Tuesday, October 29, 2024

How harmful are microplastics to human health?

Isabelle Cortes
Tue 29 October 2024 

Scientists have discovered that microplastics not just throughout nature but also throughout human bodies (Ben Stansall) (Ben Stansall/AFP/AFP)

Microplastics have been found throughout the human body -- including inside lungs, blood and brains -- and while it is not yet clear how harmful they are to our health, some researchers are sounding the alarm.

These tiny pieces of plastic have been detected almost everywhere on Earth, from the deepest oceans to the highest mountains, as well as in the air, water, soil and food chain.

Every day humans ingest, inhale or otherwise come in contact with microplastics, which are less than five millimetres (0.2 inches) and mostly invisible to the naked eye.

"A human in 2024 has plastic in almost all the organs of their body," French specialist researcher Fabienne Lagarde recently told a hearing of France's parliament.

"And it will probably be even worse for the children born in 2040," she added.

Numerous studies have linked the presence of microplastics -- or nanoplastics which are 1,000 times smaller -- to a range of health problems.

In March, a study in the New England Journal of Medicine found an association between microplastics accumulating in people's blood vessels and an increased risk of heart attack, stroke or even early death.

- 'Red flag' -

"The body of research on microplastics is growing and it is already showing us that the health impacts are very concerning," said Tracey Woodruff, a researcher at the University of California, San Francisco.

Woodruff recently conducted a systematic review of 2,000 previous studies on animals, finding that microplastics "can harm fertility, are linked to increased cancer risk and can harm respiratory health," she told AFP.

It is a "red flag" that microplastics have been found in so many areas of the body "including the brain, testes and even crossing the placenta into the foetus," she added.

Many of the most worrying studies, such as the one from March, have been observational. This means they cannot prove microplastics are directly causing the health problems they have been linked to.

Others have been conducted in the lab, sometimes testing on animals, which some observers see as a limitation.

For the studies she reviewed, Woodruff said the biological systems of the animals were "quite similar to humans".

She added that "data from animals has been used to identify carcinogens and reproductive toxicants for decades."

Many things remain unknown about how microplastics could affect health, including the role played by their size, shape and composition.

Many plastics are a complex cocktail of polymers and chemicals, and there are fears they could smuggle in other contaminants in what is called the "Trojan Horse" effect.

- Plastic pollution treaty? -

Out of the more than 16,000 chemicals used or found in commercial plastic, more than a quarter are considered hazardous to human health, according to a group called the Scientists' Coalition for an Effective Plastics Treaty.

Linked health concerns include "infertility, obesity and non-communicable diseases including diabetes, cardiovascular disease and many cancers," the group said.

How damaging all this tiny plastic is to health also depends on how much humans are exposed to, which also remains unclear.

A report from the World Wildlife Fund made headlines in 2019 by estimating that people ingest around five grams of plastic a week, the equivalent of a credit card.

The methodology and results of the report have since been called into question, with numerous studies estimating lower levels of ingested plastic -- and showing that rates vary hugely across the world.

It is still early days for the field, with research into how microplastics impact health only beginning in the early 2000s.

"Despite the newness of the topic and the limitations that have been identified, the dangers linked to oral exposure and inhalation are there," Muriel Mercier-Bonin, a researcher at France's INRAE institute, told the French parliament.

And the problem is only growing. Plastic production has doubled in 20 years and at current rates could triple by 2060, according to the OECD.

The United Nations has agreed to work towards a world-first treaty to reduce plastic pollution, with negotiators meeting in a month for a final round of talks.

In the meantime, experts recommend people limit their exposure to microplastics by avoiding plastic bottles, not heating food in plastic containers, wearing clothes made of natural material and ventilating their home.

ic-dl/giv
Melbourne woman’s death after foraged mushroom dinner prompts coroner’s warning

Natasha May
Tue 29 October 2024 

Poisonous death cap (left) and yellow-staining mushrooms. In Victoria, wild mushrooms typically grow in autumn as weather grows wetter and cooler.
Photograph: Joel Carrett/AAP

A Melbourne woman has died after she and her son were poisoned by a homemade meal containing foraged mushrooms, prompting a warning from the coroner.

The 98-year-old woman, Loreta Maria Del Rossi, died in hospital on 22 May, seven days after eating the meal.

In the Victorian state coroner’s report released on Wednesday, Judge John Cain said Del Rossi died from multi-organ failure after poisoning from the toxins found in lethal “death cap” mushrooms (Amanita phalloides).

The death prompted Cain to call for an annual public health campaign about the dangers of consuming wild mushrooms – including how to identify and remove deadly fungi, and instructions for suspected poisoning.

Victoria’s health department warns people in the state not to pick and eat them “unless you are an expert”.

Related: The forager’s code: wild mushroom hunters urged to take a conscious, conservative approach

Del Rossi lived with her adult son, Nicola Del Rossi, in the eastern suburb of Bayswater, where, according to the report, she cooked with homegrown vegetables and was known to regularly collect wild edible grasses such as dandelion, milk thistle and cat’s ear.

Foraging is common in European countries including Italy, from where Del Rossi migrated with her son and daughter in 1955.

The report detailed that Del Rossi found wild mushrooms in the garden in April, and told her son that she would collect, clean and test them. They consumed the mushrooms in a meal of rice and tuna with no negative effects.

On 15 May, Del Rossi found more mushrooms growing in the same patch and prepared them in the same way for her son to cook for dinner.

After they both ate the meal and went to bed, Del Rossi began vomiting at 2am and her son became unwell at 6am. He called an ambulance and they were transported to hospital.

Del Rossi’s son survived, but her condition deteriorated despite aggressive treatments. She told staff she was in significant pain, and in line with her wishes, entered palliative care on 20 May.

The health department’s Better Health website, referenced in the coroner’s finding, warns poisonous mushrooms typically grow in Victoria in autumn.

It states the yellow-staining mushroom is the most commonly eaten poisonous mushroom in Victoria, and is, the coroner’s report noted, “often confused for edible mushrooms that can be purchased in supermarkets”.

“The death cap mushroom is usually whitish, yellow, pale brown or green in colour and often grows under oak trees,” the report said.

The estimated lethal dose of amatoxins in humans is 0.1 mg/kg. As such, the coroner’s report warned, a 50g mushroom could contain a potentially fatal quantity of anatoxins for a 70kg adult.
CLIMATE CHANGE CREATION

Taiwan battens down for Super Typhoon Kong-rey

Akio Wang with Joy Chiang in Taipei
Tue 29 October 2024 

A fisherman secures a boat as Typhoon Kong-rey approaches Taiwan's Yilan County on Wednesday (I-Hwa CHENG) (I-Hwa CHENG/AFP/AFP)


Taiwan suspended work and classes on some outlying islands and fishers secured their boats Wednesday as authorities warned approaching Super Typhoon Kong-rey could trigger landslides.

Strong winds and heavy rains were expected to pound swathes of the island of 23 million people ahead of Kong-rey making landfall in the southeast on Thursday afternoon.

Kong-rey was packing maximum sustained wind speeds of 240 kilometres (150 miles) per hour as it neared Taiwan, the US Joint Typhoon Warning Center said in its latest update.


Fishers wearing raincoats tied down their boats in the harbour of Yilan county, southeast of Taipei, as rain fell.

"Of course I'm worried. All my assets are here," a fisherman, who gave his name as Captain Chen, told AFP.

Kong-rey was expected to dump the heaviest rain over Taiwan's eastern and northern coastal areas and the mountains in central and southern regions, said state forecaster the Central Weather Administration.

Yilan and the eastern county of Hualien were expected to be hardest hit, with accumulated rainfall from Tuesday to Friday reaching 800 millimetres to 1,200 millimetres (31 inches to 47 inches), forecaster Chang Chun-yao told AFP.

"Based on the projected path of the typhoon, we advise Yilan, Hualien, and Taitung to take precautions against potential landslides and debris flows in areas expected to receive heavy rainfall," Chang said.

Classes and work were suspended on the two main islands of Taitung county, where the typhoon looks set to make a direct hit based on the storm's current trajectory.

Ferry services between Taiwan's outlying island of Kinmen and the Chinese port city of Xiamen were also halted.

Taiwan is accustomed to frequent tropical storms from July to October, but Chang said it was unusual for such a powerful typhoon to hit the island this late in the year.

"It is very rare for a moderate or stronger typhoon to make landfall in late October. The last occurrence was the Typhoon Nock-ten in October 2004," Chang told AFP.

Scientists have warned climate change is increasing the intensity of storms, leading to heavy rains, flash floods and strong gusts.

In July, Gaemi became the strongest typhoon to make landfall in Taiwan in eight years, killing at least 10 people, injuring hundreds and triggering widespread flooding in the southern seaport city of Kaohsiung.

That was followed in early October by Krathon, which killed at least four people and injured hundreds, as well as triggering mudslides, flooding and record-strong gusts.

joy/amj/cwl

Taiwan warns Typhoon Kong-rey 'rapidly' intensifying

AFP
Tue 29 October 2024

Typhoon Kong-rey was heading towards southeastern Taiwan and could make landfall late Wednesday or early Thursday, the Central Weather Administration said (I-Hwa CHENG) (I-Hwa CHENG/AFP/AFP)

Authorities in southeastern Taiwan suspended some ferries and advised fishers to return to shore Tuesday as the island's weather forecaster warned approaching Typhoon Kong-rey was "rapidly" intensifying.

Packing maximum wind speeds of 155 kilometres (96 miles) per hour, the storm could make landfall late Wednesday or early Thursday, the Central Weather Administration said.

"It is now intensifying rapidly," Lin Po-tung of the weather agency told a news conference.

Lin warned waves could reach five to six metres (16 to 20 feet) high on Wednesday, with heavy rain also forecast in the capital Taipei.

Disaster officials in Taitung county, which looked set to bear the brunt of Kong-rey based on the storm's current trajectory, advised fishers to return to shore and secure their boats, while ferry services to outlying islands were suspended.

"The main impact on Taitung will be damage caused by strong winds," the local fire agency said.

Further north in the coastal city of Hualien, which was hit by a magnitude 7.4 earthquake in April, authorities prepared supplies for the vulnerable and vehicles ready to evacuate people.

Taiwan is accustomed to frequent tropical storms from July to October but scientists have warned climate change is increasing their intensity, leading to heavy rains, flash floods and strong gusts.

In July, Gaemi became the strongest typhoon to make landfall in Taiwan in eight years, killing at least 10 people, injuring hundreds and triggering widespread flooding in the southern seaport city of Kaohsiung.

That was followed in early October by Krathon, which killed at least four people and injured hundreds, as well as triggering mudslides, flooding and record-strong gusts.

In a bid to avoid a repeat of the flooding, there have been "increased efforts on clearing sediment from rivers and in more areas", said Yi-fung Wang, a spokesman for the Water Resources Agency, under the economic ministry.

joy/amj/rs

Typhoon Kong-rey to bring 180-mph winds, 3 feet of rain to Taiwan

Jesse Ferrell
Tue 29 October 2024 



Typhoon Kong-rey will strengthen to the equivalent of a Category 4 hurricane on the Saffir-Simpson Hurricane Wind Scale later this week as it approaches Taiwan. Landfall Thursday will bring significant structural damage, mudslides and flooding. Kong-rey, known as Leon in the Philippines, is a 4 on the AccuWeather RealImpact™ Scale for Taiwan.

Both Taiwan and the Philippines have been hit recently by tropical storms. Deadly Super Typhoon Krathon hit Taiwan on Oct. 3. Tropical Storm Trami, known as Kristine in the Philippines, killed at least 126 people with flooding rain last weekend.

As of Tuesday morning, Kong-rey is the equivalent of a Category 2 hurricane. Additional strengthening to a very strong typhoon is likely before striking southern Taiwan Thursday. There is a chance Kong-rey could reach super typhoon intensity, the highest category ranked by the Japan Meteorological Agency, on Wednesday.





Typhoon Kong-rey will continue to track west-northwestward into Wednesday. The storm may turn more to the northwest by Thursday as it makes landfall in Taiwan, then northeastward after landfall in eastern China Friday as a tropical storm.





Heavy rain from Kong-rey is expected across northern Luzon, Philippines, the southern Ryukyu Islands, and Taiwan from Tuesday night, Oct. 29, into Friday, Nov. 1, before spreading across the northern Ryukyu Islands and south Japan from Thursday night, Oct. 31, into early Sunday, Nov. 3.

Rainfall of up to 24 inches (600 mm), with an AccuWeather Local StormMax™ of 36 inches (900 mm), can lead to flooding and travel delays, as well as mudslides in the mountainous terrain of Taiwan.





Damaging wind gusts as high as 160 mph (260 km/h), with an AccuWeather Local StormMax™ of 180 mph (290 km/h), can occur across Taiwan, the Batanes and the east coast of China from Wed., Oct. 30, through Sat., Nov. 2. This wind can lead to structural damage, power outages and logistical delays.

AccuWeather Lead International Expert Jason Nicholls contributed to this report.

Ten-storey hotel collapse in Argentina leaves one dead and several trapped

Andy Gregory and Namita Singh
Tue 29 October 2024 

A drone view shows the remains of the Hotel Dubrovnik in Villa Gesell (Reuters)


A 10-storey hotel collapsed in Argentina, leaving one person dead and seven still trapped in the debris.

Firefighters searching for survivors rescued a woman from the rubble of the Dubrovnik Hotel in Villa Gesell, a coastal city 350km south of the capital Buenos Aires.

The building collapsed in the early hours of Tuesday, local officials said.

Among those suspected to be trapped are workers from a construction site allegedly operating without municipal permits at the Dubrovnik hotel, according to reports.


Firefighters managed to rescue an elderly woman from the rubble alive, while an 80-year-old man has been killed, local newspaper Pagina 12 reported, citing provincial security minister Javier Alonso.


Rescuers search for missing people after the collapse of the Dubrovnik Hotel in the seaside resort of Villa Gessell, Buenos Aires province, on 29 October 2024 (AFP via Getty Images)

An elderly man was killed and several are missing after a ten-storey building housing a hotel collapsed on Tuesday (AFP via Getty Images)

Mr Alonso was quoted as saying that there were no guests in the hotel, but there were workers staying in another part of the building, which was built in 1986.

More than 300 firefighters, police and other rescue officials were at the scene, in a rescue operation already ongoing for more than eight hours, online outlet Infobae reported, citing the city’s mayor Gustavo Barrera as warning that the adjacent building is also at risk of collapse.


Police and firefighters work after the collapse of the Dubrovnik Hotel (AFP via Getty Images)

Firefighters search for trapped people after a hotel collapses in Villa Gesell (REUTERS)

The Independent has approached the security ministry for more information.

Local officials alleged on Tuesday that they had detected and halted unauthorised construction work that was being carried out inside the building without proper clearance back in August.

A prosecutor has opened an investigation to determine the cause of the collapse, but Villa Gesell’s municipality said in a press release that the hotel was undergoing a renovation without the proper permits.

Infobae cited Mr Alonso as saying that the courts had ordered the arrest of four people in connection with the hotel’s collapse.
Starmer condemns ‘gravely concerning’ UNRWA ban as Israel faces international backlash

Neil Johnston
Tue 29 October 2024 

The UNRWA was created in 1949 to help displaced Palestinians after the war between Arab nations and Israel - Jack Guez/AFP


Sir Keir Starmer has said he is “gravely concerned” over Israel’s decision to ban the main Palestinian aid agency from the country amid an international outcry over the move.

The Prime Minister joined the backlash from Israel’s closest Western allies after the country’s parliament voted for two bills to prevent the UN Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) from working within its territory.

His fears of Israel “jeopardising” aid to Gaza came after the United States warned of a looming humanitarian “catastrophe” and said that children could starve to death.


The UNRWA was created in 1949 to help displaced Palestinians following the war between Arab nations and the newly established state of Israel.

The agency now receives a budget of more than £1.12 billion from the UN to provide humanitarian aid including food, medicine and education supporting 5.9 million Palestinians.

However Israel has claimed that up to 10 per cent of its staff have links to terror groups and that some of its workers participated in the Oct 7 massacre.

The agency provides food, medicine and education to 5.9 million Palestinians - Ramadan Abed/Reuters

A UN investigation found that nine employees from the agency “may have” been involved in the murder of 1,200 Israelis and kidnapping of hundreds more.

Israel’s Knesset overwhelmingly voted for two bills on Monday, the first banning the agency from operating in Israeli territory and effectively shuttering its offices in East Jerusalem.

The second will severely curtail the agency’s activities in Gaza and the West Bank by banning Israel’s state authorities from having any contact with the agency.

Benjamin Netanyahu, the Israeli prime minister, who has a long-running feud with the agency he says has links to Hamas, has insisted humanitarian aid would reach Palestinians.

He has vowed to “stand ready” to help but added UNRWA personnel “involved in terrorist activities against Israel must be held accountable”.

Israel’s foreign ministry said members with links to terror were not just a “few rotten apples” but “a rotten tree entirely infected with terrorist operatives”.

There are 90 days before the laws will be implemented but Britain joined the US in condemning the move.

“The UNRWA bills passed by Israel’s Knesset are gravely concerning,” Sir Keir said. “This risks jeopardising the international humanitarian response in Gaza. We need to see an immediate ceasefire and the release of hostages. Israel must ensure sufficient aid reaches civilians in Gaza.”


Israel’s Knesset voted for two bills banning the agency from operating on Israeli territory - Ahmad Gharabli/AFP

Anneliese Dodds, the Development Minister, also hinted that Britain could suspend more arms sales to Israel if the ban goes ahead, describing the bills as “unacceptable”.

The US has urged Israel to reconsider with Matthew Miller, spokesman for the state department, saying that in the current crisis the agency was “irreplaceable”.

“There’s nobody that can replace them right now in the middle of the crisis,” he said.

The department added in a statement the legislation “risks catastrophe for the more than three million Palestinians who rely on UNRWA for essential services, including healthcare, and primary and secondary education”.

It urged Israel to “pause and further consider implementation of this legislation to ensure UNRWA can effectively carry out its mission and facilitate humanitarian assistance”.

More than a dozen other European governments including Germany and France have condemned the decision while Unicef said the move would kill children.

A spokesman for the UN’s children’s emergency fund said banning UNRWA will ‘see the collapse of the humanitarian system in Gaza’ - Abir Sultan/Shutterstock

James Elder, spokesperson for the UN’s children’s emergency fund, said banning the UNRWA could see the humanitarian response in Gaza collapse.

“If UNRWA is unable to operate, it’ll likely see the collapse of the humanitarian system in Gaza,” he said. “So a decision such as this suddenly means that a new way has been found to kill children.”

The move comes amid growing concern over conditions in Gaza, where two million residents are effectively dependent on the services from the agency.

Aid to Gaza has fallen to its lowest level since the war began with the UN stating that only 704 truckloads had entered the Strip so far this month, compared to 3,000 truckloads in September.

In the war-torn enclave displaced refugees described the agency as “our only saviour” and said they would starve to death without its support.

“These children need at least bread to eat,” Rawan Sawaf, 34, a mother of five who has been displaced from Rafah, told The Telegraph on Monday. “There is nothing to feed them. We live on UNRWA aid. If its work stops, who will provide us with services?”

Only 704 truckloads from the UNRWA entered Gaza this month compared to 3,000 in September - Bashar Taleb/AFP

Saeed Al-Helou, 55, from Gaza City, said his family received food and medicine through the agency, and said he would be unable to feed his children.

“Their stopping work means a real disaster for us. We cannot buy food supplies such as canned food, lentils, rice, and others, not even flour. We have lived through the worst experiences during this war. Should we beg to feed our children?”

Rawan Al-Louh, 40, a mother of six from Rafah, said all her family had was two bags of flour and needed the agency to survive.

“We live on their help,” she said. “The situation is very difficult and tragic. We are suffering to obtain water, medicine, food, and other things. The conditions are difficult and our days pass with difficulty.

“Without UNRWA, people will die of disease and hunger.”

‘Staggering array’ of witches’ marks discovered at English Heritage site


Nadia Khomami 
Arts and culture correspondent
Tue 29 October 2024 
THE GUARDIAN

English Heritage volunteer Rick Berry discovered witches’ marks and rare curses carved into the walls of the Tudor property once visited by Henry VIII and his fifth Queen, Catherine Howard.Photograph: English Heritage

As English Heritage welcomes thousands of visitors over the Halloween period, a new discovery has made Gainsborough Old Hall in Lincolnshire a clear contender for the spookiest site of them all.

The charity has uncovered a “staggering array” of witches’ marks and rare curses carved into the walls of the Tudor property, once visited by Henry VIII and his fifth Queen, Catherine Howard.

Rick Berry, a volunteer at English Heritage, discovered and mapped about 20 ritual protection, or apotropaic, marks – among the most identified at any of the charity’s 400 sites.

Witches’ marks were traditionally made to turn away evil, providing protection to buildings and those who lived or worked within them against demons, witches or the evil eye.


Berry discovered a particular concentration of marks in the Old Hall’s servants’ wing, including flowers with six petals carved within a simple circle – known as daisy wheels and hexafoils – that were believed to trap demons.

There were also overlapping letter Vs, or Marian marks, believed to call on the Virgin Mary for protection, as well as a pentangle, which, despite modern connotations, was originally used to protect against evil. There were about 100 burn marks, believed to protect against fire.

The research also revealed a number of curse inscriptions, something unprecedented at an English Heritage site.

The hall’s surviving structures were built by Sir Thomas Burgh II in the late 15th century, and the property was the seat of the Burghs from 1430 to 1596, before being sold to a merchant family, the Hickmans, who resided there until around 1730.

It is believed the curse inscriptions were made around the time that the merchant William Hickman owned the property, owing to his notorious unpopularity. In one inscription, Hickman’s name is written upside down (the practice of defaming a name was thought to curse the named person).

According to English Heritage, Hickman was a ruthless businessman, asserting his rights as the owner of the manor and manipulating his authority to maximise his control and income.

He enclosed areas of common land, contested local market rights, levied tolls on river goods, and sought to open up the Gainsborough market to traders from London. One complainant called him a “threadbare fellow”.

Kevin Booth, the head of collections at English Heritage, said: “It is astonishing that centuries on the amazing old buildings in our care still have secrets waiting to be discovered.

“The Old Hall has undoubtedly had a tumultuous past, not least under the ownership of the apparently unpopular William Hickman, but why it’s the scene of quite such a high concentration of protective carvings remains a mystery.”

Despite the apotropaic marks, there have been a number of ghostly sightings at the hall. Many believe it is haunted by Elizabeth Burgh, Sir Thomas Burgh II’s daughter.

The story goes that Elizabeth was ready to run away with her lover, a poor soldier or servant, when her father found out about their plans and locked Elizabeth away in one of the rooms. She died shortly after from a broken heart, and her tortured soul still haunts the hall in search of her lover. People have reported seeing her ghost emanating from the Tower Room.

Other English Heritage sites where protective carvings have already been identified include Boscobel House and The Royal Oak, Bolsover Castle, Kirby Hall, Harmondsworth Barn, Stokesay Castle, Audley End and Deal Castle.

Volunteer discovers ‘astonishing’ array of witches marks at English Heritage site

Joe Middleton
Tue 29 October 2024 at 4:09 am GMT-6·2-min read
THE INDEPENDENT

Rick Berry found around 20 carvings (English Heritage)

A “staggering array” of witches marks have been found carved into the walls at an English Heritage site.

The discovery at Gainsborough Old Hall in Lincolnshire was made by volunteer Rick Berry, who mapped around 20 carvings at the Tudor property, that was once visited by Henry VIII and his fifth queen, Catherine Howard.

Mr Berry spent two years identifying the apotropaic marks, sometimes called witches marks – the most found at any of the charity’s 400 sites.

Gainsborough Old Hall in Lincolnshire (English Heritage)


Overlapping Vs or Marian marks, which are believed by some to call on the Virgin Mary for protection (English Heritage)


The long-time volunteer found a wide variety of designs including overlapping Vs, or “Marian marks”, which are believed by some to call on the Virgin Mary for protection, and a pentangle, which was originally used to protect against evil.

Mr Berry also discovered rare curse inscriptions, thought to have been made around the time that William Hickman owned the property from 1596.

In one inscription, Mr Hickman’s name is written upside down. The practice of defacing a name was widely believed to curse the named person and is something not seen before at any English Heritage site, the charity said.

As well as the carvings, there were around 100 burn marks that are believed to be for protection against fire.

A rare curse inscription made against William Hickman who previously owned Gainsborough Old Hall (English Heritage)


A pentangle, which was originally used to protect against evil (English Heritage)

English Heritage’s Kevin Booth said: “It is astonishing that, centuries on, the amazing old buildings in our care still have secrets waiting to be discovered.

“The Old Hall has undoubtedly had a tumultuous past, not least under the ownership of the apparently unpopular William Hickman, but why it’s the scene of quite such a high concentration of protective carvings remains a mystery.

“We have a great team of volunteers across the country and it is testament to Rick’s passion for the place that these incredible protection marks have been found at Gainsborough.
‘Britain’s brass bands older than thought and invented by Napoleonic War soldiers’

Nina Massey, PA Science Correspondent
Tue 29 October 2024

Britain’s brass bands are older than previously thought and were invented by soldiers from the Napoleonic Wars, a new study has found.

The findings challenge the widely held belief that brass bands originated with coal miners and other industrial communities in northern England and Wales between the 1830s and the 1850s.


A University of Cambridge historian has found evidence that suggests Britain’s earliest brass bands were founded by military musicians in the 1810s.


According to Dr Eamonn O’Keeffe, regimental bands first experimented with all-brass arrangements in the aftermath of the Napoleonic Wars.

Dr O’Keeffe, who is the National Army Museum junior research fellow at Queens’ College, Cambridge and part of the University’s Centre for Geopolitics, said: “These findings illustrate just how deeply brass bands are embedded in British history and culture.

“We already knew about their relationship with industrialisation. Now we know that brass bands emerged from Britain’s wars against Napoleon.”

Wartime bands included woodwind instruments such as clarinets and bassoons, but the 15th Regiment of Foot had already organised a bugles-only band by 1818.

Taking advantage of new instrument designs developed at home and in Continental Europe, a number of other regiments had established all-brass bands by 1830.

The Life Guards, for example, performed on valved trumpets gifted by the Russian Czar.

Local defence units also assembled brass bands, including a volunteer rifle corps in Paisley (1819) and yeomanry troops in Devon (1827) and Somerset (1829).

Brass bands were found to have originated in the military during the Napoleonic wars (Jonathan Brady/PA)

The new study, published in The Historical Journal, shows that veterans of the Napoleonic wars founded many of Britain’s earliest non-military brass bands from the 1820s onwards.These groups often emerged far beyond the northern English and Welsh industrial communities with which they later became associated.

The Colyton Brass Band was the first named civilian band which Dr O’Keeffe has identified.

It played God Save the King in a village in Devon in November 1828 as part of birthday festivities for a baronet’s son.

The study also found slightly later examples in Chester and Sunderland (both 1829), Derby and Sidmouth (1831), and Poole (1832).

In 1834, Lincoln’s brass band was being trained by William Shaw who used to be a trumpeter and bugleman in the 33rd Regiment of Foot.

The Napoleonic Wars (1793 – 1815) led to a dramatic proliferation of British military bands, Dr O’Keeffe says.

By 1814, more than 20,000 people who played instruments were serving in uniform, in the regular army and militia, as well as a host of part-time home defence formations.

By 1814, more than 20,000 people who played instruments were serving in uniform (Dominic Lipinski/PA)

Dr O’Keeffe analysed press reports, memoirs and regimental records, and found that after they had been demobilised, men and boys who honed their instrumental skills in uniform embarked on a variety of civilian musical careers, becoming instructors, wind performers, composers and even opera singers.

He said: “It is widely assumed that brass bands were a new musical species, distinct from their military counterparts.

“They are primarily seen as a product of industrialisation pioneered by a combination of working-class performers and middle-class sponsors.

“But all-brass bands first appeared in Britain and Ireland in a regimental guise.

“As well as producing a large cohort of band trainers, the military provided a familiar and attractive template for amateur musicians and audiences.

“This coincided with expanding commercial opportunities and a growing belief in the moralising power of music.”

Many buglers appealed to their senior officers to keep their instruments after their service was complete, paving the way for future generations to secure second-hand instruments (Yui Mok/PA)

Drums and bugles that were issued by the Government were supposed to be returned to public stores on demobilisation and band instruments generally belonged to regimental officers.

However, drummers and bandsmen were often unwilling to give up the tools of their trade, the researcher found.

Seven Herefordshire local militia musicians petitioned their colonel in 1816 “to make us a present” of their regimental instruments, noting that performers in other disbanded units had been permitted to keep their instruments, the study found.

The men promised to continue their weekly practices if the request was granted, pledging that “a band will be always ready in the town of Leominster for any occasion”.

Additionally, some officers auctioned off the instruments of their disbanded corps, making large volumes of affordable second-hand instruments available to amateur players and civilian bands in the post-war decades.

Dr O’Keeffe said: “Brass bands enabled aspiring musicians of all ages to develop new skills and allowed people to make music as a community, learning from each other.

“That was the case in the 19th century and it’s still the case today.”





The Election Looks So Close That Even You-Know-Who Could Tip It

David Faris
Tue, October 29, 2024 


This is part of Wedge Issues, a pop-up advice column about politics, running now through the election. Submit a question here—it’s anonymous!

Dear Wedge Issues,

Should I fear Jill Stein—or, really, any third-party candidate? I recently read a piece about how Stein could have contributed to edging Hillary Clinton out in Wisconsin, Pennsylvania, and Michigan in 2016. I also saw, according to a poll from the Council on American-Islamic Relations last month, that 40 percent of Muslims in Michigan are backing Stein too, because of her position on Israel’s war in Gaza. But I also saw that David Duke, the former grand wizard of the KKK, has endorsed her? Lot of confusing stuff here. I just want to know whether to be afraid of what she could do to the election!

—Still, Jill?!

Dear Still?!,

The Green Party is not a particularly serious political operation. Its candidates have never won a federal election, and its vanishingly small number of successful candidates have been mostly at the municipal or state legislative level. Winner-take-all races for nearly all seats in Congress and for most states’ electors in the Electoral College mean that small parties usually get completely shut out of power. But on top of that, as an organization the Green Party does virtually nothing to build its brand and reach between elections and emerges from a cocoon of delusion and extremism every four years to terrify liberals. It makes sense that you’re freaked out—the Green Party is a zombie that has, once again, emerged from a dark resting place.

This year in particular, the Stein campaign is taking great pleasure in serving as a spoiler. Whereas the party’s 2004 nominee, David Cobb, explicitly refused to campaign in swing states after Ralph Nader was widely (and correctly) believed to have cost Al Gore the 2000 election, the Stein campaign seems to be concentrating all of its energy in a bid to deny Democratic nominee Kamala Harris the Blue Wall states of Michigan, Wisconsin, and Pennsylvania. The New York Times reported that a speaker at a recent Stein event in Michigan admitted the obvious: “We are not in a position to win the White House.” He added, “We do have a real opportunity to win something historic. We could deny Kamala Harris the state of Michigan.” OK then!

And Jill Stein, specifically, is not a serious person. The former physician is launching her sixth “campaign” for a significant position in government, having run for governor of Massachusetts twice and now the presidency three times. Her best performance was actually the 17.7 percent of the vote she received 18 years ago in the race for Massachusetts secretary of the commonwealth, in a contest that featured no Republican candidate. She has worked openly this year with Republicans trying to get her on state ballots for the express purpose of rat-fucking the election and will almost certainly receive a boost from Russian disinformation artists, as she did in 2016. While Stein has disavowed her endorsement by former Ku Klux Klan Grand Wizard David Duke, it is not a surprise that her increasingly fringe politics are attracting unwelcome bedfellows.

Stein is unlikely to draw north of 1 percent of the vote nationally—but unfortunately, she is a threat that we still have to take seriously. That’s because the 2024 election looks as if it is going to be agonizingly, almost impossibly close. The leading forecasts are close to 50–50, and it is difficult to imagine polling getting any narrower than it already is in the seven decisive battleground states. It is actually reasonable and understandable to do a little bit of doom spiraling about all the different things that could go wrong and lead to the future-warping catastrophe of a second Trump term. And Stein is, sadly, one of them.

But: This isn’t a situation where we can use simple arithmetic to get angry at Stein. To properly assign blame to Stein, and to figure out what she might wreak this time, we have to correctly assess what Stein’s voters would do if she were not on the ballot.

There’s a perception on the left that Stein cost Hillary Clinton the presidency in 2016. She did not, but it is understandable why this myth has taken hold. The way that people conclude this is to take Trump’s margins in a given state and tally up Stein’s votes there. If Stein’s raw vote totals exceeded Trump’s margin, then voilà: She must have denied Hillary Clinton victory in that state and thus the presidency. But this is a misreading of how third-party voting works, one that political scientists like me have repeatedly pushed back on. For example, the myth that Reform Party candidate Ross Perot cost Republican George H.W. Bush the election in 1992 is not sustainable when examined closely. Perot pulled more than 18 percent of the vote in an election that Democrat Bill Clinton won by fewer than 6 points, but you can’t just take the Texas billionaire’s haul and give it to Bush. Exit polls showed that Clinton and Bush were equally likely to be the second choice of Perot voters. And the most recent analysis, from Harrison Lavelle and Armin Thomas at Split Ticket, argues counterintuitively that Perot drew more votes from Clinton.

And, perhaps most importantly, there’s the fact that many third-party voters wouldn’t show up on Election Day at all if their preferred candidate is not on the ballot.

Political scientists Christopher Devine and Kyle Kotko published a paper in 2021 looking at the 2016 election and concluded that roughly 53 percent of Stein voters simply wouldn’t have turned out if she hadn’t been on the ballot. About 35 percent of Stein’s votes would have gone to Clinton, according to the study, and 8 percent to Trump. So, yes, she may have “contributed” to his margins in some states. But the one state where Stein’s candidacy may actually have been decisive in 2016 was Michigan, which Trump carried by fewer than 11,000 votes out of more than 5 million cast, and where Stein nabbed 51,463 votes. And while I’m sure it would have been a terrible, possibly unbearable blow to Trump’s crystalline ego to have won 290 electoral votes rather than 306, that one state wouldn’t have gotten Clinton anywhere near victory.

However, in 2024 Michigan could actually decide the whole election single-handedly. Forecaster Nate Silver gives Michigan his second-highest odds of being the “tipping-point state” in the election: the one that puts the winning candidate over 270 electoral votes. The Harris campaign is privately quite worried about it. If we assume similar turnout to 2020—about 5.5 million votes—and if we believe Stein’s RealClearPolitics average of 1.0 percent in multicandidate polling of the state, she is likely to draw around 55,000 votes in Michigan. But if we also assume that Stein’s actual Election Day totals will be about half of her election eve polling, which is what we saw across the board for third-party candidates including Stein in 2016 and which has been a consistent pattern in American elections, that number gets cut to 27,000.

So here’s what we can do with all this: We can apply Devine and Kotko’s conclusions and the standard Election Day dropoff for third-party candidates and assume that Stein wins 0.5 percent in Michigan, that 53 percent of her voters would have stayed home, that 35 percent would have gone to Harris, and 8 percent to Trump. If so, then Harris would have netted just over 3,000 more votes without Stein on the ballot.

Could Michigan be that close? It certainly could. But even in an era of sharp polarization during which the share of the electorate that changes sides between elections has plummeted, only a handful of states have been decided by fewer than 3,000 votes. This century, only New Hampshire (in 2016) and Florida and New Mexico (in 2000) were that close. Bumping the margin up to 5,000 votes or fewer does not add many states to the list.

The best thing to do here, though, is not to stew in your fear of Jill Stein but to reach out to friends and family members who are considering voting for her and try to gently talk them out of it, rather than calling them names on social media or accusing them of naively helping Donald Trump. Vote shaming not only doesn’t work but almost certainly causes people to dig in their heels. And that could, ironically, make everyone’s worst recurring Jill Stein nightmare a reality.

In US swing state Wisconsin, potential Green vote irks Democrats

Maggy DONALDSON
Tue, October 29, 2024 at 7:26 PM MDT
4 min read



Chester Todd walks past campaign signs outside his home in Racine, Wisconsin, where he's running for the House of Representatives in the state's first district (TANNEN MAURY)TANNEN MAURY/AFP/AFPMore

Chester Todd is an 82-year-old running for US Congress on a platform of "equality, reparations, liberation" -- and those principles, he says, are why neither Kamala Harris nor Donald Trump have earned his vote.

Wearing a Palestinian flag-colored scarf at a coffee shop in his hometown Racine, Wisconsin, Todd told AFP he will instead vote Jill Stein, the perennial Green Party candidate who is on the ballot in nearly every battleground state this presidential cycle -- and who many Democrats fear could stymie their White House chances.

Stein has virtually no chance of winning in Wisconsin -- or anywhere -- but in the key swing state where outcomes are notoriously a photo finish, her ballot line could have outsized influence.

Republicans won Wisconsin for the first time in nearly three decades in 2016, when Hillary Clinton lost by just under 23,000 votes to Donald Trump -- a shock defeat that had some Democrats blaming Stein for taking around 31,000 votes.

And the Green Party's message -- which centers on issues like climate change, healthcare, and, this year, ending arms support to Israel in its war on Gaza -- continues to find traction in Wisconsin's bluest pockets, areas crucial to a Harris win.

National Democrats recently ran a campaign ad attacking Stein that aired in Wisconsin as well as Michigan and Pennsylvania -- all part of the so-called "Blue Wall" critical to the Democrats' White House path.

"She's not sorry she helped Trump win" in 2016, the ad states. "That's why a vote for Stein is really a vote for Trump."

Pete Karas, Wisconsin's Green Party elections chair, said that "spoiler argument" simply "doesn't hold water."

"It is an excuse the Democratic Party uses when they run crappy candidates and crappy elections and they lose."

Democratic Party strategy has included legal action to remove Stein from ballots nationwide, efforts that have mostly failed.

Karas said that picking such legal fights has done little more than further aggravate Green Party operatives like himself: "We will not be pushed out of the democratic process by the Democratic Party."

- 'Not satisfied' -

Charles Franklin, who directs the nationally recognized Marquette Law School Poll, told AFP while Stein likely does pull more from Democrats than Republicans, the idea that all Stein votes "would uniformly go to Harris" is "false."

"Any third party voter by definition has already passed the option of voting for one of the major party candidates," Franklin said. "They're voting for Stein because they're not satisfied."

A smattering of Green Party-endorsed candidates have won local office over the past decade in Wisconsin, but its presence there remains tiny.

Still, "it would be silly not to think it's a threat" in 2024, said Alexia Sabor, chair of the Dane County Democrats in the state's bluest county.

She sees the Green Party figuring into national elections as more "a desire to be disruptive" than an effort towards building a successful political party -- and says even for voters who tend Green, there's a clear choice on the ballot.

"You can not love the Democratic Party and you can not love Kamala Harris," she said, but "in terms of the values, it's pretty clear that the Republican Party doesn't align with their values -- and a lot of their values do align with Democrats."

Xavier Golden, a 23-year-old student at a public university near Milwaukee who has his own future political aspirations, says he voted for Bernie Sanders in 2020, the self-identified socialist senator who caucuses with Democrats and has run for president twice.

Speaking to AFP at the Racine Public Library where he works, Golden said this time, he's for Stein.

"If the Democrats wanted to control the main spirit of the liberal front, they would do that," Golden said, pointing to what he calls their "conservative stance on Palestine" and a tendency "to be so ticky-tacky with racial issues."

Like Green Party House of Representatives candidate Todd, Golden is a Black man. And like Todd, he says the Democrats ask for support from Black voters every four years but rarely deliver on what he dubbed "empty promises."

Both men advocate ending US arms support to Israel and call for economic reparations for descendants of enslaved people. They also point to issues like universal health care and the shortage of social and economic resources in predominantly minority neighborhoods as key influences shaping their politics.

If Democrats "were to commit to actually being the social justice party that they're painted as," Golden said, "I think they would be able to sway more voters -- and there wouldn't be no need for a Green Party."




Democrats go after Jill Stein, Cornel West in digital ads aimed at young voters

JONATHAN J. COOPER
Mon, October 28, 2024 

FILE - Progressive activist Cornel West speaks at a demonstration in Union Park outside the Democratic National Convention, Aug. 21, 2024, in Chicago.
 (AP Photo/Alex Brandon, File)

PHOENIX (AP) — Democrats are spending about $500,000 for a last-minute push to persuade voters in battleground states to reject third-party candidates Jill Stein and Cornel West, warning a vote for them will help Republican Donald Trump.

The Democratic National Committee said Monday that the digital ads will run on Instagram and YouTube, targeting younger voters and college campuses. They use video of Trump from a June rally in Philadelphia, when he said: “Cornel West. He’s one of my favorite candidates, Cornel West. And I like her also, Jill Stein, I like her very much. You know why? She takes 100% from them. He takes 100%.”

Stung by narrow losses in 2000 and 2016 that they blame in part on support for Green Party nominees, Democrats have put a major emphasis this year on discouraging left-leaning voters from backing third-party candidates. They pushed back aggressively against No Labels, a nascent third-party movement, and the independent candidacy of Robert F. Kennedy Jr. before turning attention to Stein and West.

Stein was the Green Party nominee in 2016 and won 132,000 votes across Wisconsin, Michigan and Pennsylvania. Democrat Hillary Clinton lost by a combined 77,000 votes in those states. This year, Stein has broadened the Green Party's traditional pro-environment base by fiercely denouncing Israel and its military strikes in Gaza, Lebanon and elsewhere.

Critiques of Israel and support for Palestinians made up the bulk of her 45-minute appearance at a coffee shop in suburban Phoenix on Monday.

Stein urged dozens of supporters not to be intimidated by pressure to vote for the “lesser evil" between Trump and Democrat Kamala Harris, alleging both are “ genocidal candidates” because of their support for Israel.

“If we are to be a democracy we have to stand up for what we want,” Stein said. “We have to vote for what we want.”

“There is absolutely nothing to gain by voting for either one of them and there's everything to lose,” she added. She called the Democratic campaign against her a threat to free speech.

Her campaign manager, Jason Call, was more blunt.

“We want them to lose,” Call said of the Democratic ticket. “Genocide deserves losing.” He added that “nobody wants Trump to win,” but argued the consequences of sending another Democrat to the White House “will be worse than Trump.”