Friday, June 28, 2024


Bodies of 160 pilot whales lay stranded on an Australian beach, mysteriously they save themselves

As people organized to pull the dead whales out of the water and onto the beach, they circled the massive bodies and prayed, bidding farewell to these majestic creatures. The emotional weight hung heavy in the air.



Mariela Laksman
June 28, 2024

160 long-finned pilot whales beached on the western Australian coast. | Photo courtesy of Ian Wiese


JOURNALIST’S NOTES
INTERVIEW SUBJECT
Ian Wiese, director of Geographe Marine Research (GMR) in Dunsborough, is a retired IT developer with over 50 years of experience. His expertise spans programming, systems and database design, engineering simulation, and SCADA systems. Ian has worked with the Western Australian Water Corporation and completed international consulting assignments. Since retiring, he’s focused on cetacean research in Geographe Bay, applying his IT skills to develop a Lidar-based system for small drones to study whales. GMR, a non-profit charity and CSIRO-approved research institute, supports marine research, particularly cetacean studies.

BACKGROUND INFORMATION
More than 100 long-finned pilot whales that stranded along the shores of Western Australia was successfully guided back into the ocean, while unfortunately, 29 whales did not survive. .
Following the rescue efforts where marine officials and volunteers assisted the remaining whales back out to sea, boats remained on standby and a spotter plane monitored the area to prevent any whales from returning to shore. The stranding involved four pods totaling 160 pilot whales along approximately 1,640 feet of beach at Toby Inlet near Dunsborough, Western Australia.

GEOGRAPHE BAY, Australia — Early in the morning on April 25, 2024, I received an urgent message from one of our directors. Startled, I picked up my mobile phone. When I heard the news, I froze. A massive stranding of long-finned pilot whales occurred just three kilometers from my home. Without hesitation, I notified the local authorities, grabbed my car keys, and raced towards the beach.

When I arrived, I walked along the sand and witnessed the full extent of the disaster. One hundred and sixty pilot whales lay scattered across the beach, clustered in shallow water, desperately fighting for their lives. The stranded whales stretched along the coastline, covering nearly 500 meters. Some whales had already perished, and I feared more would follow as the morning went on.

Read more environment stories at Orato World Media.
Several stranded pilot whales tragically succumbed despite tireless efforts to save them

Growing up in Busselton, a small coastal town in Geographe Bay, I never saw whales. The whaling industry nearly wiped them out. By the 1960s, several species neared extinction. Blue whales and southern right whales, once abundant, now numbered only a few hundred worldwide. Learning about their plight stirred a deep desire within me—a passion to protect these magnificent creatures.

On April 25, when I arrived at the beach, I encountered an overwhelming and distressing scene. Hundreds of people already gathered there, and the crowd steadily grew. Television crews arrived, and journalists set up their cameras to capture the tragic sight. Witnessing pilot whales struggling for their lives, I steeled myself. The urgency gripped us all, preparing us for the challenging task ahead.

In the water, we tirelessly worked to ease their suffering. We shielded them from the sun and ensured they stayed hydrated. Neighbors, veterinarians, marine scientists, wildlife experts, and our dedicated volunteers from Geographe Marine Research joined forces. We fought to keep the whales afloat, their blowholes above water so they could breathe.

We learned from past incidents that euthanasia was often the most ‘humane’ course of action. Yet, this time, we pushed ourselves to the limit, determined to do everything in our power. Unfortunately, despite our determined efforts, we grappled with grief as some of the whales succumbed. My heart ached, particularly for the smaller ones, their final breaths leaving a heavy burden on my soul.
Amidst prayers and warnings, the stranded whales’ unexpected return astonished the crowd

As people organized to pull the dead whales out of the water and onto the beach, they circled the massive bodies and prayed, bidding farewell to these majestic creatures. The emotional weight hung heavy in the air.

Hours passed without anyone finding a solution. The Parks and Wildlife officials stepped in, warning the crowd about the potential danger of attracting sharks. They urged people to leave the water. Yet, some remained magnetized by the situation, including small children. I waved my hands, urging them to safety.

One hundred and sixty pilot whales stranded on a Western Australian beach, fighting for their lives in shallow waters. | Photo courtesy of Ian Wiese



Suddenly, a white-tipped shark appeared nearby, causing chaos as people scrambled toward the shore. Then, almost miraculously, the surviving whales began swimming ashore. The stranded ones turned and swam away as if an unseen force guided them. I watched in awe as I witnessed this astonishing sight. Within minutes, the whales vanished, leaving the crowd captivated. Pods of them sailed along the coast, merging seamlessly with the sea. Amidst it all, the little calf waited for its mother’s return.
The organization seeks community help to gather data and uncover the causes of the whale stranding

The next day, I returned to the area and found the same calf I saw the previous day. Only two weeks old, the calf became separated from its mother, who likely died on the beach the day before. My heart ached for the calf. Without its mother, it faced impossible odds for survival. Yet, throughout my stay, the little one reamined steadfast, waiting for a reunion that would never come.

Neighbors, veterinarians, marine scientists, wildlife experts, and volunteers joined forces to rescue the stranded whales. | Photo courtesy of Ian Wiese



Everyone asks the same question: “What drives this behavior?” The answer eludes us. Numerous theories exist, some plausible, others less so. Pilot whales, typically deep-sea dwellers, rarely venture so close to shore. Perhaps their navigation systems faltered, leading them astray. But why do some strandings result in dismal survival rates while others, like this one, yield remarkable success?

As we collect more data, we gradually enhance our understanding in order to manage these events. Our organization used social media to urge those who took photographs to share them. By piecing together a chronology of events, we aim to uncover the triggers that prompted these whales to embark on their own rescue mission.
WASTE MANAGEMENT IN REMOTE ARCTIC COMMUNITIES: UNIQUE CHALLENGES AND EMERGING SOLUTIONS

WORKSHOP PARTICIPANTS IN UNALASKA, AK
© NADINE KOCHUTEN / ALEUT INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION


28 JUNE 2024
Sustainable Development Working Group


Solid waste management practices in small, remote Arctic communities can pose significant human health, environmental and economic concerns. Communities often face challenges such as geographic remoteness, limited infrastructure and resources, harsh weather and changing climate conditions, among other things.

This has led to countless uncontrolled open solid waste dumpsites across the Arctic. These pose a wide range of hazards to local communities including co-mingling of sewage wastes, dumping of prohibited waste, and uncontrolled burning and seepage into water bodies. Often lacking an operator, systematized collection and access to cover materials, waste management is further hampered by coastal flooding, erosion and thawing permafrost, limiting access and control of sites.

Indigenous communities can face health and environmental impacts from these open dumpsites. There is a deep connection to environmental stewardship, and a subsistence diet among Indigenous communities, and solid waste can jeopardize the safety and security of their cultures and foods.

Two Arctic Council Working Groups – the Sustainable Development Working Group (SDWG) and Arctic Contaminants Action Program (ACAP) – have initiated a number of projects to address this issue over the last decade.
SIGN FOR LOCAL COMMUNITIES IN THEIR LANGUAGE, UNANGAM TUNUU
© NADINE KOCHUTEN / ALEUT INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION

A TIMELINE OF SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT ACTIVITIES IN THE ARCTIC COUNCIL

In 2016, the ACAP workshop, “Sharing Approaches on Community Solid and Hazardous Management Within Arctic Indigenous Communities” (Nome, Alaska 2016), identified community priorities, best practices, and the need for a clearing house of solid waste information. Then in 2018, SDWG initiated a desk study, “Best Waste Management Practices for Small and Remote Arctic Communities”, which provided an overview of best waste management practices from Alaska, Arctic Canada and Finland, as well as recommendations on possible actions.

From the start, Indigenous Peoples’ organizations have been the driving force behind solid waste initiatives under the Arctic Council.

From 2018-2021, inventory and clean-up efforts in Sámi communities on the Kola Peninsula were planned and carried out under ACAP’s Kola Waste project by the Public Organization for Promotion of Legal Education and Preservation of the Cultural Heritage of the Sámi of the Murmansk Region (OOSMO) in partnership with the Saami Council, and supported by the Indigenous Peoples’ Contaminant Action Program (IPCAP) Expert Group under ACAP.

The project comprised an inventory and classification of illegal waste dumps in and around thirty communities followed by a first clean-up of most of the sites, which could be handled without special treatment or licenses. The project was conducted in close cooperation between the Sámi communities and the local and regional environmental authorities.

WORKSHOP PARTICIPANTS IN UNALASKA, AK LEARNING HOW TO PREPARE AND PALLETIZE RECYCLING TO BE SHIPPED OUT OF THE COMMUNITY.
© NADINE KOCHUTEN / ALEUT INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION

THE SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT IN REMOTE ARCTIC COMMUNITIES PROJECT

As the next step to help understand and address different concerns related to solid waste management in remote Arctic communities, ACAP and SDWG are collaborating on a project to provide information, training, tools and other resources to improve planning and implementation of solid waste management practices in these communities. The project is co-led by the Aleut International Association (AIA), Saami Council and several Arctic States.

The project leads are committed to building on previous work to scale up solid waste management activities that assist, not only the pilot communities, but also other Arctic communities that face similar challenges. The project also builds on previous Arctic Council work on marine litter and plastics carried out by the Protection of the Arctic Marine Environment (PAME) and Arctic Monitoring and Assessment Programme Working Groups.

As part of a pre-project scoping effort in the U.S., AIA aimed to evaluate small, remote Arctic communities’ solid waste management practices, challenges, and new solutions. The assessment method involved a voluntary survey of small Arctic communities (fewer than 1,500 inhabitants), which are either off the road system for at least three months of the year, or, which, due to their location, encounter logistical or affordability obstacles in accessing regional or national solid waste support services and facilities.

The results indicated a top five of challenges related to solid waste management:the need for stronger or enhanced regulations;
the need to replace or improve the landfill;
the lack of regional facilities to support the community with its waste management;
insufficient resources to maintain the landfill and equipment they do have; and
the need for additional staff to operate the landfill.

Survey respondents ranked the top five most helpful actions to address solid waste challenges their community faces as:in-person training;
educational materials for residents;
targeted public service messages via radio and social media;
culturally appropriate approaches for educating community members;
and training focused on landfill operations.

The assessment identified human drivers as crucial in ensuring effective solid waste management. Individuals or groups deeply committed to improving solid waste management and motivating the community can make a difference even when resources are scarce. This conclusion was also proven by the Kola Waste project, which became possible due to the aspirational leadership of several community members. Community support and compliance are also important drivers for success.

Another scoping assessment made for the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency by the Battelle Memorial Institute provides a circumpolar overview of solid waste management in remote Arctic communities. It describes challenges, opportunities and some of the best practices, as well as suggests some ideas for future pilot projects that could serve as next step to improving solid waste management in the Arctic. The findings were derived from a literature review, environmental scan of online materials, and key informant interviews with experts working on solid waste management in the Arctic.

The report covers a variety of different waste types that appear in the Arctic region. Some of these waste types are common around the globe (e.g., marine debris and plastic pollution) and will require solutions at both local and global levels to make an impact. Some other types of waste are found elsewhere but are of particular concern in the Arctic due to context-specific limitations (e.g., construction and demolition waste).
SIGN FOR LOCAL COMMUNITIES IN THEIR LANGUAGE, UNANGAM TUNUU
© NADINE KOCHUTEN / ALEUT INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION
SIGN FOR LOCAL COMMUNITIES IN THEIR LANGUAGE, UNANGAM TUNUU
© NADINE KOCHUTEN / ALEUT INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION

ON TO THE PILOT PHASE

Both assessments show that solid waste management in the Arctic poses unique challenges, especially for small, remote, and Indigenous communities. While every country, region, and community will need customized solutions, lessons learned could be shared across countries where appropriate. So, one of the important deliverables of this project is a tool kit on solid waste management compiled by AIA.

Currently, the project leads are working to identify pilot communities in Alaska, Arctic Canada and Sápmi. They are looking for pilot solid waste improvement projects that will have a replicable component to serve as a model for lessons learned for other remote communities in the Arctic.

The pilot phase of the project will benefit from greater degrees of collaboration between local, regional, national, and international parties. Another important part of the project will be an in-person workshop, which will convene participants of different community-based pilot projects for information sharing and building relationships with their counterparts. A strong youth component will be important to share knowledge and generate solutions.

There is no one-size-fits-all solution to effective waste management in the Arctic, highlighting the importance of community-driven projects that address their specific issues and needs. However, many communities around the circumpolar north experience similar conditions such as remoteness, limited infrastructure and harsh weather. By focusing on several pilot communities across regions, best practices can be scaled up and shared to benefit many other communities around the Arctic.

Everest cleanup initiative: Battling mounds of garbage on the world’s highest peaks

I see tents, empty oxygen tanks, broken ropes, and worn-out equipment piling up on the slopes. It amounts to tons of garbage year after year. When I lay my eyes on this sight it chokes me, and I know that the slow decomposition of these non-biodegradable materials pollutes the soil and water.


Mariela Laksman
June 28, 2024


JOURNALIST’S NOTES
INTERVIEW SUBJECT
Kristin Harila, originally from the flat village of Vadsø, is a self-made icon in the mountaineering world. Born with a passion for the outdoors, she quickly developed a love for winter sports and cross-country skiing. However, her fearless attitude and exceptional talent for mountaineering set her apart. After resigning from her management position in 2019, Kristin dedicated herself to climbing the world’s highest peaks. In 2023, she and Tenjin (Lama) Sherpa set the world record for summiting three of the 14 peaks over 8,000 meters in just 3 months and 1 day, cementing her place among the best mountaineers globally. Learn more about her efforts and the Tenjen-Harila cleanup project.

BACKGROUND INFORMATION
Mount Everest has witnessed countless human feats and epic challenges over the decades. However, the constant climbing of the mountain has created a significant environmental problem: the accumulation of garbage. Due to the increased popularity of Everest as a mountaineering destination and the difficult decisions climbers face regarding what to take and what to leave behind to ensure their survival, the amount of trash left on the mountain has grown substantially.
Nepalese authorities are now considering new measures to prevent the further deterioration of the Himalayan mountains’ fragile ecosystem caused by the annual accumulation of garbage left by expeditions. These measures aim to preserve the natural splendor of Everest while maintaining its status as a premier destination for climbers worldwide.
For more information, visit the CNN Español report.

MOUNT EVEREST, Nepal — From my base camp at Mount Everest in the ice and cold, trash seemed to swallow the mountain. The landscape was marred by a plague of garbage. I felt shocked as I witnessed it and decided to do something to reverse the situation.

Today, wearing a down jumpsuit with the Norwegian flag, I climb to the 8,611-meter peak, clearing the route of worn-out oxygen cylinders, tattered tents, and ropes discarded by climbers over the decades. In one week, my team and I collected over 200 kilos of garbage. For me, the effort serves as a tribute to the mountain, and I do this work from the heart.

Read more environment stories at Orato World Media.
Launching a cleanup initiative on Mount Everest

Year after year, I saw more and more garbage pile up at Mount Everest, so I started a cleanup project. This year, I visited all the camps including the summit, cleaning garbage with my team. Removing the waste requires huge groups of people. The work remains difficult and dangerous.

The highest peaks record temperatures of 60 degrees below zero and winds up to 200 kilometers per hour in winter. These winds transport the debris and garbage, making some areas deadly. They are so fierce and biting, they pose a constant threat to our stability. My team and I often struggle to keep our balance.

Despite these challenges, I enjoy climbing Everest in good weather. I gaze up at its steep majesty, so high I can contemplate hundreds of other peaks surrounding me. It feels like my place in the world. However, as the weather worsens, I walk the slopes, my vision blurred by an incessant curtain of white snow. The threat of slippery ground and columns of glacial ice known as seracs loom.

The death zone at Mount Everest proves so extreme, if I or any climber suffers from altitude sickness, frostbite, or an accident, rescue becomes virtually impossible. The very low temperatures and the difficulty of the terrain at high altitudes forces us to take three breaths for each step, even for an experienced climber. My heart races to supply oxygen more frequently. Not even a helicopter can rescue someone at that altitude.

Nevertheless, I have fought for my place on the fixed ropes with dozens of climbers stuck along the way. Making records, like climbing the 14 giants of the earth faster than anyone else in three months and one day, seems like science fiction. In this harsh scenario, amidst such pressing conditions, when I take garbage back down the mountain, I gamble with my life.
Surge in hikers leaves mountains of garbage behind

As Everest’s popularity as a mountaineering destination grows, a significant increase in people seeking to reach its summit ensues. This generates a noticeable amount of waste. I ask myself, “What price does the mountain and the environment pay?” Little by little, I see how people destroy its beauty and ecosystem, causing irreparable damage. I witness the great demand of neo-alpinists willing to pay very high sums of money to fulfill a dream without giving up certain comforts.

At the base camp located at 5,364 meters, it resembles a bustling village with corridors and streets formed by dozens of tents that look more like inns, complete with televisions. It’s crazy. At Camp Two, at 6,500 meters, I see even more impressive facilities. Tents offer heating, internet, a wooden bed, and a mirror, along with unlimited oxygen. However, they often leave the equipment behind from one year to the next. As a result, uncontrolled waste management occurs, creating real chaos.

This starkly contrasts my experience as a true mountain climber with those who are not. True climbers venture only with the essentials, while others require every comfort to ascend. Everest now overflows with garbage. Most climbers discard their gear on the mountains because, after summiting, exhaustion takes over, and survival becomes the only priority.

I see tents, empty oxygen tanks, broken ropes, and worn-out equipment piling up on the slopes. It amounts to tons of garbage year after year. When I lay my eyes on this sight it chokes me, and I know that the slow decomposition of these non-biodegradable materials pollutes the soil and water. The situation proves even worse at the last camp on the normal route, located at more than 7,900 meters on Everest’s South Col, where garbage often remains forever.
Beyond inorganic waste: the grim reality of human corpses on Everest

Over the years, I witnessed piles of empty oxygen cylinders, plastics, human waste, and abandoned tents accumulate in Everest’s crevasses, turning them into tattered rags flapping in the wind. Abandoned ropes mislead teams off-route, while discarded tents force climbers to set up in more exposed areas, increasing the risk of fatal falls.

As I climb, some areas stink from the waste. I find it unbelievable that people set up tents with kitchens and leave everything behind. South Col has become a shocking sight. In addition to inorganic garbage, Everest harbors a grim record of human corpses. Some remain for years, while others emerge as glaciers melt due to climate change.

In July 2023, together with Tenjen Lama Sherpa, I set the world record for climbing the fourteen 8,000-meter mountains in 91 days. The most heartbreaking experience of my life was Tenjen’s death in August of the same year. He fell from a cliff, and despite our efforts to rescue him, the low oxygen, narrow path, and difficult conditions forced us to leave him behind. I plan to return to the mountain in October to find his body and return him to his homeland and family.

This mission is not just about bringing him back; it’s a personal journey to find closure and peace. Climate change exacerbates the challenges on Everest. Rising temperatures melt glaciers, revealing trash from early expeditions. The glaciers’ continuous movement uncovers new waste annually. Despite the hard and dangerous task, I am committed to preserving the mountain’s beauty and integrity.

Political advisors discuss HK, Macao's roles in China's development of open economy


Source: Xinhua
Editor: huaxia
2024-06-28 

BEIJING, June 28 (Xinhua) -- China's top political advisory body held a virtual consultation session on Friday to discuss the roles of Hong Kong and Macao in China's development of new systems for a higher-standard open economy.

The meeting of the National Committee of the Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference (CPPCC) was chaired by Wang Huning, a member of the Standing Committee of the Political Bureau of the Communist Party of China Central Committee and chairman of the CPPCC National Committee.

Wang emphasized the importance of focusing research on key issues related to the roles of Hong Kong and Macao in China's development of new systems for a higher-standard open economy.

He called for actionable and targeted policy recommendations to support the implementation of national policies that aid the development of Hong Kong and Macao.

Twelve members of the CPPCC National Committee delivered remarks from Beijing, Fujian, Hong Kong, Macao, and other locations via video link.

They proposed enhancing the coordination of economic regulations and mechanisms across Guangdong, Hong Kong, and Macao to facilitate the efficient flow of people, goods, capital, and data, thereby improving market integration.

Recommendations included consolidating Hong Kong's status as an international financial, shipping, and trade center, leveraging Macao's unique advantages as a platform for cooperation between China and Portuguese-speaking countries, and expanding smooth and convenient international connections.

Officials from relevant departments provided information and engaged in discussions with national political advisors.

Holding consultation sessions on specific themes remains a regular practice for the CPPCC National Committee to fulfill its functions of political consultation, democratic oversight, and participation in the deliberation and administration of state affairs. ■

 

For a community with shared future, China calls for five principles to be carried forward in new era

CGTN





Chinese President Xi Jinping delivers a speech at the Conference Marking the 70th Anniversary of the Five Principles of Peaceful Coexistence in Beijing, China, June 28, 2024. /Chinese Foreign Ministry

The Five Principles of Peaceful Coexistence were proposed 70 years ago.

Having emerged in a complex historical context, the five principles have been gradually accepted by countries worldwide and become fundamental norms for maintaining international peace and security and promoting friendly relations among nations.

At a commemorative conference marking 70 years of the principles, held by China on Friday, Chinese President Xi Jinping called for the principles to be carried forward to build a community with a shared future for mankind and provide a strong driving force for human progress.

'Firm resolve' to peaceful development

In 1954, then Chinese Premier Zhou Enlai put forth in full the Five Principles of Peaceful Coexistence for the first time – mutual respect for sovereignty and territorial integrity, mutual non-aggression, non-interference in each other's internal affairs, equality and mutual benefit, and peaceful coexistence.

Later, these principles served as guidelines for countries with different historical and cultural backgrounds, social systems and national conditions to handle their interrelations.

Noting the five principles have withstood the test of international vicissitudes, Xi said in the speech at Friday's conference that 70 years on, China has answered the call of the times by proposing a community with a shared future for mankind.

The Chinese president said that the Vision of Building a Community with a Shared Future for Mankind, carrying forward the spirit of the five principles, is the most effective way to sustain, promote and upgrade these principles, demonstrating China's firm resolve to follow the path of peaceful development.

China is the only country in the world that has incorporated peaceful development in its Constitution, and the only country among the five nuclear-weapon states to pledge no first use of nuclear weapons.

In April 2022, China proposed the Global Security Initiative to create a new path to security featuring dialogue over confrontation, partnership over alliance, and win-win over zero-sum. Under its guidance, the country released papers on its position on resolving the Ukraine crisis and the Palestinian-Israeli conflict, respectively, urging political settlement and diplomatic mediation.

Guiding Global South cooperation

The five principles were initiated with the purpose of protecting the interests and pursuits of small and weak countries from power politics. As the international order is being rebuilt based on South-South cooperation, the five principles are gaining ground and guiding solidarity and collaboration among Global South countries.

Under the China-proposed Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), many participating countries have reinforced their capacity of development through cooperating with China on fields including transportation, agriculture, energy and communication.

This is demonstrated by BRI landmark projects such as the China-Laos Railway which turned landlocked Laos into a land transport hub, Kenya's Mombasa-Nairobi Railway which contributes two percent to the African nation's economic growth, and Indonesia's Jakarta-Bandung High-Speed Railway, the first high-speed railway in Southeast Asia.

In the speech, Xi put forward a series of suggestions to better support Global South cooperation, such as providing 100,000 training opportunities to Global South countries in the coming five years, discussing free trade arrangements with more Global South countries, and welcoming more Global South countries to join the Initiative on International Trade and Economic Cooperation Framework for Digital Economy and Green Development.

He noted that China's imports from fellow developing countries are expected to exceed $8 trillion between now and 2030.

"Standing at a new historical starting point, the Global South should be more open and more inclusive, and join hands together to take the lead in building a community with a shared future for mankind," said the Chinese president.

UK

PETER OBORNE: EXPOSING MEDIA SMEARS AGAINST JEREMY CORBYN

It’s the wild west out there for the former Labour leader: any smear will do, however false and malicious, and Britain’s mainstream media is often ready to leap to attention.

28 JUNE 2024

Anna Wintour visits University of York

The Guardian’s editor-in-chief Kath Viner. (Photo: Anna Gowthorpe via Alamy)

The Guardian, in common with many other British media organisations, apparently feels at liberty to write anything it likes about Jeremy Corbyn.

Here’s an example. In April last year its deputy political editor Jessica Elgot published a story describing how Corbyn’s team left their offices in chaos when Sir Keir Starmer took over as Labour leader.

“In one room there were assorted revolutionary flags including one from the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament. In the next room there was a large bin full to the brim with shredded documents spilling on to the floor. In Corbyn’s office was a sleeping bag” Elgot wrote, citing anonymous sources.

The following day Alex Nunns, Corbyn’s speechwriter, responded with a series of photographs taken of the office as they were leaving. They show the offices stripped bare, but otherwise perfectly tidy.

Corbyn’s team complained to the Guardian, sending the photographs as proof. The newspaper then amended its article to include the line, in parenthesis; “Members of Corbyn’s team have disputed details in this account, saying the offices were left tidily.” It made no mention of the photographs, and offered no apology. 

Declassified asked Elgot whether she had approached Corbyn’s team for comment or rebuttal before publication. She referred us to the Guardian’s press office, which refused to answer the question, saying “We have nothing to add.” Senior members of Jeremy Corbyn’s team pre-2019 told Declassified no checking call was made.

Demonising Diane

Here’s another example, from earlier this year. A story appeared in the Independent at a time when – amid a scandal over alleged comments by Conservative donor Frank Hester that Corbyn ally Diane Abbott “should be shot” – the media was beginning to scrutinise Starmer over why the investigation into alleged anti-semitic remarks by Abbott had dragged on so long.

Helpfully for Starmer, on March 15th, the Independent’s Archie Mitchell reported that Abbott had been “offered the Labour whip back but refused because she would have had to undergo antisemitism training.”

In this version of events, Starmer was not to blame for the delay; rather the cause was Abbott’s “refusal to compromise.” Quoting an anonymous shadow minister, the Independent reported that Abbott would not undertake the requested training, “and that is why this has been going on for 10 months and not 25 minutes.”

The Independent presented an MP “on the left of the party” as a second source, but this MP did not appear to add any additional information, and was quoted saying only: “I don’t know why she didn’t just do it.”

Later the same day Abbott posted on X that the report was: “A blatantly shoddy piece of journalism. I told the reporter that all the key ‘facts’ in his piece were false – on the record. Instead, he has led with the unattributable briefings from Labour party sources.”

Two-and-a-half months later, the BBC revealed the party’s investigation into Abbott had in fact concluded in December 2023, when Abbott was asked to undertake a “two-hour antisemitism awareness course.”

According to the BBC, “Abbot did the module in February, after which it is understood she received an email from Labour’s chief whip acknowledging she had completed it.” The BBC’s reporting was not denied by the Labour Party or by any of its representatives.

Declassified approached Archie Mitchell by email and text message for comment or rebuttal. He did not respond.

RELATED

EXPLAINER: FIVE REASONS THE UK INTELLIGENCE AGENCIES FEAR JEREMY CORBYN...

READ MORE 

Condemn Hamas?

The Hamas atrocities of October 7th opened up a fresh line of attack. Rachel Cunliffe of the New Statesman accused Corbyn of “equivocating and deflecting on the rape, kidnap and murder of women and children.” 

Corbyn’s office wrote to Cunliffe pointing out that Corbyn had said that “The horrific attacks on civilians in Israel were deplorable”, adding “We should condemn the use of violence against all civilians, Israeli and Palestinian.” She apologised.

The Jerusalem Post reported that Corbyn “has refused to condemn Hamas”, then deleted the claim after a complaint from his office. Declassified contacted the Jerusalem Post to ask why the paper did not offer an apology, but had received no response at the time of publication.

LBC presenter James O’Brien told a podcast that “Jeremy Corbyn was simply invited to condemn Hamas, or call them a terrorist group. He couldn’t do it.” After pressure from Corbyn’s office, the podcast issued a clarification.

Guido Fawkes published an article headlined “Jeremy Corbyn Disinvited From Socialist Conference Over Hamas Views”. Following a complaint from Corbyn’s office the headline changed and a false accusation about Corbyn’s supposed failure to condemn Hamas was removed.

On October 7th last year the Guardian – which seems unable to help itself when it comes to retailing dubious or false information about Corbyn – cited a pro-Palestinian tweet that the former Labour leader had posted a few days earlier as if it was a response to that day’s Hamas atrocities. 

In December it reported that Corbyn had been “expelled from the [Labour] Party.” After a complaint from Corbyn’s office came the usual clarification.

RELATED

HOW THE UK MILITARY AND INTELLIGENCE ESTABLISHMENT IS WORKING TO...

READ MORE 

Putin puppet?

Over the last week a longstanding smear against Corbyn has resurfaced regarding alleged support for Vladimir Putin. For example LBC presenter Iain Dale accused Corbyn of “sympathies with Russia.” 

This claim that Corbyn supports Putin has frequently been made by the Tories – and unchallenged by Starmer’s Labour Party. The truth is that no modern politician has been more consistent or more prescient when it comes to Putin than Corbyn, as I laboriously demonstrated

It serves a double purpose for the Tory establishment to point the finger at Corbyn over Russia. It distracts from its own long collaboration with Vladimir Putin and his oligarchs. Moreover Tories are determined to damage Starmer by association with Corbyn. 

Meanwhile Starmer, lacking any strong narrative of his own, has made a strategic decision to define himself against Corbyn. An interesting case involves shadow cabinet minister Bridget Phillipson.

She told Kay Burley on Sky News in December last year that “Keir Starmer has taken tough action to turn around the prospects of the party, and that has included taking action around antisemitism that cast a very long and dark shadow over the party, was completely unacceptable and when Jeremy Corbyn refused to condemn that, action was taken again him.”

Phillipson’s claim that “Jeremy Corbyn refused to condemn that” was laden with ambiguity. At worst, it falsely implied that Corbyn had failed to condemn antisemitism inside Labour. To be fair she subsequently wrote to Corbyn saying that “the wording I used on Sky on Tuesday morning regarding you was imprecise, and I regret that.” 

But when the Corbyn team demanded an on air retraction, Sky News refused. Last week Declassified twice wrote to Sky asking why. No reply.

The list goes on and on. Last March Labour strategist John McTernan apologised after calling Jeremy Corbyn an “antisemitic pensioner” on LBC.  In the Independent Tanya Gold wrote about “Jeremy Corbyn’s anti-Jewish racism.” It was removed after Corbyn’s office complained. 

The i issued a clarification after Ben Kentish wrote that Corbyn was “Barred from standing as a Labour candidate after refusing to apologise for his comments about antisemitism in the party.

RELATED

EXCLUSIVE: JEREMY CORBYN ON THE ESTABLISHMENT CAMPAIGN TO STOP HIM...

READ MORE 

Wild West

I lived in Corbyn’s Islington North constituency for 30 years and by any standards he was an immensely popular constituency MP. A Times leader on May 25th read as follows: “Owing to his longevity as a constituency MP Mr Corbyn may prevail on July 4th against a lesser known Labour candidate.” 

The Times leader writer was misleading readers, either deliberately or through ignorance, by attributing his popularity to nothing more than long service. Some of these errors spring from ignorance. Others are defamatory. 

Collectively they show that everything written in the papers about Jeremy Corbyn should be assumed false unless proved otherwise. It’s the wild west out there for the former Labour leader: any smear will do, however false and malicious, and Britain’s mainstream media is often ready to leap to attention.

But not always. Reporters can behave with integrity. A year ago The Times published a story, citing the usual anonymous sources from Starmer’s office.

“The hard left had got the band back together, said a breathless Labour official: Corbyn’s closest aides had reunited in the office of Lutfur Rahman, the mayor of Tower Hamlets, forming an ensemble cast of Team Starmer’s pantomime villains,” wrote Times columnist Patrick Maguire.

“All were apparently ensconced in Rahman’s office, planning the Corbyn comeback: an audacious run for London mayor against Labour’s Sadiq Khan,” Maguire wrote.

Unlike the GuardianThe Times checked out the story. Maguire concluded that: “With this political morality tale, asserted confidently as fact, there was only one problem: not a word of it was true.”

Here’s a suggestion the British political press corps might do well to consider. Next time a snake oil salesman connected with the Starmer machine tries to sell you a smear story on Corbyn, follow Maguire’s example and take the elementary precaution of checking the facts.