Tuesday, June 23, 2026

China’s Antimony Ban Sent Prices Up 2,600%. Rare Earths Are Next

In 2024, China announced export controls on antimony.      It’s a metal most people have never heard of, but antimony goes into more than 200 types of military munitions.

Within weeks, the price went from $1,400 per ton to $38,000 — a 2,600% spike — and shipments to the United States fell 97%.

Today, Beijing is setting up for something bigger. And REalloys (NASDAQ: ALOY) — a U.S.-based mine-to-magnet rare earth company — has spent years getting ready for it. 

The company holds an exclusive 80% offtake from the only non-Chinese rare earth processing plant in North America capable of processing heavy rare earths. And it operates its own metallization facility in Euclid, Ohio, and plans to source feedstock from the U.S., Canada, Brazil, Kazakhstan, and Greenland, which means no Chinese inputs at any step. 

The heavy rare earth materials at the center of China’s next mineral weaponization, like dysprosium and terbium, are precisely the ones REalloys has spent years positioning to supply. 

While they’re less widely discussed than light rare earths, heavy rare earths are the metals inside every drone motor, every missile guidance system, and every fighter jet engine the Pentagon fields. And in recent years, we’ve already seen Beijing tightening the screws on what are quickly becoming the most important elements on earth.

China’s Pattern Is Years in the Making

What happened with antimony wasn’t an isolated incident. It was just the latest chapter in a long history of escalations from China that have only been picking up steam over the past three years.

In July 2023, Beijing imposed export licensing on gallium and germanium — two metals critical to semiconductors and infrared optics.

In August 2024, they did the same with antimony before prices spiked 2,600% and shipments collapsed. In December 2024, China escalated to an outright ban on gallium, germanium, and antimony exports to the United States.

Then in April 2025, Beijing put seven heavy rare earth elements under export licensing — including dysprosium and terbium, the two materials that keep magnets stable at the extreme temperatures inside jet engines and drone motors.

And in October 2025, China went even further, restricting the export of rare earth processing technology itself and asserting jurisdiction over any foreign-made product containing even trace amounts of Chinese-origin rare earth content.

Every one of those moves has made REalloys’ supply chain — built entirely outside China’s reach — more valuable than it was the day before.

Each wave has been bigger than the last. And each one has targeted materials deeper in the supply chain, harder to replace, and more critical to Western defense, which is why the pricing data is already starting to tell the story.

It’s Already Showing Up in the Numbers

You don’t have to guess what the rare earth version of the antimony spike will look like. The early signals are already in the pricing data.

Terbium — one of the two heavy rare earths at the core of military-grade magnets — is up 103% just this year. Dysprosium and terbium from non-Chinese sources are now trading at three to four times Chinese domestic prices — a split that didn’t exist two years ago.

Meanwhile, China’s rare earth magnet exports to the United States fell 22.5% year-over-year in the first two months of 2026, even as overall magnet exports rose.

A two-price world is forming, which threatens militaries all across the Western world. It’s one where you’re charged one rate if you buy from China, and a dramatically higher one if you don’t. That gap? It’s only widening.

REalloys operates entirely on the non-Chinese side of that divide. That means its output could be priced at a premium, and its supply chain is one of the only ones that can actually deliver.

How Far Ahead is REalloys?     

Antimony showed what happens when a single mineral gets weaponized and there’s no backup supplier. REalloys has been building the backup for heavy rare earths, and the head start has put them as far as three to seven years ahead of the competitors trying to start today.

The processing side runs through the Saskatchewan Research Council’s Rare Earth Processing Facility, where REalloys has already secured the majority of output under an exclusive operating agreement. From there, the Company plans to send the oxides to Euclid, Ohio, where the company plans to convert them into the defense-grade metals and alloys as magnet-ready inputs that contractors actually purchase.

On the feedstock side, REalloys (NASDAQ: ALOY) has already signed an agreement with the highest-grade rare earth deposit in the United States, adding to its existing sources in Canada, Brazil, Kazakhstan, and Greenland. That means there’s no single point of failure and no Chinese technology, chemicals, or equipment at any critical step.

Plus, earlier this year, the company demonstrated a patent-pending process that eliminates dangerous hydrofluoric acid from a key stage of rare earth metal production — potentially cutting costs further, simplifying its infrastructure, and removing one of the world’s most hazardous chemicals in the process.

Put it all together, and you've got a company with a processing facility already in staged commissioning     , a heavy rare earth metallization plant in development,           feedstock diversified across Western-allied nations     , and a patent-pending breakthrough in its lab. And the deadline that makes it all matter even more is now less than a year away.

The Deadline That Makes All of This Urgent

After years of watching supply chain cracks expand across the defense sector, the Pentagon finally drew a line in the sand. 

That's because the new DFARS procurement rules taking effect January 1, 2027, will ban Chinese-origin rare earths from the entire U.S. defense supply chain — every stage from mining through finished product.

Billions in annual Pentagon contracts are expected to require fully compliant sourcing by the cutoff, forcing every defense prime from Lockheed Martin to Northrop Grumman to prove their heavy rare earth supply chains are clean before the clock runs out.

For Lockheed Martin (NYSE: LMT), that means the rare earth materials needed in everything from F-35 fighter jets and missile defense systems to military satellites will need to be sourced from outside China. The company got a preview of these risks in 2022, when F-35 deliveries were temporarily halted after a Chinese-origin alloy was discovered in a magnet used in the aircraft. But the Pentagon's 2027 rare earth restrictions go much further, extending scrutiny across the defense supply chain rather than a single component.

All of this is happening as the Pentagon’s demand for rare earth magnets is expected to triple by 2030 to roughly 10,000 tons annually.

That demand surge is already showing up in production schedules of the defence giants. Northrop Grumman (NYSE: NOC) is currently ramping up manufacturing of the B-21 Raider stealth bomber, one of the Pentagon's most important modernization programs, while simultaneously expanding output across its missile and space systems businesses. Every additional aircraft, missile, and satellite ultimately increases demand for the same rare earth materials that REalloys has zeroed in on.

In March, the company closed an upsized $50 million public offering, directing roughly $40 million toward building the largest heavy rare earth metallization facility outside China.

Just days later, the company appointed Joe Kasper — the former Chief of Staff to the U.S. Secretary of Defense — as Chair of its Advisory Board. He will be advising Board Members like highly decorated retired U.S. Army four-star general and foreign policy expert, General Jack Keane, and Board Chair, Steve duMont, who serves as President of GM Defense.

And all of that happened in a single month — the capital, the facility, and a former Pentagon Chief of Staff leading the advisory board. It seems that while REalloys has been building for this moment for years, it's arriving at exactly the right time, with the DFARS deadline arriving just 9 months from now.

What the Antimony Spike Should Have Taught Us

Antimony wasn't exactly a mineral that kept anyone up at night before 2024. But when China cut exports, prices jumped 2,600%, and suddenly every weapons manufacturer in the country realized they were holding a single thread connected to Beijing. 

The problem is, heavy rare earths make antimony look small by comparison. Dysprosium and terbium are woven through every major weapons system in the American arsenal, including drone navigation, missile guidance, and fighter jet engines running at extreme temperatures. 

Meanwhile, defence companies are aggressively increasing weapons production and driving demand for these critical resources. General Dynamics (NYSE: GD)’s Virginia-class propulsion motors are named outright in the Pentagon’s new rare earth magnet procurement rules, the same NdFeB and samarium-cobalt magnets at the center of this entire supply chain push, and the Navy has been steadily shifting toward permanent magnet motors on later submarines for quieter, more stealthy operation. 

And China doesn't just control most of the ore—they control the refining as well, which means they have the same leverage with rare earths that they just showed they're willing to use with antimony.

With the DFARS deadline now months away, defense contractors could soon be cut off from Chinese rare earths across the entire supply chain. Most of them still don't have a domestic source ready to go. 

REalloys has been building the answer while everyone else is just now becoming aware of how severe the problem is. It has the metallurgical expertise and the operational partnerships. As 2027 gets closer and the supply pinch hits, that's the kind of position that could change the entire landscape for domestic rare earth production.

By. Michael Kern

 

China blacklists MP Materials, USA Rare Earth in critical minerals war

Mountain Pass, the only rare earth mine in the US. Credit: Plazak, Wikimedia Commons, under licence CC BY-SA 3.0.

China has imposed export controls on two US rare earth companies central to the US efforts to build alternative supply chains for critical minerals used in advanced manufacturing and defence.

MP Materials (NYSE: MP) and USA Rare Earth (NASDAQ: USAR) were added to China’s export control list on Monday, restricting access to Chinese dual-use goods and technologies that could have commercial or military applications.


The designation bars Chinese exporters from supplying such items to the companies and prohibits organizations or individuals in any country from transferring Chinese-origin dual-use products to them. Beijing also added eight other US companies, including drone, robotics and aerospace firms, to the same list.

Trade tensions

The decision signals that tensions between Washington and Beijing remain elevated despite recent efforts by US President Donald Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping to stabilize relations. It also highlights China’s continued leverage over rare earth supply chains, even as Western governments invest heavily in alternative production.

MP Materials, which operates the Mountain Pass rare earth mine in California and counts the Pentagon as a shareholder, has expanded processing capacity over the past year.

USA Rare Earth is also advancing domestic production as the US seeks to reduce dependence on Chinese supplies. Both companies accelerated development plans after China imposed export controls on key rare earth elements and magnets in April 2025.

Supply chains

The latest restrictions come days after Group of Seven countries agreed to cap imports of rare earths from any single country outside the bloc and its partners at less than 60% by 2030. The measure is designed to reduce reliance on China, which dominates global production and processing of many critical minerals.

The practical impact on the two companies remains unclear. Both have worked to localize supply chains and reduce exposure to Chinese inputs, though many downstream industries still rely heavily on materials and technologies sourced from China.

The move follows a series of escalating trade and security measures. Earlier this month, the Pentagon added several Chinese companies to a blacklist over alleged military ties.

China responded on Monday by also placing 10 US defence firms on its own control list, barring exports of Chinese-made products with potential military applications.

China’s foreign minister calls on BRICS to strengthen strategic minerals cooperation

Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi. Image source: U.S. Department of State

China’s Foreign Minister Wang Yi called on BRICS countries on Tuesday to jointly respond to global challenges from Ebola to AI, and to strengthen cooperation on strategic mineral resources, according to a statement from his ministry.

Wang told a meeting in India that BRICS countries should respond to global energy and food security challenges and unite to respond to the Ebola epidemic in Africa.

The countries should resolutely combat all forms of terrorism and oppose the weaponization of outer space, Wang added, while also calling for close oversight of AI risks.

Speaking at a security meeting in New Delhi, China’s top diplomat said the group should “hold high the banner of multilateralism” and firmly oppose unilateralism and protectionism.

“BRICS members need to take the lead in speaking up for justice and delivering fair outcomes, and elevate their standing and role in international affairs,” Wang said.

He also urged the BRICS to back dialogue and political solutions to resolve disputes and hotspot issues.

Touching on the US-Iran conflict, Wang said it underscored the importance of upholding international rules, respecting sovereignty and adapting to evolving forms of warfare such as cyber and information warfare.

“Traditional and non-traditional security threats are increasingly intertwined, making it timely for BRICS to strengthen dialogue and cooperation on security affairs,” Wang told the meeting, according to a separate report from state agency Xinhua.

(By Shi Bu and Liz Lee; Editing by Gareth Jones)


China’s rare earths curbs extend pressure on supply to Japan

Stock image.

China’s exports to Japan of several rare earths used for powerful magnets were negligible in May, data showed on Saturday, extending a months-long supply squeeze caused by a diplomatic dispute with Beijing over Taiwan.

Japan’s rare earth magnet makers are the world’s biggest outside China but like those elsewhere are overwhelmingly reliant on Chinese imports of key so-called heavy rare earths.

Export controls on rare earths like dysprosium, terbium, and yttrium — used in specialty alloys and coatings– and several niche minor metals have become one of China’s most effective diplomatic levers.

There have been no shipments to Japan of terbium or dysprosium oxide since November and only tiny shipments of yttrium oxide since December, Chinese customs data for May released on Saturday showed.

Beijing introduced export controls on types of heavy rare earths and the magnets that contain them in April 2025. It publicly tightened controls on exports to Japan in January, and twice again the following month, targeting major conglomerates.

Comments on Taiwan by Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi in November prompted a diplomatic breakdown between Beijing and Tokyo.

The export curbs have disrupted the availability of some magnets and led to a rush of Japanese investment into new supply of heavy rare earths.

Most recently, rare earth magnet manufacturer Shin-Etsu Chemical said it was planning to build its first new rare earth refining facility since 2008.

Japan is also the world’s largest consumer of chip metal gallium outside of China. It received some respite in May, with the first big shipment sent from China since December.

China’s exports of rare earth magnets were close to their historic levels in previous months, but were down 35% month on month in May, to their lowest volume since the same month a year earlier.

(By Solomon Cefai)


Iluka secures $1.2B loan from Australia for rare earths refinery

Reference image by Iluka Resources Ltd.

Iluka Resources said on Tuesday that the Australian government has provided a A$1.65 billion ($1.15 billion) non-recourse loan to build the Eneabba rare earths refinery in Western Australia.

Iluka said the loan access was confirmed by Export Finance Australia, the country’s export credit agency.

The funding comes as Western countries look to reduce their dependence on rare earths from China, the largest producer, for the materials that are vital for electric vehicles and other technologies.

Iluka expects the first tranche of the funding, comprising A$1.25 billion, to be fully drawn by 2026-end, when Eneabba is expected to be 75% complete. The refinery is currently over 50% complete, the company said.

Eneabba will be Australia’s first fully integrated rare earths refinery, according to the company.

The miner said Civmec has been awarded a contract for structural, mechanical, piping, electrical and instrumentation (SMPEI) works at the refinery.

Separately, Iluka said it had concluded a binding agreement for the supply of magnet rare earth oxides to an unnamed global automotive company.

The agreement has an initial term of four years, and represents about 10% of Iluka’s planned production over that period.

Iluka expects revenue over the contract period to be $155 million minimum and $172 million assuming prices forecast by the industry.

($1 = 1.4290 Australian dollars)

(By Nichiket Sunil; Editing by Sahal Muhammed)


UK to invest $66 million in critical minerals to reduce import reliance

Britain will invest £50 million ($66 million) to boost domestic production of critical minerals, the government said on Monday, as it seeks to reduce reliance on concentrated global supply chains and strengthen economic resilience.

The funding will support projects across extraction, processing and recycling, aimed at securing materials used in products ranging from smartphones and fridges to electric vehicle batteries.

The move builds on more than £200 million already committed to the sector.

Industry minister Chris McDonald was set to launch the program during a visit to a hub for industrial research in northeast England, where companies are developing technologies for metal recovery and processing.

Britain is stepping up efforts to secure supplies of critical minerals as demand rises and China retains a dominant position, accounting for about 70% of rare earth mining and 90% of refining.

“Critical minerals are vital for our national security,” McDonald said.

Recent progress includes the opening of Britain’s first commercial rare earth magnet plant in 25 years, operated by Mkango Resources’ HyProMag unit in Birmingham, which uses recycled materials to produce magnets for electric motors and other technologies.

Britain has also sought to diversify access through partnerships with allies including the United States and South Korea, focusing on collaboration in supply chains, processing capacity and investment flows.

The new funding will be split across three pillars, including £20 million for a rare earth magnet hub, £25 million for an accelerator program to help scale projects, and up to £5 million for a platform to aggregate industry demand and unlock private investment.

($1 = 0.7564 pounds)

(By Sam Tabahriti; Editing by William James)

Energy Fuels to buy Germany’s VAC as rare earths magnet race heats up


Wet concentrator plant. (Image: Screenshot from Energy Fuels’ video.)

Rare earths producer Energy Fuels (NYSEAMERICAN: UUUU) will buy Germany’s Vacuumschmelze in a $1.9 billion cash-and-stock deal to become one of the world’s largest non-Chinese producers of magnets used in the aerospace, defence and renewable energy sectors.

US-based Energy Fuels is joining the race to capitalise on efforts by Washington and allies to wean themselves off market leader China, which has curtailed exports of critical minerals as trade tensions with the West have intensified.

G7 leaders said last week that they aim to reduce dependence on any one supplier for ​rare earths and permanent magnets to less than 60% by 2030, with an ultimate goal of 50%.

Energy Fuels, a producer of uranium for the nuclear power industry, said it will pay private equity firm Ara Partners $718 million in cash plus 65.853 million newly issued Energy Fuels common shares for Vacuumschmelze ONEQPV.UL, also known as VAC.

Shares in Energy Fuels fell as much as 6.2% in premarket trading and were last down 2.3%.

CENTURY-OLD MAGNET PRODUCER

VAC is more than 100 years old and supplies magnets to more than 1,000 customers, including General Motors GM.N, from facilities in Germany, the U.S., Malaysia and other countries.

While the likes of MP Materials MP.N and USA Rare Earth USAR.O have built their own magnets businesses, Energy Fuels preferred to buy an existing producer, CEO Ross Bhappu told Reuters.

“This is not an easy business to get into. It’s not an easy one to understand,” said Bhappu, who took the helm in April.

“It also takes a long time to get customer acceptance of those magnet products. VAC has that customer acceptance.”

Ara Partners will become one of the largest Energy Fuels shareholders with a roughly 20% stake and a seat on the board when the deal closes early next year.

Bhappu said that Energy Fuels intends to integrate VAC and its 3,600 workers, including CEO Erik Eschen, but keep the Vacuumschmelze brand name.

Existing VAC plants, including one in China, will stay open, with expansions planned for a facility that opened late last year in South Carolina, Bhappu added.

(Reporting by Pooja Menon in Bengaluru and Ernest Scheyder in Houston; Editing by Tasim Zahid and David Goodman)


EU courts Brazil as strategic partner in global race for critical minerals



The European Union is turning to Brazil as a strategic partner in its push to diversify its critical mineral supplies, offering a deal that it says will be beneficial to Brazil’s development goals, EU Commissioner for International Partnerships Jozef Sikela told Reuters on Saturday.

The commissioner visited the rare earth research and processing center of Australian mining company Viridis Mining and Minerals, in Poços de Caldas, in the southeastern state of Minas Gerais, one of four priority projects selected to accelerate collaboration between the EU and Brazil.

Sikela said the European approach emphasizes sustainable business and local rare earth processing, aligning with Brazil’s push to export higher-value processed minerals instead of raw materials from a sector in which it holds the world’s second-largest critical mineral reserves.

“What is extremely important is that also Brazil moves from the like a low-margin business so basically that the value is created here in the country,” the commissioner said in an interview during his visit to the Viridis facility, highlighting that Brazil is currently the EU’s most strategic partner in Latin America and a growing economy.

Sikela said the partnership would allow the EU to secure supplies through purchase agreements while helping Brazil build refining capacity, access new technologies and move up the supply chain into higher-margin production.

Viridis’ pilot mining project in Minas Gerais, inaugurated in May, can process 100 kilograms of ore per hour and produce up to 2.92 kg of mixed rare earth carbonate (MREC) annually.

Viridis plans to invest $360 million in a commercial plant capable of producing 15,000 tons of MREC per year from 2028, spanning 228.62 km² of licenses in Minas Gerais.

“And that is why I like this particular project (Viridis) so much, because it basically delivers on objectives: it creates jobs, creates new partnerships, brings new technologies, education and knowledge transfer, all based on the most advanced environmental, social and technical standards,” Sikela said.

Deal in sight

Sikela also noted a non-binding letter of intent signed this month between Viridis and Belgian chemicals company Solvay for the supply of MREC, which could evolve into a broader partnership that would include technological processing support.

Viridis CEO Rafael Moreno told Reuters that talks with the EU are at an advanced stage, with a Solvay deal potentially finalized by the end of July.

Viridis’ progress in Brazil comes amid a global race for rare earths and critical minerals, as Europe and the US seek to reduce their dependence on China — the largest producer — for materials vital to electric vehicles and defense systems.

When asked about the landscape, Sikela said the European strategy aims to reduce “dependencies” across global supply chains, following shocks such as the pandemic and the war in Ukraine, stressing the issue extends beyond China alone.

He added that the EU considers projects involving other critical minerals in Brazil, such as nickel and lithium, as priorities, and indicated plans to advance a memorandum of understanding with the Brazilian government, though details remain under negotiation.

Asked whether the EU was late to the competition for assets in Brazil, Sikela argued that “our value proposition is more beneficial than what these others want,” citing sustainability, job creation and education as key differentiators.

Moreno said the company is aligned with European guidelines on diversifying the rare earth supply chain, favoring an approach open to partners across multiple regions.

At the end of last month, he told Reuters that Viridis was in advanced negotiations with potential buyers in Europe and the US.

(By Marta Nogueira; Editing by Aurora Ellis)




 

Hyundai backs ioneer’s Nevada lithium-boron project


The Rhyolite Ridge lithium-boron project in Nevada. (Image courtesy of ioneer.)

Shares in Australian lithium developer ioneer (ASX: INR) jumped after securing support from two South Korean engineering and infrastructure groups for its Rhyolite Ridge project in Nevada, a key US source of battery materials targeting production by 2029.

The stock climbed as much as 29% intraday on Tuesday before closing up 7.1% at A$0.158, its highest level since January, giving the company a market capitalization of A$461.2 million ($320 million). 

Ioneer said Korea Overseas Infrastructure & Urban Development and Hyundai Engineering plan to formalize their cooperation through memorandums of understanding in July 2026. 

Ioneer said the agreements build on its relationship with South Korea, which includes a supply agreement signed with EcoPro Innovation in 2021.

The partnerships add international backing to one of North America’s most strategically significant lithium projects as Western governments and automakers seek secure supplies of battery minerals outside China. 

“Securing domestic critical minerals is an economic imperative,” executive chairman James Calaway said. “We are now one step closer to a final investment decision and the construction of this once-in-a-generation asset for US critical minerals production.”

10 years in the making

Ioneer has been working on Rhyolite Ridge since 2016 and brought in Sibanye-Stillwater (JSE: SSW)(NYSE: SBSW) as a partner in 2019. However, the South African miner walked away in February 2025 from a proposed $490 million investment for a 50% stake in the project.

Rhyolite Ridge hosts the continent’s only known lithium-boron reserve and is one of only two such deposits globally, according to ioneer. The company has invested more than $220 million in the project since 2016 and completed more than 70% of its advanced engineering work. It’s s targeting a final investment decision in the second half of 2026. 

Once operational, the project is expected to produce 27,800 tonnes a year of lithium hydroxide and 135,500 tonnes a year of boric acid, with all processing conducted on site.

 

US sanctions shut Canada’s only cobalt refinery


Old Havana. (Stock image by kmiragaya.)

Sherritt International (TSX: S) has begun shutting down its Fort Saskatchewan refinery after expanded US sanctions on Cuba halted the feedstock supply needed to keep the Alberta, Canada facility running.

The Toronto-based nickel and cobalt producer said the transition follows previous guidance that refinery operations would continue only until mid-June based on available inventory. The company has implemented shutdown procedures and will retain the personnel and resources required to keep the facility in a safe and secure state while operations remain suspended.

Sherritt said it is preserving cash, managing costs and preparing the refinery for a potential restart while carrying out maintenance work during the shutdown.

The shutdown marks the latest fallout from Washington’s tougher stance on Cuba and highlights the vulnerability of supply chains that depend on the island’s mining sector. 

Sherritt mined nickel and cobalt at its Moa joint venture in eastern Cuba and processed the material at its refinery near Edmonton.

Impact

The refinery will remain idle until mining and processing activities at Moa resume and the feed pipeline is rebuilt. Sherritt said it cannot provide guidance on when that may occur and continues to suspend its direct participation in the Cuban joint venture.


The company continues to produce fertilizers and sulphuric acid for resale, providing a source of revenue while its core nickel and cobalt operations remain constrained.

Sherritt has faced mounting operational and financial challenges since the US expanded sanctions against Cuba in May. The measures have disrupted the company’s primary source of refinery feed and forced it to focus on preserving cash while preparing for an eventual restart.



 

Cobalt users warn EU health rules threaten minerals supply push



H.C. Starck tungsten powders. Credit: H.C. Starck Tungsten GmbH

Some of the European Union’s top cobalt users warn that planned rules to protect workers’ health will instead threaten the bloc’s push to bolster its mineral supply chains and industries like energy and defense.

The European Commission will on Tuesday decide whether to approve legislation to reduce workers’ exposure to cobalt dust and particles to safeguard against cancers and other respiratory illnesses. But companies involved in the supply chain say the proposed limits are too strict, costly and challenging to meet, and risk closing businesses and diverting investments away from the EU.

Cobalt is a key metal in electric-vehicle batteries, and is also used in space and defense applications, construction tools, magnets and even animal feed as a vitamin source. The planned health rules come as the EU in 2024 adopted the Critical Raw Materials Act to secure supplies of such metals and reduce dependence on China, which dominates processing.

“The risk is creating a self-defeating mechanism, reducing Europe’s own recycling, refining and processing capacity, while continuing to rely on imported cobalt produced under higher exposure limits elsewhere in the world,” said Mike Blakeney, head of government and public affairs at the Cobalt Institute, an industry group.

Germany’s H.C. Starck Tungsten GmbH, which extracts tungsten from recycled products like carbide tools that often contain cobalt, is among firms concerned that the new rules could undermine the EU’s plan to support its industries. It called the planned legislation “overkill.”

“On the one hand they are trying to support the industry, on the other hand they make sure that you cannot operate any more competitively,” chief executive officer Hady Seyeda said. “The level of safety we have is best in class globally, and to increase that further doesn’t help anybody, because the money and the production will go to areas where it’s less safe.”

The proposed rules will limit workers’ inhalable exposure of cobalt from 20 micrograms per cubic meter to 10 micrograms after a six-year transition period. Similar regulations in China allow 50 micrograms, while US federal law permits 100 micrograms.

The European Chemicals Agency, which provided the scientific basis for the new rules, originally suggested even stronger restrictions. The ECHA told Bloomberg that it makes recommendations based on “hazards and risks, not on possible societal impacts and costs.”

The commission said in an impact assessment last year that 113,000 people are exposed to cobalt dust in the workplace at more than 15,300 companies. About 12 people a year will get lung cancer linked to the exposure and another 100 will get restrictive lung disease, it said. Around 19,000 workers will become ill over the next 40 years if the rules don’t change, according to the assessment.

The proposal “followed a balanced approach to prevent industry closures or major economic setbacks while ensuring adequate protection of workers’ health and safety,” the commission said in an emailed statement on Monday.

The proposed six-year transition is meant to “give the industry more time to adapt to the new occupational exposure limits,” it said, adding that it can revise its directives based on operational realities.

Supporters of the planned law include the European Respiratory Society and the European Cancer Organisation, according to feedback published on the commission’s website in October.

Other users

Finland is the largest cobalt refiner outside of China, where a unit of Jervois Global and Belgium’s Umicore SA have operations.

“There are no established industrial technologies today that operate at that level” of cobalt dust proposed by the rules, said Wouter Ghyoot, vice president of government affairs at Umicore. “Our preference is clearly to continue investing and operating in Europe, the question is ensuring the regulatory framework remains workable in practice.”

Jervois employees use protective equipment when cobalt dust is present and are regularly monitored, said Sami Kallioinen, Jervois Finland’s president and managing director. When test results exceed the set limits, it’s most usually due to human behavior, such as when workers don’t change clothes or smoke with gloves that contain traces of cobalt dust, he said.

Opponents of the planned rules also included Catalysts Europe, the Federation of European Producers of Abrasives, and major German defense company Rheinmetall AG.

“It is clear that the defence supply chain in general will be negatively impacted from stricter rules,” Rheinmetall said in the published feedback.

(By Michael J. Kavanagh and Annie Lee)


 


Timeline: The Oyu Tolgoi saga

A world-class copper discovery. Billions in investment. Years of political battles. Our Oyu Tolgoi timeline follows Mongolia’s and Rio Tinto’s (ASX: RIO) flagship mining project from its discovery in the early 2000s to last week’s blockade of the mine’s main road, capturing the deals, disputes and power struggles that have shaped one of the world’s most important copper assets.

The next chapter could be the most consequential yet.