Thursday, November 19, 2026

‘Shut It Down’: Vulnerable GOP Senator Pitches Abolishing Social Security During Fox Interview

“Social Security is the most popular and effective program in America. Ron Johnson wants to ‘shut it down.’ And any Republican who won’t commit to making billionaires pay their fair share agrees with him,” said Social Security Works.


Sen. Ron Johnson (R-Wis.) speaks during a hearing of the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee on February 12, 2026 in Washington, DC.
(Photo by Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)

Brad Reed
Nov 18, 2026
COMMON DREAMS

A Republican senator up for reelection in a swing state in 2028 floated abolishing America’s most popular social insurance program during a Wednesday interview on Fox Business.

While appearing on the cable news network, Sen. Ron Johnson (R-Wis.) made his case for doing away with Social Security entirely.

“[Social Security] is a scam, it is grotesque,” he said. “At this point, there’s really no way to fix Social Security. It’s a Ponzi scheme, you can’t fix it. You just shut it down and hope that you can recovery some of your money.”



The Wisconsin Republican’s attack on Social Security came just hours before he was set to preside over a Senate Budget Committee hearing titled “Social Security: The Reality,” which Johnson claimed would demonstrate how the program has been “grossly mismanaged.”

Johnson’s statement drew a swift rebuke from the progressive advocacy group Social Security Works.

“Social Security is the most popular and effective program in America,” the group wrote in a social media post. “Ron Johnson wants to ‘shut it down.’ And any Republicans who won’t commit to making billionaires pay their fair share agrees with him.”

Nancy Altman, president of Social Security Works, described Johnson’s call to end Social Security as “a brazen effort, in broad daylight, to steal Americans’ earned benefits.”

“Sen. Johnson has an estimated net worth of $40 million,” Altman added. “He wants to shut Social Security down so that he never has to contribute his fair share. If he gets his wish, he will still enjoy a secure retirement. Meanwhile, millions of seniors and people with disabilities will face homelessness and hunger.”

Stephen Nuñez, director of stratification economics at the Roosevelt Institute, wrote that Johnson’s claim about there being “no way to fix Social Security” is “complete horseshit,” pointing to an analysis he published earlier this year explaining the real reasons for the program’s projected fiscal shortfall.

“Social Security’s current difficulties are a combination of the quirks of the laws governing it (a separate and limited funding source, no capacity to borrow, etc.),” Nuñez explained, “combined with some important ‘misses’ in actuarial projections and legislators’ unwillingness to legislate.”

“There is no bankruptcy or collapse in the cards,” Nuñez emphasized. “Just like in 1981, we are simply waiting for lawmakers to act.”

Economist Matt Darling, a policy fellow at Searchlight Institute, similarly pushed back on Johnson’s fearmongering about Social Security’s finances.

“Regular reminder that the worst-case scenario for Social Security is something like ‘pays out 80% of benefits,’” explained Darling, who noted that this would still make Social Security “roughly the equivalent of the old age program in Japan.”

Independent policy analyst Ned Resnikoff predicted that Johnson’s attacks on Social Security will end poorly for him when he runs for reelection in two years.

“The last time they tried to privatize Social Security was when they were flush with victory after the 2004 election and it brought their political momentum to a dead halt,” Resnikoff observed, referring to former President George W. Bush’s failed privatization effort.

 “Bringing it up again after a historic rout is just evidence of a death wish.”


Senate Democrats Pile On GOP’s Ron Johnson After He Floats Abolishing Social Security

“This is the first time in decades that a senior senator... said he would rather shut down Social Security than fix it,” said US Sen. Ron Wyden.



Brad Reed
Nov 18, 2026
COMMON DREAMS


Democrats on the US Senate Budget Committee on Wednesday took turns slamming a Republican colleague who floated abolishing Social Security.

Earlier in the day, Sen. Ron Johnson (R-Wis.) appeared on Fox Business, where he described Social Security as a “scam” that cannot be reformed.

“At this point, there’s really no way to fix Social Security,” Johnson said. “It’s a Ponzi scheme, you can’t fix it. You just shut it down and hope that you can recovery some of your money.”

Democratic senators wasted no time in pouncing on Johnson’s claims about the country’s most popular social insurance program during Wednesday’s hearing.

Sen. Jeff Merkley (D-Ore.), ranking member of the Senate Budget Committee who is in line to be its chairman next year, accused Johnson of peddling baseless fears about Social Security going bankrupt.

“I think the biggest factor scaring Americans right now was your quote this morning,” Merkley said. “That does terrify people across the country. And much of what my colleague has described is the fact that he does not like the way that Social Security is structured.”

Merkley also tore into Johnson’s claim that there is no way to fix Social Security’s finances when a significant portion of it can be solved by raising or even eliminating the cap on wages subject to the payroll tax.

“This year, I held 36 town halls, one in each county in Oregon,” Merkley said. “And in each one, we did a survey on how people would like to see Social Security addressed to make sure it is solvent. The results were clear and consistent... from cities to rural communities. The top response from citizens was, ‘Raise the cap on the income to which premiums apply.’”

“Most think it’s unfair,” the Oregon Democrat added, “for a local firefighter who pays the exact same contribution as a billionaire hedge fund manager.”



Sen. Ron Wyden (D-Ore.) similarly denounced Johnson for wanting to scrap Social Security rather than make the ultrarich pay higher taxes.

“This is the first time in decades that a senior senator, chairman of the Budget Committee, said he would rather shut down Social Security than fix it,” Wyden said, “in effect, saying he would rather throw in the towel and have billionaires pay their fair share. That is, in my view, an astounding statement.”



Sen. Mark Warner (D-Va.) told Johnson that he was “shocked and disappointed” to see Johnson’s call to shut Social Security down, to which the Wisconsin Republican replied that he was being “taken out of context.”

“No,” Warner shot back. “I’m reading a quote from you on Fox News!... We don’t want to scare the American public. This is outrageous scare tactics. The American people deserve better.”


Johnson, who is up for reelection in 2028, is projected as one of Democrats’ top targets as they aimed to further expand their majority in the US Senate.

No comments: