October 29, 2026
By P. K. Balachandran
Key Takeaways:
On 6 October a coalition of 21 news publishers, including groups owned by Mukesh Ambani and Gautam Adani, petitioned the Supreme Court to strike down key provisions of the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, arguing that consent and erasure rules would destroy investigative journalism and expose sources.
The challenge coincides with India’s drop to 157th in the World Press Freedom Index, amid concentrated media ownership, limited access to the prime minister, and concerns that the privacy law could further deter whistleblowers and curtail reporting.
With the Gen Z relentlessly tormenting him, the opposition Congress rising like a Sphinx from the ashes to challenge him, Manipur continuing to be restive, Arunachal Pradesh complaining of a serious Chinese threat, and the US showing scant regard for his status, Prime Minister Narendra Modi is watching the iron-clad support structure he had raised over 12 years develop multiple cracks.
Each of these developments has been unanticipated. For years it was an article of faith that Modi was the Messiah of the Indian middle-class youth, called the “aspirational generation” that will not rise against him as the youth Sri Lanka, Bangladesh and Nepal did. But a chance remark by the Chief Justice of India about the youth being cockroaches set alight a movement against examination and electoral roll frauds.
An attempt to make up with China as a riposte to bullying the US only resulted in China supporting Pakistan during the May 2025 war and China sending the PLA deep into Arunachal Pradesh in 2026. An attempt to normalize relations with the US was snubbed when the US began to negotiate an oil deal directly with oil baron Mukesh Ambani, sidelining New Delhi.
Even the servile “lapdog” media which had been a strong pillar of support for more than a decade, showed signs of disaffection when the Digital News Publishers Association (DNPA), with the Ambanis and Adani as members, went to the Supreme Court challenging the Digital Personal Data Protection Act (DPDPA) or the Privacy Act.
A group of 21 Indian news publishers, including mega companies owned by Mukesh Ambani and Gautam Adani, challenged India’s “privacy law” in the Supreme Court on October 6, pointing out that it would trample investigative journalism and let the government of India find out journalists’ sources.
Reports said that the law would force a journalist to get “prior consent” from a person he wants to investigate and force publishers to erase stories. The filing in the Supreme Court also said that the powers granted by the law to demand information could expose reporters’ sources.
It was in 2023 that the controversial DPDPA was mooted. It was designed to be the basis for India’s personal data regulatory regime and protection. It stayed in the incubator for two years until its regulators and rules were made known to news publishers in September 2025. The DPDPA replaces the previous IT (Information Technology) Rules, 2011 under the IT Act 2000
Through the DPDP Act, the government has imposed some compliance requirements for platforms like Meta and Google. But the new publishers pointed out that since media outlets were not exempted, the law was an invasion of press freedom.
Media companies received assurances in an August meeting with the government that the law would protect press freedom. But there was no written assurance for journalists, unlike what exists in the European Union, Singapore and Britain. The news publishers (DNPA), pleaded that the court quash most of the law’s contentious provisions.
The law would “render investigative journalism a benign and neutered recorder of events,” the DNPA’s 698-page filing said according to Reuters. The cited provisions “constitute pre-censorship which is anathema to any democracy worth its name,” the filing said.
The litigants included Ambani’s Network18, which has seven digital news platforms, Adani’s NDTV and other marquee media groups including the Indian Express and Times Internet, which is part of the Times of India group.
Requirement for Consent
A key concern in the privacy law is the “requirement of consent”, the group’s filing says. The litigants have argued that requiring a journalist to notify the subject of an investigation and seek his or her consent “would allow that subject to destroy evidence and intimidate witnesses”.
The law also lets people withdraw consent at any time and demand that their data be erased, without any public-interest safeguards.
Fines and Blocking Access
News publishers are concerned that a Central government authority created under the said law, can impose fines for non-compliance and grants powers to the government to block access to any information in the “interests of the general public. But that would curtail press freedom, the publishers said.
In a letter to the government written in August, which was attached to the lawsuit, the publishers said that India “has chosen to grant broad exemptions to the State, while failing to extend any corresponding protection to the press”.
From next year, the law will also let New Delhi order any organisation handling personal data “to furnish such information as it may call for”, putting newsrooms at risk of having to divulge sources, the filing said.
If reporters cannot promise confidentiality, fewer people will come forward with information about wrongdoing. That would hurt the public, not just the media. The law needs a clear exemption for journalism, written in a way that protects sources without opening a door for misuse. Until that happens, the fear that privacy rules will become a tool for surveillance of the press is real, the publishers said.
Deterrence to Whistleblowers
The Privacy Law can also deter whistleblowers from sharing information on corruption, corporate wrongdoing or electoral malpractice with reporters, the litigants pointed out. The State’s power “can also extend to privileged communications in possession of a reporter or the informant.” These provisions must be quashed, they demanded.
Silencing RTI Activists
A particularly controversial aspect of the Privacy Act is its direct impact on the Right to Information (RTI) Act. According to the RTI Act, citizens could seek out access to records that public authorities hold if their disclosure was in the larger interest of the public.
The challenge against the Act in the Supreme Court brings together the Adanis and Ambanis, said to be rivals. The new found unity signals how seriously the industry views the law’s impact on reporting.
Declining Media Freedom
The lawsuit comes amidst accusations of sharply declining press freedom in India since Narendra Modi took office in 2014. Critics say many mainstream media outlets have not done enough to scrutinise Modi’s government. India’s ranking in the “Reporters Without Borders” World Press Freedom Index fell to 157th out of 180 countries this year, from 140th in 2014.
“India has fallen further in global press freedom rankings, slipping below countries such as Pakistan and Palestine,” says the 2026 World Press Freedom Index released April 30 by Reporters Without Borders. India is behind most of its South Asian neighbours. Pakistan ranks 153rd, Bangladesh 152nd, Bhutan 150th, Sri Lanka 134th, and Nepal significantly higher at 87th. China remains among the lowest-ranked at 178th.
In its country assessment, “Reporters Without Borders” points to multiple factors affecting India’s ranking, including rising violence against journalists, concentrated media ownership and increasing political alignment within the media landscape.
It notes that major business groups have expanded their influence in the sector, with the Ambanis, close to the Modi government, owning 70% of the outlet and Adani now owning NDTV and reshaping the mainstream media environment.
The report also raises concerns about access to information and the relationship between the government and the press. It states that India’s prime minister Narendra Modi never holds press conferences and instead gives interviews to YouTubers and outlets friendly to him.
Economic pressures are also cited as a key factor. With media organizations heavily reliant on advertising revenue, including significant government spending, the report says authorities are in a position to influence editorial content.
On safety, the index notes that India remains a challenging environment for journalists, with an average of two to three reporters killed each year in connection with their work.
About P. K. Balachandran
P. K. Balachandran is a senior Indian journalist working in Sri Lanka for local and international media and has been writing on South Asian issues for the past 21 years.
View all posts by P. K. Balachandran →




