The DNC has so far denied a request to allow Americans to hear the stories of Palestinian people in Gaza whose lives have been upended by Israel’s massive military.
Protesters rally at a pro-Palestinian demonstration in Union Park during the Democratic National Convention, Aug. 21, 2024, in Chicago. (AP Photo/Noah Berger)
August 22, 2024
By Yonat Shimron
(RNS) — Arab Americans, Muslim Americans and their interfaith allies spent much of Thursday (Aug. 22) pushing Democratic officials to allow a Palestinian American to speak from the party convention’s main stage, to convey a message of solidarity despite the party’s so-far consistent support for Israel in its prosecution of the war in Gaza.
The push was accompanied by an all-night sit-in outside Chicago’s United Center at which members of the “uncommitted” movement also made speeches pressing the Democratic National Convention to feature a Palestinian speaker.
The uncommitted — so-called because members of the movement wrote in “uncommitted” on their ballots rather than vote for President Joe Biden in this year’s Democratic primaries — want the DNC to recognize the suffering of Palestinians, 40,000 of whom have been killed by Israel’s massive Gaza assault of the past 10 months, an assault backed by U.S. bombs and munitions that has flattened the Gaza Strip and left tens of thousands homeless.
In an emotional speech from the stage of the convention on Wednesday, Israeli Americans Rachel Goldberg-Polin and her husband, Jon, spoke about their 23-year-old son Hersh, who is among the dozens of hostages kidnapped by Hamas militants on Oct. 7.
The Polins, modern Orthodox Jews who grew up in Chicago, have made their case to every major news outlet and met personally with Biden and Vice President Kamala Harris numerous times.
Jon Polin and Rachel Goldberg-Polin, parents of hostage Hersh Goldberg-Polin, speak during the Democratic National Convention, Aug. 21, 2024, in Chicago. (AP Photo/Erin Hooley)
But the DNC has so far denied a request to allow Americans to hear the stories of Palestinian people in Gaza, many of whose lives have been destroyed by Israel’s massive military retaliation for the Hamas attack that left 1,200 mostly Israelis dead.
Harris has adopted a somewhat different tone on the war from Biden. In March, she became the first administration official to call for an immediate cease-fire, which she has repeated since becoming the Democratic front-runner. But at a campaign stop in Detroit, the vice president admonished protesters calling for a cease-fire by barking, “If you want Donald Trump to win, then say that. Otherwise, I’m speaking.”
On Thursday, the United Auto Workers, a powerful labor union, threw its support behind the effort to feature a Palestinian speaker. So too did several progressive Jewish groups.
“Our colleagues and friends are in deep pain over this decision and it felt like an important moment to offer a show of support,” said Jamie Beran, who leads Bend the Arc: Jewish Action and participated in the sit-in. “It’s just been such a low-bar ask that would only be good for the campaign by and large.”
Abbas Alawieh, an uncommitted delegate from Michigan who had been negotiating with the Harris campaign to get a Palestinian speaker, left the United Center on Wednesday night after being told the DNC would not allow a speaker.
“Tell the vice president that I’m sitting outside, I’m not going anywhere, I hope she changes her mind — the Palestinian children need to be heard,” he was quoted as saying.
Alawieh is co-founder of the uncommitted movement that succeeded in getting as many as 700,000 people to vote “uncommitted” in protest of Biden’s unconditional support for Israel in the war. About 30 delegates to the convention have declared themselves uncommitted, citing the U.S. government’s complicity in what they regard as a genocide in Gaza. Those delegates are demanding not only a commitment to an immediate cease-fire but an arms embargo against Israel, which both the Biden and Harris campaigns have opposed.
RELATED: Faith abounds at the Democratic National Convention, but don’t be surprised
An interfaith vigil organized by a group called Not Another Bomb drew dozens of Muslims, Jews and Christians to the Hyatt Regency McCormick Place Thursday morning.
The war in Gaza has galvanized public opinion among Arab Americans, both Christian and Muslim, as well as younger voters more generally.
“We’ve been polling Arab Americans since the 1990s,” said James Zogby, the Arab American pollster, “and when we ask about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, how important it is, like other Americans, they’d say the No. 1 issue was jobs. Foreign policy was not in that top tier.”
But not this year. The scale of the war, Zogby said, made an unprecedented impression on Arab voters. “The devastation was so enormous, the genocide was so real and the frustration with the administration for not recognizing it was so profound, that it had an impact that we hadn’t seen before.”
Zogby, along with Keith Ellison, the Minnesota attorney general, co-led a DNC-approved panel on the war in Gaza on Monday. It drew a standing-room-only crowd of more than 300 people.
Progressive House Democrats, including Reps. Ilhan Omar of Minnesota, Cori Bush of Missouri, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez of New York and Summer Lee of Pennsylvania, have supported the uncommitted delegates’ call for a Palestinian speaker.
Meanwhile, marches and protests outside the DNC organized as part of the Coalition to March on the DNC, an umbrella organization, continued.
Tarek Khalil, a member of the Chicago chapter of American Muslims for Palestine, said he’s not surprised by the DNC’s intransigence.
“To say that this is unexpected, to say that this is surprising would not be entirely truthful,” he said. “It’s shameful. It’s disappointing, but it’s not unexpected.”
Parallel to DNC, a Chicago interfaith vigil mourns the loss of life in Gaza
Activists who have been protesting at the Democratic National Convention over the war in Gaza took time out to mourn and draw strength from their varying faiths.
People attend a vigil at Montrose Harbor, Aug. 20, 2024, in Chicago.
(RNS photo/Bob Smietana)
August 21, 2024
By Bob Smietana, Reina Coulibaly
CHICAGO (RNS) — On Tuesday night (Aug. 20), thousands of cheering delegates packed the United Center to hear former President Barack Obama and other dignitaries lend their support to Vice President Kamala Harris’ bid for the Oval Office.
About 20 minutes away, along Chicago’s lakeshore, a more solemn gathering was being held. There, as the sun set and the city’s skyline lit up, about 100 people from different faiths gathered to remember those killed in Gaza over the past 10 months in a vigil hosted by the American Friends Service Committee, a Quaker organization.
Small clusters of older women and men, some wearing kaffiyehs, the familiar Palestinian scarf, greeted one another with hugs. Families with kids and young activists made their way to the lakefront, where they were met with a table topped with battery-powered votive candles, pins reading “Remember Gaza” and AFSC literature. On the ground stretched a long, wide ribbon, marked with the amounts spent on military spending around the world and serving as an illustration of the American military budget compared with that of other countries.
As the crowd gathered, a young mom swung her giggling daughter while the song “Sido’s Dance” by Palestinian American musician Clarissa Bitar played over a speaker and a couple of joggers passed by.
The words “Remember Gaza,” drawn in red and green chalk, adorned the concrete walkway along the lakefront near where the group gathered, sitting on a series of high steps facing the water.
For months, many in the gathering had been protesting, making calls to elected officials, watching accounts of the war in Gaza and raising their voices in support of an end to the conflict. Now, they were taking time to stop and to find refuge in their faith and the bonds of friendship.
People attend a vigil Aug. 20, 2024, at Chicago’s Montrose Harbor to remember those killed in Gaza. (RNS photo/Reina Coulibaly)
“I believe many of us have souls that are tired,” said Jennifer Bing, national director of the U.S. Palestine Activism Program for the AFSC, adding that many of the activists gathered were worn out from the news of bloodshed in Gaza, or from protesting and making calls for a cease-fire that many feel have gone unheeded.
“Our weary souls need to be nourished by our community of the faithful,” Bing said. “We hold each other up so we may continue to work for a world we still believe is possible.”
A series of speakers from different faith groups, some with family or colleagues in the Palestinian territories, then spoke to the gathering. Some read poems or offered prayers, while others shared stories of loved ones lost to violence.
Among the first speakers of the evening was Laura Boyce, AFSC’s associate general secretary for U.S. programs. For Boyce, advocacy for Palestinians reflects her Quaker belief that “there is that of the divine in all people.”
Above all, Boyce and the AFSC want to be “very clear that we need to see a cease-fire.”
A red ribbon illustrates the U.S. military budget during a vigil Aug. 20, 2024, at Chicago’s Montrose Harbor to remember those killed in Gaza. (RNS photo/Reina Coulibaly)
While the city of Chicago is bustling with rallies and protests this week, Boyce said this interfaith vigil complements other such solidarity actions by offering a quiet change of pace. For her, this is just one of many ways to work toward the ultimate goal of a cease-fire and arms embargo.
During the vigil, Boyce read a message written by Firas Ramlawi, an AFSC colleague in Gaza, addressed to those gathered at the vigil. Ramlawi sent his thanks and said the “unwavering support and steadfast belief in our just cause” was a grounding constant for him, said Boyce.
“We are human beings, longing for life in all its details, striving to live with freedom and dignity, because there is so much on this earth that is worth living for,” said Boyce, quoting from Ramlawi’s message. “Let us be tireless in our efforts to end this violence.”
Boyce added that in times of strife, “you just have to keep trying,” to which some replied “Amen!”
RELATED: Faith abounds at the Democratic National Convention, but don’t be surprised
Fidaa Elaydi, a Chicago attorney who was born in Gaza and still has family there, told of her aunt Zainab, who she said was killed during the war. Elaydi described her aunt as a kind, giving woman, dedicated to their family.
“She fled, hoping to find shelter, and instead, met her fate,” Elaydi said.
Elaydi, a mother of four, also spoke about being pregnant when the war in Gaza broke out, and how the war overshadowed the joy of having a new child, knowing other children were not safe. She said that while she was bringing one new Palestinian life into the world, she felt despair witnessing Palestinian deaths daily.
Annie Sommer Kaufman. (RNS photo/Bob Smietana)
“It was especially difficult to feel joy or happiness at the birth, or the kick, or the movements, or the milestones in my child when I was watching Palestinian mothers bury their children throughout this genocide,” she said.
Annie Sommer Kaufman, a Chicago-based Yiddish translator who also teaches Talmud, read a poem from a friend, who said she could no longer pray after hearing about the death of children during the Gaza war.
She told those gathered about the Jewish tradition of Shabbat — of taking time away from the noise of the outside world and reconnecting face-to-face with those around us.
“I know this is a long struggle that takes a lot of endurance,” she said. “I also know that this is a time of great change, violence and agitation—and we really need each other to help us stay in it for the long haul.”
Paula Roderick, a member of United Methodist Kairos Response, which has long called for peace in the Middle East, said she’s been concerned about violence in Gaza since the late 2000s. She recalled visiting Israel and the Palestinian territories in 2008 as part of an interfaith group — and said she has been involved in peace activism since.
That’s involved protests and grieving for the lives that have been lost to violence.
“I’m just grieving. This is not my first vigil for Gaza,” said Roderick, who gave a prayer to end the vigil. “I wish it were.”
Paula Roderick. (RNS photo/Bob Smietana)
Roderick, an attorney, said her faith also motivates her activism. The United Methodist Church tells her that the loss of life in Gaza and in any war is wrong — and motivates her to do something about it. She also believes in the power of working with people from other faith traditions.
Roderick pointed to resolutions passed by the United Methodist Church calling for the end of Israel’s occupation of the Palestinian territories and to the end of U.S. support for military occupations in any part of the world.
“We just can’t keep having our money go to fund military occupations,” she said.
Among the last to speak was Deanna Othman, a Muslim Palestinian woman and attorney in Chicago. She took the microphone to offer a prayer for her people at the end of the vigil. She quoted a saying of the Prophet Muhammad that stressed the need for action in the face of evil — and not just words or feelings.
“First and foremost, we pray that we are among the people of action who change evil with our hands and who speak out firmly against it,” she told the crowd.
Othman is a board member of the American Muslims for Palestine’s flagship Chicago chapter and an experienced interfaith organizer. She said in an interview that she believes in the importance of interfaith work but urged other Muslims to not participate in interfaith organizing with groups that “want to place Palestine on the back burner but then engage in other types of interfaith efforts.”
“We should not be engaging with people who will not acknowledge the humanity of Palestinians, who will not acknowledge their right to exist in their land and the justness of their cause.”
Daniel Lakemacher. (RNS photo/Bob Smietana)
Daniel Lakemacher, a Quaker and Iraq War veteran who is now part of an anti-war veterans group, has been protesting this week outside the Democratic National Convention. He said the vigil serves a different purpose than the protests. The protests, he said, were about issues. The vigil is about the people who have been killed in Gaza.
“It’s a solemn time of remembrance,” he said. “It’s an opportunity to be in solidarity across many different faiths. All are welcome to grieve together.”
He said protesters opposed to the war in Gaza — along with everyone who sees images from the war — are processing the war in real time, with images streamed on social media platforms such as TikTok and X from inside the war zone.
“We are able to follow what is happening with individual families, not through a news media outlet but directly through posts they are making themselves,” he said.
Lakemacher, who said he grew up in an evangelical Christian home where supporting Israel was part of his faith, said his time in the military turned him into an anti-war activist. He is concerned that a belief in Christian Zionism — with which he grew up — has influenced the U.S. response to the war in Gaza.
He hopes it will also remind people of the human cost of the war.
“The people who are being killed are not just numbers,” he said.
One of the last speakers was Nader Ihmoud, editor-in-chief of Palestine in America magazine. Ihmoud read the names of journalists who have been killed during the Gaza war. As he did so, some of those gathered placed glowing votives along the ground, outlined by the words “Remember Gaza” written in chalk.
After each name was spoken, those gathered at the vigil responded with, “We remember.”
People add lights to the words “Remember Gaza” during a vigil Aug. 20, 2024, at Chicago’s Montrose Harbor. (RNS photo/Bob Smietana)
No comments:
Post a Comment