Who was behind the sabotage of France’s railway network? Here’s what we know
THEY HAVE NO CLUE TILL THE COMMUNIQUE
Ivana Kottasová, Saskya Vandoorne and Sana Noor Haq, CNN
Sat, July 27, 2024
Authorities are investigating what outgoing French Prime Minister Gabriel Attal called a “coordinated” effort. He said that intelligence services and internal security forces are involved in inquiries and urged caution over jumping to conclusions.
French police will know “quite quickly who is responsible” for the attacks, the country’s Interior Minister Gerald Darmanin said on Saturday. They recovered an “amount of evidence” following the operation, Darmanin told CNN affiliate France 2.
No-one has yet claimed responsibility for the attacks, but given their scale, timing and precision, it is clear they are more than just random acts of vandalism.
There are many possible culprits – the opening day of the Olympic Games is one of the most watched events in the world, a tempting target for anyone seeking to cause chaos and disruption in the limelight.
Here’s what we know.
Extensive knowledge of railways
High-speed trains connecting southwestern, northern and eastern regions of French were all impacted on Friday, in what authorities described as a methodical pattern of attacks hitting key arterial routes.
The perpetrators have extensive knowledge of the network, according to Axel Persson, a leader of the CGT rail union. They must have had access to very “precise information,” he added.
Authorities should not rule out industrial espionage, Persson told CNN on Friday, saying that a railway staffer, or someone who built the tracks including construction workers, could also be to blame.
Employees had implemented a failsafe plan in preparation for the Olympics, allowing some passengers to use alternative lines that would slow down traffic, but at least travelers would get to their destination, Persson added. “France is disrupted but not paralyzed,” he said.
Jean-Pierre Farandou, the CEO of state-owned rail company SNCF, told journalists that cables – which are there to ensure the security of train drivers – were set on fire and taken apart but again stressed authorities “don’t know who is behind it.”
An act of protest?
France is no stranger to widespread strikes or political demonstrations that manifest into blocked transport links across the country.
The parliamentary election held just weeks ago attracted large scale protests and rallies. However, such events tend to be announced in advance and those behind them are keen to make their cause known.
Environmental activists have previously blocked traffic to bring attention to the climate crisis. But these groups have mostly staged bold and striking demonstrations focused on fossil-fuel intensive transportation, such as on airports and highways, and also make it known when they are behind such protests.
Railway staff and police work to repair one of several sites where vandals targeted France's high-speed train network, in the northern villege of Croisilles, on Friday. - Brian Snyder/Reuters
The attacks could also have been an act of civil disobedience. An intelligence source told CNN that services pointed out “these methods have been used by the far left in the past,” but said that “there is no evidence to tie today’s actions to them.”
The last major act of vandalism on high-speed train lines in France was in 2008, when steel rods were placed on overhead power cables. Police arrested individuals from an alleged anarchist group from Tarnac village but 10 years later, after a lengthy investigation, they were all acquitted and cleared of sabotage.
Foreign actors?
Recently, France has been one of several countries impacted by a wave of suspected Russian sabotage attacks against infrastructure and other targets.
French President Emmanuel Macron has remained a staunch ally of Kyiv throughout the fighting. Just in May, he suggested that Ukraine should be allowed to use their weapons against targets inside Russia from which the Kremlin attacks Ukraine.
Earlier this week, French authorities detained a Russian citizen in Paris, accusing him of preparing destabilizing events during the Games. Kremlin spokesperson Dmitry Peskov said Russia did not have any information on the arrest.
Ahead of the Games, Dale Buckner, CEO of the security firm Global Guardian, told CNN France has “a lot of enemies” due to its stance on a wide range of international and domestic issues, singling out cyber attacks as one of the greatest threats.
CNN has previously reported on a host of suspected Russian attacks across Europe. Russia has not admitted to any of them and did not respond to a CNN request for comment.
CNN’s Ben Church and Xiaofei Xu contributed reporting.
Henry Samuel
Fri, July 26, 2024
THE TELEGRAPH
Passengers gather around the departure boards at the Gare Montparnasse train station in Paris after France's high-speed rail network was brought down - THIBAUD MORITZ
It was the moment France and the world had been waiting for – the opening ceremony of the Paris Olympic Games down the river Seine, the first ever for a Summer Games outside a stadium.
But as the country awoke to the final Olympic countdown and the prospect of a spectacular show involving 7,500 athletes, 300,000 spectators, superstar appearances and an audience of VIPs, saboteurs had already thrown a huge spanner in the works.
In the early hours of Friday, reports emerged of a “massive” and “co-ordinated” sabotage attack on the country’s high-speed national rail tracks, which essentially knocked out most lines to and from northern, eastern and western France.
While officials insisted the opening ceremony itself would suffer no disruption, Gabriel Attal, France’s acting prime minister, said: “The consequences for the rail network are massive and serious.”
“Our intelligence services and law enforcement agencies are mobilised to find and punish the perpetrators of these criminal acts,” he added.
French authorities had laid on a large, high-tech security regime to defend the Olympics, with Reaper drones in the skies and AI-powered cameras on the ground to keep an eye out for suspicious activity.
But Friday’s attack suggests they paid far less attention to key rail routes, which were sabotaged by old-fashioned arson rather than cyber-attacks.
The saboteurs chose to avoid the heavily guarded French capital and instead struck rural targets in the middle of the night. While hundreds of armed police officers and soldiers patrolled the streets of Paris, several cables were apparently set alight in the commune of Courtalain, around 150km south-west of the capital.
The local community’s social media page posted a picture of burnt-out cables in a shallow gully, with its protective paving stones discarded.
SNCF, France’s state-owned rail company, says the saboteurs either vandalised or tried to vandalise five signal boxes and electricity installations between 1am and 5.30am local time on Friday.
They struck not just at Courtalain but at Pagny-sur-Moselle, a village outside the eastern city of Metz, and Croisilles, not far from the northern city of Arras.
The targeted sites are small but are located at crucial junctions on the high-speed network.
Another attempted attack, on a TGV junction to the south east of Paris at Vergigny, was foiled by SNCF workers who happened to be carrying out maintenance in the early hours of Friday.
Matthieu Chabanel, head of SNCF Réseau, which runs SNCF’s infrastructure, said staff first detected a major problem at 4am.
“Fifty cables of 10 wires each makes 500 cables to reconnect linked to installations that are essential for safety, such as signalling,” he told Le Monde.
Patrice Vergriete, the French transport minister, said that France had received no warning of the attacks but that “we are preparing for (others)”.
“Today we are on alert, so obviously we have mobilised all security forces, as well as drones, so today we have greatly increased our vigilance”, he told TF1.
SNCF railway workers work at one of the targeted sites along the network - REUTERS/Brian Snyder
It remains unclear who is behind the crippling attacks that affected 250,000 passengers on Friday and are estimated to hit 800,000 over the weekend.
Senior figures have suggested the sabotage could have been carried out by hard-Left radicals or Russia, whose athletes have been barred from the opening ceremony.
But whoever committed this crime knew what they were doing as they chose strategic “switch points” to cause maximum damage. “For one fire, you hit two destinations”, said Jean-Pierre Farandou, head of SNCF.
“Part of France is under attack. The French are under attack,” he told BFMTV.
Friday was a huge day of departures for hundreds of thousands of French leaving Paris to go on holiday by train and car. Thousands more were due to arrive in Paris to attend the opening ceremony.
The saboteurs “knew where to hit”, said Mr Attal, adding that they had “knowledge of the network”.
“What we know, what we can see is that this operation has been planned, coordinated, that key points have been targeted which shows a kind of knowledge of the [train] network,” he added.
Burnt-out cables near Courtalain, around 150km south west of Paris - Mayor of Vald'Yerre/Franck Marchand
One in four Eurostar trains was cancelled on Friday and over the weekend, spoiling Olympic plans for some British fans.
Toby Morris told The Telegraph a friend gave him boxing tickets along with £250 train tickets to Paris as a gift.
“I thought I’d come here to try my chances, but they’ve said I definitely can’t get on another train today, so I just won’t be able to go now,” he said.
Gérald Darmanin, the French interior minister, told the press that the sabotage had no “direct consequence on the organisation of the Olympic Games”.
However, Downing Street said Sir Keir Starmer had to change his travel plans as he was meant to travel on the Eurostar to Paris but flew instead.
Sir Keir earlier insisted that travel disruption would not “overshadow” the Olympic Games.
SNCF urged passengers to postpone their trips, stay away from train stations and await text message instructions, but by Friday afternoon, traffic was slowly resuming to western France – with one in three trains operating – while trains to the east and north had resumed with delays.
Valérie Pécresse, the Paris regional council head, said: “Clearly this attack is not a coincidence. This attack is an attempt to destabilise France.”
Suspicions of Russian involvement were raised this week when a Russian reality TV “bachelor” turned Le Cordon Bleu-trained chef was unmasked as an alleged spy plotting to sabotage the Olympics.
Jérôme Poirot, terrorism expert for RMC-BFMTV, a French television and radio network, added: “We know that Russia and other countries want to interfere with the Olympic Games. There may be a plan in place to prevent the opening ceremony.”
Israel, on the other hand, blamed Iran. Israel Katz, Israel’s foreign minister, said: “The sabotage of railway infrastructure across France ahead of the Paris 2024 Olympics was planned and executed under the influence of Iran’s axis of evil and radical Islam.”
But Mr Attal advised against jumping to conclusions.
“The investigation is starting, and I would urge everyone to exercise caution. What we know, what we can see, is that this operation was prepared, coordinated, that key points were targeted, which shows a kind of knowledge of the network in order to know where to strike”, he said.
Emmanuel Macron declined to comment.
Asked if the arson attacks were the work of Russia or a terrorist group, Amélie Oudéa-Castera, the French sports minister, responded: “Maybe,” before adding: “It could also be protesters – even French people.”
Gabriel Attal, France's acting prime minister, said the saboteurs had 'knowledge of the network' and 'knew where to hit' - Tschaen Eric/Pool/ABACA/Shutterstock
It emerged on Friday that a similar incendiary device to the ones found at the sabotage sites on Friday was detected in May on a high-speed line between Marseille and Aix-en-Provence. An investigation was launched but no arrests were made.
Jean de Gliniasty, the former French ambassador to Moscow, told LCI the threat could have come from the far-Left.
“There’s a tradition in France of black blocs, every time there’s a demonstration they destroy, they break things,” he said. “In fact, France has been facing these problems for several years now, and we haven’t managed to solve them.”
In 2008, French anti-terrorist police arrested 10 members of a “violent anarchist movement” for sabotaging power cables on high-speed TGV train lines. Severe delays were caused when power was cut by metal bars hooked onto overhead electric cables on TGV lines around Paris.
However, in what was called a judicial “fiasco”, the “Tarnac ten” were later all acquitted.
Some French unions, including the powerful Leftist CGT, had called for strikes during the Games over working conditions but these were mainly withdrawn due to concessions.
Paris prosecutors said an investigation has been launched into charges of “damaging property likely to harm the fundamental interests of the nation”, “damage and attempted damage by dangerous means in an organised gang”, “attacks on an automated data processing system in an organised gang” and “criminal conspiracy”.
Ivana Kottasová, Saskya Vandoorne and Sana Noor Haq, CNN
Sat, July 27, 2024
France is still facing travel disruption a day after saboteurs targeted high-speed railway lines in an attack coinciding with the start of the Olympics. As operators try to get service back to normal, a key question remains - who was responsible?
Authorities are investigating what outgoing French Prime Minister Gabriel Attal called a “coordinated” effort. He said that intelligence services and internal security forces are involved in inquiries and urged caution over jumping to conclusions.
French police will know “quite quickly who is responsible” for the attacks, the country’s Interior Minister Gerald Darmanin said on Saturday. They recovered an “amount of evidence” following the operation, Darmanin told CNN affiliate France 2.
No-one has yet claimed responsibility for the attacks, but given their scale, timing and precision, it is clear they are more than just random acts of vandalism.
There are many possible culprits – the opening day of the Olympic Games is one of the most watched events in the world, a tempting target for anyone seeking to cause chaos and disruption in the limelight.
Here’s what we know.
Extensive knowledge of railways
High-speed trains connecting southwestern, northern and eastern regions of French were all impacted on Friday, in what authorities described as a methodical pattern of attacks hitting key arterial routes.
The perpetrators have extensive knowledge of the network, according to Axel Persson, a leader of the CGT rail union. They must have had access to very “precise information,” he added.
Authorities should not rule out industrial espionage, Persson told CNN on Friday, saying that a railway staffer, or someone who built the tracks including construction workers, could also be to blame.
Employees had implemented a failsafe plan in preparation for the Olympics, allowing some passengers to use alternative lines that would slow down traffic, but at least travelers would get to their destination, Persson added. “France is disrupted but not paralyzed,” he said.
Jean-Pierre Farandou, the CEO of state-owned rail company SNCF, told journalists that cables – which are there to ensure the security of train drivers – were set on fire and taken apart but again stressed authorities “don’t know who is behind it.”
An act of protest?
France is no stranger to widespread strikes or political demonstrations that manifest into blocked transport links across the country.
The parliamentary election held just weeks ago attracted large scale protests and rallies. However, such events tend to be announced in advance and those behind them are keen to make their cause known.
Environmental activists have previously blocked traffic to bring attention to the climate crisis. But these groups have mostly staged bold and striking demonstrations focused on fossil-fuel intensive transportation, such as on airports and highways, and also make it known when they are behind such protests.
Railway staff and police work to repair one of several sites where vandals targeted France's high-speed train network, in the northern villege of Croisilles, on Friday. - Brian Snyder/Reuters
The attacks could also have been an act of civil disobedience. An intelligence source told CNN that services pointed out “these methods have been used by the far left in the past,” but said that “there is no evidence to tie today’s actions to them.”
The last major act of vandalism on high-speed train lines in France was in 2008, when steel rods were placed on overhead power cables. Police arrested individuals from an alleged anarchist group from Tarnac village but 10 years later, after a lengthy investigation, they were all acquitted and cleared of sabotage.
Foreign actors?
Recently, France has been one of several countries impacted by a wave of suspected Russian sabotage attacks against infrastructure and other targets.
French President Emmanuel Macron has remained a staunch ally of Kyiv throughout the fighting. Just in May, he suggested that Ukraine should be allowed to use their weapons against targets inside Russia from which the Kremlin attacks Ukraine.
Earlier this week, French authorities detained a Russian citizen in Paris, accusing him of preparing destabilizing events during the Games. Kremlin spokesperson Dmitry Peskov said Russia did not have any information on the arrest.
Ahead of the Games, Dale Buckner, CEO of the security firm Global Guardian, told CNN France has “a lot of enemies” due to its stance on a wide range of international and domestic issues, singling out cyber attacks as one of the greatest threats.
CNN has previously reported on a host of suspected Russian attacks across Europe. Russia has not admitted to any of them and did not respond to a CNN request for comment.
CNN’s Ben Church and Xiaofei Xu contributed reporting.
‘France is under attack’: How Olympics saboteurs brought chaos to the Games
Henry Samuel
Fri, July 26, 2024
THE TELEGRAPH
Passengers gather around the departure boards at the Gare Montparnasse train station in Paris after France's high-speed rail network was brought down - THIBAUD MORITZ
It was the moment France and the world had been waiting for – the opening ceremony of the Paris Olympic Games down the river Seine, the first ever for a Summer Games outside a stadium.
But as the country awoke to the final Olympic countdown and the prospect of a spectacular show involving 7,500 athletes, 300,000 spectators, superstar appearances and an audience of VIPs, saboteurs had already thrown a huge spanner in the works.
In the early hours of Friday, reports emerged of a “massive” and “co-ordinated” sabotage attack on the country’s high-speed national rail tracks, which essentially knocked out most lines to and from northern, eastern and western France.
While officials insisted the opening ceremony itself would suffer no disruption, Gabriel Attal, France’s acting prime minister, said: “The consequences for the rail network are massive and serious.”
“Our intelligence services and law enforcement agencies are mobilised to find and punish the perpetrators of these criminal acts,” he added.
French authorities had laid on a large, high-tech security regime to defend the Olympics, with Reaper drones in the skies and AI-powered cameras on the ground to keep an eye out for suspicious activity.
But Friday’s attack suggests they paid far less attention to key rail routes, which were sabotaged by old-fashioned arson rather than cyber-attacks.
The saboteurs chose to avoid the heavily guarded French capital and instead struck rural targets in the middle of the night. While hundreds of armed police officers and soldiers patrolled the streets of Paris, several cables were apparently set alight in the commune of Courtalain, around 150km south-west of the capital.
The local community’s social media page posted a picture of burnt-out cables in a shallow gully, with its protective paving stones discarded.
SNCF, France’s state-owned rail company, says the saboteurs either vandalised or tried to vandalise five signal boxes and electricity installations between 1am and 5.30am local time on Friday.
They struck not just at Courtalain but at Pagny-sur-Moselle, a village outside the eastern city of Metz, and Croisilles, not far from the northern city of Arras.
The targeted sites are small but are located at crucial junctions on the high-speed network.
Another attempted attack, on a TGV junction to the south east of Paris at Vergigny, was foiled by SNCF workers who happened to be carrying out maintenance in the early hours of Friday.
Matthieu Chabanel, head of SNCF Réseau, which runs SNCF’s infrastructure, said staff first detected a major problem at 4am.
“Fifty cables of 10 wires each makes 500 cables to reconnect linked to installations that are essential for safety, such as signalling,” he told Le Monde.
Patrice Vergriete, the French transport minister, said that France had received no warning of the attacks but that “we are preparing for (others)”.
“Today we are on alert, so obviously we have mobilised all security forces, as well as drones, so today we have greatly increased our vigilance”, he told TF1.
SNCF railway workers work at one of the targeted sites along the network - REUTERS/Brian Snyder
It remains unclear who is behind the crippling attacks that affected 250,000 passengers on Friday and are estimated to hit 800,000 over the weekend.
Senior figures have suggested the sabotage could have been carried out by hard-Left radicals or Russia, whose athletes have been barred from the opening ceremony.
But whoever committed this crime knew what they were doing as they chose strategic “switch points” to cause maximum damage. “For one fire, you hit two destinations”, said Jean-Pierre Farandou, head of SNCF.
“Part of France is under attack. The French are under attack,” he told BFMTV.
Friday was a huge day of departures for hundreds of thousands of French leaving Paris to go on holiday by train and car. Thousands more were due to arrive in Paris to attend the opening ceremony.
The saboteurs “knew where to hit”, said Mr Attal, adding that they had “knowledge of the network”.
“What we know, what we can see is that this operation has been planned, coordinated, that key points have been targeted which shows a kind of knowledge of the [train] network,” he added.
Burnt-out cables near Courtalain, around 150km south west of Paris - Mayor of Vald'Yerre/Franck Marchand
One in four Eurostar trains was cancelled on Friday and over the weekend, spoiling Olympic plans for some British fans.
Toby Morris told The Telegraph a friend gave him boxing tickets along with £250 train tickets to Paris as a gift.
“I thought I’d come here to try my chances, but they’ve said I definitely can’t get on another train today, so I just won’t be able to go now,” he said.
Gérald Darmanin, the French interior minister, told the press that the sabotage had no “direct consequence on the organisation of the Olympic Games”.
However, Downing Street said Sir Keir Starmer had to change his travel plans as he was meant to travel on the Eurostar to Paris but flew instead.
Sir Keir earlier insisted that travel disruption would not “overshadow” the Olympic Games.
SNCF urged passengers to postpone their trips, stay away from train stations and await text message instructions, but by Friday afternoon, traffic was slowly resuming to western France – with one in three trains operating – while trains to the east and north had resumed with delays.
Valérie Pécresse, the Paris regional council head, said: “Clearly this attack is not a coincidence. This attack is an attempt to destabilise France.”
Suspicions of Russian involvement were raised this week when a Russian reality TV “bachelor” turned Le Cordon Bleu-trained chef was unmasked as an alleged spy plotting to sabotage the Olympics.
Jérôme Poirot, terrorism expert for RMC-BFMTV, a French television and radio network, added: “We know that Russia and other countries want to interfere with the Olympic Games. There may be a plan in place to prevent the opening ceremony.”
Israel, on the other hand, blamed Iran. Israel Katz, Israel’s foreign minister, said: “The sabotage of railway infrastructure across France ahead of the Paris 2024 Olympics was planned and executed under the influence of Iran’s axis of evil and radical Islam.”
But Mr Attal advised against jumping to conclusions.
“The investigation is starting, and I would urge everyone to exercise caution. What we know, what we can see, is that this operation was prepared, coordinated, that key points were targeted, which shows a kind of knowledge of the network in order to know where to strike”, he said.
Emmanuel Macron declined to comment.
Asked if the arson attacks were the work of Russia or a terrorist group, Amélie Oudéa-Castera, the French sports minister, responded: “Maybe,” before adding: “It could also be protesters – even French people.”
Gabriel Attal, France's acting prime minister, said the saboteurs had 'knowledge of the network' and 'knew where to hit' - Tschaen Eric/Pool/ABACA/Shutterstock
It emerged on Friday that a similar incendiary device to the ones found at the sabotage sites on Friday was detected in May on a high-speed line between Marseille and Aix-en-Provence. An investigation was launched but no arrests were made.
Jean de Gliniasty, the former French ambassador to Moscow, told LCI the threat could have come from the far-Left.
“There’s a tradition in France of black blocs, every time there’s a demonstration they destroy, they break things,” he said. “In fact, France has been facing these problems for several years now, and we haven’t managed to solve them.”
In 2008, French anti-terrorist police arrested 10 members of a “violent anarchist movement” for sabotaging power cables on high-speed TGV train lines. Severe delays were caused when power was cut by metal bars hooked onto overhead electric cables on TGV lines around Paris.
However, in what was called a judicial “fiasco”, the “Tarnac ten” were later all acquitted.
Some French unions, including the powerful Leftist CGT, had called for strikes during the Games over working conditions but these were mainly withdrawn due to concessions.
Paris prosecutors said an investigation has been launched into charges of “damaging property likely to harm the fundamental interests of the nation”, “damage and attempted damage by dangerous means in an organised gang”, “attacks on an automated data processing system in an organised gang” and “criminal conspiracy”.
No comments:
Post a Comment