Thursday, February 01, 2024

 

How does the majority population feel about policies for minorities?


The United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples was adopted by a large majority at the UN General Assembly in 2007


Peer-Reviewed Publication

UNIVERSITY OF KONSTANZ




On the international level, there is broad consensus that it is essential to recognize and implement Indigenous rights as well as to correct inequalities and historical injustices. Yet many nation-states struggle with effective implementation: "National policies play a decisive role in the implementation of these rights. At the same time, such policies also clearly depend on public opinion", explains Fabian Bergmann, a doctoral researcher in the Cluster of Excellence "The Politics of Inequality" at the University of Konstanz.

Study in Norway and Sweden
In a recent study, Bergmann compared the political preferences of the Sámi, an Indigenous population in Norway and Sweden, with those of the majority population in both countries. He studied the level of support for political measures that grant the Sámi rights in the areas of language, self-administration and land use. The results paint a differentiated picture: On the one hand, Sámi respondents strongly support political agendas that clearly promote the self-determination of the Indigenous population. On the other hand, respondents from the majority population are sceptical of such agendas, but do not completely reject the implementation of Indigenous rights. Instead, the majority population prefers policy measures that allow for limited implementation of Indigenous rights for the Sámi.

Although Sweden and Norway have different national policies on Sámi rights, the attitudes of the majority populations in both countries are surprisingly similar. This suggests that a country's political context is not the only deciding factor in the formation of these preferences, but that social identity also plays an important role. Public opinion on Indigenous peoples' policies is of great relevance for democratic societies: "It is difficult to pursue effective policies for implementing indigenous rights if there is not enough support from the majority population for doing so", Bergmann says.


Individual rights vs. collective rights
Against the backdrop of Norway and Sweden's reputation as committed advocates of human rights, he concludes: "The majority of the Swedish and Norwegian population supports international human rights conventions. Yet these conventions only define individual rights, whereas the rights of Indigenous peoples are collective rights. In order to generate a similar level of support among the majority population for both the collective protection of Indigenous peoples and individual human rights, a great deal of persuasion still seems to be necessary".

 

 

Key facts


Note to editors

Photos can be downloaded below:

 

Link: https://www.uni-konstanz.de/fileadmin/pi/fileserver/2024_EXTRA/wie_steht_die_mehrheit.jpeg

 

Caption: The library of the Sami Parliament in Norway. Picture: Denis Caviglia.

 

Link: https://www.uni-konstanz.de/fileadmin/pi/fileserver/2024_EXTRA/wie_steht_die_mehrheit_bergmann.jpg

 

Caption: Fabian Bergmann, PhD student at the Cluster of Excellence "The Politics of Inequali-ty" at the University of Konstanz. Image: Ines Janas.


Dortmund physicists develop highly robust time crystal


The team led by Dr. Alex Greilich has published its findings in the journal Nature Physics


 NEWS RELEASE 

TU DORTMUND UNIVERSITY

Dr. Alex Greilich 

IMAGE: 

DR. ALEX GREILICH WORKS AT THE CONDENSED MATTER RESEARCH FOCUS OF THE DEPARTMENT OF PHYSICS AT TU DORTMUND UNIVERSITY.

view more 

CREDIT: TU DORTMUND UNIVERSITY




A team from TU Dortmund University recently succeeded in producing a highly durable time crystal that lived millions of times longer than could be shown in previous experiments. By doing so, they have corroborated an extremely interesting phenomenon that Nobel Prize laureate Frank Wilczek postulated around ten years ago and which had already found its way into science fiction movies. The results have now been published in Nature Physics.

Crystals or, to be more precise, crystals in space, are periodic arrangements of atoms over large length scales. This arrangement gives crystals their fascinating appearance, with smooth facets like in gemstones. As physics often treats space and time on one and the same level, for example in special relativity, Frank Wilczek, physicist at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) and winner of the Nobel Prize in Physics, postulated in 2012 that, in addition to crystals in space, there must also be crystals in time. For this to be the case, he said, one of their physical properties would have to spontaneously begin to change periodically in time, even though the system does not experience corresponding periodic interference.

That such time crystals could be possible was the subject of controversial scientific debate for several years – but quick to arrive in the movie theater: For example, a time crystal played a central role in Marvel Studios’ movie Avengers: Endgame (2019). From 2017 onwards, scientists have indeed succeeded on a handful of occasions in demonstrating a potential time crystal. However, these were systems that – unlike Wilczek’s original idea – are subjected to a temporal excitation with a specific periodicity, but then react with another period twice as long. A crystal that behaves periodically in time, although excitation is time-independent, i.e. constant, was only demonstrated in 2022 in a Bose-Einstein condensate. However, the crystal lived for just a few milliseconds.

The Dortmund physicists led by Dr. Alex Greilich have now designed a special crystal made of indium gallium arsenide, in which the nuclear spins act as a reservoir for the time crystal. The crystal is continuously illuminated so that a nuclear spin polarization forms through interaction with electron spins. And it is precisely this nuclear spin polarization that then spontaneously generates oscillations, equivalent to a time crystal. The status of the experiments at the present time is that the crystal’s lifetime is at least 40 minutes, which is ten million times longer than has been demonstrated to date, and it could potentially live far longer.

It is possible to vary the crystal’s period over wide ranges by systematically changing the experimental conditions. However, it is also possible to move into areas where the crystal “melts”, i.e. loses its periodicity. These areas are also interesting, as chaotic behavior, which can be maintained over long periods of time, is then manifested. This is the first time that scientists have been able to use theoretical tools to analyze the chaotic behavior of such systems.

What looks like a flame is the measurement of the new time crystal: Each point corresponds to an experimental value, resulting in different views of the periodic dynamics of the nuclear spin polarization of the time crystal.

CREDIT

Alex Greilich/TU Dortmund University


 

HKUST researchers develop AI-enabled model to help mitigate global ammonia emissions from cropland by 38%


Contributing to UN’s Sustainable Development Goals


Peer-Reviewed Publication

HONG KONG UNIVERSITY OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY

Group photo of the HKUST research team 

IMAGE: 

(FROM LEFT) PROF. ALEXIS LAU, HEAD AND CHAIR PROFESSOR OF THE DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENT AND SUSTAINABILITY; PROF. JIMMY FUNG, CHAIR PROFESSOR OF THE DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENT AND SUSTAINABILITY IN THE ACADEMY OF INTERDISCIPLINARY STUDIES AND DEPARTMENT OF MATHEMATICS; MR. LI GENG, PHD STUDENT OF THE DIVISION OF EMERGING INTERDISCIPLINARY AREAS AND DR. ZHANG XUGUO, RESEARCH ASSOCIATE OF THE DEPARTMENT OF MATHEMATICS.  

view more 

CREDIT: HKUST




An international research team led by the Hong Kong University of Science and Technology (HKUST) has achieved a significant breakthrough by developing an artificial intelligence (AI) model that can help mitigate global ammonia (NH3) emission from agriculture.  

Harnessing the power of machine learning, this groundbreaking study not only revealed that global NH3 emissions from cropland are lower than previously estimated, but also demonstrated how optimizing fertilizer management can effectively reduce emissions by approximately 38%, without compromising the overall use of nitrogen fertilizers. It provides valuable insights for policymakers worldwide to address the United Nations' Sustainable Development Goals related to poverty eradication, food security, and sustainable agriculture.

The release of NH3 from various agricultural and industrial processes could cause air and water pollution, damaging the ecosystem and posing threats to human health. While NH3 itself is not a greenhouse gas, it can react in the soil and atmosphere, forming compounds like nitrous oxide, a potent greenhouse gas that contributes to climate change.

Notably, the production of three major crops – rice, wheat and maize – account for more than half of the global cropland NH3 emission. As the demand for food increases amid the world's population growth, it has become crucial to discover ways of reducing these emissions for sustainable development. However, the lack of accurate global-scale information makes it challenging for countries to implement effective emission reduction strategies tailored to their specific conditions.

To address this challenge, a research team led by Prof. Jimmy FUNG Chi-Hung, Chair Professor of HKUST’s Division of Environment and Sustainability in the Academy of Interdisciplinary Studies and Department of Mathematics, and Prof. ZHENG Yi from the School of Environmental Science and Engineering at the Southern University of Science and Technology (SUSTech), collected and compiled a dataset based on field observation data of NH3 emission rates spanning between 1985 and 2022. 

They subsequently trained an AI-powered computer model to estimate global NH3 emissions using the dataset while considering various geographical factors such as climate, soil characteristics, crop types, irrigation water, fertilizer, and tillage practices. This model is capable of generating customized fertilizer management plans for different regions.  For instance, in Asia, around 76% of wheat land is suitable for using enhanced-efficiency fertilizers (EEFs) to reduce NH3 emissions due to the influence of global warming, as temperature plays a pivotal role in NH3 emission from wheat land in Asia.

The AI model discovered that by optimizing fertilizer management, including adjusting the timing of fertilization, utilizing a specific blend of nutrients, and implementing suitable planting and tillage practices, it is possible to reduce global NH3 emissions from the three crops by up to 38%, with Asia having the highest NH3 reduction potential, followed by North America and Europe. This finding holds particular significance as this work has projected a 4.0% to 5.5% increase in global NH3 emissions from cropland over the 30-year period until 2060. Therefore, even achieving a fraction of this potential reduction would suffice to offset the projected increase.

Prof. Jimmy Fung said, "Global efforts to reduce emissions currently face significant obstacles, such as high costs and small farm sizes. The findings illustrate a global map with up-to-date data on global NH3 emissions, which can inform policymaking and management practices aimed at reducing haze and ensuring food security. This underscores the tremendous potential of utilizing big data and AI in promoting sustainable development."

The study, entitled “Fertilizer management for global ammonia emission reduction”, has been published in Nature, a leading multidisciplinary science journal. The research’s co-first authors included Mr. LI Geng, PhD student from HKUST and Dr. XU Peng, Research Assistant Professor from SUSTech. The research team comprised members from Tianjin University, Colorado State University, Peking University, Peking University Shenzhen Graduate School, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Beijing Forestry University, and Cornell University.

This groundbreaking study not only reveals that global NH3 emissions from cropland are lower than previously estimated, but also demonstrates optimizing fertilizer management can effectively reduce emissions by approximately 38%.

NH3 emission maps and mitigation potential of three major crops – rice, wheat, and maize.

Prof. Jimmy FUNG, Chair Professor of the Division of Environment and Sustainability in the Academy of Interdisciplinary Studies and Department of Mathematics (front row, middle); Prof. Alexis LAU, Head and Chair Professor of the Division of Environment and Sustainability (front row, right); Dr. ZHANG Xuguo, Research Associate of the Department of Mathematics (front row, right); Mr. LI Geng, PhD student of the Division of Emerging Interdisciplinary Areas (second row). 

CREDIT

HKUST

 

Improving cancer prevention among people experiencing homelessness


First systematic analysis as a basis for targeted prevention measures


Peer-Reviewed Publication

MEDICAL UNIVERSITY OF VIENNA





While people experiencing homelessness are more exposed to cancer-associated risk factors, there is a lack of awareness and structures for targeted cancer prevention. Yet people experiencing homelessness are twice as likely to be affected by cancer as people who are resident. Against this backdrop, an international team led by Igor Grabovac and Maren Jeleff from MedUni Vienna's Center for Public Health has systematically assessed the health challenges of this population group for the first time in order to create a scientifically sound basis for the development of preventive measures. Their review article has just been published in the top journal The Lancet Public Health.

By analysing 40 studies on aspects of the topic, it was possible for the first time to gain a comprehensive overview of the many factors that determine access to cancer preventive services for people experiencing homelessness. "We systematically collected the findings on both the cancer risk factors and the barriers to cancer prevention among people experiencing homelessness," says study leader Igor Grabovac (Department of Social and Preventive Medicine, Center for Public Health at MedUni Vienna), summarising the special feature of the review.

In addition to the obvious focus of people experiencing homelessness on basic needs such as food and a safe place to sleep, the deficits in cancer prevention include a lack of support from family and friends, a low level of education or a lack of infrastructure and privacy for preparing for examinations. However, studies have also shown that negative experiences with the healthcare system and staff can also be an obstacle. Sexual trauma, for example, combined with judgemental and unsympathetic treatment during the PAP test for the early detection of cervical cancer, leads to screening services not being used or no longer being used. "Conversely, sexually traumatised women experiencing homelessness were willing to have a PAP test if they had a trusting relationship with the provider and received sensitive care," says first author Maren Jeleff (Department of Social and Preventive Medicine, Center for Public Health at Medical University of Vienna), citing a not insignificant factor in cancer prevention in this group.

Considering living conditions and experiences
How many people experiencing homelessness use or are able to use the opportunities offered by screening is not recorded. As studies show, for example, in the case of breast and bowel cancer screening in the USA, less than 50 per cent of this group have access to it. As early detection is essential for the prognosis of cancer in particular, cancer mortality is also significantly higher in this group. The fact that the incidence of cancer among homeless people is twice as high as among the housed population can be explained by the higher prevalence of risk factors. Substance abuse, especially tobacco and alcohol, high-risk sexual practices and increased exposure to environmental risk factors such as sunlight or pollutants have a greater impact on this group. "The study results show that people experiencing homelessness are highly exposed to certain cancer risk factors. Accordingly, there is an urgent need for prevention measures that are tailored to the living conditions and experiences of this group," says Igor Grabovac in the run-up to further research and initiatives. The review was conducted as part of the large-scale EU project "CANCERLESS" (Cancer prevention and early detection among the homeless population in Europe: Co-adapting and implementing the Health Navigator Model), which is also led by Grabovac.

 

Positive associations revealed as key driver in maintaining soil biodiversity and ecological networks


Peer-Reviewed Publication

CHINESE ACADEMY OF SCIENCES HEADQUARTERS





In a study published in PNAS, researchers from the Institute of Soil Science of the Chinese Academy of Sciences, the Institute of Natural Resources and Agrobiology of Seville (IRNAS), and the University of Cádiz analyzed 151 ecosystems across six continents, delving into the intricate coexistence network among diverse species including bacteria, fungi, protists, and invertebrates. Through this work, they linked biotic coexistence relationships with global biodiversity maintenance for the first time, thus offering insights into the understanding of soil biodiversity and its ecological networks. 

This study challenges traditional views that predominantly focus on competitive interactions in ecological networks by showing that facilitative networks are more common in soil ecosystems than previously thought. This paradigm shift stems from recognizing that soil processes, such as decomposition of organic matter, necessitate cooperation among various species, thus suggesting that facilitation might play a more significant role than researchers had realized. However, empirical evidence supporting this hypothesis has been scarce.  

In addition, this study closes a gap in understanding the basic structures of biotic associations that form complex soil organism communities. While research on plant and animal networks has explored network motifs—i.e., associations among species triads—and their ecological significance, the application of these motifs to soil networks had not been explored. This study thus offers insights into whether soil networks differ significantly from those of other taxa or whether they follow universal ecological principles.  

Moreover, this study demonstrates that soil networks characterized by higher levels of positive facilitation foster richer soil taxa and more stable biotic coexistence patterns, even when accounting for variables like soil properties, climate, and spatial factors. It identifies temperature seasonality as a predictor of the global distribution of positively facilitated soil network modules, offering new perspectives on the widespread nature of facilitative associations among soil organisms and their pivotal role in sustaining global soil biodiversity.  

"This study underlines that positive facilitation is predominant in soil microbial associations and is vital for the diversity and stability of soil biological networks. This globally consistent pattern underscores the role of cooperative interactions in complex soil networks,” said Prof. CHU Haiyan, one of the authors of this study.  

Prof. Manuel, another author, pointed out that the complexity of ecological networks, encompassing both specific and higher-order associations across multiple trophic levels, underscores the need to consider unexplored variables in biodiversity and functioning, and rare species and weak correlations could be included in further soil network studies.  

In conclusion, this study establishes facilitation as a key driver in maintaining diverse and stable soil networks, which is crucial for supporting soil biodiversity and enhancing ecological stability amidst global change.  

 

Trading between households in smart energy communities: the more the merrier?


Recently published study sheds light on key questions about energy trading in local communities


Peer-Reviewed Publication

CENTRUM WISKUNDE & INFORMATICA

Portrait of Valentin Robu 

IMAGE: 

VALENTIN ROBU IS A SENIOR RESEARCHER IN THE INTELLIGENT AND AUTONOMOUS SYSTEMS (IAS) GROUP OF CENTRUM WISKUNDE & INFORMATICA. HE IS ALSO A PROFESSOR IN ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE FOR SMART, DECENTRALISED ENERGY SYSTEMS AT TECHNICAL UNIVERSITY EINDHOVEN.

view more 

CREDIT: CENTRUM WISKUNDE & INFORMATICA




Our energy systems are undergoing rapid change. Many households are generating electricity with solar panels, and there are new sources of demand and storage, such as charging electric vehicles and home batteries. Local prosumers (energy consumers who also generate and store energy) are taking control of their own energy supply. This development is prompting the creation of energy communities and micro-grids, such as the SchoonSchip community in the north of Amsterdam.

Energy communities allow consumers to generate, use and trade energy locally. In this way, they are no longer dependent on large energy suppliers. By bringing energy generation closer to where it is needed, these communities also help to alleviate grid congestion, which is a growing challenge for grid operators.

 

Unanswered questions

There are two main models for energy communities. In the first, prosumers individually control their own energy resources and then trade with each other. In the other model, multiple prosumers share and jointly control energy resources, such as wind turbines, solar panels or community-owned batteries. In both models, distributed AI techniques are often used to automate and optimize peer-to-peer (P2P) exchanges.

Yet these models raise many unanswered questions: how do you honestly share the costs and benefits of generating energy from shared assets? Other important questions are: how many prosumers need to be involved to make P2P trading economically viable, and what are the various reasons for people with different energy consumption needs to participate in such projects?

Large-scale real data

A recent study, to be published in Applied Energy on 1 February 2024, aims to shed light on some of these key questions. The researchers used large-scale real data from the UK. Co-author Valentin Robu, a researcher at CWI and TU Eindhoven, explains: "The focus of our study was on the marginal benefits of peer-to-peer energy exchange contracts, using a method of measurement known as 'Gains from Trade'. We found that as the number of peer-to-peer energy contracts increases and more prosumers enter the market, diversity in consumption profiles quickly decreases, leading to significantly diminishing returns. This means that most of the Gains from Trade from an energy community can be achieved if only a fraction of the community members participate. Especially those members with the most different demand profiles from other community members."

"Our study also explores how an AI technique called multi-agent systems can be used to automate and optimize P2P negotiations so that both parties benefit from the energy exchange."

Collaboration

The study was the result of a collaboration between researchers at CWI (the National Research Institute for Mathematics & Computer Science in Amsterdam), Delft University of Technology & Eindhoven University of Technology in the Netherlands, together with researchers at University of Glasgow (UK) and Princeton University (USA). It was part of the Marie Curie TESTBED-2 project, funded by the European Union, under the Marie Curie Staff Exchange Programme (MSCA-RISE).

The paper is published open access (free of charge) in the Elsevier Applied Energy journal: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0306261923015374.

 

Tidal landscapes a greater carbon sink than previously thought


Peer-Reviewed Publication

UNIVERSITY OF GOTHENBURG

Mangrove trees 

IMAGE: 

MANGROVES ARE MAJOR CARBON SINKS. NEW RESEARCH SHOWS THAT THE CLIMATE MITIGATION EFFECT IS EVEN BETTER THAN PREVIOUSLY THOUGHT.

view more 

CREDIT: LUKE JEFFREY




Mangroves and saltmarshes sequester large amounts of carbon, mitigating the greenhouse effect. New research from the University of Gothenburg shows that these environments are perhaps twice as effective as previously thought.

Natural habitats flooded by the tide form ecosystems that captures large amounts of carbon, which can help to mitigate climate change. Carbon dioxide is stored in the biomass and in the muddy soils. Therefore, several governments have launched blue carbon market initiatives to encourage landowners to restore and preserve mangrove and saltmarsh ecosystems, similar to the rainforest.

Large flow of bicarbonate

A new research report from the University of Gothenburg shows that the climate mitigation effect is even better than previously thought. 

”We have uncovered additional stored carbon in mangrove forests and salt marshes. Our new findings show that much of the carbon is exported to the ocean bound as bicarbonate as the tide recedes and remains dissolved in the ocean for thousands of years. Bicarbonate stabilises the pH and can reduce ocean acidification. This contribution has previously been overlooked," says Gloria Reithmaier, a researcher in marine chemistry at the University of Gothenburg.

Bicarbonate is harmless and is used in baking powder, among other things. In the oceans, carbonate and bicarbonate are used to build shells and coral skeletons.

Measured all over the world

Reithmaier and her colleagues enlisted the help of scientists from 12 different countries to analyse intertidal carbon transport in 45 mangrove swamps and 16 salt marshes around the world. When they accounted for bicarbonate export from the ecosystems to the ocean, the size of the carbon trap in these ecosystems doubled.

”Our results showed that bicarbonate exports were equal to, or even surpassed, the amount of carbon stored in the soil. Therefore, previous estimates of these blue carbon sources have underestimated the potential of mangroves and saltmarshes to mitigate climate change," says Gloria Reithmaier, adding:

”Our results show that blue carbon ecosystems are more effective in mitigating climate change than previously thought. It is now even more important to protect and restore mangrove and salt marsh ecosystems.”

 

Relocated songbirds can successfully learn the diversity of song they need to survive


Peer-Reviewed Publication

UNIVERSITY OF PLYMOUTH

Cirl buntings 

IMAGE: 

A NEW STUDY EXPLORED HOW CIRL BUNTINGS RELOCATED AS PART OF CONSERVATION PROGRAMMES CAN SUCCESSFULLY LEARN THE SONG REPERTOIRES THEY NEED TO COMMUNICATE – AND ULTIMATELY SURVIVE – IN THE WILD

view more 

CREDIT: BEN ANDREW (RSPB-IMAGES.COM)




Nestling songbirds relocated as part of conservation programmes successfully learn the song repertoires they need to communicate – and ultimately survive – in the wild, a new study has found.

The research, published in the journal Conservation Science and Practice, is the first to follow translocated songbird chicks over time to assess their song development.

It focused on populations of cirl buntings (Emberiza cirlus), taken from a number of sites in Devon before being hand-reared and then reintroduced in Cornwall as part of a major programme co-ordinated by the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB) between 2006 and 2011.

Cirl buntings are songbirds, which means they need to learn their songs from adult tutors and the relocated birds were all chicks that were hand-reared.

As a result, in addition to RSPB officers examining the overall success of the conservation programme, scientists recorded the birds’ song to assess the song repertoires of the relocated birds.

Recordings at the release site in Cornwall in 2011 showed the population contained a reduced number of song types and individuals sang a wide range of abnormal song types, all very different to the source populations in Devon.

This was not that surprising given they had only had a CD with a single cirl bunting song played to them while being hand-reared.

However, on following up in 2019 the Cornwall population’s song repertoire had reached similar levels to the source populations in Devon, with song types also typical to those found within other cirl bunting populations.

This showed that despite an issue with the songs produced in 2011, termed by scientists as a cultural bottleneck, the population recovered as it increased in size.

It also suggests that if the translocation of nestlings is deemed necessary for conservation purposes, it may not lead to long-term problems for communication and population persistence.

The research was carried out by conservation experts at the University of Plymouth, the RSPB, and Manchester Metropolitan University.

Dr Sarah Collins, Associate Professor in Animal Behaviour and Welfare at the University of Plymouth, is the study’s lead author. She said: “Song diversity is a crucial feature among songbird populations, and although it has been examined as part of relocation or reintroduction programmes in the past, there were no studies on what happens when you translocate nestling songbirds before they have had a chance to learn their song. Although we found translocating nestlings led to a short-term lack of song diversity, the population recovered from this to produce normal songs.

“This is ultimately a positive conservation story that we can learn from for the future. What we found with these cirl buntings, however, cannot be guaranteed to occur in all song learning birds. So we believe the song development of a species needs to be considered in translocation projects, and that could include playing species typical song to young chicks before they are released in the wild.”

The reintroduction programme in Cornwall was a collaboration between the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB), Natural England, National Trust, Zoological Society of London and Paignton Zoo.

It was spurred by the loss of cirl buntings from the county, and over the space of six years several groups of chicks were released at a site in Cornwall.

In the decade from 2007 to 2016, the number of breeding pairs in the reintroduction location observed by the RSPB project team had risen from nine to 65.

Cath Jeffs, the RSPB’s then Cirl Bunting Project Manager and a co-author of the new study, said: “Cirl buntings have been a pioneering conservation success story. That they are singing once again in Cornwall is testament to the hard work by the many people involved. That they are singing like cirl buntings demonstrates how wonderful nature is.”