Metis National Council files a multi-million dollar lawsuit
In January of 2022, the Metis National Council (MNC) filed a multi-million dollar lawsuit in the Ontario Superior Court against:
- The Manitoba Metis Federation (MMF);
- former MNC president Clement Chartier;
- current MMF president and former MNC vice-president and minister of finance David Chartrand;
- former MNC executive director Wenda Waytteyne;
- and at least a dozen other individuals.
Newly-elected MNC president Cassidy Caron released a statement in late January saying that an audit of the MNC had “uncovered agreements, contracts and consultation arrangements that may be questionable in nature.”
Based on the findings and consultation with legal counsel, the lawsuit was filed.
The MNC alleges that the previous administration operated a scheme that caused financial damage to the organization, while bettering the position of the MMF on the national stage.
The statement of claim reads in part, “MNC’s claims arise from a scheme perpetrated by each of Chartier, Chartrand, MMF and Watteyne in the Province of Ontario to intentionally cause severe financial harm and other injury to MNC, and to correspondingly benefit, among others, themselves, upon their departures from MNC in the summer of 2021.”
Clement Chartier was the president of the MNC from 2003 to 2021. Shortly after his departure, Chartier was hired by the MMF to act as an ambassador for international and inter-nation relationships for a “new government” the MMF was reportedly forming.
The statement of claim alleges that the defendants had, "embarked upon a scorched earth policy to intentionally cause financial harm and other injury to MNC, recognizing that MNC and MMF would now be competing to be the legitimate or recognized authority and voice of the Métis Nation going forward."
The lawsuit is reportedly seeking $15 million in damages, as well as $1 million in punitive damages.
MNC president Caron said of the matter, "We need to understand what happened at the MNC prior to my election. We deserve truth, we deserve justice, and we deserve to put a period on the past and we deserve to finally move forward together.”
While many issues were brought up in the lawsuit, some of the more notable accusations by the MNC include: $1.5 million in wrongfully paid lump sums, inappropriate severance payments, and the transfer of a “vital” database of archival and genealogical materials to the MMF without approval of board members.
None of the allegations have been proven.
However, the national zeitgeist seems to favour the the Caron administration as the Metis Nations of Saskatchewan, Alberta, Ontario and British Columbia have all issued statements in support of the MNC’s decision to take legal action.
Audrey Poitras, president of the Metis Nation of Alberta, released a statement that said, “As a governing and founding member of MNC, the Métis Nation of Alberta fully supports President Caron and the MNC Board of Governors’ decision to take action.
“We are obligated to do what is right and necessary to restore accountability, transparency, and integrity to the MNC by moving forward with this litigation with a view to ensuring transparency and accountability and holding individuals responsible for their actions.”
Meanwhile, current MMF president Chatrand spoke to APTN, stating that the audit to which Caron was provided does not exist.
“If you have an audit, (if) you have so much you want to sue MMF, you want to sue David Chartrand, you want to sue Clement Chartier, you want to sue them, you believe it’s valued at $15 million, show us,” said Chartrand.
“You should have nothing to hide, nothing to fear because it scared you. It should scare all of us then.”
“There is no audit, that’s what I’m telling you,” he said.
Jacob Cardinal, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter, Alberta Native News
Rift between Metis leaders widens ahead of meetings with premiers, PM
David Chartrand, president of the Manitoba Metis Federation watches on as Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau holds a rally in Winnipeg, Saturday, Oct. 19, 2019. On the eve of First Ministers' meetings with national Indigenous leaders, the vice-president of the Metis National Council is stepping up his rhetoric against three provincial Metis leaders, accusing them of striking a "backroom deal" that allows new members into the nation he believes are not Metis.
March 10, 2020 - 1:00 AM
OTTAWA - The vice-president of the Metis National Council is stepping up his rhetoric against three provincial Metis leaders, accusing them of striking a "backroom deal" that allows new members into the nation he believes are not Metis.
The escalation is on the eve of a major meeting among Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, provincial premiers and national Indigenous leaders, where David Chartrand is to represent the Metis National Council as its national spokesperson.
Two separate gatherings are being held this week among Metis members, before the first ministers convene in Ottawa starting Thursday, and their divergent objectives highlight a growing rift between the leadership of the Metis National Council and the Metis leaders of Ontario, Alberta and Saskatchewan.
The leaders of the Metis Nation of Ontario, Metis Nation-Saskatchewan and the Metis Nation of Alberta say they do not want to be pulled into "distractions" from the work they are trying to do. In interviews, they said they want to continue progress they have made in gaining recognition and self-government rights from the federal government.
But meanwhile, Chartrand began a two-day forum on citizenship and identity in Saskatchewan Monday, with sessions on "Metis identity theft and cultural appropriation in Ontario and eastern Canada" and a "third invasion" of allegedly non-Metis people trying to gain official citizenship in the Metis Nation.
He said there is a lot of concern among those living on the Prairies about the way Ontario defines its members as Metis after an announcement in 2017 that six new Metis communities had been identified in the province.
The Manitoba Metis Federation, of which Chartrand is also president, commissioned a study of these new communities and Chartrand said Monday the findings suggest the residents are Algonquin and Ojibwe.
"They are attempting to be in both worlds and trying to say they're Metis ... They're not us, they're not connected to us," Chartrand said.
In November 2018 Chartrand brought these concerns about Ontario's membership registry to a general assembly and a resolution was passed placing Ontario's Metis group on probation and calling for an external committee to review its membership registry.
But the Ontario nation has refused to allow it, citing privacy concerns. Since then, the Metis National Council has issued proclamations saying Ontario has been suspended from the national body. But the leaders of Ontario, Alberta and Saskatchewan say this move was illegitimate, pointing to bylaws that say a member nation can only be suspended from the national council by vote of a general assembly.
No such general assembly has been held. Also, the national council has not held a board of governors meeting in over 16 months, despite repeated calls for one.
Chartrand said he hasn't called a board of governors meeting because he anticipates Ontario will show up expecting to have voting rights. He fears Alberta, Saskatchewan and Ontario will vote as a bloc and assume control over the national council.
Chartrand said his members have been asking why there is "divisiveness" among the provinces, but hopes people don't think of it as fighting — even as he called the co-operation among the three other leaders a "backroom deal."
He dismissed the notion it could have an impact on his ability to represent the Metis people as a whole at the upcoming first-ministers meetings.
"We can have differences of opinion, and these are strong differences of opinion because it's a very dangerous precedent they're trying to create, but it will never prevent me or the Metis National Council for pushing forward the agenda for all of our citizens."
Meanwhile the leaders of the Metis nations of Ontario, Alberta and Saskatchewan began their own two-day conference in Gatineau, Que., Monday to discuss working together on initiatives that will build upon self-governing agreements they each signed with Ottawa last June.
They say these agreements are significant milestone for their respective provincial nations in gaining recognition as Metis governments — a goal for generations of Metis peoples in Canada dating back to the days of the Louis Riel in the 1800s.
Alberta president Audrey Poitras acknowledged tensions between the three provincial nations and the Metis National Council, but said she and her counterparts from Saskatchewan and Ontario are choosing to focus on the steps being taken to recognize the Metis right of self-government.
"We choose to look at moving forward, not to look for divisions," Poitras said.
"I'm right now focusing on the positive of moving forward with the other two provinces to really focus on ... how do we move forward as fast as we can on something that our forefathers, our previous leaders, have worked so hard to get, the recognition that we so rightfully deserve?"
Ontario president Margaret Froh said she finds it frustrating the national council continues to call her provincial registry into question at meetings to which Ontario is not invited.
"It's too bad, but again, we're not being distracted by that work that's happening," Froh said.
"We really are truly focusing on these great opportunities that are in front of us and having real, meaningful conversations, which is why our three governments are coming together to talk about Metis self-governments and how all three of our governments are going to work together moving forward to make sure we bring that home for our people."
Saskatchewan president Glen McCallum said he doesn't believe there is any tension between the national body and his province. But after Chartrand called him out for rebuffing the national council forum this week in his own province and attending the meetings in Quebec with Ontario and Alberta instead, McCallum said the current leadership of the Metis National Council is "not in line with the bylaws and resolutions of the MNC."
"The MN-S (Metis-Nation of Saskatchewan) is committed to a path forward for self-government that we have chosen for ourselves and it is a path based on democracy, transparency, and accountability. We are working with the federal government to move forward the Metis government recognition and self-government agreements."
The three provincial leaders declared in January that the MNC "has become increasingly dysfunctional and unaccountable to its governing members and the Metis citizens."
This report by The Canadian Press was first published March 10, 2020
No comments:
Post a Comment