Suez Canal Earnings Fall as Vessels Re-Route Around Africa

Suez Canal traffic, January 13 (File image courtesy SCA)

PUBLISHED FEB 6, 2024 4:04 PM BY REBECCA GALANOPOULOS-JONES, VESON NAUTICAL

 

 

As we enter into the third month of escalating conflict in Yemen, the security risk has prompted significant rerouting of vessels with far-reaching consequences for global trade and transport. The latest trade data from Veson Nautical indicates a notable shift in traffic patterns. Geopolitical tensions and conflict have raised maritime security concerns in the region, given its strategic importance and critical maritime trade routes.

In addition, the ongoing crisis in Yemen has implications for traffic through the Suez Canal and therefore Egypt, which may incur substantial costs due to the disruptions in trade and transport. This situation could potentially serve as a catalyst for increased diplomatic efforts to broker peace, considering the economic losses incurred by the Egyptian government as a result of the crisis. Understanding the economic impact on Egypt and specifically the Suez Canal might encourage a more proactive approach towards resolving the conflict and mitigating its adverse effects on global trade. 

We take a look at the changes in the Suez Canal toll fees for crude tankers, bulkers, LNG, LPG and container ships over the period spanning from the beginning of 2023 to early January 2024. This analysis provides valuable insight into the financial implications for the Suez Canal and for the Egyptian government as Suez Canal transits reach a low.  

Overall toll fees fall about 40% since November 2023

Looking at the weekly tolls graph*, overall tolls have fallen by about 40% since the end of November from $47 million to $28 million. Container tolls have significantly decreased, falling by about 66% from the end of November, where estimated fees fell from about $18 million that week to $6 million at the start of January. However, in percentage terms the LPG sector experienced the biggest drop with tolls down by about 93%, from $1 million at the end of November to $153,000 in the first week of January. LNG tolls ranked third, with a fall of about 66%, followed by crude tankers which experienced a fall of about 23% from $7.3 million to $5.7 million in January. Bulkers were the least affected, with a comparatively modest decline of about 7%.   

Graph 1: Weekly estimated Suez Canal toll fees for crude tankers, bulkers, LNG, LPG and container ships 

The analysis of the sum of weekly calculated SCNT (Suez Canal Net Tonnage) transiting through the Suez Canal versus the Cape of Good Hope (Graph 2) reveals a noteworthy trend. The graph illustrates a reduction in SCNT through the Suez Canal and a corresponding increase in the Cape of Good Hope region/transit zone, which is particularly evident since November 2023. Month on month, there has been a significant decline of approximately 38% in the sum of weekly calculated SCNT through the Suez Canal, while the sum of SCNT going around the Cape of Good Hope has increased by about 25%. 

Graph 2: Sum of weekly calculated Suez Canal Net Tonnage (SCNT) for cargo vessels transiting through the Suez Canal vs Cape of Good Hope. 

This shift is attributed to a surge in attacks targeting vessels in the region, compelling ship operators to alter their routes. The consequences include increased costs including rising oil prices, shipment delays, threats to maritime security, and concerns about geopolitical instability. Without a resolution to the situation, this could further impact trade flows and increase commodity prices and emissions.  

As vessels divert away from the affected area and opt for the Cape of Good Hope route, tonne-mile demand for various sectors has increased, providing support to vessel earnings.  

In addition, the intervention of the US and UK military with strikes has caused a spike in oil prices. While levels have not risen as dramatically as they did following the invasion of Ukraine, there are ongoing threats of retaliation from Iranian-backed forces, suggesting potential further disruptions to oil supply in the future. 

Mixed impact on cargo markets

The influence of the situation on the various cargo markets has been mixed. In the crude tanker sector, rates for Suezmaxes and Aframaxes have firmed since the start of December up by around 16% and 63% respectively. The route around the Cape of Good Hope more than doubles the length of voyages from the Middle East to Europe and therefore reduces the supply of available tonnage in the market.  

In the container sector, the diversion has reversed a steady downward trend in freight rates since 2022. A large number of vessels have diverted from the Red Sea to Travel around the Cape of Good Hope, and this has also led to increasing earnings with Post Panamax period rates for one year up by about 7% from December.  

Although the impact on the bulker sector is significantly lower than for other markets, despite the usual dip in earnings during January, rates have remained historically high for this time of the year, even after a decrease from the peak in December. 

Conclusion

The complex interconnection of geopolitical events, maritime security concerns, and global trade dynamics underscores the multifaceted challenges facing the shipping industry in the current scenario. Although longer transit times and increased earnings may be acceptable in the short term, looking further ahead, they could be outweighed by increased costs to the owner.  

From the perspective of Egypt, reduced traffic through the Suez Canal and therefore a lower income from toll fees is likely to persist for the foreseeable future. However, understanding the economic repercussions on the nation could foster a more proactive approach to resolving the conflict and alleviate its adverse effects on global trade.  

*Estimated toll fees were calculated using the toll fees pre-15th Jan. 

Rebecca Galanopoulos-Jones is a Senior Content Analyst at Veson Nautical.

The opinions expressed herein are the author's and not necessarily those of The Maritime Executive.

India's Navy Steps Into the Spotlight in Red Sea Crisis

Indian commandos capture suspected Somali pirates aboard a dhow, January 26. Somali piracy has surged back in parallel with Houthi attacks (Indian Navy)

PUBLISHED FEB 1, 2024 9:48 PM BY THE MARITIME EXECUTIVE

 

The Red Sea maritime security crisis is an unwelcome burden on Indian commerce, but it is also a moment for India's blue-water navy to step out into the spotlight. The Indian Navy has established a heavy presence in the Gulf of Aden and the Western Indian Ocean, responding to Houthi attacks and helping to chase off the Somali pirate groups that are taking advantage of the conflict. 

At least a dozen Indian warships are operating to the east of Bab el-Mandeb, complementing the U.S.-led naval coalition without directly participating under its umbrella. It is the largest maritime force that India has ever deployed to the region, officials said. 

The Indian Navy's warships have served as first responders, helping in the aftermath of Houthi strikes and defeating hijackings (three in the span of two days). 

"[The Indian Navy] is increasingly showcasing the ability to be able to protect not only its interests but also give confidence to regional players that it is willing and able to shoulder regional responsibility," said Harsh Pant of the Observer Research Foundation, speaking to VOA. 

According to Chinese military researcher Zhang Junshe, the People's Liberation Army believes that India may have an additional reason for the large-scale deployment: a "gesture of goodwill towards the United States." Even though it has not publicly joined the American-led alliance, India's presence substantially expands the available pool of response assets in the region. 
Meanwhile, the U.S. Navy can concentrate on the more politically fraught task of countering Houthi attacks.