Silver vine or catnip? When cats can choose, silver vine wins
Cats respond more reliably to silver vine than to catnip, despite catnip’s abundant active compounds
video:
The video clip for explaining the article.
view moreCredit: Reiko Uenoyama
What plant do cats love most?
In Europe and North America, many people would probably answer “catnip.” In Japan, the answer would more likely be silver vine (matatabi in Japanese). Both plants are famous for triggering the well-known feline response: cats rub their faces and bodies against them, roll on the ground, and sometimes lick or chew the leaves.
Previous work by the same research group showed that these plant-derived compounds can repel mosquitoes, suggesting that the behavior may function as a form of natural pest defense. But what happens when cats encounter catnip and silver vine at the same time in a more natural, free-choice setting? Do they choose silver vine, catnip, or both?
A research team from Iwate University and Nagoya University in Japan has found that domestic cats respond more reliably to silver vine (Actinidia polygama) than to catnip (Nepeta cataria) under free-choice conditions. The finding challenges a simple assumption: that a plant containing more active chemical compounds will necessarily produce a stronger behavioral response.
In outdoor experiments in Morioka, Japan, the researchers placed fresh silver vine branches and leaves near living catnip plants in a garden that free-roaming cats could enter and leave. Over ten presentation nights, six identifiable cats were recorded visiting the site. Five of them showed rubbing and rolling behavior toward silver vine, while none showed the same behavior toward either the growing catnip plant or freshly harvested catnip material. The team then compared plant extracts. When catnip and silver vine extracts were presented in the same outdoor setting, cats again showed a stronger tendency to respond to silver vine-derived stimuli.
To test whether this pattern was limited to a small group of local free-roaming cats, the researchers next studied 22 captive purebred cats housed at two facilities in Japan. The cats represented breeds originating from Europe, the United States, and the Middle East. They were tested in a large indoor environment where they could move freely, rather than in individual cages, allowing them to approach, investigate, or ignore the stimuli on their own. When catnip and silver vine extracts were presented simultaneously, 15 cats responded only to the silver vine extract, three responded only to the catnip extract, one responded to both, and three sniffed the papers but did not rub or roll. Overall, cats were significantly more likely to respond to silver vine extract than to catnip extract.
The result was surprising because chemical analysis showed that the catnip used in the study contained abundant active compounds. In fact, the catnip extract contained substantial amounts of cis-trans nepetalactone, a major active compound known to induce the feline response. The total amount of measured bioactive compounds in catnip was about 170 times higher than that in the silver vine extract used in the study.
Further laboratory tests confirmed that these catnip compounds were indeed biologically active. When cats were tested individually in cages, catnip extract and purified nepetalactone isomers found in catnip, compounds made of the same atoms but arranged in slightly different shapes, could trigger the typical rubbing and rolling response. This means that the weak response to catnip under free-choice conditions cannot be explained simply by the absence of active chemicals.
“At first glance, this was counterintuitive,” says Professor Masao Miyazaki of Iwate University, who led the research project. “One might expect a plant containing more active compounds, and compounds that clearly work in laboratory tests, to trigger a stronger behavioral response under free-choice conditions. But that was not what we observed.”
Why cats responded less reliably to catnip remains unclear. One possibility is that fresh catnip may release too much of these active compounds. In other words, the odor may be too strong when cats encounter the living plant. If the odor is intense and continuously released, cats may detect it but be less likely to proceed to rubbing and rolling.
Interestingly, a similar observation was recorded more than 250 years ago. In The Gardeners Dictionary, published in 1768, Philip Miller wrote that cats were especially fond of catmint, now commonly known as catnip, “when it is withered,” but that they tended not to disturb it when a large quantity grew together. Although this was an anecdotal observation rather than a controlled experiment, it closely resembles the pattern suggested by the present study: the amount and presentation of catnip odor may strongly influence whether cats choose to engage with it.
This idea may also help explain why many commercial catnip products use dried leaves. During drying, some volatile nepetalactone isomers may evaporate, possibly reducing the odor to a level that is more effective for inducing the feline response.
“Catnip can make cats respond in laboratory tests, but that does not mean cats will choose it in a more natural, free-choice setting,” says first author Reiko Uenoyama, an assistant professor at Iwate University. “Our study shows that what cats can respond to and what they actually choose are not always the same.”
The findings suggest that real-world behavior depends not only on the presence of active compounds, but also on how the odor is presented and whether animals voluntarily approach and interact with it.
“This study suggests that silver vine is a particularly reliable stimulus for inducing cats’ self-anointing behavior,” says Professor Miyazaki. “It also reminds us that animal behavior should be studied in settings where animals can make their own choices.”
These insights may help improve enrichment materials for domestic cats and provide a broader framework for understanding how chemical cues influence animal behavior in real-world environments.
Journal
Journal of Chemical Ecology
Method of Research
News article
Subject of Research
Animals
Article Title
Free-Roaming and Captive Cats Prefer Silver Vine to Catnip for Self-Anointing
Article Publication Date
12-May-2026