Wednesday, October 28, 2026

 

Ask an expert: When do identity politics and perception undermine democracy?




In his new book ‘The Great Perceptual Divide,’ Penn State Professor Mitchell P. Smith explores how identity-based perceptions drive political divides in the US and UK and offers actionable paths back to healthy political disagreement




Penn State






UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — Disagreement is crucial to a healthy democracy, according to Mitchell P. Smith, director of the School of International Affairs and professor of international affairs at Penn State. But when perceptions diverge so sharply that people and parties cannot agree on a common interpretation of events or information, it creates a political divide that can erode a democratic society.

In his new book “The Great Perceptual Divide: Identity and Democracy in the U.S. and Britain,” Smith examined the role that identity plays in the political divides in the two nations and offers steps for a return to “good-willed partisanship.” In the following Q&A, Smith discussed his book and how identity politics drive misinformation and undermine institutions. He also offered three potential outcomes of what he calls “the great perceptual divide.”

Q: Where did the idea for “The Great Perceptual Divide” originate?

Smith: The book originated with what was happening in Britain during “Brexit” — the British exit from the European Union that began with a referendum in June 2016. I was following Brexit closely, and what I learned over time was that perceptions of what was happening and the consequences of Brexit were diverging sharply in the population. And yet, as data came in on the likely consequences for British society, those perspectives diverged further rather than converging. Then, when the COVID pandemic hit, when the 2020 election took place in the United States, I saw the same phenomenon taking place. So, the book that originally was going to focus on Brexit increasingly became about perceptual divides and how the accumulation of information, rather than bringing perspectives closer together, was driving them further apart.

Q: Why are people with these diverse perspectives unable to agree on a common narrative today?

Smith: In pluralistic societies, in a healthy democracy, you want there to be a divergence of views and even a divergence of interpretations of new information. For example, the historical record shows that in the United States, those whose favored party occupies the presidency have a much more positive view about things like the economy than those of the opposition party. However, history suggests that when cataclysmic events take place, like the 2008 financial crisis, what is taking place and the harm to the economy that's taking place is so clear that we see some convergence of views. 

Around the time of Brexit, COVID and the 2020 U.S. presidential election, we began to see a phenomenon where that's not what's happening. In the book, I explain this by the identities that divide us. In the British case, that divide centers around Brexit, the “Remainers” and the “Leavers.” In the United States the identity divide is about conceptions of who should belong to the political community, who should have rights in the country, what is and is not the role of government, what is the meaning of "freedom," among other questions. Those views drive interpretations of events, regardless of objective facts.

Q: What’s driving the divide in the United States?

Smith: I start “The Great Perceptual Divide” by referencing a book written by researchers at the University of Minnesota in the 1950s. The book is called “When Prophecy Fails,” and in it the researchers looked at this small group of people who believed that a cataclysmic flood would wipe out life on Earth, though true believers in this prophecy would be rescued by extraterrestrial beings. The researchers found that even after the prophecy did not materialize on the projected date, there was a group within this community who doubled down on their efforts to gain adherents, arguing that they had misinterpreted some signs and that additional signs confirmed the prophecy. 

Clearly, what was taking place was that identification with this worldview, this fundamental belief, was driving interpretations of reality. This finding shed light on some of the events taking place in the contemporary United States, where people were interpreting, for example, rules about COVID through their fundamental lens of identity. That is, say I'm someone who does not believe that government is really looking out for the best interests of society but is fundamentally committed to societal control. If I believe that, then I have a very different interpretation about public health recommendations. So, you begin to see, even as evidence about the course of the pandemic accumulates, very different responses to that information.

You want to have partisanship in a healthy democracy. You want people to have different views. But what begins to happen over time is that views no longer converge in response to information that seems very clear to an objective observer. In fact, there are fewer and fewer objective observers. Secondly, the divergent groups begin to look at one another as enemies. One result is that in the United States today, culture wars that speak to and reinforce identities have come to supplant genuine policy debate in which we clash over approaches to a shared challenge. We see this in a variety of areas where the focus of people in political office is to mobilize supporters around identities rather than addressing policy problems. In such an environment, policy problems, such as the growing U.S. federal debt, fester. Rather than drawing lessons from the COVID pandemic about how we can best prepare for the next public health crisis, battles rage over efforts to identify the villains of the pandemic response.

Q: How did we get from a place of respectful disagreement to viewing the opposition as an enemy?

Smith: One factor driving this phenomenon is the demand for disinformation. People driven by different identities are actually searching for information that verifies their views — what psychologists call “confirmation bias.” 

In the book, I look at psychological work on cognitive dissonance, which occurs when evidence comes to bear that violates one’s beliefs, one’s sense of self. Threats to an individual's sense of self are psychologically costly, and the individual engages in an effort to reconcile those contradictions. Embracing disinformation is one way to reconcile that dissonance. Another is an assault on authoritative institutions, from the media to governing institutions — the so-called "Deep State." If people dismiss evidence because of the source, then it becomes easier for them to reconcile what is happening with their beliefs and to dismiss challenging information. Instead of pursuing information driven by an accuracy motive, people are looking for information to affirm their worldviews.

Q: How do we end the great perceptual divide?

Smith: The factors driving the divide — the undermining of authoritative institutions; the spread of disinformation; the perversion of political accountability where politicians, instead of being held accountable for their policy measures and whether they advance the welfare of society, are held accountable by their party members for whether they vilify the opposition —are self-reinforcing, which suggests that this is likely to continue or perhaps get worse. 

I think that if political figures emerge who understand what's happening and try to separate political issues from identity, it's possible to make some progress in bringing people back together. For instance, making an argument that the government is looking after your best interests and you should listen to the recommendations of the government is the wrong approach for some groups because it pushes up against the fundamental beliefs of people who are, for a wide variety of reasons, skeptical of government. Rather than trying to convince them to change those views, simply divorce the two things and suggest policies that benefit people. A podcast produced during the pandemic, for example, demonstrated that when encouraged to take the COVID vaccine because of recommendations from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, a skeptical group was entirely unconvinced. When the argument shifted to a focus on preventing the hospitalizations and deaths experienced by peers, and the recommendations of physicians, views began to soften somewhat. If we have savvy politicians who can begin to make common sense arguments in ways that don't run afoul of people's identities, there might be some progress in bringing people together on common views, or at least shared definitions of policy challenges.

Healthy pluralism means that there are partisan divisions, but that when something of a dramatic magnitude occurs, like a pandemic or financial crisis, perceptions of what's going on and what needs to happen begin to converge. That happened with the 2008 financial crisis, but that's sort of the last time it happened. In all the crises that we've seen since, views have grown further and further apart over time, even with the accumulation of evidence — for example, that the announced 2020 presidential election outcome was accurate. If we can return to a place where, as evidence comes out, people have different partisan takes on what's happening but there's sufficient convergence to drive a policy response that says, “here are some ways we can meaningfully address this issue,” then we can shore up political institutions, stabilize democracy, and react more quickly to the next crisis.



Does the future of food production start in the lab?


Producing food for a growing world population amidst climate change and supply chain constraints is a tall order. Is biotechnology part of the solution?



College of ACES at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign

Yong-Su Jin

image: 

Yong-Su Jin, professor of food science at tje University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign. 

view more 

Credit: L. Brian Stauffer.





URBANA, Ill. - Lab-grown protein that mimics the color, taste, and texture of meat. Egg white substitutes used for baked goods. Food colorants that replace beta-carotene extracted from carrots. Those are some of the products created with precision fermentation, an emerging technology that can develop tailored food ingredients in the laboratory. If adapted to large-scale production, it can potentially contribute to reducing global food insecurity by creating affordable, sustainable products supplementing those delivered by traditional agriculture.

What is precision fermentation?

While precision fermentation has been around for decades, the technology has primarily been used in production of fuel and animal feed. Regular yeast that is used for corn ethanol fermentation can’t process non-edible grain sources such as corn stover, but with metabolic engineering it’s possible to produce yeast that can ferment sugar from cellulosic biomass.

More recently, the technology is also being applied to food production, such as alternative proteins, vitamins, and nutrients. Traditional fermentation uses naturally existing micro-organisms to produce beer, wine, cheese and other consumables. However, precision fermentation uses genetically engineered microorganisms to redirect the cellular metabolism to produce specific food ingredients. One example is leghemoglobin, an alternative protein that is used to give plant-based burgers a red, blood-like color.

University of Illinois precision fermentation initiatives

Researchers at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign are on the forefront of these developments. Several facilities on campus provide resources for precision fermentation technology and applications, including the NSF iBioFoundry and the Integrated Bioprocessing Research Laboratory.

IBRL is a research and development facility that helps companies bridge the gap from basic discovery to commercialization of bioproducts. It is part of the Department of Agricultural and Biological Engineering in the College of Agricultural, Consumer and Environmental Sciences and The Grainger College of Engineering at the U. of I.

“Precision fermentation is one of our core competencies, and one of the areas that has been the busiest for the IBRL. Currently, we're seeing a lot of interest from the major consumer packaged goods companies on replacing traditionally petroleum-derived ingredients with natural alternatives, including food dyes, non-caloric sweeteners, and preservatives,” said Beth Conerty, IBRL Associate Director of Business Development.

Singapore research collaboration

The U. of I. has also co-established a research institute in Singapore. The Centre for Precision Fermentation and Sustainability (PreFerS) is funded by a $15 million grant from Singapore’s National Research Foundation and administered through the Illinois Advanced Research Center at Singapore Ltd., a U. of I.-affiliated non-profit organization.

Yong-Su Jin, professor in the Department of Food Science and Human Nutrition, is a program lead of PreFerS. 

“Singapore is a small country with no agriculture, so they are very interested in using precision fermentation for food production,” he said. “The center focuses on advancing technologies for microbial cell engineering to produce targeted nutritional molecules, including alternative proteins and vitamins. The goal is to enhance cost-effective production of safe and nutritious foods, ultimately improving food security while reducing environmental impacts.”

Specialized food product categories

In a recent publication, Jin outlined the steps necessary to bring these specialized food products to market. He highlights the core concept of minimum viable product, which indicates a product that provides value for the consumer and can be produced safely and economically.

He also introduces the precision fermentation ingredient pyramid, which comprises three tiers based on production volume, market value, and functionality.

  • High-value food ingredients, the pyramid’s top tier, are traditionally obtained through plant extraction or chemical synthesis. An example of this is beta-carotene, which is used as food colorant and antioxidant. Extracting beta-carotene from carrots is inefficient and expensive. In comparison, microbial production can provide an economical, sustainable approach.

  • The pyramid’s mid-tier, functional ingredients, includes products that deliver specific properties in a concentrated way. For example, ovalbumin, the main protein in egg whites, is widely used for baked goods and other food products. Precision fermentation can be a desirable way to produce functional proteins that mimic the natural product and does not rely on animal-derived ingredients.

  • Commodity ingredients, the bottom tier of the pyramid, are typically inexpensive to produce with traditional methods. However, precision fermentation can be used to improve microbial production systems, for example to develop single-cell proteins as edible biomass for food ingredients. The technology is also used to produce amino acids such as lysine for animal feed and citric acid for canning.

“Most products are currently developed in the high-value category, which is a small market. My vision is to fill the whole pyramid, including commodity ingredients, within the next 10 to 20 years to obtain greater environmental impact,” Jin said. 

A platform for sustainable food production

It is critical to consider consumer demand and economic potential when developing new products, he added.

“Scientists typically study fundamental technology, while consumers in the marketplace are looking for mature products,” Jin said. “But if we start with consumer input, we can ensure greater acceptance. We also need to conduct techno-economic analysis to evaluate market viability. This is a paradigm shift that is needed to advance the precision fermentation industry,” he said.

Jin is collaborating with campus facilities like IBRL and industry partners to research and develop consumer products. A novel approach to precision fermentation research and application is crucial to turning the technology into a viable platform for sustainable food production, he said. 

The article, “Minimum viable products in precision fermentation: defining translational milestones for food biotechnology,” is published in Current Opinion in Biotechnology [DOI: 10.1016/j.copbio.2026.103515].

 

Researchers study why some trees thrive far from home



Findings could offer insights on which trees serve best as carbon sinks




University of Mississippi

Conifers-Pines

image: 

Pine trees grow up to four times faster and are more drought-resistant when planted in the Southern Hemisphere, even though they do not grow there naturally. An Ole Miss biologist is among an international team studying why conifers grow so well outside their native habitats and how that affects their potential for carbon storage.

view more 

Credit: Photo by Mitchell Diggs/ University Marketing and Communications





In a study spanning 192 sites and four continents, researchers have discovered that conifers planted in the Southern Hemisphere grow up to four times faster and are more drought-resistant than those growing in their native ranges.

This expedited growth and resilience could make conifers a strong candidate for carbon storage, but there may also be drawbacks to planting trees outside their home turf.

University of Mississippi ecologist Stephen Brewer was among more than two dozen researchers across multiple continents who studied the growth rate of pines, spruces, firs, cedars and other conifers in their native and nonnative habitats. The group published its findings in Nature.

"That result is surprising because ecological theory predicts that there should be a tradeoff between how fast a plant can grow and how tolerant it would be of stressful conditions," said Brewer, Ole Miss professor of biology. "This is interesting to us because with the elevated carbon dioxide concentrations in the atmosphere contributing to climate change, there's a desire or push for afforestation, or planting trees in areas where there weren't any before, as carbon sinks.

"For that to be effective, you want the trees to grow quickly and not die in droughts."

While the exact cause for the trees increased resilience needs more study, the researchers found that Northern Hemisphere conifers planted in the Southern Hemisphere had higher concentrations of carbohydrates, such as sugars and starches, that could be used to store energy during stressful seasons.

"This phenomenon of skipping the growth-stress tolerance trade-off is something crucial that this study is reporting," said Alex Fajardo, researcher at the Institute of Ecology and Biodiversity and professor at the University of Talca. "It is also valuable that we pursued finding the physiological mechanism responsible for this: an increase in carbon reserves needed for drought tolerance."

Although the findings position conifers as well-suited for afforestation efforts, the researchers cautioned that more factors are involved.

"The easy answer to this question is to advocate for plantations with nonnative conifers that can both grow (quickly) and tolerate drought," Fajardo said. "However, this decision has some serious risks, as nonnative conifer plantations, particularly in the Southern Hemisphere, have come with high biodiversity and social costs."

Pines and Douglas firs, two of trees researchers studied, do not naturally grow in the Southern Hemisphere, but they have been planted in countries including Chile, Brazil and South Africa as a part of the lumber industry for decades.

"The problem is, these pines are not necessarily staying in their plantations; they are actually expanding into natural, native habitats," Brewer said.

"In Brazil, it's escaping into what they call their Cerrado, which is a savanna, and it grows much faster there and just basically eliminates all the native vegetation. It's actually become a big problem."

The problem of escaping or encroaching pines has also affected Mississippi, he said. Local lumber industries began replacing longleaf pines with slash pines in the 1930s because of their faster growth rate.

Both species are native to Mississippi, but longleaf pines are more fire-resistant. The threat of fire wiping out entire stands has prompted many foresters and nonprofit agencies to return to the more resilient longleaf.

"I've seen wildfires completely eliminate entire stands of slash pines, whether that's in Mississippi or in the Southern Hemisphere," Brewer said. "The Cerrado in Brazil gets comparable rainfall amounts to what we get along the Mississippi Gulf Coast, and it's a savanna for the same reason that we have longleaf pine savannas on our coast: fire.

"Fire is what maintains those savannas, and if you plant slash pines in really high densities, there could be an actual elevated fire risk, too."

The researchers also found that native Southern Hemisphere trees in the genus Nothofagus, known as southern beeches, performed relatively well in growth and drought-tolerance measures.

"In our study, we also found that native angiosperms of the genus Nothofagus did a decent job growing and tolerating drought," Fajardo said. "They may be a more potentially sustainable alternative."

 

Global chocolate supply threatened by disease, new cacao plant offers solution





Penn State

Just-harvested cacao pods

image: 

Just-harvested cacao pods display a range of vivid colors. 

view more 

Credit: Mark Guiltinan / Penn State






UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — Chocolate lovers may not realize it, but the future of one of the world's most popular foods is increasingly under pressure. Diseases, shifting weather patterns and other environmental stressors are threatening cacao production globally, contributing to supply concerns and economic challenges for the millions of farmers who grow the crop that makes chocolate possible.

Now, after decades of research, Penn State scientists have developed a new disease-tolerant variety of cacao — and they said it has the potential to fundamentally change the chocolate industry.

The new cacao variety builds on decades of research led by Mark Guiltinan, J. Franklin Styer Professor of Horticultural Botany and professor of plant molecular biology in the Department of Plant Sciences at Penn State's College of Agricultural Sciences, and Siela Maximova, research professor of plant biotechnology in the same department.

“For consumers, chocolate is something they expect to find on store shelves every day, but behind that product is a crop and industry facing significant challenges,” Guiltinan said. “Our goal is to develop tools that help growers continue producing cacao sustainably and profitably.”

Penn State's Program in the Molecular Biology of Cocoa, which Guiltinan and Maximova co-direct, traces its roots to an industry-supported endowment established in the 1980s. Since then, researchers at the University have developed foundational tools for cacao biotechnology, mapped important genetic pathways, and built one of the world's leading cacao research programs.

The University recently entered into a licensing agreement with AgroNetica, a cacao-focused biotechnology company, to work toward bringing the plant to growers worldwide. The company will advance field testing of the plants with the goal of eventually marketing the plant directly to growers, helping address some of the most significant threats facing global chocolate production.

The AgroNetica agreement represents a new chapter in the University’s effort to understand and improve cacao, Maximova said, one focused on translating discoveries into technologies that can help growers, strengthen supply chains and support the future of chocolate production.

“Thanks to this long-term investment in research and maintaining a sustained program, we now have an opportunity to begin getting technologies developed here in the lab closer to the hands of farmers,” Maximova said. “The focus was always on helping cacao farmers and the industry. We're now at the place where we have a partner whose expertise is moving these discoveries into real-world use.”

According to Guiltinan, this new commercialization opportunity is particularly important as cacao production worldwide faces mounting threats from disease, climate variability, and changing environmental conditions that jeopardize both grower livelihoods and supply chains.

Black pod disease, an especially destructive disease caused by a mold-like pathogen, alone is estimated to cause yield losses of roughly 30% worldwide, he said, while climate-related stresses continue to threaten production in major cacao-growing regions.

Native to the Amazon rainforest, cacao evolved as an understory tree growing beneath a tropical forest canopy. Today, it is cultivated across tropical regions in Africa, Asia and Latin America, often under environmental conditions that are very different from those in which the species evolved.

“Cacao evolved in a very stable rainforest environment,” Guiltinan said. “It's a delicate plant in many ways. Changes in rainfall, temperature and humidity can all affect production, and some of those changes can also increase disease pressure.”

Traditional cacao breeding is notoriously slow. Maximova explained that developing and evaluating new varieties can take decades because cacao trees require roughly three years to mature and produce seed. That slow rate of growth means climate change is an especially dangerous threat to its survival, she added. Not only are environmental conditions shifting faster than plants can evolve, but increased humidity and weather variability can create favorable conditions for pathogens and insect pests.

“The climate is changing faster than these trees can naturally adapt,” she said. “One of our goals is to develop tools that help breeders respond more quickly to those challenges.”

In a study published in the Plant Biotechnology Journal, the researchers combined advanced genetic tools such as genome sequencing and editing with traditional plant breeding to create a cacao plant with significantly improved resistance to black pod disease.

Using gene editing technology (CRISPR), the scientists modified a cacao gene known as TcNPR3, which acts as a natural brake on the plant's immune system. The mutation partially activates the plant's defense response, increasing its defenses against subsequent pathogen infection. After introducing the desired edit, researchers bred the plants to remove all transgenic material, or foreign DNA associated with the gene-editing machinery, leaving only the beneficial genetic change.

The result was a cacao plant carrying a precise genetic modification for disease tolerance, but no longer considered a genetically modified organism or GMO, consistent with U.S. and European Union regulatory frameworks that treat certain gene-edited traits similarly to those developed through conventional breeding.

“In one case, we only changed two bases in the entire genome of the plant,” Guiltinan said. “Out of roughly 450 million bases, that single change resulted in about a 42% reduction in disease under laboratory conditions.”

Although the edited plants have shown promising results in laboratory testing, the researchers emphasized that further work is needed before growers could plant them commercially. Field evaluations are underway through collaborations with the U.S. Department of Agriculture in Hawaii and Puerto Rico, where researchers will assess performance under real growing conditions.

“These plants are specifically designed to improve disease resistance,” Maximova said. “The next step is proving performance in field trials. Scale-up and marketing will be the next challenges should the field testing prove encouraging. That's where commercial partners can play an important role in helping move the technology forward.”

She noted that commercialization of improved cacao varietie requires substantial investment, beyond what universities are designed to provide.

That’s where AgroNetica comes in. The company recently licensed the commercial rights to the plants carrying the mutation for disease tolerance. AgroNetica has a plan to test, scale up and sell new varieties of cacao with improved traits for more sustainable production in cacao-growing countries. The company also plans to introduce additional traits from its development pipeline aimed at improving heat and drought resilience, reducing cadmium accumulation, enabling more compact plant architecture and greater mechanization, accelerating time to first harvest, and developing caffeine-free cacao varieties.

“It takes millions of dollars and many years to bring a new crop variety to farmers,” Maximova said. “That's why partnerships with companies willing to invest in development, testing and deployment are so important.”

While the licensed technology focuses on resistance to disease, Maximova and Guiltinan are also studying traits related to climate resilience and crop productivity. Accelerated breeding and genome editing will become increasingly important tools as environmental pressures on cacao production continue to grow, they explained.

“The diseases are changing. The climate is changing. The challenges growers face continue to evolve,” Maximova said. “This is not something you solve once and then you're finished. It's an ongoing effort to develop better plants and provide growers with new options.”

For Guiltinan, the licensing agreement represents more than a commercial milestone. It is evidence that long-term university research can lead to tangible benefits for agriculture.

“We're trying to solve real problems for farmers,” he said. “If we can help growers reduce losses, improve productivity and adapt more quickly to changing conditions, then that's the ultimate measure of success.”