Sunday, December 26, 2021

Rare ‘thunder bird’ fossil gives researchers clue to demise of Australian species of megafauna


At 230kg Genyornis newtoni weighed around five or six times as much as an emu and stood about two metres tall
Genyornis newtoni once roamed Australia’s interior before a change in climate turned lakes and forests into flat desert. Photograph: Brook Mitchell/Getty Images


Australian Associated Press
Sun 26 Dec 2021

Flinders University researchers may have discovered what ultimately led to the extinction of the last of Australia’s massive thunder birds, Genyornis newtoni.

The clue came with the discovery of a rare fossil. The find, by researchers at Flinders University, unveiled severe bone infections in several dromornithid remains mired in the 160 sq km beds of Lake Callabonna fossil reserve, 600km northeast of Adelaide.

At 230kg Genyornis weighed around five or six times as much as an emu and stood about two metres tall, but becoming stuck in the treacherous mud of the lake wasn’t the only concern facing the giant birds.



It appears some also had a painful disease, which lead researcher Phoebe McInerney says would have hampered their mobility and foraging.

“The fossils with signs of infection are associated with the chest, legs and feet of four individuals,” the PhD candidate said. “They would have been increasingly weakened, suffering from pain, making it difficult to find water and food.

“It’s a rare thing in the fossil record to find one, let alone several, well-preserved fossils with signs of infection. We now have a much greater idea of the life challenges of these birds.”

The study found about 11% of the birds were suffering from osteomyelitis.

“We see frothy and woven bone, large abnormal growths and cavities in their fossil remains,” McInerney said.

Finding multiple individuals in the population with osteomyelitis suggests a somewhat complex situation may have caused the phenomenon.


Study co-author associate prof Lee Arnold dated the salt lake sediments in which genyornis was found, linking them with a period of severe drought beginning about 48,000 years ago.

At the time, the thunder birds and other megafauna, including ancient relatives of wombats and kangaroos, were facing major environmental challenges.

As the continent dried, large inland lakes and forests began to disappear and central Australia became flat desert.



With conditions worsening, associate prof Trevor Worthy believes food resources would have been reduced, placing considerable stress on the animals.

“From studies on living birds, we know that challenging environmental conditions can have negative physiological effects,” he said. “So we infer that the Lake Callabonna population of genyornis would have been struggling through such conditions.”

It now appears the effects of severe drought phases included high rates of bone infection, with weakened individuals more likely to become mired in the deep mud and die.

With no conclusive evidence to suggest Genyornis newtoni survived much past this time, it’s likely protracted drought and high disease rates contributed to its eventual extinction.

The research findings have been published in Papers in Palaeontology.

Canada’s first new nuclear reactor in decades is an American design. Will it prompt a rethink of government support?

Ontario Power Generation chose GE Hitachi Nuclear Energy to build a light water reactor at its existing Darlington nuclear power plant, a decision that could shape Canada’s nuclear industry for decades to come.
GLOBE AND MAIL
PUBLISHED 1 HOUR AGO
A visitor to the Darlington Nuclear Generating Station in Clarington, Ont., looks out onto the facility grounds during a tour in February 2016.
FRED LUM/THE GLOBE AND MAIL

Ontario Power Generation’s selection of GE Hitachi Nuclear Energy to help build a small modular reactor (SMR) at its Darlington station in Clarington, Ont., set in motion events that could shape Canada’s nuclear industry for decades to come.

OPG’s choice, announced in December, is the BWRX-300. It’s a light water reactor, the variety most popular in developed countries, and quite unlike Canada’s existing fleet of CANDU heavy water reactors. Though not exactly small – the BWRX’s 300-megawatt nameplate capacity is roughly equivalent to a large wind farm – it would produce only one-third as much electricity as traditional reactors. It would use different fuel, produce different wastes and possibly have different safety implications.

The Darlington SMR would be the first BWRX-300 ever constructed. By moving first, OPG hopes Ontario will become embedded in a global supply chain for these reactors.

“OPG ourselves, we don’t really get anything out of it – it’s a lot of work,” said Robin Manley, OPG’s vice-president of nuclear development. “Our goal is to have as many contracts signed with Canadian suppliers as we possibly can.” But that might not satisfy some critics, who’ve protested OPG’s selection of a U.S. design by GE Hitachi, which is based in North Carolina.

It does seem to confirm the end of Canada’s tradition of homegrown reactors. The BWRX-300 would be Canada’s first new reactor since Darlington Unit 4 in Ontario, completed in 1993. According to Mycle Schneider Consulting, the average age of the country’s 19 operational reactors is 38 years. Attempts to update the CANDU design proved largely fruitless; OPG and Bruce Power opted to refurbish reactors at Darlington and Bruce stations to operate another few decades, while sizing up SMRs as a possible next act.

Time is running short. This decade is widely regarded as crucial for building emissions-free generation capacity. SMRs will be late to that party even if this BWRX-300 is built on time. Delays and cost overruns, ever-present risks with any reactor, could kill its prospects.

The partnership with OPG represents a major coup for GE Hitachi, a U.S.-Japanese alliance that set up its SMR subsidiary in Canada less than a year ago. There are at least 50 SMR designs worldwide, but most exist only on paper; vendors compete vigorously to sell to experienced nuclear operators such as OPG because they represent an opportunity to build a bona fide reactor that might entice other clients. For the same reason, OPG’s decision is a blow to the losing candidates, Oakville, Ont.-based Terrestrial Energy Inc. and X-energy, an American vendor.

“There’s lots of enthusiasm among nuclear reactor designers, developers and national laboratories, and academic nuclear engineering departments” about SMRs, said Edwin Lyman, director of nuclear power safety at the Union of Concerned Scientists, who published a report on SMR reactor designs in early 2021. “There’s a lot of supply but there’s not much demand, because utilities don’t want to be guinea pigs.”

Nuclear industry executives and government officials hope the Darlington SMR will be the first of many deployed in Ontario and beyond. SaskPower is also shopping; it has collaborated with OPG since 2017, and said the BWRX-300 is among its candidates. Canada has a small population, so observers doubt the country could support supply chains for multiple reactor designs.

But OPG’s selection of an American SMR has drawn some sharp criticism. Some observers assumed Terrestrial enjoyed a home turf advantage, particularly in light of the federal government’s decision to invest $20-million toward its Integral Molten Salt Reactor (IMSR). The Society of Professional Engineers and Associates, a union representing engineers and others working on CANDU reactors, complained that “priority should have been given to Canadian design.”

Efficient or resilient: Alberta must find the right balance to protect our food supply

Heat dome illustrated the fragility of mainstream farming, writes researcher

Researcher Tatenda Mambo is managing the University of Calgary's Simon Farm project. (Riley Brandt, University of Calgary)

This column is an opinion by farmer and researcher Tatenda Mambo. For more information about CBC's Opinion section, please see the FAQ.


Last summer, a brutal heat dome knocked out crops across the prairies. But on our experimental farm just south of Calgary, it also gave a measure of hope.

At the University of Calgary's Simon Farm Project near Blackie, Alta., we're testing whether the traits found in locally-saved and traditional seed varieties can bring more resilience to our food production in the face of climate change.

It's part of a larger research effort to help Alberta's farmers shift their practices and weather the increased drought we know is coming.

The heat showed a difference between the various seed varieties we were testing, and it was staggering.

Most potatoes, kale and other plants from the seed of national distributors succumbed to the heat and withered away. The same plants from the locally-saved seed held on. 

This seed was from farmers in the region who had been planting and gathering it for at least 10 years, letting it acclimatize to our conditions. At the end of the day, despite four weeks of no significant rain and  27 C heat, we still got a modest harvest from the locally-acclimatized seed.

Of course, this is just one extreme summer and the work is ongoing, but the resilience of local seeds has been documented by other researchers. Traditional or Indigenous agricultural practices around the world have shown we can work with nature to produce our food in a manner that can restore and support ecological functions rather than degrade and erode them. And if we go back to incorporate these techniques, we can create a system that is more resilient.

Efficient or redundant

Recent events such as COVID-19, the 2021 drought, and the effects of the atmospheric rivers in B.C., shine a light on the fragility of our food systems. We saw simultaneous food dumping and supply disruptions, lost crops, and increased need for emergency food services. 

This is because within our food system and rippled throughout society is an inherent tension between efficiency (streamlined approaches to doing things) and redundancy (multiple approaches to doing things). This impacts resilience. 

On Simon Farm, Tatenda Mambo says most of the potato plants grown from the seed of national distributors did not survive the extreme heat and drought last summer. (Submitted by Tatenda Mambo)

You need the right balance between these two elements to create sustainable systems. Too much efficiency and the system becomes brittle, with disruptions causing system failures that have difficulty rebounding. Too much redundancy causes stagnation.

403 varieties of peas

Simon Farm is one of several efforts to learn how to bring resilience back into our food systems in ways that are ecologically sound and, eventually, commercially competitive.

With seeds, for example, the traditional practice of planting and harvesting seed meant farmers used to have many varieties of a single crop. For example, there used to be over 403 varieties of peas and today we only find 25. This has reduced resilience, but many farmers buy seed from distributors because it's easier and normally more cost effective.

On Simon Farm, we also increase the diversity of plants that we grow together. Rather than planting one crop per bed, our beds are filled with a mix of plants selected to support the overall growth and success of the beds. Together, they deter pests, enhance soil fertility, reduce compaction, shade the bed to conserve moisture, or fix nitrogen.

This diversity in crops is less efficient, but it enables resilience in both the short and long term.

Potatoes and kale growing last summer on Simon Farm. The farm deliberately mixes plants in their beds to strengthen the soil. These plants were grown from locally-harvested seed. (Submitted by Tatenda Mambo)

We rotate annual crops suited to our climate, and have perennial crops such as sunchokes, asparagus and sorrel. The produce is donated to the High River Food Bank.

Wide adoption still a dream

The next major step for the farm is a passive solar greenhouse to enable vegetable production into the winter months, when the need for fresh produce is highest locally. Unlike much of the greenhouse industry in Alberta, it will largely depend on the sun for heat during the winter, and will tap low grade geothermal energy to regulate temperature extremes. 

The truth is climate change will bring both challenges and opportunities to our agricultural sector. In some ways, it will no longer be prudent for our food system to cheaply provide us whatever we want to eat, regardless of the season. 

But Alberta has untapped resources that can strengthen regional food production and leverage skills and infrastructure already present. Already, we have great examples of farmers working to restore the soil and being supported by customers buying their products directly. The Blue Mountain Biodynamic Farms in Carstairs, Alta., is one good example. Other organizations such as YYC Growers and Organic Box distribute locally-produced food to clients year-round. Local greenhouse operators are already using geothermal heat, and there's huge potential to use excess heat from repurposed orphan wells or industrial activities.

The tools are there. But while we have innovators in this field, we are a ways off from wide scale adoption. Government policies focused on export, the current supply chain and even crop insurance, are still all skewed toward conventional practices that fail to account for the problems they create, leaving our system fragile.

We need to recognize that change is coming. The question is whether we will lead it or be victims of it.


CBC Calgary: The High Cost of Food

CBC Calgary is using community insight to help understand the gaps in Calgary's food system. Add your cell phone number to share tips on saving money and help document how the high cost of food is changing the way we eat and shop. Read the series at cbc.ca/costoffood.

'There's fosters leaving left, right and centre': Pet surrender requests and COVID-19 lead to increased need for animal fosters in Edmonton

Author of the article:Kellen Taniguchi
Publishing date:Dec 26, 2021
These two domestic rabbits are being fostered by Katryna Patterson, a volunteer with Infinite Woofs Animal Rescue Society, until they are adopted. 
PHOTO BY LARRY WONG /POSTMEDIA NETWORK


A staggering number of pet surrenders amid the COVID-19 pandemic has led to an increased need for animal foster homes in Edmonton, according to one local rescue.

Katryna Patterson, who volunteers as a small animal foster for Infinite Woofs Animal Rescue Society (IWARS) in the city, said she currently has seven rabbits living with her — the most she’s ever had at one time.

“I have three foster rabbits and four rabbits of my own. They’re really busy right now,” said Patterson.

The need for her to care for three rabbits at a time is partially due to the lack of foster homes available, she added.

“There’s fosters leaving left, right and centre,” said Patterson. “I don’t necessarily know all the personal reasons as to why, but I would definitely say a lot of it is probably COVID-related. People seem to be moving, a lot of the people I meet in passing, some of them are downsizing and they can’t keep the animals.”

IWARS hasn’t been taking in new rabbits since springtime and Patterson said once one rabbit is adopted there is always another needing a home.

Volunteer fosters are responsible for taking care of animals until they are adopted, including taking them to the necessary vet appointments.

Alisha Petryshyn, admin team member and cat foster with IWARS, said the need for dog and cat foster homes is also high.

She said surrender requests, specifically for dogs, have skyrocketed this year and there is no sign of it slowing down. During the summer and early fall, the rescue was receiving 70 to 80 dog surrender requests per month, compared to about 30 per month prior to the pandemic.

“I’d say it’s like two prongs — there’s a lot of owner surrenders for specific reasons and then there’s kind of the stray population that has kind of exploded in many areas, especially more rural and remote areas,” said Petryshyn.

Petryshyn said more than 400 dogs were adopted from IWARS in 2020 and if they had more foster homes available they probably would have been able to take triple the number of adoption requests.

“In all worlds, but for the dog team, we turn away dogs pretty much on a daily basis just because we don’t have enough foster homes or we aren’t able to support, for example, a very critical medical patient at this time,” Petryshyn said. “We don’t have a shelter and all of our fosters go directly into homes so we need to have available and appropriate homes for all animals before we can commit.”

Anyone interested in fostering can fill out the application form under the volunteer tab on the rescues’ website at www.infinitewoofs.com , reach out to them on Facebook or contact them at info.iwar@gmail.com

 Nova Scotia

How storing energy without batteries could be key to N.S. giving up fossil fuels

Wayne Groszko says storing energy as heat is an affordable

alternative to lithium ion batteries

Thermal storage options can store heat for use in hot water and space heating, at a fraction of the cost of lithium ion batteries, says Wayne Groszko, a scientist at the Nova Scotia Community College. (Moria Donovan/CBC)

In a laboratory at the Nova Scotia Community College sit two water tanks bristling with copper wires. They don't necessarily look like a piece of renewable energy technology. But they may nonetheless play a role in reducing one of the province's greatest sources of greenhouse gas emissions. 

In Nova Scotia, as much as 60 per cent of the energy consumption comes from space heating, a figure that rises to 80 per cent when hot water is included. 

As the province looks toward its new target of moving off coal-fired power by 2030, and achieving net-zero by 2050, researchers say storing heat — including through some of the thermal energy storage options being investigated at NSCC — could help bring about that transition. 

"If you can find a way to store heat for when you need it later, and if that happens to be more affordable than installing a bunch of batteries to store electricity, which it often is, then that can give you a lower-cost solution to storing your energy," said Wayne Groszko, applied energy research scientist at the Nova Scotia Community College.

"So thermal energy storage, we see as part of a future in which all, or most, of our electricity on the grid is from renewable sources."

Solving the variability challenge

In the future, an increasing proportion of energy around the world, including in Nova Scotia, is likely to come from wind and solar. 

But a central challenge with these technologies is their variability, said Groszko. "Basically, that doesn't necessarily correspond with when you need that energy. And so having some way to store the energy when it's plentiful, and use it later, is very key."

Technology like lithium ion batteries are one answer, but are relatively expensive, have a limited lifespan and use raw materials, such as lithium and cobalt, that exist in limited quantities.

Given that much of the ultimate use of energy in Nova Scotia is to generate heat anyway, storing that energy as heat is an affordable alternative, Groszko said.

One example is a hot water tank — a technology most people already have in their homes. Such a tank could be superheated on a windy day to store that energy. Then, when the wind drops, the tank's heaters could be turned off, and the energy released as hot water or space heating. 

Groszko says hot water tanks can be superheated on a windy day, storing the energy. When the wind drops, the tank's heaters could be turned off and the energy released as hot water or space heating.  (Moira Donovan/CBC)

In Groszko's lab, the team is investigating how this can be accomplished with smart controllers, which can switch the heater on and off remotely in response to demand on the grid, while still leaving enough hot water available to take a hot shower, for example.

"That's the kind of the experiments we're working on, is how to integrate this relatively simple technology into people's lives," said Groszko.

"The idea is you shouldn't notice it, you should just use your hot water as usual. But in the background, it's saving demand on the grid when it's needed, and then putting it back in later."

This would also reduce costs for households, when coupled with time-of-day electricity rates. 

Another option involves using phase-change materials, which store energy by, for instance, moving from liquid to solid. A 2020 report by the International Renewable Energy Agency estimated the global market for thermal energy storage like phase-change materials could triple by 2030. 

Phase-change materials — which are a version of the handwarmers shown here — store energy by moving between states. (Moira Donovan/CBC)

Several companies in the Maritimes are investigating the possibility of integrating phase-change materials into heat sources to allow more integration of renewables. 

One is Fredericton-based Stash Energy. Dan Curwin, director of business development, said they've developed heat pumps with phase-change material storage built in, to store energy from renewable sources like hydro when it's plentiful, such as overnight, and discharge it in the morning when demand is high, to be stored up again from renewables like solar during the day. 

This can help with the integration of renewables and with greater adoption of electric heat pumps, which are the most efficient heating option but risk overburdening the grid. 

Curwin said the company has partnerships with efficiency agencies across Atlantic Canada and New England, as well as housing authorities such as Housing Nova Scotia that recognize the particular burden posed by heating costs. 

"With batteries, or with electric vehicles, it's generally higher-income individuals who are able, at least right now, to purchase those systems," Curwin said. "But space heating and cooling is a huge piece of people's monthly bills. And we do want to make sure that we can get the system to a point where it's available for everyone, not just for the people who can purchase it because they want to, essentially."

Daniel Larsen, the company's co-founder, said now that they've developed a system that can efficiently heat and cool while allowing access to affordable energy through storage, the next step is to work with partner agencies to make the system attainable to households. 

"Access to renewable energy cannot be just for people who have money. So it's absolutely about making a product that's accessible to everyone," said Larsen.

The company hopes to have the units available in Nova Scotia through a larger demonstration project by next fall. 

Sean Kelly, director of clean energy for the Nova Scotia environmental charity Clean Foundation, said the need to improve access to affordable energy is particularly high in Nova Scotia. The province has some of the highest rates of energy poverty — which some researchers define as households spending more than six per cent of their income on energy for heat and other purposes — in the country, according to the Canadian Urban Sustainability Practitioners. 

"We have to deal with energy poverty at the same time as climate action, because they're both quite intertwined," said Kelly.

Technologies and policies that allow more households to be part of the energy transition, while also lowering energy costs, are an important part of taking action on climate change, Kelly said. 

"Climate change doesn't sit just with the environment movement, it's something we all have to be involved in," Kelly said.

"These sorts of clean energy initiatives will benefit those living on lower incomes more than almost anyone else. I mean, who needs lower energy [costs] more than someone living on lower income?"

Back in the NSCC lab, Groszko said some of the technology his lab is investigating is currently available through utilities and wholesalers, but is not yet available at the consumer level. 

In the future, though, he said by allowing more households to participate in the transition to renewable energy, thermal storage options could tap into Nova Scotians' willingness to help with that transition.

"Over the past 10 years, Nova Scotians have improved their energy efficiency dramatically, and I think there's a certain amount of pride about that," he said. "It's something that I think a fair number of people would be interested in continuing to move in the right direction."

P3 PUBLIC PENSIONS FUND PRIVATE BUSINESS
Fairfax buys back $1-billion of shares after CPPIB, OMERS investment

DECEMBER 26, 2021

Fairfax Financial Holdings Limited bought back US$1 billion of its own stock at a premium price on Christmas Eve, after selling a stake in a subsidiary to institutional investors OMERS and the Canada Pension Plan Investment Board for US$900 million.


Fairfax, a global property and casualty (P&C) insurance company, in November announced plans to buy back up to 8.7 percent of its own stock for between US$425 and US$500 for each subordinated voting share. At the same time, Toronto-based Fairfax said it had acquired its Stamford, Conn.-based division Odyssey Group Holdings Inc. Sold a 9.9 percent stake in CPPIB and OMERS, Canada’s two largest pension fund managers.

Fairfax is the latest in a string of Canadian financial services companies to initiate significant share buybacks, as regulators ease capital restrictions imposed during the pandemic and allow banks and insurers to cash in as they see fit.
advertisement

Toronto-based Fairfax last Friday set the buyback price on its buybacks using a “modified Dutch auction,” which allows shareholders to choose the price they are willing to tender their stock at. According to a report by Scotiabank analyst Phil Hardy, the auction was “slightly oversubscribed”.

Fairfax received two million shares at the top end of its pre-set range at US$500 each. That day, Fairfax shares closed at US$464.02 on the New York Stock Exchange, so the buyback played out at an 8 percent premium to where the company’s stock was trading at the time.

The decision to sell a stake in a subsidiary and use the capital to buy back the shares “provided a great solution for increasing book value per share in the near term while supporting future growth,” Mr. Hardy said.

The CPPIB and OMERS investments valued Odyssey at 1.7 times its book value. In contrast, the buyback saw Fairfax repurchase its shares at a 10 percent discount to the company’s reported book value, which is US$561.88 per share. Mr Hardy said: “The Odyssey deal highlights a significant gap between Fairfax’s share price and the estimated intrinsic value of the company and its holdings.”

Fairfax, controlled by entrepreneur Prem Vatsa, also raised capital in October by selling a 14 percent interest in London-based reinsurance subsidiary Brit Ltd to OMERS for US$375 million.

Historically, Fairfax has used the cash generated from its operating companies and investments to grow through acquisitions, rather than paying for share buybacks. In recent years, the company expanded into India and Africa.

The property, casualty and reinsurance industries are consolidating around their biggest players, which includes Fairfax. “With the P&C business becoming more risky and complex, the capital requirements and the need for reinsurance will increase,” Swiss Re, the world’s largest reinsurance company, said in a recent report. The Zurich-based company said: “Asset will be the fastest-growing segment, with global premiums projected to grow 5.3 percent annually through 2040. Climate risk will be the main driver of asset growth.”

Fairfax is expected to continue snapping up smaller rivals. In a report last week, RBC Capital Markets analyst Mark Dwley said: “The company has more than $1 billion in holding company cash and has the operational flexibility to pursue a variety of near-term and long-term growth initiatives and acquisitions.” “

 

Canada And The UK Are Eyeing Massive Tidal Power Developments

  • The UK plans to invest $26 million per year into funding for tidal power.

  • Canada is also betting big on tidal power, hoping to harness some of the world’s highest tides in Nova Scotia.

  • While Scotland and Canada become pioneers in tidal energy technology, the rest of the world is sitting and waiting to see if these investments pay off.

Tidal power is expected to grow exponentially over the next decade as several countries boost investments in the renewable energy source. As Scotland secures funding for a huge new project, Canada expects to start operations in 2022. While financing is an issue, due to high set-up and operational costs, other countries could also start to establish tidal projects if early developments are seen to be a success.  Scottish firm Nova Innovation has secured a $2.83 million investment from the European Innovation Council Accelerator Fund for its planned Upscaling Tidal Energy Manufacturing and Production Output project. Nova aims to construct a 200-kilowatt tidal turbine that is more compact, reducing both the weight and cost of the machinery. 

The company was also granted planning permission for a 30-megawatt tidal development in the U.K.’s Isle of White this month. Work on the Perpetuus Tidal Energy Centre (PTEC) will commence in 2023 to be completed by 2025. It is expected to be “England’s first multi-megawatt tidal stream power generation project.” 

Nova hopes to carry out a third project in Wales - the Morlais tidal demonstration project. Natural Resources Wales stated, “The project is for the installation and commercial demonstration of multiple tidal energy devices and will provide an area for the offshore development of renewable energy sources across 35km2  to the west of Anglesey [in Wales].”

As part of the U.K. government’s renewable energy strategy, it has earmarked almost $26.7 million a year in funding for tidal power. This brings the total annual national investment via its renewable energy auction scheme to $380 million. This funding will contribute towards Britain’s goal of cutting carbon emissions by 78 percent by 2035 and eventually achieving net-zero by 2050. The government hopes this will help develop the tidal industry as well as create new jobs across the country. 

In Canada, Sustainable Marine hopes to have its new tidal project up and running by 2022. Having constructed an onshore electrical substation in Nova Scotia, it plans to use the PLAT-I tidal energy platform to harness the power of some of the world’s highest tides to provide energy to the grid next year. It will be the first floating tidal platform to connect directly into the power grid.

The company also made a multi-million-dollar investment in the Tidal Pioneer in the region, marine operations support vessel. Sustainable Marine plans to carry out an extensive monitoring and evaluation program to see what impact the new project has on marine life in the region. It hopes to use Nova Scotia’s natural resources to develop the province’s renewable energy sector. 

Other countries have also shown interest in future tidal energy developments but are put off by the high setup and operational costs involved. India has the opportunity to become a major tidal energy generator, with an estimated 54 gigawatts (GW) of potential ocean energy, but has not yet carried out tests to explore the practically exploitable potential.

India has long considered the potential of its tidal power. However, after starting two projects - a 3.75-megawatt project in West Bengal in 2007 and a 50-megawatt development in Gujarat in 2011 – it decided costs were simply too high to continue. But now the government is suggesting that these costs need to be reevaluated due to innovations in technology and machinery, to be compared effectively to other renewable energy projects such as solar and wind power production.

So, is now the time to invest? Those working in the sector point out that tidal energy seems to have been generally overlooked when thinking about how to develop the renewable energy sector. At present, there are around 60 megawatts of wave and tidal energy installations worldwide, largely due to high prices and competitive alternatives. A scientific analysis of the current cost of tidal power operations suggests that costs need to be reduced from $320 per MWh to below $200 per MWh to make this a viable energy option. 

Another U.K. company, Orbital Marine, hopes its 72-meter submarine-esque O2 tidal turbine will provide the learning stage needed to attract greater interest in the sector. The company hopes the use of innovative technology will help to reduce project costs, aiming to attract greater funding for future projects.

With the potential for tidal power to provide a tenth of the U.K.’s energy, is it money worth spending? Dan McGrail, CEO of Renewable UK explains, “we need a range of renewable technologies to get us to net zero as fast as possible.” Further, “as an island nation with superb tidal energy resources to harness, it is clear that tidal stream should have a key role to play in our shift to clean energy.”

 While Scotland and Canada become pioneers in tidal energy technology, the rest of the world is sitting and waiting to see if these investments pay off. Harnessing the power of a greater range of natural resources, without contributing to environmental degradation, will help countries achieve carbon reduction targets. But the high cost involved in something largely unknown has, so far, put many governments off. 

By Felicity Bradstock for Oilprice.com