Wednesday, May 31, 2023

How a Mexican state siphoned off millions – and a reporter risked her life to expose it

María Teresa Montaño Delgado was kidnapped while investigating suspicious contracts worth $300m awarded by the state of Mexico


María Teresa Montaño Delgado was kidnapped while investigating suspicious government contracts in the state of Mexico.
Composite: Guardian Design/Alamy

LONG READ

by Nina Lakhani in Mexico City
THE GUARDIAN
Wed 31 May 2023

It was a muggy summer day when the veteran reporter María Teresa Montaño Delgado drove almost 450 miles from Toluca, capital of the state of Mexico (Edomex), to a rundown neighbourhood in Coatzacoalcos, an oil city on the Gulf coast.

Montaño carried with her a $35m contract for “specialist human capital management” with the government of Edomex – the last bastion of power for the Institutional Revolutionary Party (PRI) which has ruled the state uninterrupted for almost a century.

She double-checked the company address, which turned out to be a second-floor apartment in a pastel-pink residential building, on an unremarkable street with boarded-up bars and empty lots.

The company, one half of a consortium with contracts with three agencies worth about $55m – existed on paper, but there was no sign of any business operations or employees.

“I was shocked by the crumbling building, but it confirmed my suspicions: the contract was completely illogical,” said Montaño, founder and editor-in-chief of the independent news website the Observer. “This was a fake company, part of a scheme to embezzle huge amounts of public money … That’s why they tried to silence me.”

Coatzacoalcos seemed an unlikely location for a human resources company with multimillion-dollar contracts on the other side of the country. All the contracts were signed on 29 December 2018, at a time when a vicious turf war between rival cartels had helped make the port city one of the most violent places in Mexico.

When the Guardian visited in January, the seafront boulevard was lined with burned-out hotels, abandoned shopping malls and decrepit housing blocks, and the streets patrolled by marines. A few courageous women were out selling seafood cocktails and coconuts, but it looked like a hurricane had swept through downtown.

The $55m contracts weren’t the only questionable deals that Montaño had uncovered while trawling through the government’s information portal. In early 2021, Montaño had noticed other contracts worth millions of dollars with companies and individuals across Mexico – many for vaguely defined products and services available locally such as cleaning, office furniture, construction and computer software.

On paper, the companies and contracts looked legitimate but there were multiple “red flags”, according to Muna Dora Buchahin Abulhosn, a forensic accountant who has led investigations into state-run embezzlement schemes.


A cursory search on Google Maps found companies awarded lucrative contracts were often located in residential streets, abandoned lots and shopping malls. Some addresses were linked to several companies – or didn’t exist; other companies had no functioning website despite multimillion dollar contracts.

Montaño’s reporting was potentially embarrassing for the PRI, which is desperate to hold on to the state in elections on 4 June. But investigating corruption can be deadly in Mexico, particularly for local reporters.

Last year 15 journalists were killed in Mexico, making it the most dangerous country for the media apart from Ukraine. The violence – and the impunity that fuels it – has a chilling effect, with reporters routinely silenced by threats, bribes and blacklists blocking access to jobs and information.
María Teresa Montaño writes on her computer. Photograph: Ginnette Riquelme/Ginnette Riquelme for The Guardian

“The contracts were signed with companies far away to make it almost impossible for local journalists to physically verify. The government has so much control but I kept asking questions and downloading documents,” said Montaño. “That’s why I think I was kidnapped.”

On 13 August 2021, Montaño’s car broke down en route to a medical appointment in Toluca. She left it parked at a convenience store and took a bus to the clinic, close to the state congress building which is surrounded by surveillance cameras.

By the time she was finished it was just after 7.30pm. A huge rainstorm had broken and Montaño was soaking wet, when a white car that looked like a shared taxi signalled for her to get in.

Almost immediately, a skinny man in the passenger seat pulled out a revolver. “Don’t scream and you won’t die,” he said. In the back, a second man covered her eyes with her Covid mask and pulled up her jersey to expose her stomach and chest.

The driver added: “You’re the journalist, aren’t you?”

Fearing for her life, Montaño denied she was a reporter, but the kidnappers knew where she lived and even where she’d left her car.

“Is your son home?” the driver asked as they pulled up at her gated housing complex.
A residential building in Coatzacoalcos, at the address on a $35m contract for ‘specialist human capital management’ signed by the government of the state of Mexico. Photograph: Nina Lakhani/The Guardian


The two assailants ransacked Montaño’s tiny home, before leaving her blindfolded on a dusty lot a few miles away at about 11pm. She had no phone and no money, but following a distant light, she found her way to a shopping mall and called her family.

She reported the kidnapping to the authorities immediately. It was only later that she realised the assailants had taken her laptops, phone, voice recorder, camera, notebooks and documents – but not the TV or other valuables.

“They stole my whole investigation. The message was clear, but I survived – and this information is too important to keep to myself. Before the people go to vote, they need to know.”

Over the past six months, the Guardian and Organized Crime and Corruption Reporting Project (OCCRP) have worked with Montaño as part of an initiative by the Paris-based non-profit Forbidden Stories to continue the work of threatened and murdered journalists.

The team analysed dozens of state contracts issued during the current administration led by Alfredo del Mazo Maza – whose family has governed Edomex for 29 years – visited every company address and consulted experts on corruption and politics in Mexico.

As Edomex prepares to go to the polls on 4 June, the investigation can reveal that the outgoing government issued at least 40 contracts involving at least 15 front and shell companies worth more than $300m.

In some cases there was no company at the listed address: no sign, no workers and no infrastructure. In others, real companies were contracted for goods or services they had no expertise in. Several companies shared the same address and/or legal representatives. Unusually, many were awarded at the end of the year when most government employees are on leave. Freedom of information requests for evidence on each procurement was ignored.

The Del Mazo government said that it complied with the law at all times and all contracts were awarded through competitive tender to the “best provider”; it said it respected press freedom and journalists, and had no prior knowledge of Montaño’s kidnap.

All the contracts were authorized by the department of finance, which coordinates the state’s procurement process. Approached by the consortium for comment, the department said it was obliged by law to open tenders to companies across the country, and provided a dossier of photocopies of undated photos and documents purporting to prove that all the contractors were legitimate.


But further investigation revealed multiple inconsistencies and irregularities in the government’s evidence, including offices which were apparently not in use, or addresses in use by seemingly unrelated companies.

Together, the contracts illustrate a pattern of “acts and omissions” that suggest an embezzlement scheme involving public officials and private individuals, according to Buchahin, the forensic accountant.

In Monterrey, a city 600 miles north of Toluca, the company Sevacom was contracted to provide materials for workshops – such as jewellery-making, balloon decorating and dressmaking – by six different government agencies, including the governor’s office and department of rural affairs. The consortium found 12 identical contracts worth almost $5.2m. There is a business called Sevacom at the address on the contract, but it is a retail store selling household cleaning products. The owner denied receiving any public contracts or any knowledge of workshops. A website for Sevacom was created after the first contracts were awarded, but telephone calls, letters and messages to the contact details it contains went unanswered.

In its dossier, the Edomex government provided photocopied photographs of an unidentified warehouse and women receiving boxes of government aid, as well as photocopies of a social security letter and documents provided by two commercial certification companies. It provided no evidence that any workshops had taken place.

The address listed on a half-million-dollar outsourcing contract with a supposed construction company in Edomex was actually a tiny house belonging to a woman with a makeshift neighbourhood nail salon, who said she had never heard of the deal. In another case, a nearly $100,000 contract for elevator maintenance was awarded to an audiovisuals company. The mismatch between the firm’s specialism and the contract it won was another red flag, said Buchahin

The supposed HR company in Coatzacoalcos, Instituto C&A Intelligent, was awarded another three contracts worth $67m with an address in Edomex that doesn’t exist. The company was listed online at a different but nearby location - an office building on which the company logo has appeared and disappeared several times this year. A phone number listed for the company is out of service, emails to its address bounced back and the company website is defunct.

The Edomex government provided copies of photographs showing people standing outside the building. Consortium reporters visited the site four times over the past year, but saw no sign of activity in the building. On Monday, a neighbour said he saw workers reattaching the company sign to the building’s facade last week, adding that the building was mostly empty apart from a few residential renters.

The address for a company awarded four contracts for office furniture worth a total of $2.4m is an unattended office in a strip mall on the outskirts of the city of Querétaro, 120 miles north-west of Edomex, with no answering machine. The government provided photocopies of photos showing stacks of furniture ostensibly taken at a company warehouse in the state of Puebla. The consortium visited the address, and found a modest metal workshop, whose employees said they had no knowledge of the company.

The findings suggest a new version of an old embezzlement scheme.

María Teresa Montaño, smokes a cigarette while walking during a break. Photograph: Ginnette Riquelme/Ginnette Riquelme for The Guardian

In 2017, the Federal Audit Office (ASF) and investigative journalists uncovered an alleged multimillion-dollar embezzlement enterprise involving at least 11 federal government agencies, eight public universities and more than 120 fake companies registered in several states. The case, known as La estafa maestra or the master swindle, took place during the presidency of Enrique Peña Nieto, former governor of Edomex – and Del Mazo’s cousin.

No one was ever charged over the allegations, which implicated several institutions and PRI officials in Edomex. Peña Nieto has denied any wrongdoing.

Eric Sevilla. Photograph: Future Publishing/Getty Images

Such impunity has allowed the “modus operandi” to continue, said Buchahin, who previously led the ASF forensic accounting unit. Some of the companies implicated in the estafa maestra continue to receive government contracts, while officials suspected of wrongdoing were simply moved to new roles.

Alejandra del Moral. Photograph: Marco Ugarte/AP

Nine of the 40 contracts analysed by the Guardian involved the Edomex department of social development. Alejandra del Moral, who led the department in 2022, is running for governor. Eric Sevilla Montes de Oca, the 2018-2020 director, is currently president of the PRI in Edomex and running the governor’s election campaign. Neither Sevilla nor Del Moral responded to the allegations.

“This is a network of powerful senior officials who simulate contracts and payments which are supported by legal but unsupported invoices in order to get money out … It continues because they know nothing will happen, impunity is generalised. Everybody knows and nobody does anything. The state of Mexico is the most corrupt in the country, it’s where they get money for all the others,” said Buchahin.

Edomex is Mexico’s largest state by population, with 17 million people: a sprawling conurbation of dormitory communities, industrial sites and colonial pueblos wrapping around the capital city. It is home to members of the political, economic and criminal elites, but includes some of the country’s most dangerous municipalities – especially for women and girls.

Del Mazo Maza – whose grandfather, father and uncle have also governed the state – eked out an election victory in 2017 amid widespread allegations of fraud. Next week’s election matters because Edomex is the only state that the PRI – which ruled the country uninterrupted between 1929 and 2010 – has clung on to.

Governor Alfredo del Mazo Maza. Photograph: Mario Guzman/EPA

“The state of Mexico has both great political and symbolic value for the PRI – and their opponents,” said Rogelio Hernández, a political scientist at the College of Mexico. For the PRI, retaining the state would prove that it is still relevant as a party; for Morena – the party which is in government nationally but in opposition in the state – a victory would be a much-needed token of support for President Andrés Manuel López Obrador.

PRI’s success in Edomex is partly down to its control of the media. Most news outlets – and many journalists – depend on the state government for advertising and off-the-books monthly payments, known as chayotes, in exchange for non-critical coverage.

“Intimidating journalists has been a constant for many decades in the state of Mexico – just like chayotes. It’s how the PRI has been able to remain in power, and why there is virtually zero independent and investigative journalism in the state,” said Lenin Martell, media studies professor at the autonomous university of the state of Mexico.

Journalists who reject the status quo often pay a great personal and professional price.

Montaño has spent her whole career reporting on politics, crime and corruption in Edomex, mostly as a correspondent for national newspapers, and has a track record of irking powerful people.


But after refusing to accept an envelope of cash in early 2018, she started getting pressure from editors to send fewer freedom of information requests. Colleagues and sources cut her off and it became harder to make ends meet.

After the kidnap, she left Mexico for several months but returned determined to continue the investigation. Despite CCTV footage of at least one assailant withdrawing cash using her bank card, no one has been arrested. Prosecutors investigating the case have denied that the kidnapping was related to her journalism.

A spokesperson for the Del Mazo government said that it fully “complied with the law at all times with its transparency and accountability obligations” and that procurements for all goods and services had been consolidated under the finance department “to obtain technical and economic advantages”. The government did not respond to specific questions about the investigation’s conclusions, or the use of threats, publicity and payments to control the media.


Mexico media say president’s attacks on journalists are ‘invitation to violence’


The finance department said that all contracts were awarded through competitive tender to the “best provider” regardless of their location, taking into account factors including price, quality and financing, and that the process was supported by an oversight committee.

“It’s a miracle that María Teresa has continued reporting in a state totally controlled by mafia politicians, where government publicity is disguised as journalism and independent reporters are isolated and punished, leaving the public with a huge black information hole,” said Marcela Turati, co-founder of investigative news site Quinto Elemento Lab. “The violence continues because impunity is guaranteed.”

Reporting team, María Teresa Montaño Delgado (El Observador), Lilia Saúl Rodríguez (OCCRP) and Nina Lakhani. Additional reporting by Aïda Delpuech and Paloma Dupont de Dinechin (Forbidden Stories)
China’s 11.6m graduates face a jobs market with no jobs

With youth unemployment at a record high, the problem of overeducated young people is acute


Amy Hawkins Senior China correspondent
THE GUARDIAN
Thu 1 Jun 2023

With a master’s degree in applied linguistics from one of Australia’s top universities, Ingrid Xie did not expect to end up working in a grocery store. But that was where she ended up after graduating from the University of Queensland in July last year.

Xie did her undergraduate degree in China, studying English in the shade of palm trees at Hainan Tropical Ocean University. She went abroad for her master’s because she thought that would help her find a better job.

‘The last generation’: the young Chinese people vowing not to have children


But after working at a Korean supermarket in Brisbane for several months after graduating, in February she decided to return to her home city of Kunming, in the south-west province of Yunnan, to find a job as an English teacher.

Xie soon discovered that “a lot of people studied abroad and want the same thing”. She says a friend in the same city recently sat an English teacher recruitment test, along with about 100 other people. Her friend did not get the job.

Youth unemployment in China hit a record high in April, with 20.4% of 16- to 24-year-old jobseekers unable to find work. Xie is 26 and has not managed to find a job in China since leaving higher education. “It makes me really frustrated,” she says.

Nearly 11.6 million students are set to graduate in June, facing a labour market that looks increasingly hostile.

The problem of overeducated unemployed youths has become so acute that people have started comparing themselves to Kong Yiji, a fictional character from a story by Lu Xun, one of the greats of Chinese literature. Kong is a scholar turned beggar who is mocked by the locals at a tavern he drinks at for his pretentious airs.
Graduates look for work at a jobs fair in Haikou, Hainan province. Photograph: Shutterstock

State media has criticised these memes, accusing them of being self-indulgent. In March a commentary in state media said youths were “unwilling to engage in jobs that are lower than their expectations”.

China’s economy is suffering from a mismatch between the jobs available and the qualifications of jobseekers. Between 2018 and 2021 the number of graduates majoring in sports and education increased by more than 20%, according to Goldman Sachs.

But in 2021 the government suddenly banned for-profit tutoring, decimating an industry that had previously been worth $150bn. That eased the homework burden for schoolchildren but torpedoed jobs for young graduates, including Xie, who had previously looked at tutoring as a way of getting teaching experience.

The country is also struggling to fill jobs in the right places. Xie has seen job advertisements that require the teacher to work in a rural school for a year. “I don’t like [the idea of] teaching in a rural area as it is hard to survive in that environment, especially for girls,” she says.
A queue at a graduate jobs fair at Jianghan University in Wuhan, Hubei province, China, in April. Photograph: Shutterstock

Eric Fish, the author of a book about Chinese millennials, says the value of an international degree has diminished in China’s jobs markets. “Some recruiters think that students might have inflated expectations or are too westernised.”


China overtakes US in contributions to nature and science journals

The government is aware of the problem. In April it published details of a set of policies designed to stimulate the jobs market, including subsidies for companies that hire unemployed university graduates. The government wants state-owned enterprises to recruit 1 million trainees in 2023, and has set an overall target of creating 12m urban jobs this year, up from 11m in 2022.

This year the government also abandoned the use of the employment and registration certificate, a document that was used for decades to approve a graduate’s transfer from a university to an employer.

Although the certificate was mostly a bureaucratic relic, its cancellation would “make it more convenient for college graduates to seek employment”, the ministry of human resources and social security said in a notice on 12 May.

China is not alone in struggling to rebalance its economy after being battered by the Covid pandemic. Researchers at Goldman Sachs noted that in 2021 youth unemployment in several European countries was more than 20%, while in the US it was close to 10%.

But the dearth of opportunities also creates pressure to take any job regardless of interest, says Xie. “You don’t even know what you want to do when you’re 25.” For now she is resigned to spending a long time with her parents and looking after her cat, Shrimp. “What I’m looking for is enough private time and a job with work-life balance but I can’t find that.”

Additional research by Chi Hui Lin
ANOTHER STUPID SELFIE STORY
Indian official fined after draining reservoir in search of mobile phone

Rajesh Vishwas dropped phone into Paraklot reservoir in Chhattisgarh state while taking a selfie

Hannah Ellis-Petersen in Delhi
THE GUARDIAN
Wed 31 May 2023 

An Indian official who drained a reservoir to retrieve a mobile he dropped while taking a selfie has been fined 53,092 rupees (£520) by the government.

Rajesh Vishwas, a food inspector, had dropped his new phone worth about £1,000 into the Paralkot reservoir in Chhattisgarh state while taking a selfie during a picnic and swim with friends.

Local people spent two days attempting to dive down and retrieve the phone from the water, but their efforts proved futile. So Vishwas hired a diesel pump and emptied the reservoir of millions of litres of water.

Vishwas claimed his phone contained sensitive government information, which was why it needed to be retrieved, and alleged he had been given “verbal permission” to pump out the water into a nearby canal by the water resources department.

The water resources department later stated it had given permission for a few feet to be drained but “not that much”.


Indian official suspended after draining reservoir to retrieve phone

Though Vishwas eventually did manage to find the phone, his efforts made local headlines and then gradually went viral. He was accused of misusing his position and triggered outrage at the scale of wasted water, which is a scarce and valuable resource in India during the hot summer months and was used locally from the reservoir by farmers to irrigate their fields.

His actions landed him in hot water with government officials. Vishwas claimed they had been “overblown”, but he was suspended from his job and put under investigation by the state authorities.

This week he was given a total fine of 53,092 rupees by the state’s irrigation department, which accused him of wasting 4.1m litres of water. His actions were described as illegal and he was told to pay a fine of 10,000 rupees as well as an additional 43,092 rupees to cover the cost of the wasted water.

Meanwhile, after three days at the bottom of the reservoir, Vishwas’s phone proved broken beyond repair.

HOLLOYWOOD BABALON;SCIENTOLOGY
Danny Masterson, star of That ’70s Show, found guilty of rape
The charges against Danny Masterson date to a period when he was at the height of his fame, starring from 1998 until 2006 as Steven Hyde on Fox’s That ‘70s Show.The charges against Danny Masterson date to a period when he was at the height of his fame, starring from 1998 until 2006 as Steven Hyde on Fox’s That ‘70s Show. Photograph: Chris Delmas/AFP/Getty Images

47-year-old actor, who allegedly drugged women’s drinks, faces up to 30 years in prison after jury finds him guilty

Associated Press
Wed 31 May 2023 

Danny Masterson, the actor best known for his role in That ’70s Show, was found guilty of two counts of rape on Wednesday in a Los Angeles retrial in which the Church of Scientology played a central role.

The jury of seven women and five men reached the verdict after deliberating for seven days spread over two weeks. They could not reach a verdict on the third count, that alleged Masterson raped a longtime girlfriend. They had voted 8-4 in favor of conviction.

Masterson was led from the courtroom in handcuffs. The 47-year-old actor faces up to 30 years in prison.

His wife, actor and model Bijou Phillips, wept as he was led away. Other family and friends sat stone-faced.

Prosecutors, retrying Masterson after a deadlocked jury led to a mistrial in December, said he forcibly raped three women, including a longtime girlfriend, in his Hollywood Hills home between 2001 and 2003. They told jurors he drugged the women’s drinks so he could rape them. They said he used his prominence in the church – where all three women were also members at the time – to avoid consequences for decades.

Masterson did not testify, and his lawyers called no witnesses. The defense argued that the acts were consensual, and attempted to discredit the women’s stories by highlighting changes and inconsistencies over time, which they said showed signs of coordination between them.

“If you decide that a witness deliberately lied about something in this case,” defense attorney Philip Cohen told jurors, “you should consider not believing anything that witness says.”

The Church of Scientology played a significant role in the first trial but arguably an even larger one in the second. Judge Charlaine F Olmedo allowed expert testimony on church policy from a former official in Scientology leadership who has become a prominent opponent.

Tensions ran high in the courtroom between current and former Scientologists, and even leaked into testimony, with the accusers saying on the stand that they felt intimidated by some members in the room.

Actor Leah Remini, a former member who has become the church’s highest-profile critic, sat in on the trial at times, putting her arm around one of the accusers to comfort her during closing arguments.


Founded in 1953 by L Ron Hubbard, the Church of Scientology has many members who work in Hollywood. The judge kept limits on how much prosecutors could talk about the church, and primarily allowed it to explain why the women took so long to go to authorities.

The women testified that when they reported Masterson to church officials, they were told they were not raped, were put through ethics programs themselves, and were warned against going to law enforcement to report a member of such high standing.

“They were raped, they were punished for it, and they were retaliated against,” the deputy district attorney, Reinhold Mueller, told jurors in his closing argument. “Scientology told them there’s no justice for them. You have the opportunity to show them there is justice.”

The church vehemently denied having any policy that forbids members from going to secular authorities.

Testimony in this case was graphic and emotional. Two women, who knew Masterson from social circles in the church, said he gave them drinks and that they then became woozy or passed out before he violently raped them in 2003.

The third, Masterson’s then-girlfriend of five years, said she awoke to find him raping her, and had to pull his hair to stop him.

The issue of drugging also played a major role in the retrial. At the first, Olmedo only allowed prosecutors and accusers to describe their disorientation, and to imply that they were drugged. The second time, they were allowed to argue it directly, and the prosecution attempted to make it a major factor, to no avail.

“The defendant drugs his victims to gain control,” said the deputy district attorney, Ariel Anson, in her closing argument. “He does this to take away his victims’ ability to consent.”

Masterson was not charged with any counts of drugging, and there is no toxicology evidence to back up the assertion. His attorney asked for a mistrial over the issue’s inclusion. The motion was denied, but the issue is likely to be a major factor in any potential appeal.

These charges date to a period when Masterson was at the height of his fame, starring from 1998 until 2006 as Steven Hyde on Fox’s That ’70s Show – the show that made stars of Ashton Kutcher, Mila Kunis and Topher Grace.

Masterson had reunited with Kutcher on the 2016 Netflix comedy The Ranch, but was written off the show when an LAPD investigation was revealed in December 2017.

Information and support for anyone affected by rape or sexual abuse issues is available from the following organisations. In the US, Rainn offers support on 800-656-4673. In the UK, Rape Crisis offers support on 0808 500 2222. In Australia, support is available at 1800Respect (1800 737 732). Other international helplines can be found at ibiblio.org/rcip/internl.html
CRIMINAL CAPITALI$M
‘People wanted to believe the fairytale’: the downfall of Elizabeth Holmes
Elizabeth Holmes, founder and CEO of Theranos.Elizabeth Holmes, founder and CEO of Theranos. Photograph: Jeff Chiu/AP

Disgraced founder of fraudulent blood-testing company Theranos begins prison sentence

Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes begins 11-year sentence

Kari Paul in San Francisco
THE GUARDIAN
Tue 30 May 2023

Elizabeth Holmes has begun her prison sentence, in a remarkable fall for a startup founder who had become an icon known far outside Silicon Valley.

Holmes, 39, had once promised to revolutionize the medical world, but was convicted in January 2022 on four counts of defrauding investors in her blood-testing company, Theranos.


Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes turns herself in for 11-year prison term

It was a stunning turn for an entrepreneur who had once riveted the tech world. Holmes dropped out of Stanford University in 2003 at the age of 19, set on developing a company that would turn upside down the field of medical diagnostics.

She had filed a patent for a technology that aimed to perform a wide range of tests on a small amount of blood, a development that would eliminate the need for large blood samples for diagnostics.

For years, Theranos operated in stealth mode. But by 2013, it started attracting widespread attention and Holmes became a media darling, easily recognizable with her distinctive blond hair, black turtlenecks and husky voice.

“Here was a photogenic, telegenic young woman posing as the female Steve Jobs,” Margaret O’Mara, a historian of Silicon Valley who holds a professorship at the University of Washington, said ahead of Holmes’s trial. “It was an incredibly alluring narrative that everyone wanted to believe.”

“Holmes was going to be the first woman who reached billionaire status and join the pantheon of tech leaders,” said John Carreyrou, the Wall Street Journal reporter whose investigation into the company was key to exposing its lies. “People were really rooting for her – young girls were writing her letters. A lot of people wanted to believe the fairytale, because it would have represented real progress in a very male-dominated world of Silicon Valley.”

Led by Holmes and her co-executive, and former romantic partner, Sunny Balwani, Theranos would end up raising hundreds of millions of dollars from investors. Big-name board members, including the former US secretary of defense James Mattis and former US secretaries of state George Shultz and Henry Kissinger, gave the company an air of legitimacy, even though behind the scenes it had little scientific proof to show for its claims. Theranos and Walgreens cut a major deal to distribute the company’s testing devices in pharmacies across the US.

At its height, Theranos was valued at more than $9bn and Holmes became the world’s youngest female self-made billionaire in 2015. That same year, however, the fairytale would start to fall apart.

It began with a 2015 article by Carreyrou that revealed Theranos’s revolutionary technology wasn’t exactly what it seemed. Over the succeeding months, Carreyrou exposed how the testing devices Holmes said could perform a variety of medical tests with just a drop of blood were not actually being used to perform most of the analyses.

After scrutiny from regulators, Theranos started to retract its tests and recall its machines. Holmes stepped down as CEO in June 2018, with the company dissolving that same year.

Holmes settled with the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), which accused her of an “elaborate, years-long fraud”. But the US government charged Holmes and Balwani with defrauding both investors and patients, and making false claims about the effectiveness of the company’s technology.

Delayed by the pandemic and the birth of Holmes’s first child, the media-hyped trial kicked off in August 2021. It would last four months, with the jury in the San Jose courtroom hearing testimony from former employees, investors like Mattis and Holmes herself.

In her testimony, Holmes argued she understood Theranos’s technology to be more accurate than it was and her defense team portrayed her as under the influence of Balwani.

Still, the jury convicted her of four counts of defrauding investors, and in November 2022 she was sentenced to serve more than 11 years in prison.

Holmes’s conviction was a crucial moment in Silicon Valley, the central hub of an industry where the ethos of “fake it till you make it” has reigned for years.

The Silicon Valley investor Jason Calacanis, who was an early backer of major firms like Uber and Robinhood, said the verdict was a “reminder to founders”.

“Never lie, never bend the truth, always be honest about where you are at with your traction, especially when raising money,” he tweeted.

It was also an important moment for workers in the sector. Several former Theranos employees testified during the trial they had long suspected the company could not deliver on its promises, but felt they could not raise questions and risked being sued if they spoke out.

Holmes had been out on bail since she was indicted, and after her sentencing had unsuccessfully argued she should be able to remain out of custody while she sought a new trial.

In her last weeks of freedom, she broke her media silence with an extensive profile in the New York Times about her time at Theranos, her mistakes as an entrepreneur, and her life as a mother and partner to her husband, Billy Evans.

Holmes is serving her sentence at the federal prison camp Bryan, a minimum-security facility in Texas. Under federal law, she’s required to serve 85% of her sentence, even if it is reduced for good conduct. She faces three years of supervised release after her sentence ends and has been ordered to pay $452m in restitution to victims of the fraud.

Bryan prison houses primarily white-collar and non-violent female prisoners, and lacks the fencing and strict rules of higher-security prisons. It is a work-focused program that requires all inmates to hold a job for a minimum of 90 days.
30 YEARS LATER
Thelma and Louise review – punchier, bolder, hotter and sweatier than ever
Susan Sarandon and Geena Davis in Thelma and Louise.Still has the power to stun … Susan Sarandon and Geena Davis in Thelma and Louise. Photograph: Snap/Rex Features

Callie Khouri’s feminist crime classic is a masterclass in narrative and character development and director Ridley Scott delivers pure action brio

Review
FIVE OUT OF FIVE STARS
Peter Bradshaw
THE GUARDIAN
Wed@ 31 May 2023

Screenwriter Callie Khouri’s desperada road-movie thriller Thelma & Louise is the classic whose Bechdel test credentials go all the way up to the title. Just over 30 years later, it looks punchier, bolder, hotter and sweatier than ever. This is a masterclass in narrative construction and character development and director Ridley Scott puts his pedal to the metal with pure action brio; I always particularly love the shot where the camera lovingly counter-swooshes back along the flank of the Thunderbird while it barrels down the highway, for the pure hell of it. It is a feminist crime classic in the tradition of Gun Crazy and Bonnie and Clyde, whose two heroines, played by Geena Davis and Susan Sarandon, get the Polaroid camera out for the most famous selfie in film history. And that ending – although arguably a concession to the idea of crime not being allowed to pay – still has the power to stun.

The film is the story of two friends. Louise Sawyer (Sarandon) is a worldly wise woman waiting tables in a diner in Arkansas, whose supposed boyfriend, Jimmy (Michael Madsen) never seems to be around. Louise’s younger best friend is housewife Thelma Dickinson, a role in which Davis gave a wonderfully sweet-natured, innocent, vulnerable performance; it briefly made her an A-list star and we should have a twinge of regret thinking about the roles Davis should have been offered after this. Thelma is being bullied and cheated on by her boorish husband Darryl (Christopher McDonald) and longs for some escape. Then Louise offers her a special girls-only weekend break in a fishing cabin she’s managed to borrow – just the two of them, taking off for some fun in Louise’s sleek T-Bird.

The pair stop off for drinks at a roadhouse where Thelma dances and then goes outside with a creep who tries to rape her. Louise pulls a gun on him in the parking lot, and the chilling ruthlessness of the result, still startling even now, turns the two women into fugitives from the law. But the experience makes them more alive and wide-awake than they have been in their lives. Harvey Keitel is the kindly state cop who tries to get Thelma and Louise to turn themselves in peaceably, and Brad Pitt made his debut as the sweet-talking young rascal for whom Thelma briefly falls, but who turns out to be (almost) as bad as the rest of the menfolk.

Essentially Thelma & Louise is a rape-revenge film, and Khouri and Scott adroitly show you that the rape that it is a revenge for happened a long time before this story started: the gunshot discharges the backstory’s pent-up frustration and rage. Another writer might have given us a set-piece reminiscence making everything explicit, or even a flashback; Khouri gives us just a glancing line in the dialogue, a bitter joke about why Louise never goes to Texas any more. The movie gives us just motivation in the tank and keeps the momentum going.

There are so many great moments. Louise seeing what appears at first to be a freckle in the bathroom mirror – but is in fact blood, which she fiercely wipes away. We get some great comedy when Thelma tells Louise to shoot the cop’s radio, and poor innocent Louise thinks she means the radio he’s listening to music on. And then there’s the outrageous action-movie explosion provided by the two heroines symbolically shooting the odious truck-driver’s phallically shaped lorry by the roadside with its flammable load.

It all leads up to the Butch and Sundance finale in the Grand Canyon; perhaps tougher and more shocking than Butch and Sundance in that there is no escape into ambiguity. A warm welcome back to this great popular film.

Thelma and Louise is released on 2 June in UK cinemas, and is screening now in select Australian cinemas.
Kosovo: ‘fascist mobs’ guided by Serbia causing violence, says country’s PM
A soldier from the Austrian contingent of the Nato-led international peacekeeping force in Kosovo sets up a razor wire fence in front of a municipal building in Zvecan, Kosovo, on Wednesday,A soldier from the Nato-led peacekeeping force in Kosovo sets up a razor wire fence in front of a municipal building in Zvecan, Kosovo, on Wednesday. Photograph: Georgi Licovski/EPA

More than 30 Nato peacekeeping soldiers were injured in clashes on Monday after ethnic Albanian mayors took office


Shaun Walker in Bratislava and Lorenzo Tondo
THE GUARDIAN
Tue 30 May 2023 

Kosovo’s prime minister has blamed violence in the north of the country on “fascist mobs” controlled by the government of neighbouring Serbia, and said he had rejected a US request to relocate recently installed mayors out of their official offices.

More than 30 Nato peacekeeping soldiers were injured in clashes on Monday, prompting the alliance to announce it would send another 700 troops to the country. Serbia’s president Aleksandar Vučić put his country’s army on high combat alert.

The Nato peacekeeping mission, Kfor, said Italian and Hungarian peacekeepers were subjected to “unprovoked attacks and sustained trauma wounds with fractures and burns due to the explosion of incendiary devices”.


Kosovo clashes: Nato commander criticises ‘unacceptable’ attacks on troops

“Yesterday was very severe, we were very lucky that no life was lost,” Kosovo prime minister Albin Kurti told the Guardian by telephone from Pristina on Tuesday. He said “several” Nato peacekeepers were still in hospital.

Italy’s prime minister, Giorgia Meloni, called the attacks “unacceptable and irresponsible”.

The violence came after ethnic Albanian mayors took office in Serb-majority areas of northern Kosovo, after elections in April which Serbs boycotted. Kurti blamed Belgrade for orchestrating the boycott, which led to an extremely low turnout.


00:50Kosovo: Serb protesters throw teargas at Nato soldiers as internal frictions escalate – video

The area’s majority Serbs have never accepted Kosovo’s 2008 declaration of independence from Serbia, and consider Belgrade their capital more than two decades after the Kosovo Albanian uprising against repressive Serbian rule.

Ethnic Albanians make up more than 90% of the population in Kosovo, but northern Serbs have long demanded the implementation of an EU-brokered 2013 deal for the creation of an association of autonomous municipalities in their area.

The violence has been widely condemned, but western allies of Kosovo have also sharply criticised the government in Pristina for the decision to install the mayors.

On Friday, the US secretary of state, Antony Blinken, issued an unusually strong rebuke to a US ally, saying the decision to use force to access municipal buildings in the north had been taken “against the advice” of the US and European partners and had “sharply and unnecessarily escalated tensions”.

Kurti expressed his displeasure at the statement, calling it “appeasement” of Vučić.

“I think it’s not just unfair and wrong and hurtful but at the same time very naive,” said Kurti, speaking to the Guardian by telephone from Pristina. “Perhaps secretary Blinken will explain this further one day, but definitely it was not helpful.”


Since then, Kurti said he had spoken to Gabriel Escobar, the US special envoy for the Balkans. He said Escobar had asked the Kosovan authorities to move the mayors to different premises, or to have them work from home, a request he had rejected.

“We cannot have Zoom mayors, we are a democratic republic,” said Kurti. “A democratic republic cannot surrender to fascist militia,” he added.

In a sign of how much the recent events have damaged the relationship between Washington and Pristina, the US ambassador to Kosovo, Jeff Hovenier, told the Financial Times on Tuesday that the US will cancel joint military drills with Kosovo and put diplomatic meetings on hold.

“I would be surprised if, in this situation, Kosovo officials would visit the US,” Hovenier said.

Kurti insisted that the new mayors would continue to work from municipal offices.

“These are administrative, technical mayors who are necessary for smooth functioning of municipalities … I acknowledge that the political legitimacy of these mayors is low, however the legitimacy of others is zero,” he said.

Kosovo has been backed strongly by the west, but non-recognition by Russia, China and even five of the 27 EU nations has meant it has not been able to take up a seat at the UN or most other international organisations.

A deal signed earlier this year, mediated by the EU, foresaw Kosovo granting rights to Serb municipalities in the north and Belgrade agreeing to Kosovo’s accession to international institutions, but the recent violence shows that there is still a long way to go to implement the agreement.

On Tuesday, the Nato secretary general, Jens Stoltenberg, told a press conference in Oslo that the alliance would send additional troops to Kosovo.

“We have decided to deploy 700 more troops from the operational reserve force for western Balkans and to put an additional battalion of reserve forces on high alertness so they can also be deployed if needed,” he said.

‘Unprecedented’ Nova Scotia wildfires expected to worsen, officials war

More than 18,000 people remain under evacuation order outside Halifax as Canadian PM Justin Trudeau pledges federal assistance

Smoke rises from a wildfire near Barrington Lake in Nova Scotia's Shelburne county.
 Photograph: Nova Scotia Government/AFP/Getty Images

Leyland Cecco in Toronto
THE GUARDIAN
Wed 31 May 2023 
Officials in the province of Nova Scotia say unprecedented wildfires that have forced thousands from their homes will keep growing despite the “water, raw muscle power and air power” deployed by fire crews.

As of Wednesday, more than 20,000 hectares of the Maritime province were burning from 13 wildfires, including three fires that considered out of control. More than 18,000 people remain under evacuation order outside Halifax, the region’s largest city. More than 200 structures, the majority of which are homes, have been destroyed by the fire. No fatalities have been recorded.

‘Like Nagasaki’: devastating wildfires will only get worse, new book warns


Hot, dry and windy conditions have seen the fire near the community of Tantallon grow to 837 hectares. Temperatures are expected to hit more than 30C this week, giving little respite to fatigued crews.

“Today could possibility be a very difficult day,” David Steeves of the Nova Scotia Department of Natural Resources told reporters. “Today could be a day that is very dangerous for the folks on the ground.”

Dave Meldrum, deputy chief of Halifax regional fire and emergency, said exhausted crews have been using “water, raw muscle power and air power” to fight the blazes since Sunday, using three helicopters and fire fighters from the city, province and department of national defence. Even after four days, the fires remains out of control.

For a province that typically measures the total amount of the region burned in hundreds of hectares, the record-breaking Barrington Lake blaze, stretching more than 20,000 hectares and still growing, has pushed Nova Scotia’s scarce resources to the brink. The largest ever fire recorded in Nova Scotia was in 1976 and measured 13,000 hectares.

“We’ve got more fires than we have resources to support them,” Scott Tingley, manager of forest protection at Nova Scotia’s department of natural resources, said during a news conference, adding the province is prioritizing safety and human life ahead of infrastructure.
Firefighters with Halifax regional fire and emergency work to put out fires in the Tantallon area of Nova Scotia. 
Photograph: Nova Scotia Government/AFP/Getty Images

The prime minister, Justin Trudeau, said images of people fleeing their homes are “heartbreaking” and pledged federal assistance.

On Tuesday, the Nova Scotia premier, Tim Houston, announced a ban on all activity in the province’s forests, including hiking, camping, fishing, hunting, the use of off-highway vehicles and logging after six illegal burns were reported on Monday evening.

“For God’s sake, stop burning. Stop flicking cigarette butts out of the car window. Just stop it. Our resources are stretched incredibly thin right now fighting existing fires,” Houston said. “This is absolutely ridiculous with what’s happening in this province … It’s mind-boggling.”

On Wednesday, the province’s natural resources minister said the conditions Nova Scotia in are “unprecedented” and expected to worsen.

“Everything lined up for a perfect storm, if you will,” Tory Rushton told the CBC. “The dry winter, dry spring, perfectly warm breeze and warm weather in the spring has certainly not helped our province at all with this fire season.”

He said Barrington Lake fire had so far destroyed 40 structures, but added the size and speed of the fire made it difficult for officials to gauge the true scope of damage.

Officials are hopeful that rains forecast for the weekend will slow the largest fires and give crews a better chance at controlling the blazes.
AUSTRALIA

AFL Players Association criticises league’s handling of Hawthorn racism allegations
Hawthorn president Andy Gowers speaks to the media at Waverley Park in Melbourne.Hawthorn president Andy Gowers speaks to the media at Waverley Park in Melbourne. Photograph: Robert Cianflone/Getty Images

CEO says ‘flawed’ process could prevent people speaking out

Investigation closed as Hawks hope to avoid AFL sanctions


Nino Bucci
THE GUARDIAN AUSTRALIA
Wed 31 May 2023 

The AFL Players Association has criticised the league for its “flawed” process of investigating allegations of racism at Hawthorn, saying it could make people hesitant to report concerns in future.

In a statement the AFLPA’s chief executive, Paul Marsh, said it had “serious concerns about the AFL’s process” which was “not truly independent”.

“The allegations raised by players and their families as part of Hawthorn’s Binmada Report were extremely serious and disturbing in nature and required an independent, wide-ranging, well-resourced and culturally safe process,” Marsh said.

He said the issue “presents the industry with an urgent need to reflect on whether the right industry-wide reporting systems, commitments and levels of accountability exist to ensure this does not happen again”.


Hawthorn racism review: ‘no adverse findings’ against trio as AFL inquiry ends


The AFLPA has proposed a human rights policy and framework to the league as part of ongoing collective bargaining agreement negotiations.

“Until this work is done, we hold considerable fears that players and other members of our industry who suffer racism, sexism or other forms of exclusion or discrimination will be hesitant to raise concerns or share their experiences,” Marsh said.

The Hawthorn president, Andy Gowers, has admitted that closing the investigation into alleged racism within the AFL club does not represent a “total resolution” of the matter, and said he hoped the league would not go on to sanction the club.

Gowers spoke to media on Wednesday morning, after the AFL revealed that an independent panel would make no adverse findings against the three former Hawthorn staff who were linked to the allegations: Alastair Clarkson, Chris Fagan and Jason Burt. All three have strongly denied any wrongdoing.

“The announcement last night by the AFL, in one sense, is a step towards a resolution, a broader resolution, but it’s only one part of it, because it only involves the players,” Gowers said.

“A final resolution will involve us, the AFL and also our former staff on top of that. So there’s mixed emotions. Because although it was a resolution for one or two parties in a sense, it’s not total resolution and we’re not able to move on completely.”

The AFL is still considering sanctions against Hawthorn for any potential breaches of AFL rules in relation to the allegations.

Gowers said that in a “perfect world” the club would not be sanctioned, with penalties including fines or the stripping of draft picks among the options reportedly being considered.

“We’re disappointed that this is the nature of the discussion. We went into this with the best of intentions. Where it ended up, no one is happy about. That’s clear,” he said.

“But the dialogue between all parties has not been able to happen to this point. We would welcome that and we think that that is an opportunity for people to be heard, to tell their truth and to heal, as I said before.”

Gowers expressed regret that the former First Nations players and staff had all been unable to speak to the club about their version of events. But he agreed with sentiments expressed multiple times by AFL chief executive Gillon McLachlan on Tuesday night that the way in which the report was made public influenced the club’s ability to be able to do this properly.


How the Hawthorn racism inquiry became an interminable mess where everyone loses

“As Gil said last night, it was leaked and that blew everything up,” Gowers said.

In April 2022, the Age reported multiple concerns the former Hawk Cyril Rioli and his wife Shannyn Ah Sam-Rioli had regarding the player’s time at the club.

The club asked the former AFL player Phil Egan to investigate its history. The terms of reference, according to the report, included to “listen and learn from the experiences of players and staff”, understand whether any of these people needed ongoing support provided by the club, and review its current practices to ensure it had a supportive environment for players and coaches.

Egan then went about speaking to current and former First Nations players and staff, saying 23 people were identified and 17 were spoken to.

In August 2022, Egan completed the report, also known as the Binmada report, which outlined a series of serious allegations.

It is unclear when the report was provided to Hawthorn.

But in late September 2022, the ABC revealed details of the contents of the report, and separately spoke with the families of three First Nations players.


Gowers said on Wednesday that he did not know where the leak came from but that he was not aware of a suggestion it came from Hawthorn.

He conceded that it would have been “preferable” for the former coaches to have been spoken to, but that, under AFL rules, once the Egan report was received by the club it had to provide it to the AFL’s integrity unit.

Gowers also made clear he was aware that the matter was far from over, with the AFL-backed independent investigation already taking eight months and having not publicly released a report on its findings.

He would not be drawn on other possible consequences facing the club, apart from his comments regarding AFL sanctions, with civil court action and human rights complaints also reportedly being considered by former players.

‘Insulted, humiliated, hunted’: plight of migrants as slums razed in French territory of Mayotte
The shantytown Talus 2 is demolished on the French Indian Ocean island of Mayotte as part of operation ‘take back’ to deport undeclared migrants, 22 May 2023. Photograph: Philippe Lopez/AFP/Getty Images

As the first shantytown falls to the bulldozer under France’s operation ‘take back’, people on the Indian Ocean island tell of living in constant fear

Meerie Jesuthasan in Marseille
THE GUARDIAN
Wed 31 May 2023
 
It took less than 24 hours to raze the shantytown of Talus 2 on the French Indian Ocean island of Mayotte. France’s Operation Wuambushu (“take back”) began on Monday last week in its overseas territory, between Madagascar and Mozambique, with a dozen excavators and trucks carrying police officers. By Tuesday 23 May, most of the neighbourhood’s 162 informal homes had been destroyed, leaving hundreds of people without shelter.

Details of the operation were revealed in February as President Emmanuel Macron approved sending 510 additional French police officers to Mayotte with the aim of fighting “gangs, substandard housing and irregular immigration”.

Backed by far-right collectives and elected officials in Mayotte, the Macron government has begun waging a tough battle on the island.

Already, police have been using live rounds and arresting young people alleged to be involved in criminal gangs. The government reportedly aims to deport between 10,000 and 20,000 undocumented people (310,000 people live in Mayotte, an estimated half of whom are foreigners), and to destroy 1,000 bangas, or informal housing, in slums where 40% of the island’s inhabitants live.

Police perform identity checks and unannounced house raids in the name of controlling migrants on Mayotte.
 Photograph: Patrick Meinhardt/AFP/Getty Images


Undocumented immigrants will be sent to the state of Comoros, comprising three of the four islands in the archipelago that includes Mayotte, and where many of the undocumented originated.

Wuambushu, officially announced in April, has revived debate on Mayotte, the poorest department in France, where most deportations on the entire French territory occur.

Residents say the operation has brought a climate of fear that has crystallised into violent anti-Comoran sentiment. On 24 April, the initial intended start date of the operation, Salime Mdéré, vice-president of the departmental council of Mayotte, talked about “thug” and “terrorist” Comoran youths on evening television. “It might be necessary to kill some of them,” he said. “I’m weighing my words.”
I’m not going to wait for the authorities to arrest me. I failed. I didn’t get my papersOcéane, undocumented resident

The operation faced delays: a judge suspended the demolition of Talus 2 on 24 April, citing a lack of housing solutions for evicted families, while the Comoran government initially refused to accept deportees. But in mid-May, the prefecture successfully appealed against the court’s decision, and the Comoran port reopened to Mayotte’s boats after the Comoran president visited France.

In the meantime, police continued an anti-delinquency operation, arresting suspected gang members in violent clashes. At least one teenager, who claimed not to have been involved in crime, was shot.

A woman confronts a French gendarme during the demolition of an informal settlement in Longoni, Mamoudzou, 17 April. 
Photograph: Patrick Meinhardt/AFP/Getty Images

For those without papers, it is an intensification of a “hunt for the undocumented” that has existed for decades. Océane*, 37, who has two young children and has lived in Mayotte since leaving the Comoro island of Anjouan in 2015 , has no legal status and says her landlord has told them to leave due to the operation. She left a violent situation at home, but is now contemplating going back.


“I’m not going to wait for the authorities to arrest me,” she says. “I failed. I didn’t get my papers.”

Many cross the 70km channel between the islands for healthcare unavailable in the Comoros. But while Mayotte benefits from resources due to its status as a European region, it suffers from its best medical staff leaving to work in France.

Océane says her ordeal didn’t begin with Wuambushu. “Everywhere I moved, I had to hide because there was the police, or Mahorans, who would come and report you,” she says.

Police presence is heavy in Mayotte, where numerous legal exceptions made in the name of controlling migrants have meant identity checks based on profiling, and routine unannounced police raids on people’s homes. It has, in effect, turned the territory into a police state, say human rights groups such as La Cimade.
Gendarmes patrol the streets after clashes ahead of planned evictions in Majicavo village in Mayotte’s Koungou commune on 25 April. 
Photograph: Chafion Madi/AFP/Getty Images


Océane says she regularly has to go through fields to take her daughter to school undetected, or hide out with neighbours when she hears the police are circling. The Mamoudzou hospital refused to give her son a birth certificate when he was born in 2018, making it impossible to sign him up for school.

Océane says those who told her landlord to evict her were not police but members of citizen collectives. Such groups have been holding pro-Wuambushu rallies, blocking hospitals that treat foreigners, and threatening to block ports if Comoros-bound ships don’t take undocumented migrants. This is similar to the xenophobic evictions in 2016, when collectives went door-to-door, searching for foreigners.
Don’t forget to bring your children with you. They are part of your luggageA flyer ordering foreigners to leave

This month, a flyer was distributed in the village of Hagnoundrou, ordering all foreigners to leave. “Don’t forget to bring your children with you,” it read. “They are part of your luggage.”

Collectives have strong links to the islands’ political elite: a former president of one is Estelle Youssouffa, the Mahoran deputy in the National Assembly since 2022. She has previously said that small boat factories in the Comoros should be bombed to stop migrants.
A pro-Wuambushu rally at a football stadium in Chirongui, Mayotte. Such groups have also blocked hospitals that treat foreigners. 
Photograph: Gregoire Merot/AP

Like Mdere, many blame Comoran youth for violence on the island and claim that Wuambushu will combat insecurity. Gang rivalries have led to violence in the past – last November, clashes resulted in several deaths.

French interior minister Gérald Darmanin, who sent an anti-terrorism police unit to contain the clashes, has repeatedly emphasised the anti-delinquent aspect of the operation. “There is a situation of serious delinquency, and we must respond with firmness,” he said in an interview with Le Figaro.

Others point to a more complicated reality, saying the gangs include poor Mahorans. DSK*, who arrived in Mayotte from the Comoros as a child and is a member of La Cimade, says France is following inhumane policies on the island. He asked not to use his real name for fear of being targeted.

“Mayotte is not the same as France,” he says, listing numerous obstacles that foreign-born children face – from being barred from schools to being denied citizenship or separated from deported parents.

DSK, who works as a school bus driver and struggled to obtain his own papers, says he has seen the consequences first-hand. “Children as young as 10 have to rely on themselves to eat, to dress themselves, to house themselves, and there is no social welfare for these kids. These are monsters that we are creating.”


He says children ask him to drop them outside their homes to avoid being seen by police. Mayotte locks up a high number of undocumented children – in 2021, France detained 3,135 children in Mayotte.

Numbers indicate which buildings will be spared in the demolition of Talus 2 shantytown.
 Photograph: Morgan Fache/AFP/Getty Images

The operation has revived debates around French colonialism, specifically Mayotte’s status as a French department, made official in 2011. The Comoran archipelago fell under French colonial rule in the mid-19th century and voted overwhelmingly for independence from France in 1974, but Mayotte – representing 8% of the total electorate – was against. France held a second referendum in 1976, with similar results. The UN general assembly has condemned France’s presence in Mayotte.

Ties between the islands remain strong, most Comorans and Mahorans have family on both sides. Mayotte’s economy relies heavily on foreign labour, particularly in construction. “If Darmanin had a magic wand and could transfer all the populations back to their islands, the first effect would be to destroy the local economy,” said anthropologist Damien Riccio in an interview with Mediapart.

Some offer a political explanation for France’s actions, saying the government is trying to showcase its immigration offensive after forcing through an unpopular pension reform in April that triggered large-scale protests. Wuambushu has become a platform for Macron’s government to appear tough on immigration in the face of far-right figures such as Marine Le Pen, who claim it does not go far enough.
Migrants arrive in Mayotte after being intercepted by border police while sailing at night from Comoros.
 Photograph: Philippe Lopez/AFP/Getty Images

France has significant economic interests in the Mozambique channel, and Mayotte allows control in one of the largest maritime exclusive economic zones in the world. “France is only there to enrich itself, not to develop the island,” says DSK. “France doesn’t want the island or the island’s population – all it wants is the riches around it.”

Youssouffa has emphasised the region’s natural resources: “The Mozambique channel, where Mayotte is located, has significant gas reserves,” she said in a recent interview. “It’s important to let the entire regional gas and petrol ecosystem know that we have an interest in their working in our region, and that they must make particular efforts for security to stabilise that region.”

Meanwhile, deep divisions have been fostered between historically linked people. Océane says she doesn’t want to move back to Comoros, but has little choice.

“I don’t believe in the French Republic any more,” she says. “What do you want me to do, when I have kids and they didn’t even give one of them a birth certificate?

“France is destroying my kids’ future, and what do you want me to do, stay like this, and live a life of playing cat and mouse? To be discriminated against, insulted, humiliated everywhere I go? I can’t take it any more, my kids can’t take it.”

* Names have been changed