cleaned, each woman wore a backpack outfitted with personal air monitoring equipment created by collaborators at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory. The backpacks, originally designed as hydration packs, had tubes that could collect samples of air near the women’s faces as they cleaned.  

“The backpacks were important because we wanted to know what people's actual exposure to the chemicals was,” Harley said. “The backpack can take little sips of air through tubes that sit on the shoulder, and we put the tubes close to the breathing zone of the mouth. We felt like this was a better way to gauge human exposure than just analyzing what was in the product because what we really care about is how much of these chemicals are going into the air that we are breathing in.”

The women’s measurements showed that the switch to green cleaning products decreased their  exposure to a variety of chemicals that may cause cancer, disrupt hormones in the body or act as reproductive toxins. However, the switch also increased the women’s exposure to some potentially harmful fragrance compounds.

Switching to green

While the study results showed that making the switch to green cleaning products can help reduce exposure to certain harmful chemicals, Mayo-Burgos points out that not everyone is in a position to change up their routines.

For one, it’s not always easy to identify which products are actually safer. Though a 2017 California law now requires that cleaning product manufacturers list their products on the label, there remains no standard definition for what products qualify as “green.” Concerned consumers can start by looking for the Safer Choice Label or consulting consumer databases, such as the Environmental Working Group Guide to Healthy Cleaning. However, not everyone has the time or money for to follow these guidelines.

“I would love to push people to get the green cleaning products, but I can tell that a lot of people in my community don't believe in them or don’t have the time to buy them online,” Mayo-Burgos said. “So, I feel like it's just as important to educate people about the amount of exposure that they experience and to teach them ways to reduce that exposure, like opening up windows, opening up doors and using a microfiber cloth that can clean surfaces without the need for cleaning products.”

Other ways to protect yourself while cleaning include wearing protective gear, like gloves and goggles, and not mixing products that could potentially react to form even more dangerous chemicals, Mayo-Burgos added.

Nolan said that this connection to the community is one of the reasons why the youth council is so important.

“The youth voice really brings this energy and creativity to the work, and they are also really approachable,” Nolan said. “One of our side missions has been to highlight other opportunities that they might not have thought about and think about ways that we can open as many doors as possible for them.”

Mayo-Burgos and Cabrera both said that they hope to pursue college degrees that will allow them to continue to help their community: Mayos-Burgos wants to major in environmental studies, while Cabrera would like to double major in public health and computer science.

“One of my long-term goals is to bring technological access back to my community because I believe that technology is also a major factor as to why people from my community aren’t always as informed as they can be,” Cabrera said. “My community really inspires me to want to continue learning and to bring what I learn back, so we can all benefit from it.”

Co-authors of the study also include Lucia Calderon and Asa Bradman of UC Berkeley, Randy Maddalena and Marion Russell of Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Katherine Roman of the CHAMACOS Youth Council, and Norma Morga of the Clinica de Salud del Valle de Salinas.

The LUCIR Study was funded by the California Breast Cancer Research Program. The CHAMACOS Youth Council has been supported by the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences and the California Breast Cancer Research Program.

After leaked videos, Iran opens cases against prison guards


In this undated frame grab taken from video shared with The Associated Press by a self-identified hacker group called "The Justice of Ali," a guard looks at surveillance screens taken over by the group, at Evin prison in Tehran, Iran. The alleged hackers said the release of the footage was an effort to show the grim conditions at the prison, known for holding political prisoners and those with ties abroad who are often used as bargaining chips in negotiations with the West. The caption on the screens reads in Farsi: "Cyberattack: Evin prison is a stain on (Iranian President Ebrahim) Raisi's black turban and white beard. General protest until the freedom of political prisoners." (The Justice of Ali via AP)

DUBAI, United Arab Emirates (AP) — Iranian prosecutors opened criminal cases against six guards at the country’s notorious Evin prison, the judiciary reported on Tuesday, after footage showing the widespread abuse of detainees at the facility leaked out last week.

The judiciary’s three-day investigation into mistreatment and grim conditions at Tehran’s Evin prison had landed “some” prison guards in detention, said judiciary spokesman Zabihollah Khodaeian. Authorities also summoned two guards and punished others, Khodaeian said, without elaborating on the penalties or identifying the suspects.

The revelation comes days after The Associated Press published parts of the videos and a report about the abuse at the facility in northern Tehran, long known for holding political prisoners and those with ties to the West whom Iran uses as bargaining chips in international negotiations. An online account, purportedly by a self-described hacker group, shared footage of the incident, as well as parts of other surveillance video it seized.


FILE - In this undated file frame grab taken from video shared with The Associated Press by a self-identified hacker group called "The Justice of Ali," guards drag an emaciated prisoner, at Evin prison in Tehran, Iran. Iranian prosecutors opened criminal cases against six guards at the country's notorious Evin prison, the judiciary reported on Tuesday, Aug. 31, 2021, after footage showing the widespread abuse of detainees at the facility leaked out last week. (The Justice of Ali via AP, File)


“The scenes shown in the published films were against the law and it is not justifiable under any circumstances,” said Khodaeian, noting that the leaked clips had been selected and edited from different scenes over the course of years.

In one part of the footage, a man smashes a bathroom mirror to try to cut open his arm. Prisoners — and even guards — beat each other in scenes captured by surveillance cameras. Inmates sleeping in single rooms with bunk beds stacked three high against the walls, wrapping themselves in blankets to stay warm.

Iran’s judiciary ordered an investigation into the abuse last week after the head of the country’s prison system acknowledged the videos were real, expressing contrition and saying he took responsibility for the “unacceptable behaviors.”

Since its construction in 1971 under Iran’s shah, the prison has seen a series of abuses that continued into the Islamic Republic.
Shocking report says air pollution is cutting years off the lives of billions of people

“Air pollution is the greatest external threat to human health on the planet,” said a researcher for the Air Quality Life Index.

By Jenna Romaine | Sept. 1, 2021
THE HILL


(Максим Шмаков/iStock)

Story at a glance

Researchers at the University of Chicago created the Air Quality Life Index, which calculates how the concentration of air pollutants impacts life expectancy.

According to the September 2021 data, air pollution takes 2.2 years off the average global citizen’s life.

Addressing air pollution can reverse the effects and add years back onto the lives of citizens.


A new report has found that air pollution is cutting years off the lives of billions of people.

Researchers at the University of Chicago created the Air Quality Life Index (AQLI), which calculates how the concentration of air pollutants impacts life expectancy.

According to the September 2021 data, air pollution takes 2.2 years off the average global citizen’s life.

“Air pollution is the greatest external threat to human health on the planet, and that is not widely recognized, or not recognized with the force and vigor that one might expect,” Michael Greenstone, one of the researchers who developed the index, told The Guardian.

But the impact is far more detrimental in areas suffering the worst pollution.

In India, where the air pollutant particulate matter concentration is seven times higher than the World Health Organization’s guideline, the average Indian life expectancy is cut by 5.9 years. In some areas of the country, such as in Uttar Pradesh where pollution is even higher, life expectancy is shortened up to 11.1 years.

However, addressing air pollution can reverse the effects and add years back onto the lives of citizens.

In China, a “war against pollution” was launched in 2013. Since then, its particulate pollution has been reduced 29 percent and added an average of 1.5 years back onto the population’s lives.

“Fossil-fuel driven air pollution is a global problem that requires strong policies at every front—including from the world climate negotiators who are meeting in the coming months,” said Ken Lee, director of the AQLI. “The AQLI’s latest data provides leaders and citizens alike with the justification for strong clean air policies in the form of longer lives.”
AN INVASIVE PROCEDURE

NI school installs CCTV cameras in pupil toilets

A grammar school in Northern Ireland has confirmed to the News Letter it did not consult with parents before deciding to install CCTV cameras in pupil toilets.

By Andrew Quinn
Wednesday, 1st September 2021
Belfast Royal Academy.

Belfast Royal Academy insists the CCTV cameras have not yet been activated and said any decision to do so would be taken after consultation with "the wider school community".

Belfast Royal Academy did not inform parents of any policy change in the use of CCTV cameras until after it was contacted by the News Letter on Tuesday afternoon.

"It was decided that it would be prudent to install the technical infrastructure needed to allow the school to extend the coverage of the CCTV system to areas where we have had isolated incidents in the past, including the main pupil toilet facilities," said school principal Mrs. Hilary Woods.

"Installation of the underlying technical infrastructure has now been completed, but it has not been commissioned and it has not been activated.

"The school currently has no plans to activate the infrastructure in the main toilet facilities and it has only been installed on a precautionary basis," added Mrs. Woods.

Principal Woods explained the decision to install CCTV in the main pupil toilets was taken after a review and an upgrade to the school CCTV system over the summer.

"We have had a CCTV system in Belfast Royal Academy for more than five years," said Mrs. Woods.

"The system helps us to protect school property and provide a safe and secure environment for pupils, parents, staff, and visitors

"Over the course of the summer and in line with good maintenance practice, we took the opportunity to upgrade the system and review the number and positioning of individual cameras."

Mrs. Woods continued: "In addition, it is important for pupils, parents, staff, and visitors to note that if a decision was taken by the school at some point in the future to activate the new infrastructure and make the cameras in the toilets operational, then this decision would only be taken after appropriate consultation with the wider school community and in line with all relevant guidance and legislation, including the Data Protection Act 2018 and the General Data Protection Regulation 2016.

"An impact assessment of the proposed use of the CCTV cameras would be undertaken by the school at that time and all stakeholders would be notified of the potential activation of the cameras.

"Our updated policy on the use of CCTV cameras will be available on our School website following ratification by the Board of Governors."
ETHIOPIA
NEWS: USAID BLAMES ALL WARRING PARTIES FOR FOOD AID THEFT
addisstandard / September 1, 2021 / 1k

Sean Johnes, the USAID mission Director to Ethiopia. Photo: Screengrab


BY BILEH JELAN @BILEHJELAN

Addis Abeba, September 01/2021 – In an interview with Ethiopian Broadcasting Corporation (EBC) that was aired yesterday, Sean Jones, the USAID mission Director to Ethiopia, accused forces loyal to the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF) of looting food aid and causing intentional damage to its warehouses in Amhara regional state. He also blamed Ethiopian federal forces aligned with Eritrean forces of engaging in “in a lot of theft.”

“We now know, because again new facts have arisen, that in recent weeks some of our warehouses have been looted and emptied by advancing TPLF troops, especially in Amhara right now,” the director said.

But, in a segment that was edited out by the state broadcaster EBC and has since been released by the US Embassy in Addis Abeba, Mr. Jones first highlighted that “throughout nine months of conflict all of the warning parties have been stealing aid. Months ago, when the federal forces aligned with Eritrean forces were in Tigray, there was a lot of theft that was going on, that was occurring.”


The director answered questions on reasons behind the U.S.government issuing a statement denouncing accusations of collusion with TPLF levied against USAID. He said, “The United States government was very concerned about the recent misrepresentation and inaccurate reporting across some of the state run media about the USAID assistance in the country,”

He further explained that explanations were necessary before denying the involvement of USAID with TPLF and forces loyal to it. He said, “In no history of our humanitarian assistance in Ethiopia has the USAID ever given food, drugs or any other kind of assistance to TPLF or any other groups in the country.”


“IN ARMED CONFLICT, THERE ARE WAYS WHERE ARMED GROUPS GET FOOD AND NON FOOD ITEMS FROM HUMANITARIAN ACTORS.”
SEAN JONES

The director explained circumstances where the food aid delivered to Tigray regions might have fallen into the hands of TPLF. But defended his organization against government accusations that it was complicit in it. “In armed conflict, there are ways where armed groups get food and non food items from humanitarian actors,” he said, “we know that we haven’t delivered any high energy biscuits since February.”

He went on to add that in conflict zones, there were three possible ways where food aid could fall into the hands of armed groups. The first is “food is sold to soldiers. Maybe even to other citizens”, he mentioned common occurrences in Ethiopia where “everybody who travels around the country in Ethiopia, going to rural and even in the urban local markets, you see a lot of humanitarian supplies that are actually being sold.” Another way in which food aid ends up in the hands of armed groups is “some citizens are sympathetic to, in this case, the TPLF. Maybe they gave their food to the soldiers.” The third, which he described as “the worst thing that could happen,” is when “soldiers and armed groups come in and they steal that food, or non-food, from citizens.”


“WE KNOW FOR FACT, MUCH LIKE THE ERITREANS WERE DOING MONTHS AGO IN TIGRAY, IN AMHARA NOW, WE NOW KNOW THAT THE TPLF HAS, IN EVERY TOWN THEY’VE GONE INTO, THEY LOOTED THE WAREHOUSES ...”SEAN JONES

Regardless, he accused the TPLF of looting USAID warehouses. “We know for fact, much like the Eritreans were doing months ago in Tigray, in Amhara now, we now know that the TPLF has, in every town they’ve gone into, they looted the warehouses, they’ve looted trucks and they have caused a great deal of destruction in all the villages they have visited.”

He further accused the TPLF of being “opportunistic,” and that “maybe they are stealing from citizens”, but said the USAID doesn’t “have a proof for this but what we know is that a couple of warehouses were emptied especially in the Amhara region.”

His criticism didn’t spare the Ethiopian National Defense Forces (ENDF) where are aligned with Eritrean Forces. According to him, both have been engaged in theft of of food aid in Tigray. “To be honest throughout nine months of conflict all of the warning parties have been stealing aid. Months ago, when the federal forces aligned with Eritrean forces were in Tigray, there was a lot of theft that was going on, that was occurring.”

Such acts were causing “great concern for humanitarians”, he said. Humanitarians have fled for their lives. “Humanitarians are the ones at the center of the conflict. They are the first ones to go in and provide life-saving assistance, and only when their lives are threatened or when the things are stolen or when their building are looted or burned down are they the ones to leave. And unfortunately, we have also seen quite a few, I think it is fifteen now of our humanitarian brothers and sisters have lost their lives, in the past nine month of conflict.”


“WE ARE ALSO A BIG CONTRIBUTOR TO THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT’S PRODUCTIVE SOCIAL SAFETY NET PROGRAM, WE SUPPORT 1.6 MILLION PEOPLE WHO WANT TO ESCAPE POVERTY. IN ACTION WE PROVIDE FOOD AID TO 5 MILLION PEOPLE IN NORTHERN ETHIOPIA AS OF NOW IN TIGRAY, AMHARA AND AFAR.” SEAN JONES

Highlighting USAID efforts to provide assistance to 7% of the population in Ethiopia, the mission director said, “In the past five years, we have invested 4.2 billion USD, some of it humanitarian assistance but a lot of it development assistance.” He explained that UAID operations expand across all regional states.


Moreover, the mission director highlighted current operations outside Tigray region, he said, “We are providing emergency aid to 3.5 million people in places like Benishengul Gumuz, Oromia, Somali and SNNP regions, where people are still struggling with conflict, drought, desert locust, floods and whatever it might be,” he added, “We are also a big contributor to the federal governor,ent Productive Social Safety Net program, we support 1.6 million people who want to escape poverty. In action we provide food aid to 5 million people in northern Ethiopia as of now in Tigray, Amhara and Afar.”


“AS A PARTNER SOMETIMES WE HAVE TO RAISE OUR VOICE ‘LIKE IN A GOOD MARRIAGE’, WE HAVE TO SAY WHAT WE ARE FEELING AT MOMENT, WE HAVE TO PROVIDE OUR ADVICE AND MAYBE WE SEE DECISION MADE ON THE PART OF OUR PARTNER THAT MIGHT BE IN ETHIOPIA’S BEST INTEREST.”

SEAN JONES

Speaking on the Ethio-US relations, the mission director said, “I think there is some strain or some stress in the relations right now,” he added, “As a partner sometimes we have to raise our voice ‘like in a good marriage’, we have to say what we are feeling at moment, we have to provide our advice and maybe we see decision made on the part of our partner that might be in Ethiopia’s best interest.” The mission director added that the relations with senior Ethiopian officials remain intact.

The director reiterated calls by the USAID chief to end hostilities and ensure the continuance of the aid operation to avoid catastrophic outcomes as result of food shortages. His interview came a week after Ethiopia and the US exchanged blame over the failure of the humanitarian operation in Tigray. AS

Editor’s Note: The headline and parts of this news was edited after the release of the full transcript of the interview by the US Embassy in Addis Abeba, which included parts omitted by he State broadcaster, EBC.

CRIMINAL CAPITALI$M THE GAAP

UK
FRC issues formal KPMG complaint over false information allegations

The targets of the complaint, which comes under the accountancy scheme, also include a former KPMG partner, as well as current and former KPMG employees


Harry Deacon 




The Financial Reporting Council (FRC) has issued a formal complaint against KPMG over allegedly false and/or misleading information provided in the audit quality inspections of Carillion and Regenersis.


The targets of the complaint, which comes under the accountancy scheme, also include a former KPMG partner, as well as current and former KPMG employees.

It comes in relation to the provision of supposed false and misleading documents to the FRC for both Carllion’s audit for the period ended 31 December 2016, and Regenersis’ for the period ended 30 June 2014.


First opened in November 2018, the watchdog’s Carillion audit investigation was expanded in July 2019 to include the Big Four firm’s Regenersis audit.

Following the formal complaint, a disciplinary tribunal has been scheduled to commence on 10 January 2022 to determine “whether or not the respondents have committed misconduct”.

The individuals included in the allegations are Peter Meehan, KPMG’s engagement partner for the Carillon audit, and Stuart Smith, who held the same role in the Regenersis audit.

The FRC said that these individual allegations are made “only in respect of their own conduct”, meaning that it will not suggest any misconduct of any other individual.

A spokesperson for KPMG UK told the Financial Times: “We take this matter extremely seriously. We discovered the alleged issues in 2018 and 2019, and on both occasions immediately reported them to the FRC and suspended the small number of people involved.

“The allegations in the formal complaint would, if proven, represent very serious breaches of our processes and values. We have cooperated fully with our regulator throughout their investigation.”

Accountancy Today has contacted KPMG for further comment.

 MESSED UP THINGS THAT HAPPENED DURING THE WAR IN AFGHANISTAN


The War in Afghanistan began in 2001 following the September 11 attacks as part of the United States' War on Terror. The US invaded hard, hitting with a heavy hand. As war typically goes, many people died. US soldiers, Afghan forces, the Taliban, and allied forces all took part in the war effort from two sides. No one seemed to be safe in the area. Targets one wouldn't expect to be attacked were attacked. Civilians died in numbers no one wants to read. Alleged war crimes and crimes against humanity set the tone from the beginning of the war to the present day.

The whole affair is a sad story for everyone involved. Accounts of messed up things are plentiful in the region, and the conflict's history is dotted with corruption and painted with long strokes of administrative dysfunction in ways that might make you think about the War in Afghanistan in a different light.

CIA-TRAINED AFGHAN TROOPS WERE RESPONSIBLE FOR CIVILIAN DEATHS

The United States Central Intelligence Agency has a track record of training foreign troops aligned with US interests. They did so with Bolivian soldiers who were fighting against Cuban insurgents in the '60s, leading to Che Guevara's death, for example. In more recent history, the CIA trained Afghan special forces who were fighting against the Taliban and other organizations alongside the US. According to an NBC breakdown of a report conducted by Human Rights Watch, these troops don't always operate within the laws of war.

The breakdown details an instance when these Afghan special forces broke into a private residence and executed four brothers while claiming to be hunting Islamic State militants. One of the brothers was a schoolteacher, and another worked as an assistant for Afghanistan's parliament. On a different occasion, these forces pulled a similar move that resulted in the unwarranted execution of four people who were visiting home for the holidays. Still another time, they killed two construction workers and a religious teacher.

The report referenced claims that CIA-trained Afghan troops have been running up the numbers of civilian casualties and perpetuating the old CIA trope of making people disappear without a trace. In case you didn't know, these acts outright violate international humanitarian law and are considered war crimes.

PRESIDENT TRUMP PARDONED TROOPS WHO WERE BEING PROSECUTED FOR WAR CRIMES

Sticking with the troops takes on a whole new meaning if they've been accused of war crimes and even more so if they've been convicted. It's not really something anyone in their right mind would support, but US president Donald Trump did it, anyway. And he's done it on more than one occasion

President Trump pardoned two people in November 2019. One was a former Green Beret, Major Mathew Golsteyn, who was awaiting trial after being accused of killing an Afghan bomb-maker. For those who don't know, you aren't supposed to kill people who aren't actively violent at the time you're arresting them. The other person pardoned was Lieutenant Clint Lorance. Lorance wasn't just accused of a crime — he was actually convicted. In 2012, Lorance ordered his men to open fire at three Afghan citizens, two of whom were killed, all of whom were unarmed. This, in official military talk, is a "big no-no.

To add insult to questionability, President Trump ordered that a convicted former Navy SEAL, Special Warfare Operator 1st Class Edward Gallagher, be given a promotion, according to The Guardian. This officer had been found guilty of posing with a dead captive for a disgustingly immoral glamour shot and had his rank officially downgraded. The promotion reinstated his former rank.

THE TALIBAN KILLED THREE CIVILIANS TWO DAYS AFTER AGREEING TO A PARTIAL TRUCE WITH THE US

Early in 2020, the United States and the Taliban had agreed to a partial truce that was meant to encourage peace talks between the Afghan government and the insurgents. The truce included a temporary "reduction in violence" that was supposed to last for seven days, thrown in for free by the Taliban as a sign of good faith. That's not very long, but something is better than nothing. On the United States' side of the agreement, US forces were to begin pulling out of Afghanistan, completing their withdrawal within 14 months. All of this happened on Saturday, February 29. The reduction in violence didn't make it through Monday.

The Taliban announced that the truce was over two days after it had been signed because the United States had basically put words in the Afghan government's mouth. The US had offered the release of 5,000 prisoners who weren't theirs to offer before the official negotiations were set to begin. According to The Guardian, the Afghan government made a public statement saying they'd never agreed to such a thing. The Taliban responded by setting off a motorcycle bomb at a soccer game that killed three people and injured 11.



THE ARREST OF AHMED KHAN

The arrest of Ahmed Khan was a real "shoot first, ask questions later" situation, something you're not supposed to do during an arrest. Especially with helicopters. Helicopters that are firing machine guns. But, according to Human Rights Watch, that's exactly how eyewitnesses say the situation played out.

One night in July 2002, Ahmed Khan and his family were in bed for the night, though the family says they weren't asleep when the "arrest" took place. It was a calm night, and all was quiet in the house until bullets began to spray through the walls. The Khan family pressed themselves against the floor and, one can presume, hoped not to be killed. The gunfire put holes in the walls and shattered the windows. When the shooting finally stopped, US forces arrested Ahmed Khan and his two sons.

The aftermath left the house fairly wrecked, with bullet casings littering the yard. No one in the family was killed in the attack, but there was one casualty and one injury, neither of which were people within the house. A farmer in a nearby field who was sleeping next to his harvest was killed, and a woman suffered non-serious bullet wound. Since the Khan family was later released, the charges probably didn't warrant a full-frontal assault.


THE OBAMA ADMINISTRATION LOOKED THE OTHER WAY ON CORRUPTION

Corruption seems to be a major theme in the War in Afghanistan. The United States funneled ridiculous amounts of cash, billions of dollars, into Afghanistan to support the war effort during the Obama administration, and all the while, they promised the public that they'd be cracking down on the corruption that infected the country. According to The Washington Post, this wasn't the case. They argue that the US did the exact opposite and looked the other way while thieves were thieving, drug dealers were running narcotics, and warlords were participating in illegal activities. Why? Well, they were on the United States' side of course, and confronting the corruption could have alienated allies during wartime.

WaPo claims the United States funneled cash in to directly pay warlords and government officials for both loyalty and information. Human Rights Watch states that corrupt officials directly influenced the conduct of US forces, citing numerous complaints of US troops being fed false information that caused them to be unknowing participants in local rivalries. They go on to say the United States' presence was unwittingly leveraged for extortion of funds from local populations. Other forms of corruption common in the area included young boys being abused and enslaved by Afghan officials, according to NPR.


THE CIA ILLEGALLY HELD PEOPLE IN SECRET PRISONS

When we think of the covert ops, the spies, and the espionage that go hand in hand with the CIA's dramatic renderings in the cinematic realms of Hollywood, it makes accepting the real-life actions of the intelligence agency seem a little less outlandish. There's a problem, though. Where movie CIA may get away with illegal actions, the world of the true-true isn't so approving when real citizens go missing or when human rights are violated. The CIA's illegal prisons during the War in Afghanistan fall into that mess.

According to Reuters, the CIA hosted illegal prisons in various countries — some in Lithuania, others in Romania, and one in Poland. Both Lithuania and Romania made great choices for any prison that may have wanted to break international human rights law, since both countries were already at odds with the European Human Rights Convention (EHRC). That's the thing that says European countries can't torture prisoners or engage in otherwise crappy behavior that would be cruel to use against human beings. The European Court of Human Rights declared that two prisons, one in Lithuania and one in Romania, had broken the EHRC, which means they had to have committed some sort of abhorrent atrocities against prisoners. Both prisons have been closed since the mid-2000s.

RUSSIA MAY HAVE PUT OUT BOUNTIES ON US TROOPS

It's possible that Russia may have put bounties out on United States soldiers in Afghanistan, though there seem to be two sides to this argument, depending on what source you look at. The news came to light after President Donald Trump announced earlier this year that he'd be pulling troops out of the country by 2021, which, in itself, might be problematic for entirely unrelated reasons.

According to The New York Times, one middleman for the bounty scheme had been arrested following an investigation by US intelligence agencies. The man, Rahmatullah Azizi, established a relationship with Russian intelligence and was somehow making it rich. They go on to say that Azizi was bringing in money from Russia and relaying it to the Taliban and their allied forces when they took down American soldiers. When his home was raided, roughly $500,000 was found within.

Not all of the US intelligence agencies are in agreement about this. MSN says the NSA isn't nearly as confident that the evidence can reasonably confirm any scheme involving bounties, but this sort of disagreement is common for the National Security Agency, which has always been more conservative than other agencies with their assessments. They insist, instead, that there is some evidence to support the claim, while other evidence could be used to refute it.

US-PAID PRIVATE CONTRACTORS

Private security contractors are civilian companies who pick up government contracts to assist war efforts in noncombatant roles. That means they're not actually allowed to fight. These companies take standard security contracts for private clients as well, but their government contracts usually have them working as prison guards, escorts, or in other support roles. An assumption that follows the use of private contractors is that they're cheaper and more efficient at these jobs, allowing the military to focus their efforts on more militant things like war. Global Policy Forum claims there's no hard evidence to support that assumption.

Since the War on Terror brought the United States to the Middle East in 2001, the country has relied heavily on civilian contractors in Afghanistan and other parts of the region. There have been times where more than 50 percent of the Department of Defense's forces were made up of these contractors.

Some of these companies have been caught committing war crimes, but since they're a nongovernment entity, they're entitled to prosecution in the United States as civilians while being immune to courts that would normally try military personnel. For instance, a former Blackwater employee was charged with shooting over a dozen unarmed civilians in Iraq. Questions about the effectiveness of current legal oversight for contractors have been raised.

THE TALIBAN'S ATTACKS HAVE CREATED MASSIVE CIVILIAN CASUALTIES

Insurgent war tactics aren't the same as what you'd see from a well-backed and large government army. They don't usually have the same resources, support, or status that functioning nations have, so they resort to tactics that can be played out with less artillery and fewer troops. These tactics are often guerrilla in nature and involve aspects of terrorism as a way for the smaller force to get their point across, and a lot of civilians usually get hurt in the process. The Taliban and their allied forces fall under this category.

The Taliban have been known to attack government facilities, and most of their civilian casualties happen on accident. If they relied on attacking civilians, they'd never have a shot at gaining popular power in the region, which is something needed for a successful long-term regime change. They don't have the manpower to attack facilities outright, so they often rely on techniques such as bombing to get the job done. Per the BBC, while attacking an intelligence agency in 2019, their bomb ended up destroying a hospital. That same year, as reported by Amnesty International, they bombed the Afghan Ministry of Defense. The explosion killed three people and injured over 90 others, many of whom were children in the schools close by. These indiscriminate attacks show either a dangerous lack of foresight or a serious disregard for civilian lives.

US AIR STRIKES KILLED HUNDREDS OF CIVILIANS

Civilian casualties are a disgusting element of a tragic tradition that already costs the world plenty of human lives: war. It's the sort of thing you'd expect a species to have risen beyond by the time they've made the leap into space or harnessed the power of the Sun to microwave burritos, but humans haven't. In the War in Afghanistan, the number of civilians killed has been particularly high, and part of that is due to air strikes deployed by the United States and its allies.

According to the AFP, US-led air strikes cost the lives of 680 people in 2008 alone. Meanwhile, Afghan forces added a civilian death toll of 520. That's for one year. Each incident adds more bodies to the count. An airstrike against drug labs cost at least 60 civilian lives in 2019. At the start of the war, three towns were bombed, killing at least 70 people. Bombs are difficult weapons to control, and jets don't exactly have pinpoint accuracy, so it's easy to see why the range extends from the beginning of the war to today. The Taliban and their allies have plenty of civilian casualties of their own, but they don't have the funding to be conducting many air strikes.


MORE THAN ONE WEDDING WAS ATTACKED

It may sound a little absurd, but we're pretty sure the War on Terror would win an award for most weddings attacked if, you know, that sort of award existed. (It doesn't. We checked.) The total number of weddings bombed by the US in the War on Terror comes to a ripe eight, with around 300 civilian casualties, according to The Nation. That's 300 people in their finest clothes, planning a night of merriment and festivities and having it all cut short to fulfill the bloodlust of the god of war.

One of the bombings occurred in Yemen while the US was targeting Al-Qaeda in the area. It killed dozens. Another occurred in Iraq. The other six happened during the War in Afghanistan. A wedding bombed by US forces in 2008 killed 47 Afghans, all of whom were civilians. These incidents aren't just at the hands of the US, either. The Taliban and their allied forces are to blame for other wedding attacks. For instance, the Islamic State bombed a wedding in 2019 via suicide attack, killing 63 people and injuring at least another 180. In Afghanistan, it seems that no target is too wholesome to be safe from the carnage of war.


THE US THREATENED TO SANCTION INVESTIGATORS FOR LOOKING INTO POTENTIAL WAR CRIMES

When you're accused of a crime, the last thing you want to do is threaten your accuser. Well, not if you want to look innocent, anyway. It's not going to help your image. But when you have the military might and economic pull that a country like, say, the United States has, it occasionally works out.

In June 2020, just a month before this article was written, the US did just that. It was announced by the International Criminal Court that they'd begin looking into complaints about American soldiers and the CIA committing war crimes in Afghanistan. They'd also investigate the Afghan government and the Taliban. It was an all-around investigation, since all sides had claims of alleged war crimes and crimes against humanity. 

That happened sometime in March. Back to June. President Donald Trump decided he'll prove the country's innocence of these alleged claims of torture, murder, illegal imprisonment, and targeting civilians in the most logical way he could think of: imposing travel restrictions and economic penalties on ICC investigators. US officials claimed they did so because America handles its own business, according to The New York Times. The ICC, on the other hand, thought the move was an unnecessary escalation. To be fair, the United States never signed onto the ICC, so they don't technically have jurisdiction here, but we've cooperated with them in the past.

Read More: https://www.grunge.com/227158/messed-up-things-that-happened-during-the-war-in-afghanistan/?utm_campaign=clip