Monday, October 23, 2023

Hundreds of pro-Palestinian protesters rally in Sask. for second weekend in a row


CBC
Mon, October 23, 2023


Pro-Palestinian protesters in Regina and Saskatoon are asking for an immediate ceasefire as the Israeli military continues its nearly two-week siege on Gaza.

More than 1,400 Israelis were killed in Hamas's Oct. 7 assault, and according to the Gaza Health Ministry the latest death toll in Gaza is 4,385, plus 13,561 wounded since Israel declared war on Hamas.

The Saskatoon chapter of Canadians for Justice and Peace in the Middle East organized a protest in Saskatoon Saturday.

"Our aim is to bring attention to the urgent need for a ceasefire in Gaza and to shed light on the devastating loss of innocent lives," said a news release from the organization.

As hundreds of protesters filed into the Saskatoon city hall courtyard, one of the organizers told CBC that people will continue to protest until there is a ceasefire in Gaza.

"This is [the] least thing we can do for the people who get killed every single minute," said Mohammad Abushar.

"There's no food, no electricity, no water, no Internet, so that's the least we can do, and we need to push for the politicians, the government, to push for ceasefire."

For the first time since the war started, aid was allowed into Gaza, with 20 trucks entering on Saturday and more than a dozen on Sunday, but Abushar said it's not enough for the 2.3 million people who live there.


Muhannad Alzaza, left, and Ahmed Becai walk in the march through downtown Saskatoon on Saturday. Alzaza is from Gaza and his parents live there. (Liam O'Connor/CBC)

Muhannad Alzaza, who is Palestinian and from Gaza, said he was at the protest to show support for his parents who live in Gaza. For the first time in days, he made contact with them on Saturday.

Alzaza said he was able to confirm his parents were safe, but "no place is safe."

"Maybe they were safe like maybe 10 minutes ago. I don't know what, after 10 minutes, what would happen to them. I'm always worried about them," Alzaza said.



City of Regina Ward 3 Coun. Andrew Stevens speaks at a pro-Palestinian rally outside the Saskatchewan Legislature on Sunday in Regina. (CBC)

On Sunday in Regina, protesters convened outside the Legislature. Andrew Stevens, City of Regina councillor for Ward 3, spoke at the event.

"We can't be comfortable simply calling for the safe passage of Palestinians out of Gaza. That will lead to displacement," Stevens said.

"We must aim for the return of residents to their homes with the presence and assistance of the United Nations."

Another pro-Palestinian protest was also held in Saskatoon on Sunday.

Three arrests made at Calgary protests amid calls for a ceasefire in Gaza and counter-protest


CBC
Sun, October 22, 2023 


Calgary police have made three arrests in relation to protests related to the Israel-Hamas war that took place at Olympic Plaza on Sunday.

Police said an initial protest planned by those supporting Gaza was met by a smaller counter-protest of Israel supporters. Approximately 900 people gathered downtown altogether, said a spokesperson for the Calgary Police Service.

In a statement, Calgary police said the arrests ranged from charges of breach of peace to one arrest for assault with a weapon.

"We maintain that we police behaviours and not beliefs, and in the last two protests we have seen increasingly escalating behaviour that has required police intervention," it said.

Police were unable to confirm what group those arrested were supporting.

Muhannad Ayyash, a professor of sociology at Mount Royal University who was at the protests, said the demonstrations seemed peaceful for the most part.

"These are simply [protests] in support for the Palestinian struggle to be free and to have human rights like everyone else, and to stop the genocide that is being directed toward the Palestinian people at this moment in Gaza," said Ayyash.

"This was one of the largest demonstrations for Palestinian freedom in the city of Calgary that I have ever seen."

Previous protests peaceful

The Canadian government has previously said does not recognize Israeli actions against Palestinians as genocide.

Rallies in support of Gaza were also held last weekend in the city. Police said those protests had remained peaceful.

Over the weekend, two convoys of trucks carrying aid were allowed to enter Gaza, but humanitarian workers say the amount of aid entering the region is inadequate. Israel cut supplies to the territory after Hamas militants crossed the border into Israel and conducted a series of deadly attacks and kidnappings against civilians on Oct. 7.

Ayyash, the professor, called the aid convoys a "publicity stunt."

"[It's] for Western countries to pretend that they are doing something but it's not putting a dent into the need."

The Hamas-run Gaza Health Ministry said Saturday that the death toll in the enclave has reached 4,385, while 13,561 people have been wounded.

More than 1,400 people in Israel have been killed, mostly in the initial attack, according to the Israeli government

Rallies continue in Winnipeg as latest Israel-Hamas conflict reaches 2-week mark


CBC
Sat, October 21, 2023 


Hundreds of pro-Palestinian demonstrators and a contingent of pro-Israel demonstrators held concurrent rallies near the Manitoba Legislature Saturday afternoon.

Tensions ran high at points between participants, who faced off against each other on opposite sides of Broadway in front of the legislative grounds, as the ongoing war between Israel and Hamas reached the two-week mark. However, no arrests were made and all parties left without incident, the Winnipeg Police Service said in a statement.

"Hopefully both of our communities can stay safe in Canada," said Ramsey Zeid, president of the Canadian Palestinian Association of Manitoba.

"We do live in a democratic country where people have the right to expression, right to free speech. At the same time, everybody needs to feel safe."


Israel supporters gathered in front of the Manitoba Legislature as pro-Palestinian demonstrators rallied in Memorial Park, across the street. (Zubina Ahmed/CBC)

Thousands have died in Israel and the Gaza Strip since Oct. 7, when Hamas militants launched surprise attacks in Israel, crossing into Israeli towns and firing a barrage of rockets.

Israel has responded with a series of airstrikes in Gaza.

The Israeli government has said more than 1,400 people were killed in the initial Hamas attacks. More than 200 people were also taken hostage, according to Israel, and more than 300 of its soldiers have been killed since Oct. 7.

More than 4,300 people have been killed in the airstrikes on Gaza, according to a figure released Saturday by the territory's Hamas-run Health Ministry. The United Nations says more than a million have been left homeless.


Ramsey Zeid, president of the Canadian Palestinian Association of Manitoba, speaks at Saturday's rally. (Prabhjot Singh Lotey/CBC)

"My family was from there," said Sabrina Saad, who was at Saturday's rally in support of Palestinians.

"I still have family ties there through relatives and friends, and we're just hoping that it ends soon."

Seeing Winnipeg's Palestinian community come together "feels amazing," she said.

"It helps knowing we have community support for this cause."

Counter-demonstration

While hundreds of pro-Palestinian supporters made their voices heard at Memorial Park, a small contingent of pro-Israel supporters held a counter-demonstration across the street, in front of the legislative building.

"Today's rally is just again to show up and show support for Israel under these very difficult times," said rally organizer Ron East. "There's a war going on in our region and we're here just to [show] support for Israel."

However, he also said no one wants to see the "death of any innocent people, whether they be Israeli, Palestinian or other."

"As human beings we don't like seeing the suffering of any people," said East.


Ron East organized Saturday's pro-Israel rally. (Prabhjot Singh Lotey/CBC)

In a Facebook post Friday, the Jewish Federation of Winnipeg said while rallies "are an effective tool to increase visibility, helping to send messages to decision-makers and spread awareness to the public," counter-protests "are not an effective tool to change minds and only inflame tensions and polarization between both sides."

The statement added if community members are compelled to attend they should do so safely and "not engage directly with the other side."

Zeid said the city's Palestinian community's message is a call for peace and humanity as the war continues.

"How many thousands of people have to be killed, how many children have to be killed, before somebody says anything?" said Zeid.

"The longer this carries on, the more hate the Palestinian people in Gaza will have for Israel."


Thousands across Canada protest against Israeli airstrikes in Gaza: 'End the siege'

Thousands of Canadians rallied in cities like Toronto, Montreal and Vancouver as the Israel-Hamas war entered its second week.





Chris Stoodley
·Lifestyle and News Editor
Updated Sun, October 22, 2023 


Thousands of people across Canada took to the streets over the weekend to protest devastating Israeli airstrikes on Gaza amid the on-going Israel-Hamas war.

Since Friday, people in cities including Toronto, Montreal and Vancouver have expressed their anger with Israel's bombing, following Hamas' deadly Oct. 7 incursion.

In photos and content posted to social media over the weekend, people can be seen chanting and holding Palestinian flags, while others hold signs that read demands like "end the siege on Gaza" and "stop Israeli war crimes."

Hundreds of protestors, mostly university students, gathered to protest against Israeli airstrikes in Gaza Strip, at Toronto's Queen's Park outside the Legislative Assembly on Oct. 20. (Photo by Mert Alper Dervis/Anadolu via Getty Images) (Anadolu Agency via Getty Images)

During a pro-Palestinian rally at Toronto's Queen's Park on Friday, demonstrators called on the Ontario government to reconsider a motion that passed the day prior. The motion condemned Hamas and affirmed Israel's right to defend itself.

"We're calling on the provincial government to reconsider the vote that it took yesterday. It was a vote whereby the government refused to include anything that had to do with breaking the siege on Gaza, with allowing humanitarian aid in. It was one that was continuing this trend of erasing Palestinians really across the board," said demonstrator Dalia Awwad, according to CBC News.

People gather outside the constituency office of Canada's Deputy Prime Minister Chrystia Freeland during a rally in support of Palestinians on Oct. 20 in Toronto. (Photo by Mert Alper Dervis/Anadolu via Getty Images) (Anadolu Agency via Getty Images)
Hundreds of protestors, mostly university students, gathered to protest against Israeli airstrikes in Gaza Strip, at Toronto's Queen's Park outside the Legislative Assembly on Oct. 20. (Photo by Mert Alper Dervis/Anadolu via Getty Images) (Anadolu Agency via Getty Images)

On X, formerly known as Twitter, people shared footage of demonstrations that took place in support of Palestine, including several clips showing protesters chant while blocking downtown streets.

In downtown Calgary on Sunday, police shared around 330 people gathered in the Olympic Plaza park — some supporting Israel and others supporting Palestine.

"There have been incidents of violence and we are asking the public to avoid the area as we work with both groups to de-escalate the conflict," Calgary police shared on X, adding in a follow-up post that multiple arrests were made.

Other parts of the world also saw large demonstrations in support of Palestine, with thousands gathering in countries including France, Brazil, Belgium and Sweden.

Thousands of people gathered at Porte d'Aix, despite intensive police measures, and marched towards the Saint-Charles railway station in support of Palestinians on Oct. 22 in Marseille, France. (Photo by Sener Yilmaz Aslan/Getty Images) (Sener Yilmaz Aslan via Getty Images)
Demonstrators waved flags and displayed placards during a demonstration in solidarity with Palestinians in the Gaza Strip, at Sergel's Square in Stockholm, Sweden on Oct. 22. (Photo by Pontus Lundahl/TT NEWS AGENCY/AFP via Getty Images) (PONTUS LUNDAHL via Getty Images)
People took part in a demonstration against Israel's military offensive in the Gaza Strip in Sao Paulo, Brazil on Oct. 22. (Photo by Nelson Almeida/AFP via Getty Images) (NELSON ALMEIDA via Getty Images)
Participants marched to demonstrate in support of Palestinians in the Gaza Strip outside the Danish Parliament in Copenhagen, Denmark on Oct. 22. (Photo by Emil Helms/Ritzau Scanpix/AFP via Getty Images) (EMIL HELMS via Getty Images)
Demonstrators pictured during a demonstration "Gaza: Stop Massacres, Stop Impunity" in support of the Palestinian people in Brussels, Belgium on Oct. 22. (Photo by Nicolas Maeterlinck/BELGA MAG/AFP via Getty Images) (NICOLAS MAETERLINCK via Getty Images)
Members of the Shia Muslim organization Majlis Wahdat-e-Muslimeen (MWM) marched to the U.S. consulate as they protest against the Israeli attacks on Gaza in Karachi, Pakistan on Oct. 22. (Photo by Yousuf Khan/Anadolu via Getty Images) (Anadolu Agency via Getty Images)
Protestors hold banners to protest Israeli airstrikes in Gaza Strip as hundreds of people gather near the Israel embassy in Tokyo, Japan on Oct. 21. (Photo by David Mareuil/Anadolu via Getty Images) (Anadolu Agency via Getty Images)

More than 30 MPs in Canada — 23 of whom are Liberals — have written a letter to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, urging him to advocate for a ceasefire between Israel and Hamas.

After Israeli warplanes struck targets across Gaza, two airports in Syria and a mosque in the occupied West Bank on Sunday, threats of a widened war grew. Israel has also been trading fire with Lebanon's Hezbollah militant group since the war began.

An estimated 700,000 people have fled northern Gaza amid an expected ground offensive by Israel. However, supply shortages are impacting hospitals and forcing doctors to ration treatment, as Palestinians run low on food, drink dirty water and suffer from cases of chickenpox, scabies and diarrhea.

On Saturday, Israel allowed 20 trucks to enter Gaza through the Rafah border crossing shared with Egypt, in the first humanitarian aid shipment since the siege began.

Israeli authorities said late Sunday they had allowed a second batch of aid into Gaza at the request of the United States, according to the Canadian Press.

Since the conflict began two weeks ago, more than 4,600 people have been killed in Gaza, according to the Hamas-run Health Ministry. More than 1,400 people in Israel have also died, most of whom were killed during Hamas' initial Oct. 7 attack.

Local Palestinian-Canadians gather en masse to grieve loved ones killed in Israel-Hamas war


CBC
Sun, October 22, 2023 


Palestinian-Canadians in Ottawa living in dread of the increasingly deadly Gaza conflict gathered Saturday to share condolences and help families grieve their loved ones lost in the war.

Two weeks after the Oct. 7 rampage by Hamas on Israeli citizens and soldiers that left more than 1,400 people dead, Israel continues to launch waves of airstrikes across Gaza and Palestinian militants fire rockets into Israel.

Gaza's 2.3 million Palestinians, half of whom have fled their homes amid the fighting, are rationing food and water. Talk of an Israeli ground offensive to root out Hamas, which has ruled the territory for 16 years, continues. All told, the war has already killed more than 4,000 people living in Gaza, according to Palestinian officials and the United Nations.

Maha Buhisi was born and lives in Ottawa, but the war has hit close to home.

She woke up on Oct. 12 to learn that three relatives — her uncle Mohammed Al-Buhisi, her cousin Hamdan Al-Buhisi, and her cousin's two-year-old daughter, Noor Al-Buhisi — were killed in an airstrike in the central Gazan city of Deir El Balah.

"From what my family explained to me, they had left the house seconds before and they were just outside playing," Buhisi said.

"We're just praying for the time that there's a ceasefire."


Maha Buhisi says she lost three family members on one day of the Israel-Hamas conflict. (CBC)

'Need to be there for each other'

Buhisi's family hosted its own gathering at a Barrhaven mosque where mourners came to pay their condolences last weekend.

But since then, the total number of Palestinian-Canadian families in Ottawa who have lost loved ones has grown to at least 19, according to the Ottawa-based Jerusalem Community Services of Ontario.

The group held a mass condolences gathering Saturday night in the community centre below the Mercy Mosque.

It was the first event of its kind since the organization launched in the 1990s, and was intended to relieve people of what co-organizer Ala Abu Alkheir called "the trauma [of] suffering through this alone."

Two long rows of chairs faced each other in the centre of the room: one for representatives of the grieving families, who wore scarves of red, white, green and black — the colours of the Palestinian flag — and one for visitors.

A whiteboard listed the names of the 19 families in Arabic, while volunteers handed out coffee and dates and speakers like Abu Alkheir addressed the large crowd.

"Losing one beloved person is already a catastrophe … losing two is even more so. Losing 10 is unthinkable," he said.

"But the numbers we have been hearing of over the past few days are worse than a nightmare."


A volunteer at Saturday's event wore this symbol. (Guy Quenneville/CBC)

Buhisi, who attended Saturday's event, said it was important for people to be there for each other.

"We're checking in on each other. We're making sure that all of us are in a good mental state, which most of us aren't. Most of us aren't sleeping. We're not eating. We can't function [in] our normal daily lives."

Hala Alshaer was also at the Saturday gathering.

Alshaer lives in Ottawa too and also has family ties to Palestine. Her father and mother are from the southern Gaza cities of Rafah and Khan Younis, respectively.


Ala Abu Alkheir, one of the organizers of Saturday's mass condolences gathering at the Mercy Mosque, is from Jordan but has a lot of family in Gaza. (Patrick Foucault/Radio-Canada)

Alshaer said her family is grieving the deaths of 77 relatives, spread between her father's and mother's sides. One of the oldest was 61, she said, while the youngest was just one year old.

"My cousins that are married with kids ... they're just taking their kids and they're sleeping together inside the kitchen where there's no windows so that — if the building behind them gets bombed and the glass starts breaking in — their kids don't get hurt," she said.

"They're saying that if [they're] going to die, [they] would rather all die together as a family, so that their kids aren't orphaned, or that the mother isn't widowed."

More gatherings planned

As for Abu Alkheir, he's from Jordan but has a lot of family in Gaza.

He described the last two weeks — in which Palestinians have been glued to their phones in anticipation of messages from back home, seven time zones away — as "living on the edge."

Two other mass condolence gatherings are planned, one for Oct. 28 and Nov. 4. Abu Alkheir hopes that by then, the situation in Gaza won't be so desperate.

"Hopefully, we end up cancelling them," he said.
Canada pledges $50M in humanitarian aid for Palestinians in Gaza Strip

Last week, the Government of Canada announced an initial $10 million in aid for worsening conditions amid the Israel-Hamas war.


Chris Stoodley
·Lifestyle and News Editor
Sat, October 21, 2023 

Canada is pledging $50 million in humanitarian aid for Palestinians in the Gaza Strip and neighbouring areas, amid the on-going Israel-Hamas war.

The announcement was made Saturday, as Foreign Affairs Minister Mélanie Joly and Minister of International Development Ahmed Hussen arrived in Cairo, Egypt for a two-day visit, in what's being dubbed the "Cairo Peace Summit."

"It is critical that Palestinian civilians in Gaza who need life-saving assistance receive it as soon as possible," Joly says in a statement. "Canada will continue to work with its trusted and experienced humanitarian partners to make sure this funding reaches those who are suffering."

The funding will go towards providing food, water, medical assistance protection services and other life-saving assistance to civilians in the area, while ensuring no money "goes into the hands of Hamas," according to the news release.

The announcement comes after Canada already pledged an initial $10 million in humanitarian aid on Oct. 12, money aimed to "address urgent needs" stemming from the war. A portion of that funding went to support the Canadian Red Cross, the Palestine Red Crescent Society and Magen David Adom.

Global Affairs Canada notes the new $50 million pledge aims to "address the acute needs Palestinians in the Gaza Strip and neighbouring areas."



Minister of International Development Ahmed Hussen says "the humanitarian needs of civilians are more urgent than ever," while announcing Canada's $50 million pledge to help Palestinians in the Gaza Strip and neighbouring areas. (The Canadian Press/Justin Tang) (The Canadian Press)

On Saturday, the border crossing between Gaza and Egypt opened, allowing 20 trucks — while more than 200 trucks have waited at the border for days — to bring a bit of desperately-needed aid into the besieged Palestinian territory.

The 2.3 million Palestinians in Gaza, half of whom have fled their homes, are rationing food and drinking dirty water.

Meanwhile, hospitals say they're running low on medical supplies and fuel for emergency generators. The Hamas-run Health Ministry says five hospitals have stopped functioning due to fuel shortages and bombing damage.

Earlier this week, at least 500 people were killed following an explosion at the Al Ahli Arab Hospital in the middle of Gaza City, which was sheltering thousands of residents who fled their homes in northern Gaza amid on-going Israeli airstrikes.

Canadians have put pressure on Prime Minister Justin Trudeau to issue a response to the blast, especially after Israel and the U.S. held Hamas accountable based on their intelligence.

More than 30 MPs — 23 of them Liberals — have also written a letter to Trudeau, calling on him to advocate for a ceasefire between Israel and Hamas.
PRO PALESTINE
NDP kicks Hamilton MPP Sarah Jama from caucus, saying her actions have 'broken the trust' of colleagues


CBC
Mon, October 23, 2023 


Ontario New Democrats have kicked Hamilton Centre MPP Sarah Jama out of caucus, nearly two weeks after she posted a controversial statement in support of Palestinians.

NDP Leader Marit Stiles said in a statement Monday that while the caucus allows different viewpoints, some of Jama's actions since making her comments "have contributed to unsafe work environments for staff."

"Ms. Jama and I had reached an agreement to keep her in the NDP caucus, which included working together in good faith with no surprises. Our caucus and staff have made significant efforts to support her during an undoubtedly difficult time," Stiles said.

"Since then, she has undertaken a number of unilateral actions that have undermined our collective work and broken the trust of her colleagues."

By midday Monday, Jama was listed with the Legislative Assembly of Ontario as an Independent.

The news comes after a tumultuous couple of weeks for the first-time MPP following her statement Oct. 10 in support of the people of Gaza in the Hamas-Israeli conflict. The statement prompted Premier Doug Ford to call for Jama's resignation and he accused her of antisemitism.

Jama's office served a cease and desist letter to Ford last Thursday, according to her lawyer, Stephen Ellis, and the Legal Centre for Palestine. The letter said if Ford did not remove his social media post and publicly apologize, Jama would pursue legal action for defamation.

"Ms. Jama maintains the post was reckless and malicious," the statement said. "Ms. Jama will not tolerate Premier Ford's attempts to tarnish her reputation in such a public manner."

Stiles responded to the legal notice last week, calling the premier's accusations of Jama "inflammatory" and saying the Ford government was "repeatedly and cynically fanning the flames of division during such a painful time."

Jama also said on X, formerly Twitter, on Friday that her Hamilton Centre office staff were directed to work remotely because they had "received a number of concerning calls and emails that have made us question the safety of remaining open for walk-ins."

NDP will still vote against censuring Jama

The Progressive Conservatives have also tabled a motion to censure Jama in the House.

In Stiles's statement Monday that announced Jama's removal from caucus, she said the Ontario NDP will still vote against the "extreme motion."

"We do not believe the government should use its majority to strip a member of their right to speak and vote," Stiles said. "This is an extreme step that will disenfranchise the voters of Hamilton Centre."


Premier Doug Ford's government has put forward a motion to censure Jama in the House. (Nathan Denette/The Canadian Press)

Jama's original statement posted to X called for an immediate ceasefire as well as an "end to all occupation of Palestinian land."

She focused largely on the Palestinian territories, saying "violence and retaliation rooted in settler colonialism have taken the lives of far too many innocent people." She did not directly mention the Hamas attacks.

The statement prompted both anger and support.

'I hope even more of you will speak out': Jama

Shortly before Stiles's announcement, Jama spoke in the House on Monday. She reaffirmed her support for Palestinians in Gaza and opposition to Israel's military action in retaliation to the Hamas attacks.

"I restate my call for an immediate ceasefire by Israeli forces, and for the immediate restoration of food, water, fuel, and electricity to Gaza," Jama said. "I applaud the many elected officials in Canada who have joined this call in recent days, and I hope even more of you will speak out."

She described Israel's historical and continued actions as "domination and occupation of Palestinian land."

"Governments and institutions in Canada are trying to use their weight to silence us, to silence workers, students, educators, and peace-loving people who dare to support Palestine," Jama said. "To every person taking risks to speak up for Palestinian dignity and safety, I see you, I hear you, and I am with you."

Booting Jama from caucus draws criticism and praise

The decision to boot Jama from caucus led to condemnation and praise online.

The Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs posted to X, saying it was "pleased" to see the move.

"Ms. Jama's remarks were inappropriate, egregious, and hurtful to Jewish and Israeli Canadians," the centre wrote.

Michael Levitt, president and chief executive officer of Friends of Simon Wiesenthal Center, echoed similar sentiments, saying it was "important to see" Stiles take the "necessary steps."

"Jama's abhorrent and reckless words and actions have caused repeated hurt and harm to the Jewish community in her riding of Hamilton Centre and far beyond," he wrote on X.

Meanwhile, union leaders expressed disappointment in the decision.

Fred Hahn, president of the Canadian Union of Public Employees, called it a "sad, sad day," adding that Jama is a "necessary and strongly supported voice."

"This is a deeply troubling and massively dangerous move," he said on X.

"What my party the [Ontario NDP] must understand is that [first] this move doesn't change that support, and [second] they just handed the right a gift."

Anthony Marco, president of the Hamilton and District Labour Council, said the NDP could consider his membership card "revoked."

"While I cannot predict [the labour council's] continued relationship with the party, I can say they voted to support Sarah!" he posted to X.

Deanna Allain, chair of Hamilton's women and gender equity committee, said it was "absolutely shameful" to see Jama kicked out of caucus.

"Politicians who continue to choose to stay silent, know you'll be campaigning without a lot of the support that got you those seats in the first place," she wrote on X.


‘Sarah Jama is a ‘photo op’ for NDP’: Diversity expert weighs in after Hamilton MPP is removed from Ontario caucus


'Governments and institutions in Canada are trying to use their weight to silence us,' Jama warned after her removal



Joy Joshi
·Writer, Yahoo News Canada
Updated Mon, October 23, 2023

A GTA-based Diversity, Equity and Inclusion expert is calling out the Ontario NDP leadership after Hamilton MPP Sarah Jama was removed from the caucus Monday morning while Ford's PCs also voted to censure Jama in the House.

Jama, who went through a volatile few weeks after posting a controversial statement on the ongoing war between Israel and Hamas, was kicked out of caucus by Ontario NDP leader Marit Stiles with support from fellow party MPPs in the province.

DEI expert Dr. Sabreena Ghaffar-Siddiqui is calling Jama’s removal to be a “convenient” move for the Ontario NDP who backed her for bringing “new energy” and “new representation” to the party earlier in March this year during election.

“Let’s not forget Sarah Jama is a racialized woman who is also a part of the disability community. She has been excluded from a space that is already historically not so inclusive,” Dr. Ghaffar-Siddiqui told Yahoo News Canada.

“A lot of people for the first time felt represented because of her. Her removal is going to create a distrust among people in government practice.”

Dr. Ghaffar-Siddiqui shared with Yahoo News Canada that as a DEI specialist she is not surprised by Stiles’ decision.

“What we’ve found in our research is that groups, communities, companies and organizations bring on the people who ‘check boxes’ so to speak. People from racialized, disabled, LGBTQ communities who make for positive publicity and support among the general public.”

Sarah Jama was a ‘photo op’ for NDP. She likely checked all the boxes for the party during election in March 2023 and now since she doesn’t fit the party narrative on the Israel-Palestine situation she has been conveniently removed.Dr. Ghaffar-Siddiqui, Diversity, Equity and Inclusion expert

Race and ethnicity had nothing to do with Jama's ouster, expert says

On the contrary, Nelson Wiseman, an expert on Canadian government and politics, said the issue had more to do with if Sarah Jama was able to successfully carry out the job her party expected of her.

“There is discrimination only in one sense here. She won't be able to represent the people who elected her. That is all. However, that did not happen because of her ethnicity or the colour of her skin. It’s about what the job demands and on this occasion it required for all the members to come forward as one,” Wiseman shared with Yahoo News Canada.

They are keeping her from voting/speaking in the legislature. That’s where the discrimination is. The NDP voted against that and rightly so.Nelson Wiseman, Political Science Professor Emeritus, University of Toronto

Dr. Ghaffar-Siddiqui maintained prejudice may have played a role against Sarah Jama before she was ousted from NDP’s Ontario caucus in the wake of the Israel-Hamas war.

“There is discrimination happening, there's a bias in play here. There's clearly some sort of political pressure being applied by Israeli lobby groups.”

The Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs, who welcomed Marit Stiles’ definitive action, rejected any suggestions of lobbying or pressurizsing the government at any level.

“The insinuation that “Israel lobby groups” are exerting pressure is a dark one, and we urge all Canadians not to allow anti-Semitic rhetoric and tropes to be given space to fester. MPP Jama’s comments have been painful to the Jewish community and, as such, many Jewish organizations and community members have raised their voices to oppose her and to call on political leaders to make it clear that anti-Semitism must never be tolerated Canadian politics,” CIJA Vice President Jamie-Kirzner Roberts told Yahoo News Canada.

Jama’s removal from the Ontario NDP caucus comes after she threatened to sue Premier Doug Ford if he failed to respond to her demands stated in a cease-and-desist letter, which also accused him of defamation over the controversial comments made by Jama two weeks ago.

Many Canadians saw that as a power move and raised questions over Stiles’ control as the party leader in Ontario. S, following which came the latest development on Monday this week that too had social media users were divided on Jama’s ouster and Stiles’ decision:

While the news of Stiles ejected Jama from the Ontario NDP caucus circulated online, the Hamilton MPP posted a thread on X, accusing the Canadian government of “silencing” leaders like her.

The National Council of Canadian Muslims expressed their disappointment at Jama being expelled from the caucus and told Yahoo News Canada that they “are in touch with MPP Stiles' office and are very concerned about the decision. We will have more to say about this soon.”