Sunday, July 24, 2022

Fears rise for a rights activist captured while fighting for Ukraine.

In this image provided by his family, Maksym Butkevych is shown between his parents,
 Yevheniia and Oleksandr. Mr. Butkevych was captured in June and is now a prisoner
 of war held by Russia.
Credit...via Oleksandr Butkevych

By Valerie Hopkins
July 24, 2022, 5:07 a.m. ET

Maksym Butkevych made his name in Ukraine as a journalist and human rights activist, campaigning on behalf of refugees and internally displaced people and serving on the board of Ukraine’s chapter of Amnesty International.

At the end of June, he was captured by Russian forces while fighting for Ukraine, and that hard-earned reputation became a potentially dangerous liability.

Russian propaganda began bragging about Mr. Butkevych’s detention almost as soon as he was taken hostage, in an ambush on his platoon during the battle for the eastern city of Sievierodonetsk. His family and friends chose initially to stay quiet, hoping silence would hasten the process of bringing him home.

But as pro-Kremlin media outlets have denounced Mr. Butkevych in wild terms — as both a “British spy” (he once worked for the BBC) and a “Ukrainian nationalist,” both “a fascist” and a “radical propagandist” — his colleagues and loved ones have come to fear for his life, and have decided to speak publicly about him to set the record straight.

The man they know, they say, is the opposite of the one portrayed on Russian television.

“He never accepted either the extreme-right views or the extreme left,” said his mother, Yevheniia Butkevych. “He took shape as a person who is absolutely alien to extreme positions, which, as a rule, are aggressive.”

Better Understand the Russia-Ukraine WarHistory: Here’s what to know about Russia and Ukraine’s relationship and the causes of the conflict.
On the Ground: Russian and Ukrainian forces are using a bevy of weapons as a deadly war of attrition grinds on in eastern Ukraine.
Outside Pressures: Governments, sports organizations and businesses are taking steps to punish Russia. Here is a list of companies that have pulled out of the country.
Updates: To receive the latest updates in your inbox, sign up here. The Times has also launched a Telegram channel to make its journalism more accessible around the world.

In fact, said Ms. Butkevych, her son was a pacifist who had maintained after Russian proxies invaded eastern Ukraine in 2014 that the best use of his talents was as an activist. But that changed on Feb. 24, when Russian missiles went crashing into his hometown, Kyiv, and cities and towns across the country.

The same day, Mr. Butkevych, 45, reported to a military recruitment center.

“He said, ‘I will leave my human rights work for a while, because now it is necessary, first of all, to protect the country, because everything I have worked on all these years and everything that we all worked for, the rules of our lives and of our society are now under threat,’” said Ms. Butkevych of what her son, her only child, had told her.

He was called up on March 4 and became a platoon commander around Kyiv, before being sent in mid-June to try to reinforce the army as it fought to keep Sievierodonetsk.

On June 24, Ms. Butkevych said, a volunteer called to tell her that there was a video circulating online of her son in captivity. His platoon had lost connection with their commanders. When two men went looking for water, she said, they were captured, and then they lured the rest of the group into a Russian trap.

“There has never been a worse period in my life,” Ms. Butkevych, 70, said.

Her son is one of an estimated 7,200 Ukrainian prisoners of war in the custody of Russia and its proxies in eastern Ukraine. It is a number that dims the prospect of a swift exchange.

“The situation is very complicated, because we have fewer prisoners of war than Russia,” said Tetiana Pechonchyk, a co-founder alongside Mr. Butkevych of the human rights nonprofit organization Zmina. “Russia also captures civilians and holds them as hostages, and we need to exchange those people, too. It’s a direct violation of human rights international law.”

Mr. Butkevych’s public profile may help him stay alive, but it may also make him vulnerable to ill-treatment. In an interview with The New York Times, the prominent Ukrainian medic Yulia Paievska detailed torture and relentless beatings during her three months in Russian custody. She was also dragged in front of television cameras and used as a prop in an attempt to paint Ukrainians as “Nazis,” one of the Kremlin’s justifications for the invasion.

She said that as hard as her treatment was, she feared that male prisoners faced “far worse.”

Mr. Butkevych last spoke with The Times in May, on the day that the Kyiv Opera reopened; he had come from his barracks to attend the first performance.

“It is a kind of promise that we will prevail. Life will go on, not death,” he said. “It is important not to forget that this is what we are fighting for.”

Russia and Ukraine signed an agreement in Istanbul to unblock more than 20 million tons of grain stuck in blockaded Black Sea ports in Ukraine, a deal aimed at bringing down soaring grain prices and alleviating a mounting global hunger crisis. But a string of Russian missile strikes in the southern city of Odesa, an important port for global grain supplies, risk undermining the deal.

Ukraine is again trying to make its case to the world that it can defeat the Russians with the right equipment, pointing to successful attacks using new long-range rocket systems. This is clear push back against skepticism among some Western countries that getting more weapons will allow them to turn the tide against Russia.

On the Ground


As Moscow signals it may be entering a more aggressive phase of its invasion, the front lines in the eastern Donetsk region have seen little relief, as Ukrainian soldiers there say they live under almost constant Russian artillery and aerial bombardment. But a rare military success by the Ukrainian troops in the eastern city of Pavlivka offered them a confidence boost.

Foreign Minister Sergey V. Lavrov, Russia’s top diplomat, said that his country’s territorial ambitions in Ukraine might broaden, adding that Moscow was now casting its gaze on a swath of Ukraine’s south, specifically naming the Kherson and Zaporizhzhia regions. In recent days, Ukraine has been intensifying attacks on Russian forces in the Kherson Province, suggesting that the ground is being laid for a broad Ukrainian counteroffensive in the region.

Maria Varenikova contributed reporting.

Valerie Hopkins is an international correspondent covering the war in Ukraine, as well as Russia and the countries of the former Soviet Union. @VALERIEinNYT

How We Verify Our Reporting

Our team of visual journalists analyzes satellite images, photographs, videos and radio transmissions to independently confirm troop movements and other details.

We monitor and authenticate reports on social media, corroborating these with eyewitness accounts and interviews. Read more about our reporting efforts.


British aid worker accused of being a mercenary dies after being held by separatists in Donetsk
Aid worker Paul Urey had been suffering from diabetes and required insulin shots.
 Photo: Presidium Network via Reuters


Jake Cordell and Elizabeth Piper
July 16 2022 

A British man who was detained by Russian-backed separatists in Ukraine and accused of being a mercenary has died, an official in the self-proclaimed Donetsk People’s Republic (DPR) said yesterday.

The death of Paul Urey (45) was confirmed by a British charity that described him as a humanitarian worker and denied he had any military background.

Mr Urey was captured in south-east Ukraine in late April while attempting to help a woman who had been given permission to travel to Britain leave Russian-controlled territory, said Presidium Network, a charity that had advised him on safety.

He was stopped at a checkpoint, detained and charged with “mercenary activities” by separatists in the DPR.

Presidium Network said Britain’s Foreign Office had informed Mr Urey’s family of his death on July 10.

A spokesperson for the Foreign Office said it was “urgently seeking clarification from the Russian government on media reports that a British aid worker has died in Ukraine”.

Asked about Mr Urey, a spokesman for UK prime minister Boris Johnson said: “They’re clearly alarming reports and our thoughts
are with his family and friends.”

Daria Morozova, who has the title of human rights ombudsman in the DPR, said on social media that Mr Urey had been suffering from diabetes and respiratory, kidney and cardiovascular issues.


Presidium said he needed insulin injections, and this would have led to his death.
THE WAR ON WOMEN
'We are not safe anywhere': Egyptian women fear systemic normalisation of gender-based violence and femicide



A series of horrific cases of femicide and grievous bodily harm against women in Egypt in the last two months have caused outrage across the region.

Yousra Samir Imran
19 July, 2022

Shock, fury, heartbreak, and outrage; these are the sentiments women in Egypt have felt over the past two months since the day 21-year-old university student Nayera Ashraf was stabbed to death outside her university in Mansoura as she was on her way to her final exams.

“Women in Egypt are outraged and furious, and I think most people are in incomplete shock, but Egyptian women no longer feel safe,” Egyptian feminist and former TV and radio broadcaster, Reem Ayed, tells The New Arab.

“When you think about it, Nayera Ashraf was murdered outside of campus, and it’s terrifying because your university is like your second home – when you’re a university student, you end up spending more time on campus than you do at your own home. The two places that you’re supposed to feel the safest are your own house and your school.

"The fact she was murdered right outside her school is terrifying because it means that safe place is no longer safe for women. Egyptian women never felt safe on the streets, to begin with, so now it’s even worse.”

"There were 415 violent crimes committed against girls and women in Egypt in 2020, 113 cases of women murdered as a result of domestic abuse, and a total of 165 cases of femicide"

Nayera’s murderer Mohammed Adel, who has been sentenced to death by hanging, was a man who had been stalking her for some time after she refused his marriage proposal.

According to Egyptian news outlet Cairo 24, Adel’s neighbours said he had never caused any trouble and they only heard him when he was beating his mother and sister, exhibiting the social acceptance of a man who was known to have been committing acts of violence against his female family members.

The murder of Nayera Ashraf had a knock-on effect. Just a couple of days later, the Arab world was shaken once more when nursing student Iman Irshaid in Amman, Jordan, was shot five times outside her campus at the University of Applied Sciences. Her murderer, 37-year-old Uday Abdullah Hassan, reportedly sent her this text message the day before:

“Tomorrow I am coming to speak to you and if you don’t accept I am going to kill you just like the Egyptian killed that girl today.”

He died by suicide after refusing to surrender himself to the Jordanian authorities.

A woman carries a placard that reads in Arabic "A man cares about his mother, sister, daughter and wife" during a rally to eradicate gender-based violence and exploitation of women and children [Getty Images]

Within days of Nayera’s murder, Egyptians woke up to the news that missing TV presenter Shaima Gamal’s body had been found on a farm in Giza – she had been murdered by her husband, a judge, her face burned with acid in an effort to disguise her identity.

His judge immunity has been lifted and he is to be trialled in a criminal court. And if this isn’t enough, in June a woman in the district of Halwan in Cairo was stabbed by her husband 20 times followed by having her right ear cut off. When asked why he did it, her husband said, “because she does not listen to what I say.”

The murders of Nayera Ashraf and Iman Irshaid are reminiscent of those of Farah Akbar in Kuwait and Noor Mukadam in Pakistan just last year, whose murderers took their lives after having their proposals rejected.

"A woman in the district of Halwan in Cairo was stabbed by her husband 20 times followed by having her right ear cut off. When asked why he did it, her husband said, 'because she does not listen to what I say'"

Similar to the case of Farah, Nayera and her family had made repeated formal complaints to the Egyptian authorities. In both Akbar and Ashrafs’ cases, the authorities failed to keep them safe, leading to their deaths.

Yet sadly neither the authorities in Kuwait nor in Egypt have been held accountable for their part in failing to take action.

RELATED
Society
Lara Bellone d’Altavilla

These acts of femicide are not new to Egypt. In October 2020, three men sexually assaulted 24-year-old Mariam Salah and then proceeded to attempt to steal her handbag, dragging her to her death with their microbus.

Two of the men were sentenced to death and the third was acquitted. And last year, three men broke into a 34-year-old woman’s flat in El Salam district in Cairo for receiving a male visitor, torturing her visitor and then terrorising her to the point she reportedly jumped off the balcony of her 6th-floor apartment and died.

However, her body was found lying on the floor outside another building, making the claim that she threw herself off unclear. The men were charged with unlawful imprisonment and thuggery, not with murder.

What this all proves is that targeted gender-based murders and violence have become systemic in Egypt, something that Amira Salah-Ahmed, Chief Media Officer and Executive Producer at Womena, agrees with.

In a public statement following Nayera’s murder, Amira said, “Nayera Ashraf’s murder cannot be seen as an isolated incident, but needs to be accurately portrayed as part of a dangerous narrative that normalises gender-based violence.

"The dangerous cultural narrative not only discriminates against women on a daily basis but goes further to normalise gender-based violence by depicting it lightly or comically as entertainment in all forms of media. Patriarchal and misogynistic mindsets are further cemented by these fatal narratives that are brought directly into our homes. This is worsened by the lack of legal frameworks to protect women who actively seek protection from authorities.”

"When we look at a country like Egypt or Jordan... you’re socialised into waiting to get married until you have sex. Because of patriarchy in South West Asia and North Africa, men have much more leeway when it comes to this; they are able to express their sex drive in ways that women can’t"

Gathering statistics on cases of femicide and the numbers of girls and women subjected to gender-based violence is a mammoth task in Egypt.

The Edraak Foundation for Development and Equality is one of a few reliable organisations that has undertaken this incredibly difficult task.

In their report issued last year, they estimated that 7.8 million girls and women in Egypt have experienced some form of gender-based violence.

There were 415 violent crimes committed against girls and women in Egypt in 2020, 113 cases of women murdered as a result of domestic abuse, and a total of 165 cases of femicide in that same year.

In the days following Nayera Ashraf and Iman Irshaids’ murders, some on social media referred to their murderers as incels. However, Arab writers and academics have disagreed with the use of this term which has been created by the West to describe men who find themselves involuntarily celibate and as a result target women with misogynistic abuse and violence.

An Algerian activist holds a placard reading in Arabic "The future is female" during a rally in Algiers [Getty Images]

Egyptian American feminist, journalist, and author of The Seven Necessary Sins for Women and Girls, Mona El Tahawy, tells The New Arab that there is an important distinction that needs to be made between incels in the West, and men like Nayera Ashraf and Iman Irshaids’ murderers.

“When it comes to sex and the ability to express one’s self sexually and openly, we’re talking about very different cultural contexts, because today for most people in the so-called West, you can have sex with whoever you want whenever you want and it’s a different scenario in Egypt, in Jordan, and in what we now call South West Asia and North Africa,” explains Mona.

“There’s much more taboo connected with it, there’s much more shame, there’s much more silence, so it is a different playing field. When we look at a country like Egypt or Jordan and other countries in the region, you’re socialised into waiting to get married until you have sex. Because of patriarchy in South West Asia and North Africa, men have much more leeway when it comes to this; they are able to express their sex drive in ways that women can’t, so it's a different kind of involuntarily celibate men," Mona continues.

These men in Egypt and Jordan believe that women must succumb to their advances, these women owe them their attention and their love, and if they don’t, then these men believe – because patriarchy protects and enables men’s violence against us – that they have the right to punish women. And there is nothing in our societies that holds those men accountable.”


The outpouring of rage and anger from people in Egypt following Nayera’s murder meant that her murderer’s trial and conviction was one of the fastest ever seen in Egypt’s Criminal Court, as murder cases tend to take months or even years to reach a verdict.

However, this is not the norm, and the Egyptian legal system is greatly lacking when it comes to laws that punish femicide and acts of gender-based violence. In fact, terms such as “misogynistic hate crime” and “femicide” are not recognised.

Article 60 in the Penal Code allows a perpetrator of domestic violence to be pardoned if he “acted in good faith,” and Article 17 allows a judge to lower a sentence for rape or an honour killing as an act of “mercy,” although recently there has been talk of Article 17 being abolished.

Furthermore, when you are living in a country where the state itself commits acts of gender-based violence against women, such as the sexual violence and forced virginity tests perpetrated by the military during the Arab Spring in 2011 and anti-military protests in 2014, it is no wonder that men like Nayera Ashraf’s murderer kill so brazenly and with such impunity.

RELATED
Culture
Karen Dabrowska

“It is essential that we identify these violent men, while not forgetting that femicide is an act fuelled by misogyny and the absence of laws that view women as equal citizens. We cannot stop at blaming these men, or calling them incels, without working to dismantle the larger patriarchal system we live in,” says Huda Jawad, Co-Director of Musawah, the global movement for equality and justice in the Muslim family.

For over a decade Musawah has been campaigning for reform to personal status laws and family laws in both Egypt and other Muslim-majority countries.

“It is important to note here that we do not yet see femicide as a crime in our region. We do not differentiate between the act of killing and the act of killing a woman because of the sole fact that she is a woman, so the penal code is lacking when it comes to femicide.

"We hope we will be able to get justice for these women. We also hope that we start building a collective discourse on femicide that translates into systemic and legal efforts. At Musawah, we believe equality and justice are necessary and possible and we know that the time for this change is now."

Yousra Samir Imran is a British Egyptian writer and author who is based in Yorkshire. She is the author of Hijab and Red Lipstick, being published by Hashtag Press in the UK in October 2020

Follow her on Twitter: @UNDERYOURABAYA
THE WAR ON WOMEN
Let’s be honest, Iran’s hijab saga is not about religion

The Iranian government’s preoccupation with hijab continues, from controlling ‘guidelines’ issued on women’s dress in workplaces, universities and on the streets. This obsession, however, seeks to target civil liberties, not protect religious values.

Perspectives 
Kourosh Ziabari
21 Jul, 2022

Debate on the imperative of observing the Islamic dress code, or hijab, has been ongoing in Iran since the advent of the 1979 revolution, writes Kourosh Ziabari.

It seems that not a day passes in Iran’s blistering summer without the state media publishing something new about the administration of President Ebrahim Raisi’s plans to counter the alleged corruption of social morality through women’s lax compliance with the government’s strict hijab mandate.

Debate on the imperative of observing the Islamic dress code, or hijab, has been ongoing since the advent of the 1979 revolution. There are few priorities, like the way women should dress, that Iran’s theocracy treats as a life-and-death urgency. Not even the desolate state of the national economy, spiralling poverty, unfettered inflation and human capital flight precipitated by the traction of nepotism on different levels of governance, take such centre stage.

The intensity of the conversation has usually varied under different administrations. Pro-reform presidents Mohammad Khatami in early 2000s and Hassan Rouhani recently, contained the fever of the ultra-conservatives and refused to allow the hijab battle to become a political priority. But the hardline presidents Mahmoud Ahmadinejad and Raisi, despite paying lip service to the ideals of freedom and equality, have pandered to making the lives of women more difficult in the public sphere over their choice of dress.

''For the Islamic Republic, investing in the dogma of compulsory hijab, the concern is not upholding a religious principle, as Islam does not require its maxims to be implemented coercively. In reality it is a pathway for the government to consolidate political power.''

To many, it may seem obvious that the Iranian government focuses on the hijab, after all, it is an Islamic establishment with religious tenets constituting the core of the social, political, judicial, and economic system.

One might argue the leadership is determined to cultivate ethics in everyday life and demand that women adhere to what the Islamic faith requires.

But the convenient counterargument that strikes down any such fallacy is that there is no other Islamic country anywhere in the world that makes conformity with the hijab codes compulsory, and resorts to violence, propaganda, police vans, fines and prison terms to proliferate morality. If the Taliban in Afghanistan can be cited as an exception, even such a conservative state as Saudi Arabia has forsaken its hijab orthodoxies and is embracing a more inclusive understanding of Islam and the Sharia law.

The Iranian government’s hijab mania is exceeding the limits of religious advocacy.

In June, local media reported that the morality police officers had fired several bullets into the leg of Reza Moradkhani, a former national boxing champion, after he intervened to deter them from harassing his wife in a Tehran park over her dressing style and loosely-worn headscarf.

The Initiative for the Promotion of Virtue and the Prevention of Vice, an influential religious watchdog that was relatively dormant under the moderate president Hassan Rouhani, has had a comeback under Raisi. It is issuing a list of spine-chilling guidelines on how women should dress in the workplace and other public places, and how this should be regulated.

Some of these playbooks of “ethical conduct” portend the relegation of Iran to the shadowy years of 1980s, when women were amongst the first targets of a hot-blooded revolutionary zeal to promulgate “pure Islam”. Vigilantes would aggressively confront women on the streets, at times even attacking them if they did not accept to “correct” their appearance in a more modest fashion.

RELATED
Perspectives
Tharwa Boulifi

In the newly-issued instructions, particulars of “proper” hijab and conduct are laid out in unprecedented detail. For instance, female employees are warned against using perfume, wearing makeup, and talking to their male colleagues about issues unrelated to work. In addition to the specifications of the length of their dresses and dimensions of their headscarves, it is even stipulated that the administrators of government offices in which female employees do not comply with the codes, can be fired.

The Raisi administration has also given carte blanche to universities to target female students dressing in ways deemed not conservative enough, and to take disciplinary action against them.

Students have been protesting what they believe is a conversion of university campuses into “military barracks” as campus patrols have been making rounds, cautioning students over what they should and shouldn’t wear. Unsurprisingly, student activists have been coming under increased pressure.

That is not where the convolution ends. The police summons women passengers of private vehicles if they remove their headscarves while driving. Since early 2019 until July, 300,000 car drivers received text warnings on their phones over the “crime” of removing hijab, and signed affidavits that they won’t repeat it.

Whilst the latest figures on the police initiative have not been released, it is still very much in force. Every day there are noticeable queues of women in front of police departments, being forced to commit keeping their headscarves on while driving, or consenting to their cars being interdicted.

RELATED
Voices
Sam Hamad

Across the country, a detested morality police squad known as “Gasht-e Ershad” or “guidance patrol,” in green vans, are trained to apprehend women whose dressing is interpreted to be un-Islamic. Hundreds of them are given the power to arrest scores of “offenders,” often through force.

Scenes of women resisting arrest, passers-by intervening to rescue them, and ensuing skirmishes are becoming recurrent in hotspots where these vans are stationed.

For the Islamic Republic, investing in the dogma of compulsory hijab, the concern is not upholding a religious principle, as Islam does not require its maxims to be implemented coercively. In reality it is a pathway for the government to consolidate political power.

The bottom line is that for the Iranian government, the hijab is mostly a matter of trying to tighten the grip around the civil society. The aim is to maintain an ironclad control over a restive population and make sure the country’s dynamic youth does not pluck up the courage to make further demands on civil liberties. The leadership recognises that if it makes a concession on its unpopular hijab mandate, the people will ask for more freedoms.

Kourosh Ziabari is an award-winning Iranian journalist and reporter. He is the Iran correspondent of Fair Observer and Asia Times. He is the recipient of a Chevening Award from the UK's Foreign and Commonwealth Office and an American Middle Eastern Network for Dialogue at Stanford Fellowship.
Newport Folk Festival Includes Stage Powered By Bicycles

The Newport Folk Festival, known for creating electrifying musical moments — the most famous being Bob Dylan's decision to plug in his guitar in 1965 — this weekend has a small outer stage that is being powered in part by festival-goers on stationary bicycles.
Newport Folk Festival PTI

UPDATED: 23 JUL 2022

The Newport Folk Festival, known for creating electrifying musical moments — the most famous being Bob Dylan's decision to plug in his guitar in 1965 — this weekend has a small outer stage that is being powered in part by festival-goers on stationary bicycles.

The Bike Stage is the brainchild of the band Illiterate Light, an environmentally conscious indie rock duo from Virginia, who has partnered with a company called Rock the Bike to create a pedal-powered sound system, which they have already been using at small club shows.

Frontman Jeff Gorman said the “Bike Stage” at the event in Rhode Island is the first time the system has been tried at a festival. About a dozen artists are scheduled to perform mostly acoustic sets on the stage.

About 1,300 of the festival's 10,000 fans rode bicycles to Newport on Friday. Gorman said when he saw that sea of bikes during the band's appearance in Newport in 2019, he and partner Jake Cochran approached festival director Jay Sweet about setting up the stage.

“It's a way for them to just do something different and for us to start the conversation around energy use and just thinking differently and trying out new ways of creating electricity,” Gorman said.

The stage is equipped with solar panels that will provide most of the power to the equipment, with the bikes providing the rest.

When the show begins, fans jump onto five bicycles adjacent to the tent.

The pedalling generates electricity, which is fed through wires to an electrical box on the stage.

With temperatures in the upper 80s, fans take turns pedalling for about five minutes during the 20-minute sets. In exchange, they get a few spritzes of water from a spray bottle, a free can of iced tea and a front-row view of the performance.

Sarah Gaines, 44 of Wakefield, Rhode Island, pedalled for one song during a Friday set by singer Madi Diaz and came off the bicycle with a huge smile on her face.

“I love riding bikes, we rode our bikes here today,” she said. “I also feel like it's time for us to be more proactive and come up with some (energy) solutions that aren't reliant on traditional energy sources, so I was really excited they were doing this.”

Gorman said Illiterate Light was among the first of a group of bands that have been trying to find ways to make their shows more environmentally friendly. Coldplay, for example, harnesses energy from a kinetic dance floor at their shows and also uses stationary bikes to store some power.

“We don't want people to spend their fun weekend having to sweat their butt off,” Gorman said. “But we do think it's fun to be able to jump up for five minutes and have that bodily experience of making this music happen.”

(Inputs from PTI)
Nadhim Zahawi: Who Really is The New UK Chancellor?

Posted on July 11, 2022 

UK’s Finance minister Nadhim Zahawi (R) sits next to Prime Minister Boris Johnson as he chairs a Cabinet meeting in the Cabinet Room after delivering his statement resigning as the leader of the Conservative Party, July 7, 2022. 
Photo: No 10 downing Street/via Ekurd.net

Sheri Laizer | Exclusive to Ekurd.net

From Boris to Worse?

No evidence has been produced that the Zahawis had any political problems with the Iraqi Ba’ath government and if they did they may not have been political in nature. Most editors drop in the line about Zahawi’s background that the family is Kurdish and fled from Iraq but no real details are given.

He claims they fled in 1976 from Saddam Hussein but Saddam Hussein was not in power then. Saddam was only vice president to Ahmad Hassan al-Bakr. Nadhim Zahawi was a child of nine years old at the time and his recollections are not based on his experience but on the propaganda circulated by the opposition against Saddam Hussein from the time of the Iran-Iraq war as many groups were backed by Iran. The Spectator gives a variant age of 11 for the time that the Zahawi family were accepted in the UK as migrants, not refugees. At this time, the UK had very good relations with Iraq and maintained them until the debacle over Kuwait in August 1990. A pro-Zahawi article published in the Spectator, taking him at his word, accordingly gets its Iraqi history wrong.

It also notes that Zahawi had received a Spectator award, so it can be considered to be a promo feature. Zahawi has paid the former strategist of Boris Johnson, Mark Fullbrook of strategy firm, Crosby Textor Fullbrook Partners, for the past three years to secure him the top job according to a recent article by James Cusick in Open Democracy.

Zahawi himself said they arrived penniless yet he was schooled at public schools, Ibstock Place, followed by an Eton group school, King’s College School in Wimbledon. He went on to University College, London. His sister received similar tuition. Although he claims the family arrived from Iraq (long after the Ba’ath coup) and without any money his grandfather (after whom he was named) was Nadhim Zahawi, the governor of the Central Bank of Iraq (CBI). The official is even named on Iraqi dinar banknotes.

His father, Hareth managed to earn quite a sum in order to declare himself bankrupt between Nadhim’s arrival in the UK aged 9, and his eighteenth birthday. A variant on the penniless refugee story that emerged in 2013 claimed Zahawi grew up on a Sussex farm with horses and when a boy had wanted to become a jockey before moving to London with his family. A disclosure under the Waxman Inquiry states that his father, the CEO of IPBD contractors, received $40 million in kickbacks from the US government.

UK government data does not show the full data on his son, Nadhim, at GKP and at Afren, from which he derived additional undisclosed millions. Zahawi had also worked with DNO for two years before he became an MP. He has been closely linked with Ashti Hawrami, the former head of the Kurdistan Ministry of Natural Resources, blasted for corruption and missing millions of oil revenues diverted into private pockets. He now owns race horses and has a livery in the UK and is rumored to enjoy stables in Dubai.

Nadhim Zahawi was not known to be among the Kurdish opposition active in exile in London. He had been propelled into the spotlight using the “Kurdish” tag by Jeffrey Archer in May 1991 (who had nicknamed him Lemon Kurd and his friend and future brother-in-law, Brusk Saib, as Bean Kurd).

The Kurdish community was astonished when Archer secured the keynote address for Zahawi at the Simple Truth concert televised live seeking funds for Kurdish refugees stranded on the mountains after the failed 1991 uprising in the name of the Red Cross.


A British Kurdish millionaire Nadhim Zahawi appointed as new UK finance minister on July 5, 2022. Photo: No 10 Downing Street/via Ekurd.net

Zahawi had not represented Kurdish political interests in any public capacity before the Simple Truth. The proceeds never reached the people for whom the money was raised and most was “accounted for” as administration costs.

A more recent association of Nadhim Zahawi with Kurdistan has been one that is far more profitable rather than it is charitable. In 1994, Archer had given Zahawi a further hand up helping him to secure a position on Wandsworth Council. Archer’s penthouse overlooking the Thames is situated within Wandsworth Borough near the MI6 ziggurat. In return, in 1998, Zahawi ran Archer’s mayoral bid, that did not succeed. His own bid for re-election as a Conservative candidate for Stratford-on-Avon secured him a position as an MP in 2010, which he held through three successive elections through till 2019. It is reported that in 2013 he also became a member of Number 10’s Policy Unit.

Zahawi went on to co-found YouGov with Stephan Shakespeare (Kukowski)and remained Chief Executive until February 2010. When YouGov was set up, one of its biggest shareholders was Zahawi’s Balshore Investments, based in tax haven, Gibraltar.

As the Guardian recorded: “Last year (2016) Balshore received around £112,000 in dividends from YouGov. The current tax on dividends for higher rate taxpayers in the UK is 32.5%. There is also no liability to tax on dividends paid by a Gibraltar company to a person who is not resident in Gibraltar…”

Therefore, when Zahawi claims currently to be a ‘victim’ of a smear campaign in being investigated for dubious financial dealings, it is owing to doubts about his accountability overall and not just his declared income for tax purposes.

The Mirror published a preliminary probe in November 2021 observing: “Mr Zahawi was co-chairman of the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Kurdistan in 2015 when he landed the job with Gulf Keystone, which has an oil field in Kurdistan and which paid him more than £1,000 an hour. His Gulf Keystone income was declared in his register of interests, but his total second job earnings are not known thanks to Parliamentary rules allowing him to advise companies through Zahawi & Zahawi Ltd, a consultancy he set up with his wife… Alex Runswick, of Transparency International UK, said: “Any new controls on MPs’ second jobs need to focus on potential conflicts of ­interests, not just the hours worked or additional earnings.

“Any company owned by an MP risks becoming a shell behind which the extent of the work and these conflicts remain hidden.” A caption noted he received almost £300,000 in bonus payments from Gulf Keystone.

Oil corruption in Kurdistan – lawsuits threaten the future


British Prime Minister Boris Johnson (R) meets Iraqi Kurdistan Prime Minister Masrour Barzani for a bilateral meeting in 10 Downing Street, London, April 19, 2022. Photo: No 10 Downing Street/ via Ekurd.net


Shell companies abound in Kurdistan and its oil and fledgling gas sector lacks transparency. KRG President, Nechirvan Barzani, Massoud Barzani’s nephew, has been making generous promises on Kurdistan’s future gas delivery (to Turkey) but Kurdistan does not even possess the infrastructure to deliver gas.

Kate Dourian writing for the Arab Gulf States Institute in Washington (AGSIW) stressed recently hat there is also no Kurdish gas to spare. “Shortly after the February 24 Russian invasion of Ukraine, Masrour Barzani, the KRG’s prime minister, spoke at an energy conference in Dubai where he declared that the Kurdistan region could become an important source of energy to its immediate neighbors and the world. On recent visits to London, Doha, and Ankara, he conveyed a similar message.

The problem is that Iraq’s Kurdistan region currently has no natural gas to spare, and its oil production has stagnated…”

KDP media outlet, Rudaw, claimed business partner and neighbor Turkey was after its gas whether via Barzani or Baghdad. Erdogan said, “Although Nechirvan Barzani is from northern Iraq, we are also discussing and we have discussed with him [issues related] to central Iraq. Our friendship with Nechirvan Barzani is very very different and our relationship is at a high level.”

Baghdad for its part has for some months being trying to take the Kurdistan regional government to court over its suspect oil contracts in violation of the Constitution. The Kurdistan oil sector has become known as among the most corrupt in the world.


Iraqi Kurdistan Prime Minister Masrour Barzani (R) met with UK Secretary of State for Education Nadhim Zahawi on April 21, 2022. Photo: Barzani’s Twitter


On July 6, al-Hurra reported, based on an earlier report by AFP, that Baghdad had ruled that the contracts of four foreign oil companies operating in the Kurdistan region were void. The ruling on July 4, reportedly affected Western Zagros, DNO, HKN Energy, and Genel Energy. The court found the contracts in question to be in violation of the February 15 ruling by the Federal Supreme Court against oil operations in the Kurdistan region, according to an unnamed senior Iraqi oil official.

Earlier contracts pre-dating that of HKN are, however, also in violation. HKN arrived on the scene comparatively late in the day. For example, Prime Natural Resources with Turkish Petoil and Heritage with Oryx Addax. If DNO contracts were to be voided this would have a knock-on effect on voiding Gulf Keystone, Shamaran, Hunt Oil and MOL of Hungary, among others.

With paper tiger Kurdish president of Iraq, Barham Saleh, still in position in Baghdad, justice is hampered anyway as Saleh sits astride two horses. As one Kurdish commentator preferring to remain anonymous rightly asked, “Where else do you have a country with two presidents and two legal codes?”

Halliburton is among the first IOCs now agreeing only to work with Baghdad setting a trend that other IOCs are likely to follow as support for the Kurdish kleptocracy withers. The Iraq Oil Report ran a heading dated June 29, 2022, claiming Halliburton pledges to obey blacklist policy against KRG oil sector noting: Three major U.S. oil services companies have now told the Oil Ministry they will comply with new restrictions stemming from February’s landmark court ruling against Kurdistan. It went on: U.S. oil services giant Halliburton joined Schlumberger and Baker Hughes in notifying Iraq’s Oil Ministry that it will comply with a Federal Supreme Court (FSC) rulling invalidating the legal foundations of Iraqi Kurdistan’s energy sector…Halliburton’s letter came in response to a set of circular letters — one from the Ministry of Oil to the Iraqi National Oil Company and one from the Basra Oil Company — instructing “all lead contractors and sub-contractors” to sever their contractual engagements with the KRG within three months or risk being blacklisted by Baghdad.

Gulf Keystone, Zahawi’s former flying carpet, has been getting lower payments than they did five years ago despite oil prices being higher than ever and reaching over $100 a barrel with more oil being produced. They are also being paid months late. How can that be?

So, if the contracts should be voided by Baghdad what will happen to Kurdistan – and its British, American and other ‘friends’ with their fingers in the pie? Baghdad accuses the region of delay tactics in its lawsuit against an initial seven oil companies.

The KRG’s notorious Ministry of Natural Resources reportedly filed a tit-for-tat lawsuit in Erbil’s court of criminal investigation against several Baghdad Oil Ministry chiefs. Each can unravel the other and expose where some of the missing billions has gone…and is still going.

Zahawi and the oil boom in Kurdistan


As I wrote in my article, Iraqi Kurdistan-Sold Out, III: In 2010, Zahawi took up his position in the UK Parliament with former head of Talisman, John Manzoni [8], after the sale of PSC contracts to Gazprom and Repsol. Manzoni became Chief Executive of the UK Civil Service and Permanent Secretary of the Cabinet Office on 2 July 2015. Zahawi was previously the advisor to Talisman (and to the now defunct Afren) and declared Talisman to be a registered client of his consultancy, Zahawi and Zahawi Ltd. in 2014.

As I wrote in my article, Iraq-The Cynical Swindle: In 2013, Gulf Keystone Petroleum (GKP) [London-listed oil company registered in Bermuda], argued with one of its investors, M&G, and murky details were revealed in the UK press. Its AGM was held in Bermuda. GKP often made the news in Kurdistan…as Nadhim Zahawi, had been receiving substantial amounts of money every month (some sources say £1000 a month) as well as bonuses.

Over a two-year period, GKP paid Zahawi a £2.5 million package, as listed in his parliamentary declarations. He also acquired £25 million in property. [Sourced from UK parliamentary records. It is not apparent how much Nadhim Zahawi’s other companies may or may not have received, including Zahawi Zahawi Company and what it may have been paid from IPBD Limited, established by his father.]

In January 2016 when GKP was owed $500 million by the KRG, Nadhim Zahawi and Mark Denning called in chapter 11 to restructure the company, which was advantageous to them both. Zahawi had in fact been appointed to GKP, via Denning, the Portfolio Manager of Capital, who answered to Philip May [73], during David Cameron’s term in office as Prime Minister. But the chapter 11 was dealt with during the appointment of Philip May’s wife, Theresa, as British Prime Minister following the Brexit referendum, that is still a fiasco…Mr and Mrs May were involved in five different oil companies in Kurdistan and connected with Bafel Talabani of the PUK and Federal Petroleum… The Capital Group held significant shares in Western Zagros…”

From Boris to Worse?


It is difficult to finger Zahawi because he employs top lawyers like those used by Dubai’s ruler, Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid al-Maktoom to protect his name and keep critics at bay. Maktoom launched Emirates airlines and owns property in the UK worth more than £100m. Emirates stadium, P&O Ferries and Thames port London Gateway are all linked to the Sheikh. He is close to the Queen and was helped by New Labour. Zahawi would fly to the UAE regularly each year, meeting the horse race set around Sheikh Maktoom, and his accountant. Money was routed through several companies, as financial regulators monitored from the Parliamentary register.

The Independent has published a telling photograph of Zahawi with the grin wiped from his face referring to an HMRC probe against him. However, it is not just HMRC, but also the Serious Fraud Office (SFO), the National Crime Agency and the Labour opposition. Last year the Labour Party demanded an official probe into Zahawi’s £100m property empire at a time when he was business minister and Boris Johnson also made him vaccines minister.

A self-interested player, this is not the type of man the British need as their next Prime Minister after the demise of his mentor, Boris Johnson.

The Mirror last year cited Sir Alastair Graham, the former chairman of the Committee on Standards in Public Life, saying “How are we to perceive a conflict of interest if we don’t know where the Zahawis are investing these vast sums? Ministers are expected to show leadership in applying the seven principles of public life. This looks like a total failure of leadership.”

In an update to the questions hanging over Zahawi, Mirror Investigations Editor, Nick Sommerlad, asked where the £30m loan came from to fund Zahawi and wife’s property empire.

Will it go from Boris to worse?


Sheri Laizer, a Middle East and North African expert specialist and well known commentator on the Kurdish issue. She is a senior contributing writer for Ekurd.net. More about Sheri Laizer see below.

The opinions are those of the writer and do not necessarily represent the views of Ekurd.net or its editors.

Read more about Nadhim Zahawi

Nadhim Zahawi knocked out of UK’s conservative party leadership race 14.7.2022
Nadhim Zahawi: Who Really is The New UK Chancellor? 11.7..2022
Nadhim Zahawi pockets fortune from second job at Iraqi Kurdistan-focused oil company 16.11.2021
Nadhim Zahawi’s £100m property empire revealed, Labour demands probe…5.8.2021
Iraqi Kurdistan – “Sold Out!” – Part III – 17.5.2021
Iraq – The Cynical Swindle 24.11. 2018
Kurdish-British MP Zahawi ‘closely linked to tax-haven-based companies’ 7.1.2017
Gulf Keystone’s Nadhim Zahawi owns property worth more than £25 million 3.1.2017
Nadhim Zahawi stands to make £1.5m from Iraqi Kurdistan oil company sale 15.12.2016
How Zahawi made £370k from Gulf Keystone while small investors suffer a share price crash 6.10.2016
Ashti Hawrami’s Kurdistan activities with international oil companies and banks 4.8.2016
Millionaire British-Kurdish MP Nadhim Zahawi gets £20,000 salary from Gulf Keystone 13.11.2015
Bust oil firm advised by Tory MP Nadhim Zahawi faces fraud probe 19.11.2016
Tory millionaire Nadhim Zahawi in talks over Iraqi Kurdistan oil role 13.6.2015
Kurdistan delegation led by Tory millionaire Nadhim Zahawi raises concerns that British MPs… 13.5.2014
British PM’s advisor, Zahawi used offshore tax haven to buy £1m mansion in his own constituency 25.11.2013
First Kurdish MP in UK history 10.5.2010

Read more about Corruption in Iraqi Kurdistan

Copyright © 2022 Ekurd.net. All rights reserved




COMPRADOR QUISLINGS FOR TURKIYE

Masrour Barzani holds talks in Baghdad with Iraqi PM al-Kadhimi on oil disputes

BAGHDAD,— Iraq’s federal government in Baghdad and the autonomous Kurdistan region pledged Saturday to “increase dialogue” to ease a simmering oil dispute that has been playing out in the courts in recent months.

The announcement came during a rare visit to the Iraqi capital by the Kurdish region’s prime minister. Masrour Barzani, who had not visited Baghdad since 2019, met Iraqi Prime Minister Mustafa al-Kadhimi for wide-ranging talks.

An oil dispute that has been poisoning relations between the two sides, and threatening to harm Iraq’s lifeline oil industry according to analysts, was among the topics.

“It was agreed to increase dialogue between the federal ministry of oil and the ministry of natural resources in the Kurdistan region of Iraq to address the outstanding issues and continue working to reach common solutions,” a statement from Kadhimi’s office said.

“The two sides… emphasised the need to strengthen cooperation and joint coordination between the federal government and the regional government to attract investments, and maximise revenues,” it added.

The long-simmering dispute came to a head in February — at a time of political deadlock in Baghdad — when the federal supreme court ordered Kurdistan to hand over oil extracted from its territories to the federal authorities.

Iraq, the second largest producer in the Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries, sits on enormous reserves, and revenues from the sector feed 90 percent of the federal government budget.

It exports an average of 3.3 million barrels per day (bpd) of crude, while production in Kurdistan amounts to just over 450,000 bpd.

In a bid to defuse tensions, Kurdistan proposed setting up two companies specialised in oil exploration and marketing that would coordinate with Baghdad, a spokesperson for the regional government said earlier this month.

Baghdad has fought to regain control of output from fields in Kurdistan since the autonomous region began marketing oil independently more than a decade ago.

On February 22, 2022, Iraq’s Supreme court deemed an oil and gas law regulating the oil industry in Iraqi Kurdistan unconstitutional and demanded that Kurdish authorities hand over their crude supplies.

According to a court ruling, the Kurdish authorities in Erbil must hand over all crude from the KRG and nearby territories to Iraq’s federal government, which is represented by the oil ministry in Baghdad.

Oil contracts between the KRG and oil firms, foreign parties, and states were declared null and void by the court verdict. Exploration, extraction, export, and sale agreements are all included, according to the court.

The KRG has repeatedly rejected the federal court ruling. In 2007, the Kurdistan region adopted an oil and gas law, allowing it to manage and develop its own natural resources.

On April 2, the Iraqi oil ministry has asked for copies of all oil and gas contracts signed by the Kurdish administration since 2004, as well as information on the Kurdistan region’s hydrocarbon revenues, for the purpose of reviewing and amending them. Iraq’s federal government has instructed the KRG to transfer its oil and gas operations to a new company named Kurdistan Oil Company ahead of Baghdad’s takeover of the Kurdistan’s operations.

On May 7, 2022, Oil minister Ihsan Ismael said Iraq’s oil ministry would start implementing a February federal court ruling that deemed the legal foundations of the Kurdistan region’s oil and gas sector unconstitutional.

On May 12, INOC published an analysis detailing how the KRG’s production-sharing contracts are financially worse for both the government and foreign oil firms than federal Iraq’s own technical service contracts. According to the report, the KRG’s contracts with multinational corporations and the exportation of extracted oil and gas violate the Iraqi constitution as it deprives the federal government of control over the country’s oil and gas industry.

On May 15, Iraq’s state-owned North Oil (NOC) claimed that KRG forces took control of some oil wells in the disputed region of Kirkuk but the KRG denied the allegation, claiming it was designed to create chaos.

On May 19, Iraq has asked oil and gas firms operating in Kurdistan region to sign new contracts with state-owned marketer SOMO rather than the Kurdistan Regional Government (KRG). The Iraqi oil ministry appointed international law firm Cleary Gottlieb Steen and Hamilton to approach some oil and gas firms operating in the Kurdistan region to “initiate discussions to bring their operations into line with applicable Iraqi law.”

On May 26, 2022, Iraqi Kurdistan region’s Minister of Natural Resources, Kamal Atroshi, has resigned from his post.

On June 18, 2022, the KRG said that it is working to establish two oil firms KOMO and KROC, the latest move in the battle between Erbil and Baghdad to control the oil sector in Kurdistan. The KRG’s new oil firm KROC would specialise in oil exploration, while the second – KOMO – would focus on oil exports and marketing from Kurdistan region.

On June 26, 2022, U.S. energy company Schlumberger has said it will not apply without Baghdad’s consent for any tenders in the oil and gas sector of Iraq’s Kurdistan region, according to a letter sent to the Iraqi oil minister.

In July 2022, a commercial court in the Iraqi capital annulled contracts between the Kurds and foreign firms, after the oil ministry in Baghdad filed a judicial complaint.

On July 5, 2022, U.S. oilfield services companies Schlumberger, Baker Hughes and Halliburton have pledged to comply with a federal supreme court ruling and withdraw from Iraq’s Kurdistan region, the country’s oil ministry said in Baghdad.

PDK PETTY BOURGEOIS CORRUPTION

The Kurdish administration which called itself a Kurdistan Regional Government KRG is not transparent in disclosing the exact amount of oil revenue to the public and to Kurdistan parliament, according to observers and Kurdish politicians.

Many Kurdish politicians, observers, and the ordinary people believe that many of Iraqi Kurdistan’s oil industry projects and deals are conducted in a non-transparent way. Some have even described them as secretive.

Iraqi Kurdistan region considered as the most corrupted part of Iraq. According to watchdogs, Kurdish lawmakers and leaked documents billions of dollars are missing from oil revenues.

According to local and international analysts and watchdogs the lack of control mechanisms in Iraqi Kurdistan makes it a paradise for illegal financial activities by the Kurdish ruling leaders.

Iraqi Kurdistan-ruling Barzani clan, known as the “Kurdish oligarchs”, have been routinely accused by critics and observers of neptunism and amassing huge wealth from oil business for the family instead of serving the population.

Massoud Barzani, remains the most powerful leader in the shadow according to analysts. Massoud’s son Masrour is the Kurdistan region’s prime minister and his nephew Nechirvan Barzani is the president of Kurdistan.

Copyright © 2022, respective author or news agency, Ekurd.net | AFP | Agencies