Showing posts sorted by relevance for query 2021 BEST SUMMER EVER. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query 2021 BEST SUMMER EVER. Sort by date Show all posts

Sunday, September 05, 2021

YIPPEE-KI-YAY! KENNEY GOVERNMENT EXEMPTS WEEKEND RODEOS FROM A FEEBLE COVID-19 RULE


JASON KENNEY CELEBRATES THE BEST SUMMER EVER ™ AT THE CALGARY STAMPEDE IN JULY 
(PHOTO: CHRIS SCHWARZ, GOVERNMENT OF ALBERTA).

Alberta Politics

DAVID CLIMENHAGA
POSTED ON SEPTEMBER 05, 2021

Friday’s jaw-dropping “Kenney Pennies” announcement may have included a few feeble temporary measures to slow surging COVID-19 infection rates and ease the strain on the fraying health care system, but it took less than 24 hours for word to leak the Alberta government has created special exemptions for rodeos.

So while as of yesterday restaurants, cafes, bars, pubs, nightclubs and the like were required to stop serving alcohol at 10 p.m., it turns out rodeo beer gardens will be allowed to go on serving till 2 a.m.


Alberta culture, as imagined by that old Ottawa hand, Mr. Kenney (Photo: Originator not identified).

Yesterday morning, sharp-eyed Facebookers spotted Airdrie Pro Rodeo cheerfully announcing “the Provincial Government has granted us an exception for our FCA Rodeo September 4th & 5th. Therefore beer gardens will carry on as usual and will be open until 2am.”

As this is written, presumably, rodeo goers in the bedroom community of 70,000 north of Calgary, where the full vaccination rate is said to be well under 60 per cent, have lots of time to chug more beers and celebrate the infectious end of Alberta’s Best Summer Ever ™.

Similar exemptions were soon discovered at other Alberta weekend rodeos in Ponoka, Rockyford, and Benalto. This being Alberta, there are likely more.

But that’s just the way we roll here in Wild Rose Country.

If you’re a friend of the United Conservative Party, or better yet a Friend of Kenney (FOK), you don’t have to phone up and beg for an exemption. Someone will phone you.

And if there aren’t any exemptions, restrictions tend to be timed to take place after events the premier wants to happen – and Mr. Kenney loves rodeo. (What’s with that, anyway? Is it because he spent so many years in Ottawa he thinks that’s the real Alberta?)


Indeed, it was Mr. Kenney’s determination to reopen in time for the Calgary Stampede in July that is credited for some of the current Delta-variant-fuelled coronavirus surge that has ICU occupancy at 95 per cent province-wide. And God forbid, as Mr. Kenney put it in Friday’s news conference at which he announced those $100 gift cards for tardy vaccine recipients, that we should ever have to re-close!


Progress Alberta’s Jim Storrie (Photo: David J. Climenhaga).

If you’re not an FOK, it can be a little harder to get permission to break the rules, but not impossible.

CTV Calgary reporter Timm Bruch tweeted last night that Alberta Health “reached out” to Calgary Pride, which had been denied a liquor licence under the new restrictions, to advise them they too had an exemption to serve alcohol into the wee hours last night and tonight.

Needless to say, these exemptions may make political sense, but they don’t make any sense from a public health perspective. Alas, as has become increasingly evident over the past year, the office of Alberta’s chief medical officer of health is now a political office.

As the Progress Report’s Jim Storrie asked yesterday, “You ever hear that bit about how conservatism is all about defining one group that has to obey the law but isn’t protected by it and another group that gets protected by the law but doesn’t have to obey it?”

Well, that’s Alberta in a beer glass.

Meanwhile, COVID infection rates and chronic understaffing has Alberta Health Services so far behind the 8-ball it’s admitted to signing deals with staffing agencies to hire contract nurses from other provinces to address staff shortages in Alberta hospitals.

The admission came in the form of an email to the labour relations director of United Nurses of Alberta, which represents more than 30,000 Alberta nurses, conceding that AHS did intend to hire contract nurses during the fourth wave of the pandemic.

By the way, the email said, AHS will be dropping its August labour board complaint in which it accused the union of bargaining in bad faith by saying AHS was using staffing agencies to hire contract nurses and planning to pay them more than UNA members are paid now.

In its current negotiations with UNA for a new collective agreement, AHS is demanding pay cuts of 3 per cent from every one of its RNs and RPNs!

You’d almost think, at a time like this, it would make more sense to stop trying to cut nurses’ pay and keep making bars close early!

Three rodeos granted exemption to 10 p.m. liquor sales curfew not long after those rules were unveiled.

Author of the article: Brodie Thomas
Publishing date: Sep 04, 2021 • 
CALGARY HERALD
 
Three Alberta rodeos were granted exemptions to new temporary limits on the sale of alcohol after 10 p.m. 
PHOTO BY NICOLE BENGIVENO /NYT

Three rodeos received exemptions from new COVID-19 public health restrictions limiting alcohol sales, not long after those rules were unveiled.

Health Minister Tyler Shandro announced Friday a curfew on liquor sales in licensed establishments after 10 p.m., part of rules and recommendations meant to quell the spread of COVID-19 during this current fourth wave.

Ponoka Mayor Rick Bonnett said the provincial government found his town and others a “grey area” that allowed them to avoid the newly implemented liquor sales limits for its long weekend rodeos.

Bonnett said the Ponoka’s Stampede was already hampered earlier this summer because it was set to take place just before the July 1 reopening. Organizers moved it to the Labour Day long weekend.

“We put together the (event), and here on Friday at noon the government and Alberta Health comes out with the shutdown again, after ticket sales had been done,” he said.

Bonnett said the Saturday night concert following the chuckwagon races is a popular event, and stopping alcohol sales in the middle would not have been ideal.

“I think we’d incite a riot if we told people at 10 o’clock, halfway through a concert, that the bar was closing. I don’t think we want to see what could happen with 3,000 or 4,000 people getting upset.”

Bonnett reached out to his area MLA, Ron Orr, and was told special event licences were not on the order signed by chief medical officer of health Dr. Deena Hinshaw on Friday.

“The cabinet committee obviously was contacted,” said Bonnett. “We are basically going off what Alberta Health said — that they didn’t have special events listed in there.”

But Hinshaw’s order specifically lists “Special Event Licenses” under heading 5.4, noting persons who hold these licences are prohibited from selling liquor after 10 p.m.

In an emailed statement, an Alberta Health spokesperson said selected once-a-year events have been granted a public interest exemption over the course of the pandemic, adding these exemptions are not new.

“Exemptions are granted due to the event’s importance to the local economy and community,” read the statement. “Current exemptions are all for open-air events. Each event is considered individually, and mask requirements continue to apply to any indoor component.”

Alberta Health said three exemptions were granted — for the Ponoka rodeo, the Airdrie Rodeo, and the Cochrane rodeo.

When reached by Postmedia Saturday afternoon, organizers of the Cochrane Lions Club Rodeo said in an email they were not granted an exemption and would be following the new COVID-19 rules.

Two rodeos not mentioned by Alberta Health — Daines Ranch Pro Rodeo near Innisfail and Benalto Agricultural Society’s rodeo — both posted on their Facebook pages they had approval to ignore the 10 p.m. liquor curfew.

Bonnett noted the Ponoka Stampede is a huge event in his town, with many business owners relying on the event to break even in a fiscal year. He also said money from the admission to the Stampede goes back into the community and not-for-profit organizations that provide volunteers to work at the event.

“I’m thankful to the government for at least finding us a grey area for the weekend, and I don’t think anyone wants to be law-breaking citizens here,” said Bonnett.

However, Calgary business owner Chris Hewitt said he’s been left scrambling to cancel or reschedule Calgary Pride events he had planned at his establishment, Dickens Pub.

Chris Hewitt, owner of Dickens Pub, poses for a photo inside the bar in this file photo from Nov. 2020. 
PHOTO BY BRENDAN MILLER/POSTMEDIA

“We don’t get any exemptions,” said Hewitt. “Nobody is coming to us with these options.”

He said he felt angry and defeated after hearing about the rodeos’ exemptions. He’s also baffled at how they could get their exemptions so quickly.

“Anybody who’s applied for things from the government knows that they do not turn around in the space of a few hours,” said Hewitt.

He feels it was the rush to reopen for another rodeo event — The Calgary Stampede — that has contributed to this fourth wave.

“All the wrong people are getting rewarded all the time for this behaviour,” said Hewitt.

Friday, September 03, 2021

The political consequences of Kenney's 4th-wave vacation

Alberta premier hasn't been seen by the public in weeks, leaving a vacuum filled with critics and concern

Premier Jason Kenney addresses Albertans about COVID-19 on May 5, 2021, not long before his government declared the province 'open for business' for summer. The premier hasn't been seen by the public in weeks as a fourth wave grips the province. (Andrew Peloso/VEK/Alberta Newsroom)

In Alberta, COVID-19 hospitalizations are up, case counts are up, and anxiety, too. Schools are reopening, some workplaces are returning, vaccinations are lagging. "Best Summer Ever" hats, meanwhile, are still for sale on the United Conservative Party website. 

And there sits an empty podium. 

Taking a casual stroll through social media in Alberta these days, it's hard to ignore a common question: Where is Jason Kenney? Why has the premier been silent in public since Aug. 9, as the delta-driven fourth wave of the pandemic surged? 

The absence appears, for all intents and purposes, to be a direct refutation of everything that's known about communications in a crisis: Get out front, be clear, calm people down, empathize, never leave a vacuum. 

But does it matter? 

Without a guiding voice, citizens, businesses and organizations are left to fill a void, with their own policies and procedures, their own personal decisions or their own misinformation. There are many questions that have been left unanswered in the absence, including the rationale for lifting almost all COVID-19 restrictions this summer. 

Critics of the government have also filled the space left by the premier, ministers and the chief medical officer of health and the message has spiralled well out of the government's control. 

So why then has the premier been missing in action?

Where is Kenney?

Kenney's office says he was simply on a well-deserved vacation and that he was in constant contact with officials. On Wednesday, the office said he had returned to work. It's not known where the premier was.

It was a similar argument laid out by Finance Minister Travis Toews on Tuesday as he spoke to reporters after presenting the province's fiscal update. 

Kenney's last public appearance was 23 days ago, on Aug. 9, when he announced an expansion to the Labatt's brewing plant in Edmonton expected to create 25 jobs. (Alberta Newsroom)

"There has been communication, daily communication around the pandemic and I have full confidence in our chief medical officer of health and our health minister to, at the appropriate time, make themselves available for the press," he said.

"Look, we're in the fourth wave at this point in time. The delta variant is very contagious. Cases are going up. That wasn't unexpected at this point in time."

Kenney's office has not yet responded to questions for this article.

It's hard to argue with the need for a vacation. The premier is not known to be lazy and the pace of the pandemic would be gruelling for any leader. Give the guy a break. 

But it's also hard to understand the timing of it all, or why there hasn't been a minister who stepped up to answer questions for the premier. 

In an article on crisis communication and COVID for doctors published last year by the journal Clinical Infectious Diseases, the authors argued that emotional responses to pandemic public health measures require a steady communicative hand.

As the public tires of uncertainty tied to a novel virus, that becomes even more important. 

"This uncertainty can again increase anxiety, stress and fear, causing the public to dismiss risk altogether, or become angry about mitigation strategies," they wrote. 

"Communicating actionable steps for the public to take can help to reduce this anxiety and fear by increasing a sense of agency and personal control."

Without a guiding hand, the vacuum gets filled.

Crisis communication and the vacuum

In the absence of briefings or public appearances by either Kenney or the chief medical officer of health, Dr. Deena Hinshaw, a group called ProtectOurProvince, which includes physicians critical of the government's pandemic response, has sprung up to offer regular updates. 

Hinshaw has not made a public appearance since Aug. 13, when she delayed the province's plans to lift testing, tracing and isolation measures until at least Sept. 27. 

"We really don't have very far to go before the [health-care] system is completely overloaded, not just because of the number of cases but because of burnout," Dr. Ilan Schwartz of ProtectOurProvince said Monday. 

"I've never seen my colleagues in the ICU more despondent in the last week … in part because this wave is entirely preventable."

Dr. Joe Vipond, who has been critical of the Alberta government's COVID-19 plan, gives a speech to supporters gathered in front of the Foothills hospital. He is part of a group of doctors that have started regular COVID briefings. (Rachel Maclean/CBC)

It's not the kind of message a government would usually allow to dominate the headlines without a response. 

It's also just one side of the coin. 

"The thing is, their absence is not just leaving a void with the pro-vaccination people, it is also leaving a void with the anti-vaccination people," said Janet Brown, a Calgary-based pollster who runs Janet Brown Opinion Research.

She points to the City of Edmonton bringing back a mask mandate and the Calgary Flames requiring proof of vaccination for spectators as two examples of changes being implemented without the province. 

"I mean, if I'm an anti-vaxxer, am I happy that Jason Kenney is not responding to that?" she said.

The opening for critics is especially hard to understand in the context of who Kenney is. 

"Everything I know about politics and Jason Kenney is that Jason Kenney loves the battle, right?" said David Taras, professor of communications studies at Calgary's Mount Royal University.  

"He loves this smoke of war, right? He loves to be engaged and he loves the headlines. And not to be there? Not to be on the field of battle? Very strange."

That's not to say there isn't plenty of speculation as to why.

Why?

Sifting through the theories as to why the premier has been so quiet, some percolate to the top. Chief among them is that Kenney is so unpopular and controversial at this time that either he is maintaining, or has been asked to maintain, a low profile during the tight federal election campaign. 

Kenney has held the lowest approval rating of any premier throughout much of the pandemic and the UCP has trailed the NDP of late in both polls and fundraising.

Brown argues the downside of that keep-away strategy for Kenney far outweighs any positive impact it could have.

There has been speculation that Jason Kenney, right, is keeping a low profile to boost the chances of Conservative Party of Canada Leader Erin O'Toole, left, during a tight federal election campaign. (Ryan Remiorz/The Canadian Press, Chris Schwarz/Government of Alberta)

Taras says he can't account for what goes on within the federal Conservative Party, but there would likely be people who would want Kenney to stay out of the picture. Or perhaps Kenney is worried about internal ideological battles within his own UCP.

"The only logic that I can think of is that they don't know what to do, that they're paralyzed," said Taras.

"That they've just sort of trapped themselves in a series of decisions. That he can't get out of that. That he's played his cards poorly, that he's lost the public trust and doesn't know how to regain it."

In June, shortly before his government removed most public health restrictions, Kenney said they did not expect to see a scenario where case counts rose dramatically. His government opened quickly, removed restrictions ahead of any other province and pushed hard to turn the page on the pandemic. 

"If we see any unforeseen circumstances, we will respond to those in due course," he said in June. 

The lack of response and the perception his government is paralyzed could have political consequences for the leader and his party.

The consequences

Brown hasn't conducted any recent polls she can point to that might indicate the impact of Kenney's vacation, but she says she conducted focus groups on Monday night and nobody had anything positive to say about the premier. 

"I was hearing really, really harsh language," she said. 

"But what was so surprising was I was hearing harsh language from people who I would have, in another period in time, expected a more sympathetic tone toward the premier and a conservative party."

It's a snapshot that fits into a larger picture of a party and a leader that are struggling to maintain the support that launched them into government in 2019. 

These are the Best Summer Ever Hats being sold on the United Conservative Party's website for a 'limited time only.' (unitedconservative.ca)

Politics is, after all, a profession of self-promotion and image control. When things get tough, the leader appears with sleeves rolled up, ideally with a hint of crust in the eyes to suggest a sleepless night of policy debates.

When critics attack, you refute, you fight, you defend or demur, but you try to control the message. 

In the middle of a pandemic, you speak to the citizens impacted by every uptick in cases.

Without those responses, the message gets away from you and building trust becomes increasingly difficult.  

"For a government to have gone silent for three weeks, in the middle of a health crisis is ... I can't even come up with a parallel that's even close," said Brown. 

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Drew Anderson is a web journalist at CBC Calgary. Like almost every journalist working today, he's won a few awards. He's also a third-generation Calgarian. You can follow him on Twitter @drewpanderson. Contact him in confidence at drew.anderson@cbc.ca. Signal contact upon request. CBC Secure Drop: www.cbc.ca/securedrop/


Welcome back to your political problems, Jason Kenney

Twenty-three days.

That’s how long Albertans went without seeing their premier, Jason Kenney, in the flesh as a 4th wave of COVID hit Alberta.

Then suddenly, without any advance warning, Kenney appeared live on Facebook Wednesday night where he took selected questions sent in online from the public.

He made no apology for being away so long, saying he had been on vacation recharging his batteries. He scoffed at critics who complained he has been in hiding since August 9 when he made his last public appearance – and mockingly pointed out he was “hiding in plain view” Wednesday by being on Facebook Live.

Mind you, he could pick and choose the questions on Facebook where he didn’t have to deal with irritating journalists who have a habit of asking followup questions.

Kenney said the 4th wave is a “wave of the unvaccinated” and the COVID Delta variant tends to attack the unvaccinated elderly and although some children might be getting sick, none have died.

You have to think his performance isn’t going to placate his critics.

Kenney’s whereabouts have been the topic of rumour and speculation for weeks.

His office had announced he was on a two-week-long vacation. Considering that Kenney disappeared August 9 – more than three weeks ago –  it would seem time runs at a different pace for Kenney than for the rest of us.

With apologies to Einstein, call it the Special Theory of Political Relativity, where even reality moves differently.

Kenney seemed to be living in an alternative world where Alberta’s economy opened “for good” on July 1, where Albertans have enjoyed their “best summer ever,” where there is no worrying fourth wave of COVID, and where nobody is wondering where in heck their premier disappeared to.

Either that, or Kenney was so painfully aware that, in his rush to drop restrictions and open the economy two months ago, he managed to launch a fourth wave in Alberta that is, per capita, the worst in the country. In that scenario he was in hiding figuring out how to explain himself to Albertans.

At the same time, he’s become so politically toxic for Conservatives across the country that Erin O’Toole and the Conservative Party of Canada would happily launch the premier into orbit for the duration of the federal election campaign.

A few of Kenney’s cabinet colleagues have made appearances, including Finance Minister Travis Toews who on Tuesday announced government revenues are projected to be up by $11 billion this year – and the deficit is projected to drop by almost $8 billion.

The good news is oil prices are up. The bad news is the Alberta government continues to rely on volatile oil prices to save the day.

Being the only cabinet minister available, Toews couldn’t avoid questions from reporters about why neither Kenney, nor Health Minister Tyler Shandro, nor the province’s medical officer, Dr. Deena Hinshaw, has held a news conference in weeks to explain the government’s COVID plan. In the face of an information vacuum, municipalities and school boards have been forced to come up with their own plans.

The City of Edmonton, for example, is re-invoking a mandatory mask mandate for indoor public spaces on Friday.

“We have not kept anybody in the dark,” said Toews, who pointed out Hinshaw has been issuing regular tweets updating Covid numbers. But Twitter hardly seems like a suitable means of communicating with the public when 1,000 people a day are contracting COVID. More than 400 are in hospital and more than 100 of those are in ICU.

Yes, everyone is entitled to a vacation — including Kenney, Shandro, and Hinshaw, who’ve been front and centre for the past 18 months. But it beggars belief to think they couldn’t have nominated a deputy to hold news conferences to take questions and provide answers.

Kenney’s absence from the federal campaign is no doubt frustrating for him, especially when he loves to bash Liberal leader Justin Trudeau, but it is an understandable tactic when Trudeau is eager to use the unpopular Kenney as a whipping boy and a stand-in for O’Toole.

The good news for the federal Conservatives who, when the campaign began, faced losing four seats in Alberta (two in Edmonton and two in Calgary) to a relatively popular Liberal party. Now, with Trudeau’s prospects faltering nationally and O’Toole’s chances blossoming, Liberals could be completely shut out of Alberta as they were in 2019.

However, Kenney’s lengthy absence during the fourth wave of the pandemic will be more difficult for him to justify, and could further erode the public’s confidence in a premier whose popularity has fallen from a high of 60 per cent in 2019 to about 30 per cent now.

Kenney is back in the office and speaking to the public – but in a carefully crafted appearance online.

He has yet to face the news media who tend to be more difficult to handle than written questions on Facebook.

And he has yet to face the ballooning problems plaguing Alberta as the province is hit yet again by the worst COVID wave in Canada.

 

Kenney's vacation is over, but his political troubles aren't

Premier is back in the office but questions linger about his 23-day absence

Alberta Premier Jason Kenney speaks at a news conference Aug. 9 in Edmonton. (Janet French/CBC)
This column is an opinion from Graham Thomson, an award-winning journalist who
has covered Alberta politics for more than 30 years.

OK, now what?

Now that Premier Jason Kenney has poked his head over the ramparts via a Facebook live appearance Wednesday night, what will he do about the worrying fourth wave of COVID?

Other than trying to gaslight us as he did during his Facebook performance where he suggested it was no big deal that he hadn't been seen for 23 days as COVID-19 cases skyrocketed in Alberta and Justin Trudeau called a federal election.

"I don't think people taking a bit of personal time should be a political football," said Kenney who explained he was simply on vacation. His critics, though, say he was in hiding.

There's no reason, I suppose, why he couldn't be doing both: vacationing and hiding.

Depending on where he went, it might have been a staycation. But then again, since we don't know much about his trip, call it an obfuscation. Or considering he left no one to answer questions in person about the fourth wave, call it an abdication.

That he chose to avoid the federal election is not in itself a mystery. Down-in-the-polls Kenney has become so politically toxic that if the United Conservative premier turned up on the campaign trail, Conservative Leader Erin O'Toole would have to wear a hazmat suit.

And then there's pandemic. In June, Kenney promised Albertans the "best summer ever" after he announced the province would be dropping pandemic restrictions July 1 and reopening the province "for good."

The delta variant apparently didn't get the memo. Alberta has seen COVID-19 explode to the point the province is averaging 1,000 new cases a day, where Alberta Health Services is postponing surgeries to free beds up for COVID-19 patients, where the City of Edmonton is re-invoking a mandatory mask mandate for public spaces, and where several other provinces – with fewer cases than Alberta – are introducing vaccine passports.

Perhaps Kenney went on vacation to avoid explaining why he prematurely promised Albertans the best summer as he rushed to lift pandemic restrictions July 1.

Albert Health Minister Tyler Shandro and Alberta Premier Jason Kenney unveil an opening sign after speaking about the Open for Summer Plan and next steps in the COVID-19 vaccine rollout, in Edmonton, Friday, June 18, 2021. (Jason Franson/The Canadian Press)

It now seems the province is on track to deliver the worst Autumn ever where experts with British Columbia's COVID-19 Modelling Group are warning that in October, Alberta could see 6,000 people a day contract the virus, with 1,500 in hospital and 500 of those in ICU.

That's a worst-case scenario but it's a scenario that doesn't seem to frighten the government.

'Wasn't unexpected'

On Tuesday, while delivering optimistic news about the province's finances, Finance Minister Travis Toews suggested the government has not been caught off guard by the current numbers: "We're in the fourth wave at this present time and the delta variant is very contagious, cases are going up. That wasn't unexpected at this point in time."

Not "unexpected"? Yet, as the numbers grew, the premier went on vacation while Health Minister Tyler Shandro and the province's chief medical officer of health, Dr. Deena Hinshaw, communicated with the public via tweets. 

I'm not one for conspiracy theories but you have to wonder if critics of the government are on to something when they argue Kenney wants the delta variant to burn itself out by ripping through the unvaccinated.

Lending credence to this theory are comments from the government's caucus chair Nathan Neudorf who, in an interview last week, seemed to suggest he expected and wanted COVID-19 cases to escalate among the unvaccinated and then quickly drop off as the virus has nowhere else to go – as it did, he said, in the United Kingdom.

Except that in the U.K. the numbers quickly began to rise again. 

After facing a public backlash, Neudorf said he was only speaking for himself, not the government, and was hoping cases would simply level off quickly. But his initial comments would certainly help explain why Kenney and others in government disappeared from public view in the last half of August. They were hoping the case numbers, after suddenly spiking, would suddenly drop.

But they keep rising.

After 18 months of COVID-19 during which Kenney's popularity dropped from 60 per cent to 31 per cent he is still caught between urban voters who want more restrictions and rural voters who want fewer or no restrictions.

"If indeed we do see this wave jeopardizing the health-care system, we may have to take some very targeted actions but nothing like lockdowns," Kenney said Wednesday night in an equivocating comment sure to irritate people on both sides of the issue.

Kenney mentioned that Shandro and Hinshaw would hold a news conference later this week. They didn't do that Thursday. So, expect them to face journalists Friday — on the eve of a long weekend, the favoured time for governments to release bad news and then head to the hills.

That won't be a problem for Alberta government politicians and officials who have had plenty of practice the past three weeks running for the hills.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Graham Thomson is an award-winning journalist who has covered Alberta politics for more than 30 years, much of it as an outspoken columnist for the Edmonton Journal. Nowadays you can find his thoughts and analysis on provincial politics Fridays at cbc.ca/edmonton, on CBC Edmonton Television News, during Radio Active on CBC Radio One (93.9FM/740AM) and on Twitter at @gthomsonink.

Sunday, September 19, 2021


TWO & OUT
PETERS: Alberta is a fascinating case study for those who would seek to drop COVID-19 restrictions



Image Credit: The Canadian Press


By James Peters
Sep 17, 2021 | 


ALBERTANS WHO ARE NOT GASPING FOR BREATH in a hospital ICU are likely gasping in shock and horror at what is happening in their province right now.

Consider for a moment, if you will, their plight.

Alberta is in the midst of a real, honest-to-goodness COVID-19 emergency. There is no denying this.


Don’t look at case counts, don’t look at vaccination rates, just look at intensive care admissions for a moment.

As of Thursday, Alberta was seeing 18-to-20 admissions to ICU due to COVID-19 every day and there were 310 ICU beds left in the entire province, including surge beds that have been opened up as a contingency.

Three-quarters of all ICU patients in Alberta have COVID-19. If admissions continue at this rate — and remember, ICU admission spikes lag behind case count spikes — there will be no more ICU space at all in two weeks. Not a single bed.

B.C. has already said it will not be accepting ICU patients from Alberta and Saskatchewan is bracing for its own wave.

Here in our province, the situation is not exactly peachy-keen, but it is measurably better.

What has made the difference? After all, it’s the same virus in both places.

The difference is the speed and enthusiasm in which each province loosened its restrictions over the past few months.

While both provinces opened up significantly, Alberta Premier Jason Kenney flung the doors wide and with reckless abandon.

Restrictions were dropped so dramatically that people couldn’t help but feel it was time to party — at Calgary Stampede, for example, which kicked off the so-called ‘Best Summer Ever.’

Kenney’s UCP even sold merchandise saying ‘Best Summer Ever — Alberta 2021.’

In B.C. and elsewhere, governments were significantly more circumspect.

Albertans, regardless of their personal approaches to COVID-19, should be furious with their provincial leaders.

It will be a miracle if Kenney’s political career survives to the end of the year, let alone until the next election in the spring of 2023.

A line between decisions and consequences has rarely been so straight and so clear.

——

Editor’s Note: This opinion piece reflects the views of its author, and does not necessarily represent the views of CFJC Today or Pattison Media.

Sunday, October 03, 2021

A living nightmare’: Alberta’s former CMOH says current COVID-19 situation was ‘preventable’


by caracampbell
POSTED OCT 3, 2021

Medical devices are seen at Ochsner Medical Center in the New Orleans suburb of Jefferson, La., on Tuesday, Aug.11, 2021. (AP Photo/Stacey Plaisance)

CALGARY (CityNews) ─ Two Alberta doctors are calling the province’s COVID-19 strategy “cold blooded,” and an experiment on the people of Alberta.

Dr. James Talbot, Alberta’s former chief medical officer of health, and Dr. Noel Gibney penned an open letter to the province, saying Albertans have a right to know what the next few months of modelling data looks like.

“You think you’ve fallen asleep, and you’re having this nightmare, and you try to wake up from it, and you can’t,” said Talbot. “It’s like a living nightmare.”



Alberta is dealing with a COVID-19 crisis that has seen well over 1,000 new cases a day for weeks while filling intensive care wards to almost twice normal capacity.

The province’s health delivery agency has had to scramble and reassign staff to handle the surge of intensive care patients far above the normal capacity of 173 beds.

Talbot describes what it’s like watching the COVID-19 situation unfold in Alberta as a medical professional.

“You know, I have friends, family, people I care about who are on the front lines,” he said. “I get a steady stream from them that people don’t seem to understand, and the government doesn’t seem to understand how unbearable this situation is for them.”

In recent days, doctors have called for a swift lockdown or a “firebreak” to immediately reverse the tide of COVID-19 patients.

That would mean a mass shutdown of schools, non-essential businesses and mass gatherings.

Intensive care physicians, emergency ward doctors, the executive of the Alberta Medical Association and the Canadian Medical Association have issued such pleas in recent days.

Talbot says based on the decisions made by the Jason Kenney government, the strategy seems to be to let COVID-19 run its course.

“We think that they should come clean with that and let us know,” said Talbot. “Are they prepared to let this number of people die for two more weeks, two more months, for four more months?”


Other researchers support the open letter, saying it’s important that the models are available for scientific scrutiny and to check for accuracy.

That’s something that didn’t happen before this summer.


“Alberta made mistakes,” said Gosia Gasperowicz, a developmental biologist at the University of Calgary. “The chief medical officer of health (Dr. Deena Hinshaw) and the government had absolutely wrong assumptions. Had they been put under scrutiny, the mistake could have been caught early in the summer. And other scientists could say, ‘hey, you’re assumptions are wrong, let’s not go this way.’”

Added Talbot: “Knowing that it’s all preventable, just makes it more horrible.”


In a statement to CityNews, Alberta Health said: “Recently, the Premier cited Alberta Health Service’s ‘early warning system’, an internal capacity-planning tool. This is not modelling data. It shows a wide range of potential scenarios at a given time, updated constantly based on the latest trends. The worst case informs contingency planning but, as the Premier said, government is working to ensure that does not happen.”

—With files from The Canadian Press


'Cold-blooded' handling of the pandemic, say prominent Alberta doctors in letter taking aim at UCP government


Author of the article: Hamdi Issawi, Anna Junker
Publishing date: Oct 01, 2021
Dr. James Talbot, co-chair of the Edmonton Zone Medical Staff Association strategic COVID committee. Postmedia, file


On Friday, an open letter from prominent Alberta doctors requested the province share its predictive modelling for the fourth wave of a pandemic that’s crippling Alberta’s health-care system, criticizing the government’s “cold-blooded” handling of the pandemic.

Co-written by Dr. James Talbot, Alberta’s former chief medical officer of health, and Dr. Noel Gibney, a former critical care department head for the province’s health authority in Edmonton, the letter questioned the modelling that led the provincial government to previously decline assistance from Newfoundland and Labrador Premier Andrew Furey, which they say is “badly needed and welcome.” Alberta changed its mind Thursday, saying a small team from Newfoundland and Labrador would be heading west to help out in Fort McMurray.

“Like most Albertans, we would like to know how long the fourth wave is going to last, how many more Albertans are projected to die and when we can expect elective surgeries to begin and ICUs to return to normal,” the letter read.

According to predictive modelling from University of Victoria professor Dean Karlen, the letter notes, Alberta’s fourth wave will peak near mid-October, but ICU admissions will continue to increase through to the end of the month.

By failing to share its own predictive modelling, the doctors argue, the government denied Albertans the opportunity to make good decisions and protect themselves.

In sharp contrast to Alberta Premier Jason Kenney’s promise of a “best summer ever,” the letter notes that the deadly fourth wave meant the “last summer ever” for 350 Albertans and more who continue to die from the disease.

The doctors recommend seven medium-term and short-term actions to bring down the province’s case count, including patient transfers to ICU facilities in Ontario, the use of vaccine passports and employment mandates to increase immunizations, renewed contact tracing efforts and measures to prevent indoor transmission.



Even with Alberta’s enhanced ICU capacity, doctors say that the province doesn’t have enough trained professionals to care for critically ill patients, which makes a “fire break” crucial to reducing transmission.

Alberta reported 1,630 new cases of COVID-19 on Friday after 15,857 tests were completed over the last 24 hours for a positivity rate of about 10.3 per cent.

Across the province, there are currently 20,215 active cases of COVID-19, a decrease of 40 from Thursday.

There are 1,066 Albertans hospitalized with the virus, a decrease of 17. Of those, 263 are in intensive care units, which remains unchanged from Thursday.

Fourteen more deaths from COVID-19 raised the provincial death toll to 2,731.

Of Albertans aged 12 and older who are eligible to get a COVID-19 vaccine, 83.8 per cent have received one dose, while 74.5 per cent are fully vaccinated.

About 63 per cent of Alberta’s total population is fully immunized against the virus.

Meanwhile, the third and final winner of Alberta’s $1 million vaccine lottery was announced Friday.

Hayley Hauck, of Sherwood Park, was awarded the prize after her name was drawn from more than 1.9 million entries that were received between June 10 and Sept. 23.

A total of 623 Albertans have received lottery prizes for getting immunized against COVID-19.


Military aid for Alberta to arrive Monday; doctors say provincial ‘fire break’ is more impactful step
Morgan Black 
© THE CANADIAN PRESS/Graham Hughes A member of the Canadian Armed Forces is shown at Residence Villa Val des Arbres a long-term care home in Laval, Que., Sunday, April 19, 2020, as COVID-19 cases rise in Canada and around the world.

Critical care nurses are set to arrive in Alberta on Monday -- reinforcements sent by the Canadian military in an effort to help the province's drowning medical system.

"The Canadian Armed Forces is preparing to provide up to eight critical care nurses to assist in intensive care units in hospitals in Alberta," read a statement from Bill Blair, the minister of public safety and emergency preparedness.

Read more: COVID-19: Edmonton doctor recounts calling woman to share her mom’s dying moments

Just days after saying assistance offered to Alberta by the federal government and Newfoundland and Labrador was not immediately necessary, Premier Jason Kenney announced his province has now agreed to accept help as the health-care system is under “enormous pressure” because of the fourth wave of COVID-19.

Kenney said eight to 10 staff from the Canadian Armed Forces will be coming, likely to CFB Edmonton, along with up to 20 trained staff from the Canadian Red Cross, who will likely be deployed to the hard-hit Red Deer Regional Hospital Centre.

He said his government is in the process of finalizing plans to bring in a medical team from Newfoundland, likely to be deployed to Fort McMurray’s hospital. Alberta Health Services confirmed to Global News the process will likely happen this week.

Read more: COVID-19: Kenney says Alberta to accept help from feds, N.L. as health system under ‘enormous pressure’

“These contributions may help us to staff four or five additional ICU beds,” the premier said, noting that every little bit helps.

"Alberta Health Services is grateful for the assistance of the Canadian Armed Forces and the Canadian Red Cross in providing additional medical personnel to help alleviate the increased pressure on our health system as a result of COVID-19," read a Sunday statement from AHS.

"Specific details of where these medical personnel will be deployed is still being finalized, but it is expected the Canadian Armed Forces will be stationed in Edmonton."

Blair's statement said the initial team will be "in position" by Monday and will seek to confirm where and how the nursing officers will be integrated into the Alberta health-care system.

Read more: Alberta Premier Jason Kenney refused COVID-19 help from N.L. premier

The release said the Canadian Red Cross is planning to provide up to 20 medical professionals with "some intensive care unit experience" to augment or relieve existing staff working in Alberta hospitals.

Dr. Darren Markland, an intensive care physician, said this move does not address the problem of hospitals being overrun and surgeries being an "afterthought."


"This is not a solution. It's appreciated, but we really need to focus our political will on things that will make a difference," he said.

Markland cited the need for a "fire break" -- something major medical groups have been calling for at the provincial level for weeks.

That measure would include the reintroduction of more sweeping restrictions for Albertans.

"If we don't do this soon... what is in my job description for next week is to be involved in looking at making choices for triage," Markland said. "We aren't there yet, but eventually, we are going to pay a price."
'It's not enough'

Danielle Larivee with the United Nurses of Alberta said though she can't give enough thanks to those coming to assist on the front lines, the reality is that there would need to be hundreds of nurses sent to the front lines to make a difference.

"It's very welcome, but it's not enough. We need to stop the flood of ill people into the hospitals," Larivee said. "Our health-care system is actively collapsing."

Read more: COVID-19: Alberta ICU nurse dies as pressure on health-care system continues to mount

A request for federal assistance is initiated when an emergency event overwhelms or threatens to overwhelm the resources of a province or territory and federal government help is needed to support the region.

"The Government Operations Centre is working closely with federal and provincial partners to co-ordinate the federal response to the situation in Alberta," read a release from the federal government.

"Short term, this is appreciated. In the long term, we don't see an end to this with the way it is now. We need to stop community spread," Larivee said.

– With files from Phil Heidenreich