Monday, March 17, 2025

ECOCIDE

A 500-cubic-metre oil spill is still tainting lives in this Hungarian town

Hungary oil spill leaves residents afraid to use wells and demanding action from MOL.
Copyright Lili Rutai
By Lili Rutai
Published on 

After nearly 500 cubic metres of oil spilled from an old pipe, locals are demanding compensation and accountability from the Hungarian oil company.

In the outskirts of Gárdony, a town in central Hungary, small houses are occupied by agricultural workers and commuters. Robert Dudás, 28, and his partner, who both work in the nearby city of Székesfehérvár, moved here last February.

They were drawn to the clean, calm environment - a nice change after living in a Soviet-style apartment. But just a few months later, an oil spill changed their neighborhood.

Last September, MOL, Hungary’s leading gas and oil company, detected a drop in the pressure of one of their pipes. A weeks-long investigation eventually revealed a leak near Dudás’s house.

The cleanup could cost billions of forints (millions of euros) according to local media. The local population, including Dudás, claims there has been a lack of transparency, and is campaigning for compensation and answers.

The oil spill in Hungary

According to a report it released in late February, MOL - in which the Hungarian government has shares through foundations - detected a drop in pressure in its 190km long pipeline in September.

After locating the leak to a stretch two metres below ground near Gárdony in October, MOL dug up the pipe to reveal a 10cm long break.

It then halted the flow of oil for a few weeks before replacing the part, covering the pipe with fresh soil, and resuming operations. The monitoring and cleaning continues, through blue pipes that mark newly dug-up monitoring wells, of which around a dozen are visible in the streets near where the leak happened. 

But residents were left with questions, including about the quantity of the oil that escaped.

MOL initially acknowledged a spill of 10 cubic metres. But after an investigation by independent investigative watchdog Átlátszó, and pressure from the locals, the company admitted that almost 487 cubic metres of oil had escaped. 

That’s around one fifth of the volume of an Olympic swimming pool, or 6,500 times as much oil as a car gas tank could hold.

The locals in an ‘alternative’ living situation looking for answers

“There is one family which is directly affected,” Árpád Pál Eötvös, Gárdony’s mayor, told Euronews. They lived on the property next to where the spill happened. According to Eötvös, this family received compensation from MOL, which offered to buy their property.

Eötvös highlighted that his office is in weekly communication with MOL, which tested a dozen wells. On top of this, the municipal government tested over 50, none of which showed signs of contamination from oil, but found sodium, nitrite or e-coli bacteria, all of them harmful. 

According to Eötvös, this is due to the fact that this area, close to agriculture and without running water or paved roads, isn’t fit for full-time residents, but acknowledges that the high cost of renting drives people to live here. 

“This area is an alternative for the cost-of-living crisis,” agrees Róbert Dudás, a local resident. His property is around 200 metres from the leak. He learned about the incident on Facebook. 


Local residents Tibor Horányi, left, and Róbert Dudás, right, say MOL should do more for Gárdony after the incident.  Lili Rutai

Like many, Dudás relies on the well in his garden. He did a test privately in January 2025, and found no contamination. Nevertheless, he received a letter from the municipal government, advising residents to abstain from drinking well water due to possible contamination unrelated to the spill. 

He thinks that the municipal government should advocate for those living here, not only the one family which received compensation. “There are 164 residents here. The local government has let all of them down,” he says.

According to Tibor Horányi, an environmental engineer and member of the NGO Alba Natura Foundation, and a member of the municipal assembly, there are more victims from the oil spill than MOL and the local government have acknowledged.

"This person doesn’t want to use well water because he can smell oil. This one can’t keep animals, this [person] stopped growing vegetables,” Horányi points in different directions, standing on soil MOL used to fill holes after the leak. According to the Gárdony-based environmental engineer, the locals could take MOL to court for compensation.

“But not everyone is in a financial position to pay for a lawyer,” he says.

A slow cleanup in Gárdony

In its February report, MOL announced it is building an L-shaped solid wall underground, to halt the potential spread of the contamination while extraction is ongoing through monitoring wells.

Experts, including Horányi and the local branch of Greenpeace, fear the contamination could reach Lake Velence, Hungary’s third largest lake which lies just a few kilometres away and is home to multiple endangered species.

Lake Velence is home to many bird species including the Purple Heron and Moustached Warbler, as well as otters and frogs.    Lili Rutai

“In a standard damage clearance, one doesn’t use isolation walls because they are expensive,” says Gergely Simon, a chemical expert from Greenpeace Hungary. “We suspect that the contamination is larger than they thought.”

Gárdony’s mayor says that the contamination has not spread beyond the initial scope, but believes the plan for building the underground wall is “reassuring.” 

Aging pipes could be a source of future accidents

Greenpeace notes that MOL’s pipe system is vulnerable due to its age, as many of the pipes were laid 50 years ago.

The incident in Gárdony wasn’t an isolated case. Moreover, the locals share a rumour about a leak here, ten years ago, although there is no evidence of this.  

A few weeks before MOL acknowledged the break in Gárdony, another pipeline in Kiskunmajsa, a town in southern Hungary, burst and leaked crude oil.

MOL also has a controlling stake in INA, the Croatian oil-gas company, which lost one of its gas platforms in the Adriatic Sea in 2020. It hasn’t been recovered since, posing a threat to marine life.

Greenpeace is demanding compensation, transparency, and cleanup at these sites, as well as stronger efforts to prevent similar incidents, and a transition away from fossil-fuel infrastructure.

MOL says they look after their network of over 1,200 kilometres of pipeage in Hungary using “the most modern equipment.”

“It seems like the maintenance and care of these pipes is not sufficient,” Gergely Simon, from Greenpeace, says. "Because if it were, these events wouldn’t have happened."

MOL didn’t respond to questions from Euronews.

 ICYMI

Peruvian farmer takes German energy giant RWE to court over melting glaciers

Saul Luciano Lliuya, pictured in Essen in 2015, could reframe the fight for climate justice
Copyright AP Photo
By Craig Saueurs
Published on 

The case has taken nearly 10 years to be heard with judges travelling to Peru to visit his village.

A landmark climate case brought by a Peruvian farmer against energy giant RWE resumes today (17 March) at the Higher Regional Court in Hamm, Germany.

Saul Luciano Lliuya is a Quechua-speaking farmer and mountain guide from Peru’s Ancash region. The 44-year-old believes that RWE, as one of the world’s top historic greenhouse gas emitters, should share in the cost of protecting his hometown, Huaraz, from a swollen glacial lake at risk of overflowing due to melting snow and ice.

The hearings will determine what evidence will be permissible in the final trial, which will rule on whether RWE – which has never operated in Peru – can be held liable for damages.

RWE denies legal responsibility, arguing that climate change is a global issue caused by many contributors.

What is the case about?

Lliuya first challenged RWE after a 2013 Carbon Majors Study found the company responsible for 0.5 per cent of climate change since industrialisation began in the 1850s.

He is asking for the company to pay for about 0.5 per cent of the cost of protecting Huaraz from the imminent risk of flooding and overflow from Lake Palcacocha. That amount has been tallied at around €17,000.

“What I am asking is for the company to take responsibility for part of the construction costs, such as a dike in this case,” he told reporters in Lima in early March before departing for Germany.

In 2015, Lliuya filed a suit against the company that was later dismissed by a court in Essen. In 2017, a higher court in Hamm admitted an appeal.

Following pandemic-induced delays, the initial hearings are now taking place. 

What does it mean for global corporations?

The case is ground-breaking in every way.

RWE insists it has always complied with government guidelines on greenhouse gas emissions and aims to be carbon-neutral by 2040. Yet its historical contribution to a warming planet has put it in the crosshairs, raising questions about corporate accountability for climate change and cross-border legal responsibilities.

Tourists walk in front of the Tuco glacier in Huascaran National Park.
AP Photo/Martin Mejia, File

“Never before has a case of climate justice reached an evidentiary stage,” Andrea Tang, a lawyer for Germanwatch, the environmental NGO supporting Lliuya, said in Lima.

She added that the case “would set a huge precedent for the future of climate justice.”

With more than 40 climate damages cases ongoing worldwide, according to not-for-profit research group Zero Carbon Analytics, Lliuya's case has major precedent setting potential.

How a Peruvian farmer captured global headlines

Before the case even reached this stage, it had already commanded global attention. 

For one, Lliuya had never left Peru before he decided to take RWE to court. His efforts also brought European experts to Peru.

Following diplomatic talks, judges from Germany visited Huaraz and Lake Palcacocha – about 4,500 metres above sea level in the Andes - in 2022. Surrounded by dozens of journalists and documentary film teams, they assessed the potential risk to the village.

While Lliuya has won the legal battle to have his case tried, it is yet to be seen if that visit also won the judges over to his side of the scientific argument. 

 

Southeast Europe erupts in weekend of protests

Southeast Europe erupts in weekend of protests
Drone footage from NGO CRTA shows the huge crowd gathered in and around Slavija Square. / CRTA via FacebookFacebook
By bne IntelliNews March 16, 2025

Close to 300,000 demonstrators took to the streets of Serbia’s capital Belgrade this weekend, in the latest of a series of mass student-led protests. While the demonstration in Belgrade was by far the largest, smaller protests took place in several countries across Southeast Europe and the wider region. 

These included rallies in solidarity held in Slovenia’s capital, Ljubljana, and in Banja Luka, the de facto capital of Republika Srpska, Bosnia & Herzegovina.

In Romania, approximately 10,000 people gathered in a pro-European demonstration against the growing influence of far-right parties. 

In the broader region, in Hungary, tens of thousands marched in opposition to the government’s increasingly tight grip on the media. Georgia, too, has seen persistent demonstrations, with protests continuing for over 100 days following the government’s decision to halt the country’s EU accession efforts. 

While each protest has its own immediate trigger, a common theme runs through the region: frustration with entrenched political elites accused of eroding democratic institutions, consolidating power and curbing civil liberties. The protests in countries including Serbia, Hungary and Georgia reflect mounting discontent over corruption and democratic backsliding. While the Romanian protest was aimed not against the government but at the increasingly powerful far-right parties, participants share with the Georgian opposition a commitment to EU values. 

The aims of the protesters differ too. Those in Georgia want a re-run of the October 2024 election that was widely seen as rigged in favour of the ruling Georgian Dream party. In Hungary, the opposition is also keen to oust Prime Minister Viktor Orban’s long-ruling Fidesz party. 

In Serbia, by contrast, protesters say they are not looking to oust the government or stage a colour revolution, but to bring in much needed reforms and force the authorities to take responsibility for a deadly accident at Novi Sad railway station. The months-long wave of protests has, however, already led to the resignation of Prime Minister Milos Vucevic, and more recently President Aleksandar Vucic has talked of a snap general election to resolve the crisis. 

Serbia’s largest protest in decades

The March 15 protest in Belgrade followed months of student-led protests following the collapse of a canopy at Novi Sad railway station in November 2024. The accident, which claimed 15 lives, ignited public outrage over government negligence and corruption.

Despite efforts by the government to quell discontent, protests have grown. The biggest by far was the gathering in Belgrade on March 15, with students and other activists travelling across the country to join. Independent observers and aerial footage suggest the number of people at the event was between 275,000 and 325,000.

The scale of the March 15 protest has intensified pressure on Vucic, raising the likelihood of snap elections.

The ongoing protests in Serbia have resonated beyond its borders. Hundreds gathered in Banja Luka, the de facto capital of Republika Srpska, in support of Serbian demonstrators, while a rally in Ljubljana saw protesters observe a 15-minute silence outside the Serbian embassy.

Romanians rally for Europe 

Thousands of Romanians gathered in Bucharest on March 15, waving EU and Romanian tricolour flags to express their support for the European Union, as tensions mount over the upcoming presidential election in May.

The country is set to hold a fresh two-round presidential vote on May 4 and 18 after the Constitutional Court cancelled the initial election in December, citing allegations of Russian interference that reportedly benefited front-runner Calin Georgescu.

This time around, the candidacies of both Georgescu and fellow far-right candidate Diana Sosoaca have been rejected, but polls indicate another far-right candidate such as Alliance for the Union of Romanians (AUR) leader George Simion could perform well. 

Georgescu’s stunning first-round victory last year, and the subsequent decision to cancel the election drew global attention to Romania. Georgescu’s cause has been seized upon by allies of US President Donald Trump, with both Vice President FD Vance and billionaire Elon Musk speaking out in his defence. This has placed Romania at the centre of the rift between the EU and Trump’s US.

New political crisis looms in Bulgaria

Earlier this week, thousands of people protested in the Bulgarian capital on March 12 after the head of the Constitutional Court accused prosecutors of interfering with the recount of votes cast in the October general election. 

Reports and video footage on election day indicated widespread fraud, including ballot stuffing, with the frauds believed to be in favour of DPS — New Beginning and Gerb, now the largest party within the ruling coalition. 

The result of the recount has now been announced, resulting in a reshuffle of seats in parliament. Both Gerb and DPS — New Beginning have lost seats, while the nationalist, pro-Russian Greatness party will now enter parliament.

After the changes in the parliament’s composition and a rift within the ruling coalition, a new political crisis is looming after Gerb’s Boyko Borissov said nothing can be done without the backing of Magnitsky-sanctioned oligarch and politician Delyan Peevski, indicating Peevski will likely wield a high level of influence over the Gerb-led government. Any attempt to give Peevski a formal role within the government would likely result in protests. 

109 days of protests in Georgia 

Elsewhere in the region, Georgians have been protesting daily for 109 days as of March 16 against the abandonment of the country’s EU path and what they see as a slide toward authoritarianism under the ruling Georgian Dream party. 

Rustaveli Avenue in Tbilisi remains a focal point, with protesters blocking the street in recent protests to demand fresh elections and the release of detained activists and journalists.

The recent arrest of media figures, including Batumelebi/Netgazeti founder Mzia Amaghlobeli, has further fuelled public anger. Despite heavy-handed police crackdowns, protests persist.

Hungary’s opposition gains momentum

In Central Europe, tens of thousands of Hungarians rallied in Budapest against Prime Minister Viktor Orbán, as opposition leader Péter Magyar of the Tisza party vowed to end Orbán’s 15-year rule in the next general election.

As over 50,000 supporters of Tisza and other groups gathered in Budapest despite the cold, Magyar promised to launch a public survey addressing 12 key economic and political topics to gauge the "voice of the nation”. He told supporters: “Our moment has arrived.”

On the same day, Orbán addressed his own supporters, intensifying his rhetoric against NGOs, independent journalists and pro-EU opposition figures, accusing them of being foreign agents. He also reiterated his stance against Ukraine’s EU membership.

Serbians call for systemic change at country's largest-ever protest

Serbians call for systemic change at country's largest-ever protest
Around 300,000 people flooded the streets of Belgrade on March 15. / bne IntelliNewsFacebook
By Tatyana Kekic in Belgrade March 16, 2025

On March 15, Serbia witnessed its largest protest in history, an outpouring of public anger, hope and demand for accountability. An estimated 300,000 people flooded the streets of Belgrade, the culmination of months of student-led protests triggered by an accident at Novi Sad’s railway station in November 2024, which claimed the lives of 15 people and injured two others.

The scale of the protest has been the subject of debate. While the police reported 107,000 attendees at its peak, independent sources, such as the Archive of Public Gatherings, estimated the crowd at anywhere between 275,000 and 325,000. Whichever the exact figure, the protest marked an unprecedented display of discontent with the government of President Aleksandar Vucic. 

The tragedy in Novi Sad, caused by the collapse of a canopy roof at a station that had just recently been renovated, has galvanised both students and ordinary citizens into a powerful movement demanding justice. The protesters believe corruption contributed to the disaster, and their calls for accountability have already led to the resignation of Prime Minister Milos Vucevic and several other high-ranking officials.

Despite the government's efforts to limit the size of the protest by suspending public transportation to Belgrade, including trains and buses, masses of people arrived on foot, by bike and in cars. "We flew in without the falcon," read one of the many witty placards, referring to the suspension of the train services connecting Novi Sad and Belgrade.

Public transport ceased in Belgrade just after 9 a.m. on March 15 "for security reasons", but this did little to dampen the determination of the demonstrators, many of whom arrived from across the country the night before. Even Vucic, always keen to downplay the scale of such protests, was forced to admit that this one was quite large. "We will have to change ourselves," he acknowledged in an address to the nation after the protest.

The protest was a testament to the anger over government mismanagement, but also to the peaceful determination of the demonstrators. Despite the overwhelming size and tense atmosphere in the run up to the protest, the event remained largely incident-free.

This was a stark contrast to fears raised in the days leading up to the protest, when rumours of violence were rife, mostly fuelled by government rhetoric and state media. "I felt everyone was on edge… expecting something to happen," said a young teacher from Belgrade. But against the backdrop of so much anticipation, the protest unfolded remarkably peacefully.

Vucic praised the police for their handling of the situation. "We managed to preserve the peace," he declared, an acknowledgment of the success of the police and the people in keeping the protest largely free from violence.

Nonetheless, some incidents did occur, including another car-ramming incident, a grim reminder of  the past months’ rare clashes, when enraged drivers have rammed their cars through groups of students blocking traffic. Serbian media reported that 22 people were arrested and 56 others injured throughout the day.

The student organisers made significant efforts to keep the peace, even as tensions escalated. Towards the end of the day, a small group of individuals threw objects and pyrotechnics. Student organisers wearing yellow vests attempted to contain the situation, but soon withdrew, stressing that such incidents were not part of their protest. By 11 p.m., the streets were mostly empty.

In an official statement posted before the protests, the student organisers had condemned any form of violence, emphasising that the protest’s goal was not to attack or invade institutions but to demand systemic change.

This is not a colour revolution, the students insist. Despite the scale of the protests, they are not officially calling for regime change or siding with opposition groups. What they seek is far more fundamental: transparency, accountability and the restoration of the rule of law. They want a government that works for the people, not for itself. "All we are saying is give the constitution a chance," another sign read.

Their demands echo those heard in Serbia a quarter of a century ago, during the mass protests against Slobodan Milosevic, to live in a "normal" European country. "We just want a country that works," law student Jana Vasic told the BBC, a sentiment echoed by many in the crowd.

The people of Serbia are asking for systemic change, for a system which is not dependent on bribes and favours and for a future where public officials are held responsible for their actions.

Prosecutors have indicted at least 16 individuals in connection with the Novi Sad collapse, including former construction minister Goran Vesic, but charges have yet to go to trial. The protesters vow to continue their fight until those responsible for the tragedy are held accountable.

Serbia could be heading for elections after largest protest in history

Serbia could be heading for elections after largest protest in history
Serbian President Aleksandar Vucic said that he may hold early elections to win a new mandate after the country saw the largest ever demonstrations in its history calling for societal change. / bne IntelliNewsFacebook
By bne IntelliNews March 16, 2025

Serbia could be heading toward snap elections after the country saw its largest protest in history on March 15, raising pressure on the government and President Aleksandar Vucic to respond.

An estimated 300,000 people gathered in the capital Belgrade on Saturday, marking the climax of months of student-led protests sparked by a deadly infrastructure collapse at Novi Sad railway station in November 2024.

The incident, which killed 15 people and injured two others, has sparked a wave of protests led by students, demanding government accountability and justice. The protests have created a political crisis for the President, leading to the resignation of the Prime Minister, Milos Vucevic.

During a government session at the Palace of Serbia on March 16, President Vucic said that the Prime Minister’s resignation would be formally confirmed on March 18. Following this, the 30-day deadline for the formation of a new government will begin.

“If the new government is not formed within the legal deadline, elections will be held, most likely on June 8,” Vucic told reporters, adding that the situation in the country needs to be normalised as soon as possible.

Despite the government's attempts to address public dissatisfaction and calm the months-long protests, public anger has only escalated. Protests have continued to grow in size, with the Belgrade protest on March 15 representing the peak of a nationwide movement that has seen similar demonstrations in over 200 towns and cities across Serbia.

Vucic's comments came in a meeting with National Assembly Speaker Ana Brnabic, where he outlined the timeline for Vucevic’s resignation to trigger the 30-day deadline. If a new government is not formed within that period, the country could face early elections in June.

While the protests have gained significant momentum, opposition parties have struggled to present a unified response or alternative leadership to challenge the ruling Serbian Progressive Party (SNS). This political fragmentation could encourage Vucic to call elections as a means to reaffirm his political legitimacy, despite the risk of losing his parliamentary majority.

Vucic, known for his frequent use of snap elections to reinforce his authority, may view elections as a chance to reset his leadership amid mounting public dissatisfaction. However, holding an election in the wake of the largest protest in Serbia’s history carries significant risks.

Public frustration could lead to a surge in support for opposition parties, even those who have struggled to present a cohesive platform. Nevertheless, the president’s history of political manoeuvring suggests that he may view elections as the best option for resolving the current crisis. 


Serbian police reportedly use sonic cannon against protesters

Serbian police reportedly use sonic cannon against protesters
Video footage from the protest shows demonstrators scattering.Facebook
By bne IntelliNews March 16, 2025

The Serbian police have been accused of using a sonic cannon against protesting students on March 15 when the largest protest against strongman Aleksandar Vucic was held in the capital Belgrade.

According to local authorities, the rally gathered around 100,000 people, but independent observers and aerial footage suggest the number was much higher, at between 275,000 and 325,000.

A video, posted on X by a protester, shows the moment when all protesters on one street scattered after the use of the weapon. A sound can be heard as well.

The LRAC sonic cannon is an acoustic weapon that fires a targeted "beam" of sound at very high volume, up to 160 dB, according to Visegrad24.

The weapon was allegedly used during the 15-minute silence protesters were holding to pay tribute to the 15 people who died after a roof collapse at the railway station in Novi Sad in November 2024.

The incident fuelled accusations of government corruption and mismanagement, escalating into a broad movement against President Vucic.

Vucic has called on the Prosecutor's Office to investigate the alleged use of the sonic cannon. However, he suggested that the story was fake news, and demanded the prosecution of those who first published the story.