Wednesday, September 18, 2024

Sri Lanka's plantation workers live on the margins. But politicians still want their votes

Published: 18 Sep 2024 - 10:26 am | Last Updated: 18 Sep 2024 - 10:35 am

In this photograph taken on September 2, 2024, tea pickers listen to Palani Shakthivel, national organiser of the Ceylon Workers Congress (CWC), at a village in Hatton. 
Photo by Ishara S. KODIKARA / AFP.

Spring Valley, Sri Lanka: Whoever Sri Lanka's next president is, Muthuthevarkittan Manohari isn't expecting much to change in her daily struggle to feed the four children and elderly mother with whom she lives in a dilapidated room in a tea plantation.

Both leading candidates in Saturday's presidential election are promising to give land to the country's hundreds of thousands of plantation workers, but Manohari says she's heard it all before.

Sri Lanka's plantation workers are a long-marginalized group who frequently live in dire poverty, but they can swing elections by voting as a bloc.

Mahohari and her family are descended from Indian indentured laborers who were brought in by the British during colonial rule to work on plantations that grew first coffee, and later tea and rubber.

Those crops are still Sri Lanka's leading foreign exchange earners.

For 200 years, the community has lived on the margins of Sri Lankan society.

Soon after the country became independent in 1948, the new government stripped them of citizenship and voting rights.

Around 400,000 people were deported to India under an agreement with Delhi, separating many families.

The community fought for its rights, winning in stages until achieving full recognition as citizens in 2003.

There are around 1.5 million descendants of plantation workers living in Sri Lanka today, including about 3.5% of the electorate, and some 470,000 people still live on plantations.

The plantation community has the highest levels of poverty, malnutrition, anaemia among women and alcoholism in the country, and some of the lowest levels of education.

They're an important voting bloc, turned out by unions that double as political parties that ally with the country's major parties.

Despite speaking the Tamil language, they’re treated as a distinct group from the island’s indigenous Tamils, who live mostly in the north and east.

Still, they suffered during the 26-year civil war between government forces and Tamil Tiger separatists.

Plantation workers and their descendants faced mob violence, arrests and imprisonment because of their ethnicity.

Most plantation workers live in crowded dwellings called "line houses,” owned by plantation companies.

Tomoya Obokata, a U.N. special rapporteur on contemporary forms of slavery, said after a visit in 2022 that five to ten people often share a single 10-by-12-foot (3.05-by-3.6 meter) room, often without windows, a proper kitchen, running water or electricity. Several families frequently share a single basic latrine.

There are no proper medical facilities in the plantations, and the sick are attended to by so-called estate medical assistants who do not have medical degrees.

"These substandard living conditions, combined with the harsh working conditions, represent clear indicators of forced labour and may also amount to serfdom in some instances,” Obokata wrote in a report to the U.N. high commissioner for human rights.

The government has made some efforts to improve conditions for the planation workers, but years of fiscal crisis and the resistance of powerful plantation companies have blunted progress.

Access to education has improved, and a small group of entrepreneurs, professionals and academics descended from planation workers has emerged.

This year, the government negotiated a raise in the minimum daily wage for a plantation worker to 1,350 rupees ($4.50) per day, plus an additional dollar if a worker picks more than 22 kilos in a day.

Workers say this target is almost impossible to achieve, in part because tea bushes are often neglected and grow sparsely.

The government has built better houses for some families and the Indian government is helping to build more, said Periyasamy Muthulingam, executive director of Sri Lanka's Institute of Social Development, which works on plantation worker rights.

But many promises have gone unfulfilled. "All political parties have promised to build better houses during elections but they don’t implement it when they are in power,” Muthulingam said.

Muthulingam says more than 90% of the planation community is landless because they have been left out of the government's land distribution programs.

In this election, sitting President Ranil Wickremesinghe standing as an independent candidate has promised to give the line houses and the land they stand on to the people who live in them, and help develop them into villages.

The main opposition candidate, Sajith Premadasa, has promised to break up the plantations and distribute the land to the workers as small holdings.

Both proposals will face resistance from the plantation companies.

Manohari says she's not holding out hope.

She's more concerned with what's going to happen to her 16-year-old son after he was forced to drop out of school due to lack of funds.

"The union leaders come every time promising us houses and land and I would like to have them," she said. "But they never happen as promised.”

 

China opens 12 nuclear research facilities to global scientists

science
Photo credit: WAM

China will open 12 nuclear research facilities and testing platforms to international scientists and institutions to enhance global cooperation, a senior Chinese official said here on Monday, Xinhua reports. 

These include the China Advanced Research Reactor, the new-generation tokamak device Huanliu-3, and the Beishan Underground Research Laboratory, Liu Jing, vice chairman of the China Atomic Energy Authority (CAEA), said at a meeting on the sidelines of the International Atomic Energy Agency's (IAEA) annual general conference.

The facilities span areas such as basic nuclear research, isotope production, nuclear environment simulation, equipment testing, and radioactive waste treatment and disposal.

Monday's meeting, themed "Share for Development," was organized by the CAEA to promote international cooperation in nuclear technology research and development, as China marks the 40th anniversary of its accession to the IAEA.

Yu Jianfeng, chairman of China National Nuclear Corporation, said at the event that the company aims to deepen cooperation with the IAEA and expand international collaboration. He expressed hope that opening China's nuclear research facilities will contribute to advancing nuclear technology globally.

IAEA's Deputy Director General Mikhail Chudakov commended China's remarkable achievements in nuclear energy development and highlighted the long-standing, fruitful relationship between the IAEA and the CAEA.

Welcoming China's decision to open up more of its nuclear research and development facilities, Chudakov said the move will further strengthen the agency's technical capacity to support its member states.

On Monday evening, the CAEA and China's permanent mission to the United Nations (UN) and other international organizations in Vienna jointly held a reception at the UN headquarters in Vienna to celebrate the 40th anniversary of China's accession to the IAEA. More than 200 participants, including IAEA representatives and foreign envoys to Vienna, attended the event.

Li Song, China's permanent representative to the UN and other international organizations in Vienna, said at the reception that China and the IAEA have expanded practical cooperation and jointly promoted the development of nuclear energy over the past 40 years.

China, he said, will continue to strengthen collaboration with the IAEA and its member states to address emerging challenges in international security, safeguard the global non-proliferation regime, and promote the use of nuclear energy and technology for the benefit of the Global South.

At the reception, Liu, Li and IAEA Director General Rafael Grossi jointly unveiled a bronze statue of Qian Sanqiang, a renowned Chinese nuclear physicist and one of the founders of China's nuclear industry.

The statue, donated by China, will be permanently displayed at the IAEA headquarters, alongside sculptures of Polish-French physicist Marie Curie and other prominent figures who have made significant contributions to the peaceful use of nuclear energy.

Saving the Aral Sea: Central Asian states debate transboundary water use

Kazakh PM
Photo credit: gov.kz

Kazakh Prime Minister Olzhas Bektenov met with the heads of the delegations of the member states of the 1st meeting of the Executive Board of the International Fund for Saving the Aral Sea (IFAS) chaired by Kazakhstan, Kazinform News Agency reports referring to the Government’s press service.

The meeting focused on the joint use of transboundary water resources and further measures to tackle ecological and socioeconomic issues in the Aral Sea basin.

Kazakhstan assumed the chairmanship over the International Fund for Saving the Aral Sea (IFAS) in 2042-2026.

The Prime Minister said Heads of State pay great attention to water sector issues. The Kazakh President prioritized the saving of the Aral Sea in long-term international cooperation. The Fund’s main task is the complex and rational use, and protection of water and energy resources of Central Asia given their socioeconomic, energy, irrigation and environmental significance.

He stressed despite the measures taken regarding the deficit of water resources in the Aral Sea basin growing due to climate change as well, the Fund should consolidate the efforts of the concerned states.

The Kazakh Prime Minister highlighted the role of regional cooperation institution and defined the top priorities of the Fund set by the Heads of State of the International Fund for Saving the Aral Sea (IFAS).

The International Fund for Saving the Aral Sea (IFAS) was founded in 1993 by five Central Asian countries, including Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan, Tajikistan and Turkmenistan. Its goal is to unite the countries' efforts to mitigate the impacts of the Aral Sea crisis on the environment and population. The Fund finances joint interstate ecological and scientific programs and projects.

As earlier reported, Kazakh Ecology and Natural Resources Minister Yerlan Nyssanbayev suggested building an international center for the afforestation of the dried bottom of the Aral Sea and semidesert areas at the V Meeting of the Heads of Environmental Protection Ministries and Agencies of the SCO member states.

US Senate hearing exposes deep bias as Arab activist faces vile attacks

During hearing on rise in hate crimes, Republican Senator John Kennedy tells Maya Berry, Executive Director of the Arab American Institute, she "should hide her head in a bag," an expression epitomising hostile atmosphere of hearing.


Zahra Yarali
TRT/AA

Supporters of the Palestinian cause advocate for the passage of the Wadee Act.
 Photo: TRT World


During a US Congressional hearing that was designed to counter the unprecedented increase in hate crimes nationwide, an American Senator John Kennedy (R-LA) attacked an Arab American community advocate, shedding light on the overarching attitude of the Senate to suppress Palestinian-American voices.

The hearing, held on Tuesday in Washington, DC, took place in the shadow of Israel's war on Gaza and was supposed to explore the wave of hate-fuelled violence sweeping the nation.

Instead, it devolved into political mudslinging, with Republican lawmakers targeting Arab American advocates and derailing discussions meant to provide accountability and justice.

One of the most glaring omissions during the hearing was the failure to acknowledge Wadea Al Fayoume, the 6-year-old Palestinian-American boy, who was brutally murdered in Illinois last year in what has been recognised as a hate crime.

Wadea's mother, Hanan Shaheen, was among the attendees, alongside prominent figures like Yaqeen Institute founder Dr Omar Suleiman and emergency physician Dr Thaer Ahmad.

However, the killing of her son, who was stabbed 26 times, was conspicuously absent from the discussion.


"I was surprised that these Republican Congress folks could not even muster up the compassion to offer a word of condolence," Dr Omar Suleiman told TRT World in an interview after the hearing.


"[It] was extremely telling of the cruelty, the callousness, the apathy that exists in the halls of Congress today, especially as it relates to Palestinian life. I was particularly disgusted to be honest with you."




'You support Hamas'


Instead of discussing Wadea's death or the uptick in anti-Arab and anti-Muslim hate crimes, Republican senators used the hearing as a platform to attack Maya Berry, Executive Director of the Arab American Institute, who was the sole Arab witness called to testify.

Senator Kennedy began by reading her biography, which noted her advocacy for Arab and Middle Eastern causes in the US, before launching into a series of inflammatory and unfounded accusations.

He asked Berry, "You support Hamas, do you not?"

Following up with similarly loaded questions about her supposed support for Hezbollah, Kennedy’s line of questioning represented the kind of anti-Arab sentiment that Palestinian Americans had come to fear from this hearing.


Berry handled the attacks with composure, responding to Kennedy's provocations by saying, "Oddly enough, I’m going to say thank you for that question. It demonstrates the purpose of our hearing today."

She denied any support for Hamas and quickly shifted focus back to the real issue: "You asking that question very much puts focus on the issue of hate in our country."

But the attacks did not stop there. At one point, Kennedy even told Berry that she "should hide her head in a bag," an expression that epitomised the hostile atmosphere of the hearing.


Wadee Act introduced

Throughout the second half of the hearing, Republican senators, including Ted Cruz (R-TX), Josh Cornyn (R-TX), and Marsha Blackburn (R-TN), took turns deriding Berry and Arab Americans.

Instead of focusing on the very real hate crimes that had brought Shaheen and others to testify, the senators shifted the conversation to free speech policies on college campuses, criticising student protests against Israel's actions in Gaza.

Asked how the concept of political violence became so warped in today's senate hearing, Suleiman responded, "Because it's American exceptionalism, right? America sees what happens to it, not what it does. [It sees] what happens to a very specific part of it and not to the whole of it. And we've never been a part of America."

Despite the disappointment of many attendees, there was one small legislative victory that came out of the hearing: the introduction of the Wadee Act in both chambers of Congress.

The Act, named in honour of Wadea Al Fayoume, aims to address the rise in hate crimes against Arab and Muslim communities.

Dr Suleiman called it a "success," but emphasised that this was just one step in a long fight for justice.

"It requires people to simply insist that they will not be intimidated into silence, and we will not allow our land, our identity, our cause to disappear without us being visible [and] without us standing, especially with those that have unfortunately faced the brunt of this hatred."


SOURCE: TRT World

Historic US hate crimes hearing overshadowed by senator's 'extremism' on Muslim advocate

Senator John Kennedy's accusation of extremism against a leading Muslim civil rights advocate at a senate hearing has faced strong backlash from rights groups.

Brooke Anderson
18 September, 2024

At a US hate crimes hearing, a prominent activist faced intense questioning by US Senator John Kennedy (pictured) regarding Hamas and student protests in support of Gaza. [Getty]

A historic US congressional hearing on the proliferation of hate crime in the US was overshadowed by a series of questions seemingly accusing an Arab speaker of supporting Hamas, Hezbollah and Iran.

At the centre of the hearing was the case of Wadea Al-Fayoumi, a 6-year-old Palestinian boy from Plainfield, Illinois near Chicago, who was stabbed to death by his family's landlord 11 months ago, reportedly because of his background.

In his remarks, Senator Dick Durban of Illinois, who was chairing the hearing, pointed to the danger by white supremacists in the US.

"Since 2000, according to federal law enforcement, white supremacists have been responsible for more homicides than any other domestic extremist group," he said, adding that public figures have a responsibility to not incite hatred.

However, by the end of the hearing, the focus on cases such as that Al-Fayoumi were had been overshadowed by an unusual line of questioning of one of the speakers.

Republican US Senator John Kennedy accused a leading Muslim civil rights advocate, Arab American Institute Executive Director Maya Berry, of supporting extremism during a Senate hearing on hate incidents in the US, drawing criticism from many rights groups.

"You support Hamas, do you not?" Kennedy told Berry, who replied by saying: "You asking the executive director of the Arab American Institute that question very much puts the focus on the issue of hate in our country."

In a follow-up question, the senator asked, "You support Hezbollah, too, don't you?" He later told her, "You should hide your head in a bag."

Berry repeatedly said in her responses that she did not support those groups, and added that she found the line of questioning "extraordinarily disappointing."

Hamas, which carried out a deadly 7 Oct. attack on Israel, and Hezbollah are both designated as "foreign terrorist organisations" by the US government.

Multiple rights advocates denounced Senator Kennedy.

"It is absolutely reprehensible that a US senator would weaponise the racial identity of a witness and accuse her of supporting terrorism by using an anti-Arab and anti-Muslim trope in a hearing meant to tackle precisely that kind of bigotry," Council on American Islamic Relations Government Affairs Director Robert McCaw told news agency Reuters.

"This harassment is alarming," Muslim American advocacy group Engage Action said.

James Zogby, president of the Arab American Institute, who attended Tuesday's hearing, told The New Arab that he thought Berry's answers were "masterful."

"Maya didn't take the bait. She focused on the broader issues after she was asked demeaning questions. She remained on the high ground," he said.

"In the end, Senator Kennedy provided her with the opportunity to respond, and she scored the final point with her ability to turn the tables on him," he added.

Despite widespread praise for Berry's responses by advocacy groups, Zogby pointed to a more concerning aspect to Berry's exchange with Kennedy, which is the possibility that his comments may have now exposed her to public threats against her, the very reason many advocates felt the need to convene such a hearing.

The Democratic-led Senate Judiciary Committee, which organised Tuesday's hearing, also condemned the senator and called Berry's response to him "powerful."

Rights advocates have warned about rising threats against American Muslims, Arabs and Jews since the eruption of Israel's war on Gaza.

US incidents in recent months include the attempted drowning of a 3-year-old Muslim girl in Texas, the fatal stabbing of a 6-year-old Muslim boy in Illinois, the stabbing of a Muslim man in Texas, the beating of a Muslim man in New York, threats of violence against Jews at Cornell University that led to a conviction and sentencing, and an unsuccessful plot to attack a New York City Jewish centre.




Finland's Stubb calls for UN Security Council reform amid Russia-Ukraine conflict

Finland's President calls for UN Security Council reform, veto abolition, and suspension of members in 'illegal wars'


By REUTERS
SEPTEMBER 18, 2024

Finland's President Alexander Stubb attends the European Political Community meeting at the Blenheim Palace near Oxford, Britain July 18, 2024.
(photo credit: REUTERS/HOLLIE ADAMS)

Finland's President Alexander Stubb has called for expansion of the UN Security Council, abolition of its single state veto power, and suspension of any member engaging in an "illegal war" such as Russia's invasion of Ukraine.

Stubb, who leads the Nordic nation's foreign policy, said he would support reform calls at next week's UN General Assembly in New York, which will discuss the composition of the global body's Security Council.

The council, which consists of five permanent and then rotating member states, is mandated to maintain global peace. Still, geopolitical rivalries have deadlocked it on issues ranging from Ukraine to Gaza.

In an interview on Tuesday, Stubb said he would propose expanding the number of permanent members from five to 10, with one more from Latin America, two from Africa, and two from Asia.

"No single state should have veto power in the UN Security Council," he told Reuters.

The US, Russia, China, France, and Britain are among five nations with veto power. It has also backed two permanent seats for Africa.

Delegates react to the voting results during the United Nations General Assembly vote on a draft resolution that would recognize the Palestinians as qualified to become a full UN member, in New York City, US May 10, 2024. (credit: Eduardo Munoz/Reuters)

Stubb said any member engaging in an illegal war, "such as Russia is in right now in Ukraine," should be kicked off.

Moscow has justified its invasion of Ukraine by saying it is creating a buffer against Western aggression and taking territory that is historically Russia's.
Backing Ukraine

Stubb said he knew his Security Council proposals were "beyond what is usually said from small member states" but added that the big nations would otherwise not propose weakening their own influence.

"So they talk the talk but don't walk the walk," he said, hoping others would help take the plan forward by the UN's 80th birthday next year.

Any changes to Security Council membership need approval by two-thirds of the General Assembly, including the five veto powers.

"My basic message is that if countries from the global South, Latin America, Africa, and Asia do not get agency in the system, they will turn their backs on the United Nations. And that we do not want," he said.

The former Finnish prime minister and European parliamentarian, who took office in March as president, urged support for Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy, who will address the UN assembly about his "victory plan.

"He has informed us that 90% is already there, and the 10% that he will present is what will be needed for him to win this war," Stubb said.

He urged Western nations to lift restrictions on the use of donated arms that leave Ukraine "with one hand tied behind its back."

"We need to let that hand go and allow Ukraine to do what Russia is doing to it," he said.

Stubb did not give credence to Russian President Vladimir Putin's threats of nuclear escalation. "Last time we saw Putin using aggressive language on nuclear weapons, the global South and China basically told Putin to stop," he said.
Reporting on corruption being passed off as criminal defamation

Nigeria|Free Expression & the Law

Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ)

17 September 2024



People queue to vote during an election, at a polling station in Bauchi, capital of Bauchi state, nothern Nigeria,
TONY KARUMBA/AFP via Getty Images

"WikkiTimes" journalists Haruna Mohammed Salisu and Yawale Adamu face the prospect of a prison sentence for their accountability journalism.

This statement was originally published on cpj.org on 16 September 2024.

Authorities in Nigeria should discontinue criminal proceedings against journalists Haruna Mohammed Salisu and Yawale Adamu, of the privately owned WikkiTimes news site, and reform laws that criminalize the press, the Committee to Protect Journalists said Monday.

“Nigerian journalists must be allowed to investigate allegations of corruption without fear of imprisonment,” said CPJ Africa Program Coordinator Muthoki Mumo, in Nairobi. “The criminal proceedings against WikkiTimes journalists Haruna Mohammed Salisu and Yawale Adamu should never have ended up in court and should be discontinued without delay.”

Adamu, a reporter, is set to be arraigned on September 17 at a court in the northern Bauchi state on charges of criminal defamation, injurious falsehood, and mischief, in a case privately prosecuted by a businessman, Abubakar Abdullahi, according to the journalist, WikkiTimes lawyer Idrees Gambo, and a charge sheet reviewed by CPJ.

Gambo told CPJ that Salisu, the outlet’s publisher, who is currently outside of Nigeria, is facing the same charges and that on September 3, the court had issued an arrest warrant for him. The defamation and falsehood charges each carry a sentence of up to five years, with a term of up to two years for mischief, according to the Bauchi state penal code. The journalists would also face an unspecified fine if convicted.

The charges emanate from an April 16 report alleging that a federal lawmaker from Bauchi state, Mansur Manu Soro, colluded with the businessman to fraudulently divert public funds.

Abdullahi told CPJ in a phone interview that he was aware of the court case, but he denied instituting the proceedings.

CPJ’s September 16 calls and messages for comment on the charges to Soro went unanswered.
Saudi oil giant spends well over a billion on ‘sportswashing,’ new report says

Fossil-fuel companies are the new patrons of Big Sport, according to think tank New Weather Institute.

Saudi state-controlled oil giant Aramco, one of the world's most profitable firms, is pouring around $1.3 billion into the global sports industry. | Shawn Thew/EFE via EPA


September 18, 2024 
By Federica Di Sario and Giovanna Coi


Saudi Arabia is spending more than a billion dollars to sponsor global sporting events as it looks to burnish its reputation and assert itself as a global superpower, according to a new report out Wednesday.

The report by think tank New Weather Institute revealed that oil giant Aramco, a Saudi state-controlled company and one of the world's most profitable firms, is pouring around $1.3 billion into the global sports industry, leveraging a playbook widely employed by Big Tobacco before it was banned from doing so.

The findings come as the just-concluded Paris 2024 Olympics shed light on the extent to which climate change, primarily caused by the burning of oil, gas and coal, is already affecting the health and performances of athletes.

“Petrostates are betting on sports sponsorship to sell tourism and business opportunities in their countries, but also to sell the idea that their countries can offer something just like the West,” said Madeleine Orr, an assistant professor of sport ecology at the University of Toronto and the author of Warming Up: How Climate Change Is Changing Sport.

Since 2016, when Riyadh launched its strategic “Vision 2030,” a roadmap setting out how Saudi Arabia could diversify its oil-reliant economy to remain competitive in the long run, the Gulf country has become a regular host of international sporting events. Saudi Arabia will likely stage the 2034 FIFA World Cup and could also throw its hat into the ring to host the Summer Olympic Games in 2036.

Experts use the term “sportswashing” to refer to the sponsoring of an athlete or a major sporting event with the intention of distracting world attention from unethical practices such as human rights abuses and corruption scandals.

The huge Aramco figure doesn't include further huge sums that Saudi Arabia's Public Investment Fund is spending separately on sports.

Riyadh, for its part, isn't particularly bothered by the accusations.

“If sportswashing is going to increase my GDP by 1 percent, then we’ll continue sportswashing,” Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman said bluntly in an interview last year, rebuffing accusations that the country was using positive associations with hugely popular sports to distract from its core business: fossil fuel extraction.

A global trend

Aramco isn’t alone in pouring mammoth sums into global sports events aiming to legitimize its fossil fuel production and market its products to millions of sports fans.

Including Aramco, top fossil-fuel firms like TotalEnergies and Shell and petrochemical giant Ineos have together injected “at least” $5.6 billion through 205 active sponsorship deals, the report calculated. Most of the deals remain opaque, however, so their exact amounts, duration and conditions are unknown.

“Sportswashing isn't new,” Orr said, noting the practice was developed by Western oil companies to head off potential uprisings in local communities that were grappling with worker rights and public safety.

“For decades, sports have been a very effective tool for selling things, from sports drinks to shoes, flights to cereal,” she added.

According to the study, the sports that attract the largest sums include football, motor sports, rugby union and golf.

To crack down on sportswashing, the authors of the report implored sports organizations like world football governing body FIFA and the International Olympic Committee to introduce tobacco-like bans on sponsorship from fossil fuel firms. They should also ensure that the green credentials of future donors are scrutinized, the authors said.

“If sport is used as a billboard to promote the very companies, products and lifestyles that fuel climate breakdown, it becomes at best an obstacle to climate action, and at worst fans the flames of a heating planet,” the report stressed.
US urges Western states to reject UN draft resolution on Israeli occupation, reparations

The US previously vetoed a resolution in April which called for the State of Palestine to be granted full UN member status.


The New Arab Staff
17 September, 2024

Palestine recently took up a seat in the UN General Assembly as an observer member state [Getty]

The US is urging its allies to reject a new UN resolution calling on Israel to withdraw from the occupied West Bank and Gaza.

The draft resolution, set to be put forward by the State of Palestine, calls for Israel to unconditionally withdraw from the occupied territories, including Israeli settlers, and pay reparations to Palestinians.

According to Sky News Australia, the US has condemned the draft resolution and is calling on Australia and other Western allies to either reject or abstain from the vote.

Australia's shadow foreign minister also urged the government to reject the motion, saying it would be counterproductive to peace between Israel and Palestine.

In comments made to Sky News Australia, Simon Birmingham said "with such a counterproductive and one-sided motion, the decision for the Albanese government should be clear cut".

According to Ibtisam Azem, the UN correspondent for The New Arab's sister publication Al-Araby Al-Jadeed, Palestinian Ambassador to the UN Riyad Mansour said the draft was done in consultation with other countries.

Mansour added that the resolution was part of taking steps to end the occupation of the Palestinian Territories, as well as stopping international support for Israel, such as through arms deals.

Last week, the State of Palestine took its seat at the UN General Assembly as a permanent observer member state, giving its representatives new rights in the UN.

The draft resolution, which is eight pages long, is set to be debated on Thursday and includes several items.

Included is the demand for the withdrawal of Israeli forces in the occupied Palestinian Territories, including East Jerusalem within 12 months of the passing of the resolution.

It also calls for the evacuation of all Israeli settlers and the dismantling of part of the wall surrounding the occupied West Bank.

Likewise, all properties, lands and assets seized by Israel since 1967 should be returned, as well as displaced Palestinians.

Additionally, the resolution calls for the imposition of sanctions on Israel and on individuals involved in maintaining the occupation on the Palestinian territories.

In June, the International Court of Justice ruled that Israel's occupation of the West Bank is illegal and amounts to apartheid.

 

Rights organizations urge UN member states to enforce ICJ advisory opinion on Israel
Rights organizations urge UN member states to enforce ICJ advisory opinion on Israel

A coalition of humanitarian, development and human rights organizations urged all UN member states on Tuesday to adhere to the International Court of Justice’s (ICJ) advisory opinion on the unlawfulness of Israel’s occupation of Palestinian territory. This comes as the UN General Assembly prepares to vote on a resolution to end the occupation.

The organizations highlighted the humanitarian consequences of Israel’s occupation, including the use of weapons by Israeli forces and settlers resulting in civilian casualties and disabilities, arbitrary detention and prosecution of Palestinians in Israeli military courts, forced displacement through home demolitions and Israeli settlement expansion and a discriminatory permit regime denying Palestinians freedom of movement and access to basic services. The organizations wrote:

These practices have taken place without accountability for decades, but the intensification over the last 11 months has led to a staggering humanitarian catastrophe for Palestinians throughout the occupied Palestinian territory, fueled by the virtually unconditional supply of weapons, parts [] and ammunition.

The organizations urged all governments, including UN Security Council members, to adhere to the ICJ’s advisory opinion, which suggests states halt the transfer and sale of weapons and ammunition to Israel. They stressed that failure to adhere to the opinion would undermine international law and institutions.

In July, the ICJ issued an advisory opinion concluding that Israel’s decades-long occupation and annexation of Palestinian territory violates fundamental tenets of International Humanitarian Law (IHL) and denies Palestinians human rights. The ICJ also stated that all states must refrain from recognizing the legality of Israel’s presence in the Occupied Palestinian Territory and avoid rendering aid or assistance to Israel.

The UN General Assembly is expected to vote on a draft resolution introduced by Palestine on Thursday at 11:00 AM local time, demanding an end to the occupation within one year.

The draft resolution, co-sponsored by 30 countries, outlines key demands and actions based on the ICJ’s advisory opinion. It calls for Israel to end its unlawful presence in the Occupied Palestinian Territory within 12 months, withdraw all military forces, cease all settlement activities, evacuate all settlers and make reparations for damages caused. The resolution also urges all states to comply with their obligations under international law, such as refusing to recognize the legality of Israel’s presence in the occupied territories and distinguishing between Israel and the occupied Palestinian territory. Additionally, it calls for the establishment of an international mechanism for reparations and the convening of a Conference of High Contracting Parties to the Fourth Geneva Convention. The resolution emphasizes the need for accountability for serious international crimes and requests the Secretary-General to report on the implementation of these measures within three months.

During the Assembly’s 10th emergency special session, Lebanon’s ambassador Hadi Hachem supported the draft resolution but questioned whether Israel would respect and implement it if adopted. Iran’s ambassador Amir Saeid Iravani emphasized that Israel should cease its unlawful presence in the occupied Palestinian territory and stop all settlement activity immediately. South Africa’s representative called on those with influence over Israel to “exert real pressure” to stop the war.

Before voting on the draft resolution, the UN General Assembly is set to hear from additional member states, including South Africa and China.

UN to demand Israel end 'unlawful' presence in Palestinian territories within 12 months


Palestinians walk past the rubble of houses destroyed during the Israeli military offensive, amid Israel-Hamas conflict, in Khan Younis in the southern Gaza Strip, July 10, 2024.
PHOTO: Reuters file

PUBLISHED ON  September 18, 2024 

UNITED NATIONS — The United Nations General Assembly will on Wednesday (Sept 18) adopt a Palestinian-draughted resolution that demands Israel end "its unlawful presence in the Occupied Palestinian Territory" within 12 months.

The action will isolate Israel days before world leaders travel to New York for their annual UN gathering. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is due to address the 193-member General Assembly on Sept 26, the same day as Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas.

The draught resolution aims to welcome a July advisory opinion by the International Court of Justice that said Israel's occupation of Palestinian territories and settlements is illegal and should be withdrawn.

The advisory opinion — by the highest United Nations court also known as the World Court — said this should be done "as rapidly as possible", although the draught General Assembly resolution allows for a 12-month timeline.

The draught resolution is the first to be formally put forward by the Palestinian Authority since it gained additional rights and privileges this month including a seat among UN members in the assembly hall and the right to propose draught resolutions.

US Ambassador to the UN Linda Thomas-Greenfield urged countries to vote no on Wednesday. Washington — an ally of Israel — has long opposed unilateral measures that undermine the prospect of a two-state solution.

The ICJ advisory opinion is not binding but carries weight under international law and may weaken support for Israel. A General Assembly resolution also is not binding, but carries political weight. There is no veto power in the assembly.

"Each country has a vote, and the world is watching us," Palestinian UN Ambassador Riyad Mansour told the General Assembly on Tuesday. "Please stand on the right side of history. With international law. With freedom. With peace."

Israel's UN Ambassador Danny Danon criticised the General Assembly on Tuesday for failing to condemn the Oct 7, 2023 attack on Israel by Palestinian Hamas militants that sparked Israel's assault on the Hamas-run Gaza Strip.

He rejected the draught Palestinian text, saying: "Let's call this for what it is: This resolution is diplomatic terrorism, using the tools of diplomacy not to build bridges but to destroy them."

Israel captured the West Bank, Gaza Strip and East Jerusalem — areas of historic Palestine which the Palestinians want for a state — in the 1967 Middle East war and has since built settlements in the West Bank and steadily expanded them.

The war in the Gaza Strip began on Oct 7, 2023, when Hamas gunmen stormed into Israeli communities, killing around 1,200 people and abducting about 250 hostages, according to Israeli tallies.

Since then, Israel's military has levelled swaths of the Palestinian enclave, driving nearly all of its 2.3 million people from their homes, giving rise to deadly hunger and disease and killing more than 41,000 people, according to Palestinian health authorities.

The General Assembly on Oct 27 called for an immediate humanitarian truce in Gaza with 120 votes in favour. Then in December, 153 countries voted to demand — instead of calling for — an immediate humanitarian ceasefire in December.

A two-thirds majority of those present and voting — abstentions don't count — is needed to pass the draught resolution on Wednesday.

Mansour told reporters on Mondays that while he expected the draught text to be adopted, it would likely be with less support than received by the resolutions last year.

The Palestinian Authority represents the Palestinian people at the UN, where it is a non-member observer state and the delegation is known as the State of Palestine.