Sunday, March 22, 2026

 

Study uncovers the feeding secrets of sharks 5 million years ago





Bournemouth University
Painting of a shark scavenging on a whale 

image: 

A painted reconstruction of a bluntnose six-gill shark (or cow shark) scavenging on a tiny extinct right whale carcass during the Early Pliocene of the southern North Sea. A pod of an extinct whale related to today’s belugas swimming in the background. Painting by Alexander Lovegrove.

view more 

Credit: Alexander Lovegrove




A new study analysing two fossilised whale skulls from around 5 million years ago has revealed fragments of sharks’ teeth lodged inside them. This provides rare evidence of how sharks fed on whales in north European waters in prehistoric times.

The study led by the Institute of Natural Sciences in Brussels (RBINS) analysed the skulls to determine how the sharks fed on their prey. CT scans of the two skulls revealed teeth from the shark that had broken off and lodged in whale’s skulls during feeding.

Dr. Olivier Lambert, a palaeontologist at the Institute of Natural Sciences who conducted the examination of the skulls said: “Our knowledge of past marine mammal assemblages in the North Sea remains rather fragmentary, so any new fossil may prove informative. In this case, the studied skulls revealed some unexpected and fascinating clues about the way these whales' life ended.”

Both skulls date from the Early Pliocene period, 4 – 5 million years ago and were found in Belgium. One of the whale skulls (from an extinct tiny form of right whale) was found in the 1980’s by Professor John Stewart, Evolutionary Palaeoecologist from Bournemouth University, when he was fossil hunting with his father in the Antwerp docks in Belgium. The second skull is of a monodontid, a relative of the present-day beluga and narwhal, and was found by another fossil enthusiast – Dr. Paul Gigase, who was a pathologist by profession, together with his son Pierre.

40 years after Professor Stewart’s discovery as a teenager, modern technology has revealed some of the secrets within the two skulls. Dr. Lambert, lead-author of the paper said: “The CT scans revealed the shape of the teeth allowing the sharks’ identification without having to damage the skulls. The position of the bite marks in the upper part of the right whale skull tells us that the animal had probably already died when the shark scavenged its carcasses and that it was in a belly-up position, which is common for deceased whales.”

The tooth fragment found in Professor Stewart’s whale is from a cow shark. The tooth fragment in the other skull belongs to a relative of the modern great white shark. None of these animals, or their modern relatives, are found in the southern North Sea today.

These whale skulls provide a rare glimpse into the relationships between large predators and their prey off the coast of Northern Europe 5 million years ago.

Professor Stewart said: “Palaeontologists often have to make assumptions about the interactions between many of the species from this period. This study provides them with actual evidence they can work with – not just bite marks, but fragments from the predators who made the bites.”

The image of whales and large predatory sharks swimming in their seas would be an unusual one for most people in Northern Europe today. However, palaeontologists are piecing together a picture of a time when these animals inhabited those waters.

Dr. Lambert said: “These whale skulls provide a rare glimpse into the relationship between large predators and their prey off the coast of Northern Europe 5 million years ago. These findings are a first step towards understanding changes through time in the availability of prey in the southern North Sea and the loss of large predatory sharks in this area. Given that ongoing climate change is altering the distribution of marine mammals, including in the North Sea, it is likely that the distribution of their predators will also change. Could great white sharks return to the North Sea to feed on local seal populations?”


Images of the two fossil whale skulls with bite marks 

Photographs (left) showing the extinct right whale partial skull with shark bite marks highlighted in red. The more complete skull on the lower part of the illustration is from another individual of the same right whale species. Photographs (right) showing shark bite marks on the rostrum of the monodontid cranium, targeting the fat-rich melon. The skull on the lower part of the illustration is the one of a modern beluga. Photos and illustrations by Olivier Lambert (RBINS).

Photograph showing the detail of the bite and embedded tooth 

Photo detail of some shark bite marks on the skull of the extinct right whale. The lower photo shows a bite made by the bluntnose six-gill shark, with a tooth tip deeply embedded in the bone. Scale bars = 10 mm. Photos by Olivier Lambert (RBINS).


CT Scan of the embedded shark's tooth 

CT scan view of the tip of bluntnose six-gill shark (or cow shark) tooth (blue) found embedded in the extinct right whale skull. Scale bar = 1 mm). Illustration by Olivier Lambert (RBINS).

 

California condor protections are working and should continue, new study finds



Disturbing increases in toxic lead exposure are linked to wider foraging by the critically endangered species and more wild pigs being shot throughout the state, masking positive effects of outreach and lead-ammo bans




University of California - Santa Cruz

California condors 

image: 

Condor 204, a 16-year-old male, soars along California's central coast in 2015 with his 7-year-old son, condor 470, in the background.

view more 

Credit: Tim Huntington, webnectar photography





SANTA CRUZ, Calif. – Recent data showing an increase in lead exposure and deaths among critically endangered California condors seems to fly in the face of decades of conservation measures, including bans on lead bullets and public-education campaigns about the plight of this once-vanishing raptor.

But new research by an environmental toxicologist at the University of California, Santa Cruz and her team, shows that the unfortunate rise is despite the clear efficacy of the lead bans and outreach efforts. The study, which analyzed nearly three decades of almost-daily observational data, found that condors are eating less of the lead-free carcasses provided by conservation workers. Instead, they are foraging farther from their release sites into areas where the impact of lead-ammunition bans and education campaigns might not be as strong.

Another likely reason for the increase in lead poisoning is that more wild pigs are being shot in California due to their expanding numbers. The authors of the new study, published in the journal Nature Communications, say these dynamics are masking the continued effectiveness of the lead-bullet bans and outreach—a clear pattern that emerged after accounting for foraging and hunting changes.

"We feel this is critically important research that reveals the lead bans and outreach in California have been effective at reducing condor lead poisoning risk," said the study's senior author, Myra Finkelstein, an adjunct professor of microbiology and environmental toxicology at UC Santa Cruz. "Together, our results show that multiple factors have influenced condor blood-lead levels, including changes in wild behavior by condors and shooting behavior by humans."

Finkelstein and her team were the first to definitively link lead bullets to the poisoning that slowed the recovery of condors in California. Her pioneering research on lead poisoning in California condors helped bolster a 2019 state ban on the use of lead ammunition in hunting. A partial ban within the vulture's geographic home range was enacted 12 years earlier.

A bird that’s hard to miss

The California condor is the largest land bird in North America, with an adult's wings spanning about 9.5 feet. Their feathers are mostly black, and they boast a bald, red-orange head. They are estimated to live at least 60 years, making them one of the longest-living raptors. They are also monogamous and reproduce slowly, typically laying just one egg every two years.

Condors, eagles, and other scavenger species are poisoned by ingesting bullet fragments when they feed on the remains of animals shot with lead-based ammunition. Enormous resources have been spent over the past three decades to recover condors in California, where two of the oldest and largest reintroduced flocks reside, in the central and southern part of the state. At the end of December 2025, about 600 California condors were alive, with about 65% in the wild and the remainder in captivity. They were at their lowest in the mid-1980s, numbering in the 20s.

All free-flying condors are wing-tagged and many have telemetry tags for GPS tracking, with behavioral monitoring occurring on a near-daily basis and resulting in extremely rich long-term datasets covering 1996 to 2023.

Troubling trends in the data

To better understand the paradox of rising condor lead exposures, despite decades of conservation actions, the team used computer models to dissect the different and sometimes opposing influences—including the behavior of condors and hunters, outreach efforts, and post-ban time periods—on condor blood-lead levels.

Consistent with previous studies, they found that lead poisoning was the biggest cause of death among condors in the central and southern flocks, at 62% and 44%, respectively. The team also found that the number of birds with potentially lethal levels of lead in their blood almost doubled in the past five years.

But a closer look at the data revealed a pattern of "wilder behavior" over the 27-year study period: Condors fed less often on the lead-free carcasses proffered at feeding stations, respectively declining by 52% and 85% for condors in the central and southern flocks. They also spent less time near release sites where outreach and enforcement of the lead-ammo bans is most likely strongest, with the data showing declines of 42% and 70%.

“Thanks to the heroic efforts to bring condors back from near-extinction and track their recovery, we have a uniquely complete data set for this species,” noted the study’s lead author, Victoria Bakker, a quantitative conservation biologist at Montana State University. “It was this decades-long record of behavior and health for every individual condor that allowed us to account for the multiple drivers of lead exposure and measure the true effectiveness of outreach and lead-ammunition bans.”

The team lacked data to determine direct links between condor lead risk and the shooting of wild pigs for population control. But the researchers hypothesized that was a major driver given the ongoing range sprawl of wild pigs in California, coupled with their findings of increased lead risk associated with pig hunting, plus the strong correlation between pig hunting and pig control.

The study also points out that just a few contaminated meals can explain increased lead exposure in condors. Fewer than 10 feedings on carcasses containing lead over the course of a year are enough to tip the scales from condors being self-sustaining to conservation reliant, based on analyses of blood lead levels.

“The good news is non-lead ammunition for pig hunting is reasonably available and through effective outreach and free giveaways, we can solve this problem while supporting the heritage of hunting and ranching,” said Kelly Sorenson, a recovery partner at the Ventana Wildlife Society. 

Beware the Red Queen

Looking ahead, the authors suggest that additional outreach to those who shoot wild pigs and deer about the risk of lead poisoning to condors could increase their survival rates. California is currently the only U.S. state to ban lead bullets for shooting wildlife, and the success of conservation actions can serve as a beacon for addressing lead poisoning of wildlife elsewhere—like in the U.K., European Union, and several U.S. states where legislation on the use of lead ammunition have recently passed or are under consideration.

To drive home a main point in the paper, the authors reference the organizational theory known as the "Red Queen dynamic," which occurs when system changes require increasing effort and innovation to sustain the same level of success. The term stems from Lewis Carroll's classic Through the Looking Glass, where the Red Queen explains the chaos of her kingdom to Alice: "Now, here, you see, it takes all the running you can do, to keep in the same place."

"Running to stand still is the exact scenario our results have uncovered for condor recovery actions implemented amidst changing ecological conditions," Finkelstein said. She and Bakker collaborated with a wide array of agencies on this study, including Pinnacles National Park, the Ventana Wildlife Society, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S. Geological Survey, and the San Diego Zoo Wildlife Alliance.

"Our findings are a reminder to watch for Red Queen dynamics when evaluating conservation measures in today’s complex settings that can mask effectiveness,” Bakker added. “Otherwise, successful policies and actions could be abandoned."

# # #

Condor 79, a 23-year-old female with a days-old chick in a cliff nest in Ventura County, California, near the Hopper Mountain National Wildlife Refuge. This adult California condor died in 2023 at age 31 of lead poisoning, underscoring the continued threat of lead to condor recovery.

Credit

Photo by Joseph Brandt, USFWS



Condor 646, a 13-year-old female, feeding on a carcass in central California in December 2025.

Credit

Photo by Tim Huntington, webnectar photography

 

Stand-level probability of spruce bark beetle damage mapped across Finland





University of Eastern Finland




A new study predicts the likelihood of European spruce bark beetle damage, Ips typographus, at stand level in Finland, opening a path to proactive interventions for bark beetle management. Researchers at the University of Eastern Finland have identified stands where bark beetle damage is more likely to occur.

The study estimated the probability of individual forest stands to experience bark beetle damage. Using data from more than two million forest stands across approximately 11.4 million hectares in Finland, the researchers identified forest and landscape conditions where damage is more likely to occur.

Stand-level prediction across a national forest landscape

The researchers combined nationwide forest inventory data with disturbance and climate information collected between 2020 and 2022. The analysis included stand characteristics such as tree size as well as landscape features such as nearby disturbances.

The study shows that the landscape surrounding a forest stand strongly influences damage likelihood. Stands located close to previous bark beetle infestations or near clear-cut areas showed higher probabilities of damage. Stand characteristics, particularly larger tree diameters, also increased susceptibility to damage.

Short summer heat waves further increased the probability of bark beetle damage, highlighting how extreme warm periods can interact with forest structure and landscape conditions to influence the likelihood of infestation.

Supporting proactive forest management

Based on these results, the researchers produced a stand-level map identifying areas where bark beetle damage is more likely to occur. The map can help forest managers prioritise monitoring and target preventive actions before infestations start and spread.

“Our map reflects the situation in 2022. Forest managers and forest owners can use the map to check whether the likelihood of damage in their stand was high and, if yes, consider the need for more intensive monitoring and preventive measures,” says Alexander Pulgarín Díaz, PhD, of the University of Eastern Finland.

The study also highlights that disturbances such as clear-cuts, including those associated with salvage logging, may influence future infestation patterns in nearby stands.

By identifying the forest and landscape conditions that predispose stands to attack, the study provides tools for anticipating bark beetle outbreaks and improving forest health in boreal forests.

Stand-level likelihood maps are available at:
https://alexpulga.github.io/sprucebarkbeetle-likelihood-map-for-2022/