Saturday, January 04, 2025

Myanmar's new cybercrime law will suppress information, say analysts

January 03, 2025 
By VOA Burmese
Protesters hold up the three-finger salute and placards denouncing the move to shut down internet access during a demonstration against the military coup in Yangon 
on Feb. 7, 2021.

WASHINGTON —

Myanmar's military leaders have enacted a new cybersecurity law that analysts say will provide the junta with extensive control over access to information.

The expansive law — which has 16 chapters and 88 articles — includes regulations on Virtual Private Networks, or VPNs, which allow internet users to circumvent website blocks. It penalizes users who access or share media articles and information from banned websites.

The military council has said that the law is needed to protect against cyberattacks and cybercrimes that could threaten the country's stability. Among the regulations is a ban on the creation of illegal online gambling sites, which have been linked to organized crime.

But an expert with the digital rights group Myanmar Internet Project, who asked to be identified only as U Han, said the law is more focused on suppressing rights than protecting the public.

"All the provisions of the law are designed to suppress rather than protect the public," Han told VOA Burmese. "We believe that junta will use this bill as a weapon prepared for this purpose."

The law will harm "cyber freedom, digital freedom, and the right to use the internet, which are among the most fundamental of our human rights," said Han.

Myanmar youths browse their social media pages at an internet shop in Yangon, Dec. 18, 2018.

By suppressing these rights, Myanmar "will be violating other basic human rights, socio-economic rights, such as education, business rights and religious rights," he said.

The law includes penalties for noncompliance, including warnings, fines and suspensions. It has the power to blacklist digital platform service providers who fail to prevent, remove or cease circulation of content deemed by the junta as "disinformation" or "rumors" that could damage unity or stability.

Digital platform service providers are now required to collect the names and data of their users for up to three years, and to disclose those details to the authorities.

The law additionally includes penalties for anyone found to have read, stored or shared articles from media outlets or groups banned or labeled as terrorists by the military council; gives the authorities power to shutter online services for reasons of security of the "public good"; and allows for action to be taken against Myanmar citizens outside of the country's borders.

One of the biggest criticisms from digital rights experts is the regulations around VPN use.

Since the junta seized power in a military coup in February 2021, it has sought to control the flow of information. Dozens of journalists have been detained, broadcasting licenses revoked and websites blocked.

Because of that, many residents use VPNs to access social media and media websites, or even to study.

But under the new law, those users could face up to six months in prison and fines for using banned VPN services.

A lawyer based in one of Myanmar's largest cities said the new law will make it harder for the public to access information.

The lawyer, who asked not to be identified for security reasons, said that after thoroughly reading the full law, he sees no clear and concise provision.

"It seems that it has been written to be used as needed and that it has been written with the primary focus on those who will use [a] cyber platform," the lawyer said.

Myanmar in May of last year expanded blocks on websites, digital platforms and VPNs. According to Freedom House, the action specifically limited users to being able to access only about 1,500 preapproved websites.

"Internet freedom in Myanmar consequently declined, leaving it tied with China as the worst-surveyed country," Freedom House said in November.

Citing leaked documents, the activist group Justice for Myanmar reported in June that the enhanced censorship system uses technology from a Chinese network security company to block VPNs.


Myanmar junta's VPN block poses 'major threat,' say analysts


The technology allows authorities to create a list of all known VPN domains and IP addresses they want blocked.

"Instead of just attacking the media, which they've done until now, [the junta are] actually attacking the ways that the general public can communicate and can access information," Oliver Spencer, an expert on free expression in Myanmar, told VOA last year.

Myanmar scores poorly on world rankings for digital rights and media freedom. Freedom House lists it as "not free" for both global and internet freedoms, and the country ranks 171 out of 180, where 1 shows the best environment, on the World Press Freedom Index.

Some information in this report came from The Associated Press.



EXPLAINED: Why is an internet-famous Vietnamese monk on a trek to India?


Thich Minh Tue, whose fame drew the apparent ire of authorities, is on 2,700-kilometer barefoot pilgrimage.


Vietnamese monk Thich Minh Tue walks in Ubon Ratchathani Province, Thailand, Jan. 1, 2025, one day after he arrived in Thailand from Laos.
Vietnamese monk Thich Minh Tue walks in Ubon Ratchathani Province, Thailand, Jan. 1, 2025, one day after he arrived in Thailand from Laos. (RFA)

A Vietnamese monk who became an internet hit last year is going international.

Thich Minh Tue, 44, is on a 2,700-kilometer (1,650-mile) barefoot pilgrimage across Thailand and Myanmar to Buddhist sites in India -- if authorities will let him.

He left Vietnam in late November, walked across Laos and entered Thailand on Dec. 31. Next he’s bound for Bangkok.

His roadside journey -– carrying just a rice cooker and a few other personal items while accompanied by a handful of supporters -– is similar to his walk through Vietnam last year, which brought him fame as social media influencers documented his travels.


Who is Thich Minh Tue and why does he matter?

Le Anh Tu, who took the monk name Thich Minh Tue (“Thich” means “Venerable”), became a household name in Vietnam last May when he was on a barefoot walk across that country.

Followers on and off social media were drawn to his humble attitude and ascetic practices. Sporting a shaved head and wearing a patched robe, Thich Minh Tue usually goes barefoot, which is common among monks.

And actually, Thich Minh Tue isn’t officially a monk because he’s not recognized by the state-sanctioned Vietnam Buddhist Sangha, or community.

That doesn’t seem to matter to him or to his fans. He says he’s simply trying to live out the teachings of Buddha.

But the attention he was getting appeared to worry the authorities. In early June, law enforcement officials raided his camp in the middle of the night, detaining him and several of his followers. That prompted an international call for his release.

How does Thich Minh Tue practice his religion?

Thich Minh Tue adheres to a form of Buddhism that requires followers to own only three sets of clothes, to subsist by collecting alms house to house and to live a low-impact life in outdoor places like forests, mountains or even in graveyards.

He began his religious journey six years ago and has since made several pilgrimages on foot between Vietnam’s southeastern city of Nha Trang and the northern border with China. It was only after his trip in May was covered on social media that he drew widespread attention.

Supporters say his modest ways stand in contrast to senior monks in Vietnam who encourage followers to give offerings while living in large pagodas and flaunting expensive watches and luxury cars.

Vietnamese monk Thich Minh Tue is seated in Ubon Ratchathani Province, Thailand, Jan. 1, 2025, one day after he arrived in Thailand from Laos.
Vietnamese monk Thich Minh Tue is seated in Ubon Ratchathani Province, Thailand, Jan. 1, 2025, one day after he arrived in Thailand from Laos. (RFA)

How freely can people practice religion in Vietnam?

Freedom of religion is technically enshrined in Vietnam’s constitution but Thich Minh Tue does not belong to a Buddhist sect that is recognized by the state. Without recognition, religious groups are not allowed to organize in Vietnam –- a policy some say demonstrates how protections for religion exist in name only.

In its 2024 annual report, the United States Commission on International Religious Freedom, or USCIRF, said Vietnamese authorities “continue to monitor all religious activity closely, often harassing, detaining, or otherwise preventing unregistered faith communities from exercising their fundamental right to religious freedom.”

USCIRF recommended that the U.S. Department of State designate Vietnam a Country of Particular Concern because its government engages in or tolerates “particularly severe” violations of religious freedom.

Vietnamese monk Thich Minh Tue walks in Chong Mek, Ubon Ratchathani Province, Thailand, Dec. 31, 2024, as he arrives in Thailand from Laos.
Vietnamese monk Thich Minh Tue walks in Chong Mek, Ubon Ratchathani Province, Thailand, Dec. 31, 2024, as he arrives in Thailand from Laos. (RFA)

What prompted Thich Minh Tue to leave Vietnam?

Thich Minh Tue disappeared from public view for nearly a month after authorities raided his camp in June.

He resurfaced in July, and then in November, several letters purportedly written in his own hand began to circulate on social media.

In one letter, Thich Minh Tue said he would no longer adhere to a vow of poverty as he continued to study the Buddhist virtues. A newspaper report said he had announced he would no longer be begging for alms to prevent disruption to “security, order, and social and political safety.”


RELATED STORIES

Vietnamese monk leaves Laos, enters Thailand

Publisher’s partner says book about ‘barefoot monk’ hasn’t received approval

Vietnamese followers of ‘barefoot monk’ question call for social media silence

How TikTok made a barefoot Vietnamese ‘monk’ go viral


Supporters were quick to question whether he had been forced to write the letter under duress, or whether someone else had wrote it for him.

At about the same time, the Government Committee for Religious Affairs announced on its website that Thich Minh Tue had “voluntarily retired.”

Why is he walking to India?

But then in November, Thich Minh Tue announced that he wanted to go on a pilgrimage to visit religious sites in India, where Buddhism originated.

The question remains whether he will be allowed to return to Vietnam after the pilgrimage, a Thai observer told BenarNews.

The observer, who requested anonymity for security reasons, noted that Thich Minh Tue is being accompanied by Doan Van Bau, a former security official in the Vietnamese government who specialized in criminology and psychological operations.

“It is unclear whether he was assigned to escort the monk out of the spotlight in Vietnam and lessen his influence there,” he said.

Vietnamese monk Thich Minh Tue, center, walks in Chong Mek, Ubon Ratchathani Province, Thailand, Dec. 31, 2024, as he arrives in Thailand from Laos.
Vietnamese monk Thich Minh Tue, center, walks in Chong Mek, Ubon Ratchathani Province, Thailand, Dec. 31, 2024, as he arrives in Thailand from Laos. (RFA)

A Thai police officer said Thich Minh Tue came into the country legally.

“He didn’t indicate plans to travel to Myanmar, only stating he was coming for a pilgrimage, and we haven’t found any violations,” said Police Lt. Col. Kittipong Thanomsin of the border town of Chong Mek.

“There are no concerns or need for special coordination, as we conduct regular checks as usual,” he told BenarNews, an RFA-affiliated online news outlet. “There has been no communication from Vietnam.”


Edited by Matt Reed and Malcolm Foster. BenarNews’ Nontarat Phaicharoen and Ruj Chuenban in Bangkok contributed to this report.