Tuesday, January 23, 2024

Western corporate media whiteout on hearing of Israeli genocide

The South African government defended its powerful charges against the genocidal actions of Israel during their initial presentation in front of the International Court of Justice in The Hague, Netherlands, Jan. 11. 

Palestinians in Nelson Mandela Square, in occupied Ramallah on the West Bank, Jan. 10, 2024. Credit: @sumayamamdoo

South Africa’s legal team consists of a multinational and multigenerational group of advocates, including Tembeka Ngcukaitobi, Adila Hassim, John Dugard and Max du Plessis, plus other junior and external counsel members. Many members of the legal team staff wore Palestinian keffiyehs along with scarves featuring the colors of the South African flag.

Prominent South African lawyer Adila Hassim passionately told the court, “Israel has subjected Gaza to what has been described as one of the heaviest conventional bombing campaigns in the history of modern warfare.” (BBC, Jan. 11)  

In his closing remarks, South African counsel Tembeka Ngcukaitobi stated, “The evidence of genocidal intent is not only chilling, it is also overwhelming and incontrovertible.” (Timeslive, Jan. 11) 

South Africa is a country that legally defeated a white-supremacist, apartheid system in 1994. It is also the first country to courageously bring charges of genocide against Israel before a world court. 

More than 20 countries are publicly endorsing South Africa’s case, including socialist Cuba and the pro-worker governments of Brazil, Bolivia, Nicaragua and Venezuela. Despite the strong global showing of solidarity, the Western corporate press has egregiously censored the proceedings as a strategic attempt to discredit South Africa’s claims and to undermine the justified grievances of the people of Palestine.

Corporate press displays empathy towards Israel

Much of the corporate media downplayed the arguments made by the South African attorneys, while at the same time presenting Israel as a “victim” simply “defending itself.”  Take for example the first sentence of a Reuters article: “Israel on Friday rejected as false and ‘grossly distorted’ accusations brought by South Africa at the U.N.’s top court that its military operation in Gaza is a state-led genocide campaign against Palestinians.” (Jan. 12) The author legitimizes Israel’s deceitful response to the charges of genocide at the very beginning of the article, setting its tone.

Unlike South Africa’s diverse legal team, the Israeli respondents are predominately white. In a sick twist of irony, Germany has decided to testify on Israel’s behalf, which the bourgeois press has been happy to report. Numerous U.S. media headlines, have highlighted how Germany is calling South Africa’s charges “baseless.”

Israeli representatives peddled false claims about the Hamas Islamic Resistance Movement of Gaza and demonized its supporters. The U.S. corporate media has also been pushing misinformation about the Palestinian resistance movement in recent months. Neither the Israeli legal team nor the bourgeois press willingly admit that the people of Gaza overwhelmingly voted for Hamas as their legitimate representative during the 2006 legislative elections. 

The Palestinian people should be the only ones able to determine their own destiny — not the racist leaders of the U.S., Germany or Israel. The South African government, led by the African National Congress, is going out of its way to do what it can to show solidarity with its Palestinian siblings who are experiencing similar apartheid conditions. Their efforts must be defended and honorably recognized by those who support a “Free Palestine!”

What can be done to eradicate period poverty?


BY DR ZAREEN ROOHI AHMED
21ST JAN 2024
LIFE


Dr Zareen Roohi Ahmed is on a mission to eradicate period poverty all over the world and, with a cost of living crisis and global unrest, it’s time to finally move together to a period poverty-free future

In a world progressively vocal about equality and empowerment, a shadowed issue persists, often deemed the final taboo: period poverty.

Period poverty is a widespread yet concealed affliction that touches millions of women and girls, yet it lingers at the periphery of global discourse. The stigma enveloping menstruation remains the most formidable barrier. This article is a personal testament to my accidental discovery of this crisis, the journey to confront it, and the community-driven solutions promising a dawn free from period poverty.

My awakening to the issue: an article in Lahore

My voyage against period poverty commenced unexpectedly—in the lounge of Lahore’s airport in Pakistan. There, in the wake of launching a school dedicated to my late daughter Halimah for underprivileged girls, I grappled with my grief and a longing to uphold our shared vision for philanthropy. It was amid this introspection that an article about Syrian women in the Zatari refugee camp caught my attention. Their stories of hardship and the dire lack of sanitary products, which forced them to repurpose strips of fabric from the clothing they wore into makeshift pads, moved me profoundly. Their indomitable spirit amidst such adversity ignited a resolve within me: I was determined to bring about change. In that moment I envisioned myself handing menstrual pads to these women and this marked the genesis of my crusade against period poverty.

"Syrian women in the Zatari refugee camp forced to repurpose strips of clothing into makeshift pads moved me profoundly"

Period poverty is an issue often overlooked when considering the difficulties that refugees face, however it is not just women in such extreme situations that encounter this problem, but also those living what we would consider to be ordinary lives. With the cost of living on the rise, more and more people are struggling to afford period products, often having to choose between food, heating or sanitary products.

Turning inspiration into action


Zareen distributing hygiene kits in Lebanon in August 2022

I started Gift Wellness, an award-winning social enterprise after the spark I felt in Lahore airport. It is devoted to eradicating period poverty through the sale of eco-conscious, plastic-free menstrual products and cleansing bars. Our efforts have seen the distribution of over 6.5 million period products to homeless and refugee women, food banks and schools—extending from the UK to global reaches.

Fighting period poverty is about turning awareness of the issue into creative and practical ways to solve the problem. For example, Gift Wellness has also evolved into the launch of an app, Period Angels, designed to revolutionise how menstrual products are distributed to those in need. It bridges the gap between those who need menstrual products, volunteers who respond and coordinate their distribution, organisations that need the products or would like to stock them and people who want to make donations.

"Gift Wellness has distributed over 6.5 million period products to homeless and refugee women, food banks and schools "

Using schemes like this to provide free period products to the community, through volunteers and donations, will help make products more accessible for those struggling to afford them. Corporations and charities alike need to come together to tackle this issue as a united front.

The potential of technology to help fight period poverty

Period poverty and menstrual health in general is often shrouded in a layer of controversy and taboo. However, it should not be a topic that should be discussed with shame. Instead, we should be striving to increase people’s awareness of the topic and the needs of women and girls.

Technology can be essential for this. The Period Angels App also acts as an educational resource, providing vital menstrual health information. Encouraging people to understand menstruation as a topic of health is essential in the journey to preventing period poverty, and utilising technology and the connectivity of the internet is just one other way that organisations can help people in need access menstrual products and normalise talking about it.

Shifting the stigma around women's health




Zareen with her book The Gift about her journey from tragedy to activism
The eradication of period poverty demands more than activism; it calls for a cultural paradigm shift. We must realign our societal structures, historically synced to men's rhythms, to acknowledge and fit around women's health cycles. This recalibration should begin in the privacy of our homes and proliferate through the halls of education and the corridors of the workplace.

"The eradication of period poverty demands more than activism; it calls for a cultural paradigm shift"

It's a matter of recognising that the needs of menstruating individuals are not ancillary but fundamental. For organisations, this translates to instituting supportive mechanisms, ensuring ready access to menstrual products, and nurturing a culture that dispels the shame around menstruation.

Marching towards a period poverty-free future



Gift Wellness period products are helping millions of women struggling with period poverty

The battle against period poverty is a multifaceted struggle—it's not only about securing product accessibility; it's about dismantling deep-seated stigmas and inequities. My own journey, which began with a stirring article in Lahore, led to the founding of Gift Wellness and the creation of the Period Angels app, illustrating that transformative change is within our reach.

"Together, we can transcend the last taboo and craft a future where period poverty is relegated to history"
It's a path paved with vision, tenacity and collective effort. Together, we can transcend the last taboo, align our societal ethos with the reality of women's bodies, and craft a future where period poverty is relegated to history. Let's stride forward in unity.

About the author:




Dr Zareen Roohi Ahmed is a philanthropist and the founder and CEO of Gift Wellness, a social enterprise which produces a range of sustainable, natural, high-quality sanitary products and is an ongoing support to women in crisis. She is also the founder and Chair of The Halimah Trust, a charity, founded in honour of her daughter, that works to improve the lives of orphaned and needy children through education and responding to the needs of people in crisis.




Zareen’s book, The Gift, tells the remarkable story of how, after the tragic loss of her daughter Halimah, Zareen channelled her grief into real action and purpose, all in the name of improving the lives of women and girls across the globe.

Banner photo credit: Dr Zaheen Roohi Adhmed
Across the aisle by P Chidambaram: The dazzle of affluent India

While celebrating the 7 crore people who will be Affluent India, we should also reflect on the pitiable status of three times more Indians (22.8 crore) who are in poverty.

Written by P Chidambaram
FINANCIAL EXPRESS, INDIA
January 21, 2024


The 21-50 per cent of the people who earn below the median income are only slightly better off than the bottom 20 per cent.


The media has gone to town on Affluent India. Affluent India is our AI — persons having an annual income of USD 10,000 or about Rs 8,40,000. The media is gushing over the claims that AI is growing at a mind-boggling CAGR, AI is driving consumption, and AI will make India a USD 5 trillion economy by the year (yet undetermined because the goalpost is constantly shifting!).

I am happy for AI. Here comes the rider: according to the Goldman Sachs’ report, the size of AI by the year 2026 will be 100 million (10 crore) or roughly 7 per cent of India’s population. Why is Goldman Sachs concerned about AI and not the rest (93 per cent) of the Indian people? Because Goldman Sachs is a rich persons bank and, if AI were a separate country, AI would be a middle-income country and the 15th largest of the world. It is Affluent Indians (with honourable exceptions) who save, spend,

invest, splurge, squander and shout about their income, wealth and everything else. When AI buys and consumes, it creates an illusion that all Indians buy and consume. AI has become the proxy for all India. The remaining 93 per cent earn modest incomes and some lead a satisfying life while the majority makes an effort to make both ends meet.

Upper Half, Bottom Half

Let’s stack the three customary numbers denoting income:

Affluent India: Rs 8,40,000 per year

Median income: Rs 3,87,000

Per capita NNI: Rs 1,70,000

It is a tiny slice that is Affluent India. The per capita net national income (NNI) is meaningless because AI pulls the average upwards. The more relevant statistic is the median income. One-half of the Indian people (71 crore) have an income of Rs 3,87,000 per year or less, or about 32,000 a month or less. The lower you go down on the economic ladder, the income will be lesser. What does the bottom 10 per cent or 20 per cent of the population earn in a month?My generous estimate is that the per capita monthly income of the bottom 10 per cent will be Rs 6,000 and of the bottom 11-20 per cent Rs 12,000. We should worry about the conditions in which they live, the kind of food they eat, the healthcare they get, and so on. According to the UNDP’s multi-dimensional poverty index, 22.8 crore people or about 16 per cent of the population are below the poverty line. (According to NITI Aayog, it is 11.28 per cent or 16.8 crore.)

Forgotten Poor

While celebrating the 7 crore people who will be Affluent India, we should also reflect on the pitiable status of three times more Indians (22.8 crore) who are in poverty. It is not difficult to identify the poor: The 15.4 crore active registered workers under MGNREGS who were promised 100 days of work in a year but were allotted in the last five years, on average, only 49-51 days;
Most of the beneficiaries who were given an LPG connection but could afford, on average, only 3.7 cylinders in a year;
Those who own or cultivate less than 1-2 acres of land among the 10.47 crore farmers (the number dropped to 8.12 crore as on November 15, 2023) who received the kissan samman of Rs 6,000 per year;
Most daily wage workers who are engaged as agricultural labourers;
The ‘street people’ who live and sleep on pavements or under bridges;
Most single women old-age pensioners; and
Most persons who do so-called ‘unclean’ jobs like cleaning sewers, drains and public toilets; skin animals, make or repair footwear, etc.

The 21-50 per cent of the people who earn below the median income are only slightly better off than the bottom 20 per cent. They don’t go hungry or without shelter but they live on the edge of uncertainty. Most private jobs have no job security or social security benefits. For example, the 2.8 crore domestic help registered on the government’s e-SHRAM portal work at below-the-minimum wage (the actual number is many times more). Except government and public sector employees, the others live in fear of losing their jobs. In 2023, the tech companies alone laid off or retrenched 2,60,000 highly qualified employees. 100 start-ups axed 24,000 jobs.

Blinded by Dazzle

The five-star hotels, resorts, glitzy malls, luxury brand stores, multiplex cinemas, private jets, destination weddings, Lamborghinis (priced in the range Rs 3.22 to 8.89 crore, the company sold a record 103 cars in 2023), etc. have enough patrons among AI. AI is able to sustain this high standard of living because AI owns 60 per cent of the nation’s wealth and earns 57 per cent of the national income.

The dazzle of AI has blinded the BJP government to the state of the bottom 20 per cent because it has the unflinching support of a steel frame called RSS; its coffers are brimming with money thanks to the rich corporates and electoral bonds; and it knows how to make a potent mixture of religion and hyper-nationalism. It is a government verily for Affluent India.

India is being pulled away from the idea of a social and economic democracy. The Opposition parties and the media may not be vigilant but the poor and middle classes — the 93 per cent — are watching and waiting.



Deprived UK town where foodbanks stand next to celebrity 'Millionaire’s Row'

A small Lancashire town is split between pockets of wealth and deprivation as residents are 'crying their hearts out' as local councillor says they have never had an increase in funding


Danny Gutmann
21 JAN 2024

A small UK town has been ravaged by drugs and is home to some of the UK's most financially deprived areas, where gangs burn rivals to death.

Skelmersdale, which is near Wigan, has seen some residents 'crying their hearts out' as they seek help getting basic items such as food and nappies for children. Meanwhile, despite the desperate conditions in the city centre, Tanhouse and Digmoor areas close by such as Upholland and parts of Ashurst are thriving.

It's also become a drugs market, where violent gangs from Liverpool and Manchester lay down the law with brutal precision. In 2019, in his home by a gang who were trying to stamp their control on the town.

For more of the latest news from the Daily Star, click here.

He had died during a turf war for control of lucrative drug markets, Preston Crown Court heard.

Margaret Highton who runs a Foodbank said Skelmersdale is a 'beautiful place' 
(Image: James Maloney/Lancs Live)

Amanda-Jane Hardwick, a volunteer at the Evermoor Hub in Digmoor, told The Sun gangs recruit kids in the area to sell drugs for them. She said: "We see big cars coming and going. We know what is going on. They use the motorway network to get in and out very quickly."

Just last year, she claimed a local man approached the centre with a replica firearm and machete making threats.
Margaret Highton, director of Evermoor Hub in Digmoor runs a community shop and foodbank in Skelmersdale - often referred to by locals as Skem - told LancsLive about the dire situation.

Robert Beattie was burned alive amid a drugs turf war (Image: SUPPLIED)

She said: "There are new houses but no amenities, like a sports centre or a place for kids to go. Skem is a beautiful place - we have got the Beacon - but there's nothing to do. Bus services are not good and come the winter, that's it - there's nothing down for you in Skem."

The torched home of Robert Beattie (Image: SWNS)

Over the Christmas period alone she helped provide toys and food to 650 people, but said three cases in particular that were especially 'desperate'.

Margaret said: "People have been crying their hearts out. A young woman has just been crying as she had no nappies for her baby. She came in for a food parcel and was stuffing the food into her mouth.

"The baby was about six months old; it's a common scene. We had three desperate cases in the last week, including a young man who had not eaten for two days."

A run-down home in Skelmersdale (stock image) (Image: GETTY)

Mum of two and a Digmoor resident Sam Rimmer said: "I avoid going out - there's too many kids hanging around smoking weed. Give the kids somewhere to go; invest in their education and in something outside school."

Meanwhile, Dasa Sajgalova, who is also a local resident and mum works at Cappy, an eastern European food store in Digmoor Shopping Parade.

Poverty is rife in the area, statistics show (Image: GETTY)

Saying that she didn't agree with the survey Dasa said: "People think this is a bad area but I have never had any problems with anybody. It's a nice community, I have a lot of friends and I walk home at night by myself.

"A few times, we have had to call police because kids were throwing fireworks, but they stopped after that."
Hong Kong reef rescue: Helping endangered oysters protect and purify coastal waters

The Nature Conservancy is spearheading an ambitious project to restore once-thriving oyster reefs along Hong Kong’s coastline, after centuries of over-exploitation.


by EARTH.ORG
9 HOURS AGO 
By Martina Igini

Oysters, often overlooked in their unassuming shells, possess remarkable abilities that benefit marine life and humans alike, making them true “ecosystem engineers.” However, decades of overharvesting, habitat destruction, and water pollution have caused a significant decline in global populations, making oysters the world’s most endangered marine habitat, with an estimated 85 per cent of reefs worldwide already wiped out.
Most people associate oysters with food, but less well-known is that oysters create reef habitats that support coastal marine life. Photo: Marine Thomas/The Nature Conservancy.

For more than 700 years, oysters have been an important commodity in the Lingnan region – a geographical area that covers Guangdong, Guangxi and Hainan in mainland China, and the Special Administrative Regions of Hong Kong and Macau – both as food and as building materials. Indeed, oysters and other seashells are an essential source of lime, the predecessor of cement, making it an extremely attractive resource for both construction and agriculture.


Over the last century, Hong Kong’s coastal areas have seen significant habitat loss due to land reclamation, urbanisation, and over-extraction of lime. These activities have lead to a decline in oyster populations and a degradation of their reef habitats. The lime industry in particular, which thrived during the 19th and 20th centuries as it fed Hong Kong’s development, led to the functional extinction of oyster reefs that once stretched across an estimated 1,000 kilometres of coastline in the Pearl River Delta area.

Recognising the urgency of protecting these invaluable ecosystems, efforts are now underway to restore and conserve oyster reefs in Hong Kong. Scientists, environmental organisations, and local communities are joining forces to raise awareness about the importance of oyster reefs and implement restoration. Marine Thomas, Senior Conservation Project Manager at Hong Kong’s The Nature Conservancy, restores abandoned oyster farms at Lau Fau Shan, Deep Bay. Photo: Kyle Obermann.

Earth.Org spoke to Marine Thomas, Senior Conservation Project Manager at Hong Kong’s The Nature Conservancy (TNC) who is responsible for overseeing TNC’s marine conservation projects and focused on restoring natural habitats and developing sustainable oyster aquaculture. She delved into the world of oyster reefs, explaining their role as ecosystem engineers, the threats they face in Hong Kong’s waters, and how TNC is working to restore these valuable ecosystems.
Oysters – the guardians of the sea

To understand the importance of oyster reef conservation, we must first look at the benefits these remarkable creatures provide. Indeed, as Thomas explained, while people mostly associate oysters with food, they also fulfil several other functions important especially in the context of climate change.

Oysters are renowned filter feeders that actively purify the surrounding water, with just a single oyster capable of filtering up to 200 litres of water a day. As they draw in water to extract nutrients, they inadvertently filter out pollutants and excess sediments, improving water quality in their habitat.


Research conducted in Hong Kong in 2020 found that a seven-square-metre oyster reef can filter the equivalent of up to one Olympic-size swimming pool in a single day. A single Hong Kong oyster (Crassostrea hongkongensis) can filter up to 30 litres of water per hour at summer temperatures, one of the highest filtration rates among any oyster species.

However, oysters’ significance goes beyond water filtration. Their reefs act as natural nurseries, providing food, shelter, and protection for a diverse array of marine life. They are vital habitats for various fish species, crustaceans, and countless other forms of marine life, including shellfish and coral reefs, fostering biodiversity and supporting the intricate web of life beneath the waves.An underwater oyster reef at Tolo Harbour in May 2023. Photo: Frigatefilms.

Oysters also play a vital role in shoreline stabilisation. The dense and intricate structure of oyster reefs creates a physical buffer that absorbs and dissipates wave energy. By breaking up incoming waves, reefs help minimise erosion and prevent the loss of sediment from coastal areas. This is particularly significant in areas prone to storms and tidal fluctuations.

Oyster reefs also promote sediment accumulation and stabilisation. As oysters filter water, they extract particles and sediments, which then settle on their shells and the reef structure. Over time, this accumulation of sediment contributes to the development of a stable substrate, enhancing the resilience of the shoreline. The presence of oyster reefs promotes the formation of marshes, seagrass beds, and other coastal habitats that rely on the deposition of sediment for their growth and survival.
The Beginnings

In 2017, TNC partnered with the University of Hong Kong (HKU) to promote the conservation of oysters across the territory.

“Conservation is a very long process,” said Thomas. “In order to restore an ecosystem, you first have to understand the ecosystem and the story behind it. You have to map what’s left, identify the different species present in the area, and what has been threatening their existence.”

With the help of volunteers, The Nature Conservancy reconfigures abandoned oyster farms in Pak Nai. Photo: Tom Chan/The Nature Conservancy.

From years of intense research on site and drawing from their expertise in restoring oyster reefs at more than 150 sites around the world, TNC and HKU built the knowledge necessary to carry out conservation work and awareness campaigns. Indeed, as Thomas explained, most people in Hong Kong have never seen or heard about these ecosystems before and are not aware of their importance.

“While we are excited by the biological feasibility of restoration, unfortunately the human aspect remains our biggest challenge to bringing these habitats back at scale. Shellfish habitats are still severely underprotected in Hong Kong, with very little public awareness of their ecological value. And little awareness makes these ecosystems vulnerable to development and reclamation.”

Behind the lack of awareness, there is also government inaction. As Thomas put it, marine conservation in Hong Kong is “severely lacking.” While some development projects in Hong Kong are subject to Environmental Impact Assessments, there are no firm standards for mitigation projects and the environmental impact is only monitored for a maximum of two years

.
An Abandoned oyster farm that The Nature Conservancy studies to understand the role of oyster reefs as a habitat. Photo: Derek Tang.

“You can’t just call anything restoration. Restoration needs standards and long-term monitoring. Without them, we cannot achieve anything in the long-term,” said Thomas. “The government needs to recognise shellfish, work to protect these endangered ecosystems, and provide funds for restoration at scale.”
Conservation Efforts

“We are still at the beginning of our conservation efforts but we are almost at the end of our journey to find the secret sauce,” said Thomas, adding that, while restoration projects across Hong Kong are still in the early phase, years of research have been crucial in understanding how these ecosystems work, what has led to their functional extinction, and what the most efficient ways are to bring them back. Nevertheless, she also recognised that some of Hong Kong’s oyster reefs are so degraded that bringing them back is no longer a possibility.

In 2021, TNC and HKU launched their first pilot programme at Hong Kong International Airport to mitigate the impact of a recently completed expansion project that included a third runway. To build the 3,800-metre runway, which became operational in July 2022, about 650 hectares of land to the north of the existing airport island had to be acquired through reclamation on top of disused contaminated mud pits. According to a 2015 update on the construction issued by the Legislative Council Panel on Economic Development, some 100 million cubic metres of marine sand were expected to be needed for the reclamation, with obvious consequences for marine ecosystems.

Reclamation in Hong Kong has always been highly controversial, with environmental groups tirelessly advocating for stricter standards. The third runway project had already drawn the attention of environmental advocates for its potential impact on a population of pink dolphins, whose existence in Hong Kong is already highly threatened.
An undated photo of a pink dolphin in Hong Kong waters. 
File photo: HK Dolphin Society via AFP.

“I’m not going to lie, the airport runway is a challenging environment, it’s severely degraded,” said Thomas, who also recognised that the airport nevertheless remains one of the few government-owned bodies to go “above and beyond” to fund restoration projects – “a good thing,” as she put it, considering that there is no requirement to do so.

“Considering that the government sets no standards whatsoever to define the success of a mitigation project and only limits monitoring over a maximum of two years, definitely not enough to understand whether a project was successful or not, we were positively surprised when the airport approached TNC and tasked it with retrofitting the area.”
Restoring a Degraded Ecosystem

“How we restore an ecosystem really depends on the challenges of the area,” explained Thomas.

In Hong Kong, construction, land reclamation, and lime extraction irreversibly affected the foundation of oyster reefs, which need a hard surface – typically other oysters or oyster shells – to reproduce.
The Nature Conservancy Staff and partners build an artificial oyster reef in Hong Kong. Photo: Kyle Obermann.

“Because we have taken out the substrate that oysters need to reproduce, the obvious first step is to reintroduce that structure,” the conservationist explained.

Materials such as limestone and weathered concrete, which is rough and uneven and thus makes the perfect foundation for a reef, are all great materials that can be used to rebuild the surface. But what one might not expect is that even oyster shells are a great option.

Thanks to the Save Our Shells project, an initiative funded by the Airport Authority’s Marine Enhancement Ecology Fund that recycles discarded shellfish shells and repurposes them as substrate for new reefs, TNC has begun recovering lost ecosystems. The NGO is working with restaurants, hotels, and the local aquaculture community to retrieve oyster shells which, after being weathered, can be replanted – typically in the summer months – to create a new substrate for reefs to form and grow.

The Nature Conservancy staff and volunteers work together to deploy oyster shells back into Tolo Harbour. Photo: Frigatefilms.

The NGO is also working with experienced local oyster farmers from the Lau Fau Shan and Yung Shue O aquaculture communities to make the industry more sustainable. “Farmers are the real custodians of the area and they understand these ecosystems like no one else,” said Thomas.

This collaboration led to two pilot oyster reefs in Hong Kong’s Lau Fau Shan and Tolo Harbour using discarded shells. In the coming years, TNC will conduct ongoing monitoring of the reef’s growth and its impact on biodiversity and water quality. If successful, the data collected during these pilots and the restoration methods implemented can be applied to future, larger restoration projects.

“The Oyster Odyssey” exhibition at the Hong Kong Maritime Museum. 
Photo: Earth.Org

Five years of hard work by TNC and HKU culminated in an exhibition, “The Oyster Odyssey,” which aims to raise awareness about the cultural, historical, and ecological importance of these ecosystems in Hong Kong and shine a light on the NGO’s efforts to work alongside the government to protect and restore them. If you’re in Hong Kong, you can visit The Oyster Odyssey exhibition at the Hong Kong Maritime Museum until January 31, 2024. For more information, visit the exhibition’s website.

 INDIA

Haryana: Alarming Levels of Arsenic and Fluoride Contamination Found in Haryana's Groundwater


Newsclick Report 


Groundwater in 51 habitations across 18 districts in Haryana is now confirmed to be contaminated with arsenic.

Groundwater

Image Courtesy: Wikimedia Commons

New Delhi: In a shocking revelation, a groundwater sample from Chhara village in Bahadurgarh (Jhajjar) has been reported with an arsenic level of 0.299 mg/l, nearly 30 times the permissible limit. 

According to a report published in The Tribune, the sample, drawn from a hand pump, highlights the severity of water contamination issues in the region. Similarly, in Sui, Bawani Khera (Bhiwani), a dug well recorded an arsenic level of 0.2 mg/l, surpassing the permissible limit by 20 times. Meanwhile, Bohal village witnessed a water sample from a dug well with arsenic levels exceeding 11 times the permissible limit.

The World Health Organization (WHO) identifies arsenic as a toxic element and a significant health hazard. Long-term exposure to elevated arsenic levels in drinking water has been linked to cancer, skin lesions, cardiovascular diseases, and diabetes.

Disturbingly, groundwater in 51 habitations across 18 districts in Haryana is now confirmed to be contaminated with arsenic. Notably, nine habitations in Karnal alone—Salwan, Nanhera, Kalra Jagir, Ghari Khajur, Nalvi Khurd, Ramba, Nalvi Kalan, Chorkarsa, and Kurlan—are affected. Additionally, districts like Sirsa, Bhiwani, Rohtak, and Sonepat are grappling with the alarming issue, with six contaminated locations in Sirsa and Bhiwani and five each in Rohtak and Sonepat.

The Central Ground Water Board (CGWB) recently shared data on arsenic and fluoride contamination with the Haryana Water Resources (Conservation, Regulation, and Management) Authority (HWRA).

But arsenic contamination is not the only concern; 136 locations across 20 districts in Haryana are grappling with fluoride-contaminated groundwater. Loharwala village in Bhiwani, for instance, recorded fluoride levels at a tubewell source as high as 22 mg/l, almost 15 times the permissible value. The CGWB deems water with fluoride concentrations exceeding 1.5 mg/l unsuitable for drinking. High fluoride concentrations have been associated with enamel staining, while levels between 5 and 10 mg/l lead to pathological changes such as back stiffness and difficulty performing natural movements.

Atawala village in Panipat faces a fluoride level of 16 mg/l, approximately 11 times the permissible value. Uchana in Jind is not far behind, recording 12 mg/l, eight times the permissible limit.

The National Green Tribunal, recognising the severity of the situation, has initiated proceedings related to arsenic and fluoride contamination of groundwater in several states. On December 20, 2023, the tribunal issued a notice to Haryana through the Chief Secretary, demanding a response.

In response to the crisis, Keshni Anand Arora, the Haryana Water Resources Authority chairperson, has announced a meeting with the Chief Minister on January 18. Arora emphasises the importance of monitoring drinking water quality, urging the Public Health Engineering Department, Urban Local Bodies Department, and the Haryana Pollution Control Board to collect data on arsenic and fluoride contamination. “Our agenda is that the authorities such as the Public Health Engineering Department, Urban Local Bodies Department and the Haryana Pollution Control Board should keep monitoring the quality of drinking water. Data on arsenic and fluoride contamination will be collected,” Arora told The Tribune.

The situation poses a severe threat to public health, and urgent measures are required to address the water contamination crisis in Haryana.

 

The Rich Get Richer While Global Poverty Deepens in “Decade of Division”


Tanupriya Singh 


Wealth accumulation by the rich has risen to the point that the world could see its first trillionaire within a decade. Meanwhile, it will take more than 200 years to end global poverty, a report by Oxfam International has found.
The rich get richer while global poverty deepens in “decade of division”

The wealth of the world’s top five richest men has more than doubled since 2020 while 4.8 billion people, or 60% of humanity, have been further impoverished. At this rate, while it could only take a decade for the world to have its first trillionaire, it will take 229 years to ensure that no person is living in poverty.

These findings are part of a new report titled Inequality Inc. published by Oxfam International, released on the eve of the World Economic Forum meeting in Davos, Switzerland.

“We’re witnessing the beginnings of a decade of division, with billions of people shouldering the economic shockwaves of pandemic, inflation and war, while billionaires’ fortunes boom. This inequality is no accident; the billionaire class is ensuring corporations deliver more wealth to them at the expense of everyone else,” stated Amitabh Behar, Oxfam’s interim Executive Director, in a press release.

Neo-colonial divide

The inequality gap between the Global North and the Global South has increased for the first time in 25 years.

Rich countries of the Global North account for 69% of all global wealth and 74% of all billionaire wealth. This concentration of wealth is a legacy of colonialism and empire, the report notes, adding that “since the formal end of colonialism, “neo-colonial relationships with the Global South persist, perpetuating economic imbalances and rigging the economic rules in favor of rich nations.” This extraction of wealth has been facilitated by multinational corporations.

Meanwhile, inequalities have also been reproduced within Global North countries, where marginalized and racialized communities are facing the brunt.

Corporate greed drives inequality

Seven out of 10 of the world’s largest corporations have a billionaire either as CEO or the main shareholder. These companies have a worth of USD 10.2 trillion, surpassing the combined GDPs of all countries in Latin America and Africa.

Meanwhile, according to Oxfam’s analysis of data from the World Benchmarking Alliance, only 0.4% of the world’s over 1,600 largest companies have publicly committed to paying their workers and supporting paying workers along their value chains a minimum wage.

The rich have also extracted benefit from their shareholder positions — with the top 1% owning 43% of all global financial assets. The figure stands at 48% in the West Asia/Middle East region, 50% in Asia, and 47% in Europe.

For every USD 100 in profit made by 96 big corporations between July 2022 and June 2023, USD 82 went to shareholders in the form of stock buybacks and dividends. On the whole, in the 12 month period up to June 2023, 148 of the biggest corporations globally had raked in USD 1.8 trillion in profits.

According to the World Inequality Lab, in 2022, the poorest 50% of the world’s population earned just 8.5% of global income.

The majority of people are able to afford less with their wages each month despite working for longer hours in unsafe and precarious conditions. The wages of 791 million workers have failed to keep up with inflation, to the extent that workers have lost USD 1.5 trillion in just the last two years. This is equal to 25 days of lost wages per worker, Oxfam has stated.

The difference between the wealth of the ultra rich as compared to the wages of workers is so vast that, according to the report, it would take a female worker in the health or social sector 1,200 years to earn what the CEO of a Fortune 100 company makes in a single year.

Importantly, beyond a persisting gender gap in income, the unpaid care work performed by women has subsidized the economy to the tune of at least USD 10.8 trillion each year. This is three times the economic contribution of the global tech industry, which has benefited from government support and subsidies the world over.

Oxfam argues that a “key instrument” that has exacerbated global inequality is the growth of monopoly power, which has allowed a handful of corporations to manipulate and influence entire economies and governments, such as price gouging, suppressing wages, privatizing public services in pursuit of profit, and shaping labor laws and policies which includes restrictions on workers’ rights to unionize.

The report quotes Chile’s former democratic socialist president Salvador Allende, who was overthrown in a US-backed coup, who had warned that “‘We are faced by a direct confrontation between the large transnational corporations and the states. The corporations are interfering in the fundamental political, economic and military decisions of the state.”

Oxfam also cites a study by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) which found that monopoly power was responsible for 76% of the decline witnessed in labor income share in the manufacturing sector in the US.

“Monopolies harm innovation and crush workers and smaller businesses. The world hasn’t forgotten how pharma monopolies deprived millions of people of COVID-19 vaccines, creating a racist vaccine apartheid, while minting a new club of billionaires,” Behar stated.

Between 1995 and 2015, 60 pharmaceutical companies merged into just 10 “Big Pharma” firms. Despite the fact that innovation is made largely possible through public funding, Big Pharma monopolies have aggressively used intellectual property and global trade rules to restrict access to life-saving medications and vaccines, as has most recently been witnessed during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Moreover, “economies across the Global South are locked into exporting primary commodities, from copper to coffee, for use by monopolistic industries in the Global North, perpetuating a colonial-style ‘extractivist’ model,” the report states.

Beyond market concentration and monopoly power, corporations and their owners have shored up their wealth by waging a “sustained and highly effective war on taxation… depriving the public of critical resources.”

Between 1975 and 2019, while many corporations made record profits, the corporate tax rate dropped from 23% to 17%. In 2022, around USD 1 trillion in profits were transferred to tax havens.

The neoliberal “Wall Street consensus”

The collapse of corporate taxation is partly a result of “the broader neoliberal agenda promoted by corporations and their wealthy owners, often alongside Global North countries and international institutions such as the World Bank.”

Lack of corporate revenue also affects funds for “inequality-busting public services”. For instance, in Morocco, tax incentives, 43.9% of which benefited corporations, surpassed the country’s entire health budget for 2021.

The impact on public services, and by extension on those who rely on these services not only as consumers but as workers, is particularly acute in a context of the debt crisis in the Global South. Between now and 2029, low and lower- middle income countries will pay almost half a billion US dollars a day in interest and debt payments.

High levels of debt coupled with corporate tax dodging under the eye of the IMF and World Bank lead to austerity policies across critical sectors including health and social protections.

While the ability of governments to sustain public services is obstructed, corporations around the world have pushed for the privatization of critical services including health care and education. As the report states, this is done not only through the sale of public assets, but also through the integration of the private corporate sector into public policies and programs through outsourcing and “public-private partnerships”.  Privatization in turn grants corporations greater influence over public resources.

“Major development agencies and institutions, many of which have adopted policies that prioritize private provision of services, have found common ground with investors by embracing approaches that ‘de-risk’ such arrangements by shifting financial risk from the private to the public sector”, the report states.

“This new ‘Wall Street Consensus’ reframes the ‘Washington Consensus’ in the language of contemporary development speak, and envisions the transformation of basic services such as education, healthcare and water into financial assets backed by public resources.”

Submitting basic public services, access to which should be universal, to the logic of private profit-making, has worked to deny access to marginalized and historically oppressed communities and has worsened inequalities.

Corporations, especially in the fossil fuel industry, have also been responsible for driving the global climate crisis, while pushing market-based false solutions that exacerbate poverty and inequality. Not only have fossil fuel companies suppressed climate science and lobbied at both national and international levels to influence policy, they have used “litigation terrorism” to crack down countries that have taken measures to protect the environment.

Oxfam’s report calls on governments to take steps to build an “economy for all”. This includes “revitalizing the state” to ensure universal provision of key services such as health care and education as well as a public monopoly or a public option in sectors including energy and transport.

It further calls on states to “rein in the runaway power of corporations”, including breaking up private monopolies, “democratizing trade” and ending “abuse of patent rules”, putting in place legislations to protect wages and introducing taxes on corporations and rich individuals including through permanent wealth and excess profit taxes.

Courtesy: Peoples Dispatch

 

Rohith Vemula: Life and Death of a Dalit Scholar in 'New India'


Newsclick Report 




It's been 8 years since Rohith took his life, leaving behind a life of struggle and a haunting last letter.
Rohith Vemula

On January 17, 2016, Rohith Vemula, a research scholar at University of Hyderabad (UoH), was found dead in a hostel room. His death sparked a series of protests across the country. It was termed an 'institutional murder' by those who were demanding justice for Rohith.

Rohith, along with his friends, was being investigated for "casteist" and "anti-national" activities as members of Ambedkar Students Association (ASA). They were suspended and thrown out of their hostel and were forced to live on the street. After his death Rohith was subjected to even more humiliation by the BJP-led union government when his dalit identity was questioned. 

It's been 8 years since Rohith took his life, leaving behind a life of struggle and a haunting last letter.

 

LA REVUE GAUCHE - Left Comment: Search results for DALITS 

 

An Anniversary West Would Rather Forget


M.K. Bhadrakumar 


An epochal anniversary, the Siege of Leningrad, from the annals of modern history is coming up in another 10 days that remains a living memory for the Russian people.
On the 75th anniversary of the battle that lifted the Siege of Leningrad in World War 2, people walk in snowfall to the Motherland monument to place flowers at the Piskaryovskoye Cemetery where the victims were buried, St. Petersburg, Russia, January 26, 2019
On the 75th anniversary of the battle that lifted the Siege of Leningrad in World War 2, people walk in snowfall to the Motherland monument to place flowers at the Piskaryovskoye Cemetery where the victims were buried, St. Petersburg, Russia, January 26, 2019

An epochal anniversary from the annals of modern history is coming up in another ten days that remains a living memory for the Russian people. The Siege of Leningrad, arguably the most gruesome episode of the Second World War, which lasted for 900 days, was finally broken by the Soviet Red Army on January 27, 1944, eighty years ago to be exact. 

The siege endured by more than three million people, of whom nearly one half died, most of them in the first six months when the temperature fell to 30° below zero. It was an apocalyptic event. Civilians died from starvation, disease and cold. Yet it was a heroic victory. Leningraders never tried to surrender even though food rations were reduced to a few slices of bread mixed with sawdust, and the inhabitants ate glue, rats — and even each other — while the city went without water, electricity, fuel or transportation and was being shelled daily. 

It was on June 22, 1941 that the German armies crossed the Russian frontiers. Within six weeks, the Army Group North of the Wehrmacht, armed forces of the Third Reich, was within 50 km of Leningrad in a fantastic blitzkrieg and had advanced 650 km deep into Soviet territory.

A month later, the Germans had all but completed the city’s encirclement, only a perilous route across Lake Ladoga to the east connected Leningrad with the rest of Russia. But the Germans got no further. And 900 days later their retreat began. 

The epic siege of Leningrad was the longest endured by any city since Biblical times, and, equally, citizens became heroes — artists, musicians, writers, soldiers and sailors who stubbornly resisted the iron from entering their souls. Petrified by the prospect of surrender to the Soviet Union, the Nazis preferred to lay down arms before the western allied forces, but Gen. Dwight Eisenhower, Supreme Commander of the Allied Expeditionary Force in Europe, ordered that the honour of victory should go to the Red Army. 

Herein lies one of the greatest paradoxes of war and peace in modern times. Today, the anniversary of the siege of Leningrad has become, most certainly, an occasion that the US and many of its European allies would rather not remember. Yet, its contemporary relevance is not to be glossed over, either.

The Nazi leadership aimed to exterminate Leningrad’s entire population by enforced starvation. Death by starvation was a deliberate act on the part of the German Reich. In the words of Joseph Goebbels, Adolf Hitler “intended to have cities like Moscow and St Petersburg wiped out.” This was “necessary”, he wrote in July 1941, “because if we want to divide Russia into its individual parts,” it should “no longer have a spiritual, political or economic centre.” 

Hitler himself declared in September 1941, “We have no interest in maintaining even a part of the metropolitan population in this existential war.” Any talk of the city surrendering had to be “rejected, as the problem of keeping and feeding the population cannot be solved by us.”

Simply put, the population of Leningrad was left to starve to death – much like the millions of Soviet prisoners of war held by the Wehrmacht. The historian Jörg Ganzenmüller later wrote that this form of mass murder was cost-effective for Berlin, for, it was “genocide by simply doing nothing”. 

“Genocide by doing nothing”! Those chilling words are as well applicable today to the West’s “sanctions from hell” with an ulterior agenda to “erase” Russia and carve out five new states from its vast landmass with fabulous resources that can be subjugated by the industrial world. 

The mother of all ironies is that Germany is even today at the forefront of the “genocide by doing nothing” strategy to weaken and bring down the Russian Federation on its knees. The Biden administration depended on a troika of three German politicians to do the heavy lifting in that failed effort to erase Russia — EU’s top bureaucrat in Brussels Ursula von der Layen, German Chancellor Olaf Schulz and Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock. 

George Santayana, the Spanish-American philosopher, essayist, poet, and novelist once said, “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.” This is how the far-right thrives.

In Germany and elsewhere, younger generations are becoming indifferent to the history of fascism. The idea of a Fourth Reich has entered an unprecedented heyday and is currently experiencing a new phase of normalisation in Europe. The tumultuous political upheaval throughout the western world provides the backdrop today.

The author of The Fourth Reich: The Specter of Nazism from World War II to the Present, historian and professor of history and Judaic studies Gavriel Rosenfeld has written that “The only way to mute the siren call of the Fourth Reich is to know its full history. Although it is increasingly difficult in our present-day world of fake ‘facts’ and deliberate disinformation to forge a consensus about historical truth, we have no alternative but to pursue it.” 

The justification of political violence is classically fascist. This past week, we saw a breathtaking spectacle at the International Court of Justice (ICJ) in Hague reminding us that we are now in fascism’s legal phase. If the Nazis used Judeo-Bolshevism as their constructed enemy, Israel is doing the same thing by raising the bogeyman of Hamas. Fascism feeds off a narrative of supposed national humiliation by internal enemies. 

Meanwhile, what gets forgotten is that there has been a growing fascist social and political movement in Israel for decades. Like other fascist movements, it is riddled with internal contradictions, but this movement now has a classically authoritarian leader in Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu who has shaped and exacerbated it, and is determined that in his time in politics it will be normalised. 

The probability is high that in a matter of a few days, the ICJ will give some sort of interim order/injunction to Israel to end the violence against the hapless Palestinians in Gaza. But the fascist movement Netanyahu now leads preceded him, and will outlive him.

These are forces that feed off ideologies with deep roots in Jewish history. They may be defending a fictional glorious and virtuous national past, but it would be a grave error to think they cannot ultimately win.

The Russians are learning this home truth the hard way in Ukraine where “de-nazification” is turning out to be the weakest link in their special military operation, given its geopolitical moorings traceable to Germany’s dalliance with the Ukrainian Neo-Nazi groups in Kiev in the run-up to the 2014 coup, which the US inherited gleefully and wouldn’t let go. 

MK Bhadrakumar is a former diplomat. He was India’s Ambassador to Uzbekistan and Turkey. The views are personal.

Courtesy: Indian Punchline

Shostakovich: Symphony No. 7 "Leningrad" (Bernstein CSO 1989)

I.   Allegretto (0:00)

II.  Moderato, poco allegretto (31:44)

III. Adagio (46:32)

IV. Allegro non troppo (1:05:59)


Composer: Dmitri Shostakovich

Piece: Symphony No. 7

Conductor: Leonard Bernstein

Orchestra: Chicago Symphony Orchestra

Date: 1989

Label: Deutsche Grammophon