Sunday, November 22, 2026

Technology Injunctions: Trump Goes MAGA On Data Centers – OpEd




After the Shenzhen summit, President Trump declared that U.S. companies would not be allowed to build data centers abroad and would face heavy taxes if they did, citing past chip-export losses and the risk that China would capture the capacity.

Domestic opposition has grown sharply: a September Pew survey found 54 percent of Americans view data centers as mostly bad for the environment, local ballot measures in 10 states largely imposed restrictions, and a post-midterm poll showed 76 percent would oppose new centers in their communities.

Tech firms are still committing roughly $750 billion to U.S. construction this year amid rising costs, while Google’s 13-billion-euro Finnish project has already drawn regulatory penalties for premature land clearing, giving overseas protest movements an additional boost from Trump’s stance.




The insatiable lust of technology and artificial intelligence behemoths to acquire new data centres in order to sustain their own narrative of indispensable, invaluable progress has faced something of a hiccup. US President Donald Trump, AI’s great drooler-in-chief determined to force others to call it “Super Intelligence” (SI), has gone parochial and patriotic on the technology.

In a November 20 press conference, held after his Shenzhen summit with China’s President Xi Jinping and Russia’ Vladimir Putin, Trump was in a bolshie mood about American companies wishing to build their precious water and energy hungry assets in foreign environs: “We’re not going to allow our companies to build data centers outside of our country,” he declared. “They allowed that to happen with chips and everything else, and it was very destructive to our country. It’s where we started going behind.” Were the United States to permit this to take place, an opportunistic China would “take them all.”

Trump may well have been having one of his verbal jollies. Flanked by Vice President JD Vance and Secretary of State Marco Rubio, the president took childish delight in having kept these latest notions close to his chest. “I don’t know if that’s a breaking story. But I haven’t said that to my people.” He was “telling them now. They’re here. Many of them are here.” Having made it clear that companies would face an injunction on constructing the centres in other countries, Trump suggested a form of penalty, should they defy it. “If they do that, they can, but we’re going to put a tremendous tax on them.”


To milk the issue of data centres with such enthusiasm, Trump is returning to increasingly unpopular territory in the US. A Pew Research Center survey from September found that 54% of Americans thought data centres were “mostly bad for the environment”, a rise from 39% in January. Half of the respondents thought them “mostly bad for home energy costs” and 49% deemed them “mostly bad for people’s quality of life nearby”.

The Democratic majority in Congress, convincingly secured in the midterm elections, was due, in no small part, to a loss of appetite in the construction of such entities. A total of 41 local ballot initiatives dealing with data centres were up for the vote in 10 states. With the exception of one result, all endorsed restrictive and limiting measures on their construction. In her bid to oust Texan Republican Governor, Greg Abbott, Gina Hinojosa made much about data centres as “a physical manifestation of a government, a governor doing the bidding of the moneyed interests and leaving the people to fend for themselves”. Her successful electoral pitch reminded voters that Abbott had invited the construction of such centres in 2015, with the sweetened incentive of 20-year tax breaks, while fumbling over the issue of a temporary moratorium on their construction.

A post-midterm poll of 39,938 respondents for AP and other news agencies conducted by the market research firm SSRS returned a 56% figure viewing data centres as a “crucial or major” factor in the vote. 76% claimed they would oppose the construction of new centres in their community.


This turn of events has done nothing to discourage America’s chief magistrate. AI is touted as the new holy grail of competition, and it was something to be won. The Eeyorish naysayers, whether through opposition, protests and ballots, were to be ignored. “Whoever wins SI wins. And you ought to take advantage of the data centers. Make them pay you. Make them pay your community. But take advantage.” It was important not to “shut them off. And there’s always somebody else in this country. But if it’s not in this country, there’s somebody else outside.”

An example of such foreign investment, and something to catch the president’s eye with notable irritation, is Google’s plan to spend 13 billion euros ($US15 billion) on data centres in Finland’s Muhos and Kajaani sites over the course of two years. The company has not distinguished itself thus far, having been found by the Finnish Licensing and Supervision Authority (LVV) to have prematurely commenced work without mandatory environmental impact assessments. The work in question involved the brisk removal of trees and topsoil, putting in place site roads and storage areas, and altering ditches. Hanna Halmeenpää, chair of the Finnish Association for Nature Conservation, notes that precious nature sites have been felled. At Muhos, 330 hectares of forest, some 250,000 trees, was illegally cleared. Even Google had to concede in a statement to the BBC that it had “fallen short our own high standards in this instance”, though the company’s Finland country manager, Antti Järvinen, said that the actions had been undertaken “on the best understanding we had of the legislation at the time”.

The technology titans are certainly keen to fork out for the centres in the US. Meta Platforms Inc., Amazon.com Inc., Microsoft Corp. and Google owner Alphabet Inc. will, according to one estimate, put in US$750 billion into their construction this year alone. This amount alone exceeds the gross domestic product of either Ireland or Belgium, its ballooning the consequence of rising costs in construction materials occasioned by tariff wars and the Iran conflict. Short-term memory used in such centres is also proving costly, with Bloomberg Intelligence showing a five-fold increase from last year alone. Seeing as swollen corporate capitalism lacks the patriotic sentiment or a sense of loyalty beyond dividends and profits, Trump may just have to make do with penalising the detractors. The protest movement in other countries, however, will see the US president’s latest musings as a fillip for their endeavours.


About Binoy Kampmark
Binoy Kampmark was a Commonwealth Scholar at Selwyn College, Cambridge. He lectures at RMIT University, Melbourne. Email: bkampmark@gmail.com
View all posts by Binoy Kampmark →

 

Trump on reported FBI hack: 'Maybe we'll learn things'

22.11.2026

Photo: Matt Kaminsky/ZUMA Press Wire/dpa

US President Donald Trump has suggested that a reported cyberattack on the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) could have an upside.

"I don't like that," Trump told Fox News on Saturday. "But maybe we'll learn things that we would have never learned otherwise."

Trump said the breach could shed light on what he calls the "Russia hoax," referring to past FBI investigations into possible links between his 2016 election campaign and Russia.

Trump has repeatedly dismissed the investigations as a politically motivated conspiracy.

There was no immediate indication that the reported cyberattack was connected to the earlier Russia investigations.

CNN and Fox News reported that hackers had targeted the FBI's National Crime Information Center, a database used by law enforcement agencies across the country for information on arrest warrants and background checks. It is the second reported cyberattack on the FBI in two months.

It remained unclear who was behind the attack or whether any data had been stolen. The FBI did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

A series of technical disruptions in the United States has raised concerns about possible cyberattacks, including outages affecting Microsoft's Outlook email service, air traffic control systems and several banks.

However, the US government has repeatedly said the disruptions were isolated incidents, with no evidence that they were caused by cyberattacks.


Analysts Call For Investigation, Audit On US Nationwide Outages


Photo Credit: Kanenori, Pixabay

November 22, 2026

The Center Square

By Andrew Rice


Key Takeaways:

A week of sequential outages, including an FAA grounding that cancelled more than 12,000 flights after a router upgrade failed, has prompted Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy to request $50.1 billion to modernise air-traffic-control technology.

Officials including Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin and DNI Jay Clayton stated there is no evidence of a coordinated cyberattack, while Microsoft, JPMorgan Chase, Apple and the NSA also experienced disruptions linked to maintenance or technical issues.

Advocates are demanding independent oversight of investigations and clearer, itemised explanations of funding needs before further AI and technology upgrades proceed.



(The Center Square) – After more than a week of sequential outages disrupting services across government and commercial industries, government officials are requesting billions of taxpayer dollars for improvements and advocates are demanding transparency.

The Federal Aviation Administration grounded flights for more than four hours on Nov. 13, resulting in the cancellation of more than 12,000 flights. In an initial investigation, FAA officials faulted work upgrading a router at a radio communications center in El Dorado, Arkansas, for the outage that caused instability at 17 of 22 Air Route Traffic Control Centers.

is protected from day one.

Since then, Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy requested $50.1 billion from the House and Senate appropriations committees to upgrade faulty air traffic control technology that experienced issues leading to the nationwide grounding of thousands of flights.

“Our routers actually got overloaded with data,” Duffy said. “It’s the old hardware that went down. This is a continual problem that we have, and it should be fixed.”

Erin Applebaum, a partner at the law firm Kreindler & Kreindler who focuses on passenger rights, called for government agencies to fortify the airline system and prevent future security disturbances.

“People in power need to make sure that it’s done quickly, though, and that it’s done correctly because the consequences of another screw up could be disastrous,” Applebaum told The Center Square. “Whatever happens, the implementation needs to be swift, and it needs to be done correctly.”

Technology outages have also affected Microsoft, JPMorgan Chase, Apple and the National Security Agency over the past week. Andrew Tinio, director of Strategic Enterprise and Digital Native at customer communications platform Infobip, said businesses need to be consistent with communication efforts amid a slew of outages.

“Disruptions will always happen, whether it’s man-made or something else,” Tinio told The Center Square in an interview. “But you can control how you inform your customers, your employees and your partners while that is happening.”

Tinio and Applebaum said companies need to be careful about how they adopt new technology, as Apple, Microsoft and the FAA seek to expand the use of artificial intelligence across the country.

Tinio said adopting AI needs to include human intervention to ensure there is continued oversight for the technology as it is expanded.

“It’s just really trying to find the right balance of making sure you’re using these tools to not just improve things from a business perspective but also improve interactions with customers,” Tinio said.

Applebaum emphasized the importance of a thorough investigation into the outages. She said the investigation must have strict standards in order to reassure the public about issues that occurred with the technology systems.

“When a government agency or a private corporation is investigating themselves, that’s a recipe for shortcuts and is antithetical to transparency when you allow somebody to investigate themselves,” Applebaum said. “When the investigation is done, it has to be overseen either by a congressional committee or it has to be overseen by a third party with expertise on the subject matter.”

Homeland Security Department Secretary Markwayne Mullin and Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton said there was “no evidence” of a cyberattack as the cause of the outages in a congressional hearing Wednesday.

“We have no evidence that this is a coordinated cyberattack or state sponsored activity,” Clayton said during the hearing.


The FAA told The Center Square it is still in the process of an investigation to thoroughly analyze the cause of the nationwide ground stop. The NSA confirmed to The Center Square that the outage was due to a routine security upgrade.

“The National Security Agency experienced temporary degradation during scheduled routine maintenance. While some internal systems were affected, mission-critical capabilities remain fully operational and our ability to defend national security continues. NSA’s infrastructure is designed with multiple layers of redundancy to maintain operations during planned maintenance or unexpected events,” an NSA spokesperson wrote in a statement to The Center Square.

The agency was operating under normal conditions on Friday, according to an NSA spokesperson.

President Donald Trump dismissed concerns on Friday that a coordinated cyberattack took down the FAA and other private companies. He said issues are to be expected when technology upgrades are planned.

“When they upgrade bad things happen,” Trump said during a press briefing The Center Square attended on Friday. “You’re going to have companies that go down.”

Tinio called for companies that experience outages to provide specific communications with customers in order to address outage concerns. He said providing clear updates on a regular basis will improve public trust in the future.

“It’s really about proactive communications and using the right channel, depending on the situation and the content that’s being delivered,” Tinio said.

Applebaum agreed that businesses have a responsibility for informing the public about outages. She called on the businesses and the Trump administration to clearly explain how to recover from the outages and what appropriations are necessary.

“If they were to itemize why they need the money and be more transparent about the purposes of the additional funding, then Congress and the American people might be more likely to support it,” Applebaum said.
The Next Global Cyberattack Could Have Your Home IP Address – Analysis



AI-assisted tools such as ARTEX and residential proxy networks can route attacks through ordinary household internet connections, so a logged IP address may identify only the final relay rather than the actual operator.

Investigations of IPIDEA, NetNut and similar services show that free VPNs and third-party apps can silently enroll devices as exit nodes, with hundreds of threat groups observed using those addresses in short periods.

The article argues that investigators, platforms and banks must treat residential IPs as investigative starting points, not proof of guilt, and must notify users, disrupt proxy businesses and distinguish victims of concealed relaying from the attackers who control them.



AI-led intrusions and hidden residential proxy networks expose an uncomfortable distinction: a digital trail can identify the household that relayed an attack without identifying the attacker.

A bank receives an automated warning about an attempted account takeover. Its logs point to an ordinary home internet connection in another country. The residents are asleep, their router is on, and nobody in the household has tried to enter the bank. The address is real. The apparent suspect may be entirely wrong.

This is a hypothetical scenario, but the machinery that makes it possible is documented. Cybercriminals can route requests through residential proxy networks that borrow the internet connections of homes and small businesses. Some people knowingly rent out their bandwidth. Others are enrolled through software that does not clearly disclose what it is doing. For an investigator, the visible source of the traffic may be the last relay rather than the person controlling the operation.


That distinction has become newly urgent as AI-assisted intrusion tools spread. A November 20 report in the New York Post described how a phone could be used to direct ARTEX, a framework that delegates parts of hacking activity to AI agents running on other infrastructure. It did not demonstrate that ARTEX secretly installs itself on iPhones. A phone acting as an operator’s remote screen is a different proposition from an unsuspecting household device being used as a network relay. Mixing the two turns a real warning into a misleading one.
The infrastructure behind the borrowed address

The immediate connection is a finding from Check Point Research’s November 5 investigation. Researchers examined exposed ARTEX operator consoles and found that some operators configured their agents to use residential proxies to obscure traffic and work around blocking. That shows a tactic being used. It does not identify which homes or phones supplied those proxies, or prove that their owners were unaware of the arrangement.

Separate investigations explain how unwitting participation can occur. In January, Google reported disrupting the IPIDEA network, whose operators used free VPN products and code embedded in third-party applications to recruit devices as proxy exit nodes, frequently without adequate disclosure. Some of the applications still performed the service users expected. That is part of the deception: an app can look useful while quietly selling access to its customer’s internet connection.


Google reported observing more than 550 tracked threat groups using IPIDEA exit addresses during a single seven-day period that month, including espionage and criminal actors from several regions. In July, Google and partners, including the FBI, announced further action against a different network, NetNut. Its researchers observed 316 distinct threat clusters using suspected NetNut exits during a week in June. These are the investigators’ observed counts, not a census of all attacks or proof that either network carried the ARTEX traffic documented by Check Point.

The FBI warned the public in March that residential proxies can conceal the origins of cybercrime by using residential and small-business internet networks. That warning is global in consequence: a relay in one country may carry activity planned, financed and directed from several others.
An internet address is not a human identity

Residential proxies have lawful uses, including privacy protection and legitimate network testing. The policy problem is concealed enrollment and criminal use, not the mere existence of proxy technology. A public IP address establishes where traffic appeared to exit. It does not, on its own, establish who typed the instruction, whether the connection was shared, or whether software secretly relayed the request.

That should change how banks, employers and investigators handle suspicious traffic. Blocking an active attack may be necessary immediately. Accusing a customer, employee or household member should require corroboration: account and device evidence, session history, relevant application activity and, where lawful and proportionate, provider records. An IP address is a starting point for investigation, not a verdict.


The risk also runs in the other direction. Google’s IPIDEA investigation found that proxy software could expose consumer devices and other equipment on the home network to further abuse. A household recruited as a relay is not automatically innocent of every security problem, but it may simultaneously be a victim whose connection is being exploited. Making that possibility visible is as important as tracing the intrusion.
Make the hidden trade visible

The first responsibility belongs to software distributors and app stores. Google Play’s published policy permits apps to facilitate third-party proxy services only when doing so is their primary, user-facing purpose. Apple’s review rules also restrict unrelated background tasks and undocumented app behavior. Neither policy is a guarantee that covert proxy code will never be distributed. Both show that the industry already recognizes a basic principle: users should not have to infer that their connectivity is being resold from an obscure software dependency.

When concealed relaying is discovered, platform operators should notify affected users in plain language, identify the app and affected versions, explain how to remove it and say whether their connection may have been used by others. A generic “security improvement” notice is inadequate. Internet providers and security vendors should share confirmed indicators through lawful channels, without treating every residential address associated with a proxy network as a criminal address.

Cross-border enforcement also needs to follow the business rather than just the last IP address: the firms distributing software kits, the operators selling proxy access and the resellers obscuring who supplied it. Google’s January and July interventions offer a model of technical disruption, platform enforcement and law-enforcement cooperation. The limit is equally clear: taking down one network does not automatically remove every reseller or every device already enrolled.

For ordinary users, the practical precautions are modest: avoid VPNs and “earn money from unused bandwidth” applications from untrusted suppliers, examine whether a service shares your connection with third parties, keep device protections active and investigate unexpected account warnings. For authorities, the obligation is harder: protect victims of abuse without confusing the address they use with the actor who chose the attack.

The most important new digital divide may not be between those who can use AI and those who cannot. It may be between the people who control an automated operation and the people whose connections quietly carry it. Global cybersecurity will be more credible when it can tell those two groups apart.



About Burak Oktenli
Burak Oktenli holds an MBA and a Master of Professional Studies in Applied Intelligence from Georgetown University. His research addresses the governance of authority in autonomous and AI-enabled systems, and his writing has appeared at the Modern War Institute at West Point, RUSI, RealClearDefense, RealClearMarkets, and Geopolitical Monitor. He is the author of Authority Architectures for Autonomous Systems, a ten-volume series on how authority in autonomous systems is delegated, monitored and recovered, at authority-architecture.me.
View all posts by Burak Oktenli →
AI Could Make University Degrees Optional: Brain Implants Aren’t The Reason – Analysis



A November study showed a brain–computer interface decoding silent speech commands with 97.1 percent accuracy for a paralyzed participant, a medical advance that does not install knowledge or replace the need to learn.

Randomized trials already show mixed results for AI tutors: one Harvard physics experiment produced faster gains, while a Turkish high-school math study found performance dropped once assistance was removed, underscoring the difference between access to answers and independent skill.

Universities must therefore shift from selling standardized information to proving authentic learning—through workplace-tool assessments, independent challenges, and supervised practice—while preserving the right to remain unconnected to neural interfaces.




A new silent-speech brain interface marks a medical milestone, not instant knowledge. But AI tutors are already challenging what universities sell, and how they prove that students have learned.

A person with severe paralysis can now control certain smart devices by silently forming words. In a study published on November 11, researchers decoded the commands through an implanted brain–computer interface. Across 18 experimental sessions involving one participant, the system achieved a median command-decoding accuracy of 97.1 percent. It is a remarkable advance in independence, and emphatically not a way to download a university education into the brain.

That distinction is where the future of higher education gets interesting. The science is beginning to reduce the effort needed to communicate with computers. Ordinary AI tutors are already reducing the effort needed to obtain explanations and practice difficult skills. Neither achievement abolishes learning. Together they challenge universities to explain what students are paying for beyond access to information.


The disruption may arrive long before anyone needs a neural implant. A young person with a reliable connection and a capable tutor can already ask questions at midnight, work through a proof repeatedly and receive personalized feedback. The degree may remain valuable; four years of lectures as the automatic price of gaining useful knowledge becomes harder to defend.

A medical breakthrough is not a shortcut to expertise

The latest demonstration belongs in its proper context. It involved a person with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis using a clinical interface to issue a limited set of silent commands. In a separate 2026 Nature Medicine study, a participant with severe paralysis operated speech and cursor controls independently at home for more than 3,800 hours. And in March, China approved a medical brain–computer interface device intended to help certain patients regain hand-grasping ability. These are significant developments in accessibility and neurorehabilitation, not commercial systems that install knowledge or erase the need to acquire a skill.


A future interface might let someone ask an AI a question without speaking, then hear or see the answer through an ordinary output device. That possibility could make intellectual assistance less cumbersome, especially for people with disabilities. It would still leave the person responsible for judging the answer, understanding its limits and learning to apply it. Communication with a tool is not the same as competence without it.

The evidence about learning is already mixed

A 2025 randomized trial involving 194 Harvard physics students found greater gains in less time with a carefully designed AI tutor than with the active-learning classroom comparison. That finding concerned specific lessons, not an entire degree. It nevertheless raises an awkward question for institutions whose main offering is standardized explanation: why should every learner pay for the same delivery format when another approach may teach some material better?

The counterexample is just as important. In a randomized study of nearly 1,000 high-school mathematics students in Türkiye, a broadly helpful GPT-4 interface raised performance while students were using it but produced weaker results when assistance was removed. A tutor designed to give structured, teacher-informed hints largely mitigated that harm. The students, subjects and assessment conditions differ from the Harvard experiment; the studies should not be treated as a single verdict. Their common lesson is that faster answers and stronger independent learning are not interchangeable.


This is the real fault line: access to an answer versus possession of a skill. An AI system may help a student design a bridge, but the bridge still has to survive engineering calculations, laboratory testing and professional scrutiny. AI may help a student write a legal argument, but the student must still recognize a fabricated precedent. A university should be judged by how well it develops that judgment, not by how fiercely it protects the lecture hall.

A global test for the degree

The challenge is not confined to wealthy American campuses. A UNESCO survey of 200 higher-education institutions across 19 Latin American and Caribbean countries found that 87 percent already used AI somewhere in their work, while only 26 percent had a formal AI strategy. Those figures describe the surveyed institutions, not every university on Earth. They show why access to AI is advancing faster than many institutions are deciding what it should mean for instruction, assessment and fairness.

Governments, universities and employers should begin separating education into functions that technology can deliver cheaply and functions that must remain independently credible. Personalized explanations and routine practice can travel beyond a campus. Laboratory work, supervised clinical experience, serious criticism, research and interaction with people who disagree remain difficult to reproduce as a private conversation with software. Degrees should compete with shorter programs, apprenticeships and portable demonstrations of competence wherever licensing and public-safety requirements permit.

An October 2026 systematic review of higher-education assessment identifies validity and authenticity as central issues in the AI era. The policy reform is straightforward but demanding: assess graduates in two modes. First, let them use the tools they would actually have in the workplace, including AI, and show the quality of what they produce. Then require an independent challenge that tests whether they can explain the reasoning, recognize misleading assistance and handle a novel problem when the tool is wrong or unavailable. In high-consequence fields, add supervised practical assessment. These are proposed assessment principles, not findings that one method already works for every profession.

That is not an argument for abolishing universities. It is an argument for asking them to earn trust as assessors, mentors and places of discovery, not merely as distributors of information. In September, education ministers meeting at UNESCO reaffirmed education as a common good in the age of AI. A world of private AI subscriptions should not quietly replace that public purpose with a paywall around credible credentials.

Keep the option to remain unconnected

The neural dimension adds a separate obligation. UNESCO’s Recommendation on the Ethics of Neurotechnology calls for consent, safeguards for neural data and caution about use in education. Its guidance warns against academic penalties for non-participation and against using neurotechnology to evaluate students or educators. This is an international recommendation, not a worldwide binding education law, but it establishes an important boundary: nobody should need to disclose neural information, or agree to an implant, to earn a credential or keep a job.


The risks run in two directions. Expensive interfaces and subscriptions could widen inequality, while overreliance on assistance could produce graduates who can complete tasks only so long as the system remains available. The answer is neither to prohibit useful tools nor to make them compulsory. It is to preserve meaningful choice and demand evidence of learning that remains valid when technology changes.

There is no date on the calendar when knowledge will be installed directly into human memory. There is already a date on the calendar for every university’s next examination, accreditation decision and graduating class. Those are the decisions that can change now. If AI makes a traditional degree optional for more people, the institution that survives will be the one able to demonstrate what an instant answer cannot: a person who understands, can challenge, and can act responsibly on what they know.


About Burak Oktenli
Burak Oktenli holds an MBA and a Master of Professional Studies in Applied Intelligence from Georgetown University. His research addresses the governance of authority in autonomous and AI-enabled systems, and his writing has appeared at the Modern War Institute at West Point, RUSI, RealClearDefense, RealClearMarkets, and Geopolitical Monitor. He is the author of Authority Architectures for Autonomous Systems, a ten-volume series on how authority in autonomous systems is delegated, monitored and recovered, at authority-architecture.me.
View all posts by Burak Oktenli →
One Invisible Toll Of War Is Worsening Drug-Resistant TB Crisis – OpEd

Credit: Citizen News Service




Key Takeaways:

Conflict and displacement create ideal conditions for tuberculosis and especially drug-resistant TB by destroying health services, increasing malnutrition and overcrowding, and interrupting treatment, yet fewer than 20 percent of estimated drug-resistant cases are notified in complex emergencies.

Ukraine’s response shows that decentralised outpatient care, shorter regimens, pre-positioned medicine stocks and portable diagnostics can sustain services even under war, offering a model for other humanitarian settings.

Ending TB by 2030 requires integrating drug-resistant TB into humanitarian planning, protecting health workers and facilities, and adopting gender-responsive approaches so that the right to diagnosis and treatment continues during armed conflict.

As wars and armed conflicts intensify, humanitarian emergencies deepen and millions are forced from their homes, multitude of crises unfold – largely out of sight. One of them is the growing threat of tuberculosis (TB), particularly drug-resistant TB.

According to the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs, nearly 300 million people were estimated to need humanitarian assistance and protection in 2024. Also, at the end of that year, 83.4 million people were living in internal displacement worldwide, including 73.5 million displaced by conflict and violence.

These figures reveal a humanitarian crisis of extraordinary proportions. Yet behind the statistics lies another, less visible emergency: the growing vulnerability of displaced and conflict-affected populations to infectious diseases, including TB, and the increasing difficulty of providing them diagnosis treatment and care. More importantly, efforts to prevent infection transmission, including drug-resistant ones, break down during such crises.

Against this backdrop, the global ambition to end TB faces a formidable obstacle. War does not simply interrupt healthcare delivery. It creates the very conditions in which TB thrives, spreads and becomes more difficult to treat. And when disease prevention, diagnosis treatment, care and support systems collapse, the consequences can be even more devastating: drug resistance, avoidable deaths and the potential emergence of new transmission chains extending beyond national borders.

The message from Dr Ignacio Monedero Recuero, representing Action Damien and chairing the Global Drug-Resistant TB Initiative, is clear: the relationship between war, humanitarian emergencies and drug-resistant TB can no longer remain a blindspot in the global TB response. He was speaking at a session organised by Stop TB Partnership at the 55th Union World Conference on Lung Health in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil.


When war becomes a breeding ground for TB


Modern conflicts are increasingly prolonged, frequent and deadly, and disrupting or destroying essential services – including hospitals, electricity networks, water systems and other basic services.


According to the Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre, conflict-related internal displacement has increased by an average of 51% over the past decade, with a marked escalation since 2021.

Conflicts in the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Lebanon, Palestine, Sudan, Ukraine and other settings illustrate the growing geographical reach of humanitarian crises. Also, prolonged conflicts in Afghanistan, Colombia, Syria and Yemen demonstrate how emergencies can persist for years.

For TB, these circumstances create a dangerous convergence of risk factors. TB is closely associated with poverty, malnutrition, overcrowding and inadequate access to healthcare. Drug-resistant TB is particularly concentrated among populations facing severe socioeconomic deprivation and inaccessible healthcare and social welfare support.

War and complex emergencies intensify virtually every known social and clinical determinant of TB. They destroy livelihoods, increase food insecurity, disrupt health services, create overcrowded living conditions and push vulnerable communities into displacement, detention and poverty. The economic consequences are equally devastating. Conflict destroys livelihoods, increases unemployment and deepens poverty, limiting access to nutritious food, transportation and healthcare.

Malnutrition and untreated conditions such as HIV and diabetes further increase vulnerability to TB. Overcrowded shelters, informal settlements, prisons and refugee camps increase the risk of infection transmission.

Meanwhile, the destruction of diagnostic and treatment services means that people with TB may remain undiagnosed and infectious for longer periods. Untreated TB can lead to continued transmission, disability and death – all of which could have been averted – if peace prevails. Inadequately prescribed or interrupted treatment can contribute to the development of drug resistance.


In this sense, war does not simply increase the risk of TB. It creates the conditions in which drug-resistant disease can flourish.

Perhaps the most alarming finding emerging from recent research is not simply the increased risk of drug-resistant TB in humanitarian emergencies, but the extent to which the disease remains undetected.

A 2026 scoping review, co-authored by Dr Recuero, and published in BMJ Global Health, found that fewer than 20% of estimated drug-resistant TB cases were notified in complex emergency settings.

This means that the vast majority of people who may have drug-resistant TB in these settings are not being identified and reported through existing surveillance systems. Many may never receive a diagnosis, while others may struggle to access appropriate treatment or maintain continuity of care.

But even without wars and conflicts, it is a chronic and gross neglect that only 38% of estimated drug-resistant TB cases were notified and put on treatment globally in 2025 – as per latest WHO Global TB Report 2026. This is not acceptable.

If we are to end TB, we have to end drug-resistant TB first: no one should get infected with drug-resistant strains of TB and no one with drug-resistant TB should be left undiagnosed, untreated, unsupported and uncared for. We need to find all people with drug-resistant TB and link them to effective treatment, care and support – and boost infection prevention and control at all levels.

Most existing TB and drug-resistant TB guidelines were developed for relatively stable healthcare environments. The reality in conflict settings is very different. A patient may be unable to reach a health facility. A hospital may have been destroyed or lost electricity. Medicines may be unavailable due to collapse of supply chains. Health workers may have fled, while patients themselves may be forced to relocate repeatedly.

The problem in complex emergencies is therefore the accumulation of multiple known risk factors, creating conditions in which DR-TB transmission can accelerate while the capacity to detect and treat cases diminishes.


A crisis that crosses borders

The impact of conflict on TB is not confined to the countries where fighting takes place. Population displacement can alter the epidemiology of drug-resistant TB in neighbouring and even distant countries.

The escalation of the war in Ukraine in February 2022 triggered the largest refugee movement in Europe since the Second World War. This movement had important implications for healthcare systems and TB services across Europe, particularly in countries such as Poland and Germany, which received substantial numbers of Ukrainian refugees.

The critical issue is not displacement itself, but the conditions surrounding it: disrupted treatment, limited access to diagnosis, exposure to overcrowded living environments and difficulties maintaining continuity of care.


Population movements can also create additional challenges for surveillance and treatment. People may move between their country of origin, host countries and third countries, seeking local integration, repatriation or resettlement. Each transition can create another interruption in diagnosis, treatment and follow-up.


Turning crisis into an opportunity for innovation

Yet the picture is not entirely bleak, said Dr Ignacio Monedero Recuero. He shared the example of Ukraine which demonstrates how flexibility, innovation and patient-centred care can help sustain the TB response even under extremely difficult circumstances.

One significant development in Ukraine was the shift from highly centralised models towards more decentralised, community-based and patient-centred services- the proportion of patients receiving outpatient treatment increased from 24% in 2021 to 65% in 2022.

The approach incorporated nutritional support, management of co-morbidities, psycho-emotional assistance and palliative care, alongside social support such as food packages, essential goods and transportation.

Ukraine also accelerated the introduction of shorter drug-resistant treatment regimens (including BPaL and BPaLM), to reduce treatment duration, simplify care for eligible patients, and improve treatment outcomes.

Other innovations included: providing patients with sufficient supplies of medication to maintain treatment if they are suddenly forced to flee or relocate; expanding access to molecular diagnostic platforms and ultraportable AI-powered X-Rays; using mobile phone-based tools for treatment monitoring and follow-up; and introducing standardised training packages for primary healthcare workers.

These adaptations offer important lessons for other humanitarian settings: treatment must be designed around the realities of patients’ lives, rather than expecting patients to navigate healthcare systems that may no longer function as intended.


We cannot end TB without addressing war


The ambition to end TB by 2030 cannot be achieved by focusing exclusively on biomedical interventions, diagnostic technologies and treatment targets. It requires confronting the social, political and humanitarian realities that sustain the epidemic.

War destroys the conditions necessary for good health. It creates poverty, malnutrition, overcrowding and displacement. It weakens health systems, interrupts treatment and increases the risk of antimicrobial resistance.

For the TB community, ignoring these realities means overlooking some of the most vulnerable populations and some of the most dangerous conditions for disease transmission.

The global response must therefore move beyond viewing conflict as a temporary disruption to routine TB programming. As conflict is becoming a prolonged reality, TB services must be designed accordingly.

This means integrating drug-resistant TB into humanitarian health planning, protecting essential health services, investing in resilient diagnostic and treatment systems, strengthening international cooperation and ensuring that displaced people are never abandoned between healthcare systems.

It also means recognising that the right to TB diagnosis and treatment does not disappear when a country goes to war.

Protecting healthcare workers, safeguarding health facilities, maintaining humanitarian access and ensuring the continuity of essential medical supplies are not peripheral concerns. They are fundamental requirements for controlling TB and antimicrobial resistance in conflict settings.

And let us not forget that any conflict intensifies existing gender inequalities, making women more vulnerable to its devastating impacts. Women and gender-diverse people living in war-torn and conflict zones face additional barriers to TB prevention, diagnosis, treatment and care. Addressing TB in conflict zones requires a gender-responsive, inclusive and human-rights-based approach that ensures everyone- irrespective of class, race, gender, sexual diversity – can access prevention, diagnosis and treatment safely, equally and with dignity.


About Shobha Shukla
Shobha Shukla co-leads the editorial content of CNS (Citizen News Service) and is on the governing board of Global Antimicrobial Resistance Media Alliance (GAMA) and Asia Pacific Media Alliance for Health and Development (APCAT Media).
View all posts by Shobha Shukla →


Cop31

Nepal's first climate loss and damage payout falls far short of needs

Nepal is set to become the first country to receive money from the UN's Loss and Damage Fund following devastating floods in August. But the provisional €19 million allocation covers less than 1 percent of the damage – and survivors are still waiting for help.


Issued on: 22/11/2026 - RFI

Climate activists gather at COP31 in solidarity with the flood victims in Nepal. © Farai Shawn Matiashe/RFI



By:  Farai Shawn Matiashe

Dikshya Suibedi’s family now lives in a rented flat in Kathmandu. Floods in August swept away their home in Devighat, in Nepal’s Nuwakot district.

The 29-year-old’s family lost its ancestral land, home and possessions worth thousands of dollars.

“The land that we used to hold so many memories of is now covered with sandy soil,” she told RFI at the Cop31 UN climate summit, under way in the Turkish resort city of Antalya.

The place she once called home is now a wide river.

The disaster struck on 26 August when a massive ice and rock avalanche in the Langtang region of the Himalayas triggered flash floods that swept through settlements along the Bhote Koshi and Trishuli river valleys.

The floods left 1,455 people dead and 5,285 missing across the Rasuwa, Nuwakot, Dhading and Chitwan districts. Nepal’s disaster management authorities estimate the total damage and economic losses at $2.7 billion.


A historic first, but a fraction of what's needed

At Cop31, the Nepalese government confirmed that the board of the Fund for Responding to Loss and Damage had provisionally set aside $21.6 million following the disaster – including $20 million in potential recovery assistance and $1.6 million in administrative and oversight costs.

Nepal requested emergency support after the floods but must complete the application process before any money can be released.

The fund was agreed at Cop27 in Sharm el-Sheikh, Egypt, and became operational at Cop28 in Dubai. It was established to help vulnerable developing countries deal with the unavoidable economic and non-economic impacts of climate change.


Climate activists gather at COP31 in solidarity with the flood victims in Nepal. © Farai Shawn Matiashe/RFI

Overseen by a 26-member board representing developed and developing countries, the fund has the World Bank as its interim trustee.

If the money is released, Nepal will become the first country to receive support from the fund.

“This will be historical,” said Prayash Adhikari of the People’s Movement for Climate Justice Nepal.

Paul Chukwuma of the Loss and Damage Youth Coalition welcomed the allocation as a step forward, however modest.

“There is an overall welcome of the fact that for the first time in history, we are having a fund that is allocated from within the UNFCCC process,” he told RFI.

But the $20 million earmarked for recovery represents less than 1 percent of the estimated $2.7 billion in damage and economic losses – and an even smaller share of the money Nepal needs to rebuild infrastructure and restore livelihoods.

“The amount provided is nothing compared to what is needed. And when you put $21m on a scale of what is needed for the entire restoration process, then we see that we are far from where we need to be,” Chukwuma said.

Demand for the fund also far exceeds the money available. Between December 2025 and July 2026, developing countries submitted 176 applications requesting more than $2.8 billion in assistance – more than three times the $822 million pledged by developed countries.

Turkey talks green at Cop31 while cracking down on activists


Climate finance caught in red tape

For campaigners, the delays in accessing the money are almost as troubling as the size of the allocation.

Adhikari said it was frustrating that the fund had yet to pay out, nearly three months after the floods devastated communities and forced families from their homes.

“Nepal has to go through the sticky provisions of the World Bank. At least, Nepal should have received some money by now. People are living in rented houses in faraway cities,” he said.

Chukwuma said campaigners had expected a mechanism capable of providing rapid assistance so that people could rebuild their homes and livelihoods, rather than one burdened by lengthy administrative procedures.

Amos Wemanya, senior climate adviser at the Power Shift Africa think tank, said developing countries could not accept a system in which climate disasters unfold in hours but the money needed to respond takes months or even years to arrive.

He argued that climate finance needed to be adequate, accessible and predictable – and delivered at the speed of the crisis.

“What makes this even more troubling is the process. Communities lose their homes and livelihoods overnight, but governments must navigate lengthy applications, institutional requirements and approval procedures before resources can reach them,” he said.

“Climate disasters do not wait for board meetings, and neither should climate finance.”

As world leaders continue negotiations in Antalya, Suibedi hopes Cop31 will mark a turning point for people who have lost everything.

“High-emitting countries should provide more climate finance, particularly to the loss and damage fund,” she said.
Global Interest In Myanmar’s Rare Earths Might Overshadow Implementation Of ICJ’s Ruling On Rohingyas – Analysis



Photo Credit: tonywuphotography, Pixabay






Key Takeaways:

The ICJ’s first-ever finding that a state committed genocide ordered Myanmar to allow Rohingya return, pay reparations and prosecute perpetrators, yet the court lacks enforcement power beyond referral to the Security Council.

The article argues that the junta and major powers are prioritising access to Myanmar’s rare-earth deposits in Kachin and Shan states—already dominated by China and eyed by the US, India and Russia—over any serious implementation of the ruling.

Expanding unregulated mining has tripled sites since the 2021 coup, generated over $4 billion in exports to China, and raised pollution concerns, while the Rohingya crisis remains sidelined by resource competition.


Rare earth deposits in Myanmar are attracting the attention of both the military Junta and the world powers

In a landmark judgment on Thursday, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) at The Hague ruled that Myanmar had committed genocide against the Rohingya minority, killing about 10, 000 and driving 1.2 million into exile in Bangladesh since 2017.

The court ordered the government in Yangon to allow people who fled the violence to return home, commit to reparations, investigate, prosecute and punish people found to have committed genocidal acts.

This is the first time that the ICJ has ruled that a State had committed genocide. As such, the latest judgment has implications for the cases filed against Israel vis-à-vis Gaza and Russia vis-à-vis Ukraine.

The court’s rulings are final and legally binding, but it has no way to enforce them beyond reporting noncompliance to the UN Security Council, leaving it to geopolitics to take the final call.

Impediments to Implementation

(1) Going by the past record of the governments of Myanmar, whether civilian on military, very little will be done for the Rohingyas, who were stripped of Myanmar citizenship in 1982 and periodically attacked, saying that they were illegal Muslim immigrants from Bangladesh.

(2) There is doubt if the regional and global powers will put pressure on the military junta, as these powers believe that the military rulers have the means and the political will to ensure some space for the exploitation of rare earths present in North Myanmar.


(3) All powers, from China and India to the US, are eyeing the rare earths in North Myanmar.

(4) Though the Rohingyas have been crying for help since military operations began in 2017, the world has been turning a blind eye and making only feeble attempts to get the junta to be reasonable. Bangladesh kept complaining of the burden of hosting 1.2 million refugees, but help was too little. India saw the Rohingyas as Islamic extremists and was busy weeding infiltrators out.

(5) On top of the already existing financial squeeze on refugee rehabilitation, President Trump imposed restrictions on humanitarian aid.

However, the UK stood out. Shortly after the ruling was read at the ICJ, Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband said his government was expelling Myanmar’s Defence Attache from the UK and “calling urgently for a UN Security Council session to discuss the judgment.”

The Trump administration said that it was withholding judgment on the verdict. Given President Trump’s dim view of international law and human rights, very little could be expected from him, other than a deal with the junta on rare earths.


Myanmar’s Rare Earth Deposits


Meanwhile, Myanmar’s rare earth deposits are engaging the attention of both the military Junta and the world powers. This month, the Japanese paper Asahi Shimbun reported that Myanmar’s junta has been ‌urging the US to beef up re-engagement efforts and rapidly boost investment in the country’s rare earths mines. Currently, the sector is dominated by China.


The US State Department had outlined a plan to expand influence by gaining access to Myanmar’s rare-earth deposits in a strategy document released this month after months of secretive talks with Myanmar officials.

“Ultimately, the United States should treat Myanmar as a critical minerals priority, not simply a ‌diplomatic challenge,” Washington lobbying firm DCI Group said in a newsletter published on behalf of Myanmar’s Information Ministry.

“Minerals are the natural place for this deepening relationship to grow, since they connect Myanmar’s economic potential to US national security and supply-chain priorities,” the lobby group said.

A US State Department spokesman told Reuters that Washington has been encouraging Myanmar to make progress on key priorities, including “improving the domestic operating environment for US businesses, and building towards a genuine peace process that stabilises the country.”


Rare Earth Deposits

According to The Japan News, after the 2021 coup, Washington had frozen Myanmar’s assets at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York and imposed sanctions in a bid to isolate its generals. But it reversed course by holding direct talks with Myanmar officials.

Washington’s new strategy aims to secure “at least three major commercial or investment deals valued above $5 million each” for US companies. In July 2025 and October 2026, the US lifted sanctions on some Myanmar companies and individuals linked to the Myanmar military. President Donald Trump has made rare earths a ‌national security priority since returning to office, pouring billions of dollars into a clutch of companies in a bid to loosen China’s grip.

But Myanmar’s government is asking for more. It points out that China has already spent years building its position in Myanmar’s resource sector, and its companies and intermediaries hold advantages that cannot be easily displaced.
Myanmar’s Rare Earths Exports to China

The main rare earths mining sites are in northern Kachin State, which borders China. Elements such as dysprosium and terbium — used in electric vehicle (EV) motors — are mined in the region. According to the research organisation ISP-Myanmar, the number of mining sites in Kachin State has tripled since the 2021 coup.

From 2017 to 2024, the value of rare earth exports by Myanmar to China exceeded $4 billion. Of this, 84% was exported after the coup in 2021. About two-thirds of the rare earths imported by China over the eight-year period ending in 2024 were from Myanmar. In fact, China, which accounts for 90% of the world’s rare earth refining, is supported by Myanmar.

Militants’ Control

The mining areas in Kachin State had long been controlled by forces affiliated with the military. But in 2024, the ethnic armed group Kachin Independence Army (KIA) gained control, causing the Myanmar military to lose a valuable source of revenue.

Subsequently, mining operations expanded into northeastern Shan State. In 2025, the Shan Human Rights Foundation announced that mining had begun in an area near the Thai border in the southern part of the Shan State, which is controlled by the ethnic armed group United Wa State Army (UWSA). The UWSA is known for its close ties to China, and Chinese-affiliated companies are reportedly involved in mining there.

Later, mining operations began in areas controlled by the Ta’ang National Liberation Army (TNLA) in the northern part of Shan State and the National Democratic Alliance Army (NDAA) in the east.

According to the United Nations, the number of mining sites in Shan State surged from 12 before the coup to 85.


India’s Interest

In August 2025, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi met with Min Aung Hlaing, then commander-in-chief of the Myanmar military, and agreed to cooperate on rare earth development. In July this year, a mining forum led by the Indian government was held in Myanmar. At the same time, it has been reported that the Indian government has been in contact with the KIA.


Russia’s Interest

In June 2025, the Shan Human Rights Foundation announced that a Russian company was planning to mine the rare metal tungsten in the southern part of Shan State. The Myanmar government is said to have granted a mining permit to the Russian company.
Environmental Concerns

Concerns about severe pollution are mounting due to the expansion of unregulated mining operations. Water quality tests conducted by Thai authorities on various rivers since last year have detected levels of arsenic, lead and other substances exceeding safety standards in various locations. Authorities are urging people not to eat fish — which tend to accumulate heavy metals — or shrimp that live near riverbed sediments.

Although a causal relationship between mining development and river pollution has not yet been fully proven, the “in-situ leaching” method used in rare earth mining in Myanmar (which involves drilling holes into mountainsides and injecting chemicals) has been cited as a cause of groundwater contamination and the discharge of wastewater into rivers.


For the Myanmar military administration, which is seeking international recognition, mineral resources such as rare earths serve as a major diplomatic bargaining chip. Although many of the mining sites are in areas under the control of militant ethnic minority groups, the administration aims to build relationships with various countries, calling for cooperation on future development.

Rohingya Issue on the Back Burner

Given the fact that both the government of Myanmar and the world powers are engaged in the exploitation of rare earth deposits, the Rohingya issue has been put on the back burner.

While the ICJ has rendered justice, implementation of its ruling is left to the government in Yangon and world powers (since the junta cannot fulfil the obligations without foreign aid). But the attention of Yangon and the outside powers is on the rare earths and not the Rohingyas.



About P. K. Balachandran
P. K. Balachandran is a senior Indian journalist working in Sri Lanka for local and international media and has been writing on South Asian issues for the past 21 years.
View all posts by P. K. Balachandran →

 

Germany wants carmaker loyalty after ending combustion engine ban

21.11.2026, 

Photo: Moritz Frankenberg/dpa

By Burkhard Fraune, dpa

Germany expects a commitment from leading carmakers to favour the country as a business location in return for softening the phase-out of combustion engines, according to German Transport Minister Steffen Bilger.

"My expectation is clear: Germany must remain the home base for development and production," Bilger told Saturday's edition of the regional newspaper Neue Osnabrücker Zeitung.

"After everything we have achieved politically - specifically, ending the combustion engine ban in Europe - I also expect a clear commitment from the automotive industry to its home base."

A softening of European climate rules, and with it the relaxation of the combustion engine phase-out, has recently become increasingly concrete, Bilger said.

A corresponding EU proposal would mean that the auto industry could continue to sell new combustion-engine and hybrid vehicles after 2035 without having to fear penalty payments. A decision is expected to be made in December.

The German automotive industry is currently cutting tens of thousands of jobs, and plant closures are under review. Companies attribute this, among other things, to high production costs in Germany and are increasingly investing abroad.

Bilger said he understands the reasons behind foreign investments. However, "Made in Germany" still plays an important role when it comes to cars, he underscored.

"The car was invented in Germany, many innovations were developed here, and in the future, our ambition should continue to be to lead the way in all areas of automobility. To me, that also includes German manufacturers continuing to develop and produce in Germany."

The German government must reduce burdens such as labour, energy and bureaucracy costs, Bilger said. Production in Germany will never be as cheap as in Eastern Europe, he added.

Furthermore, Europe must take a stand regarding competition with China, which is not fair, he added.

Cop31

Africa's struggle for electricity puts Cop31 energy goal to the test

Turkey's plan to increase the world's use of electricity has won the support of 75 countries at the Cop31 climate summit, but deep divisions remain over how poorer nations can afford the transition – particularly in Africa, where hundreds of millions of people still lack power.



Issued on: 18/11/2026 - RFI

A shepherd tends livestock near the Khi Solar One solar power plant outside Upington, South Africa, on 29 August 2025. Expanding access to affordable electricity remains a major challenge for African countries as Cop31 pushes for a global electrification target. © AP Photo/Themba Hadebe


By:  Amanda Morrow with RFI

Launched in September, the voluntary pledge is a centrepiece of Turkey's Cop31 presidency. It aims to increase electricity's share of global energy use from around 23 percent currently to 35 percent by 2035, by encouraging more electric cars and replacing gas and oil with electricity in homes and factories.

But the target raises questions about how African countries can afford the shift, with the continent's negotiators calling for financial support that will not push them further into debt.

Support for the initiative stands at 75 countries and 94 organisations, Cop31 officials said on Wednesday. Among them are the European Union, the United Kingdom, Japan, Canada and Australia.

The goal is also part of an 18-page draft agreement released on Monday that calls for faster action to phase out fossil fuels. However, several governments have objected to including the electricity target in the final deal.

Under pressure

The draft, prepared under the Turkish and Australian leadership of Cop31 in the Mediterranean resort of Antalya, sets out proposals for the summit's main political statement, known as the "cover decision".

"There are elements in this draft that not all parties will agree on," warned Australia's Climate Change and Energy Minister, Chris Bowen, who is leading the negotiations. "That is a given."

All countries must agree on the final text for it to be adopted.

The European Union has raised concerns about the draft, particularly its sections on finance, trade and technology used to capture carbon emissions.

"I think the cover decision does not go in the right direction and needs significant change," EU climate commissioner Wopke Hoekstra told reporters on Tuesday – describing it as having "many of the characteristics of a shopping list".

The EU nevertheless supports the global electricity goal, both through the voluntary pledge and in the formal negotiations.

Other countries have taken a harder line.

Russia and the Arab Group, which represents 22 Arab states, rejected the draft outright on Monday. A group of developing countries including China, India and Saudi Arabia also objected, saying the text crossed its red lines on issues including the electricity target.

Africa's power gap

The target applies to the world as a whole, not to individual countries.

But while Europe gets around a quarter of its energy from electricity, Africa gets just 12 percent – and much of the continent is still struggling to get the lights on.

In sub-Saharan Africa, more than 560 million people lacked electricity in 2024, the most recent figures from the International Energy Agency (IEA) show.

The two continents face very different challenges. While Europe is replacing fossil-fuelled power with renewables, many African communities still rely on firewood for cooking.

In communities without reliable electricity, alternatives to electric cooking remain essential, even as governments work to expand power networks.

"The intermediate solutions cannot be abandoned while the grid catches up," said Dola Oluteye, a senior fellow in energy and transport policy at University College London's Energy Institute.

India has also questioned the global target and will not sign Turkey's voluntary pledge, Environment Minister Bhupender Yadav said before the summit.

A single worldwide goal "makes no sense unless it is translated into a national target", said Ajay Mathur, a former head of India's delegation to the climate talks, who warned that dividing the effort fairly between countries would be difficult.

The cost of progress

For African countries, one of the biggest obstacles is financing new energy projects. While the continent has abundant sunshine, solar farms and electricity networks often depend on loans that are far more expensive than those available in wealthier nations.

The cost of financing large-scale clean energy projects in Africa is at least two to three times higher than in wealthy countries and China, the IEA has said.

"At that cost of capital, investors are simply not going to put money into African electrification or industrialisation," Oluteye warned.

Even when electricity becomes available, it needs to be affordable for households that currently rely on firewood.

At the Cop31 negotiations this week, African countries warned that climate funding must not push them further into debt.

The draft agreement calls for at least $120 billion a year by 2035 to help developing countries cope with the effects of climate change. This money would fund measures such as protection against floods and droughts, rather than electricity projects specifically.

"Countries in the Global South are being asked to sign up to a new target," said Fanny Petitbon, France lead at the environmental organisation 350.org. "But the countries that have historically emitted the most will have to make the first efforts."

Clean power or more power?

Another dispute concerns whether the electricity goal should favour renewable energy. Running cars or heating systems on electricity does less to cut emissions if that power comes from burning coal or gas.

The draft recognises that electrification can bring benefits regardless of how electricity is produced, but also calls for a faster shift towards clean power.

China already gets nearly 30 percent of its energy from electricity and aims to reach 35 percent by 2030, although coal still generates more than half of its power.

"The target is really very easy to reach," said Li Shuo, director of the China Climate Hub at the US-based Asia Society Policy Institute. "It won't make them break a sweat at all."

China may, however, be reluctant to accept rules requiring electricity to be clean or green, Li told journalists in Antalya. "They don't want international forces imposing too many conditions, particularly on how electrification should be carried out."

The EU had initially favoured stronger wording on clean electricity, but climate commissioner Hoekstra said Brussels was ready to compromise to secure wider support.

That has angered climate campaigners, who fear a target that does not specify clean electricity could allow countries to expand their use of coal and gas.

"Stop taking us for fools," said Petitbon, criticising the possible retreat. "Either you're here to defend the climate, or there's no point even setting foot here."