Friday, January 08, 2021

The Most Surreal Photographs of the Invasion of the Capitol

Unprecedented violence erupted in Washington D.C. as Donald Trump supporters stopped the ratification of Joe Biden's victory.
6.1.21
GettyImages-1294932494

In a spectacle unlike any in American history, armed marauders rampaged through the U.S. Capitol Wednesday as police helplessly stood by and Donald Trump pointedly declined to say anything about what his supporters were doing. Getty photographers Win McNamee and Drew Angerer captured startling images of the scene:

Meanwhile, live streams captured other bizarre scenes:

THE REPUBLICAN TRUMP MOB WERE

WHITE CHRISTIAN NATIONALISTS

              

              NOT ANARCHISTS


The Republican Party and Victimhood as Ideology

Republican victimhood hijacks legitimate suffering to elevate itself into self-anointed martyrdom.


by
House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) speaks during a news conference with other House Republican leadership in Washington on Tuesday, November 17, 2020. (Photo: Caroline Brehman/CQ-Roll Call, Inc. via Getty Images)

House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) speaks during a news conference

 with other House Republican leadership in Washington on Tuesday, November 17, 2020. 

(Photo: Caroline Brehman/CQ-Roll Call, Inc. via Getty Images)

The Republican party has become the party of victims. It is led by the biggest “victim” of all, Donald Trump.  Victimhood is an effective political ideology because it allows its holders to shunt off blame for their own culpability in having devastated the country, whether through presidential incompetence and venality, or by millions of registered Republicans backing decades of destructive Republican policies.

Because of that, however—because it misdirects the real ownership for bad outcomes—victimhood will not be the means to deal with the real problems we face. Until Republicans can deal with reality, instead of martyring themselves in fictive victimhood, we will continue to be battered.

Everywhere you look, Republicans make themselves out as victims. Trump made himself a victim on his first day in office when he attacked the press for correcting his easily demonstrable lie that his inauguration crowd size was the largest ever.  Naming the press “the enemy of the people” enshrined his victimhood into a central institution of American society: the media.

Trump’s 2016 campaign consorted with the Russians, meeting 26 times with Russian intelligence operatives, passing them top secret polling data, and collaborating about the release of the Hillary emails.  Yet, when his own Justice Department, led by the Attorney General he himself had appointed, opened an investigation—the Mueller probe—to get to the bottom of it, Trump made himself out to be the victim of a “Russia hoax.”  As with the media, he enshrined his “victimhood” into another of the leading institutions of American democracy:  law enforcement.

He tried to shake down the leader of another country—Ukraine—to help him with his campaign against Joe Biden. He was caught red-handed and impeached, and properly so. It was a naked, self-dealing abuse of power, exactly the kind of “high crime and misdemeanor” that the Founders intended impeachment be used for. Once again, Trump made it out that he was the victim, of a “witch-hunt,” enshrining his victimhood this time into the institutions of foreign policy and Constitutional checks and balances.  

Trump is a professional victim. He is a profoundly immature man who never takes the blame for his own failures. It’s pathetic in one of the richest and most powerful people in the world, but it works for him politically.  The narrative of victimhood becomes its own auto-inoculation from culpability about anything. No matter how egregious his conduct, no matter how corrupt and self-dealing his actions, no matter how humiliating his comportment, no matter how destructive his deeds, it is he who is the victim. There is literally nothing he does bad or badly that is his fault.

Everything is foisted on him by evil others who wish him ill.  He lied effusively, relentlesssly about the lethality and the transmissibility of coronavirus and put up a Mickey Mouse response, pitting states against one another while he belittled the wearing of masks.  Hundreds of thousands of people died.  But the real perpetrator in Trump’s whimpering victimhood was Democrats who want to politicize the pandemic, enshrining his “victimhood” yet again, this time into public health policy. 

They are victims of themselves for having backed decades of Republican economic policies explicitly designed to shift vast amounts of national income and wealth to those who were already the most-wealthy.Now, he’s the “victim” of a cabal of Democrats, media, coastal elites, Silicon Valley tech-types, and other vaguely menacing ne’er-do-wells who are trying to steal the election and hand it to Joe Biden.  The outrage!  This illustrates the utility of victimhood, not just for providing universal, pre-emptive exculpation for any and all of his own misdeeds, but for converting truth into lies to justify his continuing predations on others, in this case, the entire nation and its 240-year legacy of small-d democratic governance.  

Victimhood as political ideology plays especially well with Trump’s evangelical base whose personal ideology is wrapped up in the greatest victim of all, a guy who was gentle, simple, compassionate, reverent, perhaps even divine, but who was crucified—literally—precisely because he was too good. Republican victimhood hijacks legitimate suffering to elevate itself into self-anointed martyrdom. It works because it converts the rational into the visceral, reality into fantasy, setback into opportunity, and redemption into vengeance. Viscerally lived fantasy, seeking opportunities for vengeance.  Does that sound like any Republicans you know?

The irony is that the Republican base are, indeed, real victims, but not of liberals, or Democrats, or immigrants, or Muslims, or Blacks, or women, or Dreamers, or gays, or transgenders or any of the other “others” they have been trained to hate. They are victims of themselves for having backed decades of Republican economic policies explicitly designed to shift vast amounts of national income and wealth to those who were already the most-wealthy.

Between 1978 and 2018, Republican economic policies shifted more than $50 Trillion from the working and middle classes to the already very wealthiest people in the world, the top 1%.  The Republican base giddily backed those policies, to their own extreme detriment, though they didn’t know it. They thought they were backing family values and fiscal conservatism, limited government, anti-abortion, and national defense and all the other sucker guises that the redistributive polices came wrapped in, to disguise them.

Now we see leading Republican politicians like Josh Hawley and Ted Cruz happily immolating the entire country on the bogus cross of a stolen election so that they can cancel the democracy that their wealthy masters abhor and are determined that their hired flunkies must destroy. It is the ultimate, fatal national expression of misguided victimhood, again, with the base being the true victims because they will be deprived of the democracy that is their only opportunity to undo the perfidy that has beleaguered them so and devastated their own and their children’s life chances.  But you have to have the eyes to see and the ears to hear.  Victimhood deprives you of those.

People need to grow up, man up, wake up, and step up and take back their country, their dignity, and their own salvation. They need the discernment and the courage to name the real perpetrators of shifting class fortunes and long-term national decline. That’s not going to happen by playing the victim.

Robert Freeman

Robert Freeman is the author of "The Best One Hour History" series which includes "World War I" (2013), "The InterWar Years" (2014), "The Vietnam War" (2013), and other titles. He is the founder of The Global Uplift Project which builds small-scale infrastructure projects in the developing world to improve humanity’s capacity for self-development.

They're Not Going Anywhere. 

Trump Has Created Right-Wing 

Beast He Cannot Control

When Biden takes the oath of office later this month, Trump’s presidency will be over. White supremacy, however, will not be.


Published on
by
New York Magazine Intelligencer
Supporters of US President Donald Trump protest in the US Capitol Rotunda on January 6, 2021, in Washington, DC. - Demonstrators breeched security and entered the Capitol as Congress debated the a 2020 presidential election Electoral Vote Certification. (Photo: SAUL LOEB/AFP via Getty Images)

Supporters of US President Donald Trump protest in the US Capitol Rotunda 

on January 6, 2021, in Washington, DC. - Demonstrators breeched security 

and entered the Capitol as Congress debated the a 2020 presidential election 

Electoral Vote Certification. (Photo: SAUL LOEB/AFP via Getty Images)

On Wednesday afternoon, as a mob sacked the U.S. Capitol, Donald Trump’s successor pleaded for peace. America was a good place, so much better than what we were seeing today, President-elect Joe Biden insisted. We’ve triumphed before, and we’ll triumph again. But the platitudes fall flat. So do the shocked tweets and the cable punditry. Trump could stop this with a tweet, people said; this is not who we are. But Trump cannot stop this, because this is who we are. This is who we’ve always been. The sacking of the Capitol is the latest entry in a bloody old ledger.

Though America has also always been more complex than the ugliest version of itself — it is Heyer’s country, and King’s country, as much as it’s Trump’s—there’s nothing original about the violence his presidency inspires.

Trump is not a sophisticated thinker, but he understands a basic truth about America. If you understand the Civil War as a slaveholder’s insurrection, the events of January 6 feel inevitable. This country birthed the Ku Klux Klan and lynched thousands. This country murdered Martin Luther King Jr. This country beat civil-rights protesters and killed trade unionists and Communists and so, eventually, it elected Trump. And the violence was revived. Under Trump, this country killed Jews at worship in 2018, and it targeted Latinos in an El Paso Walmart the very next year. This country gave rise to neo-Nazis in the streets of Charlottesville, Virginia, and to the murder of Heather Heyer.

Though America has also always been more complex than the ugliest version of itself — it is Heyer’s country, and King’s country, as much as it’s Trump’s—there’s nothing original about the violence his presidency inspires. When we wonder about the future of what we call Trumpism, a loose term for the racist nationalism that defines his presidency, conventional wisdom generally holds that there is no Trumpism without Trump. Without his celebrity, the coalition that coalesced around him would not survive for long. There’s still some truth to that view. But that doesn’t mean the threat Trump poses will pass. The mob that invaded the Capitol carried Trump flags, true, but it carried Confederate flags too. That’s what Trumpism without Trump looks like: old-fashioned white supremacy, outfitted with a new set of grievances.

When Biden takes the oath of office later this month, Trump’s presidency will be over. White supremacy, however, will not be. America will still be America, and Biden will have to figure out how to deal with it. Pretending that this country is nobler than it is will accomplish nothing; it will only guarantee that the forces Trump mobilized will rage on for years. So let’s agree now to call the events of January 6 what they are: an insurrection waged by the usual suspects, incited by a president who understands precisely what he’s doing. The fascistic undertones are not difficult to hear. Go home now, Trump told supporters on Wednesday, but you’re right to be angry; the election was stolen. “We love you,” he added. “You’re very special.” They know. They’re grateful. And they’re not going anywhere.

Sarah Jones

Sarah Jones is a staff writer for The New Republic. Follow her on Twitter: @onesarahjones

 

Saying Goodbye to the Con-Man-in-Chief

Demining America after The Donald.

by

Donald Trump proved a media heaven and a living hell. (Photo: Elijah Nouvelage/Getty Images)

Donald Trump proved a media heaven and a living hell. (Photo: Elijah Nouvelage/Getty Images)

2021 has indeed begun and god knows what it has in store for us. But unless, somehow, we’re surprised beyond imagining, The Donald is indeed going to leave the White House soon and, much as I hate to admit it, in some strange fashion we’re going to miss him.  Of course, it will be beyond a great relief to see his… well, let’s just say him in the rearview mirror. While occupying the White House, he was, in a rather literal sense, hell on earth. Nonetheless, he was also a figure of remarkable fascination for anyone thinking about this country or that strangest of all species, humanity, and what we’re capable of doing to ourselves. 

So, here’s my look back at our final Trumpian months (at least for a while). As I review the weeks just past, however, you may be surprised to learn that I’m not planning to start with the president’s former national security adviser (of 23 days — “you’re fired!”) cum-convictee-cum-pardonee urging The Donald to declare martial law; nor will I review the president’s endless tweets and fulminations about the “fraudulent” 2020 election or his increasing lame (duck!) assaults on all those he saw as deserting his visibly sinking Titanic, including Mitch McConnell (“the first one off the ship”); nor do I have the urge to focus on the conspiracy-mongress who captured the president’s heart (or whatever’s in that chest of his) with her claims about how “Venezuelan” votes did him in; nor even his doom-and-gloom “holiday” trip to Mar-a-Lago, including on Christmas Day his 309th presidential visit to a golf course; nor will I waste time on how the still-president of these increasingly dis-United States, while pardoning war criminals and pals (as well as random well-connected criminals), managed to ignore the rest of a country slipping into pandemic hell — cases rising, deaths spiraling, hospitals filling to the brim in a fashion unequaled on the planet — about which he visibly couldn’t have cared less; nor will I focus on how, as Christmas arrived, he landed squarely on Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez’s position of giving $2,000 checks to the American people and so for a few days became an honorary “socialist”; nor will I even spend time on his unique phone call for 11,780 votes in Georgia.   

Instead, in this most downbeat of seasons, I’d like to begin with something more future-oriented, a little bit of December news you might have missed amid all the gloom and doom. So, just in case you didn’t notice as 2020 ended in chaos and cacophony, as the president who couldn’t take his eyes off a lost election sunk us ever deeper in his own version of the Washington swamp, there were two significantly more forward-looking figures in his circle. I’m thinking of his daughter Ivanka and her husband Jared Kushner who plunked down $30 million on the most exclusive bit of real estate they could find in Florida, a small island with only 41 residences known among locals as the “billionaire’s bunker.”

They purchased a plot of land there on which they can assumedly build the most modest of multimillion-dollar mansions… but let the Hill describe it:

“The secluded spot sits on 1.8 acres and comes with 200 feet of waterfront and ‘breathtaking sunset views.’ A real estate listing dubs it an ‘amazing parcel of land,’ saying, ‘This sprawling lot provides a rare opportunity to build your waterfront dream estate.’ The listing boasts that the Miami island is ‘one of the most exclusive and private neighborhoods in the world with its private country club and golf course, police force, and 24/7 armed boat patrol.'”

And better yet, though just off the coast of Miami, it’s only 60 miles from what they may hope will be the alternate White House for the next four years, Mar-a-Lago. 

The Future, Trump-Style

As far as I’m concerned, amid the year-ending chaos of the Trump presidency, nothing could have caught the essential spirit of the last four years better than that largely overlooked news story.  Let’s start at its end, so to speak. Instead of brooding nonstop about a lost election like you-know-who, Ivanka and Jared, both key presidential advisers, are instead going to pour millions of dollars into what might be thought of as a personal investment in the future on that island off the southern coast of Florida.

When it comes to the planet, this catches in a nutshell the essence of what’s passed for long-term thinking in the Trump White House since January 2017.  After all, the most notable thing about the southern coast of Florida, if you’re in an investing (and lifestyle) mood, is this: as the world’s sea levels rise (ever more precipitously, in fact) thanks to climate change, one of the most endangered places in the United States is that very coast.  Flooding in the region has already been on the rise and significant parts of it could be underwater by 2050 with its inhabitants washed out of their homes well before that — and no personal police force or patrol boats will be able to protect Ivanka and Jared from that kind of global assault.  Even Donald Trump, should he run and win again in 2024, won’t be able to pardon them for that decision.

Put another way, the future of those two key Trump family members is a living example of what, in this world of ours, is usually called climate denialism; the “children,” that is, have offered their own $30-million-plus encapsulation of the four-year environmental record of a 74-year-old president who couldn’t imagine anyone’s future except his own.

Though climate denialism is indeed the term normally used for this phenomenon, as a descriptor in the Trump years it fell desperately short of the mark. It’s a far too-limited way of describing what the U.S. government has actually been doing. Withdrawing from the Paris climate accords, promoting oil exploration and drilling galore, and deep-sixing energy-related environmental regulations, Trump and his crew have not just been denying the obvious reality of climate change (as the West Coast burned in a historic fashion and the hurricane season ramped up dramatically in 2020), but criminally aiding and abetting the phenomenon in every way imaginable.  They have, in fact, done their best to torch humanity’s future.  As I’ve written in these years, they rather literally transformed themselves into pyromaniacs even as they imagined unleashing, as the president proudly put it, “American energy dominance.” The promotional phrase they used for their fossil-fuelized policies was “the golden era of American energy is now underway” — that golden glow assumedly being the flames licking at this overheating planet of ours.  

So, a climate-change endangered island? Why even bother to imagine such a future? In fact, the president made this point all too vividly when it came to Tangier Island, a 1.3-square-mile dot in the middle of Chesapeake Bay that global warming and erosion are imperiling and that is, indeed, expected to be gone by 2050. In 2017, the president called the mayor of its town (after CNN put out a story about the increasing problems of that Trump-loving isle). He assured him, as the mayor reported, that “we shouldn’t worry about rising sea levels. He said that ‘your island has been there for hundreds of years, and I believe your island will be there for hundreds more.’”

IED-ing the American System

And of course, let’s not forget that, for the president’s daughter and son-in-law, dropping $30 million is just another day at the office. In that, they distinctly follow in the tradition of the bankruptee who has similarly dished out dough to his heart’s content, while repeatedly leaving others holding the bag for his multiple business failures. (Undoubtedly, this is something the American people will experience when he finally jumps ship on January 20th, undoubtedly leaving the rest of us holding that very same bag.)  Pardon me, but that $30 million dollars being plunked down on a snazzy plot of land — someday to be water — should remind us that we’re talking about a crew who are already awash in both money (of every questionable sort) and, at least in the case of the president, staggering hundreds of millions of dollars in debts. It should remind us as well that we’re dealing with families evidently filled with grifters and a now-pardoned criminal, too.

Make no mistake, from the moment Donald Trump walked into the White House, he was already this country’s con-man-in-chief.  Back when he was first running for president, this was no mystery to his ever-loyal “base,” those tens of millions of voters who opted for him then and continue to stick by him no matter what. As I wrote in that distant 2016 election season,

“Americans love a con man.  Historically, we’ve often admired, if not identified with, someone intent on playing and successfully beating the system, whether at a confidence game or through criminal activity. [At] the first presidential debate… Trump essentially admitted that, in some years, he paid no taxes (‘that makes me smart’) and that he had played the tax system for everything it was worth… I guarantee you that Trump senses he’s deep in the Mississippi of American politics with such statements and that a surprising number of voters will admire him for it (whether they admit it or not). After all, he beat the system, even if they didn’t.”

And admire him they did and, as it happens, still do. He was elected on those very grounds and, despite his loss in 2020 (with a staggering 74 million voters still opting for him), a couple of weeks from now, he’ll walk away from the White House with a final con that will leave him floating in a sea of money for months (years?) to come.  Here’s how New York Times reporters Shane Goldmacher and Maggie Haberman describe the situation:

“Donald J. Trump will exit the White House as a private citizen next month perched atop a pile of campaign cash unheard-of for an outgoing president, and with few legal limits on how he can spend it… Mr. Trump has cushioned the blow by coaxing huge sums of money from his loyal supporters — often under dubious pretenses — raising roughly $250 million since Election Day along with the national party. More than $60 million of that sum has gone to a new political action committee, according to people familiar with the matter, which Mr. Trump will control after he leaves office.”

He was, in other words, in character from his first to last moment in office and, in his own way (just as his followers expected), he did beat the system, even if he faces years of potential prosecution to come. 

Oh, and one more thing when it comes to The Donald. With a future Biden administration in mind, you might think of him not just as the con-man president but the Taliban president as well. After all, he’s not only torn up but land-mined, or in Taliban terms IED-ed, both the federal government, including that “deep state” he’s always denounced, and the American system of governing itself. (“This Fake Election can no longer stand…”) And those improvised explosive devices, or IEDs, he and his crew have buried in that system, whether in terms of health care, the environment, or you name it are likely to go off at unexpected moments for months, if not years, to come. 

So, when you say so long, farewell, aufwiedersehn, adieu to you-know-who, his children, and his pals, the odds are you won’t ever be saying goodbye. Not really. Thanks to that $60 million-plus fund, that base of his, and all those landmines (many of which we don’t even know are there yet), he’ll be with us in one form (of disaster) or another for years to come — he, his children, and that island that, unfortunately, just won’t sink fast enough. 

Like it or not, after these last four years, whatever the Biden era may hold for us, Donald Trump proved a media heaven and a living hell. It’s going to be quite a task in a world that needs so much else just to demine the American system after he leaves the White House (especially with Mitch McConnell and crew still in place). Count on one thing: we won’t forget The Donald any time soon. And give him credit where it’s due. There’s no denying that, in just four years, he’s helped usher us into a new American world that already couldn’t be more overheated or underwhelming. 

The GOP Owns This

Thugs 'R Us. Getty Image

The thugs have gone home - shamefully, mostly unmolested - while the country sifts through the rubble. Many remain stunned by the racism and incompetence of Capitol police who sat back and did nothing - "It's like watching a real-life horror movie - we train and plan and budget every day, basically, to have this not happen” - amidst firings, resignations and calls for  investigations. Videos of rampaging yahoos surface: Unruly crowds chasing a black officer; entitled neo-Nazis hurling f-bombs around the People's House; the Arkansas guy who put his feet on Nancy Pelosi's desk and took a letter from it - and, it seems, earlier got a PPP loan from the government he was rioting against - bragging, "I put a quarter on her desk, even though she ain't fucking worth it, and left her a note that says 'Nancy, Bigo was here you bitch.'" Pelosi herself focused on the madman who poked and prodded and incited it all, calling for Trump's removal and declaring, "This man is deadly, to our democracy and our people." Unsurprisingly, he kept proving it: As the mobs surged, he was still railing: "These are the things and events that happen when a sacred landslide election victory is so unceremoniously & viciously stripped away from great patriots." On Thursday, reports surfaced he had "lost it," was "out of his mind," was “unstable, ranting and raving” and “bent on destruction in his final days.” Meanwhile, as far as anyone knew, the guy deemed too dangerous to be allowed on social media still had the nuclear codes.

It is not, of course, just the mad king who's brought us to the brink. Even as debates rage about the efficacy of the 25th Amendment vs. impeachment, there's broad consensus the cursing, flag-draped MAGA hoodlums assaulting the Capitol were inseparable from the pandering, well-groomed GOP suits abetting the sociopath who'd spurred them on. From the National Review blasting the "mindless tyranny" and "nihilistic lawbreaking" - "Trump must pay" - to Mother Jones declaring "Trump is now a terrorist leader," a broad swath of America views the riot as the inevitable result of a toxic, complicit, ever-more  authoritarian Republican party that for four years has coddled and propped up a sociopathic tinpot dictator - and whose standard-bearers - McConnell, Cruz, Rubio, now Hawley - were "never confused about what they were doing." "Inside and outside were two faces of the same thing," writes Rebecca Solnit. "The mob outside would not exist without the politicians inside. Those insiders will make noises of horror and repudiation, but they own this." The GOP's claim to be the party of law and order, Solnit notes, is part of an authoritarian "ideology of inequality: I make the rules, you follow them," born of white male rage against the notion other people might be equal under the law. "Entitlement is too demure a word for this," she writes, adding "the mob was always going to happen" because Trump craved infinite power, whipped up a dutifully deranged army to achieve it, and lit the fuse: "This is what he wanted... and this is what we got." Hopefully, eventually, his enablers will pay the price. For now, urges David Frum, "Impeach. Remove. Indict. Incarcerate."

Taking a stand. New social media star Adam Johnson of Florida hauls off Pelosi's lectern. Photo by Win McNamee/Getty Image

Class act: "Nancy, Bigo was here you bitch."

New Jersey's Democratic Rep. Andy Kim, first-generation American, son of Korean immigrants and Rhodes Scholar,  helps clean up the Capitol. Twitter photo