Sunday, September 15, 2024

HK pivots to Asean, Belt and Road partners as ties with the West deteriorate

Magdalene Fung
Hong Kong Correspondent

Hong Kong Chief Executive John Lee said his government was doing everything it could to strengthen ties with Asean. 
PHOTO: BLOOMBERG

Updated  Sep 15, 2024

HONG KONG – Hong Kong has intensified efforts to carve out international space for itself, especially among developing economies, as it increasingly comes under fire from the West for its governance.

Chief Executive John Lee on Sept 13 said his government was doing everything it could to strengthen ties with Asean, including improving trade, business and cultural links with the regional bloc.

On Sept 11, he talked up Hong Kong’s value to the world as a “super connector”, touting its pivotal role in inking deals with countries in China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), as Beijing said it would expand the city’s scope of participation in the initiative.

Mr Lee’s speeches came after the United States on Sept 11 passed a Bill targeting the closure of Hong Kong’s trade offices in the country and on Sept 6 warned US businesses and individuals of the rising risks of operating in the city under its national security law.

The law was first imposed by Beijing on Hong Kong in June 2020, with Hong Kong later enacting its own legislation in March 2024.

Hundreds of activists have been arrested and dozens charged under the regulations, which criminalise treason, sedition and external interference, among other offences.


Mr Lee on Sept 14 warned that US businesses would “foot the bill” for their “very shameless and ugly political tactics” if they shut Hong Kong’s trade offices in America.

Separately, Britain on Sept 12 said in a parliamentary report on Hong Kong that the city had prioritised national security over the freedoms and rights of its residents.

The growing criticism from the West that Hong Kong has faced in recent years has contributed to a fresh urgency within Mr Lee’s administration to improve its ties with the rest of the world, an international relations expert said.

“In the past, Hong Kong used to target the developed world more in its external relations efforts, such as reaching out to the US and countries in Europe,” Dr Wilson Chan, director of policy research and co-founder of local think-tank Pagoda Institute, told The Straits Times.

“But now, to sidestep the growing geopolitical tensions with the West, Hong Kong has recognised that it needs to diversify its business and trade networks and has hence shifted its focus to Asean, the Middle East, Africa and other Belt and Road countries. So the government is now more eager to engage with these fast-developing economies.”

Dr Chan described Hong Kong’s approach as a form of “paradiplomacy” centred around global economic engagement. Paradiplomacy refers to the involvement of non-central governments and organisations in conducting international relations.

Under the one country, two systems framework, China’s central government conducts foreign affairs relating to Hong Kong. As a special administrative region, however, Hong Kong has the autonomy to handle certain external affairs on its own, including trade, finance, tourism, culture and sports.

The city is also authorised to participate in inter-governmental international organisations including the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (Apec), the World Trade Organisation (WTO) and the World Health Organisation (WHO).

Hong Kong has over the past year engaged in a rapid string of global outreach efforts to bring together the city’s top leaders and those from its surrounding countries.

A Belt and Road Summit on Sept 11 and 12 was attended by Malaysia’s Trade Minister Tengku Zafrul Aziz, Cambodia’s Secretary of State for Commerce Lim Lork Piseth and Kazakhstan’s National Economy Vice-Minister Arman Kassenov, among other senior officials.

A Hong Kong-Asean Summit on Sept 13 heard speeches delivered by Datuk Seri Zafrul, Lao Deputy Finance Minister Phouthanouphet Saysombath and Cambodian Secretary of State for Tourism Prak Phannara.

More On This Topic

Quiet optimism about Hong Kong’s ‘breakthrough policy’


In July, Mr Lee visited Laos, Cambodia and Vietnam on a trip that yielded 55 memorandums of understanding (MOUs) in areas including finance, culture and education.

In May, Hong Kong’s Belt and Road Commissioner Nicholas Ho led a business delegation to Hungary and Kazakhstan, signing 10 MOUs, including in green development and technology. That same month, Hong Kong hosted its first geopolitical summit, signalling its intention to redefine its role in global development and solidify its position as an intermediary between mainland China and the rest of the world.

Its efforts appear to have been well received by its target countries at the recent summits.

“Hong Kong has (been organising) a lot of expos, and these types of forums are very important in deal-making... It’s how we can increase trade,” Cambodia’s Mr Piseth said at a BRI policy dialogue on Sept 11, noting that his country’s trade with Hong Kong in the first half of 2024 had risen by 60 per cent compared with the same period the previous year.

Mrs Shinta Widjaja Kamdani, CEO of Indonesian conglomerate Sintesa Group and chairwoman of the country’s employers’ association, urged more concrete efforts to help Indonesia’s small and medium-sized enterprises capitalise on BRI opportunities.

“Beyond the big forums and business summits, we want real deals to happen,” said Mrs Shinta. “We from Indonesia want Hong Kong’s help to access the GBA (Greater Bay Area) market and specific projects in specific sectors and more business-to-business connections.”

The GBA refers to Hong Kong, Macau and the nine cities in Guangdong province on mainland China.

Malaysia’s Mr Zafrul, meanwhile, leveraged the BRI summit on Sept 12 to urge closer cooperation between his country and the Middle East nations at the event, drawing upon commonalities between the two regions.

“We (Malaysia and the Middle East) fundamentally face similar challenges – a desire to shift from dependence on natural resources, as well as the need to move up the value chain economically and improve talent, all against the backdrop of geopolitical uncertainties and the threats of climate change,” he said.

More On This Topic

Hong Kong, Singapore and the new China gateway


At the Hong Kong-Asean summit the following day, he called for Asean to develop stronger partnerships with regions such as the GBA and financial centres like Hong Kong. Malaysia is due to take up the Asean bloc’s rotating chairmanship in 2025.

Hong Kong’s Belt and Road Commissioner Nicholas Ho expressed positivity about the impact of Hong Kong’s efforts at economic and diplomatic facilitation.

“Under Chief Executive John Lee’s leadership, Hong Kong has transformed, in many ways, our external outreach and approach to global collaboration,” he told ST. “The Belt and Road Initiative, now in its 11th year, has presented a new wave of opportunity... where public and private capital can come together to drive bankable projects... in the international sector.”

Mr Ho added that work to open a Hong Kong trade office in Kuala Lumpur was “in full force (with) the intention to open it as soon as possible”. It would be Hong Kong’s fourth such office in South-east Asia, after Singapore, Bangkok and Jakarta.

Pagoda Institute’s Dr Chan said Hong Kong’s immediate goal for its intensified global outreach efforts was “to bring the city back on the international stage”.

“That these efforts result in providing another platform that facilitates economic and political cooperation between and among countries, demonstrates Hong Kong’s unique model of paradiplomacy under the one country, two systems framework,” he said.

No comments: