Saturday, November 30, 2024

UK

Assisted dying bill: How many Labour MPs voted for, against or didn’t vote


Photo: House of Commons

MPs have given their backing to Kim Leadbeater’s assisted dying bill at its second reading, with 330 MPs voting in favour of the motion after a morning of emotional debate in the House of Commons.

A total of 234 Labour MPs voted in favour of the motion, with 147 against and 22 not voting.

The bill would allow terminally ill people with a life expectancy of less than six months to receive assistance in ending their life.


How every MP voted on the Assisted Dying Bill

Yesterday
LEFT FOOT FORWARD


MPs have voted for the Assisted Dying Bill with a substantial majority


MPs voted this afternoon on the second reading of The Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill. The Bill seeks to legalise assisted dying by allowing adults who are terminally ill with less than six months to live take their own life at the time of their choosing.

The Bill has sparked intense discussion in Westminster. As MPs were given a free vote (they weren’t instructed how to vote by party whips), each MP has been deciding independently whether to support the legislation.

Supporters of the legislation argue that it will allow people who are terminally ill and in pain to have the freedom to end their life at the time of their choosing, and reduce their suffering. Opponents have argued that there are insufficient safeguards in place and it could lead to people being coerced into taking their own life.

The Bill passed its second reading in the Commons, with 330 MPs voting in favour and 275 MPs voting against. As a result, the legislation will now continue its journey through parliament.

The breakdown of MPs’ votes by party was as follows:Alliance: 0 for, 1 against, 0 did not vote
Conservative: 23 for, 93 against, 3 did not vote
Democratic Unionist Party: 0 for, 5 against, 0 did not vote
Green Party: 4 for, 0 against, 0 did not vote
Independent: 1 for, 14 against, 0 did not vote
Labour: 236 for, 148 against, 18 did not vote
Liberal Democrat: 61 for, 11 against, 0 did not vote
Plaid Cymru: 3 for, 1 against, 0 did not vote
Reform UK: 3 for, 2 against, 0 did not vote
Scottish National Party: 0 for, 0 against, 9 did not vote
Social Democratic and Labour Party: 1 for, 0 against, 1 did not vote
Traditional Unionist Voice: 0 for, 1 against, 0 did not vote
Ulster Unionist Party: 0 for, 1 against, 0 did not vote

45 MPs did not vote on the Bill. Many of them will have intentionally abstained – including the majority of Tory MPs missing from the list. Others may have been ‘paired’ – a mechanism used by MPs when they cannot attend a vote in the House of Commons where an MP from another party who would have voted differently to them agrees not to vote, or otherwise did not attend for health or other reasons.

In addition, the speaker of the House of Commons does not participate in votes, and MPs from Sinn Fein do not take their seats in parliament.

Below is a fill list of how every MP voted on the second reading of the Assisted Dying Bill.
MPs who voted for the Bill
Stephen Kinnock Labour Aberafan Maesteg
Connor Rand Labour Altrincham and Sale West
Mark Tami Labour Alyn and Deeside
Linsey Farnsworth Labour Amber Valley
Lee Anderson Reform UK Ashfield
Laura Kyrke-Smith Labour Aylesbury
Elaine Stewart Labour Ayr, Carrick and Cumnock
Claire Hughes Labour Bangor Aberconwy
Dan Jarvis Labour Barnsley North
Luke Murphy Labour Basingstoke
Jo White Labour Bassetlaw
Wera Hobhouse Liberal Democrat Bath
Alison McGovern Labour Birkenhead
Jess Phillips Labour Birmingham Yardley
Lorraine Beavers Labour Blackpool North and Fleetwood
Chris Webb Labour Blackpool South
Natalie Fleet Labour Bolsover
Kirith Entwistle Labour Bolton North East
Phil Brickell Labour Bolton West
Peter Dowd Labour Bootle
Richard Tice Reform UK Boston and Skegness
Tom Hayes Labour Bournemouth East
Peter Swallow Labour Bracknell
David Chadwick Liberal Democrat Brecon, Radnor and Cwm Tawe
Ruth Cadbury Labour Brentford and Isleworth
Chris Elmore Labour Bridgend
Ashley Fox Conservative Bridgwater
Chris Ward Labour Brighton Kemptown and Peacehaven
Siân Berry Green Party Brighton Pavilion
Carla Denyer Green Party Bristol Central
Kerry McCarthy Labour Bristol East
Damien Egan Labour Bristol North East
Karin Smyth Labour Bristol South
Callum Anderson Labour Buckingham and Bletchley
Oliver Ryan Labour Burnley
Jacob Collier Labour Burton and Uttoxeter
Christian Wakeford Labour Bury South
Peter Prinsley Labour Bury St Edmunds and Stowmarket
Perran Moon Labour Camborne and Redruth
Daniel Zeichner Labour Cambridge
Jo Stevens Labour Cardiff East
Anna McMorrin Labour Cardiff North
Alex Barros-Curtis Labour Cardiff West
Bobby Dean Liberal Democrat Carshalton and Wallington
Alan Gemmell Labour Central Ayrshire
Mel Stride Conservative Central Devon
Ben Lake Plaid Cymru Ceredigion Preseli
Tristan Osborne Labour Chatham and Aylesford
Marie Goldman Liberal Democrat Chelmsford
Max Wilkinson Liberal Democrat Cheltenham
Sarah Green Liberal Democrat Chesham and Amersham
Samantha Dixon Labour Chester North and Neston
Aphra Brandreth Conservative Chester South and Eddisbury
Toby Perkins Labour Chesterfield
Jess Brown-Fuller Liberal Democrat Chichester
Sarah Gibson Liberal Democrat Chippenham
Rachel Blake Labour Cities of London and Westminster
Becky Gittins Labour Clwyd East
Gill German Labour Clwyd North
Pam Cox Labour Colchester
Paul Davies Labour Colne Valley
Sarah Russell Labour Congleton
Lee Barron Labour Corby and East Northamptonshire
Emma Foody Labour Cramlington and Killingworth
Connor Naismith Labour Crewe and Nantwich
Natasha Irons Labour Croydon East
Chris Philp Conservative Croydon South
Sarah Jones Labour Croydon West
Jim Dickson Labour Dartford
Baggy Shanker Labour Derby South
John Whitby Labour Derbyshire Dales
Olly Glover Liberal Democrat Didcot and Wantage
Lee Pitcher Labour Doncaster East and the Isle of Axholme
Ed Miliband Labour Doncaster North
Chris Coghlan Liberal Democrat Dorking and Horley
Mike Tapp Labour Dover and Deal
Sonia Kumar Labour Dudley
Graeme Downie Labour Dunfermline and Dollar
Alex Mayer Labour Dunstable and Leighton Buzzard
Liz Saville Roberts Plaid Cymru Dwyfor Meirionnydd
James Murray Labour Ealing North
Deirdre Costigan Labour Ealing Southall
Yuan Yang Labour Earley and Woodley
Joani Reid Labour East Kilbride and Strathaven
Tom Rutland Labour East Worthing and Shoreham
Josh Babarinde Liberal Democrat Eastbourne
Liz Jarvis Liberal Democrat Eastleigh
Chris Murray Labour Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
Tracy Gilbert Labour Edinburgh North and Leith
Christine Jardine Liberal Democrat Edinburgh West
Clive Efford Labour Eltham and Chislehurst
Charlotte Cane Liberal Democrat Ely and East Cambridgeshire
Helen Maguire Liberal Democrat Epsom and Ewell
Adam Thompson Labour Erewash
Steve Race Labour Exeter
Euan Stainbank Labour Falkirk
Claire Hazelgrove Labour Filton and Bradley Stoke
Sarah Sackman Labour Finchley and Golders Green
Tony Vaughan Labour Folkestone and Hythe
Matt Bishop Labour Forest of Dean
Colum Eastwood Social Democratic & Labour Party Foyle
Anna Sabine Liberal Democrat Frome and East Somerset
Andrew Snowden Conservative Fylde
Mark Ferguson Labour Gateshead Central and Whickham
Michael Payne Labour Gedling
Maureen Burke Labour Glasgow North East
Sarah Dyke Liberal Democrat Glastonbury and Somerton
Jeremy Hunt Conservative Godalming and Ash
David Davis Conservative Goole and Pocklington
Caroline Dinenage Conservative Gosport
Tonia Antoniazzi Labour Gower
Melanie Onn Labour Great Grimsby and Cleethorpes
Rupert Lowe Reform UK Great Yarmouth
Matthew Pennycook Labour Greenwich and Woolwich
Zöe Franklin Liberal Democrat Guildford
Alex Ballinger Labour Halesowen
Kate Dearden Labour Halifax
Andy Slaughter Labour Hammersmith and Chiswick
Tulip Siddiq Labour Hampstead and Highgate
Chris Vince Labour Harlow
Victoria Collins Liberal Democrat Harpenden and Berkhamsted
Tom Gordon Liberal Democrat Harrogate and Knaresborough
Jonathan Brash Labour Hartlepool
Helena Dollimore Labour Hastings and Rye
John McDonnell Independent Hayes and Harlington
Lisa Smart Liberal Democrat Hazel Grove
David Taylor Labour Hemel Hempstead
Freddie van Mierlo Liberal Democrat Henley and Thame
Josh Dean Labour Hertford and Stortford
Oliver Dowden Conservative Hertsmere
Joe Morris Labour Hexham
Jon Pearce Labour High Peak
Luke Evans Conservative Hinckley and Bosworth
Alistair Strathern Labour Hitchin
Keir Starmer Labour Holborn and St Pancras
Richard Foord Liberal Democrat Honiton and Sidmouth
Catherine West Labour Hornsey and Friern Barnet
John Milne Liberal Democrat Horsham
Peter Kyle Labour Hove and Portslade
Harpreet Uppal Labour Huddersfield
Jas Athwal Labour Ilford South
Emily Thornberry Labour Islington South and Finsbury
Kate Osborne Labour Jarrow and Gateshead East
Joe Powell Labour Kensington and Bayswater
Rosie Wrighting Labour Kettering
Karl Turner Labour Kingston upon Hull East
Diana Johnson Labour Kingston upon Hull North and Cottingham
Emma Hardy Labour Kingston upon Hull West and Haltemprice
Fabian Hamilton Labour Leeds North East
Katie White Labour Leeds North West
Hilary Benn Labour Leeds South
Mark Sewards Labour Leeds South West and Morley
Rachel Reeves Labour Leeds West and Pudsey
Liz Kendall Labour Leicester West
Jo Platt Labour Leigh and Atherton
James MacCleary Liberal Democrat Lewes
Janet Daby Labour Lewisham East
Calvin Bailey Labour Leyton and Wanstead
Dave Robertson Labour Lichfield
Hamish Falconer Labour Lincoln
Maria Eagle Labour Liverpool Garston
Kim Johnson Labour Liverpool Riverside
Paula Barker Labour Liverpool Wavertree
Gregor Poynton Labour Livingston
Jeevun Sandher Labour Loughborough
Victoria Atkins Conservative Louth and Horncastle
Rachel Hopkins Labour Luton South and South Bedfordshire
Tim Roca Labour Macclesfield
Joshua Reynolds Liberal Democrat Maidenhead
Josh Simons Labour Makerfield
Lucy Powell Labour Manchester Central
Jeff Smith Labour Manchester Withington
Steve Yemm Labour Mansfield
Brian Mathew Liberal Democrat Melksham and Devizes
Gerald Jones Labour Merthyr Tydfil and Aberdare
Henry Tufnell Labour Mid and South Pembrokeshire
Andrew Cooper Labour Mid Cheshire
Vikki Slade Liberal Democrat Mid Dorset and North Poole
Susan Murray Liberal Democrat Mid Dunbartonshire
Peter Bedford Conservative Mid Leicestershire
George Freeman Conservative Mid Norfolk
Alison Bennett Liberal Democrat Mid Sussex
Luke Myer Labour Middlesbrough South and East Cleveland
Kirsty McNeill Labour Midlothian
Emily Darlington Labour Milton Keynes Central
Chris Curtis Labour Milton Keynes North
Catherine Fookes Labour Monmouthshire
Steve Witherden Labour Montgomeryshire and Glyndŵr
Lizzi Collinge Labour Morecambe and Lunesdale
Pamela Nash Labour Motherwell, Wishaw and Carluke
Lee Dillon Liberal Democrat Newbury
Jessica Morden Labour Newport East
Martin Wrigley Liberal Democrat Newton Abbot
Irene Campbell Labour North Ayrshire and Arran
Ben Maguire Liberal Democrat North Cornwall
Ian Roome Liberal Democrat North Devon
Luke Akehurst Labour North Durham
Louise Jones Labour North East Derbyshire
Wendy Chamberlain Liberal Democrat North East Fife
Alex Brewer Liberal Democrat North East Hampshire
Chris Hinchliff Labour North East Hertfordshire
Dan Norris Labour North East Somerset and Hanham
Ellie Chowns Green Party North Herefordshire
Steff Aquarone Liberal Democrat North Norfolk
Helen Morgan Liberal Democrat North Shropshire
Sadik Al-Hassan Labour North Somerset
Rachel Taylor Labour North Warwickshire and Bedworth
Sam Carling Labour North West Cambridgeshire
Kit Malthouse Conservative North West Hampshire
Amanda Hack Labour North West Leicestershire
James Wild Conservative North West Norfolk
Lucy Rigby Labour Northampton North
Alice Macdonald Labour Norwich North
Clive Lewis Labour Norwich South
Nadia Whittome Labour Nottingham East
Alex Norris Labour Nottingham North and Kimberley
Lilian Greenwood Labour Nottingham South
Jodie Gosling Labour Nuneaton
Alistair Carmichael Liberal Democrat Orkney and Shetland
Jade Botterill Labour Ossett and Denby Dale
Layla Moran Liberal Democrat Oxford West and Abingdon
Miatta Fahnbulleh Labour Peckham
Jonathan Hinder Labour Pendle and Clitheroe
Marie Tidball Labour Penistone and Stocksbridge
Markus Campbell-Savours Labour Penrith and Solway
Fred Thomas Labour Plymouth Moor View
Luke Pollard Labour Plymouth Sutton and Devonport
Yvette Cooper Labour Pontefract, Castleford and Knottingley
Alex Davies-Jones Labour Pontypridd
Neil Duncan-Jordan Labour Poole
Amanda Martin Labour Portsmouth North
Stephen Morgan Labour Portsmouth South
Georgia Gould Labour Queen’s Park and Maida Vale
John Healey Labour Rawmarsh and Conisbrough
Anna Turley Labour Redcar
Chris Bloore Labour Redditch
Rishi Sunak Conservative Richmond and Northallerton
Lauren Edwards Labour Rochester and Strood
Andy MacNae Labour Rossendale and Darwen
Jake Richards Labour Rother Valley
Sarah Champion Labour Rotherham
John Slinger Labour Rugby
Alicia Kearns Conservative Rutland and Stamford
Alison Hume Labour Scarborough and Whitby
Nicholas Dakin Labour Scunthorpe
Bill Esterson Labour Sefton Central
Keir Mather Labour Selby
Laura Trott Conservative Sevenoaks
Olivia Blake Labour Sheffield Hallam
Louise Haigh Labour Sheffield Heeley
Clive Betts Labour Sheffield South East
Michelle Welsh Labour Sherwood Forest
Julia Buckley Labour Shrewsbury
Kevin McKenna Labour Sittingbourne and Sheppey
Neil Shastri-Hurst Conservative Solihull West and Shirley
Pippa Heylings Liberal Democrat South Cambridgeshire
Roz Savage Liberal Democrat South Cotswolds
Samantha Niblett Labour South Derbyshire
Caroline Voaden Liberal Democrat South Devon
Lloyd Hatton Labour South Dorset
Anna Gelderd Labour South East Cornwall
Paul Foster Labour South Ribble
James Cartlidge Conservative South Suffolk
Terry Jermy Labour South West Norfolk
David Burton-Sampson Labour Southend West and Leigh
Kim Leadbeater Labour Spen Valley
Daisy Cooper Liberal Democrat St Albans
Noah Law Labour St Austell and Newquay
Andrew George Liberal Democrat St Ives
Ian Sollom Liberal Democrat St Neots and Mid Cambridgeshire
Leigh Ingham Labour Stafford
Kevin Bonavia Labour Stevenage
Chris Kane Labour Stirling and Strathallan
Gareth Snell Labour Stoke-on-Trent Central
Cat Eccles Labour Stourbridge
Manuela Perteghella Liberal Democrat Stratford-on-Avon
Steve Reed Labour Streatham and Croydon North
Andrew Western Labour Stretford and Urmston
Simon Opher Labour Stroud
Jenny Riddell-Carpenter Labour Suffolk Coastal
Lewis Atkinson Labour Sunderland Central
Al Pinkerton Liberal Democrat Surrey Heath
Luke Taylor Liberal Democrat Sutton and Cheam
Andrew Mitchell Conservative Sutton Coldfield
Torsten Bell Labour Swansea West
Will Stone Labour Swindon North
Heidi Alexander Labour Swindon South
Sarah Edwards Labour Tamworth
Shaun Davies Labour Telford
Cameron Thomas Liberal Democrat Tewkesbury
Kevin Hollinrake Conservative Thirsk and Malton
Claire Young Liberal Democrat Thornbury and Yate
Rachel Gilmour Liberal Democrat Tiverton and Minehead
Steve Darling Liberal Democrat Torbay
Jayne Kirkham Labour Truro and Falmouth
Mike Martin Liberal Democrat Tunbridge Wells
Alan Campbell Labour Tynemouth
Danny Beales Labour Uxbridge and South Ruislip
Kanishka Narayan Labour Vale of Glamorgan
Simon Lightwood Labour Wakefield and Rothwell
Angela Eagle Labour Wallasey
Stella Creasy Labour Walthamstow
Charlotte Nichols Labour Warrington North
Sarah Hall Labour Warrington South
Matt Western Labour Warwick and Leamington
Sharon Hodgson Labour Washington and Gateshead South
Matt Turmaine Labour Watford
Adrian Ramsay Green Party Waveney Valley
Gen Kitchen Labour Wellingborough and Rushden
Tessa Munt Liberal Democrat Wells and Mendip Hills
Andrew Lewin Labour Welwyn Hatfield
Sarah Coombes Labour West Bromwich
Edward Morello Liberal Democrat West Dorset
Dan Aldridge Labour Weston-super-Mare
Josh MacAlister Labour Whitehaven and Workington
Lisa Nandy Labour Wigan
Danny Chambers Liberal Democrat Winchester
Charlie Maynard Liberal Democrat Witney
Will Forster Liberal Democrat Woking
Clive Jones Liberal Democrat Wokingham
Pat McFadden Labour Wolverhampton South East
Warinder Juss Labour Wolverhampton West
Michael Wheeler Labour Worsley and Eccles
Beccy Cooper Labour Worthing West
Andrew Ranger Labour Wrexham
Emma Reynolds Labour Wycombe
Mark Garnier Conservative Wyre Forest
Adam Dance Liberal Democrat Yeovil
Llinos Medi Plaid Cymru Ynys Môn
Luke Charters Labour York Outer
Sarah Owen (Teller) Labour Luton North
Bambos Charalambous (Teller) Labour Southgate and Wood Green

MPs who voted against the Bill
Kenneth Stevenson Labour Airdrie and Shotts
Alex Baker Labour Aldershot
Wendy Morton Conservative Aldridge-Brownhills
Brian Leishman Labour Alloa and Grangemouth
Andrew Griffith Conservative Arundel and South Downs
Sojan Joseph Labour Ashford
Angela Rayner Labour Ashton-under-Lyne
Sean Woodcock Labour Banbury
Nesil Caliskan Labour Barking
Stephanie Peacock Labour Barnsley South
Michelle Scrogham Labour Barrow and Furness
Richard Holden Conservative Basildon and Billericay
Kirsteen Sullivan Labour Bathgate and Linlithgow
Marsha De Cordova Labour Battersea
Joy Morrissey Conservative Beaconsfield
Liam Conlon Labour Beckenham and Penge
Mohammad Yasin Labour Bedford
Gavin Robinson Democratic Unionist Party Belfast East
Neil Coyle Labour Bermondsey and Old Southwark
John Lamont Conservative Berwickshire, Roxburgh and Selkirk
Rushanara Ali Labour Bethnal Green and Stepney
Graham Stuart Conservative Beverley and Holderness
Kieran Mullan Conservative Bexhill and Battle
Daniel Francis Labour Bexleyheath and Crayford
Calum Miller Liberal Democrat Bicester and Woodstock
Preet Kaur Gill Labour Birmingham Edgbaston
Paulette Hamilton Labour Birmingham Erdington
Tahir Ali Labour Birmingham Hall Green and Moseley
Liam Byrne Labour Birmingham Hodge Hill and Solihull North
Shabana Mahmood Labour Birmingham Ladywood
Laurence Turner Labour Birmingham Northfield
Ayoub Khan Independent Birmingham Perry Barr
Sam Rushworth Labour Bishop Auckland
Adnan Hussain Independent Blackburn
Graham Stringer Labour Blackley and Middleton South
Liz Twist Labour Blaydon and Consett
Ian Lavery Labour Blyth and Ashington
Alison Griffiths Conservative Bognor Regis and Littlehampton
Yasmin Qureshi Labour Bolton South and Walkden
Imran Hussain Independent Bradford East
Naz Shah Labour Bradford West
James Cleverly Conservative Braintree
Dawn Butler Labour Brent East
Barry Gardiner Labour Brent West
Alex Burghart Conservative Brentwood and Ongar
Martin Vickers Conservative Brigg and Immingham
Darren Jones Labour Bristol North West
Jerome Mayhew Conservative Broadland and Fakenham
Peter Fortune Conservative Bromley and Biggin Hill
Bradley Thomas Conservative Bromsgrove
Lewis Cocking Conservative Broxbourne
Juliet Campbell Labour Broxtowe
James Frith Labour Bury North
Ann Davies Plaid Cymru Caerfyrddin
Chris Evans Labour Caerphilly
Jamie Stone Liberal Democrat Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross
Josh Newbury Labour Cannock Chase
Rosie Duffield Independent Canterbury
Stephen Doughty Labour Cardiff South and Penarth
Julie Minns Labour Carlisle
Rebecca Harris Conservative Castle Point
Patrick Spencer Conservative Central Suffolk and North Ipswich
Tom Morrison Liberal Democrat Cheadle
Ben Coleman Labour Chelsea and Fulham
Iain Duncan Smith Conservative Chingford and Woodford Green
Dan Tomlinson Labour Chipping Barnet
Christopher Chope Conservative Christchurch
Mary Kelly Foy Labour City of Durham
Nigel Farage Reform UK Clacton
Bell Ribeiro-Addy Labour Clapham and Brixton Hill
Frank McNally Labour Coatbridge and Bellshill
Mary Creagh Labour Coventry East
Taiwo Owatemi Labour Coventry North West
Zarah Sultana Independent Coventry South
Melanie Ward Labour Cowdenbeath and Kirkcaldy
Katrina Murray Labour Cumbernauld and Kirkintilloch
Margaret Mullane Labour Dagenham and Rainham
Lola McEvoy Labour Darlington
Stuart Andrew Conservative Daventry
Catherine Atkinson Labour Derby North
Iqbal Mohamed Independent Dewsbury and Batley
Sally Jameson Labour Doncaster Central
Nigel Huddleston Conservative Droitwich and Evesham
Helen Hayes Labour Dulwich and West Norwood
John Cooper Conservative Dumfries and Galloway
David Mundell Conservative Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale and Tweeddale
Rupa Huq Labour Ealing Central and Acton
Grahame Morris Labour Easington
Sammy Wilson Democratic Unionist Party East Antrim
Mims Davies Conservative East Grinstead and Uckfield
Stephen Timms Labour East Ham
Damian Hinds Conservative East Hampshire
Gregory Campbell Democratic Unionist Party East Londonderry
Blair McDougall Labour East Renfrewshire
Claire Coutinho Conservative East Surrey
Polly Billington Labour East Thanet
Danny Kruger Conservative East Wiltshire
Scott Arthur Labour Edinburgh South West
Kate Osamor Labour Edmonton and Winchmore Hill
Justin Madders Labour Ellesmere Port and Bromborough
Feryal Clark Labour Enfield North
Neil Hudson Conservative Epping Forest
Abena Oppong-Asare Labour Erith and Thamesmead
Monica Harding Liberal Democrat Esher and Walton
David Reed Conservative Exmouth and Exeter East
Suella Braverman Conservative Fareham and Waterlooville
Gregory Stafford Conservative Farnham and Bordon
Helen Whately Conservative Faversham and Mid Kent
Seema Malhotra Labour Feltham and Heston
Edward Leigh Conservative Gainsborough
Naushabah Khan Labour Gillingham and Rainham
John Grady Labour Glasgow East
Martin Rhodes Labour Glasgow North
Gordon McKee Labour Glasgow South
Zubir Ahmed Labour Glasgow South West
Patricia Ferguson Labour Glasgow West
Richard Baker Labour Glenrothes and Mid Fife
Alex McIntyre Labour Gloucester
Harriet Cross Conservative Gordon and Buchan
Gareth Davies Conservative Grantham and Bourne
Lauren Sullivan Labour Gravesham
Diane Abbott Labour Hackney North and Stoke Newington
Meg Hillier Labour Hackney South and Shoreditch
Paul Holmes Conservative Hamble Valley
Imogen Walker Labour Hamilton and Clyde Valley
Neil O’Brien Conservative Harborough, Oadby and Wigston
Bob Blackman Conservative Harrow East
Bernard Jenkin Conservative Harwich and North Essex
Alan Mak Conservative Havant
David Pinto-Duschinsky Labour Hendon
Jesse Norman Conservative Hereford and South Herefordshire
Roger Gale Conservative Herne Bay and Sandwich
Elsie Blundell Labour Heywood and Middleton North
Julia Lopez Conservative Hornchurch and Upminster
Bridget Phillipson Labour Houghton and Sunderland South
Ben Obese-Jecty Conservative Huntingdon
Sarah Smith Labour Hyndburn
Wes Streeting Labour Ilford North
Martin McCluskey Labour Inverclyde and Renfrewshire West
Angus MacDonald Liberal Democrat Inverness, Skye and West Ross-shire
Jack Abbott Labour Ipswich
Joe Robertson Conservative Isle of Wight East
Richard Quigley Labour Isle of Wight West
Jeremy Corbyn Independent Islington North
Robbie Moore Conservative Keighley and Ilkley
Jeremy Wright Conservative Kenilworth and Southam
Lillian Jones Labour Kilmarnock and Loudoun
Ed Davey Liberal Democrat Kingston and Surbiton
Emma Hardy Labour Kingston upon Hull West and Haltemprice
Anneliese Midgley Labour Knowsley
Sorcha Eastwood Alliance Lagan Valley
Richard Burgon Independent Leeds East
Shivani Raja Conservative Leicester East
Shockat Adam Independent Leicester South
Vicky Foxcroft Labour Lewisham North
Ian Byrne Independent Liverpool West Derby
Nia Griffith Labour Llanelli
Jess Asato Labour Lowestoft
Helen Grant Conservative Maidstone and Malling
John Whittingdale Conservative Maldon
Edward Argar Conservative Melton and Syston
Saqib Bhatti Conservative Meriden and Solihull East
Blake Stephenson Conservative Mid Bedfordshire
Greg Smith Conservative Mid Buckinghamshire
Jonathan Davies Labour Mid Derbyshire
Andy McDonald Labour Middlesbrough and Thornaby East
Siobhain McDonagh Labour Mitcham and Morden
Torcuil Crichton Labour Na h-Eileanan an Iar
Julian Lewis Conservative New Forest East
Desmond Swayne Conservative New Forest West
Robert Jenrick Conservative Newark
Chi Onwurah Labour Newcastle upon Tyne Central and West
Mary Glindon Labour Newcastle upon Tyne East and Wallsend
Catherine McKinnell Labour Newcastle upon Tyne North
Adam Jogee Labour Newcastle-under-Lyme
Ruth Jones Labour Newport West and Islwyn
Alan Strickland Labour Newton Aycliffe and Spennymoor
Jon Trickett Labour Normanton and Hemsworth
Jim Allister Traditional Unionist Voice North Antrim
Richard Fuller Conservative North Bedfordshire
Simon Hoare Conservative North Dorset
Alex Easton Independent North Down
Steve Barclay Conservative North East Cambridgeshire
David Smith Labour North Northumberland
Kemi Badenoch Conservative North West Essex
Mike Reader Labour Northampton South
Louie French Conservative Old Bexley and Sidcup
Jim McMahon Labour Oldham West, Chadderton and Royton
Gareth Bacon Conservative Orpington
Anneliese Dodds Labour Oxford East
Alison Taylor Labour Paisley and Renfrewshire North
Johanna Baxter Labour Paisley and Renfrewshire South
Andrew Pakes Labour Peterborough
Apsana Begum Independent Poplar and Limehouse
Mark Hendrick Labour Preston
Fleur Anderson Labour Putney
Mark Francois Conservative Rayleigh and Wickford
Matt Rodda Labour Reading Central
Olivia Bailey Labour Reading West and Mid Berkshire
Rebecca Paul Conservative Reigate
Maya Ellis Labour Ribble Valley
Sarah Olney Liberal Democrat Richmond Park
Paul Waugh Labour Rochdale
Andrew Rosindell Conservative Romford
David Simmonds Conservative Ruislip, Northwood and Pinner
Mike Amesbury Independent Runcorn and Helsby
Ben Spencer Conservative Runnymede and Weybridge
James Naish Labour Rushcliffe
Michael Shanks Labour Rutherglen
Rebecca Long Bailey Independent Salford
John Glen Conservative Salisbury
Gill Furniss Labour Sheffield Brightside and Hillsborough
Abtisam Mohamed Labour Sheffield Central
Anna Dixon Labour Shipley
Julian Smith Conservative Skipton and Ripon
Caroline Johnson Conservative Sleaford and North Hykeham
Tanmanjeet Singh Dhesi Labour Slough
Gurinder Singh Josan Labour Smethwick
Robin Swann Ulster Unionist Party South Antrim
James McMurdock Reform UK South Basildon and East Thurrock
John Hayes Conservative South Holland and The Deepings
Alberto Costa Conservative South Leicestershire
Ben Goldsborough Labour South Norfolk
Sarah Bool Conservative South Northamptonshire
Emma Lewell-Buck Labour South Shields
Stuart Anderson Conservative South Shropshire
Rebecca Smith Conservative South West Devon
Gagan Mohindra Conservative South West Hertfordshire
Andrew Murrison Conservative South West Wiltshire
Darren Paffey Labour Southampton Itchen
Satvir Kaur Labour Southampton Test
Bayo Alaba Labour Southend East and Rochford
Patrick Hurley Labour Southport
Lincoln Jopp Conservative Spelthorne
David Baines Labour St Helens North
Marie Rimmer Labour St Helens South and Whiston
Karen Bradley Conservative Staffordshire Moorlands
Jonathan Reynolds Labour Stalybridge and Hyde
Chris McDonald Labour Stockton North
Matt Vickers Conservative Stockton West
David Williams Labour Stoke-on-Trent North
Allison Gardner Labour Stoke-on-Trent South
Gavin Williamson Conservative Stone, Great Wyrley and Penkridge
Jim Shannon Democratic Unionist Party Strangford
Uma Kumaran Labour Stratford and Bow
Esther McVey Conservative Tatton
Gideon Amos Liberal Democrat Taunton and Wellington
Mark Pritchard Conservative The Wrekin
Jen Craft Labour Thurrock
Antonia Bance Labour Tipton and Wednesbury
Tom Tugendhat Conservative Tonbridge
Rosena Allin-Khan Labour Tooting
Nick Thomas-Symonds Labour Torfaen
Geoffrey Cox Conservative Torridge and Tavistock
David Lammy Labour Tottenham
Munira Wilson Liberal Democrat Twickenham
Carla Lockhart Democratic Unionist Party Upper Bann
Valerie Vaz Labour Walsall and Bloxwich
Katie Lam Conservative Weald of Kent
Andrew Bowie Conservative West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
Douglas McAllister Labour West Dunbartonshire
James Asser Labour West Ham and Beckton
Ashley Dalton Labour West Lancashire
Nick Timothy Conservative West Suffolk
Tim Farron Liberal Democrat Westmorland and Lonsdale
Alec Shelbrooke Conservative Wetherby and Easingwold
Derek Twigg Labour Widnes and Halewood
Paul Kohler Liberal Democrat Wimbledon
Jack Rankin Conservative Windsor
Matthew Patrick Labour Wirral West
Priti Patel Conservative Witham
Sureena Brackenridge Labour Wolverhampton North East
Tom Collins Labour Worcester
Mike Kane Labour Wythenshawe and Sale East
Rachael Maskell Labour York Central
Florence Eshalomi (Teller) Labour Vauxhall and Camberwell Green
Harriett Baldwin (Teller) Conservative West Worcestershire

MPs with no vote recorded
Kirsty Blackman Scottish National Party Aberdeen North
Stephen Flynn Scottish National Party Aberdeen South
Seamus Logan Scottish National Party Aberdeenshire North and Moray East
Dave Doogan Scottish National Party Angus and Perthshire Glens
Stephen Gethins Scottish National Party Arbroath and Broughty Ferry
Brendan O’Hara Scottish National Party Argyll, Bute and South Lochaber
John Finucane Sinn Féin Belfast North
Claire Hanna Social Democratic & Labour Party Belfast South and Mid Down
Paul Maskey Sinn Féin Belfast West
Al Carns Labour Birmingham Selly Oak
Nick Smith Labour Blaenau Gwent and Rhymney
Jessica Toale Labour Bournemouth West
Judith Cummins Deputy Speaker Bradford South
Charlie Dewhirst Conservative Bridlington and The Wolds
Josh Fenton-Glynn Labour Calder Valley
Lindsay Hoyle Speaker Chorley
Peter Lamb Labour Crawley
Chris Law Scottish National Party Dundee Central
Ian Murray Labour Edinburgh South
Pat Cullen Sinn Féin Fermanagh and South Tyrone
Andrew Gwynne Labour Gorton and Denton
Gareth Thomas Labour Harrow West
Mike Wood Conservative Kingswinford and South Staffordshire
Cat Smith Labour Lancaster and Wyre
Alex Sobel Labour Leeds Central and Headingley
Ellie Reeves Labour Lewisham West and East Dulwich
Dan Carden Labour Liverpool Walton
Douglas Alexander Labour Lothian East
Afzal Khan Labour Manchester Rusholme
Cathal Mallaghan Sinn Féin Mid Ulster
Graham Leadbitter Scottish National Party Moray West, Nairn and Strathspey
Carolyn Harris Labour Neath and Swansea East
Dáire Hughes Sinn Féin Newry and Armagh
Geoffrey Clifton-Brown Conservative North Cotswolds
Debbie Abrahams Labour Oldham East and Saddleworth
Pete Wishart Scottish National Party Perth and Kinross-shire
Chris Bryant Labour Rhondda and Ogmore
Caroline Nokes Deputy Speaker Romsey and Southampton North
Chris Hazzard Sinn Féin South Down
Navendu Mishra Labour Stockport
Nusrat Ghani Deputy Speaker Sussex Weald
Órfhlaith Begley Sinn Féin West Tyrone


Chris Jarvis is head of strategy and development at Left Foot Forward



Assisted dying: ‘We should be proud of all MPs’ civil debate and serious reflection’


:

For all the speculation that the vote would be down to the wire, in the end the result was decisive. MPs, by a majority of 55, voted to back assisted dying, in stark contrast to another vote on the subject less than ten years ago.

For Labour, it was a vote that divided the party beyond traditional left-right splits, with everyone from ardent socialists to free-market thinkers walking almost hand in hand in their respective lobbies for the free vote in the Commons yesterday.

It was a split that was, and will be, evident at the Cabinet table, especially as the bill gets greater scrutiny.

While the Prime Minister and Chancellor both backed Kim Leadbeater’s bill, Health Secretary Wes Streeting and Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood were vocal opponents against it.

One notable thing that united MPs of all parties, regardless of how they voted, was their respect for one another during such a sensitive debate.

The jeering and raucousness that we have come to expect from the Commons was, mostly, gone – instead replaced by respectful, thoughtful and considered contemplation of a bill of a nature of the scale of same-sex marriage, abortion and the abolition of the death penalty.

MPs spoke passionately for and against with deeply personal anecdotes, which left themselves and no doubt many in the chamber choked up.

Regardless of how you feel about the result, we should all be proud of our parliamentarians for treating the bill and the wider debate with the seriousness it deserves.

The debate on this issue should be held up as a gold standard that we should expect all our MPs to reach when debating any parliamentary matter.

LabourList had been tracking how Labour MPs were planning on voting today; by the time the vote came, roughly 160 were on our list as undecided or had not made their position public.

From a close look at the result, it is clear that a majority of those ended up voting to back the bill at second reading.

While many of those MPs will have their own reasons for that move, it appears to suggest a willingness, at least from the Labour benches, to carry on the conversation and debate without necessarily committing Parliament to passing this bill into law.

Any talk of the bill passing into law is premature, for the result only marks the beginning of a greater debate over whether assisted dying has a place in British society and, if so, what form it should take.

Many more hours of committee procedures, along with discussion in the House of Lords and eventually again in the Commons, and of course the media, are yet to come.

However, there is no denying the historic nature of yesterday’s vote – one that may not be matched for many years, if not decades, to come.


Why many disabled people oppose the Leadbeater Bill

NOVEMBER 26, 2024

Merry Cross surveys the Government’s latest attempts to cuts the benefits bill by bullying and explains disabled people’s opposition to the Assisted Dying Bill.

I wonder if the Parliamentary Labour Party has any idea of how many voters it has lost through its insistence on continuing the persecution of disabled people, which is so forensically documented in John Pring’s new book The Department: How a Violent Government Bureaucracy Killed Hundreds and Hid the Evidence.

The cuts to our eligibility for benefits as well as the value of them, started with a Labour Government decades ago and have been enthusiastically continued ever since. The results have been disastrous, not just for our physical and mental health, but for our families too. Add into that the reduction in our and our families’ spending power and its impact on the economy, the destruction of social care and the NHS and the absence of affordable, accessible housing and the obstacles to living, let alone living a dignified life, and these cuts have been multiplied many times. That is what being disabled means today, in one of the wealthiest countries on the planet.

Exactly how are we expected to find that holy grail of jobs, when there may be no-one available to help us get up and get ready to leave the house? How, when even if we and our families have managed that, do we get to a job when there is little or no accessible transport available? How do we hold down a job, even if it is working from home, when the medication we need may no longer be available from the NHS or we are unable to get appointments with our GPs?

Mr. Starmer, I am old enough to remember the first iteration of staff in Job Centres (which used to be the Social Security offices) who were there supposedly to help us find jobs. They knew zilch, nada, nothing at all about impairments or disability and were as useless as chocolate teapots then. Nothing has changed there and neither has the enthusiasm, or lack of it, amongst employers for offering us jobs. This has been massively exacerbated by the almost total destruction of the Access to Work scheme, which even 20 years ago wasn’t that great. Let’s face it, given that all the Government bullying to date hasn’t decreased the benefits bill, why tread the same path?

So, is it any surprise that many, many disabled people belonging to many different disability organisations are against the Assisted Dying Bill? Please don’t set too much store by Tom Shakespeare’s assertion that a “quiet majority are in favour of it” when he produces no evidence for that at all. Can you imagine how humiliating and terrifying it is to see a Government possibly preparing to spend money on ending our lives, rather than on helping us live with the dignity that those in favour of the Bill desire for the end of life?

Most disabled people are likely to have the greatest compassion for those who suffer and die perhaps in pain. But we contend that if they hadn’t witnessed, and then been subjected to the reduction in the quality, support for, and meaningfulness of our lives, perhaps they too would oppose the bill.

Our slogan is #AssistUsToLive.

Merry Cross has been a disability activist for fifty years and was among the first members of Disabled People Against Cuts, of which she also chaired a local branch for ten years.

Image: https://www.flickr.com/photos/lccr/2865509591. Creator: The Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights. Licence: Attribution-NonCommercial 2.0 Generic (CC BY-NC 2.0)

Assisted dying: Not the Church, not the state, I will decide my fate

NOVEMBER 25, 2024

By Joan Twelves

After Donald Trump’s recent presidential victory, a far-right tweet triumphantly declaring “Your body, My choice” went viral. This misogynistic phrase all too sadly sums up the debate over abortion rights in the US. But it’s also relevant to the current debate on assisted dying in the UK, which is set to be debated in Parliament this week.   

I’ve spent over 50 years campaigning for a woman’s right to choose whether and when she gives birth. I cannot separate that belief, either morally, philosophically or politically, from my belief that I – and all others – must have a right to choose whether and when I live or die.

As a former local councillor, my instincts are those of a politician, but, while it is politicians who are going to decide on whether I can have the right to die at a time of my choosing, my unflinching support for assisted dying is rooted in my lived experience.

Since my late teens I’ve suffered from Crohn’s disease, a condition that is agonising and incurable. I had extensive abdominal surgery in my twenties and again in my forties, resulting in the permanent removal of my bowel and much of my lower intestine. Despite occasional periods of remission, I have lived all of my adult life with intense pain, unpredictable (and potentially fatal) intestinal blockages, and all the problems associated with living with a stoma. When I was first ill, hardly anyone had heard of Crohn’s, and explaining what I was going through was nigh on impossible. I don’t do pity, and nor do I want to listen to others’ squeamishness about my bodily functions… So I rarely talk about it.

Crohn’s effectively stole the ‘90s and ‘00s from me – I had little energy, depression, brain fog, and only the barest interest in the politics which had been my life for the previous 20 years. When my late husband, Greg, become ill in the mid-‘00s it was a real struggle for me to care for him as I could barely care for myself.

New biological drugs gave me my life back in the early 2010s. But these wonder drugs, which I am still on, bring with them their own risks. Life expectancy for a woman with Crohn’s is nearly a decade less than the average. The biological and immunosuppressant drugs I have taken may be one of the reasons for that reduced life span. And, of course, Covid-19 loves to target those with weakened immunity, and the deadly threat of catching it has limited me to only the occasional trip into the outside world since 2020. Am I facing another lost decade?

The greatest risk to my life is intestinal blockage caused by the strictures and lesions of my several operations. Getting to hospital for morphine and rehydration is urgent, and even with morphine plus added steroids the pain will continue for several days, and I will be ill for some time afterwards.

Crohn’s isn’t my only ailment. Most of my body is creaking from the effects of 60 years of strong medications along with the wear and tear of age. In fact, these days when asked how I am, I usually respond with “Still here” or “How long have you got?” I officially have multiple chronic and complex comorbidities.

Chronic illness has defined most my adult life, but, just as I have tried not to let it limit what I can do, I have no intention of giving up yet. However, I know that one day the pain may become unbearable, and I want to be able to decide for myself that I don’t want any more of it, that I’m done.

Much of the debate over assisted dying has focused on the state of palliative care – something I know a bit about. Before Greg died of throat cancer at the age of 54, he used to call the palliative care people the ‘Death Squad’. He had already lost his voice, and he knew that the pain medication of offer would soon take away his personality and identity. For him that would have been a living death, as it would for me. We didn’t talk about assisted dying, but after over 30 years together we knew each other’s views. He wasn’t ready to die when he had a fatal arterial haemorrhage, but he had been told to ‘put his affairs in order’ – a chilling euphemism for saying it’s terminal.  

Palliative care works for some, but the arguments around assisted dying shouldn’t be a competition between improved palliative care and the right to die. In an advanced society, both should be available and both should be of equally high standard. Nobody should want to die because the palliative care isn’t good enough, or because hospices aren’t receiving the funding they need. On the other hand, nobody should be stopped from dying when they choose. Yes, robust protections must be in place to stop people being coerced into something they don’t want, but this risk isn’t a good enough excuse to deny those of us who truly want the right to choose when to die.

Think of it this way: would any supporter of abortion rights argue that it should be illegal while we wait for our gynae or maternity services to be improved? Similarly, should the risk of a young women being coerced into an abortion she doesn’t want mean that nobody else should be allowed to have one? The answer is clearly no and, much like abortion, assisted dying will continue to happen, so enshrining rights and protections into law will mean there can be proper safeguards to protect the vulnerable.

To me the argument of a ‘slippery slope’ is disingenuous. Did its advocates not notice the landslide at the height of the pandemic, when thousands were assisted to die without any choice? Again, legal safeguards and procedures are needed to protect medical staff as well as vulnerable patients.

Finally, MPs and many ministers may be struggling to come to a decision on this matter, but the UK public are crystal clear in their views. The latest YouGov poll shows substantial support for both the principle of assisted dying and the bill before Parliament. The study finds a super-majority of 73% in favour, with only 13% against, spanning all demographics and political parties.

Whatever our politicians decide, support for assisted dying isn’t going away. Although there are many sincere concerns about the proposals, there doesn’t seem to be anything that scrutiny during the passage of the bill and more investment in palliative care couldn’t fix. We must grasp this chance and ensure that dignity in death is a fundamental right down to the choice of the individual, not the state.

Joan Twelves is a Labour, trade union and community activist and former Labour Leader of Lambeth Council. This article originally appeared on her blog here.

Image: https://www.picpedia.org/chalkboard/a/assisted-dying.html License: Creative Commons 3 – CC BY-SA 3.0 Attribution: Alpha Stock Images – http://alphastockimages.com/ Original Author: Nick Youngson – link to – http://www.nyphotographic.com/

Young migrants in Paris say ‘We’re fighting and we’re winning’

Thomas Foster reports from Paris where young undocumented migrants are occupying public buildings to win their right to accommodation, schooling, health—and human dignity


Young undocumented migrants celebrating their wins over the state 
(Picture: Belleville Park Youth Collective)

SOCIALIST WORKER
Friday 29 November 2024

Thousands of migrant children live unaccompanied on the streets of Paris running from traumas in their home countries—and now running from the city’s cops.

In France, they find the authorities are ranged against them. As black and brown people overwhelmingly from Africa and the Middle East, the state instantly regards them as a threat.

But these undocumented migrants have now organised themselves, are fighting back—and they are winning. They occupy council-owned buildings to demand accommodation, hold their own general assemblies and plan for their futures.

“Words are beautiful, but you have to act,” one undocumented migrant told an anti-racist assembly in Paris last week.

“It’s a fight for our rights as we can put pressure on the city council to provide us with accommodation,” one young migrant told Socialist Worker.

“Once a building is occupied, all activities inside it stop. That means the Paris council doesn’t earn any money. If the money doesn’t come in, they’re in trouble. We have power over them because we occupy.”

Another young migrant told Socialist Worker, “Through our passion for action and militancy, we’ve won around 800 to 900 accommodation places. We’ve got young people off the streets.”

Last year, around 475 unaccompanied minors were living in tents in Belleville Park in a working class neighbourhood in the east of Paris. Some only had blankets to brave the cold Parisian nights

On 19 October 2023, the Paris police organised an operation to “shelter” the young migrants. At 4am, the cops tore into the park and pressed people up against the gates until buses arrived to take them away.

Police took them to temporary accommodations all across Paris where they were sheltered for 30 days. After that, they were let out and made homeless once again. Many returned to the park as the place they knew best and began meeting with local activists, discussing what could be done.

That’s when around 20 young migrants decided to occupy a community centre to demand shelter. One of them declared during the occupation, “We are here and we will stick together until the end. We are going to fight.”

After five hours of occupation, the local authority arrived to negotiate and opened up housing places. Kahina, an anti-racist activist involved in the organisation, said, “It happened not because the local authority wanted it to, but because of the strength of our campaign.

“That’s how the Belleville Park Youth Collective began. They chose the name so as not to forget how it started.”

It’s a marked difference from the police’s round-up that forced the young migrants into centres across Paris. Instead, it is young migrants fighting for control over their lives, where they are the ones with agency.

Many of the young migrants felt that they had to fight.

One told Socialist Worker, “When we arrived here in France, many of us thought that that was the end of the journey. We thought that the state would take care of us. But in reality, the opposite was true. The state abandoned us.

“That’s why we have to organise ourselves. We have to fight for our rights and it is through our collective strength that we can win.”

The Belleville Park Youth Collective started meeting twice a week to talk about what they could do. Initially, they mostly organised protests. “There are a lot of logistics with occupations. They are quite complicated, so we didn’t do them every day,” Kahina said.

But during one demonstration organised by the Collective outside of the Paris city hall, the police swept in. They dismantled camps of homeless migrants next to the River Seine, which runs through the centre of Paris.

“When the state takes away what little you have, what choice is there but to resist?” one young migrant said. “The attitude in the moment was—many of us have nowhere to go so let’s occupy.”

There was a building, owned by the Paris council, near to where the young migrants had gathered. Its door was open. They entered the building—and after two hours 150 unaccompanied minors were inside.

Kahina said “it was a huge challenge”. “We held our first general assembly with everyone there,” she explained. “The unaccompanied minors that were already involved explained the situation to others, the reason why they were doing this action and what they wanted to win.

“Their attitude was—we are the ones living on the streets and now we are organising together. And now you, the council, are going to talk to us—that was the end goal.”

The Mayor of Paris, Anne Hildago from the Labour-type PS, sent a team to negotiate. Six unaccompanied minors representing different homeless camps and two local activists met with the officials.

The Paris council was desperate to use the building the next day. So by the evening, it had opened up gymnasiums across Paris for the young migrants to live in.

As a result of a number of occupations led by the Belleville Park Youth Collective, hundreds of young migrants are now housed in gymnasiums. Many then go on to secure a permanent housing place or enter child protection services.

Once in a gymnasium, the young people can begin the process of getting a certificate of accommodation they need to attend school. And the Collective regularly demonstrated outside of Paris’ education authority to ensure that it happened.


A general assembly of Belleville Park Youth Collective (Picture: Socialist Worker)

One young migrant told the Belleville Park Youth Collective general assembly last Tuesday, “When you arrive in Paris, people tell you that you should be in school. But it is very difficult to get to school.

“If there are unaccompanied minors in school, it is because of our struggle and our determination. Today we have more than 160 young people in various secondary schools.”

He added, “Everyone must have the right to school. Everyone, all the young people. When you leave here today, tell all the young people who want to go to school that we are making progress.”

The Collective holds general assemblies every week where hundreds of young migrants come to organise. They hold their discussions in French, but some of the migrants are only now learning the language.

Up to 100 young people attended the assembly last Tuesday. The meeting was made up of a number of different contributions—anyone can come to the front and speak.

There was a report from a recent protest on International Children’s Day, a contribution about recent struggles with getting transport to school, a call to arms for everyone to work together.

There was also a contribution about the racism one of the young migrants experienced in healthcare—something the Collective is trying to tackle.

“If a young person comes to hospital because he is ill, he’s forced to be accompanied by an adult or told that he can’t go,” one migrant told Socialist Worker.

“If a young person is sick in the gym, they often don’t get the medical treatment they need. If they even see you, it is only for a couple of minutes where they give you painkillers.”

In March this year, there were still hundreds of unaccompanied minors living outside on the streets.

The Collective decided to organise an occupation and visited a number of potential buildings. They asked, is it warm? Is it possible to sleep in? Are there toilets? They chose a large building owned by the city council near a football stadium.

The Youth Collective pretended to be organising a football match, spreading the word to come to the stadium at a particular time.

Around 70 people gathered and then entered the building. “We handed out papers to everyone in the building saying why we were here and what we were doing,” Kahina said. “The point is that the people in the building support us.

“The unaccompanied minors kept coming, they all knew each other and were calling their friends to come.”

The building door was shut, but people kept arriving outside. When the negotiations started, the council asked the migrants to leave the main building. But, if authorities agreed to provide housing, those still outside wouldn’t have gotten it.

“The unaccompanied minors said they would move out of the main room only if the doors opened for the others,” Kahina said.

That’s exactly what happened—the local authorities opened the door and over 50 more unaccompanied minors streamed into the building. “The whole neighbourhood came and supported us, bringing us food,” said Kahina.

The occupation lasted for one night. The next day, they won around 160 housing places in gymnasiums.


Occupying buildings owned by the city council has pressurised politicians to find solutions

The following month the Collective staged their longest occupation, which lasted three months. Kahina said, “After we won, many young people who weren’t previously involved came to the weekly general assembly.”

These young people were regularly attending the general assembly and the Collective felt prepared to carry out another occupation. Around 260 people were involved at the peak.

In this occupation, the Collective demanded not only housing for the homeless young people. There was a real threat that authorities would move the 400 people who were already in gymnasiums out of Paris ahead of the Olympic Games.

The council quickly conceded to not move anyone out of the gymnasiums, but refused to provide any more housing.

In response, the young migrants refused to leave. Kahina said, “There were discussions twice a day, where we held a general assembly to discuss what we were doing at that moment.”

Two of the main questions are where can get food and blankets.

“We contacted a number of organisations that we knew who helped to provide food on different days of the week. We organised a whole plan of who is going to provide food at what time,” she said.

Every day, a different handful of the young migrants were responsible for handing out the food. And they got in contact with a French refugee charity, Utopia 56, who brought a number of blankets.

Eventually, the city council conceded and opened up more gymnasiums.

Another young migrant told Socialist Worker, “We feel completely alone here in France. If you don’t resist, people will walk all over you. So you have to rise up, be courageous and fight for your rights as a migrant and as a human being, and especially if you are young.”

She said occupations mean the “authorities are obliged to come and discuss with us, to see the young person and in what situation they live.”

The struggle has transformed those involved. “Since starting to fight, my mindset has changed,” one unaccompanied minor told Socialist Worker. “Before I was sleeping rough on the streets.

“Every day you wake up, try to find a place just to get some rest and find somewhere warm. Every day it was the same.

“But by struggling to win some of our rights, you no longer have to worry about that every single day. Our struggle won us housing and then the rights to go to school. It is a step towards us building an actual life.”

Young undocumented migrants are taking the fight for accommodation into their own hands

France’s neoliberal president Emmanuel Macron pushed vicious attacks on migrants—including a new law to clamp down on undocumented migrants. This has fuelled the rise of Marine Le Pen’s fascist National Rally (RN), which then pulls Macron’s government further to the right as it tries to compete.

And, since Macron installed a right wing Tory government without a majority, the fascists are the kingmakers in parliament.

The Collective recognises that the political situation means fighting for migrants’ rights is even more urgent.

One local activist argued that the RN “is in a position to take office if nothing is done”. “New laws are set to be introduced that could make life even more difficult for our undocumented comrades,” they said.

Another local activist described it as “a war”, saying, “We need direct confrontation with the government and the fascists. We don’t just talk about why we don’t like racism and why it’s nasty.

“We have to talk about confrontation—getting organised to fight for the rights of undocumented migrants.”

One young migrant attacked the French state and its colonialism. He said that the French elites “are paying for wars in Africa and then they don’t want us to come here”.

“You created the misery over there, the wars. People are going to come here because you’ve created conditions that are not favourable. They have to flee because of the wars, trying to escape their misery to get here to Europe.”

When the Belleville Park Youth Collective started, other organisations doubted whether migrant self-organising was possible. But one young person said their success “showed how we can go beyond what we were doing previously”.

And the fight is spreading. “Other organisations have come to Paris to visit us. This leads to collectives being formed in other regions that have fought for and won accommodation places,” said one speaker at a general assembly last week.

The migrants’ victories “are due to struggle, because they have started to be militant and impose themselves”.

As one young migrant told Socialist Worker, “What we did here in Paris has enabled others in Marseille, Lille, Toulouse, Bois, Blanc, Clermont-Ferrand to form collectives to fight and assert their own rights.

“Our struggle becomes a struggle that will spread all throughout France—a method that all unaccompanied minors can use.”

He added, “We can change our own destiny. We aren’t just children. We weren’t born to sleep rough. If the young people in Paris are able to change things, then others can do the same.

“The struggle here has made a difference to the young people who were sleeping rough in other cities. They have been able to stand on their own two feet and challenge the various institutions.”

What the defiance, courage and creativity of young undocumented migrants in Paris shows is that resistance can erupt in the most unpromising of circumstances. It shows that undocumented migrants aren’t just victims of a broken system—but have agency.

As one young migrant said in an occupation, “Before we were alone. Now we are not alone. We are together—and we will win.”



Italian workers stage general strike over austerity

Fascist prime minister Giorgia Meloni’s latest budget cut spending on schools, healthcare and other services


CGIL union federation members on the march during the Italian general strike

By Judy Cox
Friday 29 November 2024   
SOCIALIST WORKER Issue

Thousands of workers took part in a general strike in Italy on Friday. It forced the Italian national airline company to cancel dozens of domestic and international flights and closed schools, hospitals and local transport systems.

Thousands of teachers, healthcare workers, rubbish collectors and others walked off their jobs across Italy. They took to the streets to protest against a cost of living crisis, low salaries and cuts in public services.

Italian unions called the eight-hour strike and mobilised marches in cities across the country. The strike was ignited by fascist prime minister Giorgia Meloni’s latest budget, which cut spending on schools, healthcare and other services.

Strikers are also demanding a fairer share of profits from private companies.

“These protests don’t just speak to the government,” Maurizio Landini, head of the CGIL trade union federation, told reporters in Bologna. “They speak also to entrepreneurs, managers and businesses, who in these years have made profits like never before.”

Transport minister Matteo Salvini imposed an injunction limiting the strike in the transport sector to four hours.

It was the first general strike since last November. Unions faced possible sanctions for involving the healthcare and justice sectors.

Italy’s healthcare sector has been suffering staffing shortages, with care in the poorer south particularly lagging that in the more prosperous north.

“There are many people who go abroad because the salaries are too low,” said Anna Salsa, a member of the UIL healthcare union, at the demonstration in Rome. “We are forced to do double shifts to give the minimal levels of essential care.”

This strike is part of the resistance to Meloni’s government and its attempts to impose greater austerity on Italian workers.
Elon Musk slammed for promoting UK far-right Tommy Robinson documentary











25 November, 2024

Musk promotes far-right yet again...

Tech billionaire and avid Trump supporter Elon Musk is once more being condemned for promoting the far-right, this time for promoting a documentary by Tommy Robinson.

Musk has faced much criticism for allowing X, formerly Twitter, to become a social media platform on which fake news and extremist content can be shared without consequence, and also previously shared fake news on the site himself.

In the latest incident, he quoted an account praising a documentary by Tommy Robinson, the founder and former leader of far-right English Defence League.

Shaun Maguire, the account in question, shared Robinson’s documentary and posted on X: “I couldn’t sleep last night so I watched this entire documentary

“Anyone who doubts the institutional decay and socialist moral rot taking hold of Western societies needs to watch this. Tommy is in jail for showing this documentary. The least you can do is watch it.”

Musk quoted the post and wrote in reply: “Yes”.

Journalist and commentator Mehdi Hasan, wrote in response to Musk: “Difficult to describe what a dangerous moment we are in.

“The owner of this site/richest man in the world/closest adviser to the next president is promoting a Tommy Robinson (!) documentary to his 200 million followers.

“This is the mainstreaming of violent, Islamophobic fascism”.

Robinson was jailed recently for 18 months for contempt of court for repeating false allegations against a Syrian refugee, in breach of an injunction.

He was told that “nobody is above the law” by a judge who said the “flagrant” breaches had been done in a “sophisticated” way to ensure the false claims would achieve “maximum coverage”, reaching tens of millions of people.

The Guardian reported at the time that the “court hearing was told that Robinson had in effect repeated all of the allegations that led to him losing a libel case brought by Jamal Hijazi, who had been filmed being attacked at a school in West Yorkshire.

“Shortly after the video of the incident went viral, Robinson falsely claimed in Facebook videos that Hijazi was “not innocent and he violently attacks young English girls in his school”.

The false claims were repeated by Robinson in a number of interviews as well as in a documentary film made by Robinson.

Basit Mahmood is editor of Left Foot Forward

Ukraine: we must remain firm in our solidarity

NOVEMBER 27, 2024

Yesterday, Tuesday 26th November, the European Parliament held a debate on strengthening support for Ukraine. We reproduce below an edited version of the contribution from Li Andersson of the Left Alliance, Finland.

About three weeks ago I was on a train from Kyiv returning to Poland. We were visiting Ukraine with a delegation of representatives of different left-wing parties and had meetings with NGOs, trade unionists and the Ukrainian left-wing organization Sotsіalniy Rukh (Social Movement).

Everyone in Ukraine was telling us the same thing: they expect this winter to be the most difficult period since Putin started this war of aggression, with attacks on energy infrastructure, soldiers becoming exhausted and incessant drone and missile attacks that keep the population on permanent alert.

It is therefore of the utmost importance that we remain firm in our solidarity with Ukraine. It is up to the Ukrainians to decide when the time is right to begin possible negotiations. But for a just and lasting peace to be possible, sufficient pressure must be exerted on Putin. This is why we need military support and a strengthening of the sanctions regime.

But Ukrainian society also needs other forms of support. There is an urgent need for social and non-profit housing models to address the housing crisis. Unions must be strengthened so that collective bargaining and social dialogue can continue as soon as possible. Strong civil society and transparency are necessary in the fight against corruption. Finally, Ukraine’s sovereign debt must be cancelled so that we can guarantee the country’s economic and political sovereignty, as well as its independence and territorial integrity.

Li Andersson is Chair of the European Parliamentary Committee on Employment and Social Affairs. She was formerly leader of Finland’s Left Alliance, an MP from 2015 to 2024 and former Minister of Education. The full European Parliamentary debate is available here.  

Appendix

The Social Movement to which Li Andersson refers held a Conference last month at which it adopted a resolution entitled “The Path to Victory and the Tasks of the Ukrainian Left”. We reproduce the text below:

1. An Honest Response to the Challenges of War, Not Hypocritical Politics

The uncertain prospects of Ukraine’s victory stem from the fact that the only reliable strategy to oppose the aggressor—mobilizing all available economic resources to support the frontline and critical infrastructure—contradicts the interests of the oligarchy. Due to the free market, Ukraine has a caricature of a war economy, and the concentration of luxury amid poverty becomes dangerously explosive. The unwillingness to nationalize production capacities, tax large businesses, and direct the budget towards rearmament makes it possible to prolong the war at the cost of significant human losses and constant mobilization.

We believe that the government should start a dialogue with the people about the achievable goals of the war, and most importantly, introduce a defensive economy or acknowledge the unpreparedness to fight for victory. We advocate for ending the uncertainty regarding the duration of military service, as it is a matter of elementary fairness. Gaining technological superiority combined with a careful approach to people is the path to victory.

The Social Movement advocates the development of the state sector of the economy, subordinated to the priorities of defence and full employment, and defends the rights of conscripts and servicemen to dignified treatment, demobilization after a defined term of service, and rehabilitation.

2. International Solidarity as a Way to Overcome the Crisis of the World Order

The ongoing war in Ukraine is one of the signs of a crisis in the world order based on the neoliberal model. It is characterized by the exploitation of poor countries by the rich, inequality in access to fundamental goods, and the prosperity of financial elites at the cost of debt bondage for entire nations. All these features of the neoliberal system have undermined trust in international law and made global polarization inevitable.

To fight against Russian aggression and for a path to post-war reconstruction that benefits working people, we need support from the global community, including humanitarian and military assistance. European integration should not serve as a justification for antisocial reforms but should take place on fair grounds, accompanied by improving the welfare of the Ukrainian people and strengthening democracy.

We are confident that our ties with leftist movements across Europe will help Ukraine better defend itself. At the same time, we stand in solidarity with- progressive movements in Asia, Africa, and Latin America in their struggle against imperialism. We condemn the aggressive and occupation policies of other states—be it the oppression of Palestinians by Israel, Kurds by Turkey, or Yemenis by Saudi Arabia. A new architecture of international relations is needed, where there are no privileges for ‘great powers,’ G7, or permanent members of the UN Security Council, and the voices of the peripheral peoples are heard.

The Social Movement advocates for nuclear disarmament, interaction with left-wing forces that recognize Ukraine’s right to self-defence, and supports the struggle of other nations for liberation.

3. Building a “Ukraine for All” as a Space for Solidarity and Security

Although the war against an external enemy was supposed to unite the people of Ukraine, in reality, shameful attempts are being made to divide Ukrainians into ‘right’ and ‘wrong’. Instead of uniting as many people as possible around ideas of justice, freedom, and solidarity, conflicts within society are being provoked. There are manifestations of linguistic chauvinism, justification of hostility towards national minorities, the queer community, and fostering ideological uniformity. This will not allow the global fight against Russian imperialism to gain traction and will complicate the reintegration of occupied territories.

Establishing equality is impossible without overcoming social vulnerability. Conversely, the state’s reduction of social spending and irresponsible deregulation are already affecting the resilience of society. It is time to end the promotion of policies that exacerbate inequality. Demands for women’s emancipation, inclusive spaces for people with disabilities, and support for victims of far-right violence can strengthen Ukraine’s ability to resist tyranny both externally and internally. Proving our humanity = gaining an advantage over the aggressor.

The Social Movement will oppose policies that divide society and will protect social rights as a prerequisite for affirming human dignity. We will demand full state control over the protection of lives and the well-being of workers, who are at greater risk than ever.

4. Ecosocialist Transformation — The Key to Survival

Russia’s eco-terrorism, combined with years of large-scale, predatory exploitation of natural resources by domestic oligarchs and the authorities’ neglect of environmental protection, poses a threat to Ukraine’s ecosystems, including its biodiversity, clean water resources, soil fertility, and the health and lives of the population. The war and the anti-environmental policy of capital negatively affect poor and discriminated groups, increasing their vulnerability.

We emphasize the need to harmonize social production and ecological reproduction based on the principles of ecosocialism. The green transition, first and foremost, should be fair, taking into account the interests of the workforce by creating new jobs, retraining workers, and ensuring social guarantees and compensation for those who may lose their jobs due to the closure of enterprises. Efficient use of energy resources requires a reduction in working hours, and the nationalization of energy companies will allow rational management of capacities without the influence of commercial interests. We support small, family farmers for food security and agricultural greening, the idea of deprivatizing common resources, and firmly oppose monopolistic agro-holdings that destroy the ecosystem.

The Social Movement will work together with trade unions and other progressive public organizations to develop a program of transformations that meet the long-term interests of workers, farmers, and other vulnerable segments of the Ukrainian population in the context of production, ecology and energy.

5. Workers Bore the Burden of the War, Therefore They Deserve a Voice

Since the beginning of the full-scale invasion, the core of resistance to aggression—both at the front and in the rear—has been the working class. Unfortunately, in conditions where the main burden of the war has been shifted to the working class, there is no left-wing political force in Ukraine that would voice the issues inherent to working people and act on the principles of inclusive democracy. Under the realities of oligarchic capitalism, restrictions on freedoms often serve the interests of the elites.

To build an ecosocial, independent Ukraine of equal rights and opportunities, there is a need for a political democratic platform that will unite workers and other oppressed groups, representing their interests in politics, including participation in elections. We are open to interaction with political parties that share our vision. The sooner a competitive political process is restored, the sooner trust in the state will be regained. Corruption, censorship, and other abuses by officials harm the defence efforts. The best remedy against this is the democratic renewal of power. Freedom is the foundation of security for all citizens.

The Social Movement advocates for the restoration of electoral rights, the right to peaceful assembly and workers’ strikes, and the abolition of all restrictions on labour and social rights.

This translation originally appeared here.

 The original text can be found here.


Left wing MPs call for Keir Starmer and Joe Biden to secure talks with Russia and Ukraine


Chris Jarvis 
27 November, 2024 
at Left Foot Forward


"Diplomacy and dialogue, not military escalation, are the only viable paths to a peaceful settlement in the region."



A group of left wing MPs have issued a call for the UK prime minister Keir Starmer and US president Joe Biden to ‘secure talks with Russia and Ukraine’ to prevent ‘escalation’ in the ongoing war.

In a letter to the Guardian, six MPs – including the Labour MP Diane Abbott and the former Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn argue that “the risk of a nuclear attack cannot be ruled out”, and that the British government should play a role in “securing an end to this horrific conflict”.

The letter opens as follows: “We are deeply concerned about the escalation in Ukraine. In response to British-made Storm Shadow missiles fired into Kursk, just days after Ukraine used the US’s army tactical missile systems (Atacms) to attack Bryansk, reports indicate that Russia has now launched intercontinental missiles into southern Ukraine. This rapid escalation seriously threatens an all-out military confrontation with Russia and Nato.”

Their letter concludes by saying that “Diplomacy and dialogue, not military escalation, are the only viable paths to a peaceful settlement in the region.”

The MPs to sign the letter were Labour’s Diane Abbott and all five members of the ‘Independent Alliance’ group in the House of Commons – Jeremy Corbyn, Ayoub Khan, Shockat Adam, Iqbal Mohamed and Adnan Hussain.

The letter was also signed by the RMT president Alex Gordon, the general secretary of the PCS union Fran Heathcote and the convener of the Stop the War Coalition Lindsey German.


Image credit: Jason – Creative Commons


Romania’s shock election: Who is Călin Georgescu and what happens next?

 

NOVEMBER 26, 2024

The first round of Romania’s presidential election produced a shock result with ultranationalist Călin Georgescu topping the poll with 23% of the votes, followed by centre-right candidate Elena Lasconi of the Save Romania Union and in third place the social democratic Prime Minister Marcel Ciolacu, the pre-election favourite, who has now resigned the leadership of his party. Below we reproduce a post by Cornel Ban.

Călin Georgescu, the frontrunner in Romania’s presidential race, emerges as a hard-right Eurosceptic, a product of the swirling nebula of far-right rhetoric fed by the catastrophic mediocrity of mainstream political campaigns.

Yet Georgescu is no typical ‘Trumpist’ outsider; his sulphurous, often cringeworthy presence signals something more insidious and extreme than anything the European far-right has in store. In theory, Romania – firmly anchored to EU and NATO interests -should not be the kind of place where such a phenomenon should flourish. After all, this is a country that has reaped transformative social and economic gains since joining the European Union. Moreover, its governments cannot be blamed for engaging in the culture wars that typically fuel MAGA-style movements.

An independent candidate backed by the far-right Georgescu is an unsettling cocktail of alt-right fervour and mystic, ‘anti-globalist’ nationalism – with a bastardized strain of ecology that flirts with what some call eco-fascism. His vision? An ethnocratic and religiously fundamentalist state presiding over a post-corporate, ‘Christian’ economy driven by small, patriotic entrepreneurs – lightly taxed, minimally regulated, and somehow enthusiastic about massive wealth redistribution to fuel an ecological utopia. Indeed, the man speaks in eschatological terms in both Orthodox and Evangelical settings and sees himself in a literally messianic role (“I do not run an electoral campaign but I am on a God’s mission”). You have to go as far as Sayyid Qutb to find similar forms of criticism of modernity.

The specifics of his economic programme are vague, but his rhetoric leans heavily on MAGA populism, interwar far-right nostalgia, and pastoral fantasies of clean water, organic food, self-sufficient farms and low taxes for all. Ironically, cooperativism and ecology – historically fringe issues even on the  fragile left of Romanian politics – don’t seem to have widespread voter appeal, making his rise all the more confounding. Polls barely register the resonance of his platform, yet Georgescu’s improbable momentum cuts against the grain of every conventional indicator.

Furthermore, Georgescu is anything but an outsider to politics and state administration. He spent decades embedded in Romania’s political and administrative elite, serving in central government roles from the twilight of communism to the country’s EU accession. He represented Romania in global institutions like the UN, OECD, and Club of Rome and spearheaded sustainability planning for multiple cabinets. A product of NATO-aligned security establishments, his credentials seem unimpeachably mainstream – at least on paper.

But in recent years, Georgescu has openly drifted into the conspiratorial ether, peddling fevered tales of international institutions hijacked by ‘globalist’ forces – a narrative peppered with antisemitic dog whistles and the kind of emotional rhetoric designed to inflame. Even Romania’s far-right Alliance for the Union of Romanians, which looks to Italy’s Giorgia Meloni for inspiration, found his extremism too toxic, ejecting him despite once considering him for a leadership role. Meanwhile, the state’s attempts to prosecute him for glorifying interwar genocidaires have fizzled, leaving the unsettling sense that such rhetoric may still find fertile ground within a Romanian establishment that has not experienced a serious reckoning with the fascist and late national-Stalinist past.

With a weak counter-candidate to Georgescu, Romanian democracy finds itself teetering on the edge – its foundations gnawed away by inequality and endemic poverty, all while riding the wave of one of Europe’s fastest-growing and least redistributive economies over the last decade. Romania must grasp the weight of a cordon sanitaire – or brace itself to peer into a yawning political chasm in its politics. My fear is that the unapologetically neoliberal tropes of Elena Lasconi, Georgescu’s counter-candidate in the upcoming presidential run-off, will fan the flames of the electoral riot taking place in Romanian society at this point.

In the next two weeks we will find out if these existential elections will yield a moment of democratic resilience or one of Europe’s biggest internal political problems for the years to come.

Cornel Ban is Associate Professor at the Copenhagen Business School and author of Ruling Ideas (OUP 2016). This is an edited version of a Facebook post, republished here with the author’s kind permission.

Image: Călin Georgescu. https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:C%C4%83lin_Georgescu,_discurs_Biserica_Penticostal%C4%83_Jebel.jpg Source: Mesajul lui Călin Georgescu la Biserica Penticostala din Jebel (archived Author: Focus Creștin,  licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported license.