Saturday, November 25, 2023

MODI'S CURSED TUNNEL
Manual drilling likely in last stretch to rescue 41 trapped workers in Indian tunnel

Sat, November 25, 2023 

Tunnel where workers are trapped following a collapse in Uttarkashi, in the northern state of Uttarakhand


By Saurabh Sharma

SILKYARA, India (Reuters) - Efforts to rescue 41 workers trapped in a highway tunnel in the Indian Himalayas for two weeks will be further slowed as rescuers are considering drilling through the last 10 meters of debris manually, an official said on Saturday.

The heavy drill machine being used to break through the nearly 60 meters of debris was damaged on Friday and needs to be pulled out entirely, according to an official statement.

The men, construction workers from some of India's poorest states, have been stuck in the 4.5-km (3-mile) tunnel being built in Uttarakhand state since it caved in early on Nov. 12. Authorities have said they are safe, with access to light, oxygen, food, water and medicines.

A senior official involved in the rescue mission told Reuters that since the damaged machine cannot be used, they are planning to cut through the remaining debris manually.

The drill machine, called an auger, was damaged as it was being pulled out of the nearly 47-meter pipe inserted to bring out the trapped workers, after hitting an obstacle on Friday.

The machine broke at a joint and some parts are being cut so it can be pulled from the tunnel. Once it has been removed, drilling will be done manually, the official said.

Sunita Hembrom, who spoke to her trapped brother-in-law Birendra Kishku, 39, said that "everyone trapped inside is very worried".

"My brother in law told me that he has hasn't eaten any food since yesterday. We are very worried," she said.

Authorities have not said what caused the tunnel collapse, but the region is prone to landslides, earthquakes and floods.

The tunnel did not have an emergency exit and was built through a geological fault, a member of a panel of experts investigating the disaster said on Friday on condition of anonymity as they are not authorised to speak to media.

The rescue plan involves pushing a pipe wide enough to pull the trapped men out on wheeled stretchers. Rescue workers rehearsed the evacuation by going into the pipe and being pulled out on stretchers, a video clip provided by the authorities showed.

A second plan to drill vertically from atop the hill is also being pursued and the drilling machines are being assembled, the statement said.

The men have been getting cooked food since a larger lifeline pipe was pushed through earlier this week and the statement said they were sent 200 rotis or Indian round flat bread, lentils and vegetable curry.

More than a dozen doctors, including psychiatrists, have been at the site, talking to the men and monitoring their health.

They have been advised to do light yoga exercises, walk around in the 2-km space they have been confined to, and to keep speaking to each other. Rohit Gondwal, a psychiatrist, said they were also considering sending in playing cards and board games.

The collapsed tunnel is on the Char Dham pilgrimage route, one of the most ambitious projects of Prime Minister Narendra Modi's government.

It aims to link four key Hindu pilgrimage sites with 890 km (550 miles) of two-lane road, at a cost of $1.5 billion.

(Reporting by Saurabh Sharma in Silkyara; Writing by Krishn Kauhsik; Editing by Jacqueline Wong)

Agonising wait for rescue of Indian tunnel workers goes on as drill breaks down on final stretch

Shweta Sharma
Fri, November 24, 2023 

The operation to rescue 41 men trapped in a collapsed tunnel in India’s Uttarakhand state has been delayed again despite reaching the final stages after a drilling machine developed a snag.

The low-wage construction workers remained trapped for the 13th day as efforts to rescue them have been delayed by hurdles.

The rescue operation reached its final stages on Thursday but had to be suspended after a drilling machine hit an iron mesh of lattice girder – a collapsed structural element of the tunnel.

The platform on which the auger drilling machine was fixed was damaged and needed to be repaired, Deepak Patil, who is heading the rescue operation, said.

It forced the team to clear the path manually with gas-cutters, delaying the work by around six hours.

The latest rescue action bulletin by the authorities said the fresh push to insert the pipe started on Friday morning and the pipe reached an additional 1.8m.

But the auger was “pushed slightly back” after a minor vibration was noted in the collapsed structure. An estimated 15m (49ft) of the debris pile is left to be drilled through and a study using ground penetration radar shows there is no metallic obstruction for the next 5m, said Bhaskar Khulbe, a senior tunnel project official.

The bulletin said drilling with the auger machine would start after the welder’s team would manually cut the bent pipe obstructing the drilling.

Australian tunneling expert Arnold Dix, who arrived in India to assist with the rescue work, said the machine has broken down three times and it will be repaired by Friday morning.

“We are only just metres away from finding passage to have the men back. But the men are safe. The auger machine has broken down, it is being repaired and it should be back up tomorrow. The drilling machine has broken down three times,” he told ANI.

He said he was disappointed but not upset as men are safe and said “the men are coming out” in any case.

A part of the 4.5km (3 miles) Silkyara tunnel in Uttarakhand collapsed on 12 November in a landslide. A communication line was established with the trapped workers following the collapse and have been supplying food, water, snacks and oxygen through a pipeline that was laid for supplying water for the construction work.

On Tuesday, the first visuals of the 41 trapped workers emerged after an endoscopic camera was sent through a pipe which captured the workers’ first images since 12 November.

Authorities planned to retrieve the men by creating a micro-tunnel by sending multiple pipes. The width of the debris is estimated to be 60m (197ft) through which the rescue workers have to pass the pipes.

Meanwhile, anticipation has been building in the families of the trapped workers.

A family member of worker Sushil Sharma said he spoke with him on Friday morning and they are doing fine.

“Everyone is fine inside, and there are facilities. I asked him if he was facing any difficulties, and he said that there were no difficulties,” Haridwar Sharma told ANI.

“They are all just hoping to come out soon. Everything is available there... There is a facility for bathing too... I said that you would surely get out.”

The collapse of the tunnel in a region already prone to landslides has sparked debate among environmentalists about the damaging impact of construction projects in the already fragile Himalayas.

It was part of the Char Dham pilgrimage route, one of the most ambitious infrastructure projects of Indian prime minister Narendra Modi’s Hindu nationalist government, which aims to connect four Hindu pilgrimage sites in the mountains through 890km (550 miles) of roads at a cost of $1.5bn (£1.2bn).



Digging to rescue 41 workers trapped in a collapsed tunnel in India halted after machine breaks

Associated Press

Sat, November 25, 2023 




Rescuers rest at the site of an under-construction road tunnel that collapsed in Silkyara in the northern Indian state of Uttarakhand, Friday, Nov. 24, 2023. Rescuers are racing to evacuate 41 construction workers who have been trapped for nearly two weeks. 
(AP Photo)

NEW DELHI (AP) — Attempts to reach 41 construction workers stuck in a collapsed tunnel in northern India for two weeks were again stymied Saturday.

Rescuers had been working by hand to remove debris after the drilling machine they were using broke down a day earlier while making its way through the debris of rock, stones and metal, but the operation was halted on Saturday.

Arnold Dix, an international expert assisting the rescue team at the accident site in Uttarakhand state, said it is unclear when the drilling will be able to start again.

“The machine is busted. It is irreparable,” he told reporters. “The mountain has once again resisted the auger (machine).”

The workers have been trapped since Nov. 12 when a landslide caused a portion of the 4.5-kilometer (2.8-mile) tunnel they were building to collapse about 200 meters (650 feet) from the entrance. The mountainous terrain in the area has proven to be a challenge for the drilling machine, which had earlier broken twice as rescue teams attempted to dig horizontally toward the trapped workers.

The machine stopped working after it had drilled about 2 meters (6.5 feet) of the last stretch of 12 meters (40 feet) of rock debris that would open a passage for the workers to come out from the tunnel.

Rescuers have inserted pipes into the dug-out channel and welded them together to serve as a passageway from where the men would be pulled out on wheeled stretchers. About 46 meters (151 feet) of pipe has been put in so far, according to Devendra Patwal, a disaster management officer.

Meanwhile, a new drilling machine used to dig vertically was brought to the accident site Saturday.

The vertical dig is seen as an alternative plan to reach the trapped men, and the rescuers have already created an access road to the top of the hill. However, rescue teams will need to dig 103 meters (338 feet) downward to reach the trapped workers — nearly double the distance of the horizontal shaft.

Authorities have supplied the trapped workers with hot meals made of rice and lentils through a 6-inch (15-centimeter) pipe after days when they survived on dry food sent through a narrower pipe. Oxygen is being supplied through a separate pipe, and more than a dozen doctors, including psychiatrists, have been at the accident site monitoring their health.

Most of the trapped workers are migrant laborers from across the country. Many of their families have traveled to the accident site, where they have camped out for days to get updates on the rescue effort and in hopes of seeing their relatives soon.

The tunnel the workers were building was designed as part of the Chardham all-weather road, which will connect various Hindu pilgrimage sites. Some experts say the project, a flagship initiative of the federal government, will exacerbate fragile conditions in the upper Himalayas, where several towns are built atop landslide debris.

Large numbers of pilgrims and tourists visit Uttarakhand’s many Hindu temples, with the number increasing over the years due to the continued construction of buildings and roadways.


Uttarakhand tunnel collapse: Machine repairs prolong ordeal for trapped Indians
BBC

Fri, November 24, 2023

The rescue operation has been delayed several times

Rescue work to save 41 workers trapped in a tunnel in India's Uttarakhand state has been delayed again because of a problem with the drilling machine.

The US-made machine is being used to drill through the debris to create an escape route for the workers.

Officials say the machine is being repaired and that drilling work is likely to restart on Friday.

The workers have been stuck inside the tunnel for 12 days after a portion of it collapsed due to a landslide.

A section of the 4.5km (3 miles) Silkyara tunnel in the Indian Himalayas caved in on 12 November.

Contact was established with the trapped men shortly thereafter, and they have been receiving oxygen, food, and water ever since.

Rescuers to drill new tunnels for trapped India workers


The unfolding drama of India's tunnel rescue mission

Rescue officials had earlier announced that they would be able to extricate the men by Thursday morning. But the operations have been delayed after the latest technical glitch.

Bhaskar Khulbe, a former advisor to the prime minister's office actively involved in the rescue operations, told the media that the platform supporting the drilling machine had weakened, requiring an entire night of repairs throughout Thursday.

On Friday, a government release said that the platform of the machine had been reinforced using concrete and that the machine would be reassembled shortly.

The machine is drilling a hole into a 60m (197ft) debris wall that is preventing the workers from escaping the tunnel.

Authorities have been working to send multiple pipes of differing widths through the debris to create a micro-tunnel through which the workers can be brought out.

The plan is to wheel the workers out on stretchers through the pipes.

But the operation is a challenging one due to the presence of rocks, stones and metal inside the debris.

The operation was stalled on Wednesday too after workers encountered a thick metal rod which had to be cut using gas cutters.

Rescuers have drilled through about three-quarters of the debris so far, but it's unclear how long it will take for them to dig through the remaining part.


Rescuers are working on multiple plans to reach the workers

Speaking to reporters on Thursday, Lieutenant General Syed Ata Hasnain, a member of the National Disaster Response Force, said it was "difficult to put a timeline on such a complex operation".

"A lot of it depends on what the rescuers encounter while drilling through the debris," he said.

Arnold Dix, a tunnelling expert helping with the rescue work told reporters, that the machine had broken down thrice during the days-long rescue operations.

"We're the length of a bus away [from the trapped men]," he said. "We were hoping to see them this morning but it looks like the mountain has different ideas," he said.

The mountainous area is also prone to landslides and earthquakes, which is further hampering rescue efforts.

In the meantime, ambulances have been kept on standby outside the tunnel. Officials say the aim is to pull the workers out to safety and shift them to the nearby hospital as quickly as possible.


India - Uttarakhand map




Race to rescue 41 Indian workers trapped inside tunnel is delayed again

Michael Dorgan
Fri, November 24, 2023

Race to rescue 41 Indian workers trapped inside tunnel is delayed again


A frantic battle to rescue 41 construction workers trapped in a tunnel in northern India has faced fresh delays due to a problem with a drilling machine, with officials warning that the next 24 hours could be critical to their chances of survival.

The workers have been trapped beneath a collapsed road tunnel in the Uttarkashi district of India's Uttarakhand state for 12 days after a portion of it collapsed due to a landslide.

The platform on which the U.S.-made auger machine has been mounted became destabilized after developing cracks, according to the Times of India.


The 25-ton platform is being reinforced with concrete with drilling expected to resume later on Friday.

A crane carries a part of a drilling machine being used to rescue construction workers in India. The platform on which the U.S.-made Auger machine has been mounted became destabilized after developing cracks.

The machine is being used to drill through the debris in order to create an escape route consisting of a tunnel of pipes welded together. Once it is in place, rescue teams hope the workers can escape to freedom.

The plan is to wheel the workers out on stretchers through the pipes, according to the BBC.

The auger machine has a drilling capacity of up to 16 feet per hour and is equipped with a 2.9-foot diameter pipe to clear debris. At times, drilling is slowed down by the pile of rubble.

Rescue teams are required to drill down about 195 feet to reach the trapped workers. They are currently about 30 feet away and in the final phase of the operation.

Rescue personnel prepare to enter the tunnel.

The construction workers have been trapped since Nov. 12 when a landslide caused a portion of the 2.7-mile Silkyara tunnel they were building to collapse about 500 feet from the entrance. The hilly area is prone to landslide and subsidence.

The workers had been helping to construct a section of a 424-mile road connecting various Hindu pilgrimage sites in the area. The mountainous topography has several Hindu temples that attract pilgrims and tourists.

Shortly after the collapse, rescue personnel were able to establish contact with the workers, and they have been able to send them oxygen, food and water.

A view of the entrance to the collapsed tunnel in the Uttarkashi district of India's Uttarakhand state. Rescue efforts have been delayed due to a problem with a drilling machine.

It is the latest setback in the rescue operation.

The operation was stalled on Wednesday after workers encountered a thick metal rod, which had to be cut using gas cutters, the BBC reported.

Officials commandeered the U.S. machine last week after the initial one they were using was too slow at pushing through the debris.

The Associated Press contributed to this report.

Rescuers in India trying to evacuate 41 workers from a collapsed tunnel are delayed again
Associated Press
Updated Fri, November 24, 2023 



Rescuers rest at the site of an under-construction road tunnel that collapsed in Silkyara in the northern Indian state of Uttarakhand, Friday, Nov. 24, 2023. Rescuers are racing to evacuate 41 construction workers who have been trapped for nearly two weeks
. (AP Photo)

UTTARKASHI, India (AP) — Rescue teams trying to reach 41 construction workers trapped in a collapsed tunnel in northern India for nearly two weeks stopped drilling again Friday after their boring machine hit a new metal obstruction in rock debris, further delaying efforts.

Devendra Patwal, a disaster management officer, said it may take the rescuers several hours to cut the metal object and resume the final phase of digging at the accident site in Uttarakhand state.

Patwal said the machine was stopped after it had drilled about 2 meters (6.5 feet) of the last stretch of 12 meters (40 feet) of rock debris that would open a passage for the trapped workers to come out.

On Thursday, the platform of the machine became unstable while boring and halted the digging, said Kirti Panwar, a Uttarakhand state government spokesman. It resumed drilling Friday evening, Panwar said.

Panwar could not say how long it would take to complete the drilling and to bring the construction workers out. They have been trapped since Nov. 12, when a landslide caused a portion of the 4.5-kilometer (2.8-mile) tunnel they were building to collapse about 200 meters (650 feet) from the entrance.

As the rescue operation stretched into the 13th day, teams had drilled through 46 meters (151 feet) and needed to excavate up to 12 meters (40 feet) more to create a passageway, Panwar said.

Before the work resumed Friday, rescuers manually dug through debris to remove pieces of metal and prevent further damage, he said.

The rescue teams also are inserting pipes into the dug-out channel and welding them together to serve as a passageway. About 46 meters (151 feet) of pipe has been put in so far, according to Panwar. Members of the National Disaster Response Force plan to bring the workers out one by one on stretchers that have been fitted with wheels.

The mountainous terrain in the area has proven to be a challenge for the drilling machine, which broke down last weekend as rescue teams attempted to dig horizontally toward the trapped workers. The machine’s high-intensity vibrations also caused more debris to fall.

The drilling had to stop again on Wednesday after the boring machine hit a metal girder, causing some damage to its blades.

Authorities have supplied the trapped workers with hot meals made of rice and lentils through a 6-inch (15-centimeter) pipe after days of surviving on dry food sent through a narrower pipe. Oxygen is being supplied through a separate pipe.

Most of the trapped workers are migrant laborers from across the country. Many of their families have traveled to the accident site, where they have camped out for days to get updates on the rescue effort and in hopes of seeing their relatives soon.

“We are all waiting here, hoping they come out,” Haridwar Sharma, whose brother, Sushil, is among the workers, said. “It is not in our hands ... the administration is at it, the machinery is there. With God’s blessing, we are hopeful.”

Officials earlier released a video from a camera pushed through the pipe that showed the workers in their construction hats moving around the blocked tunnel while communicating with rescuers on walkie-talkies.

The tunnel the workers were building was designed as part of the Chardham all-weather road, which will connect various Hindu pilgrimage sites. Some experts say the project, a flagship initiative of the federal government, will exacerbate fragile conditions in the upper Himalayas, where several towns are built atop landslide debris.

Large numbers of pilgrims and tourists visit Uttarakhand's many Hindu temples, with the number increasing over the years due to the continued construction of buildings and roadways.

14 metres to freedom: Final push to free Indian tunnel workers

Jalees ANDRABI

Fri, November 24, 2023 

Prayers have been held for the local Hindu deity Boukhnag for the safe release of the trapped workers (Arun SANKAR)


Just a few metres of rock and earth separate Indian rescue teams from 41 workers who have been trapped inside a collapsed road tunnel for nearly two weeks, officials said Friday, vowing to get all the men out safely.

After a series of rapid advances, hopes that the men's freedom was imminent were dashed late Wednesday when the drilling machine powering through tonnes of rock and concrete ran into metal rods, but those have now been cleared.

An AFP reporter could see sparks flying as workers in the entrance of the tunnel welded together the final sections of steel pipe, to make the tube that will provide a safe exit for the trapped workers.

Rescue teams have stretchers fitted with wheels ready to pull the exhausted men through 57 metres (187 feet) of pipe once it has been driven through the final section of rubble blocking their escape.

"We have to (drill) 14 metres further inside the tunnel," Bhaskar Khulbe, a senior government official overseeing rescue efforts, told reporters on Friday, adding that the "trapped workers are in good frame of mind".

Officials have repeatedly predicted they were within a few hours of a breakthrough, but a government statement has also noted that any timeline is "subject to change due to technical glitches, the challenging Himalayan terrain, and unforeseen emergencies".

Ambulances are on standby and a field hospital has been prepared to receive the men, who have been trapped since a portion of the under-construction Silkyara tunnel in the Himalayan state of Uttarakhand caved in 13 days ago.

- 'Get these brave men out' -

Syed Ata Hasnain, a senior rescue official and retired general, said their efforts were "like battle".

"By any means, we must get these brave men out", he told reporters on Friday afternoon, adding that "all resources" needed were being utilised.

"This is a war that is being fought to save the sons of India who have been toiling up there in the mountains," Hasnain said, adding that the final stretch was critical.

"We are going to be very, very careful in further progress", he said.

The area outside the tunnel has been a flurry of activity, with worried relatives gathering and rescue teams stopping to pray at a Hindu shrine erected at the entrance.

National Disaster Response Force chief Atul Karwal said his teams had been rehearsing how -- once the steel pipe breaks through -- they would bring the men out as quickly and safely as possible.

"The boys will go in first," he said Thursday. "We have put wheels under the stretchers so that when we go in, we can get the people out one by one on the stretcher -- we are prepared in every way."

Rescue efforts have been hit with repeated delays caused by falling debris, fears of further cave-ins and drilling machine breakdowns.

Arnold Dix, president of the International Tunnelling and Underground Space Association, who is at the site assisting the rescue, said engineers had even faced having to cut through construction vehicles buried in the earth when the roof first collapsed.

Uttarakhand chief minister Pushkar Singh Dhami said work was on a "war footing".

"We are trying to overcome all the obstacles soon, and bring all the workers out safely," Dhami said Friday.

bur-pjm/leg

Race to rescue 41 Indian workers trapped inside tunnel is delayed again

Michael Dorgan

Fri, November 24, 2023 

Race to rescue 41 Indian workers trapped inside tunnel is delayed again


A frantic battle to rescue 41 construction workers trapped in a tunnel in northern India has faced fresh delays due to a problem with a drilling machine, with officials warning that the next 24 hours could be critical to their chances of survival.

The workers have been trapped beneath a collapsed road tunnel in the Uttarkashi district of India's Uttarakhand state for 12 days after a portion of it collapsed due to a landslide.

The platform on which the U.S.-made auger machine has been mounted became destabilized after developing cracks, according to the Times of India.

The 25-ton platform is being reinforced with concrete with drilling expected to resume later on Friday.

A crane carries a part of a drilling machine being used to rescue construction workers in India. The platform on which the U.S.-made Auger machine has been mounted became destabilized after developing cracks.

The machine is being used to drill through the debris in order to create an escape route consisting of a tunnel of pipes welded together. Once it is in place, rescue teams hope the workers can escape to freedom.

The plan is to wheel the workers out on stretchers through the pipes, according to the BBC.

The auger machine has a drilling capacity of up to 16 feet per hour and is equipped with a 2.9-foot diameter pipe to clear debris. At times, drilling is slowed down by the pile of rubble.

Rescue teams are required to drill down about 195 feet to reach the trapped workers. They are currently about 30 feet away and in the final phase of the operation.

Rescue personnel prepare to enter the tunnel.

RAILROAD BRIDGE PLATFORM COLLAPSE LEAVES AT LEAST 26 VICTIMS DEAD, OTHERS INJURED

The construction workers have been trapped since Nov. 12 when a landslide caused a portion of the 2.7-mile Silkyara tunnel they were building to collapse about 500 feet from the entrance. The hilly area is prone to landslide and subsidence.

The workers had been helping to construct a section of a 424-mile road connecting various Hindu pilgrimage sites in the area. The mountainous topography has several Hindu temples that attract pilgrims and tourists.

Shortly after the collapse, rescue personnel were able to establish contact with the workers, and they have been able to send them oxygen, food and water.

A view of the entrance to the collapsed tunnel in the Uttarkashi district of India's Uttarakhand state. Rescue efforts have been delayed due to a problem with a drilling machine.

It is the latest setback in the rescue operation.

The operation was stalled on Wednesday after workers encountered a thick metal rod, which had to be cut using gas cutters, the BBC reported.

Officials commandeered the U.S. machine last week after the initial one they were using was too slow at pushing through the debris.

The Associated Press contributed to this report.


'Like battle': Indian rescuers strive to free 41 trapped workers

Jalees ANDRABI
AFP
Thu, November 23, 2023 


Rescue teams pause for a rest outside the tunnel entrance (Arun SANKAR)

Ambulances were on standby Thursday as Indian rescuers dug through the final metres of debris separating them from 41 workers trapped in a collapsed road tunnel for nearly two weeks.

Rescue teams have specially fitted stretchers with wheels, ready to pull the exhausted men out through 57 metres (187 feet) of steel pipe -- once it is driven through the final section of the tonnes of earth, concrete and rubble blocking their escape.

Emergency vehicles and a field hospital stood ready, preparing to receive the men who have been trapped since a portion of the under-construction tunnel in the Himalayan state of Uttarakhand caved in 12 days ago.

"We have done rehearsals on how to get people safely out," National Disaster Response Force chief Atul Karwal told reporters Thursday.

"The boys will go in first," he said. "We have put wheels under the stretchers so that when we go in, we can get the people out one by one on the stretcher -- we are prepared in every way."

But rescue efforts have been hit with repeated delays, including more debris falling, fears of further cave-ins and drilling machine breakdowns, as progress on Thursday was slowed by further mechanical problems.

- 'Himalayan geology is the enemy' -

"The 10 to 12 metres (32 to 39 feet) remaining... we don't know what can come up, but we are ready to handle it," Karwal said, adding that the trapped men were "keeping up their morale".

Uttarakhand chief minister Pushkar Singh Dhami said the work was on a "war footing", with a "team of doctors, ambulances, helicopters and a field hospital" set up.

Syed Ata Hasnain, a senior National Disaster Management Authority official, refused to say when the men might be freed.

"This is like battle," the retired general told reporters. "You cannot put a timeline on it. In battle, you don't know what the enemy is going to do.

"Here, the land is your enemy. Himalayan geology is the enemy... it is very challenging work."

Experts have warned about the impact of extensive construction in Uttarakhand, large parts of which are prone to landslides.

"The rescuers and the workers stuck inside are at equal risk," Hasnain added.

Arnold Dix, president of the International Tunnelling and Underground Space Association, told AFP while it was "not nice" the men were trapped, that fact they were safe was a "gift."

"Normally when I am responding to a rescue, there is some flooding or we're running out of oxygen or something terrible is happening," he said, noting the areas where the men were was stable.

- Prayers for safe release -


The area was a flurry of activity with worried relatives gathered outside the site, where a Hindu shrine has been erected, with a priest holding prayers for the safe rescue of the trapped men.

"The day they will come out of the tunnel, it will be the biggest, happiest day for us," said Chanchal Singh Bisht, 35, whose 24-year-old cousin Pushkar Singh Ary is trapped inside.

In case the route through the main tunnel entrance does not work, rescuers also started blasting and drilling from the far end of the unfinished tunnel, nearly half a kilometre (over a quarter of a mile) long.

Preparations have also been made for a risky vertical shaft directly above.

The workers were seen alive for the first time on Tuesday, peering into the lens of an endoscopic camera sent by rescuers down a thin pipe through which air, food, water and electricity are being delivered.

Though trapped, they have plenty of space, with the area inside 8.5 metres high and stretching about two kilometres in length.

The tunnel is part of Prime Minister Narendra Modi's infrastructure project aimed at cutting travel times between some of the most popular Hindu sites in the country, as well as improving access to strategic areas bordering rival China.

bur-pjm/leg/ash-pjm/bfm
Aftershocks from devastating 1886 Charleston earthquake may still be hitting the US today

Patrick Pester
Fri, November 24, 2023

A house damaged in the August 31, 1886 earthquake. Charleston, South Carolina, ca. September, 1886. .


North America might still be experiencing aftershocks from massive earthquakes that hit the continent over 200 years ago, a new study has found.

Aftershocks are typically small earthquakes that strike after a major earthquake as a fault, which slipped to cause the main earthquake, readjusts. They normally hit within days to years of the initial seismic event, but some researchers believe they can keep happening for centuries.

In a new study, published Nov. 7 in the Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth researchers looked at the origins of earthquakes in what geologists call stable North America — the central and eastern U.S. and part of eastern Canada that are located away from plate boundaries — where earthquakes are less common. The authors identified earthquakes that appear to be aftershocks from major earthquakes that struck the Missouri-Kentucky border between 1811 and 1812, as well as the 1886 Charleston earthquake that hit South Carolina.

Related: Simultaneous rupture of faults triggered massive earthquake in Seattle area 1,100 years ago — and it could happen again

To establish whether modern earthquakes in this region are caused by long-lived aftershocks, background seismicity — the normal background rate of earthquakes, or seismic activity, researchers would expect in a region — or both, the researchers looked at pairs of seismic events linked in the earthquake records through distance, time and magnitude.

They looked at earthquakes that occurred within a 155-mile-radius (250 kilometers) from each of the major historic quakes. If an earthquake hit close enough to the original epicenter, the authors say it could be considered an aftershock.

"If the distance between a pair of earthquakes is closer than expected from background events, then one earthquake is likely the aftershock of the other," lead author Yuxuan Chen, a geoscientist at Wuhan University in China, said in a statement.

The researchers found that three large earthquakes that happened in 1811 and 1812 may have been responsible for around 23% of earthquakes that occurred in the New Madrid seismic zone — which covers parts of Missouri, Arkansas, Tennessee, Kentucky and Illinois — between 1980 and 2016. In South Carolina, the researchers linked up to 72% of present-day earthquakes to the 1886 Charleston earthquake, a magnitude of around 7 event that devastated the region and was responsible for the deaths of 60 people.

However, Susan Hough, a geophysicist in the Earthquake Hazards Program at the U.S. Geological Survey, who was not involved in the research, said the distribution of earthquakes across the landscape could be influenced by factors unrelated to aftershocks, such as steady movement along a fault, called creep.

RELATED STORIES

500-year-old Hebrew note reveals 'lost' earthquake swarm in Italy

Earthquake reveals giant Aztec snakehead beneath Mexico City university

California's supervolcano has a massive lid that causes swarms of earthquakes

"In some respects, the earthquakes look like aftershocks if you look at the spatial distribution, but earthquakes could be tightly clustered for a couple of reasons," she said in the statement. "One is that they're aftershocks, but also you could have a process of creep going on that's not part of an aftershock process. Exactly what their results mean is still open to question."

The researchers' findings suggested that earthquakes are likely a mix of aftershocks and background seismic activity, with background seismic activity the dominant cause of earthquakes in at least two of the three areas studied. Lots of background seismic activity could mean strain is accumulating and big earthquakes could strike in the future. "To come up with a hazard assessment for the future, we really need to understand what happened 150 or 200 years ago," Hough said.
Ex-CNN chief fronting Abu Dhabi’s Telegraph bid accuses critics of ‘slinging mud’

James Warrington
Fri, 24 November 2023 

Jeff Zucker

The US media executive fronting an Abu Dhabi takeover of The Telegraph has promised he will guarantee editorial independence, even as he accused rivals of “slinging mud” to derail the bid.

Jeff Zucker, the former CNN chief, has emerged as a frontrunner in the race with a swoop backed by Sheikh Mansour bin Zayed Al Nahyan, vice-president of the United Arab Emirates.

But the approach, which is funded through a £1.2bn debt deal with the Barclay family, has stoked concerns about the United Arab Emirates’ (UAE’s) record of censorship.


Mr Zucker said he would “make sure that [the Government] understand that we’re prepared to make commitments that should assuage anyone’s concerns”.

Sky News reported that the undertakings would be legally binding and would also apply to The Spectator magazine, which is also part of the planned deal.

However Mr Zucker also appeared to dismiss criticisms of the plans that have been published across Fleet Street. The plan has sparked anger among rival bidders, which include the Daily Mail publisher DMGT. Rupert Murdoch, owner of The Times, has been pursuing The Spectator.

Mr Zucker said: “There’s a reason that people are slinging mud and throwing darts – [it’s] because they want to own these assets. And they have their own media assets to try to hurt us.”

His pledges to guarantee editorial independence highlight efforts by RedBird IMI, the investment fund he leads, to calm mounting concerns over its interest in The Telegraph.

In addition to its non-democratic governance, the UAE has also come under criticism for its track record of media censorship.

Culture Secretary Lucy Frazer has said she is minded to issue a Public Interest Intervention Notice (PIIN), which would trigger regulatory scrutiny of the bid.

This would examine a review of accurate presentation of news and free expression of opinion would be maintained, as well as ensuring there is a plurality of views and owners in the media sector.

Lloyds Banking Group seized control of The Telegraph and The Spectator in June by sending in receivers after the Barclay family failed to repay debts.

Lloyds last month launched an auction run by Goldman Sachs. However, this has since been halted while the bank considers the complicated loan-based offer that would see the Barclay family repay its debt and ownership of The Telegraph immediately transferred to RedBird IMI.

US national security committee investigates Abu Dhabi investors



Michael Bow
Fri, 24 November 2023 

Abu Dhabi

US national security officials are vetting a string of takeovers by Abu Dhabi investors over fears about its close ties to China.

The Committee on Foreign Investments in the United States (CFIUS), a secretive government group which scrutinises foreign takeovers of US companies, has ramped up the number of probes into Gulf sovereign funds in recent months.

Officials are concerned that takeovers of sensitive US assets from funds in the Gulf could harm national scrutiny because of China’s growing influence in the region. China and the UAE in particular have fostered much closer relations in recent months, spooking US officials.

Deals involving Abu Dhabi funds are particularly sensitive because national security and investment decisions are made by a small band of royals, Bloomberg reported.

Takeovers by groups including the Abu Dhabi Investment Authority and Mubadala Investment Company are reportedly at the centre of the investigations.

CFIUS is already scrutinising Mubadala’s proposed $3bn (£2.4bn) takeover of US asset manager Fortress Investment Group.

Washington’s growing scepticism of the UAE has been prompted by a surge of Gulf investment into China. The region has ploughed $2.3bn into the region so far this year, up from just $100m last year, according to figures from Global SWF, cementing the burgeoning relationship.

UAE’s relations with the Biden administration have also been frayed after US spies discovered China was secretly building a suspected military facility at a Abu Dhabi port. The plan was later abandoned after US pressure.

CFIUS has similar powers as the UK’s National Security and Investment Act. It can veto deals considered as a threat to national security.

President Biden last year ordered CFIUS to put a larger emphasis on scrutinising key technologies such as quantum computing and AI.

The Biden administration’s colder approach to UAE acquisitions stands in sharp contrast to previous UK investment policy.

The UK Office for Investment signed a deal with Mubadala Investment Company in 2021 pledging to attract £10bn of UAE investment into the UK until 2026.

Middle Eastern investors were among the most active investors globally last year, with ADIA splurging $26bn and Mubadala splashing out $11bn, according to Global SWF.

Mubadala owns UK companies such as smart metre maker Calisen, Cityfibre and software company Huboo.

The US Treasury, ADIA and Mubadala were contacted for comment.
ROFLMAO
UK
Police to hand out leaflets to pro-Palestinian demonstrators spelling out what they cannot chant
FINE THE COPPERS FOR LITTERING

Martin Evans
Fri, 24 November 2023 

Pro-Palestinian supporters will be warned how to avoid breaking the law when chanting - Paul Grover

Police will hand out thousands of leaflets to pro-Palestinian marchers this weekend, warning them what phrases and slogans they are not allowed to use.

More than 100,000 people are expected to gather in central London on Saturday in the latest demonstration against Israel’s response to the Hamas terrorist attacks.

Previous marches have been marred by criminal behaviour, with some participants seen glorifying terrorism and showing support for Hamas.


But Scotland Yard has promised a “swift and robust” response to any forms of racism, anti-Semitism, incitement to violence or support for terrorism this weekend.

Deputy Assistant Commissioner Ade Adelekan said Met officers would be lining the route of the march – which will travel from Park Lane to Whitehall – to remind people what offences “would land them in the cells”.

He said this would involve handing out leaflets which set out clearly the boundaries of what is unacceptable and illegal.

“Anyone who is racist or incites hatred against any group should expect to be arrested,” he said.
‘We will not tolerate promoting terrorism’

Mr Adelekan also said anyone who was seen to show support for Hamas or any other banned organisation should expect to be arrested.

“We will not tolerate anyone who promotes or celebrates acts of terrorism such as the killing or kidnap of innocent people,” he said.



He urged anyone taking part in the march who witnessed any form of criminality to report it to any of the police officers along the route.

“In a huge march officers cannot see everything that is going but others do. So if they do report it we will act as quickly as possible. You will see robust intervention from our officers in the event of any criminal activity this weekend.”
Police will guard the Cenotaph

Scotland Yard will have trained spotters along the route as well as Arabic translators mingling among the marchers and in the operations room to look out for any criminal acts, including hate placards, banners and clothing.

Police officers will also guard a physical barrier around the Cenotaph in Whitehall and will protect other monuments along the route.

Police will keep guard at the Cenotaph during the protest march - Shutterstock

Mr Adelekan said: “We will not tolerate criminal behaviour that disturbs the sanctity of these national monuments.”

As well as the main march organised by the Palestinian Solidarity Campaign, there will be a static protest being held at the Egyptian embassy by Hizb ut-Tahrir at which several hundred people are expected.

The police leaflets, headlined Keep On The Right Side Of The Law, advise people on conducting a peaceful protest.

They state: “To avoid ending up in our cells DON’T use words or images:

“That are racist or incite hatred against any faith.

“That support Hamas or any other banned organisation, it is illegal under UK law to support such terrorist organisations.

“That celebrate or promote acts of terrorism - such as the killing or kidnap of innocent people.”
Warning not to use flares or fireworks

The leaflet also warns protesters not to use flares or fireworks or use words or behaviour that could be considered intimidating

Protesters are told not to deface or damage monuments or statues.

The first national march against anti-Semitism is due to take place on Sunday with with concern that it might be targeted by pro-Palestinian groups.

Asked about reports that Tommy Robinson, the founder and former leader of the far-Right English Defence League, could attend the protest, Mr Adelekan said he was “not welcome” at the march and would be engaged with by officers.

Around 1,500 officers will be deployed for the protests with several hundred drafted in from other forces through mutual aid.
RED TORY
Starmer wants to water down Labour’s £28bn green pledge even more

Daniel Martin
Fri, 24 November 2023 

Sir Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves, who was was forced to scale back the green plans in June - Stefan Rousseau/PA

Sir Keir Starmer is considering watering down Labour’s £28 billion green borrowing pledge even further as the party aims to prove to the public that it can be trusted with the economy.

Aides of the Labour leader have urged Rachel Reeves, the shadow chancellor, to cut back the green prosperity fund, under which Labour would borrow billions a year to invest in environmental jobs and industries as part of a bid to go for growth.

But in June, she was forced to scale back the plans, saying that instead of coming in at the start of a first Labour term in office, the policy would “ramp up” by the middle of the first Parliament.

Now a party source has said there is growing pressure from Sir Keir’s office to go further to reduce the cost and impact of the scheme.

Another source said it was more important to fulfil Labour’s fiscal rule that debt must be falling as a share of national income after five years. “The fiscal rule matters more, and that will dictate how much is in the green prosperity fund,” the source added.

It comes after Jeremy Hunt’s Autumn Statement projected that many key public services would face real-terms cuts after the next election – leaving Ms Reeves with difficult choices.

The Conservatives have said the fund is a key dividing line at the next election, proving that Labour is unfit to be trusted with the economy. They have called it a “debt bombshell”, with Rishi Sunak raising the issue frequently at Prime Minister’s Questions.

Some shadow cabinet members are known to have concerns about the green prosperity fund, believing Labour has not done enough to articulate what it will do with the money. Earlier this month, one was quoted as saying: “My worry is that we are going to get all the downside of this without any of the upside.”

Critics claim Labour has not said enough about what schemes the money will be spent on, and has not thought enough about how to sell the plan to the electorate.

The party had promised to spend £28 billion a year on green investment until 2030 from the first year after coming to power. In June, Ms Reeves said she had taken the decision to scale back the green prosperity fund as a result of the poor state of the economy.

She announced her decision on BBC Radio 4’s Today programme, saying Labour would “ramp up” to the annual £28 billion plan by halfway through a first Parliament. However, she said she could not have predicted the market crash caused by Liz Truss’s plans for unfunded borrowing for tax cuts last autumn.

“No plan can be built that is not a rock of economic and fiscal responsibility,” she added. “I will never play fast and loose with the public finances.”

The shadow chancellor said she was “on the same page” as Keir and Ed Miliband, the shadow energy secretary, about the need to scale back the ambition of the plan.

Mr Miliband said the delay was partly a matter of practicality because it could take some time to get supply chains ready for the £28billion of spending. He added that the party is “100 per cent not abandoning our plan”.
Energy minister says hydrogen will 'not play a major role' in heating homes in the UK

Sky News
Updated Fri, 24 November 2023 



The government has given one of its strongest indications yet that it is going cold on hydrogen for home heating.

The energy minister Lord Callanan told The Climate Show with Tom Heap: "It will not play a major role in home heating.

"There's no way that could be practically achieved".


When hydrogen burns, it gives off no carbon dioxide as it is pure h2 - there is no carbon in the molecule.

This has led to considerable interest in using it as a domestic fuel for home heating and cooking to replace natural gas which is methane, a fossil fuel that worsens climate change when it burns.

Natural gas is still the workhorse of domestic energy with roughly three-quarters of UK homes on the gas grid and many supply companies are hoping hydrogen might be close to a 'drop-in replacement' for their current fuel.

But opposition has been mounting.

Many scientists point out that it takes enormous amounts of electricity to make clean green hydrogen, and it would be much more efficient to use that electricity directly in our homes to run heat pumps.

Read more from Sky News:
Investigation launched into Worcester Bosch over hydrogen marketing concerns
Potentially misleading boiler marketing over the use of hydrogen removed

The National Infrastructure Commission, the body created by the government to advise on critical fabric for the nation's economy, has said there is "no public policy case for hydrogen" in domestic heating.

Lord Martin Callanan said: "It is clear that the vast majority of decarbonisation of home heating in the UK will be electrification.

"If we have hydrogen production locally it might play a small role in some localised areas".

One of those areas could be the Yorkshire coastal town of Redcar, where a pilot project is proposed to swap natural gas for hydrogen and force people to choose between that or a heat pump.

But there is considerable local opposition, with residents questioning the safety of hydrogen and resenting the imposition of a change to their home heating.

Locals have already rejected a similar hydrogen village idea close to Ellesmere Port in Cheshire.

However, some gas companies are still insisting there is a role for hydrogen.

Click to subscribe to ClimateCast with Tom Heap wherever you get your podcasts

Tim Harwood is Hydrogen Programme Director for the supply company Northern Gas, and they are backing the Redcar trial.

"We're doing this project to demonstrate we can convert the gas network over to hydrogen.

"We can do it safely and we can provide resilience…and customers like it as it doesn't change their lifestyle very much as it is similar to using natural gas."

Whether the Redcar hydrogen trial will go ahead is still up in the air, with the government promising a decision before the end of the year.

But overall they seem to be pushing new hydrogen towards industry and away from our homes.
Texas Republicans take aim at climate change -- in textbooks


Moises AVILA with Ulysse BELLIER in Washington
Fri, 24 November 2023 

The oil well in this 2015 file photo from Garden City, Texas, produces about 55-70 barrels of oil per day (SPENCER PLATT)

The scorching summer in Texas this year was the second hottest on record -- but students in the southwestern US state might have a hard time understanding why.

That's because a slew of science textbooks submitted to the state Board of Education (BOE) were rejected last week, as the Republican-dominated body moves to curtail education materials deemed too "one-sided" on climate change.

Many of the rejected books taught that "humans are negatively impacting the environment. And the scare tactics that come with that, that is my main issue," Evelyn Brooks, a Republican board member, told AFP.


She claimed, counter to scientists and the federal government, that "the science is not settled on global warming."

America's decentralized education system leaves curriculum management mostly up to individual states, with local school districts also having a degree of autonomy.

That has led to fraught battles across the country as each jurisdiction debates how to teach climate change and other politically charged issues, such as racism and sexuality.

It also leaves room for officials like Brooks in Texas, which produces 42 percent of the nation's crude oil, to push back against the "political ideology" of climate change -- a concept she considers "a blatant lie."

- Increasingly polarized -

Science textbooks from publisher Green Ninja were among those voted down by the Texas BOE.

"It was because of our inclusion of climate change," director Eugene Cordero told AFP in an email, adding that one board member took particular issue with a prompt asking students to "create a story warning friends and family about possible future weather and climate extremes."

Textbooks from eight of 22 publishers that submitted materials to the board were rejected last week, according to a count from Glenn Branch, deputy director of the National Center for Science Education (NCSE), a nonprofit which promotes the teaching of climate change.

Some were eventually accepted, after revisions to sections on climate change and evolution -- another controversial subject in the largely Christian Texas.

The rejected books are not necessarily banned from classrooms, but using approved books is typically tied to getting government funding.

As broiling summers are supercharged by climate change, some fear that students won't see the bigger picture.

"If kids don't understand what all of that means, and they're just going to continue to perpetuate the problem," said Marisa Perez-Dias, one of five Democratic members of the board.

Staci Childs, another Democratic board member, charged that some of her colleagues "felt like some of the materials negatively reflected how oil and gas impacts our society."

In a show of just how powerful the industry is in Texas -- even as the state becomes a growing hub for renewables -- two of the 10 Republican members work directly for the sector.

Though the state has long been conservative, debate seems to have gotten more polarized recently, Perez-Diaz told AFP.

Where previously a consensus "could be met across party lines before, we don't see that as much anymore."

- Getting better? -

In neighboring Oklahoma, the state's Energy Resources Board -- which is entirely funded by the oil and gas industry -- has distributed free education materials aligned with the sector's interests, often to underfunded schools.

Former governor Mike Huckabee, of neighboring Arkansas, has created a "Kids Guide to the Truth About Climate Change."

The monthly series of lessons, available for sale online, promises to counter an agenda on climate change "that promotes fear and panic" pushed by "teachers and the media."

Like other conservative complaints about climate change, the guides try to thread a needle -- avoiding outright climate denialism, while at the same time rejecting the leading scientific consensus.

"Everyone agrees that the Earth's climate is always changing and that industrial development has negatively impacted the environment," the curriculum reads.

"But that does not mean the planet is doomed," it says. "Some very smart people have not been able (to) predict what will happen with the earth. So we really don't know."

Earlier this year, the free-market think tank the Heartland Institute sent its own climate change-skeptical book -- which AFP factcheckers found to be misleading -- to 8,000 teachers.

Despite the setbacks in Texas, Branch, of the NCSE, says climate change education across the country "is generally improving."

"That's partly because it's starting from a very low level."

ube/nro/des
World stands on frontline of disaster at Cop28, says UN climate chief


Fiona Harvey Environment editor
Fri, 24 November 2023

Photograph: Spyros Bakalis/AFP/Getty Images

World leaders must “stop dawdling and start doing” on carbon emission cuts, as rapidly rising temperatures this year have put everyone on the frontline of disaster, the UN’s top climate official has warned.

No country could think itself immune from catastrophe, said Simon Stiell, who will oversee the crucial Cop28 climate summit that begins next week. Scores of world leaders will arrive in Dubai for tense talks on how to tackle the crisis.

“We’re used to talking about protecting people on the far-flung frontlines. We’re now at the point where we’re all on the frontline,” said Stiell, speaking exclusively to the Guardian before the summit. “Yet most governments are still strolling when they need to be sprinting.”

Global temperatures have broken new records in recent months, making this year the hottest on record, and perilously close to the threshold of 1.5C above pre-industrial levels that countries have agreed to hold to. Temperatures are now heading for a “hellish” 3C increase, unless urgent and drastic action is taken, but greenhouse gas emissions have continued to rise.

Stiell said it was still possible to cut greenhouse gas emissions enough to stay within the crucial limit, but that further delay would be dangerous.

“Every year of the baby steps we’ve been taking up to this point means that we need to be taking … bigger leaps with each following year if we are to stay in this race,” he said. “The science is absolutely clear.”

The fortnight-long Cop28 talks will start this Thursday in Dubai, hosted by the United Arab Emirates, a major oil and gas-producing country. Scores of world leaders, senior ministers and officials from 198 countries will be in attendance, along with an estimated 70,000 delegates, making it the biggest annual conference of the parties (Cop) yet held under the 1992 UN framework convention on climate change.

The UK prime minister, Rishi Sunak, is expected to attend, and King Charles will give the opening speech, along with the UN secretary general, António Guterres, and the UAE president, Mohammed bin Zayed al-Nahyan. The pope will also be there, the European Commission president, Ursula von der Leyen, and an invitation has been extended to Bashar al-Assad, the president of Syria.

The presidents of the world’s two biggest greenhouse gas emitters, Joe Biden of the US and Xi Jinping of China, are not expected to attend, but their envoys John Kerry and Xie Zhenhua have signalled their close cooperation before the talks.

Sultan Al Jaber, the chief of the UAE national oil company, Adnoc, will preside over the talks. Al Jaber has come under fierce criticism from green campaigners for his dual role, but Stiell said this was “a distraction”.


Simon Stiell. Photograph: Simon Maina/AFP/Getty Images

“This is not the first Cop to be hosted by a fossil fuel producing nation and it certainly won’t be the last. Every country, even those that are major oil producers, have their role to play,” he said. “What’s important are the messages and the signals that the incoming president is giving, and they speak to the need for urgent action and a focus on the how – how do we speed up the transition to a new decarbonised world.”

Fossil fuel executives are likely to be out in force at the summit, as they have been an increasing presence at Cops in recent years.

Stiell said: “It’s important that we recognise that the fossil fuel industry has to be part of the solution. We know where the problems lie. But in order to progress the conversation from what needs to be done to how it needs to be done, the fossil fuel industry has to be part of the conversation.”

But he insisted these companies had to show they were serious about shifting the world to a zero-carbon economy. “Their engagement in the process has to be legitimate, has to be speaking to the necessary actions that are taking the transition away from our current dependence on fossil fuels to a new decarbonised business model,” he said.

One of the key issues at Cop28 will be the provision of finance for the rescue and rehabilitation of the poorest and most vulnerable communities when they are stricken with climate disaster. The absence of this loss and damage funding has been a longstanding grievance for developing countries, but earlier this month countries agreed a blueprint for the fund.

Rich countries have yet to pledge contributions to the fund, however. Stiell called on world leaders to come with pledges. “A fund that is established without the resources capitalised won’t get us to where we need to be. That opportunity, for donors to send strong signals as to how the fund will be capitalised, and the scale of that capitalisation, is on offer at this Cop,” he said.

Governments will be presented with a global assessment of how little progress has been made on emissions cuts since the 2015 Paris agreement, and how far off track the world is to meet the Paris goal of limiting global heating to 1.5C, beyond which scientists warn the impacts of the climate crisis will rapidly become catastrophic and irreversible.

Stiell said governments must list and deploy the “solutions, solutions, solutions” that they know will be effective, such as renewable energy, electrifying transport and decarbonising the global economy. “People everywhere expect governments to put these tools at work at Cop28. Public attention will be on us, and the expectations that this Cop will speak to those solutions and the urgency of action.”

He said: “We keep talking about hope, but hope can only be established if there are signs of delivery, of action. I believe that is the signal that ordinary people struggling to deal with the consequences of climate change are expecting of world leaders here at Cop28.”