Saturday, December 31, 2022

Pelé: Why black Brazilians like me mourn the King

"O Rei", Pelé, playing for the Brazilian national team at the Maracanã stadium in Rio de Janeiro

"O REI" IS PORTUGESE FOR; "THE KING"

By Malu Cursino
BBC News

Pelé, o Rei, has died.

Brazil and the world are grieving, and many of us mourn an idol we never saw on the pitch.

Being 23 years old, I was not around during the start, middle, or even the end of his glowing football career. But that does not matter. Pelé was and always will be a household name.

Growing up in Rio de Janeiro, a city of exuberance and vibrancy, football played a crucial role in our life.

Maracanã, where Pelé scored his thousandth goal, was emblematic of my day-to-day routine until I moved to the UK, aged 11.

We were always nearby. The buzz and frenzy during match days could be felt across the city. Traffic would be slower, restaurants busier, and the streets much louder.

Following the news of king Pelé's death last night, as I was writing for the BBC's tributes live page, my family group chat kept buzzing.

Four generations, all devastated in equal measure by the death of an idol. Words, emojis and GIFs expressed our shock - we are Brazilian, after all, and emotions tend to run high.

But what stuck with me was a comment from my aunt. She highlighted that Brazilian media, while discussing Pelé's life, used the phrase: "Our king is black."

   
Thousands of football fans from across Brazil flock to Rio de Janeiro to watch big matches at Maracanã

His stardom is unquestionable - and his influence worldwide says much more about him than his ethnicity and background.

But for Brazil's black community, hearing those words matter. A lot. And they signify a paradigm shift we have been going through for decades - one which Pelé played a crucial role in.

Because Pelé rose to the status of national treasure in a country with a deep history of slavery, and a legacy of division.


He regularly faced monkey chants on the pitch and had several racist nicknames. He once said that if he had stopped every game after a monkey taunt, he would have had to stop them all.

He was key to carving out space and recognition for black people in Brazilian football, his biographer Angelica Basthi has said - but he was never directly involved in the fight against racism.

Speaking to my mum, she tells me that Pelé "signifies greatness and contradiction".

Contradiction, because many Brazilians struggled with his resistance to speak out against racism.

Greatness, due to the path he forged for us, black Brazilians. Pelé rose to stardom despite Brazil's deeply rooted racism.

"He allowed us, black Brazilians, to see one of our own being acclaimed by the masses, considered a King, an icon for the whole country," my mum tells me.

"Pelé won his first World Cup only 70 years after slavery was abolished [in Brazil], in a country which continued, and continues, to treat black people as third-class citizens.


"He was an icon, who made us realise that it is possible to be a black man of international prominence."

Brazil abolished slavery in 1888. It is not ancient history for us, and anti-black racism continues to be rife.

Pelé's voice and gravitas could be heard in the commentary of big games long after the end of his career - particularly during World Cups.

"Even being quiet, he was able to contribute a lot towards Brazil's image worldwide," Edward Helal, my friend and a huge football fan, tells me.

Asked about the mood in Rio, Edward says most people are taking time to pay tributes and express their gratitude to the king of football.

Even now, during my annual visits back home, I dare not suggest having anything other than our world-renowned football commentary in the background on a Wednesday evening or Sunday afternoon.

I have Pelé to thank - and blame - for it.

Pelé’s final hurrah at New York Cosmos helped spark ‘sporting revolution’ across North America


By Ben Church, CNN
Published Sat December 31, 2022

Pelé joined the New York Cosmos in 1975 and played his last official game in 1977.Bettmann Archive/Getty Images
CNN —

He’d won three World Cups, scored goals galore and become a global icon, but Pelé wasn’t quite done yet, so off he went to the US and helped transform the sport of soccer in North America.

The Brazilian great was convinced to come out of retirement, signing in 1975 for the New York Cosmos for three more seasons.

Pelé had seemingly played his last professional game months prior to joining the North American Soccer League (NASL) side, hanging up his boots after making 638 appearances for his childhood club Santos.

It was almost unfathomable that Pelé would ever play for any other club apart from Santos, but he joined the Cosmos midway through the 1975 season on a $1.67-million-a-year contract, despite soccer struggling to generate much interest in North America at the time.

Pelé came, saw and conquered and by the time ‘O Rei’ (“The King”) left in 1977, he was an NASL champion who had helped spark a soccer boom.

“During three seasons with the Cosmos, Pelé helped transform the domestic landscape of the sport of soccer,” the Cosmos said in a statement after his death this week.

“Where once there had been baseball diamonds, now there were also soccer pitches.

“The Cosmos and their King not only started a sporting revolution in America, they also traveled the world to spread the Gospel of the Beautiful Game.”

The Brazilian speaks to then US President Jimmy Carter at the White House in 1977.Peter Bregg/AP
Pelé paved the way

Even now, after almost 50 years, Pelé’s influence is still being felt across both the men’s and women’s games in North America.

His move to Cosmos paved the way for other greats, such as Giorgio Chinaglia and Franz Beckenbauer, to follow suit and although the NASL ultimately folded in 1984, it set a blueprint for Major League Soccer (MLS) when it was established in 1993.

Superstars such as David Beckham, Gareth Bale, Thierry Henry and Zlatan Ibrahimovic have all followed in the footsteps of Pelé by helping grow the sport in North America by playing in the MLS.

Pelé opened the door for more superstars to play in the US.Peter Robinson/EMPICS/PA Images/Getty Images

Soccer in the US is now thriving, with the US National Men’s Team impressing during the Qatar 2022 World Cup.

Scouts from across the world are now looking at North America to discover new talent, with the sport cemented into the fabric of society and being naturally passed down through generations.

Much of the early work was done in the 1970s thanks to Pelé’s natural ability and infectious smile.

CNN’s Don Riddell spoke with supporters about Pelé during Qatar 2022, with one American saying the legend changed his life.

“Watching him was the first professional game I ever saw in 1975 and because of that, one of the reasons this is my 11th World Cup,” Clifton Broumand told CNN.

“Watching him and his ability hooked me to coming and watching soccer and the World Cup.”

Pelé lifts the NACL trophy after winning the title in his last season in the US.AP

In the season before Pelé joined Santos in 1975, the Cosmos’ largest attendance for a match was a little over 8,000 people.

During his final and most successful season in 1977, the average crowd was 42,689 for home games, including three occasions when the attendance was over 70,000, according to the Society for American Soccer History.

When Pelé joined the Cosmos he was aged 34 and he went on to score a total of 37 goals in 64 NASL matches.

“Pelé’s decision to bring his artistry to the United States with the New York Cosmos in the 1970s was a transformative moment for the sport in this country,” MLS Commissioner Don Garber said in a statement.

“As Pelé captivated fans throughout the US and Canada, it demonstrated the power of the game and the limitless possibilities for the sport.”

Beacon of light


The Cosmos’ first General Manager Clive Toye played a key role in getting the sport’s then biggest superstar to join the Cosmos.

A former journalist who was heavily involved in the NASL’s creation, Toye had a vision for the future of soccer in the US and believed Pelé was the man to make that dream a reality.

However, Toye and the Cosmos faced some stiff opposition from around the world for Pelé’s signature.

Heavyweight political intervention was even brought to bear, with Pelé saying then US Secretary of State Henry Kissinger had helped convince him to join the Cosmos.

“At that time, I had a lot of proposals to play in England, Italy, Spain, Mexico but I said no. After 18 years, I want to rest because I’m going to retire,” Pelé told CNN in 2011.

“Then appeared the proposal to go to New York because they want to make soccer big in the United States. That was the reason. I started my mission.”

Pelé attracted new fans to the sport during his time in New York.Colorsport/Shutterstock

Suddenly it was cool to watch soccer.

Matches were broadcast globally and the star-studded Cosmos team was the hottest ticket in town. The Comsos and Pelé even began touring around the world.

“No matter where we went, all around the world, Asia, Australia, Europe, all they wanted was Pelé,” former Cosmos player Dennis Tueart, who was signed to replace Pelé, though he played some exhibition matches with the Brazilian star, told Sky Sports.

“He had extraordinary vision, extraordinary athleticism […] he was without doubt, in my view, the best.”

Pelé still has a presence in New York City today. The ‘Pelé Soccer’ store was opened in 2019 and sits on the iconic Times Square, a location many fans flocked to after news of his death.

After the Cosmos won the NASL title in 1977, a farewell match against Pelé’s former team Santos was organized, with the Brazilian playing a half for both sides in what would be his final official game.

After the testimonial, he addressed more than 70,000 people inside a packed New York’s Giants Stadium, leading the crowd in a chant of “Love, love, love.”

A fitting end, perhaps, for a man who spread joy wherever he went and who helped establish soccer as a way of life in North America.


Pele invigorated US soccer, paved way for ‘94 World Cup, MLS

RONALD BLUM
NEW YORK
THE ASSOCIATED PRESS

Clive Toye travelled to Jamaica and walked unannounced into the hotel where the Brazilian club Santos was staying ahead of a friendly against the Reggae Boyz in January, 1971. Pele was sitting by the pool, and the New York Cosmos general manager began the cold call that changed U.S. sports history.

“You could go to Juventus, you could go to Real Madrid, yeah, you could win a championship. But so will other people,” the 90-year-old Toye recalled telling Pele. “You come to us, you can win a country and nobody else could do that except you.”

Dozens of meetings over four years led to Pele agreeing to sign with Cosmos in June ,1975. His 2½ seasons in New York put U.S. soccer on a path to holding the World Cup in 1994 and launching Major League Soccer two years later.

“There are probably two athletes that have transcended their sport and transcended sport overall in our lifetime,” MLS commissioner Don Garber said Thursday night after Pele’s death at the age of 82. “One was Muhammad Ali and the other was Pele.”

The Cosmos averaged 3,578 fans in 1974 – a figure that nearly tripled to 10,450 the next year, with people lining the sides of the Triborough Bridge approach to watch games at Downing Stadum on Randalls Island.

In 1976, the Cosmos averaged 18,227 at Yankee Stadium and then 34,142 at Giants Stadium in New Jersey the following year for Pele’s final season. Boosted by the Pele buzz – along with players Franz Beckenbauer and Giorgio Chinaglia – the Cosmos averaged more than 40,000 the following two years before a tailspin saw the league fold after the 1984 season.

From that first meeting in Kingston, where Toye brought along U.S. Soccer Federation’s Kurt Lamm for support, Toye travelled to Brazil several times and finally persuaded Pele to agree during a meeting in Brussels. The formal offer came a few days later in Rome.

Pele signed the contract in Bermuda for tax reasons, what Toye recalls as a US$2.7-million, three-year deal, and the Brazilian was introduced during a news conference at 21, a hangout for New York’s movers and shakers.

When Pele had led Brazil to his third and final World Cup title in 1970, the primary way to watch the tournament with English-language commentary in the U.S. was on closed-circuit television in arenas like Madison Square Garden. Toye and North American Soccer League commissioner Phil Woosnam had the league purchase U.S. rights that year for US$15,000 but couldn’t find a TV network that would agree to broadcast.

“There were still people, you’d say to them soccer, and they’d say, ‘What’s soccer?’” Toye said, speaking from his home in Mount Pleasant, S.C. “And then we’d talk to people about the World Cup, and they would say, ‘Oh, what’s the World Cup?’ This last World Cup you couldn’t bloody switch on any channel without seeing something about it.”

Pele was 34 when he joined the Cosmos and scored 37 goals in 64 regular and postseason matches. He agreed to countless interviews and promotional appearances as part of a mission to make soccer mainstream.

“The Cosmos was the spark that lit the fire that has become a conflagration of soccer in our country,” said Alan Rothenberg, a former U.S. Soccer Federation president and the head organizer of the 1994 World Cup. He had vivid memories of leaving the Plaza Hotel with Pele and jaywalking through traffic to Central Park.

“Cabs came screeching to a halt. They started screaming ‘Pele! Pele!’ It was like the Red Sea parted,” Rothenberg said.

Pele played for Santos from 1956-74 and for Brazil from 1957-71, making his mark on a sport that had largely bypassed an American fanbase fixated on Major League Baseball, the NFL, NBA, college football and college basketball.

“The NASL set the stage for what soccer in America is today, both from a grassroots perspective but also at the professional level,” Garber said. “He came here and said: This sport matters. I’m going to make it bigger than anybody ever dreamed it could be. And all of us who are in the sport today, whether a lover of the game or a player or administrator, we would not be where we are today if it wasn’t for Pele deciding to come to the United States.”

Sunil Gulati, another past USSF president and a member of FIFA’s ruling Council, first met Pele when he got an autograph at Dillon Stadium in Hartford, Conn., where the Cosmos played the Connecticut Bicentennials.

About 30 years later, Gulati accompanied Columbia women’s All-American soccer player Sophie Reiser to a suite at Hofstra because she wanted an autograph.

“Pele, one more, please?” Gulati recounted. “He turned to me and smiled and said, ‘There’s always one more.’ It was absolutely fantastic. He did everything with a smile.”



Pelé will be buried in 14-floor 'super-cemetery' with a museum and waterfall after lying-in-state on football pitch

31 December 2022


Pelé will be housed on the ninth floor of the super-cemetery. Picture: Alamy

By Adam Solomons

Pelé's coffin will occupy the ninth floor of a 14-storey super-cemetery after a burial parade that will stop outside his 100-year-old mother's house.

The three-time World Cup winner passed away on Thursday aged 82 after a long battle with bowel cancer.

Pelé will be housed in Ecumenical Necropolis Memorial, less than a kilometre away from home ground Vila Belmiro, where Pelé played almost his entire senior career for Sao Paulo state club Santos.

The memorial site is also home to a car museum, a waterfall and 14,000 high-security vaults.

Brazil's eminent football icon will lie-in-state in the centre circle of the Santos pitch for 24 hours, with thousands expected to visit the coffin.

It will then be paraded through the streets to Ecumenical Necropolis Memorial, stopping briefly at his bed-bound mother's home.

Read more: Harry Redknapp pays tribute to ‘main man’ Pelé

Read more: Tributes pour in for Pelé as daughter shares touching final photo with football legend


Pelé passed away on Thursday at the age of 82. Picture: Alamy

Pelé chose to occupy the ninth floor of the building in 2003, a nod to the shirt number his own father wore as a player.

Tens of thousands of Brazilians are expected to line the streets to see Pelé's coffin in what is likely to be one of the nation's biggest ever funerals.

The global superstar won three World Cups with the Brazilian national team between 1958 and 1970, and remains the only player ever to do so.


Pelé's coffin will stay on the pitch at Santos FC for 24 hours. Picture: Alamy

Pelé had been moved to end-of-life care at the Albert Einstein hospital in Sao Paolo after his body stopped responding to chemotherapy to treat bowel cancer.

His agent confirmed on Thursday that the iconic player had passed away.

Shortly after, Pelé's daughter Kely Nascimento, posted an heartbreaking final photo of him holding hands with family as he lay in hospital bed.

She wrote: "Everything we are is thanks to you.

"We love you infinitely. Rest in peace."


Pelé's life in 36 pictures  






Pelé is carried off the field by fans after Brazil defeated Italy in the final of the 1970 World Cup.Alessandro Sabattini/Getty Images









































































Christmas tragedy at M'sia wildlife park after head keeper, 49, gored to death by pygmy elephant

He left behind his wife and his three school-going children.

Fiona Tan |  December 31, 2022

 

A 49-year-old man was gored to death by a pygmy elephant in a Malaysia wildlife park.
Gored in the chest and abdomen

The incident happened at Lok Kawi Wildlife Park located in Kota Kinabalu in Sabah, Malaysia at about 8:30am on Dec. 25, 2022, The Star reported.

Joe Fred Lansou, who worked at the wildlife park, was alone in the elephant's enclosure and in the midst of treating an injured pygmy elephant calf before another adult elephant attacked him.

AFP quoted Sabah Wildlife Department director Augustine Tuuga as saying that the adult elephant "tusked [Lansou] very badly".

He was apparently pierced at least three times in the chest and abdomen by the tusks of a pygmy elephant named Kejora, also known as Joe by its nickname.

The attack left Lansou fatally wounded and he was pronounced dead at the scene.

Penampang police officers have classified the case as sudden death and ruled out any foul play, but are investigating the incident.

Head keeper who dedicated his life to endangered elephants

Lansou was the head elephant keeper at Lok Kawi Wildlife Park, where he lead a team of five staff members in managing the 16 pygmy elephants within the park.

Kejora was the sole survivor of a deadly poisoning incident in 2013 that killed a herd of 14 Borneo pygmy elephants, including Kejora's mother.

Lansou was known to be a "brave and daring" ranger that had been actively involved in caring for the elephants in captivity as well as those in the wild, The Star reported.

Borneo Wildlife Preservation paid tribute to Lansou in a Facebook post, stating that he was a "passionate, kind man who lived a life dedicated to caring for the lives of endangered Bornean elephants."

Image from Borneo Wildlife Preservation/Facebook.


Image from Borneo Wildlife Preservation/Facebook.

Image from Borneo Wildlife Preservation/Facebook.

Lansou leaves behind a wife and three school-going children.

"Too many elephants in captivity"

This is the first time that a Sabah Wildlife Department ranger was killed in an elephant attack, and conservation officials have dubbed the incident a Christmas Day tragedy.

Pygmy elephants, a distinct subspecies of mainland Asian elephants, are unique to Borneo island.

These animals are endangered and there are less than 2,000 left in the wild in Sabah.

The Star reported Malaysian social and environmental activist Jefferi Chang as commenting that there are "just too many elephants in captivity in Sabah".

He suggested for some of them to be sent to zoos overseas.

However, Tuuga noted that most of the 26 elephants in three wildlife facilities in Sabah, including the 16 at Lok Kawi Wildlife Park, would not be able to survive if they are released into the wild.

Kejora the elephant is currently being isolated "to avoid contact with the staff".

Culling the animal is not an option, Tuuga said, and some overseas zoos are reportedly prepared to accept Kejora.

Activists call for an inquiry

Following Lansou's death, Chang noted that such "unfortunate" incidents, where animals attack their handlers, are rare in zoos across the world.

He called on authorities to look into whether Sabah Wildlife Department has an "active and clearly observed standard operating procedure in place".

He added that a fatal incident can only occur if the management does not have the safeguards in place for its personnel to handle wild animals.

Sabah's tourism, culture and environment minister Jafry Ariffin said separately that the Sabah Wildlife Department had adequate standard operating procedures in place and described Lansou's death as a "very unfortunate" incident.

He later responded to calls by activists to conduct an inquiry into the incident and said: "We will have to discuss with the concerned parties (at the ministry)


Top image from Facebook of Seratu Aatai and Borneo Wildlife Preservation
RICH REACTIONARIES
Bolivians burn cars, buildings as anger widens over Camacho's arres

Protesters in Santa Cruz region attack buildings and block highways to protest the arrest of right-wing opposition leader Luis Fernando Camacho.

Protesters in parts of provincial capital torch cars and tires and hurl fireworks toward police forces. (AFP)

Protesters in Bolivia's Santa Cruz, a relatively wealthy farming region, have attacked buildings, burned cars and blocked highways as part of a 24-hour strike following the arrest of the regional governor, a right-wing opposition leader.

As night fell on Friday, protesters in parts of the provincial capital torched cars and tires and hurled fireworks toward police forces, who used tear gas to disperse the crowds.

During the day, around the city, largely peaceful groups had protested by blocking roads with tires, rocks and flags strung across streets as blockades.

The protests are the latest face-off between Santa Cruz, led by right-wing Governor Luis Fernando Camacho, and leftist President Luis Arce's government.

Camacho was detained on Wednesday on a charge of "terrorism" for his alleged involvement in 2019 political unrest that saw then-president Evo Morales resign and flee the country.

He was sentenced to four months of pre-trial detention late on Thursday and was transferred to a maximum security prison early on Friday.

Camacho has maintained his innocence and called his arrest and transport to La Paz, the country's capital, a kidnapping.

Prosecutors denied the arrest was a kidnapping or politically motivated.

READ MORE: Bolivia prosecutors call detained opposition leader a flight risk


'It was not a coup'


The governor became a face for the right-wing opposition movement as a civic leader who called for leftist Morales to step down in 2019.

On Twitter on Friday morning, Camacho's communications team said the fallout from the contested election "was not a coup, it was a fraud."

Camacho also led weeks-long protests snarling trade from the region through last month, calling for the government to move up a census date that would likely give Santa Cruz more political representation and tax revenues.

The government has not said how it will respond to Friday's roadblocks, though some military forces were spread throughout Santa Cruz late Thursday.

In the last round of protests, government-allied groups violently clashed with Camacho supporters.

READ MORE: Bolivia detains main opposition leader as tensions spike


Bolivia Protesters Burn Cars, Clash With Police After Governor Arrested
Trucks block a street as part of a "general strike" following the detention of Santa Cruz opposition governor Luis Fernando Camacho, for whom prosecutors are seeking pre-trial detention in connection to the 2019 political unrest, in Santa Cruz de la Sierra, Bolivia, December 30, 2022. REUTERS

Protesters in Bolivia's Santa Cruz, a relatively wealthy farming region, attacked buildings, burned cars and blocked highways as part of a 24-strike on Friday following the arrest of the regional governor, a right-wing opposition leader.


As night fell, protesters in parts of the provincial capital torched cars and tires and hurled fireworks toward police, who used tear gas to try to disperse the crowds.

Pedro Vaca, Special Rapporteur for Freedom of Expression for the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR), said in a post on Twitter he was receiving reports of "severe attacks" on the media, attributed to police deployments.

"I call on the authorities to give public instructions to their agents on the duty to guarantee freedoms of press, peaceful assembly and association," he said.

During the day, largely peaceful groups had protested around the city by blocking roads with tires, rocks and flags strung across streets as blockades.

The protests are the latest face-off between Santa Cruz, led by Governor Luis Fernando Camacho, and leftist President Luis Arce's government.

Camacho was detained Wednesday on a charge of "terrorism" for his alleged involvement in 2019 political unrest that saw then-President Evo Morales flee the country.


He was sentenced to four months of pre-trial detention late Thursday and was transferred to a maximum security prison early Friday morning.

Camacho has maintained his innocence and called his arrest and transport to La Paz, the country's capital, a kidnapping. Prosecutors denied the arrest was a kidnapping or politically motivated.

The governor became a face for the right-wing opposition movement as a civic leader who called for Morales to step down in 2019. On Twitter Friday morning, Camacho's communications team said the fallout from the contested election "was not a coup, it was fraud."

Camacho also led weeks-long protests snarling trade from the region through last month, calling for the government to move up a census date that would likely give Santa Cruz more political representation and tax revenues.

The government has not said how it will respond to Friday's roadblocks, though some military forces were spread throughout Santa Cruz late Thursday. In the last round of protests, government-allied groups violently clashed with Camacho supporters.

Meanwhile, some companies said they would pause sales while Camacho remained in jail.

Santa Cruz opposition governor Luis Fernando Camacho covers his face as he is escorted in a police car, as he is transferred to a prison in La Paz, after a Bolivian court sentenced him to four months of pre-trial detention, a day after his arrest in connection to 2019 social arrest that saw former leftist President Evo Morales flee the country, in La Paz, Bolivia, December 30, 2022. REUTERS

A man crosses a street blocked by demonstrators as part of a "general strike" following the detention of Santa Cruz opposition governor Luis Fernando Camacho, for whom prosecutors are seeking pre-trial detention in connection to the 2019 political unrest, in Santa Cruz de la Sierra, Bolivia, December 30, 2022. REUTERS


© Copyright Thomson Reuters 2022. All rights reserved.
‘Nowhere to be found’: Everything we know about missing Scientology leader David Miscavige

The mysterious leader behind the Church of Scientology is being sought by lawyers for three former members who are suing the religious sect alleging decades of abuse. Bevan Hurley reports



David Miscavige, the head of the Church of Scientology
(Rex Features)

Scientology leader David Miscavige is “nowhere to be found”.

Named as a defendant in a federal child trafficking lawsuit, Mr Miscavige has repeatedly dodged prosecutors who have tried to serve the 62-year-old 27 times in four months at Scientology properties in Clearwater, Florida, and California, the Tampa Bay Times reported.

Every time, security guards refused to accept the lawsuit and claimed not to know where Mr Miscavige lived or worked, court filings obtained by The Tampa Bay Times alleged.

Lawyers have resorted to sending Instagram messages to the church’s official account as they try to locate Mr Miscavige, attorney Neil Glazer said in a court filing, per the Bay Times.

According to journalist Tony Ortega, who has written about Scientology since 1995, Mr Miscavige has frequently tried to dodge lawsuits by altering his address between California and Florida.

RecommendedWomen in Afghanistan serving ‘life sentence’ under Taliban rule, Independent journalist says
Scientology leader David Miscavige can’t be found, lawyers say
Venezuelan opposition strips Guaidó of 'presidential' role

Despite being in charge of the controversial church since the death of church founder L Ron Hubbard in 1986, Mr Miscavige remains a mysterious figure who has largely stayed out of the public eye.

Who is David Miscavige?

According to an official church profile, Mr Miscavige’s official title is ecclesiastical leader of the Scientology religion.

The 62-year-old is also chairman of the Board Religious Technology Center (RTC), a corporation that controls the church’s trademarks and copyrights.

While the church claims to be a force for good through its charitable outreach and practice of dianetics, which is said to help treat mental illness, critics and former members have described it as an alleged “cult” that separates families, forces members into slavery, and extorts money from its followers.

The church flatly denies these allegations.

Mr Miscavige was introduced to Scientology by his father Ronald Miscavige in the 1960s, and quickly rose through the ranks of the Sea Org, a group of the most dedicated members that essentially serves as the church’s managerial arm.

He was mentored by church founder L Ron Hubbard, a former science fiction author, and assumed leadership of the church in 1987.

Mr Miscavige has overseen the rapid expansion of Scientology from its roots in southern California to now claim tens of millions of adherents worldwide.

In his first interview with ABC News in 1992, Mr Miscavige sought to dispel claims that former members were fearful of speaking out about the church.

“Every single detractor on there is part of a religious hate group called Cult Awareness Network and their sister group called American Family Foundation,” Mr Miscavige said according to a transcript of the interview.

“Now, I don’t know if you’ve heard of these people, but it’s the same as the KKK would be with the Blacks. I think if you interviewed a neo-Nazi and asked them to talk about the Jews, you would get a similar result to what you have here.”


Miscavige has overseen the rapid expansion of Scientology

(Getty Images)

After a decades long battle with the Internal Revenue Service, the church was granted tax-exempt status in the US in 1993.

“The war is over,” Mr Miscavige told a group of thousands of cheering Scientologists in a Los Angeles arena in 1993 after the IRS abandoned its investigations into the church and granted it tax exemption.

The ruling saved the church millions in taxes and confirmed its status as a religious entity in the US.

It has subsequently gained notoriety as former members who left the church began to detail the alleged abusive and coercive practices that the church supposedly subjected its followers to.

Mr Miscavige also faced long-running complaints from the medical and scientific communities over claims that Scientology could cure mental illness.

Church doctrine, written by its founder, proclaims that psychiatry is not only bogus, but evil, and promotes a “mind over matter” philosophy that claims attaining a “clear” state will eliminate any ills.

So-called auditors are assigned to each church member to go through past events with them to help “clear” any negativity.

Despite the many controversies, high-profile members including celebrities such as Tom Cruise and John Travolta continued to praise Scientology for having changed their lives.

Scientology now claims to have 11,000 churches in 180 nations, and millions of global followers.

The Miscavige family and Scientology


Mr Miscavige’s father Ron Miscavige left the church in 2012 after falling out with his son and complaining he had been forced to work in slave-like conditions for the church..

According to his 2016 book Ruthless: Scientology, My Son David Miscavige, and Me, the elder Miscavige claimed that Church members were “subjected to deprivation and violence” while detained at a punishment centre called “the Hole” - an accusation the Church has always denied.

According to a 2015 report in the Los Angeles Times, Ron Miscavige’s car was tracked, his emails read and he was followed.

David Miscavige with Tom Cruise, at the opening of a Scientology church in 2004.
(AP)

Florida-based investigator Dwayne Powell was arrested in 2013 near Milwaukee and allegedly told police he had been paid $10,000 through an intermediary, on behalf of the Church of Scientology, to follow Ron Miscavige “full-time”.

David Miscavige denied hiring the PI to follow his father. The church threatened to sue him over over his tell-all memoir.

In an interview with ABC News in 2016, Ron Miscavige said his estranged son “wasn’t always that way… He was a loveable kid, he had a great sense of humour. We got along great.”

Ron Miscavige died in 2021.

David Miscavige married wife Shelly in 1982. She has not been seen in public since 2007, leading to speculation about her wellbeing.

Former member Leah Remini, who has become an outspoken critic of the church and wrote a 2015 memoir Troublemaker: Surviving Hollywood and Scientology, filed a missing persons report for Shelly Miscavige with the LAPD in 2013.

The LAPD later said it had resolved the case and found her to be alive and well.

Mr Miscavige’s niece Jenna Miscavige Hill published a memoir Beyond Belief in 2013, which detailed her life in the highest ranks of the sect, her "disconnection" from family who were outside of the organisation, and her ultimate escape in 2005.

Miscavige and Tom Cruise

Tom Cruise was introduced to Scientology through his first wife Mimi Rogers.

While filming the 1990 film Days of Thunder, he reportedly fell in love with co-star Nicole Kidman, according to former Scientology senior member Mike Rinder, who writes about the period in his 2022 memoir A Billion Years: My Escape From a Life in the Highest Ranks of Scientology.

According to Mr Rinder, the church helped to engineer Cruise’s split from Rogers in order for him to be free to marry Kidman.


Nicole Kidman and Tom Cruise
(Getty Images)

Mr Miscavige was invited to the set of Days of Thunder, Mr Rinder writes, and assigned a trusted lieutenant, Greg Wilhere, to convince Rogers to go through with the divorce.

“Miscavige no doubt saw this as an opportunity to demonstrate his ability to make Tom’s wishes come true,” Mr Rinder writes.

The Top Gun star divorced Rogers in February 1990, and married Kidman later that year, with Miscavige acting as his best man.

A church spokesman has previously said Mr Rinder’s claims were “utterly ludicrous”, and said he was an “inveterate liar”.

The church requires members of its Sea Org to sign a one-billion year pledge, which former members have claimed is used to make children as young as 10 work for little or no money in virtual slavery.

Mr Rinder further writes that Sea Org members were assigned to carry out work on Cruise’s homes in Aspen, Colorado, install high-end audio/visual equipment at a property in Pacific Palisades, Beverly Hills, and his Santa Monica air hangar.

Cruise appeared at openings of new Scientology churches around the world, including in Madrid in 2004.

In a Scientology recruitment video the same year, Mr Cruise said it’s a “privilege to call yourself a Scientologist”.

“That’s what drives me: is that I know we have an opportunity to really help, for the first time, effectively change people’s lives. And I am dedicated to that. I am absolutely, uncompromisingly dedicated to that.”

Cruise has reportedly played down his Scientology links in recent years.

Scientology in popular culture

In the 2015 documentary Going Clear, filmmaker Alex Gibney profiled eight former Scientologists who were critical of the church’s practices.

Among the former members featured in the film is Oscar-winning director Paul Haggis, who had been a Scientology member since the 1970s until his departure in 2009.

In November, Mr Haggis was ordered to pay at least $7.5m to a woman who accused him of rape at a movie premier in 2013.

During the trial, jurors heard extensive testimony about the Church of Scientology, with Mr Haggis claiming members of the church had tried to discredit him.

Louis Theroux’s 2016 documentary My Scientology Movie shed further light on the church’s alleged indonctrination and disciplinary practices.

The lawsuits

Three former Scientologists filed a lawsuit in April alleging they were forced to work for the organisation from the age of 10 until adulthood for little or no pay, while suffering verbal and physical abuse.

Gawain Baxter, who is suing the church with wife Laura Baxter and a third plaintiff Valeska Paris, said in a statement released through his attorney that he was forced to sign a document at the age of six pledging to work for the Church of Scientology for one billion years.

He said he began working in low or unpaid labour for the Scientology’s Cadet Org from the age of 10 while being forced to attend “expensive indoctrination sessions”.

The Baxters later worked for the church’s military-style Sea Org before leaving in 2012.

“Growing up in Scientology, being separated from my family and subjected to severe verbal and physical abuse has scarred me in ways that I am still working through and uncovering,” Mr Baxter said in a statement released in April.

“All the while, Scientology continues to abuse and exploit its members, including young children, and does so with virtually unchecked power.”

Neil Glazer, an attorney for the plaintiffs, has asked the court to consider Mr Miscavige has been served and is in default at a court hearing scheduled in a Tampa federal court for 20 January.

“Miscavige cannot be permitted to continue his gamesmanship,” Mr Glazer wrote in a 13 December court filing, The Tampa Bay Times reports.

The Independent did not immediately hear back after making two requests for comment in relation to the allegations against Mr Miscavige in the lawsuit.

Friday, December 30, 2022

TUNISIA
Francophonie summit

The 18th Francophonie Summit of countries and regions where French is spoken, was held on the island of Djerba on November 20 and 21, under the theme of Connectivity in diversity: digital technology, vector of development and solidarity in the French-speaking world.

It marked the beginning of Tunisia’s two-year presidency of the International Organisation of Francophonie.

The summit discussed the new challenges facing Tunisia and its partners in the wake of profound global change — including economic challenges following the pandemic and the war in Ukraine.

2022, the rollercoaster year that left Tunisians hanging by a thread (thenationalnews.com)


Tunisia extends state of emergency for one 

month


CGTN

30/12/2022

Tunisian President Kais Saied decided on Friday to extend the state of emergency imposed across the country for one month.

"Saied decided to extend the state of emergency in the entire territory of the republic for one month, starting from January 1, 2023 until January 30, 2023," said the official gazette Journal of the Republic of Tunisia (JORT).

The state of emergency in Tunisia was first declared on November 24, 2015, following a bloody bomb attack on a bus of the presidential guards, which killed 12 agents.

Tunisian emergency law allows the authorities' exceptional powers, including carrying out home arrests, banning official meetings, imposing curfews, monitoring media and press, prohibiting assemblies, and media censorship without permission from the judiciary.

On February 18, Saied decided to extend the state of emergency imposed across the country until the end of 2022.


Editorial: The year of global disruption
Invasion, incompetence and inflation are three words that have characterised 2022

Opinion

The Russian war on Ukraine has defined 2022 but COVID is again rearing its head in China. Photo: AFP

By most measures, 2022 was a tumultuous year. A few words encapsulate what billions of people worldwide have experienced: massive disruption to their daily lives. The year was filled with economic, political and social disorder the extent of which has not been experienced for at least four decades.

Some of the remarkable events that characterised 2022 are likely to have lasting effects on politics, trade and international relations for many years to come.

Few analysts predicted that Vladimir Putin would invade Ukraine. Once the Russian army had crossed the border, many had no doubt it would overrun Ukraine within weeks and that geopolitical tensions would then ease. We now know, of course, how wrong these perceptions were.

The ongoing war has triggered a worldwide energy and food crisis, with the morally necessary EU and US sanctions against Russia a contributory factor. Not only were the supply chains of these critical commodities disrupted but high inflation threatened the livelihoods of millions who could not cope with the cost-of-living burden.

Even if the Ukraine war were to end in the coming weeks, international relations will not return to where they were a year ago. Sweden and Finland formally submitted applications to join NATO in May as the enthusiasm for neutrality shrunk in the face of the Russian expansionary threat.

For the same reason, Germany and the UK will be spending more on their security. The era of detente is practically over and the winds of another cold war are chilling east-west relations.

If there is a plus side from war, Russia’s violent disregard for civilised norms has prompted an outpouring of solidarity with the endlessly suffering and courageous people of Ukraine as well as a unity in the West arising from the recognition that, with leaders like Putin still around, democracy, peace and stability cannot be taken for granted.

Invasion is not the only defining term of 2022. Incompetence, of the political sort, is another. It describes the chaos that gripped the UK this summer. After Boris Johnson was kicked out and replaced by Liz Truss, financial markets passed their own vote of no confidence in the Conservative Party leadership by dumping Britain’s sovereign debt.

In China too, a combination of one-man decision-making, hard-headed resistance to the use of Western vaccines and a misguided U-turn in lockdown policy has seen COVID explode, posing a renewed threat to the wider world exactly three years after the virus first emerged.

Besides invasion and incompetence, one needs to add inflation to the mix. Central bankers admitted they had underestimated the threat of inflation in their quest to stabilise western economies. At last, they started to take action to protect vulnerable households from the devastating effects of rapidly rising prices.

The Federal Reserve raised interest rates seven times with a total increase of 425 basis points and signalled it will continue to raise rates in early 2023. The European Central Bank is likely to catch up as its rate increases have not been enough to bring inflation down to the targeted two per cent.

As most EU countries continue to struggle with slow growth, rising interest rates will only make their challenge to promote economic prosperity that much more daunting.

Meanwhile, the European Parliament scandal has again shown how urgent it is for the EU to restructure its governance.

One hopes that in 2023, the collective will of governments and leaders that favour democratic governance and international order prevail over those whose personal and national hubris blinds them to the common global good.

Trump’s Tax Returns Raise Questions About Campaign Promise 

BY NICK REYNOLDS 

NEWSWEEK

DECEMBER 30, 2022

Donald Trump made a lot of claims about his taxes on the campaign trail. On a debate stage with Joe Biden, he claimed to have paid millions of dollars in taxes in recent years, and that a reported $750 tax bill he'd reported against millions of dollars in income that was subsequently scrutinized by the media was merely a "filing fee." 

He also claimed that a Chinese bank account he'd maintained for business purposes had been closed before his run for the presidency, and that, as he and his press secretary, Sean Spicer, said in 2017, he would donate every cent of what was left of his taxpayer-funded $400,000 per year salary to charity.

 The release of the former president's tax returns Friday show that Trump kept open his foreign bank accounts—including in China—throughout his presidency.

 And he reported $0 in charitable giving on his 2020 tax return, according to various analysts, even after tweeting a photo of a check showing his payout of $100,000 to the National Park Service in August, about one month after a Washington Post story confirmed that he failed to donate a portion of his salary like he promised. 

Though his 2018 and 2019 returns showed charitable contributions of more than $500,000, and an additional $1.9 million to charity in 2017, a report on Trump's taxes noted that he provided little documentation to support his claims. 

There were other issues. On a debate stage before Fox News' Chris Wallace, Trump said he paid "millions of dollars" in taxes for 2016 and 2017, when he actually paid far less, reviving highly scrutinized claims that he prepaid those millions of dollars in taxes. 

Tax returns throughout his presidency show that Trump reported large losses he carried forward to all but eliminate his tax burden, including a $105 million loss in 2015 and a $73 million loss in 2016. Four years later, Trump claimed a refund of roughly $5.5 million. 

Meanwhile, Trump earned his income other ways. Beyond the millions of dollars in unpaid bills to municipalities that provided police and security for his rallies—plus more than $1.6 million in unpaid server hosting fees for his Truth Social revealed by Fox News over the summer—Trump regularly directed taxpayer dollars toward his various properties, including his home at Mar-a-Lago, and was long scrutinized for potential conflicts of interest over foreign dignitaries' use of his Washington, D.C. hotel.

Reports that he had potentially been double-dipping from his salary, government watchdogs claimed, fueled speculation he used the presidency to enrich himself as much as possible.

 "For years, when we'd point out Trump's business conflicts, his supporters would brush them off because he was donating his salary to charity," Citizens for a Responsible and Ethical Washington, a D.C. watchdog organization, tweeted Friday. "Turns out he wasn't." 

Newsweek reached out to Trump's office for comment.


Trump’s Taxes Are the Best Case Yet for Putting Him in Prison


PLAIN AND SIMPLE

This Friday news dump is a huge deal, and should be the final nail in his coffin.


David Cay Johnston

Published Dec. 30, 2022


Photo Illustration by Luis G. Rendon/The Daily Beast/Getty

Don’t let the cynics who know little about our tax system trick you into thinking there was nothing all that new or important in the six years of Donald Trump’s taxes released Friday by the House Ways and Means Committee.

In fact, even if some of it was previously teased by the committee, the dump includes a cornucopia of information that affects your wallet—including powerful evidence of criminal tax evasion.

Among other things, Trump’s tax returns make a strong case for restoring the law that until 1924 made all income tax returns public. Newspapers back then ran long lists showing the income of and taxes paid by the wealthiest Americans.

Knowing that your income, deductions, and tax paid will be publicly available can do far more to encourage honest tax-paying than audits, which are increasingly rare and increasingly superficial.

Not even 500 of the nearly 25,000 households reporting incomes of $10 million or more in 2019 were audited. That’s 2 percent—just 1 in 50. Only 66 audits were completed.

People like Trump who earn money from legal sources can cheat like crazy on their tax returns with almost nothing to fear. That’s because fewer than 600 people at all income levels are convicted of tax fraud in a typical year.

That makes the odds of conviction about 1 in 275,000 taxpayers. But the odds for business owners are much better (which is to say less), because most people convicted of tax crimes are drug dealers, politicians who took bribes, or people who paid bribes.

The IRS, as funded by Congress, spent far more money auditing the working poor than the 24,457 households with incomes of $10 million and up in 2019. But don’t get angry at the IRS. They are just the tax police, enforcing the law as they are instructed by Congress. If Congress tells the IRS to focus on high-income tax cheating, it will.

A little-known reason the IRS rarely audits someone like Trump, even if there are indications of brazen fraud, is that if an audit will not raise any revenue immediately, it looks bad on IRS performance reports.

Consider a rich business owner who fabricates deductions but who would still owe zero tax in the audited year even if those deductions were denied. That means an audit that will not generate any tax revenue. That’s also what Trump apparently did in 26 sole proprietor, or Schedule C, filings in the six years of released tax returns.

Denying the immediate deductions may mean more taxes in future years, but the way the IRS measures audit performance, it doesn’t take future taxes into account. As a result, many working and retired IRS auditors have told me over the years, the IRS typically decides to audit other filers who are more likely to generate taxes immediately, allowing multi-year tax cheats to slip away.

A simple change in how the IRS measures audit performance would end this practice that enables sophisticated multi-year tax cheating schemes.

Of course, if the IRS were given more money to hunt for rich tax cheats, rather than the working poor with children who apply for the Earned Income Tax Credit, we could stop a lot of high-level tax cheating. But since the rich are also the political donor class, don’t expect Congress to do much until it’s clear voters will throw out politicians who enable tax cheating by rich business owners.

The Trump tax returns also reinforce that Congress should pass a law directing the IRS to make public years of income tax returns for any presidential candidate who meets a low threshold—say, winning two primaries, or being nominated by a political party.

Congress cannot require any given candidate to disclose, because the Constitution’s only qualifying requirements are being a 35-or-older natural-born citizen. But nothing prohibits tax return disclosures based on objective criteria like a party nomination for president.

Another excellent reform would be making public the tax returns of Cabinet members, federal judges, Senators, and Representatives. It would surely deter the dishonest from seeking to hold office, which is a good policy.

Trump also turned a profit off a portion of the tax system, making $2.8 million profit off the Alternative Minimum Tax, or AMT.

He paid $15.9 million in Alternative Minimum Tax, while collecting $18.7 million in refunds in 2015 through 2020, as a Congressional staff analysis released last week showed. No one should be able to turn a tax into a profit center, but rich people and big companies do it all the time, as I showed in my book Perfectly Legal.

Since 1987, tens of millions of Americans have paid AMT, mostly married couples with children who are homeowners. Some paid because they spent huge sums on medical expenses to save the life of a family member.

Their AMT, by the way, was used to finance tax rate cuts for the likes of Donald Trump under the George W. Bush 2001 tax law. Think about that. Our Congress taxes the sick to help the rich.

Unlike those American families, Trump gets his AMT refunded.

That’s because of a 1992 law that Trump successfully lobbied Congress to restore after President Ronald Reagan signed a 1986 law denying those juicy AMT refunds to some real estate investors.

Voters should ask their representatives if they are with the politically sainted Reagan—or the disgraced Trump and his self-arranged tax favor.

Congress should also limit business deductions, so that everyone with positive income from wages, dividends, capital gains, and profits must pay a significant tax on their inflows of money.

That’s what the 1969 Minimum Tax did—before it was repealed almost two decades later. The Minimum Tax limited how many esoteric tax breaks could be piled one on top of another until there was nothing left to tax. Congress swiftly passed the Minimum Tax law after outraged Americans wrote more letters complaining about rich nontaxpayers in 1969 than about the Vietnam War.

People have the power to get better tax laws and better tax enforcement, but they must act. Sometimes, action is as simple as writing letters galore.

As for his now-notorious avoidance of audits, how did Trump duck what Biden, Obama, and every other president else going back to the late 1970s did not? Easy. Trump appointed both the IRS commissioner, Charles Rettig, and his boss, Treasury Secretary Steve Mnuchin.

Yes, other commissioners were on the job early in the Trump presidency. But Rettig and Mnuchin, I believe, violated their oaths of office by failing to ensure audits of Trump—except for a delayed, highly restricted examination of one year’s return.

Rettig is already out, but he should have been fired.

Looking forward, Congress should pass a law imposing serious fines and perhaps even prison time for any IRS commissioner or Treasury secretary on whose watch any presidential tax return isn’t promptly and thoroughly audited.

Congress could also pass a law that makes public all presidential audit findings. That would deter all but the most shameless tax cheats among presidential candidates.

Perhaps most glaring in the tax returns is that they include 26 Trump businesses—or imaginary businesses—with zero revenue and hundreds of thousands of dollars in tax deductions for expenses.

Unless Trump can produce records showing the expenses are real and meet other standards to be deductible, that’s fraud. That Trump did it 26 times as a candidate and as president is powerful evidence that he qualifies for prosecution by the federal government and New York State for criminal tax fraud.

Watch to see if Attorney General Merrick Garland, New York State Attorney General Leticia James, or Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg pursue what looks to me like a slam-dunk prosecution—or continue to enable Trump’s lawless conduct.



David Cay Johnston

davidcay@me.com
Arizona Doctors Cannot Be Prosecuted Under 1864 Abortion Ban, Court Says

The old law prohibited most abortions; the appeals court backed the state’s newer law that allows abortions at up to 15 weeks.

Democrat Katie Hobbs, then Arizona’s secretary of state, spoke at a Women’s March rally in support of abortion rights last October in Phoenix. Ms. Hobbs was recently elected governor.
Credit...Mario Tama/Getty Images

By Jack Healy
Dec. 30, 2022

PHOENIX — Arizona cannot prosecute doctors under an 1864 ban on abortions that would have outlawed the procedure in nearly every circumstance, a state appeals court ruled on Friday.

The ruling, which abortion-rights groups celebrated as a qualified victory, offers some clarity after months of uncertainty and legal fights over the fate of abortion in Arizona — and effectively allows licensed doctors in Arizona to perform abortions through the 15th week of pregnancy.

The decision resolved, for the moment, the question of which abortion ban in Arizona would be the law of the land in the wake of the Supreme Court’s decision overturning Roe v. Wade, which had guaranteed a constitutional right to abortion. The Supreme Court decision effectively sent the issue back to states to decide, and many have been caught up in litigation over state bans.

In Arizona, one law predating statehood outlawed the procedure entirely, except to save the mother’s life. Meanwhile, a law passed earlier this year by the state’s Republican-controlled legislature allows abortions through the 15th week of pregnancy, when the majority of women get them.

The ruling on Friday from a three-judge panel of the Arizona Court of Appeals declared that doctors in Arizona could not be prosecuted under the old territorial-era law, effectively rendering it toothless. The ruling also said the old and new laws were not in conflict, but that the new ban simply added another exception to the old one. The court said it sought to “harmonize” the state’s existing abortion laws and did not repeal the older law.

More on Abortion Issues in AmericaPost-Midterm Tactics: Supporters and opponents of abortion rights are re-evaluating their strategies after the midterms elections, girding for new rules, new opponents and new battlefronts.
When the Clinic Came to Town: After Roe fell, a quiet college community in Illinois became a crucial destination for abortion access. Not all residents are happy about it.
‘Parental Involvement’ Laws: As abortion access dwindles in America, these laws weigh heavily on teenagers — who may need a court’s permission to end their pregnancies.
Counting Abortions: As more women try to sidestep abortion restrictions, researchers are debating how well the existing data captures the full scope of the country’s post-Roe landscape.

The ruling could be appealed to the Arizona Supreme Court, a prospect that abortion opponents said they welcomed. Cathi Herrod, president of the Center for Arizona Policy, one of the main supporters of the 1864 ban, pointed out that state lawmakers had chosen not to repeal the prestatehood law, even as they passed subsequent abortion restrictions.

“I am confident Arizona’s pre-Roe law limiting abortion to cases where the mother’s life is at risk will be upheld,” she said.

But the incoming governor and attorney general of Arizona are unlikely to defend the 1864 ban. The two are both Democrats who are succeeding anti-abortion Republicans and appeared together during the campaign to denounce that law as a draconian violation of women’s rights.

Governor-elect Katie Hobbs criticized the court’s ruling on Friday for keeping the 15-week ban in place, pointing out that it has no exceptions for rape or incest.

“The decision to have a child should rest solely between a woman and her doctor, not the government or politicians,” Ms. Hobbs said in a statement.

Kris Mayes, who was declared the victor in the race for attorney general on Thursday after prevailing in a recount by just 280 votes out of about 2.5 million ballots cast, said she would “continue to fight for reproductive freedom.”

The outgoing attorney general, Mark Brnovich, a Republican, had argued that the 1864 ban could be enforced while abortion-rights groups fought to keep it from being revived. Mr. Brnovich’s office did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

During a few weeks over the summer when abortion providers believed they could be prosecuted under the territorial-era ban, abortions virtually ceased in Arizona and providers sent women out of state. A court then temporarily blocked the 1864 ban from being enforced while the court case proceeded, allowing abortions to resume.

“It has been a really convoluted environment,” Brittany Fonteno, the president of Planned Parenthood Arizona, said. “It is very clear, with no uncertainty, that abortion is safe and legal in Arizona through 15 weeks of pregnancy. The attorney general’s attempts to take us back to 1864 are not going to be allowed in Arizona.”


Jack Healy is a Phoenix-based national correspondent who focuses on the fast-changing politics and climate of the Southwest. He has worked in Iraq and Afghanistan and is a graduate of the University of Missouri’s journalism school. @jackhealynytFacebook