Kenya vows to challenge court ruling against Haiti deployment
By AFP
January 26, 2024
Kenya's government had said it was ready to provide up to 1,000 personnel in the deployment to Haiti - Copyright POOL/AFP Ludovic MARIN
Hillary ORINDE
Kenya’s government vowed Friday to challenge a court ruling against its decision to send a police contingent to Haiti to lead a UN-backed law and order mission in the gang-plagued Caribbean nation.
The ruling, which branded the deployment “illegal”, throws into doubt the future of a multinational force long sought by Haiti’s government, which has pleaded for international help to confront violence that has left nearly 5,000 dead.
The UN Security Council approved the mission in early October. But concerns in Kenya over Nairobi’s involvement prompted a court challenge.
On Friday, judge Enock Chacha Mwita ruled that “any decision by any state organ or state officer to deploy police officers to Haiti… contravenes the constitution and the law and is therefore unconstitutional, illegal and invalid.”
“An order is hereby issued prohibiting deployment of police forces to Haiti or any other country,” he said at Nairobi High Court.
Hours later, the authorities responded, with spokesman Isaac Mwaura saying: “While the government respects the rule of law, we have however made the decision to challenge the high court’s verdict forthwith.”
“The government reiterates its commitment in honouring its international obligations,” he said.
Ekuru Aukot, the opposition politician who challenged the deployment, said he was prepared for a long fight.
“We will still be waiting for them at the court of appeal, and we will go all the way to the Supreme Court. They should be thanking me for saving the government this embarrassment,” he told AFP.
The government had previously said it was ready to provide up to 1,000 personnel, an offer welcomed by the United States and other nations that had ruled out putting their own forces on the ground.
Kenya’s ambassador to the United Nations, Martin Kimani, on Thursday said that “significant progress” had been made in preparations towards the mission, which had parliamentary approval.
In the face of criticism, President William Ruto had described the Kenyan undertaking as a “mission for humanity” and one in step with its long record of contributing to peacekeeping missions abroad.
– War zone –
Haiti’s foreign minister on Thursday pleaded for the deployment to be speeded up, telling the UN Security Council that gang violence in the country was as barbaric as the horrors experienced in war zones.
“The Haitian people cannot take any more. I hope this time is the last time I will speak before the deployment of a multinational force to support our security forces,” Jean Victor Geneus told the council.
Gangs now run rampant in large swathes of the country and homicides in Haiti more than doubled last year to nearly 4,800 murders, according to a UN report released Tuesday.
The multinational mission — initially approved for one year — had envisioned Kenyan police on the offensive with their Haitian counterparts, who are outnumbered and outgunned by gang members.
Haiti, the Western hemisphere’s poorest nation, has been in turmoil for years, with armed gangs taking over parts of the country and unleashing brutal violence, and the economy and public health system in tatters.
The 2021 assassination of President Jovenel Moise plunged the country further into chaos. No elections have taken place since 2016 and the presidency remains vacant.
bur-amu-ho-np/kjm
By AFP
January 26, 2024
Kenya's government had said it was ready to provide up to 1,000 personnel in the deployment to Haiti - Copyright POOL/AFP Ludovic MARIN
Hillary ORINDE
Kenya’s government vowed Friday to challenge a court ruling against its decision to send a police contingent to Haiti to lead a UN-backed law and order mission in the gang-plagued Caribbean nation.
The ruling, which branded the deployment “illegal”, throws into doubt the future of a multinational force long sought by Haiti’s government, which has pleaded for international help to confront violence that has left nearly 5,000 dead.
The UN Security Council approved the mission in early October. But concerns in Kenya over Nairobi’s involvement prompted a court challenge.
On Friday, judge Enock Chacha Mwita ruled that “any decision by any state organ or state officer to deploy police officers to Haiti… contravenes the constitution and the law and is therefore unconstitutional, illegal and invalid.”
“An order is hereby issued prohibiting deployment of police forces to Haiti or any other country,” he said at Nairobi High Court.
Hours later, the authorities responded, with spokesman Isaac Mwaura saying: “While the government respects the rule of law, we have however made the decision to challenge the high court’s verdict forthwith.”
“The government reiterates its commitment in honouring its international obligations,” he said.
Ekuru Aukot, the opposition politician who challenged the deployment, said he was prepared for a long fight.
“We will still be waiting for them at the court of appeal, and we will go all the way to the Supreme Court. They should be thanking me for saving the government this embarrassment,” he told AFP.
The government had previously said it was ready to provide up to 1,000 personnel, an offer welcomed by the United States and other nations that had ruled out putting their own forces on the ground.
Kenya’s ambassador to the United Nations, Martin Kimani, on Thursday said that “significant progress” had been made in preparations towards the mission, which had parliamentary approval.
In the face of criticism, President William Ruto had described the Kenyan undertaking as a “mission for humanity” and one in step with its long record of contributing to peacekeeping missions abroad.
– War zone –
Haiti’s foreign minister on Thursday pleaded for the deployment to be speeded up, telling the UN Security Council that gang violence in the country was as barbaric as the horrors experienced in war zones.
“The Haitian people cannot take any more. I hope this time is the last time I will speak before the deployment of a multinational force to support our security forces,” Jean Victor Geneus told the council.
Gangs now run rampant in large swathes of the country and homicides in Haiti more than doubled last year to nearly 4,800 murders, according to a UN report released Tuesday.
The multinational mission — initially approved for one year — had envisioned Kenyan police on the offensive with their Haitian counterparts, who are outnumbered and outgunned by gang members.
Haiti, the Western hemisphere’s poorest nation, has been in turmoil for years, with armed gangs taking over parts of the country and unleashing brutal violence, and the economy and public health system in tatters.
The 2021 assassination of President Jovenel Moise plunged the country further into chaos. No elections have taken place since 2016 and the presidency remains vacant.
bur-amu-ho-np/kjm
Kenya's top court has ruled plans to lead a multinational mission in Haiti unconstitutional. The government plans to appeal. Kenya's offer had been met with relief as the international community struggled for volunteers.
The Kenyan government says it intends to challenge a court ruling against its decision to deploy a contingent of police officers to Haiti at the head of a UN-backed law-and-order mission to the Caribbean nation.
Nairobi's HIgh Court reached the ruling earlier on Friday.
The international community and the Haitian government had long been seeking a multinational force to help combat rising gang violence which saw almost 5,000 people murdered last year alone.
Many countries had been wary of supporting Prime Minister Ariel Henry's unelected administration — governing in the aftermath of the former president's assassination — and intervening in a nation where previous missions had been dogged by human rights abuses.
But months of fruitless appeals, Kenya stepped forward last July, saying it was doing so in "solidarity with a brother nation."
The UN Security Council had approved the mission in October, but the plans are now on hold after Justice Enock Chacha Mwita ruled that Kenya's National Security Council, which is led by the president, does not have the authority to deploy regular police outside the country.
Kenya: Haiti police deployment 'unconstitutional, illegal and invalid'
"Any decision by any state organ or state officer to deploy police officers to Haiti ... contravenes the constitution and the law and is therefore unconstitutional, illegal and invalid," he said, handing down the ruling at Nairobi High Court.
Via a spokesman, the Kenyan government responded that, while it "respects the rule of law," it had "made the decision to challenge the high court's verdict forthwith." It added: "The government reiterates its commitment in honoring its international obligations."
Why Kenya volunteered to lead a security mission in Haiti 01:36
Ekuru Aukot, the opposition politician who challenged the deployment, said he was prepared for a long fight.
"We will still be waiting for them at the court of appeal, and we will go all the way to the Supreme Court," he told the French AFP news agency. "They should be thanking me for saving the government this embarrassment."
President Ruto defends 'mission for humanity'
Kenya had been prepared to send up to 1,000 police and security personnel across the Atlantic, the first 300 of whom had been expected to arrive in the coming days. Chad, Senegal, Jamaica, Belize, the Bahamas and Antigua & Barbuda have also pledged officers for the coalition, bringing the total number of personnel to around 3,000.
President William Ruto had described the Kenyan undertaking as a "mission for humanity" and one in keeping with its record of contributing to peacekeeping missions abroad.
On Thursday, Haiti's foreign minister pleaded for the deployment to be speeded up, telling the UN Security Council that gang violence in the country was as barbaric as the horrors experienced in war zones.
"The Haitian people cannot take any more," Jean Victor Geneus told the council. "I hope this time is the last time I will speak before the deployment of a multinational force to support our security forces."
DW
mf/msh (AFP, Reuters)
Nairobi's HIgh Court reached the ruling earlier on Friday.
The international community and the Haitian government had long been seeking a multinational force to help combat rising gang violence which saw almost 5,000 people murdered last year alone.
Many countries had been wary of supporting Prime Minister Ariel Henry's unelected administration — governing in the aftermath of the former president's assassination — and intervening in a nation where previous missions had been dogged by human rights abuses.
But months of fruitless appeals, Kenya stepped forward last July, saying it was doing so in "solidarity with a brother nation."
The UN Security Council had approved the mission in October, but the plans are now on hold after Justice Enock Chacha Mwita ruled that Kenya's National Security Council, which is led by the president, does not have the authority to deploy regular police outside the country.
Kenya: Haiti police deployment 'unconstitutional, illegal and invalid'
"Any decision by any state organ or state officer to deploy police officers to Haiti ... contravenes the constitution and the law and is therefore unconstitutional, illegal and invalid," he said, handing down the ruling at Nairobi High Court.
Via a spokesman, the Kenyan government responded that, while it "respects the rule of law," it had "made the decision to challenge the high court's verdict forthwith." It added: "The government reiterates its commitment in honoring its international obligations."
Why Kenya volunteered to lead a security mission in Haiti 01:36
Ekuru Aukot, the opposition politician who challenged the deployment, said he was prepared for a long fight.
"We will still be waiting for them at the court of appeal, and we will go all the way to the Supreme Court," he told the French AFP news agency. "They should be thanking me for saving the government this embarrassment."
President Ruto defends 'mission for humanity'
Kenya had been prepared to send up to 1,000 police and security personnel across the Atlantic, the first 300 of whom had been expected to arrive in the coming days. Chad, Senegal, Jamaica, Belize, the Bahamas and Antigua & Barbuda have also pledged officers for the coalition, bringing the total number of personnel to around 3,000.
President William Ruto had described the Kenyan undertaking as a "mission for humanity" and one in keeping with its record of contributing to peacekeeping missions abroad.
On Thursday, Haiti's foreign minister pleaded for the deployment to be speeded up, telling the UN Security Council that gang violence in the country was as barbaric as the horrors experienced in war zones.
"The Haitian people cannot take any more," Jean Victor Geneus told the council. "I hope this time is the last time I will speak before the deployment of a multinational force to support our security forces."
DW
mf/msh (AFP, Reuters)
No comments:
Post a Comment