Thursday, March 17, 2022

'Here there is nothing': Yemen's Aden scarred by grinding war

Bullet-riddled homes, buildings turned to rubble and countless pictures of "martyrs": seven years into Yemen's civil war, the interim capital Aden bears the scars of a conflict that shows no signs of abating.

© Saleh Al-OBEIDI The derelict Aden Hotel in Yemeni's southern city on March 3, 2022
© Saleh Al-OBEIDI Yemeni pro-government fighters from the UAE-trained Giants Brigades, drive trhough Ataq city, east of the Red Sea port of Aden, on their way to the frontline facing pro-Iran Huthi fighters, on January 28, 2022

While Aden is now relatively stable, economically the ancient port city has been left on its knees.
© Saleh Al-OBEIDI Yemeni pro-government fighters man a position in Ataq city, the capital of the province of Shabwa, east of the Red Sea port of Aden, on January 18, 2022

Water and electricity are intermittent, serving a population that officials say has tripled to more than three million, as people seek safety from fighting raging elsewhere.

Aden governor Ahmed Lamlas said the outbreak of war in 2015 was a "disaster", leaving the city's infrastructure in ruins.

"We are still suffering from the impacts of war," said Lamlas, who narrowly escaped a deadly car bomb attack in October.

Yemen has a long history of civil war, and was divided into North and South Yemen until 1990.

It descended into brutal conflict again when Iran-backed Huthi rebels launched a military campaign to seize power in 2014, taking large swathes of territory including the capital Sanaa in the north.

- Saudi intervention -

The following year, after a Saudi-led military coalition intervened to support the internationally recognised government, the insurgents were at the gates of Aden.
© MOHAMMED HUWAIS Yemeni supporters of the Iran-backed Huthi movement brandish their weapons as they rally in the capital Sanaa on January 27, 2022

They held sway for a few months before being pushed out by loyalist forces.

Sporadic violence continues to blight the temporary seat of the government, whose troops clashed with southern separatists in 2018-19 before they reached a power-sharing agreement.

© Sophie RAMIS Map of Yemen

Flags of former South Yemen line the streets of Aden, where the separatist Southern Transitional Council has much influence, with checkpoints set up everywhere.
© Saleh Al-OBEIDI Internally displaced people sit by their tents at a camp north of Yemen's southern city of Aden, on March 6, 2022

As if civil war and a struggle for the city were not enough, Aden has also been targeted by a number of bombings claimed by the Islamic State group.

Along the corniche in Aden stands a large portrait of the former governor, Jaafar Saad, who was killed in a car bomb claimed by the jihadist group in 2015.

"Aden will not forget you," its message reads.

- Scars of war -


At the airport, a gaping hole torn into the arrivals terminal reminds visitors of a missile attack on cabinet members in 2020, a memorial of sorts to the at least 26 people killed.
© AHMAD AL-BASHA A malnourished child receives treatment in Yemen's third city of Taez, on March 6, 2022

Across Yemen, hundreds of thousands have been killed, directly or indirectly, and millions displaced by the war, which has left 80 percent of people on food aid.

UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres on Wednesday warned that Yemen risked "catastrophe", speaking at a donor conference that raised less than a third of the money needed.

The number of people starving in famine conditions is projected to increase five-fold this year to 161,000.

Lamlas said the pressure was exacting a toll on Aden's citizens.

"Living conditions have affected the people psychologically," said Lamlas, but insisted: "Aden remains steadfast and will return to life."

Aden's residents are struggling to afford basic goods amid soaring inflation.

Fish vendor Ammar Mohammed, 52, struggles to make a living, as few in the city can afford his product.

"Only those who have money can buy fish," he said.

"Everything was cheaper before the war."

- 'No internet, phone' -

On a quiet Friday evening, some Yemeni families headed to a seaside resort, one of the city's few recreational areas.

"I have work experience in hotels, makeup and accounting," Abeer, 31, told AFP as she sat with her two friends smoking shisha and electronic cigarettes.

"The salaries are low, the situation is difficult, and I am fighting to lead a dignified life," she said, adding that friends and jokes are what keep her going.

"There is no internet, phone network, there's nothing. We're looking for water, gas and petrol, but we at least still have some laughs."

Many in Aden blame the government for the city's deterioration, and some of them make no secret of their desire to become an independent southern state.

South Yemen was an independent country from 1967 -- when British colonial forces withdrew, paving the way for the creation of a Soviet-backed communist one-party state -- until 1990.

An attempt to break away again in 1994 sparked a brief civil war. That ended with northern troops and their militia allies occupying the south.

But calls for secession are growing louder, as people recall better times and more opportunities for women.

"It's all bad, whether separated or not," said Abeer.

"We don't want to unite with the Huthis in the north... but in (rebel-held) Sanaa there is more security and safety and there is electricity. Here there is nothing."

sy/mah/dm/th/fz/pjm/leg
U.N.: Myanmar's junta engaged in systematic human rights violations


Michelle Bachelet, the U.N. high commissioner for human rights, on Tuesday accused Myanmar's junta of committing abuses that may amount to war crimes. File Photo by EPA-EFE

March 16 (UPI) -- Myanmar's junta is engaged in systematic and widespread human rights violations, some of which amount to war crimes and crimes against humanity, the United Nations' human rights chief said in a new report that calls on the international community to do more to end the crisis in the Southeast Asian nation.

In the report, published Tuesday to coincide with a meeting of the U.N. Human Rights Council, Michelle Bachelet, the U.N. high commissioner for Human Rights, states the Tatmadaw military forces have shown a disregard for human life since seizing power in a coup on Feb. 1 by bombarding populated areas with airstrikes and heavy weapons as well as targeting civilians, some of whom have been shot in the head and burned to death.

"Myanmar is facing violence on a massive scale," the report states. "Arbitrary detentions, unnecessary and disproportionate use of force against peaceful protesters, extrajudicial killings as well as ill-treatment and torture in custody have characterized the Tatmadaw's seizure of power."

The report, based on interviews with more than 155 victims, details the security forces' use of landmines and hidden improvised explosives to maim and kill people throughout the country as well the military's so-called clearance operations where forces comb areas in search of resistance groups to arrest, torture and summarily execute them and in the process loot and destroy property.

Airstrikes and mortar and artillery shelling as well as other explosives were deployed in these ferreting operations, resulting in some 550 deaths.

It also states that there are at least 85 reported instances of the Tatmadaw forcing individuals to perform labor and to act as human shields for advancing troops.

The military, under the pretext of elections irregularities, seized control of the country more than a year ago and arrested several members of its civilian government before putting itself at the helm of the country. It then met the subsequent protests of its coup with a bloody and ongoing crackdown.

According to Myanmar's Assistance Association for Political Prisoners, the junta has killed 1,676 people while the U.N. report states more than 12,500 have been detained with at least 440,000 others having been displaced. Another 14 million, it said, are in need of urgent humanitarian assistance.

Bachelet said that despite the violence the will of the public to regain control of its country has not been broken.

"They remain committed to seeing a return to democracy and to institutions that reflect their will and aspirations," she said in a statement accompanying the report.

The protesters have the support of the United States and other democratic countries who have repeatedly enforced sanctions against Myanmar, targeting members of the junta as well as state-operated entities in order to cut off revenue to the military.

However, Bachelet in the report called on the international community for further action as it is urgently needed to "stem the pace at which individuals are being stripped of their rights, their lives and their livelihoods."

She said that Myanmar's military has created an environment where negotiations and dialogue cannot occur and where the country's citizens have no voice.

"The breadth and scale of violations of international law suffered by people of Myanmar call urgently for broader measures of justice and accountability that address more comprehensively the full range of violations that have been and continue to be suffered across the country," she said.

"Sustained serious violations of international law demand a firm, unified and resolute international response to effectively protect the human rights of the people of Myanmar," she said.

Nutrien to increase potash production amid Eastern Europe supply worries

(Reuters) - Canada's Nutrien Ltd, the world's biggest fertilizer producer, said on Wednesday it plans to increase potash output by nearly 1 million tonnes this year to about 15 million tonnes in response to the uncertainty of supply from Eastern Europe.

© Reuters/Nayan Sthankiya An interior view of the storage warehouse is seen at Nutrien's Cory potash mine near Saskatoon

Potash is a key input required for producing nitrogen-containing fertilizers, and Russia and Belarus are the world's second- and third-largest producers of the commodity after Canada.

Potash prices have soared since economic sanctions were imposed against Russia after its invasion of Ukraine. Belarus, Russia's ally, has also been subject to European and U.S. sanctions that have restricted its potash exports.

Nutrien said the additional volume of potash is expected to be produced in the second half of the year.

Meanwhile, Canadian Pacific Railway, which moves potash fertilizer into the United States, has sent a lock-out notice to its employees after talks with a union on wages and other issues failed, a move that could disrupt the supply of the commodity.

A lockdown at the rail-road company could have "serious implications" for potash transport to ports for shipment to offshore buyers, Natashia Stinka, a spokeswoman for Canpotex Ltd, a company owned by Nutrien and Mosaic Co, had said earlier.

(Reporting by Akanksha Khushi in Bengaluru; Additional reporting by Shubham Kalia; Editing by Subhranshu Sahu)
Pfizer executive receives University of Alberta 2021 distinguished alumni award

A Pfizer executive is the recipient of the University of Alberta’s distinguished alumni award for his work in clinical pharmacology.
© Provided by Edmonton Journal University of Alberta alumni Brian Corrigan, now global head of clinical pharmacology for Pfizer, spoke to U of A pharmacy and graduate students in Edmonton on Wednesday, March 16, 2022, before he received a distinguished alumni award.

Brian Corrigan earned a PhD in the U of A’s faculty of pharmacy and pharmaceutical sciences in 1996, and three years later he joined Pfizer. Since then, he has developed models to analyze clinical trials and develop correct doses, and supervises early-stage trials being developed for ailments ranging from neuropathic pain and Alzheimer’s to COVID-19.

In an interview Wednesday morning, Corrigan said it’s very special to be named a distinguished alumnus.

“My wife and I, we grew up in Alberta, went to school, we did a graduate school here and this is where we consider home even though we haven’t lived here for 25 years,” said Corrigan, who now lives in the United States.

“To be recognized by fellow Albertans for some of the work that I’ve been part of for the last 25 years, it really means a lot to us.

One of the reasons Corrigan became interested in pharmaceutical sciences was the role of a pharmacist in the community.

“You’re helping serve patients, both in the hospitals and outside the hospitals, giving care and in the new role, providing medicines, vaccinations, etc.,” he said.

After spending time in Japan teaching with his wife, Corrigan said they realized the importance of medicine development, leading him to work in the field of clinical pharmacology. Over the last 25 years, he has worked on various projects related to neuroscience and Alzheimer’s.

“In my current role, I head up the global clinical pharmacology organization and we oversee sort of early development clinical pharmacology studies across all therapeutic areas for Pfizer and for the medicines that we develop,” he said.

Most recently, Corrigan and his colleagues have been working on COVID-19 vaccines and therapeutics for the virus.

“We were very happy that we could play an important part in that in the history of COVID,” he said, adding he never imagined going into the field that he would play a role in a pandemic.

Over the past few decades, Corrigan has seen new technologies and mechanisms in his field, including the mRNA vaccines used for COVID-19, as well as monoclonal antibodies which can be used to help fight the virus.

“We see therapeutic proteins, we see gene therapies emerging now where we can actually go in and treat the underlying cause of a genetic disorder,” he said.

“I think it’s a really exciting time for medicines development and there’s so much happening. And the science has really evolved to allow us to do things that we couldn’t even think (about) when I joined the faculty of pharmacy.”

Before the award ceremony Wednesday evening, Corrigan gave a lunch hour talk to students at the faculty of pharmacy and pharmaceutical sciences.

Advice Corrigan would give to students is that it’s important to get solid scientific training, be open to change, and learn how to communicate effectively.

“Medicines development is a team sport,” he said. “Really some of those skills that are really important are those scientists’ ability to be able to communicate those very important ideas to people that might not necessarily be as familiar with them.”

The distinguished alumni award is the U of A alumni association’s highest honour, recognizing the outstanding lifetime accomplishments of alumni.

ajunker@postmedia.com
UCP A FRANKENSTEIN PARTY
Fallout from Brian Jean's byelection victory will be messy for Kenney, political scientists say

Wallis Snowdon 
CBC
© Terry Reith/CBC 
Brian Jean, co-founder of the governing United Conservative Party, is coming back to the Alberta legislature, setting up a confrontation with Premier Jason Kenney.

A looming battle between Premier Jason Kenney and newly-elected MLA Brian Jean will sow further divisions within Alberta's deeply divided reigning political party, political scientists say.

Jean's win Tuesday in the Fort McMurray-Lac La Biche byelection is only the first blow to Kenney in what will be an ugly battle for leadership of the United Conservative Party, said Mount Royal University political scientist Lori Williams.

The former Wildrose Party leader's return to the legislature will deepen existing fault lines with the United Conservative Party and embolden Kenney's opponents, Williams said Wednesday.

With a leadership review set for April 9 in Red Deer, Kenney is playing a losing game, she said.

"The people that oppose Jason Kenney are not going to give up, even if they can't successfully challenge him from within," Williams said.

"For the people that are really strongly opposed — the ones that are angry — they're just going to keep trying either to get Jason Kenney out as leader or split from the party."

Jean easily won the byelection Tuesday. With all polls reporting, 63.6 per cent of voters chose the UCP candidate over his challengers.

Kenney congratulated Jean on Twitter Tuesday but has not made any other comments about his rival's byelection win.

The vote was a lose-lose situation for the premier, said Lisa Young, a political scientist at the University of Calgary.

"There was really no good outcome for Jason Kenney," Young said. "Now his greatest enemy is in his own caucus.

"But if the NDP had won, it would have been seen as a huge sign that his party was in trouble and that would have hurt him in the upcoming leadership review."

For Jean, the campaign was always a means to oust Kenney.

Jean and Kenney founded the UCP together in 2017 as a merger of the Wildrose Party and the Progressive Association of Alberta, but Jean lost the leadership to Kenney in a vote stained by accusations of secret deals, colluding candidates and fraud.

Jean eventually quit as an MLA, but announced in November he was coming out of political retirement.

If Kenney remains as leader, the UCP and its place at the top of Alberta's political ladder will be in jeopardy, Jean said after his win Tuesday night.

"Jason, I hope you see what's coming and I hope you do the right thing," Jean said.

"The right thing is to resign while the party is still together. The party needs to stay together and to unify, we need him to go."

With the byelection over, opposing factions within the UCP are now focused on getting supporters to the ballot box next month for Kenney's leadership review.

Only party members will be eligible to vote at the special general meeting in Red Deer on April 9 but the cutoff to register is Saturday.

As of Tuesday, about 8,000 members had registered but that number is expected to surge.

In an interview Wednesday, Jean urged his supporters to register immediately to ensure a "clear message" is delivered to Kenney about the "bad job" he's been doing.

All Kenney needs to survive is a simple 50 per cent-plus-one majority. He has said he will be content to remain leader if that is all he gets.

Williams said even a winning vote will be a losing scenario for Kenney. Anger within caucus is likely to grow and challenges to his leadership will continue, she said.

"I don't see what win is possible for him," Williams said. "This is the never-ending story."
'One of them is going to go'

The question now becomes what happens when Jean joins the UCP caucus.

Last May, MLAs Drew Barnes and Todd Loewen were kicked out of the UCP caucus after criticizing Kenney and his COVID-19 policies.

In July, Chestermere-Rocky View MLA Leela Aheer was dropped from cabinet after criticizing Kenney for breaking COVID-19 restrictions during a rooftop lunch outside his temporary penthouse office.

"The day after the leadership review, I can't imagine a situation where both Kenney and Jean are in the caucus," said Duane Bratt, a political science professor at Mount Royal University.

"One of them is going to go. It's just unsustainable.

"If Kenney survives the leadership review, I think he's going to take steps to remove Jean from from caucus."

Bratt said he no longer expects Kenney to survive the leadership vote but no matter the outcome, the political fallout will be messy.

Five years after its creation, the party appears split by irreconcilable differences, Bratt said. He said the divisions will continue to plague the caucus and whoever leads the party.

"It's a new party, it was cobbled together because of the NDP, the desire to remove the NDP from power … but that glue didn't last very long.

"Now, there may be glue to remove Jason Kenney, but once he's removed you still have those cleavages and divisions.

"You wonder if the merger was a good idea or whether these are simply two incompatible groups in a forced marriage."
Lethbridge College showcases wind turbine program to prospective Indigenous students

Lethbridge College looked to blow away around 30 prospective students on Wednesday during an experiential learning day.

Eloise Therien
© Courtesy: Lethbridge College Lethbridge College hosts prospective students at its wind turbine facility on Wednesday, March 16, 2022.

Most of those in attendance came from the Piikani First Nation to learn about the school's wind turbine technician program and to tour the campus.

"They're actually in the lab of the wind turbine technician area," said Lowell Yellowhorn, the Indigenous services manager at Lethbridge College.

"They're getting introduced to some of the working components of a wind turbine in the nacelle, (and a virtual reality) experience."

Yellowhorn said the day was made possible through a continuing partnership with Enel Green Power.

Southern Alberta witnessing ‘unprecedented’ surge in renewable energy projects

"Looking at the recruitment of a prospective student from the Piikani Nation, it's important because Enel operates on the traditional territory of the Piikani people and the Blackfoot people."

Otys Potts, a 2006 graduate of the wind turbine technician program, shared some of his experiences.

"I think that's a huge advantage from them to be checking that stuff out, seeing if it's for them or not," Potts said.

Video: Prince Edward County wind turbines coming down

For Braxton Wells, a 17-year-old from Brocket, the thought of working on turbines is both exciting and nerve-wracking.

"I'm kind of scared of heights, so that's one thing -- one of my fears I want to build up," Wells said.

After thinking about his plans after high school for quite some time, he said he plans on applying for the one-year program.

He hopes the experience helps his peers consider their futures as well.

"On our reserve, there's a lot of people that chose the wrong path and they're going down the wrong path," he said. "I kind of just want people my age to go enjoy life and do stuff with their life."

According to the province, there are approximately 3,200 wind turbine technicians employed in Alberta.
Alberta NDP's proposed extension of utility 
cut-off ban rejected by UCP
Ashley Joannou , Lisa Johnson
 
© Provided by Edmonton Journal NDP energy critic Kathleen Ganley.

UCP MLAs rejected an NDP proposal to ban cutting off utilities to Albertans for a full year Wednesday.

Alberta already has regulations that prevent essential utilities from being fully disconnected between Oct. 15 and April 15 but a draft bill offered up by the NDP Opposition, and put forward with a motion Wednesday, would have created a one-time expansion through the spring and summer, preventing utilities from being shut off until next April.

The motion did not receive the unanimous consent it needed in the legislature to move forward.

The Opposition said the protection is required as costs go up and more Albertans fall behind on their soaring energy bills, but electricity and natural gas associate minister Dale Nally called it unnecessary, pointing to support programs for low-income seniors and Albertans.

© Provided by Edmonton Journal Natural gas and electricity associate minister Dale Nally.


“The utilities have made it clear to me that if Albertans are working with them, they will then in return work back with them and they will come out with reasonable programs that will allow them to continue to pay their bill and to keep their lights and their power on,” said Nally in the legislature, encouraging Albertans to contact their utility companies.

At a news conference Tuesday, NDP energy critic Kathleen Ganley said she thought the draft legislation could be passed in a day if it had government support.

“Albertans have already been through so much over the past two years. Between the COVID-19 pandemic and now the rising cost of living, it would be heartless to disconnect Albertans just trying to get by and keep a roof over their heads,” Ganley said.

The UCP government has responded to growing utility bills by promising a $150 rebate as soon as they can get the details worked out with the province’s power companies. Ganley called that plan “insulting,” considering how high bills have become.

The Opposition has called on the government to increase the size of the rebate or reinstate the cap on utility prices that was in place when the NDP was in power.
U.S., Canadian forces performing military exercises to test defenses in Arctic

A U.S. MH-60R Seahawk helicopter prepares to land aboard the USS Harry S. Truman during combat and training operations above the Arctic Circle. U.S. and Canadian forces will perform training exercises in the Arctic until Thursday, defense officials said
.
 File Photo by U.S. Navy/Mass Communication Specialist 3rd Joseph A.D. Phillips


March 16 (UPI) -- U.S. and Canadian military forces are conducting military exercises in the Arctic region on Wednesday, officials said, which have added significance with Russia's ongoing war in Ukraine.

The Pentagon acknowledged the drills earlier this week, which are regularly held by the military forces of the United States and Canada. The exercises began on Monday.

Officials said the joint drills are designed to test responses to aircraft and cruise missiles in the expansive and lightly defended northern region.

The recurring operation, which includes the North American Aerospace Defense Command, is called Noble Defender and officials say it demonstrates the countries' defensive capabilities in northern approaches.

"While the majority of the operation's flights will be conducted over sparsely populated arctic areas at high altitudes where the public is not likely to see or hear aircraft in Canada, there will be an increase in military presence and flying activity at Whitehorse, Yellowknife and 5 Wing Goose Bay for the duration of the operation," NORAD said in a statement.

"This iteration of Noble Defender will incorporate several assets from both Canada and the United States," Pentagon spokesman John Kirby said in a statement.

"During this exercise, NORAD fighters will conduct intercepts of U.S. Strategic Command bombers, representing threat platforms throughout the Arctic, from Alaska to Greenland."

NORAD commander Gen. Glen D. VanHerck said in a tweet that the exercise has "served the international community well for decades" and emphasizes the value of the Arctic as a "cooperative region where countries consistently work together to solve shared challenges."

As temperatures in the Arctic region have warmed, Russia has increased its military presence. Two years ago, Moscow sent long-range bombers to cross the North Pole and grazed Canadian airspace before turning back.

"[It is] not inconceivable that our sovereignty may be challenged" from the Arctic region by Russia," Canadian defense chief Gen. Wayne Eyre said, according to The Guardian.

The military exercises, which were scheduled before Russia's invasion of Ukraine, are scheduled to run through Thursday, NORAD said.

World's oldest blue-eyed black lemurs celebrate birthday

March 16 (UPI) -- The world's oldest blue-eyed black lemurs, Stewart and Bardot, are celebrating their birthdays, the Philadelphia Zoo announced.

Stewart turned 32 this past week, making him the oldest male blue-eyed black lemur, and Bardot turned 30, making her the oldest female blue-eyed black lemur.



"Blue-eyed black lemurs and spider monkeys are the only two primates other than humans that have true blue eyes. We're so thankful to have such an incredible animal care team and vet staff to keep this couple healthy and happy in their golden years," the Philadelphia Zoo said on Twitter.

Blue-eyed black lemurs are sexually dimorphic, which gives males and females different colors. Stewart has black fur while Bardot has tan fur.

The species is critically endangered and are considered to be one of the most threatened primates on the planet.
Texas National Guard troops posted at wealthy ranches as part of border mission

By James Barragán, The Texas Tribune

Members of the Texas National Guard were stationed outside King Ranch in January. Photo by Eddie Gaspar/The Texas Tribune

March 16 (UPI) -- Earlier this year, about 30 Texas National Guard members were ordered to stand watch outside some of the wealthiest private ranches in South Texas, more than an hour's drive away from the Mexico border, as part of Gov. Greg Abbott's highly touted mission to curb illegal immigration.

Placed at spots along U.S. Route 77 running north to Corpus Christi -- including the sprawling and renowned King Ranch and the GOP-connected Armstrong Ranch -- the troops were ostensibly meant to deter migrants and smugglers who might cross through private ranches to avoid detection at the U.S. Border Patrol checkpoint near the city of Sarita.

But service members with firsthand knowledge of the mission told The Texas Tribune that troops rarely saw migrants from their posts nearly 80 miles away from the border and were unable to give chase because they were not authorized to enter the private ranches if they saw migrants cutting through.

In practice, service members said, they stood around for hours, staring at each other and the highway, outside the private ranches -- some of which had their own private security.

"We really don't understand why we are there," a service member told the Tribune. "We're essentially mall security for ranches that already have paid security details to protect them."

The Texas Tribune is not identifying the service members because they were not authorized to speak to the media and feared retaliation.

Those troops said their time was wasted standing guard outside ranches with wealthy or politically connected owners when they could have been more useful at other posts closer to the border where they could be more effective to the mission, which is known as Operation Lone Star.

Representatives for the King and Armstrong ranches said they did not request the presence of the National Guard outside their ranches and that the troops were on the public right of way and not on their private property.

The service members are no longer stationed outside of the private ranches, service members said. They were removed in February, shortly after The Texas Tribune began asking questions about the deployment. Col. Rita Holton, a spokeswoman for the Texas Military Department, said the agency could not comment on the deployment because of operational security concerns.

The dispatching of troops to wealthy private ranches raises more questions about the use of National Guard troops, who have widely decried the mission as aimless, political and oversized, as the cost of the effort has ballooned to $2 billion a year. State leaders transferred nearly half a billion dollars to the Texas Military Department last month from three other state agencies to cover the mounting costs of keeping thousands of Texas National Guard troops on the southern border.

State Sen. Juan "Chuy" Hinojosa, D-McAllen, who represents a border district and sits on a committee overseeing border security efforts, said the reports of National Guard service members stationed at private ranches in the state's interior were "disturbing."

"I have no objections to them being on the border," he said. "But I certainly have concerns with military presence at private ranches. It would be a waste of time and of resources. There's better use of the National Guard on the border, not in the interior."

Even if the service members saw migrants crossing through ranches, they are unable to do anything because they do not have authority to go on the land and arrest them, said Hinojosa, who compared their deployment to scarecrows.

Abbott's office declined to comment and referred questions to the Texas Department of Public Safety and the Texas Military Department.

'Not much to do'

Abbott kicked off Operation Lone Star last March and ramped up its scale in September, leading to involuntary deployments with only a few days notice for part-time troops who have civilian jobs, lives and families. He eventually deployed 10,000 troops to the mission, many of whom have said they were not given a clear task or adequate training, equipment or lodging. A leaked survey of members of one of the six Operation Lone Star units found widespread skepticism and frustration with the mission.

On Monday, Abbott replaced the Texas Military Department's top leader after months of criticism.

In January, the Texas Military Department sent troops to stand guard outside the famed King Ranch, the largest ranch in the United States, which covers more ground than the state of Rhode Island.

It also sent troops to the Armstrong Ranch, the property of a longtime Republican family that has hosted GOP leaders like Karl Rove, former Gov. Rick Perry and former Vice President Dick Cheney. In an infamous 2006 incident, Cheney accidentally shot his friend in the face during a hunting expedition at the Armstrong Ranch. The injuries were nonfatal.

Troops were also sent to stand guard outside the ranch where Kenedy County Judge Charles Burns lives. Burns is a Democrat.

"These ranchers have enough money to do private security or have private security guard these gates," said the second service member who spoke to the Tribune. "The optics are just kind of crazy."

Jay Kleberg, a member of the family that owns the King Ranch who is running for land commissioner as a Democrat, said in a written statement that Operation Lone Star is a "colossal waste of taxpayer dollars" and a "serious threat to the health and safety of our Texas National Guard."

He said he did not have information on where the service members were stationed, but it was "beyond time to end Operation Lone Star."

"If it were up to me, these Texans would be home with their families and back at their jobs, not wasting their time on our border," Kleberg said.

The deployment along U.S. 77 consisted of multiple stations, each staffed with two service members and a Humvee. At any given time, 10 National Guard service members were posted along the highway leading to the Sarita checkpoint. With three shifts throughout the day, 30 service members were required daily to set up the points along private properties near the highway.

"Honestly, there's not much to do, if anything at all," said the second service member. "It's pretty boring just standing there for eight hours."

At the end of their shifts, service members then had to drive back to their living quarters in Harlingen, about 60 miles away.

State officials said the Texas Department of Public Safety and the Texas Military Department deployed personnel to the area at the request of the Kenedy County sheriff's office, a local property rights association and local landowners who were seeing migrants and smugglers cross their properties to circumvent the Sarita checkpoint.

"The migrants and traffickers were driving through ranch gates on several properties to the north and south of the Sarita checkpoint to avoid apprehension, and this was leading to costly damages and dangerous vehicle pursuits along the heavily traveled Highway 77," Ericka Miller, a spokeswoman for DPS, said in an email in response to questions. "In early January 2022, DPS and TMD began posting personnel at several rotating locations in the area in order to address these concerns."

While the state troopers and National Guard troops were there, Miller said, vehicle pursuits and reports of damaged properties dropped. But Miller could not provide any official statistics on the number of apprehensions or arrests from DPS before or after service members were deployed.

The Texas Tribune filed a public records request for those statistics, but DPS said it had no responsive documents. The Tribune also filed a request with the Texas Military Department.

State Rep. James White, R-Hillister, who leads one of the House committees that oversees the deployment, said data is needed to measure the mission's success.

"They have to have the data," White said. "Why do we have them here versus here? And with that data we can extrapolate success or needs improvement."

White, who supports the deployment, said leaders needed to listen to the troops on the ground about their concerns and explain to them the impact their deployment is having. He said the border mission is needed to combat human and drug trafficking through the Texas border.

Burns, the Kenedy County judge, said he had not requested the deployment of troops to stand guard outside his ranch but that he supported their presence there.

"If that's where they felt they need to be, I'm in agreement," Burns said. "Put them where they can do the best job."

Last year, Kenedy County received more than $700,000 from the state at Burns' request as part of Operation Lone Star's grant program for counties affected by the increase in migration through Texas.

The second service member said troops rarely saw migrants or smugglers. In 45 days, the troops had not seen "anywhere near the amount of activity as other strategic locations" along the border and were limited in their ability to apprehend migrants or smugglers.

The service member said troops were not allowed to enter the private ranches where they were standing guard. If they saw migrants or smugglers cutting through, the service member said, troops had to alert Border Patrol, which would then be tasked with chasing and apprehending the trespassers.

"It's strictly observe and report. If a [migrant] was coming toward us, we'd get on our radio and call Border Patrol," the service member said. "We can't act on any suspicious activity or any activity at all."

The first service member said they had seen "very little [migrant] presence" since the troops were deployed to the ranches, and the Border Patrol "has been the one to inform us of the presence and handled all apprehensions."

State Rep. Alex Dominguez, D-Brownsville, a vocal critic of Operation Lone Star, questioned the efficacy of the deployment of Guard members to the ranches.

"It is unfathomable to me why these service members would be stationed there other than for the optics of seeing a military vehicle manned by service members," he said in a statement. "If any immigrant would be moving northbound through the general area of the Armstrong or King ranches, they likely would avoid major arteries and travel through the brush. To my knowledge, the service members do not access the brush area."

'We needed it'

Among local officials, the deployment of troops along U.S. 77 was greeted with support.

"Since they've been there, the number of bailouts and the number of intrusions into private property and going through gates and fences has decreased," Burns said. "I think their presence has been very beneficial to the county."

Similarly, Kenedy County Sheriff Ramon Salinas said the presence of National Guard troops has helped deter migrants and smugglers and relieved the burden on his small agency.

"We needed it," he said. "They've come through for us, and I appreciate everything the governor has done."

Neither Salinas nor Burns could provide official evidence or data to show how the presence of the troops had deterred migrants and smugglers in the area, but Salinas said that anecdotally, ranch owners were happy that their fences were no longer being knocked down by smugglers who would cut through their properties to evade law enforcement.

"It's really made a big difference," he said. "Traffic has gone down."

But even with the troops stationed along the highway, Salinas said, ranches were still seeing groups of migrants walking through their properties to avoid the Sarita checkpoint.

"As soon as they get close to the checkpoint, they bail out and go through the ranches," he said.

That led one of the service members to question just how much impact their presence had on the deterrence of migrants in the area.

"If you can get in between us and still have the same effect, [then] they're [just] walking further," the second service member said. "They're just adapting to us being there, but there's no real data supporting us stopping this from happening."

Jessica Bolter, an associate policy analyst of U.S. immigration policy at the Washington-based Migration Policy Institute, said the continued presence of migrants and smugglers speaks to the limitations of an "enforcement-only approach."

"Simply increasing enforcement doesn't solve the challenges of unauthorized migration, particularly because there's never going to be complete 100% enforcement across the border," Bolter said. "Migrants and smugglers are always going to find new ways to cross through these areas as long as push-and-pull factors driving migration continue to exist."

While state officials may be serving local constituents by trying to prevent damage to their properties and trespassing, Bolter said posting personnel outside private properties so far inland is unlikely to reduce overall unauthorized immigration at the border.

In order to effectively curb migration, Bolter said, officials would have to address the reasons migrants leave their home countries, try to work with other countries that other migrants pass through and create an effective asylum system at the border.

"These are all things that the state government doesn't have the ability to do, which is why its response is always going to be somewhat limited," she said. "Even if it starts working as a deterrent in one area of the border, it's likely migrants will just shift to crossing in another area."

Uriel García and Eddie Gaspar contributed to this report.

This article originally appeared in The Texas Tribune. Read the original here.

The Texas Tribune is a member-supported, nonpartisan newsroom informing and engaging Texans on state politics and policy. Learn more at texastribune.org.