Court document disputes Enbridge claims regarding Line 5 shutdown

FRONT PAGE
JUN 9, 2022
GRAHAM JAEHNIG
Staff Writer
gjaehnig@mininggazette.com



ANN ARBOR — According to Enbridge’s website, a Line 5 shutdown would put Ohio refineries at risk. The closure of one of those refineries could result in the loss of $5.4 billion in annual economic output to Ohio and southeast Michigan, and the loss of thousands of direct and contracted skilled trades jobs

A Line 5 shutdown would compromise crude supply to 10 refineries in the region to varying degrees, directly affecting fuel prices. Enbridge said the information was provided by PBF Energy, which operates one of two refineries in Toledo. PBF Energy is one of the largest independent petroleum refiners and suppliers of unbranded transportation fuels, heating oil, petrochemical feedstocks, lubricants and other petroleum products in the United States.

However, filings in a lawsuit between Enbridge and the Bad River Band Tribe of Wisconsin released last week quote Enbridge’s Neil K. Earnest, independent energy industry consultant hired by the Canadian pipeline company, who said: “I estimate that a Line 5 shutdown will have a small impact on Michigan gasoline, jet fuel and diesel prices, likely less than one cent per gallon.”

The court filing contradicts recent predictions in an analysis for energy industry advocacy group Consumer Energy Alliance, which issued a report in February that predicted as much as a 9.47 to 11.66 percent spike in fuel prices, Sheri McWhirter reported on mlive.com on Wednesday. Four months ago, that would have been about 40 cents per gallon; at today’s prices it would be closer to 52 cents per gallon.

The National Wildlife Federation has been at the forefront of this issue, knowing that the pipeline running through the Straits of Mackinac is a disaster waiting to happen and a violation of sovereign tribal treaty rights, stated Anna Marie Zorn, in the Wednesday NWF article.

“My estimate of the increase in Wisconsin transportation fuel prices is the same as that for Michigan gasoline prices, i.e., approximately 0.5 cents per gallon,” Earnest wrote, states a June 8 press release from Fossil Free Media, a nonprofit media lab that supports the movement to end fossil fuels and address the climate emergency.

Enbridge’s Line 5, has run under the Straits of Mackinac for 69 years.

The company has spent millions to push misleading advertising and public statements. Shut down Line 5, it said, and gasoline prices in the state will skyrocket, said Fossil Free Media.

“Once again Enbridge has been caught misleading the public on Line 5, prioritizing their profit margins over Great Lakes water, wildlife, and our way of life.,” said Beth Wallace, Great Lakes freshwater campaigns manager for the NWF. “All should see clearly now, by their own expert’s admission, that Enbridge’s arguments and reality go together like oil and water. Greed and profiteering are at the center of Enbridge’s campaign to keep this 70-year-old pipeline running and not Michiganders’ best interests.”

Fossil Free Media stated that Sean McBrearty, campaign coordinator for Oil & Water Don’t Mix, commented, saying:

“What we suspected for years is true, and now we hear it through Enbridge’s own words in court: The products that travel through Line 5 have no effect on gasoline prices in Michigan. These court filings totally vindicate the responsible and courageous leadership of Gov. Gretchen Whitmer and Attorney General Dana Nessel, who have worked tirelessly to protect our Great Lakes from a massive oil spill.”

Enbridge’s court filing isn’t the first time its own documents show how little Line 5 has to do with gasoline prices, Fossil Free Media said. The 2017 Dynamic Risk study, funded by Enbridge, showed decommissioning Line 5 would result in price impacts of roughly 2 cents per gallon on gasoline and approximately 5 cents per gallon on propane.

Line 5 runs from Canada, through Wisconsin and Michigan, before crossing back into Canada near Port Huron. Line 5 splits into two sections on the bottom of the Straits of Mackinac, where an oil spill would be catastrophic for the Great Lakes.

Fossil Free Media said it its release that Line 5 has spilled 33 times and at least 1.1 million gallons along its length since 1968. Enbridge’s Line 6B spilled 1.1 million gallons of tar sands bitumen into the Kalamazoo River in 2010, the largest inland spill in American history.

“Line 5 is located in the worst possible place for an oil spill in the Great Lakes, according to experts at the University of Michigan,” said Michelle Woodhouse, water program manager for Environmental Defence in Canada. “With its own words, Enbridge’s court document confirms a recent report the Environmental Defence commissioned that showed a price impact of 2 cents per liter at the pumps in Ontario when Line 5 shuts down. The biggest economic threat we face is the danger Line 5 poses to the Great Lakes ecosystem.

U.S. natural gas prices slump after fire at Texas LNG terminal

Christine Buurma and Gerson Freitas Jr., 

Bloomberg News 

Jun 8, 2022

U.S. natural gas prices tumbled after a fire broke out at a Texas export terminal, threatening to leave supplies of the fuel stranded in shale basins despite surging overseas demand.

The fire is under control at Freeport LNG’s terminal in Quintana, Texas, about 65 miles (105 kilometers) south of Houston, company spokeswoman Heather Browne said Wednesday. The incident happened at about 11:40 a.m. local time and an investigation is ongoing, she said, adding that there were no injuries or risks to the surrounding community.

Freeport is one of seven US liquefied natural gas export terminals, which receive gas via pipeline and liquefy it before loading the super-chilled LNG onto tankers. The terminals have helped the US emerge in the past few years to vie with Qatar and Australia for position as the No. 1 exporter of LNG. As Europe clamors for cargoes after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, the blaze could have a significant impact on global supplies of the fuel.

US natural gas futures for July delivery slid as much as 9.3 per cent to US$8.427 per million British thermal units in New York after reports of the fire first emerged, halting a rally that sent prices to fresh 13-year highs earlier. The contract settled down 6.4 per cent at US$8.699. Prices have more than doubled this year, as US gas stockpiles remain well below normal levels.

The fire is “going to curtail exports and alleviate some of the strain on US supplies,” said John Kilduff, a partner at hedge fund Again Capital in New York. US consumers “should benefit from lower prices, but Europe and Asia will probably pay higher prices.”

Freeport receives about 2 billion cubic feet of gas per day, or roughly 16 per cent of total US LNG export capacity. The tanker Elisa Larus is currently at the terminal, though it’s under way using its engine, according to vessel tracking data compiled by Bloomberg. That suggests the tanker may be moving away from Freeport. 

 

Natural Gas Prices Tank Again As Freeport LNG Remains Shut For Almost A Month

By Irina Slav - Jun 09, 2022

• Natural gas prices fell another 7.5% percent on Thursday morning.
• Freeport LNG outage to lead to drop in exports to Europe and Asia.
• The cause of the explosion on Wednesday remains unclear.

Amid robust demand for U.S. LNG, one of the biggest liquefaction facilities on the Gulf Coast, Freeport LNG, will be out of commission for at least three weeks following an explosion yesterday.

An explosion rocked the Freeport LNG liquefaction plant yesterday morning, with its cause as of yet unclear. An investigation is ongoing, but according to the operator of the facility, Freeport LNG, the facility will remain shut down for weeks. It accounts for a fifth of total U.S. liquefaction capacity.

The Freeport facility has three liquefaction trains, and a fourth is being constructed. Its current gas processing capacity is 2.1 billion cu ft daily. With the outage, the situation with U.S. LNG exports will become problematic, as evidenced by the gas market’s reaction to the news of the explosion.

Initially, prices fell as traders worried that the outage would reduce American LNG’s market share, per a Financial Times report from earlier today. Bloomberg noted that the fire means a lot of gas will remain stranded at the fields amid surging demand for gas overseas.

Yet prices on international LNG markets might react differently because the Freeport LNG outage effectively means there will be less natural gas for export, especially to energy-thirty Europe and Asia.

In Europe, gas prices have been on the decline for the past few days as an early start of summer reduced immediate demand. An ample supply of LNG has also contributed to the price trend. With the outage, this trend might at some point reverse.

Asian demand, however, is on a strong rise as buyers seek to build inventory for the winter season, Bloomberg reported this week, which is lending further upward support to prices.

“LNG prices remain well above where they normally are, even adjusting for higher crude oil prices,” Sanford C. Bernstein analysts said in a note, as quoted by Bloomberg. “We expect this to be a lull before what looks like a tough winter ahead for consumers.”

Oilprice.com

European Gas Soars as Fire in US Compounds Russia Supply Concern

Elena Mazneva and Anna Shiryaevskaya, Bloomberg News

BC-European-Gas-Soars-as-Fire-in-US-Compounds-Russia-Supply-Concern , Elena Mazneva and Anna Shiryaevskaya

(Bloomberg) -- Europe’s natural gas prices surged after a fire at a large export terminal in the US promised to wipe out deliveries to a market that’s on high alert over tight Russian supplies.

Benchmark futures traded in Amsterdam snapped a six-day falling streak, while UK prices jumped more than 34%. The Freeport liquefied natural gas facility in Texas, which makes up about a fifth of all US exports of the fuel, will remain closed for at least three weeks. The US sent nearly 75% of all its LNG to Europe in the first four months of this year.

The closure comes as pipeline supplies from Europe’s top providers are also capped. Key facilities in Norway are undergoing annual maintenance this week, while Russia’s supplies are below capacity after several European buyers were cut off for refusing to meet Moscow’s demands to be ultimately paid in rubles for its pipeline fuel. 

“An export halt during the high demand winter months would have triggered a much bigger reaction, but the event highlights Europe’s precarious situation and it would likely signal an end for now to the calm trading seen in recent weeks,” said Ole Hansen, head of commodity strategy at Saxo Bank A/S.

Europe has been particularly reliant on US LNG to help offset risk of disruption to Russian pipeline imports, and ample supplies of the fuel in the past weeks had calmed the market after wild swings earlier this year. 

“The rising importance of US gas exports to a gas-hungry Europe has been clearly highlighted by price movements on either side of the pond these past few hours,” Saxo Bank’s Hansen said.

The extent of the damage to the Freeport facility is not yet clear, but the fire could potentially knock out abut 16% of total US LNG export capacity “for an unknown period if the fire damage proves difficult to repair,” analysts at Evercore ISI said in a note. 

Dutch front-month gas, the European benchmark, traded 12% higher at 89.13 euros per megawatt-hour by 8:53 a.m. in Amsterdam. The contract dropped 16% over the previous six sessions. 

UK next-month futures jumped to 174.14 pence a therm. Send-outs from Britain’s LNG terminals, a key European destination for US cargoes, fell about 30% Thursday to the lowest since mid-March. 

Even with tepid consumption in most of Europe amid mild weather that means that energy companies may have to turn to gas inventories just as storage levels have improved recently, getting closer to historic averages. 

LNG buyers will probably start hunting for replacement shipments from the spot market, but there is a dwindling amount of supplies available, according to traders in Asia. The move is likely to boost already intense competition between Asia and Europe for the fuel. 

Gas flows from Norway rebounded after a one-day halt of the giant Troll field for annual tests on Wednesday, but are still below normal as seasonal works at a number of facilities continue. Shipments of Russian gas via the Nord Stream pipeline to Germany will continue to edge down on Thursday, grid data show.

©2022 Bloomberg L.P.

Pipelines unclogged, but Canadian crude now faces U.S. Gulf Coast glut


By Nia Williams and Arathy Somasekhar

(Reuters) - After long being deeply discounted for years because of a lack of pipelines, Canadian heavy crude is finally trading like a "North American" grade, moving in tandem with U.S. sour crudes sold on the Gulf Coast after Enbridge Inc expanded its Line 3 pipeline late last year.

Unfortunately for Canadian producers, the Gulf is awash in sour crude thanks to Washington's largest-ever release from the Strategic Petroleum Reserve (SPR) that will amount to 180 million barrels over a six-month period, in an attempt to tame high fuel prices after Russia's invasion of Ukraine.


© Reuters/ADREES LATIFFILE PHOTO: 

The Bryan Mound Strategic Petroleum Reserve is seen

 in an aerial photograph over Freeport, Texas

Millions of barrels of sour crude are flooding the market from storage caverns in Louisiana and Texas. Heavy grades like Mars and Poseidon at the U.S. Gulf Coast, the world's largest heavy crude refining center, are languishing.

Western Canada Select (WCS) sold more than 3,000 kilometres (nearly 2,000 miles) away in Hardisty, Alberta, is getting dragged down with them.

The discount on July WCS for delivery in the Hardisty crude hub reached more than $20 a barrel below the West Texas Intermediate benchmark last week, the widest since early 2020.


"It's not great timing," said Rory Johnston, founder of the Commodity Context newsletter based in Toronto. "The vast majority of what's coming out of the SPR is medium sour crude. It's hitting directly at that marginal pricing point for WCS."

The sour Gulf surplus is undermining what some market players expected to be a period of stronger WCS demand in Hardisty, as maintenance on oil sands projects reduces supply and as U.S. refineries exit turnarounds.

Other factors causing the WCS discount to widen include the high price of natural gas, which increases the cost of refining heavy crude, and increased demand for lighter products like gasoline, BMO Capital Markets analyst Randy Ollenberger said in a note.

PIPELINE CAPACITY

Canada exports around 4.3 million barrels per day (bpd) to the United States, according to U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) data, but until last year demand to ship crude on export pipelines exceeded capacity, leaving barrels bottlenecked in Hardisty.

In 2018, the discount on WCS in Hardisty blew out to more than $40 a barrel, prompting the Alberta government to restrict output.

Now there is sufficient pipeline capacity, WCS trades around the same level as comparable crudes like Mexico's Maya. This means Canadian producers get that value, minus the spot pipeline tariff to the U.S. Gulf Coast, which is roughly $10 a barrel.

Canadian production is forecast to rise 200,000 bpd by the end of 2022, according to the EIA. That could cause bottlenecks to re-emerge until the Trans Mountain pipeline expansion to Canada's Pacific coast is completed in 2023, adding 600,000 bpd of capacity, said RBN Energy analyst Robert Auers.

"However, a massive blowout in differentials, like we saw in 2018, is unlikely since producers are likely to be prepared for such a scenario and quickly ramp up crude-by-rail volumes in anticipation of such an event," Auers said.

(Reporting by Nia Williams; Editing by Marguerita Choy)

Gas exporters see growing support for East Coast plant in Canada

Brian Platt, 

Bloomberg News

Jun 7, 2022

Canada’s natural gas companies say there’s growing domestic support for new energy infrastructure to facilitate exports to Europe, even as the country pursues aggressive climate-change targets. 

Tim Egan, president of the Canadian Gas Association, said he believes the public is beginning to recognize that boosting exports to countries like Germany is the most significant way Canada will be able to help counteract Russia’s aggression against Ukraine. He cited recent polling that shows widespread approval for a shift in policy.

“I think Canadians are seeing what’s going on in Europe and are saying, ‘Look, there must be way we can help,’” Egan said by phone.

The energy crisis has given a boost to Canada’s fossil-fuel sector, which had been hemmed in for years by slumping prices and tightening environmental restrictions. 

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s government is attempting to balance exporting more energy to help supply world markets while still making progress on decarbonizing production. Trudeau has targeted a 42 per cent cut to oil and gas emissions by 2030.

While a major exporter of natural gas, Canada currently lacks a liquefied natural gas terminal that could directly supply allied nations across the Atlantic Ocean. 

BOOSTING PRODUCTION

A public opinion survey conducted in April by Leger Marketing Inc. for the gas association found 58 per cent of respondents supported exports of LNG from the east coast, compared to 17 per cent opposed and the remainder unsure. When Europe and the Ukraine war were specifically mentioned, support rose to 63 per cent, according to the online poll.

The same proportion, 58 per cent, also said they would back the construction of new east coast terminals to export gas, with 21 per cent in opposition. That includes 63 per cent support in Atlantic Canada, where any such facility would likely be located.

In the short term, Canada has pledged to increase its exports to the US to help indirectly free up supplies to Europe, aiming to boost shipments by the equivalent of 100,000 barrels per day by the end of the year.

There are other new developments being considered that could allow Canada to ship directly to Europe, but will face more environmental scrutiny and opposition.

Natural Resources Minister Jonathan Wilkinson has already pointed to one project that could be in operation by 2025. It would see Spain’s Repsol SA convert an existing LNG import facility in New Brunswick into an export terminal. Most of the infrastructure is already in place, meaning it may not need an extensive regulatory process, the minister said. 

However, Repsol currently uses the terminal to supply gas to the US, and it’s unclear if the company is prepared to make the switch. Supplying the terminal with gas from Western Canada would also require the existing pipeline network to be expanded, which could be politically difficult.

Other longer-term projects have been floated, but they would be new facilities and would require lengthy environmental assessments. Proposals include one in Nova Scotia by Pieridae Energy Ltd., one in Quebec by GNL Quebec Inc., and another in Canada’s easternmost province by LNG Newfoundland and Labrador Ltd.

Egan -- whose association represents Canadian distributors of natural gas -- said he’s heard plenty of interest in access to Canadian gas in his own conversations with diplomats from European countries.

“I’ve met with roughly half of them,” Egan said. “The overwhelming response is: Please try to do more, and more quickly. It’s the Europeans who are very blunt about this.”

Trudeau is scheduled to be in Germany later this month for a Group of Seven leaders summit, where European energy security is expected to be a top agenda item. 

Merchandise trade data released Tuesday shows Canada had $21.8 billion in natural gas exports over the last 12 months through April -- almost double pre-pandemic levels, and the highest since 2009.

Caisse de Depot to invest US$5B in Dubai port operator

Shaji Mathew, 

Bloomberg News 

Jun 6, 2022

Dubai is selling stakes in some of its most prized assets, including the port that helped transform the city into a global trade hub, to a Canadian fund as the emirate seeks to alleviate its debt burden. 

Caisse de Depot et Placement du Quebec agreed to invest US$5 billion in the Middle East’s biggest port and two industrial zones, according to a statement Monday. Other long-term investors will have the opportunity to acquire additional stakes for as much as US$3 billion by the end of the year. 

Under the agreement, the Montreal-based pension manager will invest US$2.5 billion in the Jebel Ali Port, Jebel Ali Free Zone and National Industries Park. It’s doing the deal through a new joint venture in which it will hold a stake of about 22 per cent, with the remainder of the transaction being financed by debt. 

The transaction values the assets, which are controlled by state-owned DP World, at about US$23 billion including debt. It builds on an existing venture between DP World and CDPQ formed in 2016 to invest in ports around the world. 

 

HIGH GROWTH

“The familiarity with the management team helped us in doing this transaction,” Emmanuel Jaclot, head of CDPQ’s infrastructure business, said in an interview Monday. “The zone of Middle East, Africa and South Asia is in a different growth trajectory, and this deal helps us to diversify our exposure to this high-growth region.”

CDPQ has committed financing for the US$2.5 billion of debt it’s putting into the deal, he said. The second tranche of US$3 billion is also likely to be equally split between equity and debt, Jaclot said. 

The fund is keen to further grow its infrastructure portfolio, which has doubled in the last three and half years, and transportation is a key focus area, according to Jaclot. 

DP World has been exploring the sale of equity stakes in certain assets as the emirate works to reduce the debt pile that helped finance the city’s growth. Dubai took DP World private in early 2020 to help the company better manage its borrowings. 

 

CUTTING DEBT

The deal “achieves our objective of reducing DP World’s net leverage” to below four-times net debt to earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization, Chief Executive Officer Sultan Ahmed Bin Sulayem said in the statement. “We believe this new partnership will enhance our assets and allow us to capture the significant growth potential of the wider region.”

With the investment, DP World “may be on track for an upgrade to BBB at Fitch as it could deleverage to below 5x net debt-to-Ebitda,” said Sharon Chen, a credit analyst at Bloomberg Intelligence. “Its balance sheet may strengthen” and the deal “may help repay US$7 billion of debt due 2023.”

• Remote work creating schism as option unavailable to many workers

Ross Marowits , 

The Canadian Press

Jun 6, 2022

Employees like Matt Fairbanks are one of the reasons the hospitality and restaurant industry is struggling to find workers even as the pandemic wanes. 

The 34-year-old former bartender has moved from slinging beers in Toronto to selling software to restaurants for a Saskatchewan company — which he does remotely. 

"I was always kind of one foot out of the hospitality industry and the pandemic really showed me how vulnerable the work was and the instability of it all," he said in an interview. 

Gone are the harrowing commutes, while the additional flexibility has improved his work-life balance. Fairbanks's company allows employees to work from out of the country for up to 90 days, take unlimited vacation and travel or work from anywhere in Canada. 

"I've actually encouraged a lot of my friends from the restaurant industry to kind of look at other options and change kind of how they're doing their life, too." 

Remote work flourished during the pandemic as companies temporarily closed their offices, but it has created a schism among Canadian workers. While 40 per cent of work in Canada can be done remotely, experts say, that means 60 per cent of workers are unable to access this benefit because they are required to be on-site. 

And that can create resentment and a backlash from workers viewed as essential, such as nurses, ambulance workers and retail employees, who were applauded during the pandemic but are unable to realize the benefits that come from working remotely, said change management expert Linda Duxbury, a Chancellor’s Professor of management at Carleton University’s Sprott School of Business, who has studied remote work for decades.

"The problem we're going to have here is we're going to create two classes of workers — the haves and the have nots," she said in an interview.

Those who can work remotely, particularly professionals such as accountants, lawyers and tech workers, flourished financially during the lockdowns while those forced to work on-site were often overworked or lost their jobs entirely amid reduced capacity and businesses that shuttered for good. 

That second group was told they were valued and important "and now they don't feel important," Duxbury said. 

The ability to work remotely has been one of the pivotal moments in the history of work, even though its application is generally limited to knowledge workers, said Erica Pimentel, assistant professor of accounting at the Smith School of Business at Queen’s University. 

"So when 60 per cent of the workforce is excluded from this massive change, well that's obviously going to have some implications for society," she said, because it's very inconsistent in how it affects the population at large. 

Duxbury cautions that the jury is still out on remote work, or what she calls "enforced work from home." She constantly hears from businesses seeking best practices and examples of what others are doing. But she said it's too early to assess the work style as everybody is experimenting with different models. 

"Remote work during the pandemic was one big giant experiment. Now we're moving to the second experiment, the follow up, which is hybrid work," she said. 

The appropriateness of remote work is very job dependent. It isn't conducive to brainstorming, socialization, coaching, mentoring, onboarding, team-building and client satisfaction. 

And while people who work from home put in far more hours — estimated at four to 10 additional hours per week — data suggests it hasn't increased productivity, Duxbury said. 

"Just because we worked 100 per cent remote for the last two plus years doesn't mean it's a sustainable model for a lot of people and a lot of jobs moving forward." 

Despite the drawbacks, remote work is being increasingly favoured, especially by generation Z, digital natives who have always had access to the internet and social media, said Pimentel. 

This cohort is coming of age and joining the workforce with new attitudes about employers' duty to them and how different parts of their lives fit together that is different from millennials, generation X and baby boomers, who are in many cases now the bosses.

"And so there's this generational like mismatch between bosses and their employees and everybody is unhappy." 

Many companies would rather have employees return to the office full-time, but are facing stiff opposition from workers who have grown to like working from home, said Duxbury. Faced with record job vacancies amid decades-low unemployment rates and threats of resignations, employers have been forced to be flexible. 

That means employees with a skill that's in demand are able to negotiate better work conditions than somebody without those skills. 

Tech workers, who accounted for most of the three per cent of Canadians who worked remotely before the pandemic, are among those in the driver's seat now.

Demands to work remotely have gone from being the exception to the rule because it's so hard to compete for talent, said Kristina McDougall, founder and president of executive search firm Artemis that specializes in tech employment. 

"Unless there is an absolute reason why you physically need to be present, like you're working on a robot or you need to be in the building, most organizations are having to be flexible," she said. 

The growth in remote work has also transformed where companies source their workforce because people can work anywhere and don't have to be near a company headquarters. That widens the jobs an individual can consider, but it also gives companies a wider pool of candidates as well as increased competition with other potential suitors. 

McDougall believes the movement to remote work is permanent for sectors like technology because the pandemic has proven that organizations can get things built with people working remotely. 

"You can't put the genie back in the bottle. People are now finding it trivial that they might need to go into an office every day." 

CIBC ramps up Big Banks' hunt for staff with wage pledge

Kevin Orland, Bloomberg News

Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce is boosting its minimum wage and pledging to push it even higher in the next few years as tight labor markets force banks into fierce competition for workers.   

The lender’s minimum wage will rise to $20 per hour in Canada and US$20 in the US in July, and the bank is committing to raise those figures to $25 and US$25 by the end of 2025, according to a statement from Chief Executive Officer Victor Dodig on Thursday. The bank is also providing a 3 per cent raise for workers in the six lowest levels of its pay scale next month. 

“These investments build on the steady, strategic targeted investments we have been making as we continue to ensure we pay competitively and recognize the contributions of our team, particularly at a time when the cost of living has been increasing,” Dodig said in the statement.

The bank’s minimum entry wage for merit-based pay team members is currently $17. The 3 per cent increase applies to roles including contact center agents, mobile adviser and investment adviser assistants.

Canada’s banks are boosting pay, especially for employees in the lower tiers of their pay scale, to attract and retain workers in a historically tight labor market. Canada’s unemployment rate hit a low of 5.2 per cent in April -- the lowest in data going back to 1976. 

Royal Bank of Canada said last month that it would spend more than $200 million on pay increases, benefits and other incentives to retain workers. The bank is raising base salaries by 3 per cent in the four lowest levels of its pay scale, accounting for almost half of its workforce. 

Bank of Nova Scotia is raising pay for workers in assistant manager roles and below, representing half of its Canadian employees, by 3 per cent as of June 20. The increase, announced to employees last month, is in addition to regular year-end salary adjustments. 

Bank of Montreal in October said it was raising its minimum wage for US branch and contact-center employees to US$18 an hour, a 20 per cent bump.

CIBC, Canada’s fifth-largest lender by assets, had about 47,800 employees as of the end of its most recent fiscal quarter, according to a company filing.

Molson Canada reaches tentative agreement with striking employees in Montreal

The Canadian Press

06/09/22

Guests walk past tanks at the Molson Coors Canada Fraser Valley Brewery in Chilliwack, British Columbia, Tuesday, Sept. 17, 2019. Bloomberg/Darryl Dyck

A tentative agreement has been reached between Molson Canada and the union representing some 425 workers in the Montreal area who have been on strike since March.

Both the Teamsters union and the Montreal-based beverage company confirmed the deal today.

Details of the tentative agreement are not being disclosed before they are presented to members.

The dispute has focused particularly on wages amid rampant inflation, along with pension and work scheduling issues.

Local union president Eric Picotte says the three aspects of the dispute "have been addressed to our satisfaction."


Union members went on strike on March 25 and then rejected a company offer. Workers will vote on the agreement-in-principle Friday evening, with approval leading to a return to work next week.

STRIKING MOLSON WORKERS REJECT OFFER AS PICKET LINES STRETCH INTO 11TH WEEK

Christopher Reynolds,

 The Canadian Press 

Jun 6, 2022

A worker arranges cans of Molson Coors Brewing Co. Canadian beer , Bloomberg

Hundreds of striking Molson Canada workers have rejected an offer from the beverage company, keeping more than 400 employees on the picket lines and bar owners with less on tap.

Teamsters Canada says the union local last week voted 92.4 per cent against a collective agreement put on the table by the 236-year-old brewery in Montreal.

Teamsters spokeswoman Catherine Cosgrove said concerns over salary remain front and centre amid rampant inflation, on top of pension and work scheduling issues.

"As good as it may seem, the workers have to make sure they are not losing money by accepting the contract as presented," she said. The parties did not sit down to negotiate until May 23, she added.

Molson Coors spokesman François Lefebvre said the rejected deal marks its final offer following the walkout on March 25, with managers now having to deliver beer themselves under a contingency plan.

"This offer was more than generous. And this offer would have made our employees have the highest paying jobs in the beer industry in Quebec," he said in an interview. "The bars are kind of being held hostage."

Renaud Poulin, head of the Quebec bar owners' association, says numerous pubs in more far-flung parts of the province are missing suds due to the 73-day strike.

"It’s pretty tough. Everyone’s missing beer. We don’t have all the brands," he said.

Quebec's labour tribunal issued an interim order last month requiring Molson Canada to stop employing replacement workers until a union complaint can be heard by the quasi-judicial body.

SNC engineers ordered back to office with one business day's notice: Union

Christopher Reynolds, The Canadian Press

A union representing SNC-Lavalin Group Inc. engineers has filed a complaint with the national labour board alleging bad-faith bargaining after a subsidiary ordered workers back to the office full-time with one business day's notice.

On June 2, Candu Energy Inc. mandated all employees to return to the workplace as of last Monday, a requirement the Society of Professional Engineers and Associates (SPEA) says amounts to a negotiating tactic amid a rotating strike launched May 29 at Ontario's Darlington nuclear plant, which Candu is refurbishing.

In a copy of the memo obtained by The Canadian Press, SNC executive vice-president Bill Fox reminds workers that a hybrid work model proposed to start Sept. 12 is "on the table," meaning that the abruptly announced "full-time in-office working policy could change when bargaining concludes."

Union spokesperson Denise Coombs said SNC-Lavalin's sudden move to bring roughly 900 engineers, scientists and technicians back to the office five days a week has sent them scrambling for living arrangements after more than two years of remote work. It amounts to an unfair labour practice given the bargaining context, according to the union's filing to the Canada Labour Relations Board.

"We all knew it would take time for people to reorganize their lives, obtain child care, move back to the city, all those things," Coombs said in an interview.

Both sides had agree on Sept. 12 as a start date for hybrid work, she said. The key points of discussion were whether it should be three days a week or two and a half on average, as well as salary, benefits and whether the union would be allowed to publicize certain internal documents.

The union received an offer for a collective agreement at a June 2 meeting, where the company also gave it a heads-up on its imminent back-to-the-office memo, Coombs said.

"The clear implication was that if SPEA did not accept Candu's June 2nd offer, Candu would retaliate and force employees to return to the office with just over one business day's notice and on a five-day per week basis," the filing states.

"We were gobsmacked," Coombs said.

SNC spokesperson Harold Fortin said the company hopes to reach a "fair, equitable and competitive agreement" with the Candu workers, who have been refurbishing reactors at the Darlington Nuclear Generating Station.

"With changes in provincial restrictions, people are becoming more accustomed to being together in indoor spaces and it is time to return to the physical workplace," he said in an email.

Fortin cited collaboration, training and integration of new hires among the benefits of returning to a shared workspace.

The Montreal-based company declined to comment on negotiations over the collective agreement, which expired Dec. 31.

Tensions between SNC and the union prompted Ontario Power Generation and Bruce Power to warn they will have to consider "alternate arrangements" if the two parties cannot provide "certainty" in their services.

"This letter should not be taken as support for either side as we respect the collective bargaining process, and at the same time expect to be treated as customers, not a negotiation point," OPG CEO Ken Hartwick and Bruce Power CEO Michael Rencheck said in a letter to SNC and the union dated Tuesday and obtained by The Canadian Press.

The provincial Crown corporation owns the Darlington nuclear plant, and SNC provides services to Bruce Power, including ongoing reactor refurbishment at the Bruce Nuclear Generating Station on Lake Huron.

Between 30 and 70 Candu workers daily have been conducting work stoppages out of roughly 700 on a strike rotation, the union said.

“Now we’re preparing for a large dispute," said union spokesperson Michelle Duncan. "We’re planning on a full-blown escalation.”

Peru communities to allow Las Bambas copper mine restart after 51-day shutdown

Reuters | June 9, 2022 

Las Bambas is one of the world’s largest copper mines. Credit: MMG.

A group of indigenous Peruvian communities on Thursday agreed to temporarily lift a protest against MMG Ltd’s Las Bambas copper mine that forced the company to halt operations for more than 50 days, the longest in the mine’s history.


According to meeting minutes signed on Thursday afternoon, the truce will last thirty days and the communities and the mine will engage in talks during that time.

Las Bambas will immediately seek to restart copper production, although executives have warned that coming back to full capacity will take days after a prolonged suspension.

Peru is the world’s No. 2 copper producer and Chinese-owned Las Bambas is one of the world’s largest producers of the red metal. The protest and shutdown had caused a major problem for the leftist administration of President Pedro Castillo, who is under pressure to grow the economy and had struggled for weeks to broker a restart deal.

Las Bambas alone accounts for 1% of Peru’s gross domestic product.

The protest was started by the communities of Fuerabamba and Huancuire in mid-April, who say Las Bambas had not honored all of its commitments with them. Both communities sold land to the company to make way for the mine, which opened in 2016 and is notorious for its recurrent social conflicts.

The two communities entered the mine and settled inside, forcing Las Bambas to halt operations. While Fuerabamba was evicted soon after that, Huancuire had managed to remain inside.

Related: Peru calls for new Las Bambas talks as police hint at eviction plan

Under the agreement, Huancuire will no longer protest inside mine property. During the truce, Las Bambas will also halt construction of its new Chalcobamba open pit mine, set to be located in land formerly owned by Huancuire.

At the meeting, community leaders also demanded jobs for community members and for the reshuffling of top mine executives, who they blame for causing social conflicts.

Las Bambas has agreed to an “evaluation and restructuring of the executives” who participate in negotiations with the local communities.

(By Marcelo Rochabrun; Editing by Mark Porter and David Gregorio)