Tuesday, March 24, 2020

In a leaked memo, Hobby Lobby refuses to give workers paid sick leave during the coronavirus pandemic
Bethany Biron Mar 23, 2020,
Justin Sullivan/Getty Images

In a memo to Hobby Lobby store managers obtained by Business Insider, the company's vice president of operations wrote that sick workers would be required to use personal paid time off and vacation pay or take an "unpaid leave of absence until further notice." 

In the case of a mandated store closure, Hobby Lobby will offer emergency pay only after paid time off and vacation days have been depleted, and then offer 75% of the regular rate of pay based on an average of shifts from the previous six weeks.

"The district manager has said that our stores will remain open until the National Guard comes in and physically shuts the buildings down," a Hobby Lobby manager told Business Insider. 


Hobby Lobby is not only fighting to keep stores open as the coronavirus spreads across the US but also refusing to give its employees immediate paid sick leave if they become ill.

In a memo sent to store managers on March 23 that was obtained by Business Insider, Randy Betts, Hobby Lobby's vice president of store operations, wrote that the company "is going to make every effort to continue working the employees." In cases of illness, Betts wrote that sick workers would be required to use personal paid time off and vacation pay or take an "unpaid leave of absence until further notice."

"Employees on unpaid leave are encouraged to contact their local unemployment offices to determine whether they are eligible for unemployment benefits," Betts wrote in the memo.

According to the memo, if a store is required to close because of a state or federal mandate, employees will first be required to use "all available paid time off benefits." After those resources are depleted, workers will be eligible for "emergency pay" that is 75% of their regular rate of pay, and the payments will be made not based on scheduled shifts, but rather "on the average hours during the previous six weeks."

A Hobby Lobby district manager, who spoke on condition of anonymity to protect his job and whose employment status was confirmed by Business Insider, wrote in an email that he felt "very anxious about this whole situation."


"Our management has doubled down on the work stance, and the district manager has said that our stores will remain open until the National Guard comes in and physically shuts the buildings down," the employee wrote.

Hobby Lobby did not respond to Business Insider's request for comment on the memo. Additionally, when Business Insider called the number for the Hobby Lobby human-resources department listed in the memo as a contact for employees, an automated message said it was "experiencing abnormally large call volumes at this time" before the call went to voicemail.

Hobby Lobby drew widespread condemnation on Sunday because of a widely circulated tweet said to include a photo of a letter sent to store employees from Hobby Lobby's founder, David Green. Business Insider has not been able to verify its authenticity.

The letter in the photo said Green's wife, Barbara, received a message from God that informed his decision to leave stores open.

"In her quiet prayer time this past week, the Lord put on Barbara's heart three profound words to remind us that He's in control. Guide, Guard, and Groom," the letter said. "We serve a God who will Guide us through this storm, who will Guard us as we travel to places never seen before, and who, as a result of this experience, will Groom us to be better than we could have ever thought possible before now."


The letter said employees could "rest in knowing that God is in control" and that Hobby Lobby may have to "tighten our belts" moving forward.
Read the full memo to Hobby Lobby managers below:

To: All Store Managers

From: Randy Betts

Ref: Employee Leave Due to Covid-19

Date: March 23, 2020


Our job has always involved taking care of our people. With the COVID-19 situation evolving very second, we need to take time to review how our current Leave Policies, PPTO benefits or Vacation will help take care of our employees during this time. In addition, the company has outlined additional provisions that we will refer to as Emergency Pay.

This memo outlines the Company's policy, effective March 23, 2020, relating to employees placed on leave because of COVID-19-related reasons. This policy remains effective until further notice.

Store Closing

Once a store is closed to the public by order of federal, state, or local authorities, the Company is going to make every effort to continue working the employees, if the employee is allowed to travel to/from work. If it is necessary for the Company to place employees on leave because the store is subject to mandatory closing, after exhausting all available paid time-off benefits (e.g., Vacation Pay, Personal Time Off, Personal/Sick Pay), will be eligible for emergency pay continuation.

Emergency Pay will be made available for all full-time and part-time employees placed on leave because the store is subject to a mandatory closing. These employees will receive 75% of their regular rate of pay for two weeks following the exhaustion of all available paid time off benefits. The rate of pay for all part-time and full-time employees will be based on the average hours during the previous six weeks. The use of paid time-off benefits in conjunction with the emergency pay continuation provided by this policy must be used in 8-hour increments.


Employees unable to work due to specific related reasons to the Covid-19 event

Below is a brief outline of when to request PPTO or Vacation to use for continued pay, we have an unpaid leave of absence we can offer as well. These options can be used when the employee has a positive test result for Covid-19, suspected illness to Covid-19 and/or other approved personal reasons to request leave under our current polices [sic].
Use Personal Paid Time Off (PPTO)
Use Vacation Pay; or
Unpaid leave of absence until further notice.

Employees on unpaid leave are encouraged to contact their local unemployment offices to determine whether they are eligible for unemployment benefits.

This program does not modify or impact the Company's existing paid-time off policies. This is in addition to those policies. Pay continuation under this program is not an earned wage under any applicable law and will not be used for purposes of calculating overtime. Any unused pay continuation under this program will expire immediately upon the Company's termination of the program. Employees will not be paid for an unused pay continuation under this program on termination. Employees do not accrue or earn any vested benefit under this Program.


Management will be provided with guidance to determine whether to direct employees to contact Human Resources to request time off, a leave of absence, or an accommodation related to COVID-19. Management is still required to promptly report all COVID-19-related incidents and potential exposures to Human Resources at (405) 745-1515. Specifically, contact Human Resources in the following circumstances:
If an employee or customer reports that he/she has been diagnosed with COVID-19;
If an employee reports a member of his/her household has been diagnosed with or may have been exposed to COVID-19;
If an employee reports he/she or a member of his/her household recently had cruise travel or traveled to an area with widespread sustained (ongoing) transmission of COVID-19, which currently includes China, Iran, South Korea, Italy, Austria, Belgium, Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, Green, Hungary, Iceland, Latvia, Liechtenstein, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Malta, Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Monaco, San Marino, Vatican City, England, Scotland, Wales, Northern Ireland, and Republic of Ireland;
If an employee has or reports that he/she has symptoms consistent with COVID-19, which CDC advises are fever, cough, and shortness of breath;
If an employee's answers to the screening questions indicate that the employee should request time off, a leave of absence, or an accommodation related to COVID-19.

If circumstances require a change to this policy, you will be notified promptly. Thank you for your service to the Company, especially during this challenging time.

Randy Betts

In leaked memo, Michaels executives refuse to close stores and tell employees they must be 'here for the makers' amid the coronavirus
Bethany Biron 3/24/2020
Michaels is staying open amid the coronavirus outbreak. 
Business Insider/Jessica Tyler

In a memo sent to Michaels employees and obtained by Business Insider, Michaels executives wrote that the craft store will stay open as an "essential" business that is "here for the makers." 

Though a Michaels spokesperson said the craft store has temporarily closed in select states with strict mandates like New York, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania, among others, the chain still has hundreds of open stores across the country. 

"I am asked on a daily basis by customers why we are still open," a Michaels manager speaking on the condition of anonymity told Business Insider. "We ask ourselves the same thing. We clearly aren't important to our CEO. He is putting his hardworking employees and customers are risk. "

As retailers around the country close their doors to prevent the spread of the coronavirus, Michaels is remaining open by claiming the craft store is an "essential" business that is "here for the makers."

In a memo sent to Michaels employees on March 19 and obtained by Business Insider, outgoing CEO Mark Cosby and incoming CEO Ashley Buchanan wrote that stores will stay open and deemed its employees "an essential workforce" during the pandemic The executives wrote its stores are "fundamental" to serving business owners, teachers, parents, and communities "looking to take their minds off a stressful reality."

"Please know that even though our doors remain open, we understand that you may not be comfortable coming into the stores," they wrote, though did not state whether the company would offer sick pay or benefits in the case of illness.

Though the definition of essential versus nonessential varies depending on state, craft stores are not on the list of businesses universally considered to be essential, nor are they included in a guidance issued by the Department of Homeland Security.

According to a spokesperson, Michaels has temporarily closed stores in the states of California, Nevada, New Mexico, New Jersey, New York, and Pennsylvania, as well as select locations in Canada and in the cities of Miami and Fort Worth. Each of these locations has issued strict mandates regarding the closure of nonessential businesses or implemented safety precautions like "shelter-in-place" mandates.

Still, this leaves hundreds of Michaels stores remaining in operation across the US. It also comes in tandem with competitor Hobby Lobby also continuing to remain open, after executives at Hobby Lobby sent a memo to managers stating they would "make every effort to continue working the employee."

In the Michaels memo, the executives appear to further justify the company's decision to stay open due to its status as a UPS Access Point, writing that stores serve as "key shipping services to the public and are considered a reliable alternative to other shipping companies and locations."

However, UPS said on its website that many of its standalone pickup and drop off locations like the UPS Store will remain open and acknowledged that "some businesses that serve as UPS Access Point locations are closing or adjusting their operations due to the coronavirus."

In response to request to comment on the decision to remain open, the Michaels spokesperson reiterated the company's partnership with UPS and said the stores will continue to make an effort "to support and remain a lifeline for the teachers, parents and small businesses."

"For the stores that remain open, we are sanitizing heavily trafficked and hard surfaces frequently and encouraging social distancing," the spokesperson said in a statement to Business Insider. "We strongly encourage our Team Members that are not comfortable working in our stores or facilities to speak to their managers about their options."

However, a Michaels manager in the Midwest — who spoke on the condition of anonymity to protect her job and whose employment status was confirmed by Business Insider — said employees at her store have not been provided with adequate protections like hand sanitizer and that cleaning supplies "are scarce."

"I am asked on a daily basis by customers why we are still open," she told Business Insider in an email. "We ask ourselves the same thing. We clearly aren't important to our CEO. He is putting his hardworking employees and customers are risk. "

The employee said many of her colleagues skew older and some have underlying health conditions that make them especially vulnerable to contracting the coronavirus, but they continue to work out of fear of losing their jobs.

"I am so worried for my coworkers," she said. "If I get sick I will likely recover without incident. My coworkers and other vulnerable people could die. We are expendable. Just a means to make money."
Read the full memo, below:

Michaels Memo


A Letter from Mark and Ashley: 03.19.2020

The coronavirus (COVID-19) has placed the U.S. and the world in an unprecedented situation. As the country's largest arts and crafts retailer, we are here for the makers.
The small business owners that rely on us for their online and storefront business needs.
The teachers and parents that rely on our products to reach classes virtually, in the home or other locales.
The communities looking to take their minds off a stressful reality, even if temporarily.

Our stores are designated UPS access points, which means we provide key shipping services to the public and are considered a reliable alternative to other shipping companies and locations.

The products we sell, the services we provide and the businesses we support make us an essential workforce and are fundamental in our decision to remain open.

Our leadership team strives to make decisions that balance the safety of our Team Members with our commitments to our customers and communities. We will continue to follow all CDC and government guidelines and will make business changes when needed.

Please know that even though our doors remain open, we understand that you may not be comfortable coming into the stores. If that's the case, we encourage you to talk to your Store Manager about your concerns and your options. For any other questions, please call Team Member Services at 855-432-6543 (MIKE) option 2.

For those who continue to work, we have provided guidelines and detailed and updated information to all Stores Managers and District Managers on how to keep yourselves and our customers healthy and safe. This information can be found in your break rooms or back offices.

Thank you for all that you have done and continue to do for Michaels.

Take care of yourself and each other.

Mark and Ashley
Amazon sent guests of its canceled robotics conference $600 Moncler jackets, even as its army of warehouse workers have been fighting for better conditions amid the virus outbreak
Eugene Kim Mar 23, 2020
Jeff Bezos at a previous MARS conference. Jeff Bezos/Twitter

Amazon last week sent Moncler jackets that cost $600 per unit to VIP guests of a private event called MARS after canceling it because of the coronavirus.

MARS is separate from re:MARS, the robotics event that's open to the public.

Amazon's spokesperson said the gifts were purchased well in advance of MARS's cancellation and meant to be given to the guests anyway, as event attendees receive a gift bag of several items every year.

Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos was not personally involved in the decision to send the gift to MARS guests, the spokesperson said.

The gift is unusually generous for Amazon, a company known for its frugal work culture.
It's also a reminder of the two-class system — high-paid knowledge workers and low-wage blue-collar workers — that Amazon's business is built upon.

Amazon warehouse workers on the front lines of the coronavirus crisis won a long-fought battle this month when the company agreed to provide some of them with paid time off.

Around the same time, another group of people connected to Amazon received an unexpected surprise in the mail: a stylish winter jacket from Moncler, a French luxury-ski-wear brand known for jackets with price tags that can reach thousands of dollars.

The jackets were sent to VIP guests of a private Amazon event called MARS, which is short for machine learning, home automation, robotics, and space exploration, Business Insider has learned. MARS is an invitation-only event that started in 2016, at which CEO Jeff Bezos mingles with some of the most high-profile leaders in the robotics and space industries.

"As we'll miss seeing you in person this year, sending our warmest regards. Be well! MARS 2020 Team," Amazon's team wrote in a note for the gift.

MARS, which was scheduled to take place from March 15 to 18, was canceled a few weeks ago because of the coronavirus outbreak.

An Amazon spokesperson told Business Insider that the jackets were purchased well in advance of the event's cancellation, as they were supposed to be given as part of the event's gift bags that go to all MARS guests every year. Bezos was not involved in the decision to send the jackets, which were customized with a MARS logo and, according to Amazon, cost $600 each.
A Moncler winter jacket (not the one that Amazon gave away as gifts). Moncler.com

The jackets were shipped on March 18 — two days after Amazon announced it was temporarily raising hourly wages for warehouse and delivery workers by $2, according to the spokesperson.

At a time when Amazon's warehouse workers are in the spotlight for working long, grueling hours in conditions some say are unsafe, the Moncler jackets are a salient example of the two-class system that underpins Amazon's business empire, as well as much of today's so-called gig economy. That divide — between well-compensated "knowledge workers" and low-wage blue-collar workers — is likely to come into starker relief as the coronavirus threat sends one group to work in the shelter of their homes while the other continues to report to the workplace. 

Not your average swag

To be sure, Amazon is hardly unique in giving away special gifts to VIPs and business partners. From sports-stadium box seats to branded fleece vests, giveaways are standard practice in the corporate world. Still, the Moncler jackets are a cut above the average swag and seem like an unusually generous act of giving for Amazon, a company known for its frugal work culture.

Amazon announced the temporary raise for warehouse and delivery workers last week only after calls for better pay grew and workloads increased amid the coronavirus pandemic. On Monday, it also rolled out paid time off across all warehouses after months of pressure from its employees, according to BuzzFeed News. Some of Amazon's warehouses failed to install air conditioners in the past until a local news investigation found workers had been falling ill.

Meanwhile, sellers that account for more than half the products sold on Amazon's marketplace often complain about the lack of communication and clarity in policy changes. After the company announced last week that it would block new shipments of nonessential products to its warehouses, sellers have expressed confusion about what products are still accepted. Even in Bezos' letter to employees on Saturday, his first public response to the coronavirus pandemic, there was no mention of the sellers.

The jackets appear to have shipped relatively quickly, despite the supply-chain issues and shipment delays Amazon is experiencing because of the coronavirus. That may be because Amazon didn't ship them out of their own warehouses. One person who received the Moncler jacket told Business Insider that the gift didn't arrive in an Amazon box.

How China, the US, and Europe are using robots to replace and help humans fight coronavirus by delivering groceries, sanitizing hospitals, and monitoring patients
Mary Meisenzahl 3/24/2020
Robots distributing hand sanitizer and face masks. REUTERS/Sivaram V

The coronavirus outbreak that originated in China has killed more than 17,000 people worldwide and infected more than 398,000, according to recent totals.
The virus, which causes a disease known as COVID-19, has spread to 169 countries, and the majority of infections and deaths are now outside of China.
As the outbreak spreads, robots are being used to disinfect, take temperatures, and even prepare food.

Around the world, robots are being used to minimize the spread of COVID-19, the disease caused by the coronavirus, by taking on cleaning and food preparation jobs that are considered dangerous for humans.

The worldwide death toll of the coronavirus disease that originated in Wuhan, China, is now more than 17,000, and the virus has infected more than 398,000 people. On March 11, the World Health Organization (WHO) officially declared it a pandemic. The virus has disrupted travel worldwide, leading to flight cancellations, quarantines, and other breakdowns in movement and supply chains.

Take a look at some of the clever ways robots are used around the world to slow the spread of the coronavirus and help healthcare workers.

In Wuhan, where the outbreak started, a robot spraying disinfectant moves through a residential area of the city.

Sanitizing robots. China OUT (Photo by STR/AFP via Getty Images

Source: Business Insider

Volunteers refilled the robot with disinfectant on March 3.

Sanitizing robots. China OUT (Photo by STR/AFP via Getty Images


Workers on scooters control the robot.

Sanitizing robots. REUTERS

A patrol robot in a Shenyang, China, hospital checks temperatures and disinfects people and spaces.

Temperature monitor robot. Photo by STR/AFP via Getty Images


These robots are used at hospitals to cut down on demands on medical staff.

Temperature monitor robot. Photo by STR/AFP via Getty Images

Hangzhou, China, is yet another city using robots to disinfect large areas.

Sanitizing robots. Photo by STR/AFP via Getty Images


They're controlled via remote control, and can be seen getting refilled here.

Sanitizing robots. Photo by STR/AFP via Getty Images

Hangzhou's disinfecting robots look notably different from those in Wuhan and Shenyang, resembling miniature tanks.

Sanitizing robots. Photo by STR/AFP via Getty Images


Another robot disinfectant in Luoyang is remote-controlled and able to climb stairs.

Sanitizing robots. REUTERS

Anhui, China has a fleet of disinfecting robots ready to start working.

Sanitizing robots. Photo by TPG/Getty Images


This hand sanitizer-dispensing robot was photographed in Shanghai on March 4.

Sanitizing robots. REUTERS

On March 11, robots in the Hunan province in China conduct morning temperature checks.

Temperature monitor robot. Xinhua/Chen Zeguo via Getty Images


Engineers have also modified the robots to record data, give feedback, and even disinfect people's hands.

Temperature monitor robot. Xinhua/Chen Zeguo via Getty Images

Immediate feedback can make the containment process faster and more efficient.

Temperature monitor robot. Xinhua/Chen Zeguo via Getty Images


Robots are being used for more than just disinfecting areas with coronavirus. A hospital in Ezhou has incorporated a robot chef into its kitchen.

Food prep robot. Photo by Shi Xiaojie/China News Service via Getty Images

The robot can reportedly produce 100 pots of rice per hour.

Food prep robot. Photo by Shi Xiaojie/China News Service via Getty Images


The robot operates without human supervision, which minimizes the number of people in the hospital exposed to the virus.

Food prep robot. Photo by Shi Xiaojie/China News Service via Getty Images

Sharing food presents an opportunity to spread the virus, so some cities have been incorporating robots in food service and preparation.

Food prep robot. Feature China/Barcroft Media via Getty Images


This robot delivered food to diners in Hangzhou.

Food prep robot. Feature China/Barcroft Media via Getty Images

Beijing-based Zhen Robotics says that its yellow robots are in demand to deliver groceries and patrol malls for people not wearing face masks.

Delivery robot. Photo by Simon Song/South China Morning Post via Getty Images


Engineering students at Chulalongkorn University in Bangkok modified medical "ninja robots" designed for stroke patients to make them useful with patients who have COVID-19.

Thai ninja robot. Photo by LILLIAN SUWANRUMPHA/AFP via Getty Images

Source: Business Insider

The robots can take patients' temperatures and protect the safety of healthcare workers by reducing interactions with sick people.

Thai ninja robot. Photo by LILLIAN SUWANRUMPHA/AFP via Getty Images


They also have a screen, allowing doctors to video chat with sick patients.

Thai ninja robot. Photo by LILLIAN SUWANRUMPHA/AFP via Getty Images

Postmates delivery robots deliver food in Los Angeles.

Postmates delivery robot. Photo by AaronP/Bauer-Griffin/GC Images


Los Angeles is one of many US cities that closed all non-essential businesses due to COVID-19, and restaurants are allowed to stay open only for takeout and delivery.

Postmates delivery robot. AaronP/Bauer-Griffin/GC Images

A hospital in Johannesburg, South Africa is using a UV light robot to disinfect the facility.

Sanitizing robot. Photo by MICHELE SPATARI/AFP via Getty Images


The hospital is using UV light instead of hydrogen peroxide, because it cuts cleaning time down from hours to five or ten minutes.

Sanitizing robot. Photo by MICHELE SPATARI/AFP via Getty Images

UV light also poses less danger to healthcare workers than hydrogen peroxide.

Sanitizing robot. Photo by MICHELE SPATARI/AFP via Getty Images


Startup Asimov Robotics launched two robots to spread awareness of the coronavirus in India.

Robots distributing hand sanitizer and face masks. REUTERS/Sivaram V

They distribute face masks and hand sanitizer...

Robots distributing hand sanitizer and face masks. REUTERS/Sivaram V


...along with information about preventing the virus.

Robots distributing hand sanitizer and face masks. REUTERS/Sivaram V

A self-driving Starship robot drops off deliveries in Emerson Valley, Britain.

Delivery robot. REUTERS/Andrew Boyers


The robot goes right to people's door, eliminating the need for contact between people.

Delivery robot. REUTERS/Andrew Boyers

Belgian company ZoraBots made a robot designed for elderly people to communicate with loved ones from the safety of their own homes.

Video call robot. REUTERS/Yves Herman


The robot has video and audio so people can still talk while sheltering at home, keeping the most vulnerable people socially connected.

Video call robot. REUTERS/Yves Herman

SLOW MOTION MASS MURDER IN THE PEWS

Trump wants to reopen the US economy on Easter because he'd like 'packed churches all over our country' despite massive public-health risk
New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo announced that experts believe New York's coronavirus outbreak will reach an apex in 14 to 21 days. Easter is in 19 days.
DR TRUMP QUACK
'Trump kept saying it was basically pretty much a cure': Woman whose husband died after ingesting chloroquine tells the public not to 'believe anything that the president says'

THIS MAKES TRUMP NEGLIGENT AND COMPLICIT IN MANSLAUGHTER

Sonam Sheth Mar 23, 2020, 7:39 PM

The wife of an Arizona man who died after ingesting chloroquine phosphate to protect himself from the novel coronavirus spoke out Monday to urge the public not to "take anything" or "believe anything" without talking to a healthcare professional.

"We saw Trump on TV — every channel — and all of his buddies and that this was safe," the woman told NBC News' Vaughn Hillyard of President Donald Trump. "Trump kept saying it was basically pretty much a cure."

NBC News reported that the man, 68, and his wife, 61, took chloroquine to guard against the novel coronavirus, which causes a potentially fatal disease known as COVID-19. It's not clear how much chloroquine the man consumed, and Banner Health said he and his wife ingested a version of the chemical that's used to clean aquariums.

Both of them needed to seek medical care within half an hour; the woman is in critical condition, and the man died.

The pharmaceutical version of chloroquine — known as hydroxychloroquine — is used to treat malaria, but there is no conclusive evidence it is effective against the coronavirus, which the World Health Organization declared a pandemic earlier this month.

Trump has repeatedly touted the drug as a "very powerful" treatment for the disease and falsely claimed it had been approved by the Food and Drug Administration.

"It's shown very encouraging — very, very encouraging early results," Trump said last week. "And we're going to be able to make that drug available almost immediately. And that's where the FDA has been so great. They — they've gone through the approval process; it's been approved. And they did it, they took it down from many, many months to immediate. So we're going to be able to make that drug available by prescription or states."

The FDA came out with a statement after Trump's comments saying it had not approved chloroquine for the coronavirus and that much more research had to be done.

"Did you at any point hear that the FDA had not approved of it for coronavirus purposes?" Hillyard asked the woman.

"Yeah," she said. "But, you know, they kept saying that it was approved for other things."

Asked what her message to the American public was after what she and her husband went through, the woman told NBC News: "Oh my God, don't take anything. Don't believe anything that the president says and his people ... call your doctor."

"Please educate the people," she added, according to audio of the conversation that Hillyard posted to Twitter. "It feels like, like my heart is broken and it'll never mend. It's just broke, dead. Like my husband. My husband is 68. We're healthy. No underlying — no diabetes or lung issues. Nothing."
The single greatest threat to the global economy couldn't be clearer right now, and Congress is headed straight for it
Linette Lopez Mar 23, 2020

Senate Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY)
 Samuel Corum/Getty Images



The US share of global GDP is nearly 15%. If our economy can't stabilize and then recover from the coronavirus pandemic, it will be harder for the world to do so.


And so it's imperative that Congress write fair, generous legislation to get us through the economic shutdown required to fight the virus.


But that isn't what's happening. Republicans accuse Democrats of not moving fast enough. Democrats accuse Republicans of short-changing American workers and favoring big corporations.


That matters. Under-funding this stimulus will drag the global economy down. And any appearance that corporations are getting a more fair deal than individuals will make people not want to comply. A lack of compliance will drag on the crisis.


This is an opinion column. The thoughts expressed are those of the author.

The US economy contributes more than any other country to global GDP — about 15% of the total. When it falls into ruin, the entire global economy drags. We saw that happen during the financial crisis of 2008.

So it is imperative for the world that the US economy stay stable during the coronavirus pandemic, and that it can swing back to growth as soon as possible when it's over.

Right now there is one clear obstacle to that: the potential that Congress could under-fund the US coronavirus stimulus package. If they do, they put not only the economy but the effort to fight the virus at risk.

This is a case where the consequences (and possibility) of overspending are basically negligible, while the consequences of underspending could push the entire global economy into a longer, deeper recession.

And yet this weekend the Senate was unable to pass aid legislation. Senate Leader Mitch McConnell raged and blamed Democrats, while Democrats fumed over the legislation's $500 billion, opaque Treasury slush fund to be handed out to corporations at Treasury Secretary Steve Mnuchin's discretion. Treasury wouldn't have to report which corporations got that money for half a year, whereas during the financial crisis companies that received funds were made public within 60 days.


Democrats also rejected the bill over a lack of labor protections that would only mandate corporations keep employees "to the extent possible." They want more limits on executive compensation and share buybacks, and they want more money for healthcare workers. They accuse Republicans of being cheap, and writing a deal that favors corporations over average Americans.
You can't be cheap, and you can't be corrupt

St. Louis Federal Reserve President James Bullard on Sunday scared the pants off a lot of people by saying unemployment could hit 30% during the coronavirus. He also said the economy would take a $2.5 trillion hit. But he asked people to look at government efforts to get us through this not as an effort to stave off recession, but as an investment in public health. He's right.

"You want capital to just sit in place. Switch off the factory ... Then switch it back on," he said.

That means treating individuals and businesses with extreme generosity. To the Democrats, the Republican bill is far more generous to corporations than workers. Particularly by allowing them to fire people while still taking bailout money.

The only proposal that comes close to being generous enough for individuals comes from Democratic Rep. Rashida Tlaib. It would give a prepaid card with $2,000 to every American. That card would then be recharged with $1,000 monthly until one year after the end of the coronavirus crisis. This is the kind of plan that will make Americans believe the government has their back, not just the backs of big corporations.


Because you see, even a whiff of that kind of impropriety puts the entire global economy at risk. It is imperative that it be a fair deal.

The distrust that is bred by corruption will make it much harder to fight this virus, potentially dragging out the crisis. The vast majority of Americans already think that our lack of trust in each other and our government makes it hard to solve problems, according to Pew Research. If Americans feel like this whole aid package is a handout to big corporations — which they also distrust — they may stop listening to authorities.

After all, why should they respect a government that seems to have so little respect for them?

A lack of compliance would draw the crisis out only longer, bringing waves of the illness that will require mini-shutdowns to stabilize hospital capacity. Goldman Sachs estimates that the recession brought on by fighting off coronavirus will trough in April, knocking 10% off US GDP. Over time, bank analysts wrote last week, the economy should begin to grow again incrementally. How fast depends on how well Americans comply with government social-distancing mandates. Americans have to want to comply.
Goldman Sachs

I've said this before and I'll say it again: This all needs to move much faster. Small and midsize companies make up 83% of the US economy, and thousands of workers are already out of a job across the country. Means-testing initial payments to individuals — that is, restricting who gets the checks based on income — is a waste of time.

Let me put it this way: If you think that the 1% shouldn't get a check, then that means we wasted 1% of these aid funds. That's better than creating massive financial stress for millions of Americans and their families.

NOW WATCH: The founder of the World Economic Forum shares what he sees as the biggest threat to the global economy
ACTUAL BI AD

POPULAR FROM BI PRIME
TRUMP ANNOUNCES END OF COVID-19  PANDEMIC 
IN AMERICA BY EASTER SUNDAY
MEANWHILE PM ABE OF JAPAN HAS CANCELED THE SUMMER OLYMPICS
WHICH WERE TO OCCUR AT THE END OF JULY

ONE OF THESE IS A QUACK SNAKE OIL SALESMAN
TV networks cut away from the White House coronavirus briefing as Trump contradicted his health experts
Kayla Epstein 3/24/2020



NOT SOCIAL DISTANCING
President Donald Trump with four members of his administration's coronavirus task force — Vice President Mike Pence, FDA Commissioner Dr. Stephen Hahn, Dr. Deborah Birx, and Surgeon General Jerome Adams — at a briefing on Thursday. REUTERS/Jonathan Ernst


CNN, MSNBC, ABC News, NBC News, and CBS News cut away from President Trump's lengthy coronavirus briefing on Monday night.

During the briefing, Trump chafed at the idea of continuing the widespread order for people to stay home, saying it was harming the economy. His top infectious-diseases expert, Dr. Anthony Fauci, had said social-distancing measures would need to be in place for "several weeks."

CBS told Insider that it "plans to continue covering briefings whenever possible" but may cut away for other programming. MSNBC told Insider that it "cut away because the information no longer appeared to be valuable to the important ongoing discussion around public health."

Critics of the president have called for networks to stop airing the briefings. "All of us should stop broadcasting it, honestly," MSNBC's Rachel Maddow said on Friday. "It's going to cost lives."

On Monday night, most of the major television networks, except for Fox News, cut away from President Donald Trump's daily coronavirus briefing.

Though the briefings often feature a rotating cast of Trump administration health experts, like Dr. Anthony Fauci, the director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, and Surgeon General Jerome Adams, they have also allowed Trump to make inaccurate declarations about the administration's response and undercut the dire warnings of these professionals that Americans need to stay home to stop the virus from spreading.

As Trump has contradicted experts, provided inaccurate medical information, and engaged in lengthy diatribes against journalists, his critics have questioned how much networks should broadcast them — and whether relaying his words directly is a public benefit.
Several networks cut away from Trump's briefing on Monday night

Trump's coronavirus briefing with Vice President Mike Pence, Attorney General William Barr, and Dr. Deborah Birx of the White House's coronavirus task force was scheduled for 5:30 p.m. ET but didn't begin until after 6.

Trump quickly undermined his health experts' guidance that Americans need to stay home for several weeks, claiming that businesses would open "soon."

Trump implied that the limitations would continue for "a much shorter period of time than I've been hearing the news report," though Fauci had told the "Today" show on Friday that the measures would need to be in place for "several weeks."

At one point, Trump made Birx, the top health expert on the podium that day, part of a bit aimed at attacking journalists.

The major broadcast networks — ABC, CBS, and NBC — all cut away from Trump's briefing about 20 minutes in, The Associated Press reported. The cable news networks CNN and MSNBC followed suit after 7 p.m.

A spokesman for CBS News told Insider that the network "plans to continue covering briefings whenever possible, but may cut away for regularly scheduled news broadcasts, which many viewers depend on for delivering objective reporting and context on the developments of the day."

He said that CBS News' feed of the briefings was still available to affiliates and that it would incorporate major headlines from the events into the evening news.

MSNBC, on the other hand, "cut away because the information no longer appeared to be valuable to the important ongoing discussion around public health," a network representative told Insider.

On Twitter, Judd Deere, a White House spokesman, said the networks' decisions were "disgraceful" and thanked Fox News for airing the briefing.
—Judd Deere (@JuddPDeere45) March 23, 2020

"If the White House wants to ask for time on the network, they should make an official request. Otherwise we will make our own editorial decisions," a CNN representative said in a statement relayed by the network's media reporter Oliver Darcy.
Critics say it's time to stop broadcasting Trump's briefings

On Tuesday, the Washington Post media columnist Margaret Sullivan declared that "the media must stop live-broadcasting Trump's dangerous, destructive coronavirus briefings."

"These White House sessions — ostensibly meant to give the public critical and truthful information about this frightening crisis — are in fact working against that end," Sullivan wrote.

James Fallows, a longtime journalist for The Atlantic, also tweeted that "cable outlets should stop covering them live."
—James Fallows (@JamesFallows) March 19, 2020

"If it were up to me — and it's not — I would stop putting those briefings on live TV," the MSNBC host Rachel Maddow said on Friday. "Not out of spite, but because it's misinformation. If the president does end up saying anything true, you can run it as tape."

She added: "All of us should stop broadcasting it, honestly. It's going to cost lives."

Trump has repeatedly touted a drug called chloroquine as a possible treatment for COVID-19 over objections from his officials that it has not been approved for that use. A man in Arizona recently died and his wife was hospitalized after ingesting chloroquine phosphate, a version of the chemical that's used to clean aquariums.

"We saw Trump on TV — every channel — and all of his buddies and that this was safe," the woman told NBC News' Vaughn Hillyard on Monday. "Trump kept saying it was basically pretty much a cure."