Monday, August 15, 2022

New Zealand river's personhood status offers hope to Māori


WHANGANUI, New Zealand (AP) — The Whanganui River is surging into the ocean, fattened from days of winter rain and yellowed from the earth and clay that has collapsed into its sides. Logs and debris hurtle past as dusk looms.


Sixty-one-year-old Tahi Nepia is calmly paddling his outrigger canoe, called a waka ama in his Indigenous Māori language, as it is buffeted from side to side.

Before venturing out, he first asks permission from his ancestors in a prayer. He says his ancestors inhabit the river and each time he dips his paddle into the water he touches them.

“You are giving them a massage,” Nepia says. “That’s how we see that river. It’s a part of us.”

In 2017, New Zealand passed a groundbreaking law granting personhood status to the Whanganui River. The law declares that the river is a living whole, from the mountains to the sea, incorporating all its physical and metaphysical elements.

The law was part of a settlement with the Whanganui Iwi, comprising Māori from a number of tribes who have long viewed the river as a living force.

Five years after the law was passed, The Associated Press followed the 290-kilometer (180-mile) river upstream to find out what its status means to those whose lives are entwined with its waters. For many, its enhanced standing has come to reflect a wider rebirth of Māori culture and a chance to reverse generations of discrimination against Māori and degradation of the river.

Whanganui Māori have a saying: Ko au te awa, ko te awa ko au: I am the river, and the river is me.

___

Nepia, a caretaker at a Māori immersion school, is among a group of expert waka ama paddlers who have been training for the World Sprint Champs in Britain.

He learned to swim when his uncle threw him in the river at age 8. He first paddled on the river in a traditional Māori long canoe in 1979, when he and about 20 co-workers at a slaughterhouse got together for a regatta on Waitangi Day, commemorating the 1840 treaty signed between the British and Māori.

Considered New Zealand’s founding document, the Treaty of Waitangi has long been a source of contention. For 30 years, New Zealand’s government has been negotiating with tribes that brought grievances under the treaty, which guaranteed sovereignty over their traditional lands and fisheries. The Whanganui River deal is among dozens of settlements forged in recent years.

At its mouth in the town of Whanganui, the river is permanently discolored from the erosion that has come from turning what was once forest along the banks into farmland. The excessive sediment suffocates fish and plant life.

“We need to grow trees instead of chopping them down,” Nepia says. “The water shouldn’t be like that.”

___

A half-hour drive inland, Gerrard Albert points to the riverbank spot where his people live. He says the river and the surrounding lands have their own authority, and dictate the terms for human occupation.

“For too long, we’ve assumed it’s been the other way around,” he says.

Albert, 54, was the lead negotiator for Whanganui Māori in getting the river’s personhood recognized after his tribe battled for the river’s rights for over 140 years. He says the status is a legal fiction, a construct more commonly used to give a corporation legal standing. But he sees it as an opportunity for a permanent shift in thinking.

After the law passed, he says, the local council assumed it was business as usual when they tried to build a bridge across the river for cyclists and pedestrians. They hadn’t considered they now needed to consult first with the tribe and community.

As a result, the bridge structure sat in a field during two years of delays before it was dropped into place and opened in 2020. Albert says the tribal clan and the community pushed for improvements like protected fishing areas, speed limits on nearby roads and the addition of restrooms.

“This is truly about giving power back to the community,” he says.

___

At the Rivertime Lodge, where cyclists and walkers stay in cabins or pitch tents on the riverbank during the summer, manager Frances Marshall was puttering about in fluffy orange slippers.

On her chin, Marshall wore a traditional Māori tattoo, a moko kauae. She considers it an integral part of her spiritual being and her connection to the river.

“It’s hard to describe. It’s like this person inside you wanting to get out,” said Marshall, 61.

In addition to the erosion, she says, there have been problems with people dumping stolen cars and trash into the river. Now landowners and tribes are replanting the hills to reduce further erosion and restore the natural habitat her own family once cleared.

Around the lodge, Marshall has been planting flax bushes and native trees. Across the road, her brother planted 10,000 native manuka trees, which he plans to turn into a honey farm.

Marshall was elated when the river, or awa, was recognized.

“Over the years, our awa, she’s been sick,” Marshall says. “And so that happening, for a lot of us, means that things can be done now to help heal her.”

___

As the river loops toward Tongariro National Park, it becomes all but inaccessible due to dense forest and ravines — but not for Adam Daniel, a scientist and adventurer, a kind of Indiana Jones of the river.

At the end of a remote road, he straps into the four-seater off-road buggy he’s been towing and speeds off along an impossibly narrow track, careening over downed trees, up banks and through streams.

Originally from Washington state, Daniel, 48, monitors the Whanganui and dozens of other rivers for Fish & Game New Zealand, which collects license fees from hunters and anglers to safeguard the habitat.

“It’s our best backcountry river, and it has amazing trout fishing, great scenery,” he says.

But go a bit further downstream, and the trout can’t survive because it’s too muddied and too warm in the summer, he says.

Near the Whanganui’s source, Daniel points out where a power company is sucking out water as part of the Tongariro Power Scheme. Built about 50 years ago, the scheme draws water from some 36 rivers and streams to generate electricity and deposits most of it into a lake.

Genesis Energy, which owns the Tongariro Power Scheme, says it draws on average 20% of the Whanganui’s flow from several intakes to power over 30,000 households. Chief operations officer Rebecca Larkin says Genesis tries to mitigate the environmental impact.

But Daniel and others hope the company will be forced to make major improvements — or leave the river entirely — when its regulatory license for the power scheme expires in 2039.

Daniel had mixed feelings at first about the river being declared a living being.

“I’m certainly coming around to it,” he said. “I’m hoping that it really will turn the tide and help save the river.”

___

Associated Press religion coverage receives support through the AP’s collaboration with The Conversation US, with funding from Lilly Endowment Inc. The AP is solely responsible for this content.

Nick Perry, The Associated Press
KETTLE CALLING POT BLACK
Kenney calls Alberta sovereignty act idea backed by UCP leadership candidate 'nuts'
LOGICAL EXTENSION OF FIREWALL ALBERTA
PROVINCIAL POLICE AND PROVINCIAL PENSION

EDMONTON — Alberta Premier Jason Kenney has so far declined to pick a favourite in the race to succeed him, but when asked to comment on a prominent platform plank of one of the leading candidates, referred to it as "nuts."


© Provided by The Canadian PressKenney calls Alberta sovereignty act idea backed by UCP leadership candidate 'nuts'

Kenney was appearing on his provincewide radio show on CHED and CHQR on Saturday when he was asked via text for his opinion of the Alberta sovereignty act, which has been proposed by United Conservative Party leadership candidate Danielle Smith.

Smith has said if she wins the leadership, she will bring in a bill this fall to give Alberta the power to ignore federal laws and court rulings deemed not in the province's interest.

Legal scholars say such a bill would be illegal, unenforceable and a dangerous dismissal of respect for the rule of law.

Kenney said he's certain that even if the Legislature passed the law, the lieutenant-governor would refuse to give it royal assent and Alberta would become a "laughing stock."

Smith chastised Kenney in a statement Sunday for "interference" in the leadership contest, saying his comments were "ill-informed and disrespectful to a large and growing majority of UCP members that support this important initiative."

"If elected to replace him as Leader and Premier, I will work closely and collaboratively with our entire UCP Caucus to ensure the Sovereignty Act is drafted, passed and implemented in accordance with sound constitutional language and principles," Smith said in her statement.

"Perhaps the Premier and other 'experts' should reserve their opinion on this legislation until they can actually read it first


Kenney announced in May that he was leaving the top job after receiving 51 per cent support in a party leadership review, but he's staying on until party members pick a replacement on Oct. 6.

Smith, who started out with a handful of supporters in the United Conservative caucus and cabinet, has seen more in-house support in recent days, including some who had initially pledged to back rival Travis Toews.

Almost every week Kenney takes to the airwaves, the program's host Wayne Nelson or a caller asks for his opinion on the leadership race. He never bites, and his response to the question about Smith's proposed legislation appears to be a rare deviation from that.

Kenney summed up the legislation idea as "a proposal for Alberta to basically ignore and violate the Constitution in a way unprecedented in Canadian history." He compared it to the 1930s when the government of then-premier William Aberhart attempted to pass unconstitutional legislation which the lieutenant-governor refused to sign, escalating to the point where Aberhart cut off the utilities and fired the staff at the vice-regal's official residence.

"So we would become a laughing stock, with the lieutenant-governor doing her job, which is to ensure that the rule of law and the constitution is respected," Kenney said.

"If a lieutenant-governor were, in the unthinkable circumstance, to grant it royal assent, it would immediately be struck down by the courts."

Political scientist Duane Bratt noted last week that while the other two main contenders in the leadership race have excoriated Smith's plan, they have adopted versions of it.

Toews has promised his government would seek to levy tariffs on goods and services or imports from specific regions to counter rules and policies deemed unfair to Alberta. Brian Jean has pledged to affirm that the Alberta Bill of Rights is paramount over Section 1 of the Constitution.

Kenney said his government has been successfully battling Ottawa while the sovereignty act would jeopardize investor confidence.

"We should be talking about real, practical ways to fight unfair Ottawa policies, fight for a stronger Alberta. That's exactly what we're doing."

This report by The Canadian Press was first published Aug. 14, 2022.

https://www.alberta.ca/provincial-police-service-engagement.aspx

We are studying the potential transition to an Alberta provincial police service. We held virtual stakeholder engagement sessions in fall of 2021 and in-person meetings from January to April

  • Alberta Pension Plan: UCP to study benefits of leaving CPP

    https://www.albertaseparation.org/2020/11/alberta-pension-plan-ucp...

    2020-11-08 · Alberta Pension Plan: UCP seeking outside study of costs, benefits, whether to leave CPP - Edmonton Journal. The Alberta government is looking for an external analysis of the potential risks and benefits of a provincial pension plan. In a request for proposals ... the government says it wants a detailed analysis of the costs, benefits and ...

  • Alberta panel recommending province withdraws from CPP, …

    https://www.benefitscanada.com/news/bencan/alberta-panel-recommending...

    2020-06-19 · If the province were to go ahead with an APP, Alberta’s portion of the CPP’s $400-billion reserve 


  • The famous Alberta “firewall” letter Dear Premier Klein

    https://albertapolitics.ca/wp-content/uploads/firewall.pdf · PDF file

    The famous Alberta “firewall” letter Dear Premier Klein: During and since the recent federal election, we have been among a large number of Albertans discussing the future of our province. We are not dismayed by the outcome of the election so much as by the strategy employed by the current federal government to secure its re-election.

    • File Size: 54KB
    • Page Count: 2
  • https://calgaryherald.com/opinion/columnists/smith-alberta-needs-a...

    2018-12-28 · You’ll recall the firewall letter was authored by Stephen Harper, Tom Flanagan, Ted Morton, Andy Crooks, Rainer Knopff and Ken Boessenkool in …

    • Is Accessible For Free: False
    • Estimated Reading Time: 5 mins
  • https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/wildrose-renews-idea-of-…

    2012-04-14 · CALGARY — Echoing the famous “firewall” manifesto of a decade ago, Wildrose party leader Danielle Smith says Alberta would “assert itself” in …

    • Is Accessible For Free: False
    • Estimated Reading Time: 11 mins
  • Alberta animal shelters in ‘panic mode’ over capacity concerns

    Nicole Stillger - Saturday

    IF YOU CAN'T ADOPT PLEASE DONATE



    © Courtesy: Erin Deems life-or-death situations, according to co-executive director Erin Deems.

    Earlier this week Saving Grace Animal Society took in 31 animals, all of which were in life-or-death situations.

    "A big day like that is a large undertaking for our organization," said co-executive director Erin Deems.

    "A year ago that would have been an okay day, but now it causes quite a panic for us.


    "We have been in panic mode -- as far as shelter capacity -- for the last quite a few months."

    Read more:
    Alberta Animal Rescue Crew Society reaches capacity of rescue animals, pauses intake

    According to Deems, the situation continues to get worse.

    "The surrender requests for their animals are just coming in at unprecedented rates," she explained.

    "If we continue at this rate, we don't even have a year. We're diminishing all of our funds into these major medical cases and it's not sustainable."

    On top of that, Deems said they don't have enough foster homes and people are not donating like they used to.

    "Animal welfare across our province right now is a major struggle," Deems said.

    "We all need to start looking into what we can do to do better for the animals."

    Alberta animal rescue organization opens first Edmonton facility

    Edmonton's Alberta Animal Rescue Crew Society (AARCS) shelter is also full.

    "We're finding that there just seems to be a real significant increase in intake or requested intake," AARCS Edmonton operations manager Leigh McLean said.

    "We've been getting a lot of surrender requests, a lot of emergency requests — communities are finding lots of strays, lots of animals that have been abandoned."

    McLean also noted their outgoing animals is lower than normal and added they've reduced their adoption fees to make space for new cases.

    "There's always an increase in intake over the summer and we do tend to find that there is a little bit of a drop in terms of supporters and adopters — things like that," McLean explained.

    At Saving Grace, the rescue is currently fundraising for its own vet clinic which Deems said would alleviate a lot of pressure.

    "(It would) allow us to free up some resources so that when we do these larger intakes, and when we get these calls, we aren't in such a panic mode," Deems said.

    Deems is hoping things turn around before it's too late.

    "I don't know how it can get any harder in rescue than it is right now."
    Edmonton's Food Bank tells city to work on poverty to fix food security

    Lauren Boothby -
     Edmonton Journal
    Yesterday 

    Handing out free food won’t solve poverty or food insecurity and the city needs to use its influence to fix the root causes, according to Edmonton’s Food Bank.


    A volunteer packs hampers at the Edmonton's Food Bank. The annual drive at the Heritage Festival brought in 22,761 kilograms of food but had a goal of 50,000 kilograms.

    Demand for its hamper program hit record heights in June — nearly double the requests from in 2020 — showing the need for the service, the charity said. But in a letter sent to councillors ahead of a committee meeting discussion on food insecurity, the food bank said governments and society need to address the reasons why people are being forced into poverty in the first place.

    “As with the case with most food banks, Edmonton’s Food Bank challenges the notion that gleaned food on its own will reduce poverty,” the letter, a portion of which was shared with Postmedia, states. “There is a moral dimension to hunger and we must all be committed to enhancing the health and well-being of others. After all, salvaged food is not a realistic substitute for policies that help vulnerable Canadians enter the workforce, or access adequate income support, and affordable housing that enables low-income people to live with dignity.”

    Tamisan Bencz-Knight, a spokesperson for Edmonton’s Food Bank, told Postmedia more energy needs to be put toward poverty reduction in general because food insecurity is just one symptom. She said helping people with housing, addictions, childcare, transportation, and mental health are key.

    “Feeding people is good, we need to keep doing that, but we’re not moving that bar,” she said. “Giving away food is easy when you compare it with poverty … Those are the hard conversations we have to have as a society, as a city, and one idea will not fix it all.”

    Apart from talk on inflationary pressures, councillors didn’t discuss poverty in relation to food security more generally during the meeting. However, some members asked city administration if advocacy on food security is being considered now. No specifics on planned actions were given.

    In June, 30,770 people received a hamper from the food bank, the highest of any June in the charity’s history. By comparison, 17,962 people got a hamper in 2020, and just 12,622 in 2012. Food hampers helped 34,867 people last month , the highest ever.
    Shortfall in Alberta supports

    Multiple gaps in social services, many under provincial jurisdiction, are identified in the food bank’s letter — “inadequate welfare benefits, lack of disability supports, family breakdown and domestic violence, chronic unemployment, lack of subsidized daycare and rent, unreasonable and unsafe housing, addictions, and much much more.”

    Eric Engler, press secretary for mental health and addictions associate minister Mike Ellis, wrote in an email that the Alberta government is continuing to support the most vulnerable, including with $6 million to food banks and community groups offering food supplies.

    “We are doing everything we can to help families get the support they need to pay rent, buy food, find and keep appropriate housing and care for their loved ones,” he stated. “Overall, Alberta’s government has committed more than any other province for affordability with more than $2 billion dollars in relief that includes fuel tax relief, electricity rebate, affordable childcare, and a natural gas rebate that will begin this fall.”

    Engler said AISH payments are the highest in Canada and the province supports people with mental health issues and pointed to Alberta’s rent supplement program.

    On addictions, he pointed to the addition of 8,000 new treatment spaces , a recovery facility with 100 beds outside Edmonton, services to reduce harm like the Digital Overdose Response System (DORS) app, and expansion of opioid agonist therapy and covering the costs of the injectable opioid treatment drug Sublocade.

    Advocates have called for the province to make harm-reduction services more accessible. In May, 118 drug poisoning deaths were reported in Alberta , well above pre-pandemic levels.

    While it doesn’t offer specific policy changes, Edmonton’s Food Bank urged city council to review recommendations by Food Banks of Canada in its recent Hunger Count report . Suggestions (some issues are federal) included new supports for renters with low incomes, making affordable housing available quicker, expanding support for low-wage and underemployed workers, minimum income pilot programs, and more support for low-income single adults.

    Results of a survey in Edmonton’s Food Bank’s 2021 report found most users needed between $200 and $600 more a month to reduce reliance on its services. Its survey found many users aren’t aware of or weren’t using some City of Edmonton programs like the free leisure pass (around 75 per cent) and the low-income bus pass (around 70 per cent).

    lboothby@postmedia.com

    @laurby
    Oil spill near Clyde River water source went unreported for months

    An oil spill in Clyde River that went unreported for nine months has contaminated the hamlet’s raw water source.


    Jerry Natanine, the community’s senior administrative officer, told Nunatsiaq News he was told about the spill when it happened, but only found out about the water contamination three weeks ago.

    He said hamlet workers finished cleaning the spill on Aug. 5 by shovelling the contaminated gravel and using an absorbent material to soak up the oil from Water Lake, where residents get their potable water.

    The spill — which he estimated to be less than 20 litres — happened after a pipe carrying hydraulic oil burst in a water truck. It occurred about six metres from the lake.

    “All of it ended up on the gravel, but it seeped down to the lake,” Natanine said.

    The contamination wasn’t cleaned up immediately because the hamlet was facing other problems at the time, such as high levels of snow and blizzards.

    “They just couldn’t get to it,” he said.

    Clyde River had an especially harsh winter, with blizzards starting in November and persisting into February. The hamlet declared a local state of emergency early this year because its snow-removal equipment broke down.

    Health Department spokesperson Chris Puglia said the hamlet did not report the spill to the territory’s Health or Environment Department and no residents complained about the water quality.

    “Neither department became aware of the incident until inquiries were made following the request for information from Nunatsiaq News,” Puglia said.

    He said an environmental health officer will travel to Clyde River to investigate.

    In the meantime, Natanine says the water is safe to drink.

    The hamlet sends out weekly samples of water from different buildings that came back safe for consumption every week, which, he said, includes testing for oil.

    Puglia agrees the risk to human health is low, because the spill is small and there haven’t been any reports of the water tasting or smelling bad.

    David Venn, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter, Nunatsiaq News
    India and Russia: friends for a reason, friends for a season

    Delhi plays a delicate balancing act between self-interest
    and historical friendship. And it’s all about oil and gas.


    Russian President Vladimir Putin and Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi at Hyderabad House, New Delhi 
    (Sanjeev Verma/Hindustan Times via Getty Images)

    AARTI BETIGERI
    Published 15 Aug 2022 

    If your friend’s friend is an enemy, does that make your friend a frenemy? In the milieu of Mean Girls, it most certainly does. In the context of efforts to cast Russia as a global pariah, the West is finding its limits with some nations stubbornly insisting on keeping their other relationships buoyant, even if there’s a cost. India, in particular, has insisted on neutrality to allow it to keep trading with Russia, and, after much effort to convince Delhi otherwise, the West has given way.

    India, along with China, has been buying up Russia’s cheap oil to the tune of one million barrels per day.

    At issue is India’s continuing economic relationship with Moscow, particularly around booming oil purchases and now fertiliser sales. The United States and its allies’ “burn book” sanctions regime insists that countries work to isolate Russia in protest over President Vladimir Putin’s war in Ukraine. But in an anarchic world order, impelling partners to do your bidding is tricky business, and India has been increasingly showing its independent streak.

    India, along with China, has been buying up Russia’s cheap oil to the tune of one million barrels per day. The oil is directed towards its ever-thirsty domestic market – but also its own exports of refined products such as petroleum and diesel, which are very nice earners indeed. Meanwhile, fertiliser trade is also rising, with India importing 7.74 million tonnes of Russian fertiliser in April–June.

    With many other buyers stepping away from Russia or reducing their purchases, India and China are now being purposefully linked to the war in Ukraine, described as the war’s financial backers.
    Protests in New Delhi have focused on the rising price of petrol, diesel and gas in the country, 11 April 2022 (Sonu Mehta/Hindustan Times via Getty Images)

    It’s a description that India has already lashed out over, with Foreign Minister S. Jaishankar in June insisting that India was merely looking out for itself and was being unfairly targeted given that European countries were continuing to buy Russian gas, and limits on oil markets such as Iran and Venezuela were limiting access to oil reserves. “Is buying Russian gas not funding the war?” said Jaishankar, referring to European gas purchases. “It’s only Indian money and oil coming to India that funds it, but not the gas coming to Europe? Let’s be a little even-handed here.” His tone of defensiveness, verging on belligerence, was notable.
    Prices for Russia’s oil exports sank earlier this year but are now on the rebound, thanks to the strong demand from India and China – now the top buyers.

    India’s move to capture Russian oil cheaply is a bold and opportunistic one. Despite a general acceptance that the world will never really be able to stop trading with Russia, there have been plans put in place by the European Union, the United Kingdom and the United States to phase out imports of Russian oil, as well as limit gas and coal. But with a heavy dependence on these energy sources – the European Union relies on Russian gas for about 40 per cent of its gas needs – it is fairly clear that the sanctions can’t really be stringently enforced.

    Prices for Russia’s oil exports sank earlier this year but are now on the rebound, thanks to the strong demand from India and China – now the top buyers. At the same time, economic sanctions are easing as the West realises that falling into line won’t happen easily – even among themselves.

    It could well be considered a win for India. Confident, unwavering and unwilling to kowtow to Western demands – however morally reasonable they are – and shameless in operating in total self-interest. It might even be considered a signpost on India’s path towards great power status.

    But warning bells sound. India is meant to be an ally (small a) in the quest to ensure a rules-based order exists in the Indo-Pacific. How can it be legitimately considered one, given it is helping prop up the economy of a murderous regime? Its move to capitalise on cheap oil hasn’t just put it at odds with major powers, it has put it in proximity to China and Pakistan – both of which India sees as enduring threats. Detaching from your gang of friends – in this case, the Quad, the United Kingdom and the European Union – in favour of hanging out with your enemies is a peculiar move, but such is the reality of pursuing an unaligned stance.

    India is growing in importance as a strategic partner across the globe. But its conception of itself as a great-power-in-waiting and its current level of power should not obscure the fact that, as is almost always the case, self-interest comes first, despite its participation in fresh partnerships. Tempering expectations and treating the relationship with caution is the way to go. As they say, keep your friends close and your frenemies on a long, stretchy leash.
    China’s Europe Game


    August 14, 2022


    Slow, and rarely surely

    The Chinese Communist Party (CCP) is patient and powerful. But that does not make it invincible. The lesson of its activities in central and eastern Europe (CEE) is that it succeeds mainly because of western weakness, rather than because of its own genius.

    A new series of reports for the Center for European Policy Analysis (CEPA) looks at CCP influence in a dozen CEE countries. At first sight, the picture is confusingly varied. Chinese influence operations target big countries (Poland and Romania) and small ones (Montenegro, Estonia, or North Macedonia). They prioritize economic means (as in Hungary and the Western Balkans, but also diplomatic or soft power (Poland). They chime with domestic political objectives (Serbia and Hungary) and cut diametrically across them (the Czech Republic and Lithuania). They are systematic (Serbia) and dilatory (Romania).

    The main common factor is minimal use of effort, unless — as in Lithuania — local decision-makers violate the party’s taboos on issues such as Tibet and Taiwan. The approach is fundamentally opportunistic. Chinese agents of influence take their chances where they see them, ranging from infrastructure projects to divide-and-rule gambits. When something works, they do it again. When it fails, they lose interest.

    This is disappointing for those who would like to see the CEE region as a geopolitical crossroads, the focus of sinister schemes by a totalitarian superpower. But in truth, as seen from Beijing, the CEE region is a backwater. “They would sacrifice all their interests in the region for a slightly better position in a big German federal state like North-Rhine Westphalia,” a government China-watcher told me, requesting anonymity in order to speak frankly.

    Chinese expertise in the region can be deceptive. Individual diplomats can display stunning mastery of the local language: the fruits of specialization. But the CCP is baffled by local power dynamics or the economic, cultural, historical, and geographical differences in what seem impossibly small countries. Propaganda follows a generalized anti-Western line which falls flat more often than it works.

    It is also easy to overstate the local reaction. Illiberal governments in the region can be equally opportunistic, using ties with China for domestic political purposes, and as a bargaining chip when haggling with Western decision-makers in Brussels. True: playing the “China card” had some success during the socially stressed era of the covid-19 pandemic. But the relationship is skin-deep. China features far more in official discourse in Belgrade and Budapest than Serbia and Hungary do in Beijing. Other places matter more.

    The CCP’s showcase multilateral project, launched as the 16+1 in 2012, is a signal example of the failure. Lithuania left the framework in 2021. Estonia and Latvia have just pulled out too, underlining the CCP’s ingrained inability to practice multilateral diplomacy. Indeed, the CCP's master plan of using infrastructure to boost political and economic ties is severely dented. Recent events in countries such as Kenya, Sri Lanka, and Pakistan have highlighted flaws in the flagship Belt and Road Initiative. Far from supplanting Western-led development loans and aid, the result is overpriced projects with weak commercial rationales and shaky financing.

    This is no reason for complacency. China’s successes may be flimsy, but they still reflect gaps created by Western failure. The stuttering pace of EU enlargement in the Western Balkans, timidity in confronting the headstrong Hungarian leadership, failure to show solidarity with Lithuania over Taiwan, and the neglect of Chinese-language teaching in CEE universities were not the result of Chinese pressure. But they created conditions which the CCP could, and did, exploit. The Chinese leadership may be on the back foot now. But it thinks long term. And we, mostly, do not.


    Europe’s Edge is an online journal covering crucial topics in the transatlantic policy debate. All opinions are those of the author and do not necessarily represent the position or views of the institutions they represent or the Center for European Policy Analysis.
    Turkey’s medical touri$m eyes larger slice of global pie

    August 15, 2022

    ANKARA (XINHUA) – Turkey’s medical tourism is growing fast, as the shrinking Turkish lira has brought down the cost of treatments while cosmetic surgeries are giving the sector a competitive niche in the ever-evolving global market, professionals have said.

    Alper Capanoglu runs two clinics in Istanbul, Turkey’s largest city and commercial hub, and in the northwestern city of Bursa, serving some 3,000 patients annually, mostly foreigners from European, the Middle Eastern region, and Northern Africa countries.

    “The decline of the lira made our services more affordable, and Turkey has a very good medical infrastructure with skilled doctors,” Capanoglu told Xinhua.

    Turkey is seeking to boost revenues from tourism to help finance a current account deficit that has widened alarmingly this year due to interest rate cuts and a surge in imports. The rate cuts made despite inflation have also pressured the lira to lose much of its value since 2021.

    According to official figures, the first quarter of this year has seen some 285,000 medical tourists arriving in Turkey. It is estimated that by the end of this year, income from the branch will top USD3 billion.

    Among cosmetic surgeries, hair implantation brought in some 550,000 foreign customers in the first half of 2022, compared to 750,000 in the entire of 2019, leading the sector to post-pandemic recovery, said head of the Turkish Health Tourism Association Servet Terziler.

    In Turkey, hair loss treatments cost between EUR3,000 and EUR7,000, whereas “in Europe, doctors do it for about EUR8,000 to EUR10,000”, Terziler added.

    About a decade ago, Ankara recognised the importance of medical tourism and encouraged the establishment of private clinics and hospitals as well as private treatment wings in state-owned hospitals.

    These facilities thus receive tax breaks and certain exemptions from customs duties. Some of them also operate as travel agencies that offer streamlined medical tourism packages including flights, local transport, and top-notch accommodations, even a holiday in Turkey many resorts.

    In 2002, the share of tourists’ health expenditures in national tourism revenues was only one per cent. In 2020, it’s 4.5 per cent.

    But medical procedures don’t consist merely of facelifts and hair makeovers, people are also coming to have life-saving surgical interventions, according to business owners.

    “The cost of treatments in serious cases, such as cancer, organ transplant and other life-threatening illnesses here is only a fraction of the price in some European countries,” said chairman of a long-standing health service firm in Istanbul Aziz Ciga.

    “Medical tourism, including wellness, thermal therapies and geriatric care, amounts to an annual spending of USD1.2 trillion globally, according to surveys,” he said. “Our country has easily the potential of cashing on 10 per cent of this global pie.”
    Scotland becomes the first country to make access to free period products a legal right

    Scotland has made it the law for public settings to provide period products. -
     Copyright Canva

    By Nicole Lin Chang • Updated: 15/08/2022 - 

    Scotland has become the world’s first country to protect the right to free period products in law, marking a key step towards tackling "period poverty".

    The Period Products Act 2021 came into force on Monday, meaning that local authorities and education providers in Scotland now have a legal duty to provide free period products to anyone who needs them.

    The Scottish Government said it had invested more than £27 million (€32 million) to fund access to period products in a range of public settings, and that the new law “will cement this progress”.

    Labour Member of the Scottish Parliament (MSP) Monica Lennon, who campaigned for the legislation, said she was proud to have pioneered the new law.


    "Local authorities and partner organisations have worked hard to make the legal right to access free period products a reality," she said.

    "I’m grateful to them and the thousands of people who have got involved across the country".

    "This is another big milestone for period dignity campaigners and grassroots movements which shows the difference that progressive and bold political choices can make," she added



    "As the cost-of-living crisis takes hold, the Period Products Act is a beacon of hope which shows what can be achieved when politicians come together for the good of the people we serve".



    Scotland’s social justice secretary Shona Robison said that providing access to free period products was "fundamental to equality and dignity".

    "This is more important than ever at a time when people are making difficult choices due to the cost of living crisis, and we never want anyone to be in a position where they cannot access period products," she said.


    People can find their nearest collection point to get these period products through the PickupMyPeriod mobile app, which was launched earlier this year by social enterprise Hey Girls with Scottish Government support.

    "The Period Product Act shows Scotland is leading the way in recognising that period products are not a luxury and should be freely available to all," said Celia Hodson, the founder of social enterprise Hey Girls.



    The period product legislation was unanimously backed in the Scottish Parliament in 2020, with first minister Nicola Sturgeon saying at the time that it was “an important policy for women and girls”.

    In 2018, Scotland became the first country to provide free sanitary products in schools, colleges, and universities.

    Around one in 10 girls in the United Kingdom are unable to afford period products, according to a survey by Plan International UK in 2017.
    Number of EU citizens moving to UK plummets post-Brexit as labour shortages bite

    By Ben Turner • Updated: 15/08/2022 - 

    The UK's agriculture sector has seen the sharpest decline in EU workers, 
    according to the report - Copyright Justin Tallis/AFP

    The number of EU citizens moving to the UK has plummeted post-Brexit amid tighter visa requirements, a new report says.

    Just 43,000 people from EU member states received visas for work, study, family or other purposes in 2021, accounting for five per cent of all visas granted that year.

    It's a sharp decline compared to the 230,000 to 430,000 visas granted to EU citizens in the six years up to March 2020, according to figures from the Office for National Statistics.

    Since Brexit the UK has introduced a points-based immigration system that sets a minimum salary that prospective workers must earn.

    A study by the Migration Observatory at the University of Oxford and ReWage, a group of labour market experts, found the end of freedom of movement with the EU had "exacerbated" Britain's labour shortages.

    But the report also identifies other drivers such as higher job turnover since the Covid pandemic and less activity among people aged over 50.

    A Flourish chart


    Around 40 per cent of visas granted to EU citizens in 2021 were for students, while a further quarter went to "skilled workers" — those paid at least £26,500 (€31,400) per year.

    The UK's agriculture and hospitality industries have seen the biggest fall in jobs held by EU workers — dropping by around a quarter in both sectors between June 2019 to June 2021.

    Meanwhile the construction industry has seen a 13 per cent rise in such employees over the same period.

    However, only around 2,600 British employers hired at least one EU worker in 2021, with larger companies much more likely to provide the necessary sponsorship for a visa application.

    The report concludes there is "some evidence" that Brexit and the end of free movement contributed to labour shortages in the UK.

    "While there is some evidence that the end of free movement has contributed to shortages in some areas of the UK labour market, it is by no means the only driver," said Professor Chris Forde of the University of Leeds.

    "In fact, recruiting difficulties are not unique to the UK and several other countries have experienced high vacancy rates post-pandemic," he added.

    The report suggests expanding visa eligibility for low-wage jobs to address gaps in the UK's labour market.

    It also recommends reducing administrative requirements or fees for British employers looking to hire EU workers.

    EU citizens face tighter visa restrictions since the UK left the EU in January 2021, which ended freedom of movement with the bloc.

    The UK introduced a point-based immigration system, which sets a minimum criteria for any non-British citizens wanting to remain in the country for more than six months.

    Most people wishing to work in the UK must meet minimum salary requirements and have a minimum B1 English language level.

    Students have to obtain a visa to stay for more than six months and generally must leave the UK after their course finishes.

    Madeleine Sumption, director of the Migration Observatory at the University of Oxford, said: “While it is clear that ending free movement has made it harder for employers in low-wage industries to recruit staff, changing immigration policy to address shortages brings its own set of challenges.

    "Low-wage work visa schemes are notoriously difficult to police and often open workers up to exploitation and abuse."