Monday, September 19, 2022

Sealed cave of artifacts from era of King Rameses II found by accident in Israel park


Israel Antiquities Authority photo

Mark Price
Mon, September 19, 2022

Construction crews working at Israel’s Palmachim Beach National Park found a cave from the time of King Rameses II, revealing “what looks like an ‘Indiana Jones’ film set,” according to the Israel Antiquities Authority.

The discovery was made Sept. 14, when digging equipment created a hole that offered a view inside a mysterious room, officials said. Palmachim Beach National Park is south of Tel Aviv, on the Mediterranean coast.

“Archaeologists ... descended a ladder into the astonishing space that appeared to have frozen in time,” the authority reported in a Facebook post.

“The hewn cave was square in form with a central supporting pillar. Several dozens of intact pottery and bronze artifacts were lain out in the cave, exactly as they were arranged in the burial ceremony, about 3,300 years ago. These vessels were burial offerings that accompanied the deceased in the belief that they would serve the dead in the afterlife.”

Officials did not report if any bones or other human remains were among the artifacts, which included pottery and bronze items.

The cave has been dated to the era of King Rameses II, “the Pharaoh associated with the Biblical Exodus from Egypt,” officials said.

“The fact that the cave was sealed ... will allow us the employ the modern scientific methods available today, to retrieve much information from the artifacts ... not visible to the naked eye,” according to Eli Yannai, a Bronze Age expert with the Israel Antiquities Authority.

“The cave may furnish a complete picture of the Late Bronze Age funerary customs.”

Much of the pottery found was intact, including storage jars and footed chalices, officials said. Some of the containers had been brought from as far as Lebanon and Cyprus and may have held “expensive commodities,” officials said.

Guards were posted at the site immediately after the discovery, but “a few items were looted from the cave before it was sealed up,” officials said. An investigation of the theft is underway.

“Within a few days, we will formulate a plan to carry out the research and the protection of this unique site, which is a feast for the archaeological world and for the ancient history of the land of Israel,” the authority reports.

Palmahim National Park includes “the remains of the ancient port city of Yavne-Yam from the Middle Canaanite period,” according to the park’s web site. Past excavations in the park have uncovered “ancient waterworks and agricultural apparatus,” officials said.

"Extremely rare" ancient burial cave found on beach in Israel




CBSNews 

Israeli archaeologists on Sunday announced the "once-in-a-lifetime" discovery of a burial cave from the time of ancient Egyptian Pharaoh Rameses II, filled with dozens of pottery pieces and bronze artifacts.

The cave was uncovered on a beach Tuesday, when a mechanical digger working at the Palmahim national park hit its roof, with archaeologists using a ladder to descend into the spacious, man-made square cave.

In a video released by the Israel Antiquities Authority, amazed archaeologists shine flashlights on dozens of pottery vessels in a variety of forms and sizes, dating back to the reign of the ancient Egyptian king who died in 1213 B.C.

In a Facebook post, the authority said the burial cave "looks like an 'Indiana Jones' film set."

"The Israel Antiquity Authority archaeologists mobilized to the site, descended a ladder into the astonishing space that appeared to have frozen in time," the authority said in a statement.

Bowls — some of them painted red, some containing bones — chalices, cooking pots, storage jars, lamps and bronze arrowheads or spearheads could be seen in the cave.

The objects were burial offerings to accompany the deceased on their last journey to the afterlife, found untouched since being placed there about 3,300 years ago.

At least one relatively intact skeleton was also found in two rectangular plots in the corner of the cave.

"The cave may furnish a complete picture of the Late Bronze Age funerary customs," said Eli Yannai, an IAA Bronze Age expert.

It is an "extremely rare ... once-in-a-lifetime discovery," Yannai said, pointing to the extra fortune of the cave having remained sealed until its recent uncovering.

The findings date to the reign of Rameses II, who controlled Canaan, a territory that roughly encompassed modern day Israel and the Palestinian territories.

The provenance of the pottery vessels — Cyprus, Lebanon, northern Syria, Gaza and Jaffa — is testimony to the "lively trading activity that took place along the coast", Yannai said in an IAA statement.

Another IAA archaeologist, David Gelman, theorized as to the identity of the skeletons in the cave, located in what is today a popular beach in central Israel.

"The fact that these people were buried along with weapons, including entire arrows, shows that these people might have been warriors, perhaps they were guards on ships -- which may have been the reason they were able to obtain vessels from all around the area," he said.

Regardless of who the inhabitants of the cave were, the find was "incredible," said Gelman.

"Burial caves are rare as it is, and finding one that hasn't been touched since it was first used 3,300 years ago is something you rarely ever find," he said.

"It feels like something out of an Indiana Jones movie: just going into the ground and everything is just laying there as it was initially — intact pottery vessels, weapons, vessels made out of bronze, burials just as they were."

The cave has been resealed and is under guard while a plan for its excavation is being formulated, the IAA said.

It noted that "a few items" had been looted from it in the short period of time between its discovery and closure.

The discovery marks the latest in a string of recent archaeological finds in Israel.

Last month, scientists unearthed a lavish 1,200-year-old estate in Israel's desert south, just two months after a rare ancient mosque was unearthed in the same region.

Also in August, archaeologists announced they recently unearthed the titanic tusk of a prehistoric pachyderm near a kibbutz in southern Israel.

Meanwhile, the recent discovery of an ornate Byzantine-era mosaic in Gaza — uncovered just a half mile from the Israeli border — has set off excitement among archaeologists. But it is also drawing calls for better protection of Gaza's antiquities, a fragile collection of sites threatened by a lack of awareness and resources as well as the constant risk of conflict between Israel and local Palestinian militants.


Pandemic’s end ‘in sight,’ but COVID isn’t going away. What’s that mean for the future?


Debbie Cockrell
Mon, September 19, 2022

A recent news conference with global health officials on the world’s outlook for COVID-19 seemed like the news we’ve all been waiting for — that the end is “in sight” for the pandemic.

The Sept. 14 briefing from the World Health Organization offered optimism over signs the pandemic is winding down globally. WHO Director-General Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus announced a milestone reached in the pandemic’s global numbers.

“Last week, the number of weekly reported deaths from COVID-19 was the lowest since March 2020,” he said. “We have never been in a better position to end the pandemic. We are not there yet, but the end is in sight.”

Comparing the progress to running a marathon, he added, “We can see the finish line.”

The United States had the highest number of weekly deaths for any country reported worldwide with 2,306, according to WHO’s Sept. 14 report, but that was down 21 percent from the previous week. New U.S. cases also were down 26 percent.

Closer to home, Washington’s state of emergency and final pandemic emergency orders are set to end by Halloween.

“The end,” though, won’t be a definitive cessation of cases and health care problems tied to the pandemic. Indications point to ongoing illness and vaccination boosters as a matter of course for a long time to come.

The CDC shows low numbers of cases now requiring hospitalization, but it also shows infections still very much active nationwide.

Welcome to a new era where COVID is not completely over but is not as life threatening as it once was, at least for now.
PIERCE COUNTY

In Pierce County, weekly reported COVID-19 numbers have been steadily declining since a small spike in May. At the start of the year, weekly cases fueled by the Omicron variant peaked at 21,665 on Jan. 2.

The latest report from the Tacoma-Pierce County Health Department listed 533 cases and six deaths for Sept. 4-10.

In the months since the January peak, health officials have noted that home testing and unreported positive cases have contributed to lower case numbers. Many cases that are circulating are milder, thanks to vaccines and boosters.

The level of deaths and hospitalizations, two factors that have consistently demonstrated the pandemic’s peaks and valleys, are both low and staying there for now.

TPCHD said in its Sept. 13 update that the seven-day hospitalization rate per 100,000 was 2.1 for Aug. 26-Sept. 1. That’s 19.2 percent lower than the previous week. The rate of deaths per 100,000 per week could not be calculated, it noted on its COVID-19 data dashboard, because fewer than 10 deaths had been reported.

Wastewater monitoring, another way to track COVID community levels, is something the health department is still working to add context to as part of local reporting, according to Kenny Via, department media representative. TPCHD first announced that program in May.

Readings are posted on the CDC website. They indicated lower levels detected at two Pierce County sewersheds representing a population of 338,855.

For now, COVID-19 has retreated from the spotlight at the health department’s twice-a-month meetings.

“We are no longer doing regular COVID-19 updates at every BOH meeting,” Via told The News Tribune in response to questions. “But we’ve gone to doing Communicable Disease updates once a month at the study sessions that include info on our response to both COVID and monkeypox.”

Those updates, he added, are expected to continue once a month “for a while.”

“Occasionally we will also include updates about monkeypox or COVID in the director comments at regular meetings as well, if needed,” he noted.

The paradox of COVID tracking can be seen in the two national maps the CDC provides and the data behind them. Its community level map, based on hospital admissions and percent of staffed inpatient beds occupied by COVID-19 patients, showed low levels for most Washington counties as well as more than half of counties nationwide as of Sept. 15.


COVID-19 community levels of transmission reported as of Sept. 15.


Its community transmission level map, which measures of the presence and spread of SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19, still showed high levels in 83 percent of counties nationwide, including most of Washington.

“High” is defined as more than 100 new cases per 100,000 persons in the past seven days, along with more than 10 percent of positive NAATs (nucleic acid amplification tests) during the past 7 days. If the two indicators reflect different transmission levels, the higher level is chosen, according to CDC.


Community transmission levels reported this week by the CDC.

For example, Pierce County was at a substantial level with its cases, one level below high. That contrasts with its low level reading at the community level.

So while the WHO might see a light at the end of the COVID tunnel, most parts of the United States still see cases circulating, they just aren’t rising to hospital-level serious, thanks to vaccinations and previous illness.

That gets us to what could be the next era: endemic.

Dr. Jeremy Luban, virologist with UMass Chan Medical School of the University of Massachusetts, was asked in an August interview whether the nation is now living with endemic COVID, evolving into a general widespread population-infecting illness like influenza.

That moment, envisioned by the WHO’s anticipated finish line, seems close, given the data.

“If we get to the point where the virus continues to spread and infect us, but it rarely causes severe disease because most of us have some immunity against it, we would say that SARS-CoV-2 has become endemic,” he said.

He compared the difference between the coming fall and last fall, when the world saw the Delta variant fade and Omicron kick in with an explosion of new cases and deaths.

“It’s possible that this coming fall is going to be the first relatively normal period for us since the beginning of the pandemic,” he said. “It may be the beginning of the real endemic phase for us, where most people who get infection have a common cold. But we don’t know that with any certainty, and with SARS-CoV-2 we have to be prepared for the worst.”

BOOSTERS

Going forward, COVID-19 boosters are expected to be offered much like the flu shot each year, updated depending on the variant. Recently, the new “bivalent” booster was introduced, targeting both the original COVID-19 strain and the now-circulating BA.4 and BA.5 Omicron variants.

In Pierce County, 53 percent of eligible residents have received at least one booster, according to state Department of Health dashboard.

Tacoma-Pierce County Health Department noted in a Sept. 8 update that 25.8 percent of residents are up to date with all COVID-19 vaccines, meaning the two shots in the primary series and all recommended boosters, including the new version.

Federal health officials are encouraging people to get the new booster by Halloween to offer protection in time for holiday gatherings. CDC booster guidance is posted online.

Nigel Turner is division director of communicable disease with TPCHD. Turner noted in an online update about the new boosters earlier this month, “During the peak six months of the Omicron wave, compared to those who completed their initial vaccine series, unvaccinated people in Pierce County were six times more likely to be hospitalized with COVID-19 and seven times more likely to die from COVID-19.”

LONG COVID

For those who’ve been infected, the threat of long COVID looms, with an estimated 1 in 13 adults in the U.S. currently experiencing illness long after COVID-19 has passed.

Dr. Janna Friedly is treating long-COVID patients at the UW Medicine Post COVID Rehabilitation and Recovery Clinic at Harborview Medical Center. Friedly told The state Department of Health in an interview published Friday that research now suggests more than 200 different symptoms.

“The way I think of COVID-19 is that it’s like gasoline, it sets everything on fire,” Friedly said. “If you had underlying conditions and you get COVID-19, the disease will light everything on fire and make things worse.”

Friedly noted that “A lot of people who have chronic medical conditions or are older may not necessarily associate the worsening of their symptoms or their condition with their COVID-19 infection, when in fact it may actually be related to long COVID.

“Then there are people who were considered healthy before their infection and now are experiencing debilitating symptoms. We’re not quite sure if it’s that it’s more prevalent in those populations, or that they’re recognizing it as long COVID and seeking out care more,” Friedly said.

She speaks from experience and offers optimism for those still struggling.

“We see many, many patients who recover completely. I consider myself in that category. I had symptoms for about nine months after my initial COVID-19 infection and feel fully recovered now.”

Long COVID for WA health systems? ‘Hospitals are struggling and will be for awhile’
NO JOE, IT'S NOT
President Biden declares that the COVID-19 pandemic 'is over' weeks before the midterm elections

Adam Sabes
FOX NEWS
Sun, September 18, 2022 

President Biden said during a television interview on Sunday night that the COVID-19 pandemic "is over."

"Is the pandemic over?," a reporter asked Biden. "The pandemic is over. We still have a problem with COVID. We're still doing a lot of work on it," Biden responded.

Biden made the statement during an interview with CBS' "60 Minutes," which was his first interview with a news organization in seven months.

"If you notice, no one's wearing a mask, everybody seems to be in pretty good shape," Biden added while he walked through the Detroit Auto Show.


US President Joe Biden 
MANDEL NGAN/AFP via Getty ImagesMore

Biden has used the COVID-19 pandemic emergency as a reason for his administration's plan to end Title 42 as well as the recent student loan handout.

Biden's remarks about the COVID-19 pandemic come as America is just about a month and a half away from the midterm elections.

Biden says the 'pandemic is over' despite the US maintaining one of the highest death rates worldwide with nearly 400 Americans dying of COVID-19 daily

Isabella Zavarise
Sun, September 18, 2022 

President Joe Biden speaks with reporters on the South Lawn of the White House on September 1, 2022.
AP Photo/Susan Walsh

President Biden said the COVID-19 pandemic was over in an interview with CBS News on Sunday.

"We're still doing a lot of work on it, but the pandemic is over," said Biden.

According to the CDC, the US is averaging around 400 deaths per day.


President Joe Biden said the COVID-19 pandemic was over in an interview with CBS News on Sunday, despite the US maintaining one of the highest death rates worldwide.

The comment was made during a tour of the Detroit Auto Show with 60 Minutes correspondent Scott Pelley. As they were walking, Pelley asked Biden: "Is the pandemic over?"

"The pandemic is over," Biden said, but acknowledged the virus is still a problem. "We still have a problem with COVID. We're still doing a lot of work on it," he added.

Gesturing to attendees who weren't wearing masks to support his point, Biden said "Everybody seems to be in pretty good shape. And so I think it's changing. And I think this is a perfect example of it."

While cases are falling, Biden's comments come as hundreds of Americans continue to die from the infectious disease. According to data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the US is averaging around 400 deaths per day.

As of September 17, data from Johns Hopkins University found that the US has some of the highest COVID-19 figures globally in terms of cases and deaths. Next to the US is Japan, with 1,139 deaths recorded over the previous week.

States across the US are rolling back pandemic-related restrictions such as lifting mask mandates. Federal regulations still require passengers flying to the US from international destinations to be vaccinated.

In May, the President told Americans to not grow numb as the country's death toll rose to 1 million people.

On Wednesday, a spokesperson from the World Health Organization said the "end is in sight" but urged countries to maintain their vigilance, according to Reuters.

The news outlet reported that experts from the organization will meet again in October to decide whether the pandemic is still an international public health emergency.

Biden says 'the pandemic is over' even as death toll, costs mount


 A woman takes a coronavirus disease (COVID-19) test at a pop-up testing site in New York

Sun, September 18, 2022

By Trevor Hunnicutt

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - U.S. President Joe Biden said in an interview aired on Sunday that "the pandemic is over," even though the country continues to grapple with coronavirus infections that kill hundreds of Americans daily.

"The pandemic is over," Biden said during an interview conducted with CBS' "60 Minutes" program on Wednesday on the sidelines of the Detroit auto show, an event which drew thousands of visitors.

"We still have a problem with COVID. We're still doing a lotta work on it. But the pandemic is over. If you notice, no one's wearing masks. Everybody seems to be in pretty good shape. And so I think it's changing."

The toll of the COVID-19 pandemic has diminished significantly since early in Biden's term when more than 3,000 Americans per day were dying, as enhanced care, medications and vaccinations have become more widely available.

But nearly 400 people a day continue to die from COVID-19 in the United States, according to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Biden spent more than two weeks isolated in the White House after two bouts with COVID-19, starting in July. His wife Jill contracted the virus in August. Biden has said the mild cases were a testament to the improvements in care during his presidency.

Biden has asked Congress for $22.4 billion more in funding to prepare for a potential fall case surge.

Reporting by Trevor Hunnicutt; Editing by Shri Navaratnam


Health experts dismayed by President Biden’s view that the pandemic is over: ‘Hell no — not even close’

Ciara Linnane -19/09/2022 - AFP


© joseph prezioso/Agence France-Presse/Getty Images

Health experts reacted with dismay Monday to President Joe Biden’s assertion that the pandemic is over in an interview on “60 Minutes” that aired on Sunday.

“We still have a problem with COVID. We’re still doing a lot of work on it. … But the pandemic is over,” Biden told CBS News correspondent Scott Pelley. “If you notice, no one’s wearing masks. Everybody seems to be in pretty good shape. And so I think it’s changing.”

Eric Topol, director of the Scripps Research Translational Institute, accused the president of magical thinking and perhaps having too much confidence in the new bivalent boosters.

Others noted that with more than 400 deaths from COVID every day on average, the U.S. is suffering 9/11-level casualties every week, hardly a sign that the pandemic is fully contained.

Others said there’s no way of knowing what will happen once winter sets in and people spend more time indoors together.

Just last week, the head of the World Health Organization said that while the end is in sight, “we’re not there yet.”

The statement sent the stocks of vaccine makers sharply lower. Moderna was last down 9.5%, Pfizer was down 1.8% and BioNTech was down 11.8%. Novavax which had its protein-based vaccine win authorization in the U.S. in July, was down 2.4%.

U.S. known cases of COVID are continuing to ease, although the true tally is likely higher than reported, because data is not being collected on the many people who are testing at home.

The daily average for new cases stood at 61,712 on Sunday, according to a New York Times tracker, down 29% from two weeks ago. The tracker is showing that cases are rising in seven states, all in the Northeast — Connecticut, Maine, New York, New Jersey, Massachusetts, New Hampshire and Vermont — and that cases are flat in Pennsylvania.

See also: Impact of COVID-19 on life expectancy is misleading

The daily average for hospitalizations was down 12%, to 33,143, while the daily average for deaths was down 6%, to 464.

From the CDC: Stay Up to Date with COVID-19 Vaccines Including Boosters

Coronavirus Update: MarketWatch’s daily roundup has been curating and reporting all the latest developments every weekday since the coronavirus pandemic began

Other COVID-19 news you should know about:

• A bus reportedly taking 47 people to COVID-19 quarantine in southwestern China crashed before dawn Sunday morning, killing 27 and injuring 20 others, the Associated Press reported. The bus overturned on an expressway in Guizhou province, according to a brief statement from the Sandu county police, which did not mention any connection to quarantine.

• The beer is flowing at Munich’s world-famous Oktoberfest for the first time since 2019, the AP reported separately. With three knocks of a hammer and the traditional cry of “O’zapft is” — “It’s tapped” — Mayor Dieter Reiter inserted the tap in the first keg at noon on Saturday, officially opening the festivities after a two-year break forced by the coronavirus pandemic.

• Cities from Anchorage to New Orleans have ended or are winding down a program that housed homeless people in hotels and motels during the pandemic, the AP reported. The program was designed to avoid crowding in shelters. In Denver, Federal Emergency Management Agency funds directed through the Colorado Coalition for the Homeless helped keep a Quality Inn running for the past two and a half years. But the $9 million spent to lease the hotel from its owner and an additional $5 to $6 million in operational costs became unsustainable, said John Parvensky, president and CEO of the coalition.The COVID-19 pandemic has renewed interest in the practice of testing sewage to track outbreaks of disease, including polio, an outbreak of which prompted a disaster emergency declaration in New York state earlier this month. The Wall Street Journal visited a Bay Area wastewater facility to find out how testing works and what it can tell us about public health. (Photo illustration: Ryan Trefes)

Here’s what the numbers say

The global tally of confirmed cases of COVID-19 topped 612 million on Monday, while the death toll rose above 6.52 million, according to data aggregated by Johns Hopkins University.

The U.S. leads the world with 95.7 million cases and 1,053,461 fatalities.

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s tracker shows that 224.6 million people living in the U.S. are fully vaccinated, equal to 67.7% of the total population. Just 109.2 million have had a booster, equal to 48.6% of the vaccinated population, and 22.5 million of those 50 and over who are eligible for a second booster have had one, equal to 34.7% of those who received a first booster.

Biden declares COVID ‘pandemic is over.’ Here’s what experts say about the data
Alex Brandon/AP

Julia Marnin  

Since President Joe Biden’s declaration that the COVID-19 pandemic is done, a number of health experts are speaking out in response with some pointing to virus data.

“The pandemic is over,” Biden said Sunday, Sept. 18 during an interview with “60 Minutes.” “We still have a problem with COVID. We’re still doing a lotta work on it…but the pandemic is over. If you notice, no one’s wearing masks. Everybody seems to be in pretty good shape. And so I think it’s changing.”

A snapshot of recent U.S. data shows there have been more than 2 million confirmed COVID-19 cases and about 12,700 deaths due to the virus across the country within the past 28 days, according to Johns Hopkins University. Since the start of the pandemic, more than 1 million people have died nationwide.

The dean of Brown University’s School of Public Health, Dr. Megan Ranney, disgreed with the president’s assertion that the pandemic is “over” by referencing recent death counts.

“Is the pandemic DIFFERENT? Sure,” Ranney wrote on Twitter on Sept. 18. “We have vaccines & infection-induced immunity. We have treatments. We have tests (while they last). The fatality rate is way down. And so we respond to it differently.”

“But over?! With 400 deaths a day?! I call malarkey,” Ranney added.

In the week before Sept. 15, 2,743 people died from COVID-19 in the U.S., according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Based on the data, that is about 391 deaths each day.

In another Sept. 18 tweet, Dr. Eric Feigl-Ding, an epidemiologist and health economist, wrote “with all due respect, @JoeBiden — you’re wrong. Pandemic is not over,” and noted the number of deaths within the past week.

“Almost 3,000 Americans are dying from #COVID19 every single week. A weekly 9/11 is a very big deal,” Feigl-Ding added, referencing how nearly 3,000 people died in during the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks.

What is the definition of a pandemic?

There are several similar definitions of a pandemic out there that emphasize one detail in particular — it is a global occurrence.

Columbia University defines a pandemic as cutting “across international boundaries.”

“A true influenza pandemic occurs when almost simultaneous transmission takes place worldwide,” according to a scholarly paper published 2011 in the National Library of Medicine.

Internationally, there have been nearly 16 million COVID-19 cases and about 54,000 deaths within the past 28 days, Johns Hopkins University data shows.

During a Sept. 14 World Health Organization news briefing, WHO Director-General Dr. Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus said “Last week, the number of weekly reported deaths from COVID-19 was the lowest since March 2020.”

“We have never been in a better position to end the pandemic,” Ghebreyesus added. “We are not there yet, but the end is in sight.”

When asked about what is next for COVID-19 and the pandemic, Dr. William Gruber, senior vice president of Pfizer Vaccine Clinical Research and Development, told McClatchy News in an interview on Sept. 12 that “no one can absolutely predict the future, but we’ve seen with each successive wave that there have been fewer hospitalizations.”

“I’m optimistic that we’ll see a continuum where yes, COVID-19 is something we have to reckon with every winter, like we do influenza. But it won’t create the degree of illness that we’ve seen filling up our hospitals and overwhelming our medical personnel,” Gruber added, “provided we do vaccinate, and provide protection to individuals so the virus doesn’t have an opportunity to mutate and come back and produce serious disease.”

More experts comment on the status of the COVID pandemic

Dr. Eric Topol, a cardiologist and director of the Scripps Research Translational Institute, wrote Sept. 19 on Twitter that “remember when the pandemic was over in June 2021, when we were down to <12,000 (real number) confirmed cases per day, and Independence was declared?”

“Then came Delta. And then Omicron BA.1, BA.2, BA.2.12.1, BA.5,” Topol added.

Meanwhile, Dr. Vinay Prasad, an epidemiology and biostatistics professor at the University of California San Francisco, described Biden’s pandemic comments as “important.”

“The emergency or pandemic phase is over,” Prasad wrote on Twitter on Sept. 18. “COVID will be around for tens of thousands of years. Time to stop using EUA at FDA and time to actively advise people to throw away their n95s and get back to living. Getting COVID is inevitable.”

Dr. Gregg Gonsalves, an associate professor of epidemiology at the Yale School of Public Health, described Biden’s Sept. 18 statement about the pandemic being “over” as “deeply craven, cynical” in a Sept. 19 Twitter thread.

Gonsalves added that it “dishonors our 1M+ dead, those who have fought to keep people alive and safe.”

As of Sept. 19, about 50% of the U.S. lives in a location where COVID-19 levels in the community are considered medium or high, while the other half of the nation lives in a location where virus transmission levels are considered low, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

U.S. COVID-19 cases were dominated by the omicron BA.5 subvariant for the week ending Sept. 17 as it made up 84.8% of cases, agency data estimates show.



Proposed federal abortion ban evokes 19th-century Comstock Act – a law so unpopular it triggered the centurylong backlash that led to Roe

Amy Werbel, Professor of the History of Art, Fashion Institute of Technology (FIT)

Mon, September 19, 2022

THE CONVERSATION


A sign at a July 2022 abortion-rights protest in Santa Monica, California,
 recalls the country's long history of trying to restrict access to reproductive health care. 

Sen. Lindsey Graham has proposed a national U.S. abortion ban barring the procedure after 15 weeks. This push to restrict abortion access across the country follows a rash of new state laws passed by Republicans after the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade in June.

If American history is any guide, these efforts will ultimately neither reduce abortions nor remain settled law.

I am a historian who has studied American culture and law in the wake of the 1873 Comstock Act – the first U.S. effort to restrict access to birth control and abortions. My research finds that previous state and federal efforts to regulate the sexual expression and reproduction of Americans led to unintended consequences – and, in the long term, these laws failed.

Already, I see signs that new anti-abortion laws are triggering a similarly undermining backlash.

How ‘obscene’

In 1873, Congress hurriedly passed a law making it illegal to send “obscenities” through the U.S. mail. The legislation was branded the Comstock Act after its most vigorous proponent: Anthony Comstock, a U.S. postal inspector and evangelical Christian who believed sexual activity was a sin unless it occurred between a married man and woman for the purpose of procreation.

Birth control and substances used to induce abortion were included in the definition of “obscenity,” because Comstock and his supporters believed that life and death were God’s decisions. The law also banned mailing erotic images and literature. In Comstock’s expansive view, this category included images of athletes wearing tights.

A 1915 comic skewering the Comstock laws. The Masses

State versions of the original Comstock Law soon swept the United States. By 1900, 42 states had passed similar legislation outlawing the production, sale, possession or circulation of “obscene” matter in their own jurisdictions.

These statutes ruled until the Supreme Court declared a right to privacy in medical decision-making nearly 100 years later, in Griswold v. Connecticut (1965).

This is the same ruling that was cited eight years later to protect the right to have an abortion in the now defunct Roe v. Wade.

Impractical enforcement

Comstock zealously enforced the laws he’d advocated for, both as a detective for the privately funded New York Society for the Suppression of Vice, and as an inspector for the U.S. Post Office Department. In attempting to eradicate contraceptives – including condoms and early forms of diaphragms – Comstock organized the arrests of numerous defendants.

However, he had difficulty getting prosecutors, juries and judges to see the seriousness of many of the “crimes” he investigated. In the late 19th century, wealthier Americans already regularly used birth control.

“Of all the indictments prior to 1878, pending in the Court of General Sessions, not one has been tried the past year,” Comstock wrote in his 1879 annual report for the society.

In one of these cases, The New York Times reported, Comstock was chastised by a New York City district attorney named Phelps for his “sharp practice” in investigating Dr. Sarah Blakeslee Chase. These included his posing as a client to obtain birth control products and repeatedly harassing the suspect. A grand jury threw out the case, stating that it “did not think it for the public good.”

Even when Comstock obtained a conviction, many defendants were pardoned immediately.

Enforcing new anti-abortion laws is similarly unpopular with many legal professionals today. Shortly after the Supreme Court issued its opinion in Dobbs, more than 80 elected prosecutors vowed not to bring indictments in cases involving abortion.

As they recognize, conservative courts in jurisdictions with zealous anti-abortion prosecutors – who in some states are already enforcing new laws – will soon be filled with a host of extremely sympathetic defendants: relatives who assist children who are victims of rape in obtaining an illegal abortion, doctors saving the lives of mothers at risk, and those who choose to help pregnant cancer patients in making the best possible decisions for their health.

Enforcement of America’s new Comstock laws will likely once again make witnesses and defendants more sympathetic in the eyes of judges and jurors – and the public – undermining whatever support remains for these laws.

Beyond prosecutions, the tactics necessary to prevent women from obtaining abortions are even less practical today than they were in the late 19th century.

Enforcing anti-abortion laws may include restricting interstate travelblocking interstate and international postal services and attempting to censor information about sexual health. All of these would require laborious investigations and extensive cooperation from law enforcement agencies and private corporations who will likely have little desire to involve themselves in unpopular prosecutions.

And that’s assuming that any of these methods survive court challenges.

Uniting disparate factions

By the time of Anthony Comstock’s death in 1915, backlash to his zealous overreach had provoked growing solidarity among activists and attorneys determined to defeat his agenda.

Margaret Sanger at America’s first family planning clinic in New York. Bain News Service/PhotoQuest/Getty Images

Women’s rights activists, including Margaret Sanger, Emma Goldman and Mary Ware Dennett – formerly focused on competing goals and strategies – joined in common cause to repeal the Comstock laws. Their efforts led to the creation of new and powerful national civil liberties organizations, including Planned Parenthood and the American Civil Liberties Union. Both used lobbying and lawsuits to contribute to the death of the original Comstock laws.

These groups are still fighting new abortion restrictions today. And once again, post-Dobbs, disparate individuals and groups are raising their voices in common cause.

Obstetricians from around the country have begun lobbying politicians and forming their own pro-choice political action committees for the first time. TikTok influencers like Olivia Julianna are rallying young citizens to vote for pro-choice politicians. And diverse podcasters, from one-time provocateur Howard Stern to the hosts of the true crime show “My Favorite Murder,” are sharing resources with their listeners and expressing support for abortion rights.

Ballot box backlash

Newly registered and energized voters are turning out to support candidates and ballot initiatives that reflect the nation’s majority support for abortion rights.

Kansas roundly rejected an anti-abortion referendum in August 2022. And more states will soon vote on state constitutional protections for abortion, including Michigan.

The Comstock laws were not repealed quickly. And it’s now clear that American women’s right to reproductive health care remained tenuous after their demise.

Viewing the past as prologue, however, suggests that, once again, unpopular anti-abortion laws will cause unintended consequences that, in the long run, will render them both ineffective and ultimately futile.

This article is republished from The Conversation, an independent nonprofit news site dedicated to sharing ideas from academic experts. It was written by: Amy WerbelFashion Institute of Technology (FIT). The Conversation has a variety of fascinating free newsletters.

Read more: